transcribe

Air Traffic Control Is Collapsing. Is It DOGE, DEI, or Something Else?

Dad Saves America · 33m · transcribed May 2026
More from Dad Saves America
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Transcript

0:00 We are the country that invented air travel. Why are we behind? Why is Norway and the UK and the Netherlands and Canada and New Zealand at the cutting edge of technology looking to the 21st century and we haven't gotten out of the 1960s. Hey there friends. Welcome back to Dad Saves America. John Pola here and I thought I would take this Friday to try to understand what is going on in America's increasingly not so friendly skies. Tonight, passengers flying to or from Newark Liberty International Airport are experiencing long delays and cancellations. The be the busy airport outside New York City has been hit by disruptions all week long with no end in sight. I used to live in just just outside of New York and um this was my home airport for half a decade and the airports in New York City area end up impacting all air travel throughout the country because so many flights come in and out of those three airports, Newark, LaGuardia, and JFK that we are all impacted if we're flying by changes here. But this is just an exemplar of what's going on around the country. This airport was already hamstrung by runway construction and now some air traffic controllers have walked off the job.

1:20 It's day six of long delays, cancellations, and frustrations. That's crazy. This week, 20% of the air traffic controllers for Newark Liberty International Airport walked off the job. The FAA confirming and one airline official noting equipment failures preceded the job action. The situation so unsustainable, United Airlines cancelling 35 roundtrip flights per day from Newark. After a number of system outages, controller screens essentially went dark for up to 90 seconds, losing the ability to track aircraft at a key facility handling traffic in and out of Newark. It was a breaking point for about a halfozen controllers who requested trauma leave due to the working conditions, allowing them to essentially be off the job for up to 45 days. And as I understand it, this is a punishingly stressful job. It is one in which, as you'll hear, staffing problems result in people working 6 day weeks, 10 plus hours a day. Uh, and it is pretty stressful, pretty rough. So, I can understand being traumatized by what's going on. 200 miles south in Washington DC, an investigation into a new air scare at Reagan National. Air traffic control directed two passenger jets to abort landing at Reagan National Airport Thursday as this Army Blackhawk helicopter circled the nearby Pentagon preparing to land. This follows the deadly mid-air collision at that same airport in January between a commercial aircraft and army helicopter which killed 67 people. It's 2025. Um we are the country that invented air travel. So why is it so off the rails?

3:08 Air traffic controller is at an all-time low in staffing. Now it's hit to a critical point where this can't be sustained. We currently have 10,800 certified professional controllers where we need 14,633. That's roughly a deficit of 26%. The shortage is not new and has been around similar levels for the last decade, but recent events, despite not necessarily errors of air traffic control, are calling more attention to the importance of filling these jobs. I just had Mike Row in the studio yesterday. That'll be coming out next Thursday. We hear a lot about the need for good paying jobs in this country and air traffic control while stressful is a really good paying job. In fact, the median pay for air traffic controllers is $145,000 a year. So the notion that this entirely government-run system can't fill a gap of 3,000 jobs just seems absolutely baffling to me and probably to you as well. How could we have a decade of sustained lack of air traffic controllers? It's like, how is this possible? We're spending a lot of money.

4:20 That is what I'm going to try to help you and me understand. The investigation continues into that deadly collision between an American Airlines jet and a Blackhawk helicopter near Reagan National Airport. Air traffic control tower staffing deemed not normal, but it's not deemed unsafe under FAA guidelines. The NTSB said there was one person handling helicopter and airline traffic when typically there would be one for each. The Federal Aviation Administration has limited flights in congested areas like New York because the number of controllers are insufficient. On blue sky days last year, so days with no weather in the system, we 68% of our delays were because of air traffic control restrictions. We have a delay in New York every single day no matter what the weather is because they're simply understaffed. every single day. Blue skies and there's delays. This is a government monopoly, folks. This is a this is something that we need to look at really, really carefully. But of course, it's a government monopoly in a certain sense for a reason because the skies are a commons. And so, the argument for why the government needs to play some role in regulating air traffic control is that the skies are a commons.

5:33 They they don't have the kind of private property rights that make it possible to say manage land or even build roads. You can actually have private roads. A lot of the roads in America are private. The skies is different. Why is our government so bad at this? Well, there's several reasons. Another concern is the aging systems used by the FAA. After an outage in 2023 that grounded thousands of flights, the FAA determined that 51 of its 138 systems that provide things like communications are unsustainable and need to be modernized. They're frustrated. They're angry about having to use this old equipment.

6:09 Transportation Secretary Shawn Duffy says cracks are showing in the nation's aging air traffic control system. The delays that we're now seeing in Newark is what's going to continue to happen around the country. Duffy is expected to announce a multi-year plan to overhaul and update the system this week. This is actually the systems that our air traffic controllers use. Look at this stuff. And I'm going to come back to this because it's it's as bad and worse as this looks. It is old. It looks like it's out of the 70s and 80s. Because it is because it literally is out of the ' 60s and 70s and 80s tech. You can't build anything on top of the system that we now use. It's so old. So, you can't upgrade it. You can't add to it. New technology comes out and you can't deploy it. Technology that's going to make us more efficient and safer can't be deployed on what we have in America.

7:02 So, we have two problems. We have a fundamental staffing problem. Not enough people filling critical roles. And we have a technology problem. We are using ancient technology. Before we dive deeper into that, I just thought I'd play this quick video about what air traffic control actually is. Because if you're like me, I didn't really know. From the start of any flight, it's under the watch of the airport traffic control tower, which provides clearance for takeoff, then follows the departure on the first few miles of its flight. When the aircraft leaves the immediate airport environment, it is handed off to a terminal radar approach control facility, or TACON. Controllers at Trons handle traffic for a radius of about 40 miles and up to 10,000 ft high. Once the aircraft climbs beyond the Tron's airspace, it is handed off to an air route traffic control center. There are 24 centers across the country in the Pacific and the Caribbean, each handling a designated segment of airspace. At the end of the journey, the opposite process happens. The aircraft descends down to the receiving TCON, then to the airport tower as it lands and taxis to its gate.

8:04 Each major airport has a tower where controllers monitor all aircraft taxiing, taking off, and landing at the airport. Each control tower owns the airspace up to 3,000 ft above in a radius of 5 mi around the airport. Controllers in Trons monitor aircraft in departure, descent, and approach. Trons can handle air traffic for several different airports in an area. The 24 centers monitor aircraft during cruise altitude. Controllers here sometimes handle dozens of flights at once. I know this is a nitpick, but uh even this little drawing, what do you got? You got the African-American air traffic controller, you got the female air traffic controller. It's like fine. I don't have a problem with that. I don't care what you look like or which genitals you have if you're going to be good at your job as an air traffic controller. Um, but as we'll see, the FAA has cared and that's expressed in this animation. But why don't we have enough of these people? What's going on?

8:58 Well, one perspective, especially right now, is of course that this is all DOA's fault. that this is the draconian to the bone cuts to the FAA that is causing all of our problems. Senator Schumer, do you believe then that Doge is to blame and these cuts are to blame for what you are seeing in the air right now? All the reports we get from people who work there is the cuts have hurt and there is no rhyme or reason to them.

9:27 They're just cutting for cutting's sake and uh it's very bad. We talk to people who are in the towers. So this is the claim being made by people that want to make this entirely political. And in a certain sense, it is political. It has to be political because our politicians run air traffic control. But as it pertains to the Trump administration, they are claiming that air traffic controllers have been exempt from cuts. So out of something like 46,000 employees in the FAA, only 10,000 of which are air traffic controllers, there's been something like 400 cuts. So this Doge criticism doesn't really pass the sniff test. On the other side of the political aisle, generally more like my side, sort of kind of, there are those who say this is all the fault of DEI.

10:15 The reason why we haven't been able to fill 3,000 needed air traffic control jobs is because we're turning away perfectly good candidates in favor of frankly diversity hires. Now, before I show a clip that will underpin that, uh what is going on writ large? Over the last 8 years, we've had 146,000 applicants and we've hired 7,95 of those. So less than 10% of the people that apply for the job actually make it to the academy and then graduate to go out into the field. Many applicants also drop out before they reach the end of their training. So last year in FY24, our goal was 1,800 uh controllers. We hired 1,814 of folks that will go through the academy, but we'll lose 35% of those at the academy. We'll lose another 20% once they get in the field on the job training. So we don't net 1,800 controllers. Traditionally, people will get through the maps, they'll get through the written test, and it's when they get into the simulation and the actual practicality of the job that we lose most people. The interest starts out high and then as you see the stresses, the pressure, the continuous learning, uh the millions of decisions that you have to make every day and you have to be perfect. Pay close attention to this visual. I'm going to come back to this. This right here is a window into insanity. So that begins to detract people as time goes on. Most air traffic controllers, at least 41% of the facilities are forced on mandatory overtime, meaning they only have four days off in an entire month and they work 60 hours inside that work week.

11:48 There are various facilities out there that are working overtime. Um, but there's a lot of facilities that are not. And so we have 313 facilities in the country. Not every facility is as understaffed, so to speak, as as some. So it just depends on where you are. So, you and your family are flying across the country to visit your grandparents or go on vacation. And this government monopoly run by the FAA and funded and overseen by Congress uh hasn't filled all the jobs and has left the people that are doing this critical job working 60 hours a week, getting one day off and losing their minds. And while that is happening, this has also been happening.

12:31 Fox 10 News has learned that the FAA recently changed the way it hires air traffic controllers. Now they've changed the rules of the game. No experience necessary. Making you feel good, right? This is in 2014, so this has been going on for a long time. And many worry that this could put the flying public at risk. Tonight, our exclusive look at a stunning lack of standards for hiring new air traffic controllers. You would think the FAA would want the best and brightest in these towers. Yeah, you would think that.

13:09 But Fox 10 News has discovered that's no longer the case. For 24 years, the FAA has relied on colleges and universities to help prepare air traffic controllers. United 1420 runway 7 left cleared for takeoff through the collegiate training initiative or CTI. The FAA did a startling about face suddenly announcing it would begin hiring air traffic controllers off the street. No experience necessary. They want to change the face of the workforce.

13:39 Diversity. Veteran FAA controller John Gilding spent 20 years in the tower. He's worked with controllers hired off the street as well as CTI graduates. Who's better? CTI students. Much much better. They're better trained, better prepared. Um they they outperform the off the street hires. I know we live in an age uh where justifiable skepticism of the elite and of certifications and of credentials um is in order, but you know, air traffic control getting certified by the school seems like maybe a good place to keep certification in play. I'm just saying.

14:22 Anthony Fox, head of the Department of Transportation, oversees the FAA. This is how he described the hiring changes to Congress back in March. The FAA took an opportunity to do a more broad uh opening of the aperture, if you will, to try to get a a larger universe of applicants into the program. But just a year ago, the FAA gave the CTI program a glowing review, stating, "It is clear that the FAA ATCTI schools are making great strides to incorporate minority students and faculty into their programs." And why that should actually matter to me is completely unclear. Why would this be the point in the process where that should be the concern? And this is one of the most fundamental things about this DEI nonsense that has to go is you're trying to solve for problems that are way upstream of deciding who should enter school for air traffic control. This is a high school. This is a family problem.

15:22 And then whoever wants to be an air traffic controller and is competent come to the table. This is off the rails or dropping out of the skies as we see. But apparently the diversity numbers are not to the liking of some within the FAA. So to achieve some internal hiring goal, which has never been made public, the agency is passing over highly qualified candidates. The FAA is now requiring air traffic control applicants to take an online biographical questionnaire comprised of 63 questions such as, "What has been the major cause of your failures?" And how many high school sports did you participate in? It has nothing to do with whether they have the skills to be an air traffic controller.

16:08 I was just shaking my head at the questions that I was being given. They made no sense. Get ready for this. Brida aced his air traffic control test. I scored 100% on the adsets, but he flunked the biographical questionnaire and he has no idea why. I mean, how exactly do you flunk a biographical questionnaire? I I would really love to know. How do you flunk describing yourself? No, you you didn't really play football, son. It turns out it's just you flunk by being white. I think they never gave you a grade. They simply uh gave you either a green check or a red X. And what did you get? Red X. He's out. Nine out of 10 CTI graduates failed the biographical questionnaire, effectively washing them out. Former air traffic controller John Gilding says it's potentially putting the flying public at risk. Uh, not potentially. Actually, if you're going to climb on an airplane or you're going to put grandma on an airplane, you're going to put your kids on an airplane.

17:10 Do you want a a a a wellskilled, highly competent uh a talented person working that airplane or do you want some high school dropout that's got his hat on backwards being the person guiding the airplane? One other note, hiring off the street is very, very expensive because the government has to pay to train people, many of whom will eventually wash out. They don't make it. Having colleges train air traffic controllers has saved the government over tens of millions of dollars through the years. And remember, every time you hear the government, just think your pocket because the government doesn't have any money. They take it from us. So if that makes steam come out of your ears, it should cuz it's obviously ridiculous. It's a complete abdication of the responsibility of our agencies to do things that they are tasked with doing or in this case powers that they have assumed and taken control of like the FAA because the actually before the FAA the airlines which were private because the invention of the airplane was private. All of this was private, invented by private enterprise, and they did create an early version of the FAA because the emergent airlines knew they needed something like that. So be it. We have an FAA, and this is the kind of stuff they're doing. This isn't the only thing wrong, though. Because if you happen to have made it through the gauntlet and had a great background, you're still confronted by the fact that our technology sucks, that we are living in some technological backwater when it comes to doing this job and keeping our planes in the air. And this is a video from 2019.

18:57 Whether it's on the news or in movies, you've probably seen these before. They're called flight strips, and they're typically computer printouts of individual flights that air traffic controllers can then manually move around to help manage those flights. A lot of the time, there's those things I was telling you to look out for. It It looks like the kind of thing you would see in a 1989 Ukrainian hospital, but you won't find them in the tower in Vancouver. There are strips here, but they're all electronic. So by 2010, it was in use in every operational facility in Canada. Greg Dancero manages tower terminal operations. For Canada, he says it's a big change from the way they used to do it. But Canada's air traffic control system is different in another way. Unlike the FAA, it is not run by the government. It is a private not-for-profit corporation that makes its money largely from fees charged to the airlines. It was once part of the government but went private 23 years ago. It was a time when the country was really kind of strapped for cash. Mark Miller is an aviation journalist and pilot. Privatizing uh the air traffic control system seemed to make sense. It generated cash. Um, and it, you know, it it offered an opportunity to make the system more efficient because when you actually have to manage a budget and only earn revenue by providing a service to the user, which is the way these user feebased versions of air traffic control work, you suddenly have a what's called incentive alignment. Oh, if we adopt new technology, it drives our cost down. It even drives our labor cost down because you don't have to be stressed out moving around little pieces of plastic to try to keep planes in the air. You can use a computer. That's how things work. That's why private enterprises, competitive enterprises do better than government monopolies whose funding is not really relevant to how you're performing or the value you're creating for the user or the customer. So, Canada went this way.

21:04 And a little side note is this is part of a broader sort of embrace of freer market smaller government policy in Canada in the '9s and put put forward by an actual left of center Canadian government. And that is because unlike we in the US, Canada can't issue the world's safest asset. We we do it. It's called the US dollar. But Canada, if people aren't buying Canadian bonds, they're in deep trouble real real quick. And that was happening in the '90s. And that's why Canada found itself looking towards privatization of things like air traffic control. Our Navan sweet tower solutions. This country's private air traffic control monopoly has a name, NAV Canada. And the technology it's developed is now sold to other countries. its air traffic management system recently installed at London's massive Heathrow airport, but not sold to us. The tower at London's Heathrow airport is hiding a secret. While air traffic controllers at the top of the tower direct planes to take off and land using sight, radar, and voice take off. Hidden 200 ft down in the base of Heathrow's tower lies the next generation of air traffic control, the digital AI tower. Here, companies are testing whether highdefinition cameras and AI algorithms could bring air traffic control into the 21st century. That's because while air traffic has increased five-fold over the past four decades, the method for managing air traffic hasn't really changed much at all. So, while towers have become an iconic part of any airport, this technology could be their demise. Here's how digital towers are reshaping [Music] airports. What you're seeing here isn't a window. It's a live feed from an array of highdefinition cameras mounted here just below Heathrow's tower which are stitched together to create a panoramic view of the runways. So the views behind me are the views that the controllers see out of the window and in fact to the millisecond are seeing out of the window as we speak now. The system is being run by NATS a company that provides air traffic management services to the UK.

23:12 Andy said that as well as showing the view from the tower an algorithm is overlaying radar information on each aircraft. Of course, like this is the kind of stuff that you see in an Uber. So, uh, but but here we are, making it far easier for a controller to identify which plane is which. Now, while this technology may seem somewhat futuristic, aspects of it are already in use today. If you've ever landed at London City Airport in the UK, you may have assumed that this traditional control tower looking building was where the air traffic controllers sit. But they're actually in a digital tower over 70 miles away in this building near Southampton viewing cameras from a top this tower adjacent to the airport's runway. And in Norway, this digital tower hub run by airport group Avenue Avanor is being used to provide remote air traffic services to nine airports across the country and is set to expand to 21 by the end of the decade. Why are we behind? Why is Norway and the UK and the Netherlands and Canada and New Zealand at the cutting edge of technology looking to the 21st century and we haven't gotten out of the 1960s. For now, while digital towers are going online around the globe, they remain uncertified in America and it's set to be over 3 years before any remote tower system gets the green light. The thing that is just so striking as I've spent today looking at this footage is how little it's changed here. So, you've seen what the cutting edge looks like.

24:40 If you go back to these uh these old news reels, it it should be upsetting how little's changed here in the States. Well, hello Mr. Craig. I didn't recognize you. It's been a long time since you've flown with us. Hope you have a nice trip. Well, thank you. I'm sure I will. you some kind of celebrity or something? Well, hardly. Well, if you don't mind my asking, what kind of work are you in? Well, not at all. I'm with the FAA.

25:10 Oh, one of those government agencies. I like this guy already. Who? One of those government agencies. This isn't, you know, this is how we all talked back then. Of course, listen to this explanation and pay attention to the visuals from the 1960s. where many air traffic controllers work to control the flights of aircraft on instrument flight plans through their particular area. They keep track of all aircraft under their control 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Planes inbound. Look at this thing. Look. Look at this. There it is.

25:46 Planes going up and coming down. Now, here's today. Can then manually move around to help moving these things around. Literally, I think that might literally be the exact same plastic. Why would you want to work this kind of job? You don't. Which is why they can't fill the 3,000 roles they have on top of all the DEI nonsense and the not getting the most qualified candidates and letting people wash out from the street, etc., etc. But here's the thing. This has been understood as a problem here forever.

26:19 Every administration for the past 30 years has claimed they were going to fix this. In fact, back in 2003, there was a new initiative called NextGen that was going to modernize America's air traffic control. And the video, which by the way was already years later, is a treat. As an airline passenger, you may barely notice the changes taking place over the next 10 years to improve your flight. Did you hear that? You may barely notice what we're doing to improve the flood, but you will appreciate the increased safety, environmental benefits, and reduced delays as the next generation air transportation system is adopted.

27:08 [Music] [Music] Okay, I have to break this down for just this is what you call having boring footage and trying to spice it up in the edit. So, like in between these electrocution moments are like look look at this look at this look at this footage.

27:45 Oh, look at look at this guy with the Hawaiian shirt just standing around. Pay close attention to each of these shots. They're it's it's amazing. Oh, look at this. I think the uh the sound designer at the end here was planting a seed because that sound is the classic horror movie thriller soundtrack. Yeah, that's what we got going.

28:31 This video on YouTube was posted 16 years ago and wasn't like QCed or quality controlled because the first 7 seconds of it are black. This is these are the people controlling the skies when you look back. Okay. December 12th, 2003, Congress passed the Vision 100, Century of Aviation Reauthorization Act, which establishes the Joint Planning Development Office to manage work related to the next generation air transportation system. And then you can, this is off of the FAA's website, and then you can proceed to scroll through the fact that uh it's a timeline of of hor of not doing any of this. I'm sure it costs tens of billions to not do any of it, though. And so this is where we are. The president and the current head of the FAA has put forward a rhetoric of a plan of some kind. And let's have a quick listen to that. We're going to rebuild some towers. We're going to rebuild some TCON. We're going to rebuild some centers. Not all of them, but we're going to rebuild a few of them that need to be need to be rebuilt. So, there'll be some bricks and mortar to this plant.

29:50 However, everything else, this is really easy. Everything else that controls the airspace is going to be brand new. All new hardware, all new software, uh, is going to be built into this brand new air traffic control system. Then like your iPhone you can actually get updates you can build on top of what we are going to have in place. So as new technology becames becomes available we can actually deploy it and we're going to build upon the safety build on the technology build on innovation that's going to happen in this country to continue to make airspace safer and more efficient. So we want to build this in 3 to four years and we can do it with the help of Congress. As you saw, this is all well and good except that this is still fundamentally wrong. We should be doing what our friends to the north have already done and did back in the '9s, and that is we should spin out air traffic control to a separate enterprise like a public utility like the electricity utility that delivers electricity that powers all of this and is funded by fees. That is what should be done. That would be a transformation and then that would empower the organization doing it to actually keep us safe in the air, drive down costs and make life better, faster, more efficient for all of us. Uh there's a great and lengthy and nerdy paper you can check out by Robert W. Pool that goes into this in detail. We'll put a link over at dadsavesamea.com if you want to geek out on this, but the comparisons between us and Canada and basically everywhere else are stark and they're a perfect example of why throwing money at a problem doesn't solve it. You need to change the institution. You need to change the incentives. I don't expect, frankly, the Trump administration to make much progress unless they take a step back and say we're going to do the Canadian way.

31:56 Maybe that will mean like we just have to import Canada as a 51st state. But how about we just import the Canadian idea of privatizing air traffic control so that all of us can get to our destinations this summer and see our families and go on vacation without fear that a military helicopter is going to crash into our plane as it lands. Anyway, I hope this has helped you understand this thing that frankly most of us don't understand and for good reason, but it impacts all of us who travel. Uh, again, we'll put links to the references and research over at dadsavesamea.com. And I hope you have a great weekend.

32:38 [Music] Well, I uh warned you not to get me started about air traffic control. You know, I'm uh I'm afraid I've talked your ears off. Oh, not at all. I've enjoyed this flight more than any I've ever made. you know, getting behind the scenes and learning how all this happens. Let me say this, Mr. Craig speaking to all the air traffic controllers from all of us who fly. [Music]

Summary

America's air traffic control system is facing significant challenges, including severe staffing shortages and outdated technology, leading to frequent delays and safety concerns. While other countries like Canada and the UK have modernized their systems, the U.S. remains stuck in outdated practices, exacerbated by a lack of qualified candidates and inefficient hiring processes.

- Newark Liberty International Airport is experiencing severe delays due to a staffing crisis, with 20% of air traffic controllers walking off the job.
- The U.S. currently has a 26% deficit in certified air traffic controllers, with 10,800 in place versus the needed 14,633.
- The FAA's technology is outdated, with many systems from the 1960s and 70s, hindering efficiency and safety.
- The hiring process for air traffic controllers has changed to allow applicants without prior experience, raising concerns about competency and safety.
- Countries like Canada have privatized their air traffic control systems, leading to improved efficiency and technology adoption.
- The U.S. air traffic control system is criticized for being a government monopoly, lacking the incentives found in private enterprises.
- There is a call for a fundamental restructuring of the air traffic control system to improve safety and efficiency, similar to Canada's model.
- The FAA has proposed a multi-year plan to modernize the air traffic control system, but skepticism remains about its effectiveness given past failures.
© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram