Transcript
0:00 Do I continue to make $2 to $3,000 every single month or do I sell it and just exit? >> You always want to get a a high return on investment, but we also want to get a high return on brain damage. >> Do I want to make $20,000 forever or for the next 10 years? Or do I want to capture 20 years of profits in one fell swoop? >> If you have a really good property in a good location, you're always going to get offers on that property. It's going to be really tempting, but if this is your best property, there's no reason to sell it. your gains are going to be 400k. That kind of changes the perspective a little bit. I'm glad that I knew that out the gate because you don't want a surprise $400,000 tax bill.
0:38 Chad Carson, welcome back to the podcast, my friend. I feel like every time we do these, the videos do quite well on on our channel. So, we've been talking lately and we're like, we should do more of these because I think people like to hear our takes. >> Well, I enjoy it anyway. So, no matter what, I just I like talking to you. So, thanks for having me back. >> That's true. That's true. Hey, same same. I also like talking to you, but the audience likes when we talk to each other. So, let's let's do this. Today, we're talking about I think a good topic in the world of real estate. A lot of people, and I understand the thinking, it's like you should never sell. Never sell. If you buy a property, hold, hold, hold. The way you build wealth and the way you become a, you know, a real estate millionaire and all this stuff is by keeping your property. And there's definitely truth to that, but there's also a lot of truth to you should sell your property. There are a lot of compelling reasons why you should consider offloading certain properties in your portfolio. So, today we have three reasons why you should sell your property. And stick around until the end because we also have three reasons why you should not sell your property. The first reason you should consider selling your property. Uh it's perhaps the most obvious one. Uh but it's your property is a dog. Would you agree with this?
1:46 >> Yeah. Another way I would say it is like you did like you did a science experiment and the science experiment blew up. Like it it didn't work. like you you had a thesis, you had an idea, you had a plan, and then for whatever reason, and we can give a few of the reasons, but it just this property is not working. And so, it's just acknowledging the reality that it didn't work and pivoting and doing something different.
2:05 >> Yeah. So, for me, the I've had a lot of I've sold a lot of properties uh in the last year to two years for a variety of reasons. The main reason was it just didn't make as much money as I needed it to to be worth the time that I was putting into that property. And so this actually will kind of feed into the next bullet point here, but I think the bullet point here is like if you buy a property and it in general does not meet your expectation or I don't know, it's just not fulfilling your happiness with the amount of cash flow that's coming from it. I think that's where you offload something like if you don't make enough money then there's no reason to keep it barring certain circumstances like you're going to you don't have equity and all that stuff. But if you if you're in a position to sell it, I think you should just cut your losses.
2:52 >> Yeah, I agree. I think the main thing that before you sell a property, think about like why do you own a property in the first place? Like what's the good thing that this property is bringing into your life and it's definitely money. Like there should be some cash flow and or growth or equity that's building up. So that's definitely part of it. The other part for me is that I want to avoid negative problems. So, some of the reasons I have sold properties is maybe the neighborhood has just gotten a turn taken a turn for the worse or maybe I didn't recognize that the neighborhood was not as good as it as I thought it was in the first place.
3:19 Like I had a property where, you know, the next door neighbors were dealing drugs on the front porch every single day in the middle of the day. It's like, okay, like how can I rent my property? How can I keep a good tenant when that's going on? And so, if you have neighborhood problems, if you have neighbor problems, I think those are those are things you can't control. And so, some things you can fix. You can fix a house, you can fix it up, but if you can't control what's going on in the neighborhood, and it's not getting any better anytime soon, that's a reason to sell in my in my opinion. Just go ahead and cut your losses, find a better property, and and move on.
3:48 >> Yeah, I'm actually in a very peculiar um situation right now. I've got a property that does well. Like, uh it probably cash flows. It fits my my buy box, like what I would consider high enough cash flow to be worth my time. It makes $2 to $3,000 a month in net cash flow. So 24 to $36,000 a year depending on the on the year and in a few other circumstances. That's pretty good. The problem is that for whatever reason, this property has kind of become the party house of my neighborhood. And not like huge raers, but the way I've created the experience is I I enclosed the driveway to be a sideyard because there's no backyard in this property.
4:33 and put a hot tub and I have a ping pong table and it was meant to be like four families. But what ended up happening is I get a lot of sort of young, you know, early 20s, late 20 group of single people that come and max out the place because if you split it between eight people, it's a really cheap Airbnb. Um, and so I have music playing at night, very late, sometimes midnight. And trust me, before anyone's like, he's the reason that people hate Airbnb, I'm doing my best to correct this. This is not like I this is after many months of me finessing and pulling all the levers that I can, but at the end of the day, my neighbors are are not super happy with me. And so, I'm in this position where I'm like, "Okay, you know, uh I can't short of putting up signs and having sound detection devices and uh vetting all my my Airbnb guests, there's not a lot more I can do. So, I'm at this fork in the road where I'm like, do I continue to make two to$3,000 every single month or do I sell it and put up with my squeaky neighbors that are texting me all the time or do I sell it and just exit? And uh I guess that would probably go under the failed experiment category. Or maybe not failed experiment, but just more like this is a circumstance that I personally cannot control and you know, I might just have to cut bait. Yeah, I've got a friend who uses this this strategy. He says, "You always want to get a a high return on investment." We always think about that, but we also want to get a high return on brain damage. And like right now, your property right now is getting a low return on brain damage because you're making some money, but like your brain is getting damaged because you're having to deal with neighbors and all that kind of stuff. And so, I think there's a lot of reasons why you might have some brain damage on this property. For me, it's been, you know, I told you about the drug dealing neighbors. I've had, you know, maintenance issues. I have have properties have a lot of trees and in the moment they're not a problem but as soon as a storm comes I'm worried about these trees falling on the property.
6:27 I've got other properties with septic tanks. So you can make a long list of things that are going to increase the brain damage you have of owning this property. And you have to ask yourself as an entrepreneur how much money is worth the amount of brain damage I'm having to deal with this and there's some there's some happy medium there. And early in my career I was willing to deal with more brain damage. Now that I'm, you know, in a more kind of maintenance mode and just collecting rent, I don't I I I sell off properties that have hassle in my life.
6:52 >> Yeah. Not everyone has that luxury. So, I think that's going to be, you know, for me, I have the luxury of selling this thing and getting rid of it. But the problem is that I think $2 to $3,000 a month is worth the, you know, the brain damage. The ROD, the return on brain damage is high, I think. But I still don't like to be that guy. Uh, you know, I have a reputation and I I don't want people like being like Rob has party houses. So, all to say, this is a scenario that if you're like going, this is just an example of a scenario, right?
7:20 Like, if you're going through something like this and you're considering it, I just don't want you to be at home thinking, man, I really failed. Like, I can't believe selling this pro like selling this property cementss that I failed. That's not true. Uh, I think again if it's out of your control, you can somewhat be at ease at just cutting the property, especially if it makes you happier. >> Yeah, 100%. >> Uh, the second reason you should sell your property is you have the opportunity to move the profits or the gains from that profit pro property into something better. Tell us your your philosophy on this because I know you've done this several times in your career. What does this actually mean? What does it mean to move into something better?
8:03 >> This is especially relevant for me early in my career when I think when I I always talk about the starter phase, then the builder phase, then the harvester phase. And that the builder phase is when you're really accelerating your wealth building. You're really trying to buy more more units. And I think at that point, like turning over a property can be one of the most profitable things you do because you might have you're out there acquiring properties. So like you have this one deal that has 100,000 in equity and you're like, "All right, that's great.
8:27 I'm making a,000 bucks in cash flow." But then if you had that $100,000 in your pocket to go buy two more properties and put 50,000 down, maybe maybe you could turn that h 100,000 into 300,000 or 400,000 because you could buy two more really good deals. And so I think that's the idea is that like if you are out there hustling and finding more deals and you can buy even better properties then that you can take a move up. You can take a like a you can either trade up like with a 1031 exchange.
8:55 That's one idea. But in some cases, just even just selling the property and taking the money. Like I have a student I just worked with the other day, did a coaching call with them. He lived in a duplex for at least two I think it was two and a half years. Then he rented it out for a year. So he's owned it for like three years, but he now has 200,000 in equity in this property and he could still sell it taxfree because he lived there two out of the last 5 years.
9:19 >> And that that to me was really interesting because that because he he's in the growth mode. He really needs that money to buy the next deal. And so for him, 200,000 bucks tax-free sitting in the bank is is a really good opportunity. And he's also I know he's out there making offers and looking at at deals. So like that was a perfect situation to me of yes, you're selling a property that's in a pretty good location, but you're turning that money and you're going to buy two more good deals and turn that 200,000 into 400,000. And that to me was a an example of a good sale situation.
9:48 >> Yeah. Yeah. So, let's talk about the 1031 exchange and and what that is because it's always a fancy sounding term and every not everyone listening to this probably knows what it is. So, a 1031 is basically where and there's a whole process and you have to go through an intermediary and just make sure that if you do this, you talk to the proper professional um because I'm probably about to botch this, but a 1031 is basically where you sell one of your properties and you take the profits of that property and instead of paying taxes on those profits, you are moving them into another property. Again, there's some specifications and some criteria like it has to be a like kind property. It has to be more expensive. I believe there's just kind of like a bunch of things, but the idea is you take the profits, you move it into a higher property, like a a bigger property, and you instead of having to pay the taxes now, you just kick the can down the road. So, kind of goes a little bit into that borrow until you die strategy that we've talked about on on your channel, and obviously I had a big video on that. If you're interested, go check that out. But the idea is I've got this property with a lot of equity in it and the cash flow is so so or it's pretty good, but yeah, what can $200,000 in the example you gave unlock for somebody? And in a lot of instances, you know, moving $200,000 into a bigger property might get you something that, you know, gets you a lot more cash flow if strategically put into that new property.
11:11 >> And there's there's caveats to this one, too, is that like not always you got to make sure that next deal is even better. Like that's the that's the thing I see people mess up is like the 1031 exchanges because they have so many moving parts and they have a time limit of 180 days and you have to identify properties in 45 days. Sometimes people buy a property just to save money on taxes and they buy they buy another dog like they don't they don't buy a good property. So I think that's the biggest thing to watch out for. Like the assumption we're making is you have this property is pretty good but you're buying one or two or three more properties that are even better and you're improving your wealth building situation. Like that's a really good net move, but it could go bad if you don't buy a good replacement.
11:49 >> Yeah, for sure. So, I'll give you an example of a I just sold a property that really there was no reason to sell it. And I I'll share the numbers just because this is this was the exact deal at home for everyone watching. I know that this isn't the most relatable deal, but honestly, if you're in real estate long enough, this this this will eventually happen to you. But I bought this property in Gatlinburg, Tennessee.
12:13 We bought it for 500K, 510K, and ended up selling it for like 875K, something like that. All I know is by the end the money that was wired to me was 430K. So, I put 10% down, so I was like 50K, and then I invested some money into it, like maybe 25K and stuff. But all to say, I I had this $430,000 nest egg, and I also paid down the principal, and yeah, a lot of stuff like that. So thing to consider here is for me I had the $430,000 and the property itself was running as a Airbnb and cash flowing $20,000.
12:53 So I had to ask myself, do I want to make $20,000 I don't know forever or for the next 10 years or like what do I you know what's my plan here? Or do I want to capture effectively 20 years of uh profits in one fell swoop? I think that's right. Yeah. 20 years at $20,000. Am I wrong here? I think that math is correct. I'm gonna check. >> Yeah. 20 20 years times 10 is 200. So, yeah, you did that math, right?
13:19 >> All right. Simple math. And I'm like, did I do it right? >> Yeah. So, it's like I I asked myself, I'm like, do I want to make $20,000 in perpetuity or do I want to make, you know, effectively 20 years of profit in one fell swoop? And the answer was yes. I I did want to do that. So, I've taken that money. As you can tell, I'm in my studio, so I'm not retired in Mexico.
13:39 Uh, and I used it to basically invest into two other properties. So, I put $200,000 to renovate and revamp one of my properties and I put $200,000 to revamp another one of my properties and and get the the valuation of that much higher. So, all to say that to me is a better opportunity. Not only did I scrap one property for my portfolio, but I use that cash flow or I use that profit to enhance the cash flow here and advance and enhance the valuation of the property here because it's a commercial property. So, that to me is a better opportunity. Uh, less time management and now I've got two properties that will hopefully return me a lot more than the $20,000 a year I was making. And that equity still exists. It's now just moved into those properties. Rob, I'm curious for you, and it's probably not an exact number on every property, but if you had 20,000 in the first property, to go through the trouble and the hassle of selling it, but then also redeploying it, do you have like a multiple that you would look for? Is it like, hey, I got to make 40,000 bucks per year instead of 20,000, like 2x, or is it, you know, 50% more? Is there some kind of in your mind you, how big of a of an opportunity, better opportunity does it need to be for you to act and sell something that's pretty good by itself?
14:50 >> Um, you know, I'm not super dialed there. think it is case by case. Generally speaking, I'm not going to move a property unless I'm going to make like six figures on the profit. So, like if if I have a $100,000 profit on it, then I will consider it worth it to me. Even cuz, you know, I've been in this for eight years, I'm now starting to sell properties that I've owned for like 3 to six years. And in my mind, I'm like, yeah, hey, is it worth making 100K now? Ultimately, I think it's like here's I have a rule with them actually.
15:22 If it's 10 years of cash flow in one fell swoop, the answer is generally yes. So, I asked myself, do I want to suffer managing this dog in my portfolio? Not really, not a dog, but do I want to suffer managing this property in my portfolio for the next 10 years or do I just want the profit today? The answer is always I want the profit today because I just feel like I can do more. Like all of the properties that I've purchased pre we're in 2026, pre-2024 are not properties I would ever consider buying today. So I will always exercise my right to take the profit today to redeploy into a new property that now checks the Robbuilt box. Like it it checks my box for what I consider to be a good property. I just know so much more now. So finding properties today is just m a much more profitable thing for me than it was when I was first getting started. Does that make sense?
16:12 >> Yeah. So you're upgrading your portfolio and you're accelerating those profits and using those to do it. And would you pay taxes in that case or would you do a 1031 and like in in typically for yourself? >> So ideally I would do a 1031 but this property that I just told you about was not a 1031 because the way that those properties are structured I couldn't I couldn't 1031 into them because I already own them. Sometimes you can do a reverse 1031 and but the the LLC formations and all that stuff was so complicated I couldn't. So I'm going to pay taxes on 430 grand. But dude, I bought that property in 2021. So for me, I'm like I'll pay the taxes, you know?
16:50 I'll pay the taxes on 430 grand because that's crazy. That's >> also long-term capital long-term capital gains. I mean, if you would have made 400,000 at a day job, you might have a 50% tax bracket. you know, you might pay half of that in taxes, whereas cap long-term capital gains is 20% 22% per. So anyway, people can talk to their CPA and figure it out, but often there's an arbitrage there, too, where owning a property and delaying for a couple years to sell it and getting long-term capital gains is a much better way to pay taxes if you're going to do it than just selling it, flipping it right now.
17:20 >> Yeah. So, let's get into number three here. Um, and then we'll we'll give people a few reasons to not sell their properties because I think people sometimes jump the gun on how quickly they want to do that. But the last one here is uh and this is this really your specialty but I call it winding down. Uh you are in a phase of your life where you are winding down. Explain what this means to you because you've got the small and mighty framework that you've that you've created and pioneered. So you can say it a lot better than I can.
17:47 >> Yeah. So winding down also I think about it like pruning your portfolio. So imagine you're a fruit tree farmer. I always use this fruit tree metaphor because I think long-term rentals really make sense and even short-term rentals that you hold for a long time. They're a lot like planting a seed with a fruit tree. And you know, when you first start your journey in the very beginning, just getting one seed planted and buying one or two rentals is the game. Like that's all you're trying to do. And then you get in that builder phase and you're planning 1 2 3 4 5 6 7. You're trying to get, you know, scale and build and grow a little bit. And then the part that I I find a lot of people don't talk about is what what's next? Like how do you actually like pick the fruit off of your tree and live off of it? Because so many people just I think keep kicking the can and moving the goalpost and keep growing and keep growing and keep growing. I I really advocate for having these stages where you take a break and you harvest some of your equity. And so this is a this could be a good reason to sell. And I'll give you an example. Um let's say I have a well actually have a a real life example. A guy who works with me named Shawn and I had him on my podcast recently. He and his wife they they got into the wealth building phase. They ended up getting up to 21 properties, but that was actually more than he needed to pay. If he paid off a lot of these properties, that was a lot more than he needed. So, he ended up selling down to about nine properties. So, he sold some, paid taxes on them, and paid off and either paid off the debt or used that money for something else and like invested it in notes or something else.
19:07 The point was he like simplified his portfolio and he pruned off the properties that didn't make as much sense. It's kind of like you talked about the ones that you bought 10 years ago and you would never buy that one again, for example, or whatever. He would sell off some of those and he would keep his best properties and he would reduce the amount of debt and increase the amount of cash flow he had in his portfolio. That's a winding down.
19:28 That's like a pruning your portfolio because you're simplifying your life. You're reducing your risk. You're increasing your cash flow. And it's definitely not the move you would make when you're trying to grow and build the most wealth, but is definitely a move you would want to make if you want to have the most peace of mind, the most time, the least hassle. And so I've seen a lot of people do that and that'd be a good reason to sell.
19:47 >> Yeah. I mean, there's also a personal component to this, too. So, what you just said is very tactical and definitely the investor approved way to do this. So, I endorse that. I think windown for me is also like uh you know we were discussing right before this right right before we started recording I I'm not really looking to buy a lot more. Um you you know I'm actively selling. I've I've gotten to this point in my portfolio where yeah I just don't want to buy anymore. So everyone at home don't freak out. This isn't like a I knew it. Um, I am actually, uh, I'm currently making the most money I've ever made in short-term rentals, like from my uh, short-term rental like cash flow perspective every month. But by the end of these rehabs and these things that I that I just kind of talked about, like moving 200k here, 200k here, I just purchased a commercial property, we're coming up on a year. By the time all of these like storms that I have been going through for the last six months, by the time like those storms dissipate and the dust settles, my monthly cash flow on short-term rentals will be the highest at of all time. And so I'm at this point where I'm like, I don't really want more. I don't want to enter a new storm.
21:04 like I've already traversed kind of what I what I feel like I needed to traverse in this space and you know I'm winding down and so personally speaking I think there's a personal moment where you're winding down where you know for me I'm I'm actually like you know I'm a little bummed that I had to move these profits into these properties because that $430,000 I I was actually planning on putting that into my primary property and I am actually pro I know that it's anti all the advice out their investment advice.
21:35 Uh, you know, like I I get it, but like I want to get my primary mortgage down to zero dollars. That's my life goal right now. Uh, I don't care that it's not smart. I don't care that it's not prudent. The return on brain damage, if you will, is high. Like, I'm like, I just want to be able to I feel like if I can pay down my mortgage and get to zero, I can retire whenever I want because all I have to worry about are the property taxes and the insurance on that property. obviously maintenance and all that stuff, but like to me getting my my primary down to zero to me allows me to decide if I want to retire or not.
22:06 And so I think from a winding down perspective, I'm getting to this point in my portfolio where I am like, oo, I've got 100K here, 150K here, 200K here. Yeah, maybe I do start just getting rid of this and shoveling it into the old primary or something else in my personal life. >> Yeah, I think that's right. I I think it's it's less winding down your life and it's more winding down risk. >> Yeah. >> Like ris risk is the big deal. Like there's so many people don't really evaluate the risk and what that does to you in your life. And I can just I can tell you from personal experience the last seven, eight years where I have taken risk off the table. You know, if I was playing poker, I would have taken my chips and like taken them off the poker table no longer to be bet anymore by paying off debt and reducing risk. It was the best personal decision I've ever made because just the stress the stress level went way down and I'm still playing the game. Like I'm still investing. I'm still starting businesses. I'm still doing stuff. So it's not like I'm winding down everything I'm doing. But my stress level in terms of like is this thing what happens in a worst case scenario is I still have my house paid for. I paid off my principal residence. I think it was a great decision. I've paid off some of my rental properties. not all of them, but is it's just basically making your portfolio more like a super strong structure. Like it's a I think about like an income floor or a you could think about like a fortress. Like you just want to make sure the thing that you have is never going to go backwards and you're not going to lose. And that's a that's a different mentality. Like when you grow you're in playing offense, but when you protect what you already have, that's playing defense. And you have to do both. Like you can't win championships in football just playing offense. You can't outscore the other team all the time. That's really exhausting. You got to play defense, too. And I think that's really what we're talking about here is you wind down your portfolio, the risk of your portfolio, and then you can go back and start over again if you want to. But it's just it's a very different game at that point.
23:56 >> Yeah. It's really tempting, man, because I feel like I'm at the prime of my knowledge. Like there's a I know how to make money in short-term rentals. Like Funkit, my interior design company, we help people launch 15 to 20 super design focused, experiential focused Airbnbs every single month. we launched that many. I see how much our clients are making. And dude, we have clients that make 150 to 400K a year on a single property. Now, granted, that's not all profit, of course, but like we do have clients that make six figures in profit every year from a single property. And you know, in my in my mind, I'm like, well, you know, I could go raise money.
24:35 I could go do this. I could go get investors. I could go buy 10 of these and I could be making this. And like, you know, I am there in my career where the next move could be go do that. But I also enjoy my time. So, I don't know. I prefer to kind of just like keep the the nest egg small, which is so weird to say. Not the nest egg, but the portfolio just small and mighty, if you will.
25:00 >> There you go. >> There you go. >> And then, yeah, I'll just kind of like here and there probably build houses. Like I'm building a couple of houses in Joshua Tree right now. So that's kind of the move for now. But yeah, I don't know. I'm winding down the risk. I like I like the way you put that. So those are three reasons everybody. One, property is a dog slash it was a bad experiment. That's okay. Don't feel bad.
25:21 You can sell your property under that. Two, you want a 1031 or move the gains into a better property. And three, you're winding down or you're moving into your harvester phase. Today, what I want to do to cap off the episode is give you three reasons to not sell your property. So Chad actually wrote a book called The Small and Mighty Investor. There's a whole there's six reasons, I believe. We'll we'll link it down in the description down below. But let's get into the first reason why someone should never sell their property. So what you got?
25:47 >> The first reason is if you have a really good property in a good location, you're always going to get offers on that property. Like out of the blue, people are going to say, "Hey, Rob, I want to buy your property over there. Like it's it's amazing. I'll pay you this much money." And it's going to be really tempting because that money is going to be like, "Oh, what could I do with that money? I could go buy another opportunity." But if this is your best property or one of your best properties, there's no reason to sell it, like it's still your best property. And so I think that's that's one of the the the downfalls. Be careful that just because you got an offer on a property just because people want to buy it. If you you need to like what I like to do is like make a list of all my properties and rank them. And you can use whatever rankings you want. You could use cash flow, you could use maintenance, you could use return on brain damage, like which one's the best and the worst. But I actually have a list and the ones that I we talked about pruning your portfolio. I prune the properties that are the worst on my list, the bad at the bottom. And I never sell I say never like it's got to be really compelling to sell the best properties. And so knowing what your best properties are and not just selling them because somebody made you an offer. I think that's number one.
26:48 >> Yeah, I think that's good. I mean, the whole like, you know, I said like if you can get 10 years of cash flow in one fell swoop, the the caveat is that you're we're talking about like one to $2,000 a month in cash flow. like that to me, the brain damage needed to make that much is still fairly high. Whereas I have some properties that make like $5,000 a month, like 60k a year in net profit. That was like more than I made at my first starting position in in the copywriting world. Like that's a full-time salary. And I've got a few houses in my portfolio that I would consider like full-time salaries. So, in some instances, like, you know, like for the one that makes $60,000 a year, for example, it's my property in Austin, Texas. And, you know, that's one where I'm like, yeah, I mean, I probably could sell that and make a ton of equity out the gate, but at the same time, I'm like, yeah, but it's really hard to figure out how to make that much cash flow in real estate. Like, people spend their whole careers trying to do that.
27:48 And so I would say like if the cash flow is high and can actually offset your 9 to5 income like significantly I think that's worth considering for sure. Like I don't think you should get rid of it unless you just I don't know get a offer that you literally cannot refuse which happened to you somewhat recently. >> Yeah. Yeah. I've got I've got an offer that was somebody offered pretty much two and a halfx what I thought the property is worth in a very ambitious valuation. So and it is one of my best properties. So that's that's an example where it's got to be really really high.
28:18 But I've had lots of people offer me like let's just put real numbers on that. Like a lot of people offered a million dollars for this property. And I was like no, I'm not going to sell it. This because and this is a Warren Buffett idea. It's like this property has a moat around it. Like it's one of the best locations in town. It's just in demand. I never It's a very low hassle property. So that the money is one thing. is definitely part of it, but it's also thinking about the defensiveness of the property and the maintenance and like if it's if it has if it meets all your criteria or most of them. I I think that's a valuable thing and you don't want to just sell that just because >> Yeah, for sure. Um, so you should never sell your best show dog or your best couple of show dogs.
28:56 >> Yeah. >> Um, let's get into reason number two. Uh, reason number two you should not sell your property is taxes. Uh, and there's I think we both have uh interesting viewpoints here, but in the world of real estate, if you're practicing sort of like this kicking the can down the road and deferring your taxes and your 1031ing into this, uh, one thing to keep in mind is that if you've done that with like one specific property and you've deferred a lot of, you know, taxes and put it into here, uh, that you might have a massive tax bill come due if you're trying to sell that like very quickly after you've acquired it. So, for example, if you do a cost aggregation report and you get like a bonus depreciation and knock down your W2 taxes and you play that whole game, you know, you do have to pay recapture on your taxes. Uh, and so what that means is you basically have to pay back a lot of what a lot of the depreciation you took out the gate if you sell it super super soon. So, I would say if you haven't strategically planned that out, if you don't have a CPA like my buddy Matt Bontrager at True Books, if you don't have a team that's helping you map that out, if you don't know that like with absolute clarity, you should absolutely not sell. Um, you know, I was looking at a property that I wanted to sell and I took massive bonus depreciation on that. Emmailed my team.
30:13 I was like, can you help me calculate like what my gains would be on this? And they were like, your gains are going to be 400k on this. that's what you'll have to pay at tax time. And I was like, woof. I was like, all right, that kind of changes the perspective a little bit. We still listed it for sale, but I was like, I'm glad that I knew that out the gate because, you know, you don't want a surprise $400,000 tax bill. So, on my end, I think if you don't have your proper tax planning, don't don't sell until you do. What's your stance on this?
30:43 >> Yeah. Yeah. So, I have a little bit different angle, but I would say don't sell a property just because you've used up all the tax benefits. I I I have this this phrase that a lot of people say in real estate is like don't let the tax tail wag the real estate dog. And so, so we tax benefits are great. Like, so if you can do it if you can do an accelerated depreciation and save a bunch of money in the first couple years, that's awesome. But I also see people who they own this really good property for 10 years and they're like, "Oh, I've used up all the depreciation or like 20 years and they've used up all the depreciation." And so now mo most of their rent, all their rent is exposed to paying taxes. And so like it was before they were sheltering some of it. Now they're not. And they're like, "Well, I need to sell the property and get another one that I can kind of reset the clock on depreciation and do all that."
31:26 I think that could be a mistake, especially if it's one of your better properties because think about it, like people own stocks and they own bonds or they own all these like traditional investments that have zero tax benefits, but they can still be a great investment because they pay you dividends and because they grow. And so like real estate has a like it's the dog. Like the taxes are just the tail. Like this is a great tale that's helpful, but like don't let the taxes dictate whether you should like keep a property or sell it.
31:53 Like I think if it's a good property, keep it no matter what. And then, you know, yes, take it into account like if you have a huge tax bill, you should strategically think about like maybe I shouldn't sell it this year. Maybe I should wait till a year when I'm not working my day job because I'm making a lot less money, sell it while I'm on a sbatical or something, you know, then you can pay less taxes. There's some strategic things you can do. But I I just I think so many people focus on the taxes when it's like the second or third most important thing. The most important thing is does the property make money?
32:19 Is it in a good location? Is it, you know, a lowmaintenance property? Those are much more important than the taxes. >> Yeah. I mean, the four components that make real estate an awesome investment, um, or the four things you should at least consider when you're underwriting, the tax benefits, the cash flow, the appreciation, meaning how much it goes up in value, and the pay down. And so, you might be at this point where, you know, 10 years into your 30-year loan, what you're actually paying to principal is is making a difference now. And you're paying down that principal very, very quickly. And at the same time, it's going up in value. and at the same time you're getting cash flow. Those three benefits alone could outweigh the fact that maybe there aren't as many tax benefits to reap, but that's fine because you still have the other three things working in your favor.
33:03 >> Exactly. >> Yeah. Okay, let's get into the last thing here. Uh, which is kind of funny because I think it's uh I don't know, it's always topical. Like I I I can't I can't think of a time where this wasn't a rebuttal that I've had. But number three is >> bad economy. uh bad bad things happening in the government. Um yeah. Yeah, that's pretty common. >> Yeah. I mean, if if you watch any news, there's always going to be some negative stuff. And if you if you listen to real estate news, there's always going to be some negative stuff because because negative news sells. And so, as an investor, I think it's a bad reason to sell a property because you get depressed because of everything that's happening in the in the economy and in the world. You've got I think the key here I go back to Warren Buffett a lot because I think he's the goat in terms of like investing investing mentality.
33:53 He always has >> it's the Warren Buffet >> the Yeah, the French version. There you go. >> Um but he has a very long-term perspective. Like I always admired that about about Buffett. He did like the the current news cycle had zero relevance in whether he bought, kept, or sold a property. It's all about like what's the long-term trajectory? And so in real estate for me, I'm in Clemson, South Carolina. Like, it's much more important the long-term 20-year horizon of Clemson than it is what's happening in Washington DC last year or this year.
34:26 Like, it's much more important. Like, real estate is very local. And that's not to say like mortgage rates and what's happening in DC is not important at all. Like, it is important, but it's it's not it's not the the kind of thing that just because that changes all of a sudden you're going to pivot your strategy and sell or buy. Like I think people who get in and out of the market because they get emotionally high and low make bad decisions as an investor and instead focus on the like the quiet behind the scenes stuff that actually matters because that's what's going to either make or lose you money.
34:52 >> Yeah. uh you know doing the real estate thing now for a bit you know uh close to a decade and I know you've got a few on me but like you know I just the the the reason for people to not get into real estate or to not buy a house or to not sell a house like it's always the economy is bad whether it was Obama Biden Trump you know like it's always bad now granted there are definitely things uh there are definitely moments in history in in the last 10 years where things are escalated. So, I'm not going to like gloss over that. But in general, like if you want to sell your house, just sell it. Like you can list your h this is the crazy part is you can list your house and if no one buys it, there's no repercussion. So not selling your house because of bad economic stuff and happening right now. It's like, okay, well, if you don't get the price that you don't want, you don't have to sell it. And I think a lot of people like overthink this part of it.
35:47 >> There are times when you want to know what the market's doing. Like for example, I have property when I'm pruning my portfolio. Like I might choose to sell when everybody else is really excited and trying to buy properties. Like 2021, 222, 23, everybody was getting in and buying properties and prices were going up a lot. Like if you had to sell a property, like that that might be a good time to sell if you already had decided to sell it in the first place. But what I I think um there's been studies done on like stock investors who always they people buy the properties when they're going up and they sell the properties at the bottom when they should be buying.
36:18 Like so it's like your your psychology is not a good guide to whether you should buy or sell. Typically you should if there's anything you would do the opposite like when you when you're panicking that's probably when you should be buying and when things are like euphoric that's probably when you should be selling if you have to sell. So just like just think about that our human psychology is like kind of works against us sometimes and that's really what the news cycle is all about.
36:38 >> I agree man. Okay that that's it. Those are three reasons to never sell. One show best property. to taxes. Proper tax planning is very, very important here. And just remember, there are other benefits to real estate that aren't taxes. And so, just because you're not getting the full tax benefit doesn't mean that you're not getting cash flow, appreciation, and and and pay down. And then lastly, uh bad economic juju, bad economy, not a reason to not or you should never six reasons you should never sell. Is not a reason to not sell.
37:11 Yeah, >> you you shouldn't just sell because the because bad news and because of the bad news cycle. I guess that'd be another >> several several double negatives here, but I think if you listen to this point, you know what I mean. Um, all right, Chad, thank you so much. So, if you guys like this conversation and you want to listen to more of us jibber jabber about real estate, actually, we did a really good podcast not too long ago called Why Five Rentals Will Make You Richer Than 50 Rentals. And if you want to see that, then I highly recommend you click right here. Uh, it's very good. Very, very good. I think you'll learn something.
37:44 Okay, see you over there after you like and subscribe, of course. All right, bye.
Summary
- Consider selling if the property is underperforming or not meeting expectations.
- Selling can free up capital to invest in better opportunities, potentially increasing overall returns.
- Tax implications should be carefully evaluated before selling; unexpected tax bills can arise from property sales.
- Winding down a portfolio can simplify management and reduce risk, allowing for a more peaceful investment experience.
- Avoid selling your best properties just because of tempting offers; assess their long-term value.
- Economic conditions shouldn't dictate selling decisions; focus on the property's fundamentals and long-term potential.
- Emotional responses to market fluctuations can lead to poor investment decisions; maintain a long-term perspective.