transcribe

At The Money: Shopping in an Era of Surveillance Capitalism | Masters in Business

Bloomberg Podcasts · 25m · transcribed 21h ago
More from Bloomberg Podcasts Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Introduction to Surveillance Capitalism

What is surveillance capitalism and how does it affect pricing?

Surveillance capitalism involves algorithms collecting data to predict consumer behavior and willingness to pay, leading to dynamic pricing strategies that may not reflect a fair price for all consumers.

  • Surveillance capitalism alters traditional pricing models.
  • Consumers may face unpredictable price changes based on their data.
  • The concept of a fixed price for all is becoming outdated.
# 5:03

The Loyalty Penalty

What is the loyalty penalty in loyalty programs?

The loyalty penalty occurs when companies stop offering perks to loyal customers once they recognize them as consistent buyers, leading to a lack of incentives for continued loyalty.

  • Loyalty programs can backfire, resulting in reduced benefits over time.
  • Companies may exploit customer data to minimize discounts.
  • Understanding your purchasing habits can help avoid loyalty penalties.
# 10:06

Navigating Subscription Traps

How can consumers escape subscription traps?

Consumers can find themselves overwhelmed by subscriptions, but understanding their rights and leveraging legal loopholes can help them exit unwanted commitments.

  • Awareness of contractual rights is crucial for managing subscriptions.
  • Consumers can use legal avenues to cancel unwanted subscriptions.
  • Personal experiences highlight the challenges of subscription services.
# 15:09

The Right to Repair Movement

What challenges do consumers face regarding the right to repair?

Consumers often struggle with repair restrictions imposed by manufacturers, which can lead to delays and increased costs, particularly in critical situations like farming.

  • Repair restrictions can significantly impact consumer efficiency.
  • The right to repair movement is gaining traction to empower consumers.
  • Examples like the McFlurry machine illustrate broader issues in consumer rights.
# 20:12

Consumer Backlash and Corporate Accountability

How does consumer backlash influence corporate practices?

Consumer backlash can lead to immediate changes in corporate policies, as seen with companies like Delta, which reversed controversial practices in response to public outcry.

  • Consumer feedback is a powerful tool for driving corporate change.
  • Companies are increasingly responsive to public sentiment.
  • Positive examples exist of companies maintaining fair pricing practices.

Transcript

Speaker 1

0:02 Bloomberg audio studios, podcasts, radio news.

Speaker 2

0:15 Every breath you take, every move you make, every bond you break, every step you take, I'll be watching.

Speaker 3

0:29 Ever feel like your most used apps and companies are playing games with you? Price changes from airlines, delivery services, even Amazon seem to be all over the map. What, what does this mean for your wallet? To help us unpack all of this, let's bring in Lindsay Owens. She's CEO of Groundwork Collaborative. She is also the author of a new book, Gouged the End of a Fair Price and what that means for your wallet. So let's start out with some of the basics of surveillance capitalism and surveillance pricing that you describe in the book.

Speaker 3

1:10 Essentially, algorithms collecting all this data to try and guess what your willingness to pay might be. Are we basically in a place where a price on the shelf for everybody, is that just a historical relic?

Speaker 4

1:28 Look, we've had price tags for almost 150 years now in this country. You know, for thousands of years, we haggled. You went to the market, you picked out what you wanted, and then a negotiation commenced. But in the late 1800s, the Quakers felt like that wasn't quite right. They thought haggling was unfair, all men should be treated equal. And they dispensed with the kind of greedy way that the Puritans were haggling, and they decided to use a fixed price.

Speaker 4

1:57 And shortly after that, it was John Wanamaker, the iconic Philadelphia retailer. In his Wan Maker's department store, he put the price tag on items for the first time. And we've been living under that kind of cultural and economic regime for nearly 150 years. But these days, I think the, the transparency and the predictability that a price tag provided is really under attack and at risk of extinction. Prices are changing. Prices are more volatile thanks to electronic shelf labels and algorithmic pricing.

Speaker 4

2:32 Prices are more deceptive. Sometimes you and I are charged different amounts for the same item thanks to personalized pricing or surveillance pricing. So it really is a new frontier of pricing and I would argue a new frontier of corporate profiteering.

Speaker 3

2:46 Huh? Really, really interesting. So. So let's talk about some of the things that consumers can do, especially when it comes to online shopping or app shopping. What can we do to enhance our own digital privacy? How can we prevent stores from cranking up prices on us because of either where we live or our shopping history or any other information they know about us from online?

Speaker 4

3:18 Yeah, so the first thing I'll say is, you know, I really don't believe that it should be all of Our jobs to duck and dodge and bob and weave and figure out how to beat the machine. I think we need fair and honest markets and fair and honest prices. And I think it's the job of lawmakers to ensure that. But I also used to be a Hill staffer, so I know waiting around for Congress is not always your best, your best bet.

Speaker 4

3:45 So, so there are some things you can do. the first thing I like to say is they learn how much they can overcharge you by running experiments on you. Turn the experiment back around on them. You know, if you're going to buy your Christmas airplane tickets this year to go home and see mom, sit down with your husband or your spouse and, you know, both of you fire up your, you know, computers at the same time and see if one of you gets a better deal on the, on the tickets.

Speaker 4

4:15 There's a good chance the ticket prices will be different for each of you. Go with whoever gets the cheapest price. If you're leaving a football game this weekend with a few friends and you're gonna take an Uber home because you've had a couple beers, everyone fire up the Uber app at the same time and probably one of you will get charged a lower price for the same ride to the same destination. Go with whoever gets the lower price.

Speaker 4

4:42 There is, I think, a simplicity and turning their experiments back around on them.

Speaker 3

4:48 A lot of us use loyalty programs. How do companies use the data for these programs where we think we're getting a deal? How is that used against us?

Speaker 4

4:59 Yeah, this is one of the saddest parts of the book, which is the revelation that you might be at risk of a loyalty penalty for using loyalty programs. Right. You get really excited when you join a loyalty program in the beginning because you get promised all these perks and freebies and these inducements that get you to kind of hand over your and shop attached to your loyalty card. But what we have started to see is the problem of the loyalty penalty.

Speaker 4

5:28 Once the company knows what you purchase on a regular basis, they figure they that you're a sure thing and they no longer need to push you any of those offers or discounts. And there's an example in the book from a Washington Post reporter who lived in a state that allowed him to request his data from Starbucks. And he got the 55 page report and he learned that over time, as Starbucks knew he was a sure thing, he didn't get any perks or freebies or discounts anymore.

Speaker 4

5:58 There was also a reporter recently from Wired magazine who requested his McDonald's app data, by the way, his, that was like a 500 page dossier. I, I got to talk to him and I was like, I'm so excited to meet the Hamburglar. Like you are, you are really a serious customer. But one of the interesting things in his reporting was that McDonald's had calculated this lifetime attrition score. Like how likely is he to like, you know, leave McDonald's and go shop somewhere else like Burger King?

Speaker 4

6:31 And his attrition score was zero. They were like, he is absolutely hooked on McDonald's. But these companies do use the data that they collect about you in loyalty programs and they are pretty sophisticated data harvesting operations in pricing and promotion decisions. And you can end up being penalized once they've got a full sense of your likely purchase history. The other thing they do, of course, which you, you may or may not care about, is they often bundle up your data and sell it.

Speaker 4

7:03 Increasingly companies like Kroger, you know, where 95% of transactions are attached to loyalty programs, they have an alternative profits book of business that is 30% of their net operating income. And a big piece of that is the sale of your data. So loyalty programs are a bit of a double edged sword, I'd say.

Speaker 3

7:25 Huh. Really, really interesting. Tell us about dark patterns and drip pricing. Are companies really doing last minute fees taxed on when you're, when you're about to engage in a transaction?

Speaker 4

7:44 Yes. So drip pricing is the worst. It's this practice of sort of luring you in with a teaser rate or a low initial price only to tack on throughout the remainder of the transaction, drip, drip, drip, other fees such that the total price you pay at the end is much higher than the teaser rate. This is also in some settings called unbundling. So something that you've certainly experienced in the airlines where you know, the fair no longer includes things like your luggage or picking a seat.

Speaker 4

8:18 Right. You have to pay extra for that. So you know, drip pricing and junk fees are really tough and they're, they're made much easier to use to exploit you in E commerce because of things like dark patterns. The ways in which companies can manipulate user interfaces and make design choices that, that make it hard for you to see, you know, that these fees have been tacked on throughout the transaction. We do, thanks to the Federal Trade Commission rulemaking that happened at the end of the Biden administration, now prohibit drip pricing in two sectors of the economy.

Speaker 4

8:57 So instead you have to see the full and total price up front. The first sector is short term lodging. So if You've picked up an Airbnb or a VRBO recently, you probably noticed that you can now see the full price of a week stay inclusive of things like cleaning fees and stuff like that that used to be tacked on at the end. And we also now require upfront pricing or all in pricing in event ticketing. So you can see, you know, when you hover over a seat to, you know, pick a concert seat, you now see the full price of the ticket, not just the price of the seat.

Speaker 4

9:34 So it includes the price of the fees. And, you know, it doesn't make the price any cheaper, but it does allow you to do a better job of comparison shopping and it makes it such that you at least know the full price that you're paying up front before you start the transaction.

Speaker 3

9:50 What about subscription traps and roach motels? I have a handful of subscriptions and every now and then I try and cancel them and I get nowhere. Fortunately, I have a good relationship with my bank. We use the same corporate and personal bank. And when I say, hey, this is a fraud, they won't let me cancel, stop paying this. They've been pretty good about that. But I don't think everybody has the same access to their private banker.

Speaker 3

10:21 What can you do about subscription traps and, and getting out of the roach motels?

Speaker 4

10:26 Yeah, this is a tough one. A couple times in my life I've really been buried under subscriptions. Once when I was in high school and I got pretty in deep with the Columbia House Records subscription program.

Speaker 3

10:38 Everybody, right? Oh

Speaker 4

10:40 man, it was just like, you know,

Speaker 3

10:41 if you were in high school, you were a minor, you didn't have contractual ability and you could just send them a nasty letter. And that's the last year that's what I did. That's in law school, I dealt with my Columbia Record House debt. I'm like, sorry, didn't have contractual capacity as a 14 year old. Bye bye. So it eventually, but, you know, most times you don't get that. And they were actually pretty good about canceling. You just had to remember to send the card in on time and nobody did.

Speaker 4

11:12 Yeah, the tough thing about the Columbia House was the negative option billing. So like, you know, you picked out like two discs at full price and then you got like 12 discs for like a penny. But then they would send you some desks that you didn't select and, and if you forgot to send them back, you had to pay full price for those too. So you could really end up kind of snowed under a pile of CDs the other time in my life where I really got into trouble on subscriptions was right after I had my baby.

Speaker 4

11:40 And, you know, you're, you're not sleeping, you've got a lot going on. And I ended up in a subscription for like a developmentally appropriate toy service. And actually it was a gift from a friend. She gave me like, you know, three toy boxes. And at some point, like a year in to my son's life, I was like, why am I still getting these toy boxes? And I realized my friend had gifted me three months, but they had started charging me for them.

Speaker 4

12:08 Right. So I think even

Speaker 3

12:10 though you never signed anything, you never do anything. No.

Speaker 4

12:13 Oh, that's, that's an easy

Speaker 3

12:15 letter CC to the state attorney general and that's the end of that. But still, I mean, good luck. What, what about the fact that these companies no longer have customer service branches? If you want to cancel satellite or cable, if you want to change something on your phone, it's an hour of your life. It's pretty horrendous.

Speaker 4

12:38 Yes. My organization has released model legislation that we call the Shoppers Bill of Rights. And it includes 12 rights that we think shoppers should be guaranteed in the e commerce and agentic commerce era. And two of them include the right to a refund on the same payment method that you initially purchased it on without battling a chatbot for three hours and the right to cancellation the same way you signed up.

Speaker 4

13:10 If they auto populated your address and your credit card information on the way in with one click, you can get out of that subscription with one click. And New York City actually just about a week ago, implemented a click to cancel rule in the city. So companies operating in New York City have to give folks the same type of cancellation for subscriptions that they give for the same method of cancellation that they get for signing up for a subscription.

Speaker 3

13:42 Let's talk about something that's kind of fascinating to me is the right to repair. So what started happening with everything from computers and printers to farm equipment? The company said, you can't fix this, you have to bring it back to us and we're going to charge you an arm and a leg to do basic repairs or even things like buying cheaper toner for your, your printer. What about the right to repair and the right to shop for the components of that product?

Speaker 4

14:15 Yeah, I think a lot of people are surprised to see this included in my book because they don't always think of that kind of thing when they think of price gouging. But I absolutely think restraint of repair is a form of price gouging and arguably a real daisy chain of price gouging, because they can, you know, charge you an arm and a leg for the initial product, Then they charge you again for proprietary parts. Then they might charge you again for proprietary labor where, you know, you can't fix it yourself.

Speaker 4

14:44 And maybe if you can't fix it at all, you have to buy it again. So increasingly, companies use technology to make it hard to repair items, and car companies, you know, with engine control units that make it hard for, you know, your mechanic up the street to access what they need to fix your car. John Deere, the tractor company, a real kind of corporate villain. And the right to repair space made it impossible for farmers to repair their combines, which, you know, makes it hard.

Speaker 4

15:17 If it's harvest season, you got to wait for their dealer to come out and their repair shop to come out and fix it. There is an example in the book of the McDonald's McFlurry. If you've ever wondered why you can always get french fries but somehow the ice cream machine is always broken, well, it's because Taylor Commercial food Services, who owns the McFlurry machines, doesn't let McDonald's franchisees repair them themselves. So, you know, lots of these types of examples in the book.

Speaker 4

15:47 And, you know, thankfully, there is, I think, a really burgeoning consumer movement around what we call the right to repair your own stu run by a guy named Nathan Proctor at the United States Perg, the public interest research Group. And they've had some big wins, including some memorandums of understanding with. With John Deere, and even some movement at the federal level from the Federal Trade Commission on John Deere.

Speaker 3

16:12 Yeah, my. My experience with toner and printer was one day I was about to order yet another cartridge for an HP laser printer, and I'm like, wait a second, I've paid something like 5x the cost of this printer. Let me use AI to find what's a better alternative. And I ended up with. I went from a hp, I think it was HP inkjet to a brother laser, Unless I have it backwards, but brother inkjet.

Speaker 3

16:44 Whatever it was, the cartridges are like a fraction of the cost of the unit and are likely to be around that way for a long time. But there was a thing a while ago where you could buy these just generic printer toner refills. And when HP figured that out, they would brick your printer, meaning it would just freeze and be dead. And that was it. How much control over our devices do manufacturers have?

Speaker 3

17:18 And what can we do about that.

Speaker 4

17:20 Yeah. I mean, technically, it's illegal to void your warranty if you repair your own stuff, but we see examples all the time of companies threatening to void your warranty if you make repairs. So that's one sort of form of retribution companies can impose. There are also some examples in the book of things like, you know, the Keurig coffee machine not working if you insert a non Keurig brand cup, or the K cup, you know, or the GE refrigerator no longer spitting out water if you use a non GE water filter, things like that.

Speaker 4

17:58 And, you know, there have been a lot of. There's been a lot of litigation in the space, which has been helpful in kind of, I think, pushing back against some of this corporate overreach.

Speaker 3

18:10 Really, really interesting. Let's talk about the power of public backlash. I remember not too long ago, BMW proposed making the heated seats like a monthly subscription. I called my local dealer and said, cancel my deposits. Give me my money back. Cancel that deal. Take me off your list. You lost me as a BMW customer. I'm wondering. And then there was an issue with Wendy's, with some of their pricing shenanigans.

Speaker 3

18:41 How significant is public backlash?

Speaker 4

18:46 Hugely, hugely significant. I mean, I really think one of the quickest ways that we can discipline companies who go too far with their pricing practices is to scream and yell and like and share and tweet. Right. It is absolutely the case that consumer backlash is a powerful force in convincing companies to go in a different direction. Voting with your wallet matters. And throughout history, we've seen so many examples of consumer backlash really changing corporate behavior.

Speaker 4

19:24 One of the examples I love to talk about, which I include in the book, is, you know, actually in the mid-1990s, the CEO of Coke said in an offhanded interview to a Brazilian magazine that Coke was piloting installing thermometers in their vending machines. Again, this was in the 90s to hike the price of a Coke on a hot day. And he said he thought it was reasonable people would pay more on a hot day for an icy cold Coke out of the vending machine.

Speaker 4

19:52 And it was the shot heard around the world. It was on the COVID of every major newspaper. People were ticked about this, and they immediately had to walk it back. I mean, Pepsi really seized on the PR gaff and, you know, saw their moment for an advantage, and Coke walked it back. And we saw that happen with Delta. Their partnership with Fetcher was revealed by my organization, and, you know, Southwest and American jumped on it.

Speaker 4

20:23 And I think that was a big Part of why Delta walked back some of their plans, obviously with the Instacart study my organization helped conduct. You know, consumer backlash was critical there. Two weeks later, you know, their, you know, corporate issued a letter saying they would not use these practices. So I actually do think the quickest way to immediate action by far is consumer backlash.

Speaker 3

20:49 So. So let's talk about a couple of companies that you spotlight as doing things right like maintaining a cap on markups or freezing prices. One of the most obvious examples that comes to mind is Costco, pretty much universally beloved by their, by their clients. What are they doing right?

Speaker 4

21:14 Yeah, so Costco is a little bit of a tricky example, but I use it in the book because I still think it's a good one. I mean their business model is a little different. They make a lot of their money from the subscription, the membership that you pay to shop in Costco. But they do have a threshold on how much markup they will charge above their input costs. And they cap it at, I think it's 14%.

Speaker 4

21:41 Depends. This varies a little if it's a generic product, one of their own products, or if it's a third party product, but it's a cost plus pricing model. You're not going to see dynamic pricing at Costco. You're not going to see see personalized pricing at Costco. The other example I really like is, you know, at a time when being a sports fan is getting more and more expensive and you know, we saw FIFA over the summer use dynamic pricing for World cup tickets for the first time in World cup history.

Speaker 4

22:09 I always like to talk about the Savannah Bananas, the variety show slash baseball team. You know, they have a real fan service first pricing approach. They don't use dynamic pricing, auctioning off the seats to the highest bidder. They use lottery system and if you're lucky, you get a seat at a good price. So I think, you know, those are two good examples of folks who are cutting a different path. And I think they are doing well in part because they're cutting a different path because they have a lot of consumer loyalty and a lot of consumer enthusiasm for their brands.

Speaker 3

22:48 Really, really interesting. We started out talking about AI. Let's, let's end up talking about how consumers can use AI as shopping assistance. Are we now in an arms race between consumers and retailers in terms of who can deploy technology the best in order to get the fairest or most competitive price?

Speaker 4

23:15 Yeah, we're really at an inflection point I think with agentic commerce. And there's a lot of promise. You know, we just talked about how hard shopping has become, how hard it is to comparison shop, how hard it is to know you're going to get a deal, how hard it is to get out of subscriptions. There's a lot of, there's a lot to like about being able to deploy an AI assistant like Muse to go out and take care of all this BS for you, right, to cancel your subscribers subscriptions, to do all of the exhausting hard work of figuring out what the best flight deal is and all of that.

Speaker 4

23:47 But at the same time I have real concerns that we could be, you know, giving agents access to our wallets and we could be unleashing the most sophisticated snake oil salesman the world has ever known. And there are two early studies of AI shopping assistants, really big kind of, of meta analyses, type studies and both of them have come back with pretty sobering results suggesting that more often than not the AI shopping assistant, even when asked to go get a lower price, comes back with a high one.

Speaker 4

24:21 So I, I have real concerns about the future of agentic commerce. I also think, you know, these agents don't always work just for you. And it's important for us to know when the agent is working on our behalf and when the agent agent is working on Meta's behalf or you know, with enterprise agents like Sparky at Walmart, when the agent is working on the company's behalf.

Speaker 3

24:42 Really interesting. So to wrap up, we are very much in a new world when it comes to retail shopping and consumer spending. You have to be savvy. You have to be aware of the data that you're giving to companies and how, how they may be using it against you. If you want to learn more about this, check out Lindsay Owens new book, Gouged the end of a Fair price and what that means for your wallet. I'm Barry Ritholtz, you're listening to Bloomberg's at the Money.

Summary

Lindsay Owens, CEO of Groundwork Collaborative, discusses the evolving landscape of pricing strategies in retail, emphasizing the impact of surveillance capitalism and personalized pricing on consumers. She highlights the challenges consumers face with fluctuating prices, loyalty programs, and subscription traps, while advocating for fair market practices and consumer awareness.

- Surveillance capitalism is altering traditional pricing, leading to personalized and often deceptive pricing strategies.
- Consumers may experience different prices for the same items based on algorithms that assess their willingness to pay.
- Loyalty programs can lead to a "loyalty penalty," where regular customers receive fewer discounts as companies capitalize on their predictable purchasing behavior.
- Drip pricing and dark patterns manipulate consumers by adding hidden fees during the purchasing process.
- The right to repair movement is gaining traction as companies restrict consumers' ability to fix their own products, leading to higher costs.
- Public backlash can effectively influence corporate pricing practices, as seen with companies like Coke and Delta.
- Some companies, like Costco and the Savannah Bananas, maintain fair pricing models that foster consumer loyalty.
- AI shopping assistants present both opportunities and risks, as they may not always secure the best deals for consumers.

Questions Answered

What is surveillance capitalism and how does it affect pricing?

Surveillance capitalism involves algorithms collecting data to predict consumer behavior and willingness to pay, leading to dynamic pricing strategies that may not reflect a fair price for all consumers.

What is the loyalty penalty in loyalty programs?

The loyalty penalty occurs when companies stop offering perks to loyal customers once they recognize them as consistent buyers, leading to a lack of incentives for continued loyalty.

How can consumers escape subscription traps?

Consumers can find themselves overwhelmed by subscriptions, but understanding their rights and leveraging legal loopholes can help them exit unwanted commitments.

What challenges do consumers face regarding the right to repair?

Consumers often struggle with repair restrictions imposed by manufacturers, which can lead to delays and increased costs, particularly in critical situations like farming.

How does consumer backlash influence corporate practices?

Consumer backlash can lead to immediate changes in corporate policies, as seen with companies like Delta, which reversed controversial practices in response to public outcry.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram