Transcript
0:00 So hopefully this is more than just a book. It's about how we join together to defend public education, strengthen democracy, and provide a better future for all. >> This is what the labor movement has now become. It has become wholly parasitic on our society. It exists to consume our tax dollars and restrict our choices at every turn as parents, as students, as Americans. Hey there friends, fans and foes of Dad Saves America. John Pola here and I thought I would take this Friday, the Friday leading into glorious Labor Day weekend. Well, to talk about Labor Day, to talk about the origins of this national holiday, the philosophy that underpinned it, and that frankly proceeded to go off the rails, not just for our country and other countries, but for for labor, for workers along the way. But I think the best place to start is the riot that led to its creation, the Hey Market affair. This was this demonstration, this labor dispute uh that started off as a protest in 1886 and escalated into this riot. This was actually the match that lit the fuse of Labor Day. And I want to walk through that history a little bit to give you a sense and then dive in a little deeper.
1:25 So, I have actually geeked out a little bit today and made a little flowchart of Labor Day just so you can see how it connects. So, behold, um, a truncated genealogy of Labor Day starting with the Hey Market affair. So this right here is this lightning rod event in the United States and it actually a few years later gives rise to the establishment of international workers day. This is pinned at May 1st uh by essentially the international workers congress that was held in Paris in 1889.
2:06 um and basically a collection of socialist and Marxist movements and organizations globally. Of course, it's in France. Most of most of communism came out of France, but it is mapping against this old European holiday called Mayday. and Mayday. I'm funny thing is I never heard of Mayday until I moved here to Austin because my son went to a Waldorf school which is inspired by, you know, German education reformer Rudolph Steiner. And so he actually celebrated Mayday complete with the maple running around the maple. And so Mayday was this long-standing European tradition. It didn't really come over to the US because, you know, our Puritan roots thought that it was pagan, which it actually was. It goes back to the Greeks. You know, you can see right here in my little flowchart, paganism, paganism, right down by socialism and communism. Um, but that's the start. We have International Workers Day. And what comes next in the US is a battle over how to commemorate this event by American socialist leaders um as a national holiday. There's actually this sort of historical dispute between two men whose last names are both Maguire over you know who is the real father of America's Labor Day. But as we sit here, I believe it's actually this guy, Matthew Maguire, who was also a member of the Socialist Labor Party of America.
3:45 And he advocates for this. and Grover Cleveland, the president, the Democratic president at the time, um, opts to put it on the first Monday of September in order to distance it from the global Marxist, socialist, communist, international workers day. Grover is actually a what we would call classical liberal. He doesn't want communism to come to America. And so he's trying to find a way to recognize this event, satiate the demand for this national holiday without uh plugging America into the international uh workers of the world uniting under the banner of communism. If you click all the way through, you'll find there's some other interesting characters in this history. Um, one of which is a guy named Ferdinand who believed that the way to ultimately usher in socialism in America was through organized labor and slowly taking over the institutions. Uh, he is not a Fabian, but this is it sort of rhymes with that. And then of course we've got our buddy Carl Carl Marx who's always always floating in here somewhere. That is how we end up with Labor Day. It really does go back to the specific riot, but it is an exemplar of a broader labor movement that was happening. And I want to drill into this partly because I think the story, the lore that has been um developed here especially and is taught to our kids and and shown to all of us about the labor movement and what it has and hasn't done needs a critical eye. Let's say to most of us, Labor Day means time off from work, maybe a barbecue to mark the official end of summer. But how much do you know about what inspired its creation? The labor movement. The labor movement started around the industrial revolution. A time in the late 19th century when America exploded in size and wealth.
5:48 >> So far so good. That's that's right. That's also the time of Karl Marx and the broader uh socialist movements. this this reactionary set of movements to the transformation taking place in society that was born out of the technology revolution. You know, this graphic is actually pretty good because it really fundamentally was a technological revolution taking place. >> Advances in technology created manufacturing jobs and people moved to cities to work in factories.
6:21 But it wasn't the workers getting rich. It was their bosses who rad in big profits by paying low wages for long hours. >> And so this right here is the first problem with the story. The problem is not that workers were working in horrible conditions, including kids, for long hours for relatively low pay by our modern standards. The problem with the story is that they weren't slaves. They were moving voluntarily to the cities and taking these jobs because as difficult and long hours and horrible conditions as they were, they were better than the grinding poverty of being in subsistence agriculture that constitutes most of human civilization going back for thousands of years. That is easy to overlook. It is the most fundamental thing that gets overlooked by the story that is told about the labor movement that really all that was necessary to lift people up was negotiation. But but it's important to remember that people wanted the kind of pay as low as it was because it was more pay more opportunity than what they had back on the family farm. And to this day, farming is one of the most dangerous jobs and occupations you can be in.
7:47 >> Fed up with big business, industrial workers created unions to fight for better conditions. Unions are the backbone of the labor movement. But what exactly did they accomplish? Well, for one, you can thank the labor movement for your work- free weekend. In the late 1800s, the average American worked as much as 100 hours a week. Unions held strikes to demand shorter work weeks and an 8-hour workday to make time for family and relaxation. >> Okay. So, what do I have to say about that? Isn't that Isn't that true? Didn't unions actually fight for our weekend and for the 8 hour work week? Yes, they did. Yes, that that's right. This is the part of the story that I think has to be acknowledged is that the labor movement did form a powerful kind of negotiation at a time when you had the rapid rise of very large-scale businesses that had a lot of money and ultimately also had a lot of political power. And so I can acknowledge that. I think that that's true. The problem is when you don't understand the underlying conditions that made these things possible, you go off the rails. And that's why the socialist Marxist roots of the labor movement are such a problem because the movement in terms of being concerned about working conditions and being a way for individual workers to come together and collectively bargain. That is voluntary association. You know, that wasn't the only thing going on in the United States to actually help workers through voluntary association. The other thing going on alongside of the transformation of the work world was that we had mutual aid societies, things like the Shriners and DFW and local churches that would bind people together in community and support them. In fact, the earliest forms of health insurance were actually delivered by these voluntary non- labor, nonwork-based associations. In fact, they would have staff doctors that would take care of their members. So, labor unions at this stage were just one more form of voluntary civil society. That is still fundamentally American. That is still fundamentally a free pro-individual liberty type of arrangement. where things start to go off the rails is when the labor movement calcifies around its Marxist roots and starts to build topdown structures around it. In 1938, Congress passed a law called the Fair Labor Standards Act, which set the 40-hour work week, regulated child labor, and set standards for minimum wage and overtime pay. In the 1930s and 1940s, workers were also able to negotiate health benefit plans from their employers, though union membership is on a decline today.
10:43 >> He's glossing over this period of time where the labor movement was transformed. But this is a really important thing for you to understand. The early stages of the labor movement, socialist inspired as they may have been, were voluntary. What happened in the aftermath of the Great Depression was a transformation of the labor movement into a topdown essentially government cartel racket. You had the Wagner Act. You had the n the creation of the national labor relations board and this superstructure that forced companies to negotiate with only one union and forced all of the employees of the employer to join the union. It created monopolistic circumstances that essentially centralized power not just in the hands of the union bosses instead of the workers but in the hands of frankly an increasingly cozy class of corporate oligarchs and the government. This is the problem. The socialist roots of the labor movement led them to believe that the answer to all our problems was more and more centralized power and control.
12:02 That is the poison pill that wrecked the labor movement. And some of the things that were pushed for here, most people don't realize how dangerous and damaging they are. He referenced minimum wages. Minimum wages were advocated primarily, and this is a matter of public record, by labor unions like the AFL CIO, to try to price out free blacks who are entering the north the north from getting jobs. This was auto workers unions, Detroit and Chicago, having these southern black workers move north looking for opportunity and were willing to take a lower wage than what people were accustomed to because it was an opportunity and they were trying to compete. And so minimum wages were put in place to stop that to functionally knock that rung of the ladder out from under them. That is the origin of the minimum wage. It still has that effect today. If you keep your job when your wage is forced up by law, good for you.
13:05 You don't get to see the people that aren't hired as a result. And one of the biggest casualties of this labor union top-down movement's attack on wages and on open freely negotiated wages is our kids. Because the increase in the minimum wage has priced most inexperienced workers, namely our kids, from getting jobs. This is why we have seen a dramatic decline in teenage work.
13:37 And this is bad. So, Labor Day, labor unions, isn't it great? We eliminated child labor. We went too far with our elimination of child labor. We need to roll that back. We need a little more child labor. Our kids are spending too much time sitting in chairs, staring at screens, listening to lectures, and not working. And as a parent, I made choices to try to have my son work as much as he could starting in seventh grade. And he has been better off for it. There is a lot you can learn from work. Now, do I think the kids yearn for the minds? Um, you know, I'm not particularly interested in our kids getting black lung. So, but but the reason why they won't have to work in a mine is because we have a modern technologically advanced economy. So, so long as they can legally find a job, they will get one. No thanks to the socialistic components of the labor movement. The other piece of the puzzle that happens when you centralize power in this way and when you calcify it legally is you have Lord Actton's conundrum which is absolute power corrupts absolutely and the corruption in the labor movement is really really extreme namely the mafia may appear strange that a union membership will reelect a man accused of racketeering unfortunately if he's fought a strong fight for some improve improvements and his union has shared in the general gains achieved by the whole force of organized labor. His own police record may be overlooked. This was so with union boss Hawer. Despite the charges against Haer, which included getting rich on union funds, the teamsters elected him president and then were expelled from the AFL CIO. Jimmy Hoffa is a case study in the intermingling of the mafia and big labor. Um, some historians trace the origin of this marriage to prohibition when Al Capone and v the various sort of racketeers that emerged found themselves partnering with labor to to make things happen. But that marriage persisted for a long long time and to some extent through to today. The kind of intimidation tactics and labor racketeering that the mob frankly pioneered uh they pioneered by way of organized labor. When I was living in New Jersey, my neighbor across the street, um, which was he was kind of an ironic guy because he was actually married to a Chinese woman and and sent his daughter off to China to study cuz the local public school was not good enough. So, they thought she'd get a better education in China. But he was an actual died in the wool, deep blue, old school Democrat and a labor union lawyer. and and his claim to fame and again we're in north northern New Jersey I'm talking about was cleansing his local union of its mob roots of its mobster infestation.
16:47 Um but but this is the problem because the fundamental underlying engine of the labor movement was communism that is a totalitarian worldview. That is a worldview that says everyone should comply. Everyone should be told what to do from the top down, which is very consistent with the kinds of thugery that we see from guys with mustaches and mafia bosses. And then we come to the present. But before we come to the present, I want to point out a couple other facts of recent history as it pertains to work that I just think are interesting and important to know. And they are dataoriented.
17:26 So if the labor movement started off by trying to reduce the amount of work hours and and the number of people working specifically you know uh children people who we we ultimately today don't want to be in the workforce as a matter of necessity in a sense they succeeded but they were riding this technological transformation that has impacted everyone in the world and let's just take a look at how things have shaped up when it comes to hours worked.
17:57 So this is our world in data. And this graphic right here I just think is really interesting. So since 1870, you can see the dramatic change in hours worked per worker annually. And you can notice a couple things here. So one, um the Chinese are working. They're number one in hours worked right now. Um, and when you look at their graph, it doesn't it doesn't go as far back, but you can kind of see that they they have actually gone up. So, that's the first kind of interesting thing is that communist China actually had his work hours go up over the past 40 years.
18:35 Um, here's the United States. So, you see the dramatic fall coming out of the 1920s. Um, that part of that is driven by the Great Depression and then a a kind of steady stabilization. But the thing that's most interesting to me about this data is the differences between countries. So we are number two behind China on hours worked per year per worker. And you can see the depending on which country uh the rest of the west works less.
19:11 Ironically Germany works the least um at least as of 2019. Why is that? What happened? Is this the success of the labor movements in Europe relative to the United States where that nasty Ronald Reagan union busted? I don't think so. For example, um Sweden actually bottomed out around 1980 and has started to go creep back up. Right around 80 was Sweden's most socialistic time period. Um but everyone else has continually declined. The the other thing that's important to know is that those declines are matched by earnings.
19:56 So if you look at median income or consumption per day, so this is a median income per day graph that's adjusted for not just inflation but also um differences in cost of living between countries. And as you can see, darker blue means more money. The US at 70 bucks uh is near the highest in the world. And it's interesting because when you look over to Europe, which most more socialistminded people like to point to as exemplars of where we'd like to go for workers, you see that workers there are worse off. They're making less money. So in Spain, Spain's relatively poor. Uh they're uh they're 46 bucks.
20:44 Italy is comparable, 49. France 57. Germany's pretty close to us at 67. The UK not doing so hot, 54. Sweden 55, Finland 56. Norway is basically the Saudi Arabia of Scandinavia. And so they're actually beating us at 75 bucks, but they basically pump money out of the ground. They're they're a petrol state, so they're slightly different than we are on that front. But if you look at this sort of mapped graph, you see we are at the top. For those who think that we in the United States um trail behind other countries when it comes to earnings and labor conditions, I I think the data suggests that there's something more complex going on. So, one of the other pieces of the puzzle that's driving less work and lower incomes in other countries is taxes. So, economist Ed Prescott back in 2004 actually looked at the data over time to try to understand what is going on in Europe.
21:51 Why are Europeans so much poorer than Americans? And why do they work so much less? After all, most Americans are of European descent. were basically the same genetically. And what he found is that actually when you go back in time before the Great Society movement, before the sort of big labor socialist movements really got a foothold in our politics in the West and drove tax rates through the roof, Europeans actually worked more than Americans. Once tax rates got hiked up into the sky to the 70 80 90% marginal rates, the kind of tax rates that frankly future New York City mayor uh Zoran mom Donnie and his ilk would like to reimpose on all of us. Europeans simply stopped working.
22:41 This is the abstract to the paper and we'll put a link to the whole thing over at dadsavesamea.com. But he says the surprising finding is that this marginal tax rate accounts for the predominance of the differences at points in time and the large change in relative labor supply over time. This is important because what we're looking at is the downstream effects of the socialist origins of the labor movement. These movements have advocated for higher taxes, for bigger government, for more regulations, some in the name of safety, some in the name of protecting their racket.
23:17 And the result hasn't been good for working people. It hasn't created more opportunities for working people. It has benefited the big and the powerful. That is what it's done. The labor movement and its socialist origins have become an engine for oligarchy. everywhere they exist. And nowhere is the sort of transparent self-interest of unions clearer than their only remaining stronghold in the US today because private sector unions have been on a long slow and continuing decline since the 1950s.
23:56 Public sector unions, the penultimate communist enterprise, are all that now really remain. And they are exemplified by none other than Rowdy Randy Weinearten, my favorite punching bag. And a old bag she is. Educators in public schools from preK to higher education are under attack. And people often ask me why. Well, those who attack us fear what we do. We teach students how to reason and how to think critically. We teach them honest history and the importance of pluralism in America.
24:37 >> We teach them that they're inherently racist and that America was founded in 1619. And we lock them up in their homes during the pandemic and never apologize for it while I go off to Ukraine to be a fake war correspondent. >> And those attacks are why I had to write this book, Why Fascists Fear Teachers. I warn about the dangers of these attacks on knowledge and pluralism and I spell out the ways we can fight back and it will be in bookstores in September.
25:08 >> Oh, are you ready? Are this it is kind of amazing that this is a national organizational leader with such um cringe cloying presentational skills. I would think she'd be better at this than she is. The book is also a love letter to educators. Educators help students realize their full human potential. And they do all of this as they deal with everything from budget cuts to culture wars with class sizes that are too high and salaries that are too low. So hopefully this is more than just a book. It's about how we join together to defend public education, strengthen democracy, and provide a better future for all. This is what the labor movement has now become. It has become uh something that is unrecognizable to its origins and is wholly parasitic on our society. It exists to consume our tax dollars and restrict our choices at every turn as parents, as students, as Americans. And also, it's pretty unoriginal when it comes to graphic design because here is the cover of this ridiculous book, Why Fascists Fear Teachers. She might be maybe should get a lesson in why the overuse of Nazi language devalues it in the public discourse. Um, it bears a striking resemblance to a book dedicated to her by guest of the show and um, education reform advocate Corey D'Angelus, The Parent Revolution.
26:49 This is this one came out last year and oh, isn't that clever? You know, just barely different fonts. Barely different. So, what's the takeaway here for your Labor Day weekend? What what can you do with this uh nuanced take on the history of the labor movement if you think it's nuanced? I think it's nuanced. Well, I think number one, if you take away one thing, it's that ideas matter and that the underlying proposition of the of the socialists is that we exist as blob groups, labor, capital, workers, owners. And I think that this is false.
27:35 It's false. This is collectivism. This is the treating of people like a blob monolith with one set of interests and one set of concerns. That is not what we are. We are individuals. We are both workers and owners. We we speculate on our futures, so we are also speculators. We invest in ourselves, so we are also investors. We start things and projects and so we are entrepreneurs. We're all of these things at the same time. What is the dividing line between being a worker and being a manager or being a manager and being an entrepreneur or a capitalist? These lines are a lot blurriier than they seem. And our language and the way we measure and think about and look at work is trapped in this old big labor communist framework of us versus them of workers versus the man versus capitalists versus you the proletariat versus bourgeoisi.
28:40 That isn't the way things mostly work. It's not. We are luckily in a relatively free society still. It's not as free as I would like and I actually can find common cause with people across the political spectrum on the areas where it is not free enough. But I think that if you see the entire world through the lens of us versus them um and collective groups doing battle with each other, you end up in a permanent war of all against all. It is a path to hell. It is a path to being in the league with mobsters. It is the path to being controlled by dark forces that you seed your individual autonomy to. And I think this is something that we as parents need to find a way to help our kids understand cuz none of our institutions help them understand this. Everything is framed collectively. Every story they are told about our history is a collectivist story. So we have to do it.
29:44 We have to help them understand that their path of their life is one that is within their control. That is the most important lesson I think we can instill in our kids. It is the lesson of Victor Frankle's man's search for meaning. It is the lesson that they should take with them in their backpack as they go back to school next week. and it is a lesson that you're going to need to reinforce with them over Thanksgiving when they come back from freshman year of college with their head filled of commie gobbledygook. Let me know what you think. Uh has this been helpful? Has this added some texture to the way you understand this weekend? Um has it given you something to talk about with your kids? Uh let me know in the comments below. As always, we'll put links and references over at dadsavesamerica.com.
30:29 And so head over there and subscribe. That's a great way to help support this channel. And another way to help support our channel is head over to our Amazon store where we've got affiliate links to all kinds of stuff including this camera and the gear we use here to make all this stuff look so nice. And um every purchase helps us a tiny bit and it won't cost you anything extra. So with that, have a great weekend.
30:56 [Applause]
Summary
- Labor Day originated from the Haymarket Affair in 1886, a pivotal labor protest that highlighted workers' rights.
- The labor movement initially arose during the Industrial Revolution, as workers sought better conditions and wages.
- Unions played a crucial role in establishing the 8-hour workday and weekends, but their socialist roots led to a top-down structure that centralized power.
- The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 established the 40-hour workweek and minimum wage, but these policies have had complex, sometimes negative, effects on employment.
- The speaker argues that the labor movement has become parasitic, consuming tax dollars and limiting choices for parents and students.
- The rise of public sector unions is seen as a continuation of the labor movement's shift towards centralized power, often at the expense of individual freedoms.
- The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding labor history through a lens of individualism rather than collectivism, advocating for personal agency and autonomy in the workforce.
- The discussion concludes with a call to educate children about these concepts to combat collectivist narratives in education.