Transcript
0:00 my belief is that like any domain or industry the more it matters the more the design matters what happens is like whenever there's like a new paradigm I don't know it's like the mobile or the web or something the first iterations of those products existing there they don't have to be like super welld designed necessarily because they are the first but then like as as you built the 100 like thousand like different email clients any email client now has to be
0:25 like pretty good to be Beav and considered like reason like email clients it's like that the bar is so high so I think like today it's almost like a very basic thing now pretty much from the very beginning you need like pretty high level design that people to even like pay attention or consider you seriously today my guest is Ki sarin Ki was the founding designer coinbase principal designer at Airbnb co-founder of two previous startups and most
0:54 recently is the co-founder and CEO of linear which I am fairly confident is the fastest growing and most beloved issue tracking tool in the world and something that a growing number of product teams are using to build their own product Ki and his team are building their company and their product in a really unique way with a huge focus on Craft and quality no AB tests no metric space goals instead a focus on taste and opinions also no durable cross
1:21 functional teams instead teams assemble around a project and then disperse once it's done also they have just one product manager as a head of product and that's it in our conversation car shares how he built a culture around quality and craft how he makes trade-offs and how he operationalizes quality and thoughtfulness where design can be a differentiator in competing against incumbents we talk about something called the linear method of Building Product which is big on building
1:46 opinionated software working in consistent Cycles amongst other principles we also get into linear's unique hiring approach which involves a paid work trial where candidates work alongside the team for a number of days instead of just having an interview you also a glimpse into how linear got their first 10 customers found product Market fit and skilled their growth engine there is so much gold in this episode I very excited for you to hear it with that I bring you Ki sarin and after a
2:12 short word from our sponsors this episode is brought to you by Mercury who I also happen to use for my business checking account I've tried a lot of business Banks and there is nothing even close to the experience you get with Mercury I moved cash over from another bank and it literally took less than half an hour to set up the account and wire money over at no cost they kind of make you want to use the site more
2:35 often which I've never felt with another banking site Mercury is banking engineered for the startup Journey a modern solution to help your company become the best version of itself and Mercury isn't just a place to hold and send money it's software built to help you scale with safety and stability whether your team of two or team of a th000 Mercury also goes beyond banking to provide you with access to the foremost investors operators and tools visit mercury.com to join over 100,000
3:03 startups on Mercury the powerful and intuitive way for ambitious companies to bank Mercury is a financial technology company not a bank banking services provided by Choice Financial Group and evolve Bank and Trust members FDIC this episode is brought to you by composer the AI power trading platform now with retirement accounts algorithmic trading has historically been reserved for the hedge fund Elite now with composer you can automate your trading with a library of over 1,000 strategies that are easy to understand and tweak
3:35 using an AI assistant and visual editor composer is the first ever algorithmic trading platform where you don't need any coding experience it includes a full range of trading indicators for you to get creative and a Discord community of 2500 traders to discuss your ideas with composer also has a powerful back tester to see the historical performance of your strategies and you can then invest with a single click once you invest composer will automatically trade for you based on the logic of your strategy
4:03 with $1 billion in trading volume and over 1 million trades executed composer already has many big-time investors using the platform regularly head to composer. trade and use the code Lenny for an extra week of free trial on your composer membership that's composer. trade Cari thank you so much for being here welcome to the podcast thanks Len it's it's great to be here maybe to start to set a little context can you
4:33 just explain what ises linear what does linear do and then share maybe a few stats of just the scale of linear at this point so linear is the project and issue tracking system that software companies and Technical teams love to use we help like software companies to to build software we started 2019 um today some of the top growth companies like block versel ramp retool uh Mercury and substack are are building with lineer we also additionally have lots of
5:07 other companies like thousands of other companies using using linear these companies can be like very early stage team like some some companies just graduated from YC or or or a public company and just like briefly why we created linear is is that like like you said like we I work with you at the rpmp and and before that I I work at coinbase and I before that I had my own startup and all of us Founders there's three of
5:31 us we had like a similar bath where we worked in multiple different companies in different stages and what we saw often is that like the the tools available for managing software projects wen't that like really cutting it I think like lot of them felt very clunky or complex or or just like they had this kind of Legacy way of thinking about software development and so we just felt like we should do something about it and that's so with linear we we set out to
6:02 do like build this like most frictionless and streamlined um system for for modern software development I'm also happy to share that we we've been profitable the last two years um and we also have this thing where we actually have this net negative lifetime burn rate um which means that like we just have more cash in the bank today than we have raised I think a lot of startups like usually the normal way is is that like you you spend
6:30 you raise money and then you you need to spend it to to build it but I think we since we were able to build a business pretty early on we've been able to be in this position that actually we haven't spent any money on on building the business that is insane I didn't even know that okay so for all those reasons a lot of Founders and a lot of product leaders look up to the way lanyard
6:51 builds product and the way you think about product and so to kind of frame this conversation there's three areas I want to dive into one is just how you approach build Building Product two is how you go about building the team and the business in general and then three is just how you grow linear and to start I want to talk about craft clearly one of the biggest reasons that people look up to linear and use linear is the
7:15 quality of the user experience and the product and I know your team puts a lot of emphasis on Craft and user experience I imagine that also comes at the cost of some trade-offs like takes probably longer to get stuff out the dir you're probably losing sales because people are waiting for a feature and you're not ready ready to launch it yet because you want to make it better what have you learned about creating space for craft
7:37 and building product that is really really great yeah and I think it's interesting that those things you mention like hiring building business and Building Product and craft is like I think that all of those are are somewhat related to to each other but so what what I can say about the product craft per se is like it's it's definitely like starts with the people that like on the on the hiring front wheel always look for people that care about it as a
8:01 business like why we really care about it is is that like we see that collaboration only happens if people use the product and and like our product which is supposed to help the collaboration coordination if there's friction or the The Experience isn't that great or there's this little paper cuts I think it's gets really annoying for people to use and so we think like for the business to be successful the quality is is and The graft is very
8:25 important there is definitely like tradeoffs sometimes like there can be like for example timelines like we we are about to launch something and then for example I or someone else goes to look at it and and sees like oh this this doesn't like feel right and we just like should fix it so I don't think we should launch this now so sometimes like it it doesn't definitely push the timelines but this this might be like days it's not like we need to like redo
8:50 everything the other way we think about it it's like we are actually very okay like pushing things out to ourselves and into for like a small small group of customers like if if they opt into that so whenever we build a new feature one of the things is like we don't want to spend tons of time up front just like designing it and polishing it perfectly because we actually believe that when when you start building the thing you
9:16 actually start realizing more like how it could how it should work and how it should be better so a lot of times with the teams we tell them like just just put it there in like I don't know the first week almost like after you have some kind of designs in place or some kind of design ideas just like put it into the app and like ship it to production but only visible to us so we
9:37 internally can test it out and then I think the next stage is like we look for like a customer that could be interested in this feature or or we just like ask people to opt in to like some kind of better program and in those stages The Experience can be a little like janky or it's not that like polished but we're okay with it because we are saying it's not finished like we just want to get
9:59 your feedback early so we can make it better but like once we get to the kind of like the full General release then we like pay more attention to the actual like polish or the or the craft that is so interesting I didn't know you do that so you actually go ahead and launch things really early to select group of people that want the early stuff and then did you say that you find One customer to kind of co-create and help
10:23 evolve the feature and change with yeah usually it's it can be one or it's like three or five or 10 so it's it's often especially with the larger company like larger company facing features we usually do try to find a large company because sometimes it's hard to like imagine these things how they should work and so it's better if if someone is willing to work with us to like explain okay this is how we we do something and
10:49 something like for example we we work this way with versel that there was some some changes they wanted to see in the in the road map feature so we worked with them to to like improve it and and then they could like give us feedback along the way that is so interesting because I think people seeing linear from the outside it feels like you just take the time it need you need to build something awesome and then it launches
11:10 and it's amazing and it's great but turns out that isn't exactly how you build it's you actually do launch things really early and people don't necessarily see it until it's done but there's this whole process behind the scenes yeah I think like sometimes people can't believe like think that craft is is about perfecting things and like perfecting them in a in a very like organized way or like very early on the downside with this like Perfection
11:33 mindset is that it can be sometimes hard to like put anything out because nothing is ever like fully perfect and so we try to like balance this thinking with the fact that we should be always pushing things out very quickly but then like also fixing them like improving them very quickly so it it's almost like the opposite ideas um but then we we try to like kind of combine that and and I think it's been it's been working well
12:00 that and generally in the company there's not necessar like a lot of reviews or something that we we always like review everything that like gets shipped this way um because we do want people to like feel that they can like put something in the app and then we can try it out so it's more like let's just like try it out and then but then like yeah we do need to look at it again when before we release it to everyone a lot
12:25 of Founders a lot of product leaders a lot of designers uh definitely want to create space for craft and making products really great something they're really proud of but in practice it's really hard very few teams and companies do this is there anything else you've learned about creating space for this sort of thing and prioritizing it for Founders that are listening that are trying to instill more and more of this or do you have to be a designer Co like
12:50 Ki and there's really it's hard to do otherwise yeah I I I don't think actually it's it's it's not like purely coming from me so I think the all the all us founders like Jory and Thomas in additionally their background is engineering but I would say like they actually have almost like I think they they spend even more time on the details than than sometimes I do like um I think like very early on when it was three of
13:13 us I would be the one like kind of doing the broad Strokes designs like this is how the UI works and this is how the some of the things work and that they were the ones that like oh there should be animation here and there should be like this kind of thing here so I think it's it's kind of like that DNA I think from comes from all of us and I think like with with the craft it's always
13:32 starts with like people need to care about it like if it's not valued in the company then it's very hard to do for anyone to do because no people don't feel like it's it's valued and I I had I gave this advice to some founder he was asking me about it and like in their case like their Founders were coming from different companies like maybe this one founder came from ARB and then the other ones came from my Facebook and and
13:58 Amazon and I think like this like for example I think Facebook and Amazon have very different culture on quality or craft or or shipping and I think like I what I said to them like you just like you need to align on it like it's it's like you cannot run a company with multiple different kinds of cultures I think I I made some points like why the quality is important for certain kind of products and like you should all kind of believe
14:21 in that and then like instill that with everyone you hire the other thing I would say that what we like to do is we actually don't have much BMS in the company we only have one and like we can talk about more about it but the the one of the things I think that happens is like when when you build a team and you start creating this very specific roles for everything um where like I think
14:47 that often the BM can be the one that like figuring things out and like making decisions and guiding the team but they're not the ones like building the feature so they're not there like looking at it like the whole day it's like how how is this where does this button go or how does it work and I think like a lot of that like this graph for us happens when we give the project team this like ownership and the project
15:09 team is just engineering and design and then when they start building that feature they start seeing this opportunities that this thing could be better like a good example of this is like we one of our Engineers Andreas like when we were building this rightclick menu in the app like so you can right click different things and under that you have sub menus like Mac OS does this well where it's like when you when you open that menu you hover on
15:35 the menu and then you want to go to the subt menu so you hover to the right you don't have to go like exactly like horizontally to get into that menu you can actually go kind of like diagonally or like you don't actually have to hit the menu exactly there's like this kind of safe Zone but like a lot of software like just implements like hey let's do this menu let's make the sub menu it only works if you exactly hover over the
15:59 menu and and then like what happens is the user often like misses like with few pixels what they were trying to like do so what Andress it like which we didn't tell him to do is like yeah this kind of sucks and like we should make this better and so he figured out the way to like create those like safe areas that are Dynamic based on like like the submenu positioning and everything so it's much easier now like you can go
16:22 diagonally to the actual thing you want to go to so I think like these kind of things like happen when you give people like more of the ownership of the project and also like the space to do that and and then you also have like leadership or or generally the company culture that that values the quality or the craft all right well I got to follow this thread there's a couple questions I want ask so you have one product manager
16:47 would you call him the head of product yeah non you who who is the yeah he is the head of product awesome so what made you decide to hire him and even have any PMS we we started to see that okay we we have enough features and and and like like areas of the product and also like the team is speaker that it's hard to keep kind of like aligned on all of these things or like even keep track of
17:11 things and like initially we actually hard n as a contractor to help us with this like insights data tool so we have this like data to Tool feature built in linear so you can get like data on what's happening in the workspace and for us like Founders we realize like none of us like we are not super experienced in in data tools so we need someone to help out and luckily nonan was like we KN knew him and like he
17:36 actually worked at mode which is a data tool and so we initially hired him like can you help us figure out like what exactly should this data du tool and how should it work because I think there's different ways of doing that and I think always the easiest way is like let's just copy what some other companies's doing but we didn't want to do that so we wanted to like figure out like what is actually like useful way to to to use
17:59 this data or like get this data so he helped us with that and then we kind of saw like yeah this could be like useful in other larger areas or overall with the whole product is like we might have this kind of questions like what should we exactly be thinking around here and like why and like how would we like Define this direction and then like help the teams to also like align on it so like it to us it's more like he's kind
18:22 of like the figures out the direction of the product and and and like steer the some of the efforts and not like he's there in every meeting and like making every decision or writing every spec or or something like that another question along this line because there's a lot of PMS listening and they're going to be like oh these guys don't need PMS or PM is over product management de and so just another question along these
18:46 lines somebody needs to do the work that a PM does basically right there's all these things that is on the plate of a product manager when they're at a company and if they're not there other people have to do those things and what I'm hearing is basically you give those responsibilities to the engineer designer and maybe other functions within the team is that right yeah so I mean definitely I think what it means is and there's definitely like trade-offs
19:10 so like I think sometimes when companies specialize RS a lot it's like because of it's more efficient like if the engineer just spends 100% of their time like coding something then it's like they're using their skill set to the max but then we just think that in in order to like build quality things or build things in a certain way it's actually better if people actually also spend some time thinking about things and not just like executing so yes like for
19:35 every project there's a Project Lead that lead can be engineer or designer it's not like a formal role or it's not based on a like uh like your whatever level or or it's just like you need to be certain title that you you can be that it's more like a assignment that like okay now you are responsible at getting the project started and working with to together with the team like figuring it out and then like
20:01 communicating when changes uh or like communicating how the progress happens and and so it's definitely like it it means that the the engineers and or designers also have to like do this things and like they do need to like communicate and they do need to think about like the scope or or things it's a different way of doing things and and um also not everyone wants to do that which is fine but we when in the hiring FR try
20:26 to hire people that are kind of interested in a broader scope than just like the that the like specific skill set that they have yeah I think those last two points are really essential is one people often don't want to do this work and they kind of are happy to offload it to a potential product manager so the fact that say Engineers have to do all these boring PM things like communicate timelines and keep PR specs aligned and make sure timelines
20:53 are HID and all that stuff and run meetings a lot of people don't want to do that a lot of times they do and I think in this case people seem to really want to be doing that the other is I think you need a really high caliber team that's very product minded and the hiring bar needs to be very very high for the engineers and designers to want to do all these things and be good at
21:11 them and so I think I think those are two necessary ingredients for this to work out yeah sure for teams that want to try this sort of approach especially startups that are kind of starting out and maybe not excited about hiring product managers is there anything else that you think is essential or important to functioning well without any product managers and you're at around 50 people at this point yeah we are around 50 and probably the only thing I say it's it's
21:35 like the hiring front that like you you really need to spend more time on it and like basically you cannot really interview Engineers only for the engineering skills you also have to interview them for like the product skills and it's like it's obvious like you cannot I think expect that people have some like if you do some kind of BM interview for them it's it's not they're not going to have the same kind of skill set or the same understanding of the
21:57 cont Concepts or something but like the way we've done it in the past is like basically I might interview them about the product I'm not a technical person per se so I will just like ask them questions about like how did they do something or like how do they think about something and it's similar to other roles too it's like we we just look for like do this person have like opinions about about products and how
22:19 they they work and and like can they form opinions and and can they kind of use their own judgment in at times and then um like can they communicate article at those things as well awesome I was just thinking it's interesting that a tool that I don't think it's designed specifically for product managers but essentially for building products like the infrastructure for Building Product in a team is built by a company that is one pm and very few PMS
22:43 yeah I mean I I think like in some way I would say that like with with linear we're trying to help the whole company and like I think Engineers is probably like the largest user user group of the of the product and like I think in some ways we want to make the the bm's job easier or like that like they they have to spend less time like managing everything or like very like the daytoday because like the the engineers
23:05 actually using the product and they're like updating the things it's like for the BMS it would be much more easier to like get this like what is the state of things and and like maybe trust that much more because people actually use the product so in some ways like I think we we're trying to like kind of like make it easier for everyone easier for the engineers like they they can focus more on their work and then for BMS I
23:26 think like we're trying to make so that that they can also focus on more on other things than it's just like I don't know managing the tool that they use like I think that's not the most important job of a PM I think they should be like thinking more of the I don't know bigger picture or like other problems or like figure out like the next like features or or something just one more question along these lines
23:49 there's other companies like stripe I think waited till 200 employees to hire I think their first product manager Snapchat I think is famous for something around that do you have any sense of if you think this might change when you think you might hire more product managers there kind of plan here is it just kind of see how it goes as you grow I think we will definitely hire more um it's like I think like what I said
24:09 before is like I think we like to see him the BM smarts like operating on a higher level like the whole company like I think the way we trying to build it is like we have less people but people who are more High Caliber and can think about exter like larger scope than what their current rol is so I think like it's we're just like trying to build this like a smaller units but more effective units which I think like where
24:36 the BMS go and that that they they there would be also less of them like and they're not there at every level but I think in the future as the company grows and the team grows and the product grows we might have like several BMS that are focusing on or looking at specific areas or specific types of things of the product or specific customers or or something like that awesome okay that was to engine because I couldn't not go
25:00 in that direction but I want to come back to design again and craft so it feels like linear one of the reasons you guys have been successful is design and experience is basically a huge differentiator from other products and there's always this question of can design be enough of a differentiator in specific markets is there always an opportunity to build like a significantly better product experience and have a real shot at disrupting an incumbent do you have any sense of when
25:28 design can be enough of a differentiator and this is coming from like a Founder Trend decide should we go big on design and experience or should we invest in like distribution or new technology or something along those lines any thoughts there my belief is that like any domain or industry the more it matters the more the design matters and I think like it's kind of like it's fairly easy to see in different like if even in software or in
25:53 other Industries it's like what happens is like whenever there's like a new paradigm I don't know like the mobile or the web or something the first iterations of those products existing there they don't have to be like super well designed necessarily because they are the first but then like as as you built the hundreds like thousand like different email clients any email client now has to be like pretty good to be Beav and considered like reason like an
26:20 email client it's like that the bar is so high so I think like today the startups like I don't know if you look at like the web page Google launched with or like the web page YouTube launched with or some of these like older companies it's it they were very basic like if you launch that kind of website today it's no one would really pay attention so I think like the design is always like it's almost like
26:45 a very basic thing now that like you from pretty much from the very beginning you need like pretty high level design that people to even like pay attention or consider you seriously and I think it's like it's not the Fair because like sometimes it's like maybe the product is really good but they didn't have a designer or they didn't have like time to do it and then people just kind of like dismiss it because it doesn't
27:07 doesn't seem like something that it interest them so I think like that that's the first thing is like I think it's it is and it's going to be more and more important um but I would also say like design is never going to be like uh the reason or like the the the reason why a company is successful it's like it's like the company still has to have some other things like that the product still needs to be something it needs to
27:33 be better in some ways or it needs to be different in some ways and then like a design is just like enabling some of these things like en enable similar to technology is like if you have good technology it's like easier to do certain things and like it the product works better in some ways than you having like a bad technology or bad bad like infrastructure so similar to design I think like if you if you have a good
27:56 design and like people are or even like a good brand like people are like drawn into it and then it's like makes like some like user acquisition or user retention or just like even people perception of the product better I think like an example is like packaging in products is like apple or lot of companies spend a lot of time like effort into the packaging because it's kind of like already sets the expectations for the user who is
28:23 receiving the product is like even before you use the product you like start thinking that this is a high quality product and like I'm going to love it and then like when you actually have it then you actually like might feel that way unless the product is really bad and then like you wouldn't feel that way so I think similarly if with startups or like SAS it's like your landing page or some of the other things is like they are
28:47 already like communicating something to the user and they they setting setting the expectations and then I think that that can be like very useful thing especially early on when no one really knows you or or knows the product or cares about you so I think like especially I feel like design can be very good leverage in the in the beginning I think that's such an interesting Insight especially that that first thing you said around how the more
29:13 often and the more crowded the space is the more opportunity there is for design to be a differentiator is that roughly how you think about it yeah so I mean like just think about like I don't know any any product category it's like basically people people have then like a lot of choices and then they like how do they make choices like maybe there's a specific thing they want but like a lot of people don't necess know what what is
29:35 the specific feature I want from this software so it's more like well what is the best one like what is the highest quality one and if you put things side by side and you just people see things people are visual so like then like the design can be one of those things is like stands out it's like well that looks the best or that looks the most like quality product to me so I'm going to use that one
29:57 like when people have a lot of choices they probably will pick the one that like looks most most interesting and then I think there is the second part is the brand which is something that you if you can build a brand then I think it's like it doesn't really even the product Almost Doesn't Matter like it's it's it becomes this kind of default like I don't know like again like apple or Nike it's like yeah there's all kinds of shoes you can buy
30:24 but there's a reason for someone to buy Nike shoes other than some some random brand even if the random brand would be actually a better shoe they still buy Nike because they like I don't know like the brand so then I think like both the design of the product but also the design of the brand can be like like very strong like kind of things that like pull people to your company or to the product is there anything you've
30:48 learned about just building a brand over the course of building linear something you find to be really important in actually building that perception that linear is really great and amazing to me I think like the brand should be always like authentic and and like it should kind of like I think even people if people can't articulate it um it it people start to feel like something is off like like I think there can to be like companies or startups they like
31:14 think about brand is like oh brand is the logo or the colors of the website or something and then they like do the same thing and some some other company does and then they like think like okay now we have a brand but like you actually didn't like think about like what's your brand like what is the message or voice you you want to talk about and it it doesn't have also like the brand doesn't happen overnight so it's basically just
31:35 you start in the beginning like and and like when you start a company you don't have no brand and so you have to create it so and you you create it over time by the the things you do the things you say like how you say them and like what what kind of how do you approach things how do you treat customers how do you build the website or the product like all of these things start to like build this
31:57 like idea like what does this company mean to me in people's heads um I know like we both worked at thpb and like I think branesky is like I think the brand was probably the most important thing for him and I don't know how many hours or meetings or conversations there was about the brand and it's like the brand was always like it's like part of everything the company does because it's true it's like yeah you can you could
32:21 book things like places to stay in a lot of places on the web but when people think about like oh I want to like stay in some cool place they're going to think about Airbnb it's like they're not going to like think about those other places so that's like the power of the of the brand like people stop thinking about the other things or or they start understanding like okay this is the thing for this that's part of the reason
32:44 airbnb's been able to build a direct destination where people aren't like Googling I want to stay in a home they're like airbnb.com which gives their BB such a massive Advantage not having to run ads on you know Facebook and Google or SEO it's just like people know Airbnb and they just go straight there there's very few sites where people go I'm going to go straight there and look for some knowing that they can also compare hotels on all these other
33:07 sites coming back to design briefly just like very practically how do you guys do design reviews just like how do you actually go about reviewing What's going at and then to this may be too big a question but just whatever you can share is just like what do how do you know when it's done how do you know when it's ready and approved Ki sealed checkbox ready to go we doing like exploring different ways of doing this I think like today I like I I
33:32 still run the design team so I do see some of the designs like on on a weekly basis and and then like I or one of the other co-founders or one of the or the head of product we are basically the the sponsors for the projects so then like we we are kind of like responsible like check like reviewing the reviewing the work and so we might just have a meeting where we go through okay let just let's
33:57 go through the demo and like people can explain what what's going on and like how they think about it and why and then we might have like feedback okay this seems like strange or or or something and then I might just after that I might just like go into the product myself and like try it out and then what happens sometimes like it's like in the initial stages like obviously we're not going to like start fixing everything it's just more like
34:23 let's try to get the like the main concept there and like figure out how it works but then like before we are launching it I might just go in and like try it out and like try the different states and click it click it around and and sometimes I find things like like we we were building this threading to comments and um and then like when it looked all good in in the demos and stuff and then
34:46 then I went to try it and like try different lengths of messages and stuff and then I started see like oh sometimes the animations are kind of janky or it's just like off like they don't go the right way I don't know the screen doesn't scroll exactly right so then I I just like kind of like captured those things and like send it to the team and so we had to like kind of pull back the release a
35:08 little bit until those things were fixed that one was like it's it's very like I think like a simple concept and it's like very known concept like okay this is how threading comments works so that that was mostly about like okay what's the execution of this but then we have projects where we are like not sure exactly how this should work and like we can't really like like we can try it ourselves we also have to see how how
35:32 companies use it so something like we we built this feature project updates and it's like a common thing companies do is like you you need to write an update on your project is it yellow green red and like companies have very different ways of doing this in different tools and we just thought like well I think it would be like really really nice if it's like in inside linear and you can the team when they work on a project they can
35:54 write the update linear can also Al capture some of the stats like what actually happened I think with that feature it's like it's been working well but then also now we been like exploring like it's like after using it a while we think like oh actually there could be like more robust way of following these updates maybe people could maybe the leadership could just like get this updates over email or like maybe it's when you have a lot of updates you
36:17 should have a search or like a filtering system or something so I think a lot of times we just think like okay this is like the scope of it for now and we're okay like launching this and the execution is good but we know that like this is not the like fully figured out version and we just need to see people trying it out and like see the see the feedback so it sounds like on the
36:37 decision of whether it goes out or not it's kind of this intuitive feeling from your actual experience trying it out feeling gut level this is ready or this needs a little work yeah I would say like a lot of things that we do is is is more like that that we don't do AP testing or we don't do specific follow like certain metrics or something we might some we do have Telemetry or like we can look at like how people use
37:01 certain things and we sometimes do that but like that's not usually the goal we have in mind it's like yeah we should move this number this much so it's more about like based on the understanding of the problem we have and based on the like what we think is right is this the right solution and is this a good enough solution to be released to to the customers one more question along this thread is how do you actually structure
37:28 these reviews it sounds like you go straight to a prototype is there like a design review phase is it all kind of informal and people just review here's what we need your feedback on yeah so that there is like projects don't necess have like specific states to them but like I would say like roughly usually we do start with design so there's like the some Explorations on the design like okay there's like different ways of we
37:50 could like approach this or sometimes there's just one way because it's like pretty clear clear but then like I what I said before is that like we do try to like get into the building phase as quickly as possible because then we can also like see is this this this direction actually like reasonable and like what what else does it C like is there some problems with causes or how does it just generally feel here so I
38:13 think like that that there isn't like specific like review stages it's more like yeah let's check like if let's check on this project like every week or every two weeks and then before release using let's also make a like a review of it and like really test it out that like is it the is it the quality we want awesome so that's a good segue to another area I want to spend some time which is the
38:38 linear method you espouse this way of Building Product you call the linear method which you publish online and willing to in the show notes and I just want to ask a few questions around this way of Building Product one is you are big on this idea of building opinionated software can you talk about just what does that mean and then maybe give an example or two of how you actually have done that a linear so first like with
39:03 the linear method what we why why did we create it in the first place is like we just believe that there is more of like this modern ways of building software and thinking about it and we wanted to like share some of our our thinking on it um and that's kind of like also it it relates to how we build linear as well like so you might like understand why we make some choices because this is like
39:24 the way we think about making this choices so we're trying to like share our thinking behind the product and it's just like here's the product and like figure it out yeah so like the Ops like I personally have like this belief that productivity software should be and especially Company software should be opiated I think that like what the productivity software is trying to do is is like make people productive and I think like what what productive means is
39:53 like you actually do something that matters for the company which is which is like I don't know build some new feature or like fix something or design something like all of those things are like eventually they provide some kind of value for the customer I think there is this like ideas or Notions in the world that like flexible software is great and like I think it can be great sometimes but like what happens is like people start spending a lot of time like
40:18 figuring things out like how how does how does this feature work like you can use it in 10 different ways and then everyone every team or everyone figures out the different way of doing it so our thinking is like we we like to provide this like good defaults or good opinions like this is how the feature works and this is how the workflow works so you as a user or as a team don't have to think
40:40 about it and you can focus on the work you do and the other thing is like my design Mantra is always like design something for someone like it's very hard to design everything for everyone because there's you you just end up with a very generalized solution tion so then what we're trying to do with the op unated solution is that like that's the best solution or the most optimized solution we think of and then like when
41:06 you use it like hopefully you agree and like you can feel that it's not optimized so being op unated it's like the I think the value it provides people is like you don't have to think too much like or spend some more time on the tool than you do on your actual work and then another core element of the linear method is called cycles and I know linear is all around this idea of creating cycles and working in Cycles
41:31 you talk about what is a cycle and how it works at linear so for example like the Cycles is is it's optional like not every team has to use it or not the whole company has to use it but it's there as as you can turn it on or off but basically I think the why we created Cycles is that I think any team that works on software or or some other products like you always have almost
41:53 like infinite list of things to do and that list gets longer every day and it can be sometimes very distracting for the individual or for the team to like decide like what like there's a new thing coming in like should we work on that or should we work on this other thing we decided in the past so the Cycles is just a way to say that like like for the next week or the next two weeks or whatever time frame we're going
42:19 to work on these things and like these are the things we we think like are the are the priority or the focus for this this time frame and then the team can kind try to focus on those things now if if something happens like I don't know we really need to jump on this other thing at least there was like some kind of initial state that like we we decided before we want to do these things and then now
42:41 something else happened and so now we have to go on this thing so so you have like a answer when someone comes to you to ask like why didn't you do this other thing before then you can say well we did decide to do that but then something happened and we had to do this other thing so so the Cycles is like it's very similar to Sprints but we like to call it Cycles because we are not really
43:01 sprinting anywhere the Cycles also run on like automated schedule so it's like you don't have to think about like which day does it start or or like uh every every time like set it up manually so it just like runs automatically and so it's it's just meant to like to help the team to focus on like let's just like focus on these few things and forget about the infinite list of other things that are are um in the back
43:27 you mentioned earlier that you don't set metrics goals and so let me dig into that a little bit is that true you don't really have number goals for features for launches and things like that and so let me let me start there and then I have a followup question yeah so we might have like a company level goal sometimes like for example like weekly active users like that's like a metric we want to want to increase or or
43:47 something but in terms of like specific features we don't have goals for those and the reason is that I think like product like us or like a system that is used by different kinds of companies and and kind of it it's like a system made of multiple different parts and it's it's not like a very it's not necess like you want to optimize any specific thing about it it's like also companies are a little bit different so like their
44:15 usage of different features can like differ because they just operate slightly differently or their team size is different or the setup of the team is different or the culture is different so there's uh I think like for example I don't know some like Instagram or some of these apps it's like yeah we need to drive engagement and that's like the the main feature like that's the main metric for every feature like we don't actually we don't have that like we we just think
44:39 that like there should be features that help companies and sometimes we can look at the metrics before we start working on it like let's see what's this state of things are but we don't necess want to set like oh we need to increase the specific metric by by X it's more more like we want to solve this problem and ideally the success way it looks like the problem like customers agree that the problem is solved or they they enjoy
45:03 the solution and it's not like that the metrics went up so just to summarize so far uh you have no metrics you have no experiments you have essentially no PMS just one product leader you spend a lot of time on design and craft and making things awesome I'm curious just what you think it takes to make a company work in that way because this is pretty different from how a lot of other Founders think and a lot of other product teams work
45:32 yeah we we like to like talk about this inite like this like a mixture of like magic and science and like like how we describ is like there's always some level of science that we do and I think like some companies are very scientific on their product management that like they like to measure everything and they they do do lot of tests and things but like we just decided like and we don't think that's necessary um or that's
45:56 that's a good for us so the science for us means that like we we do talk to users a lot and like the whole whole like the uh any project we start with we do some like level of user research and as Founders like different people on the team like we might have like weekly calls with customers or users we also encourage everyone in the team like go to the customer slack they they answer people questions like we have shared
46:22 slack Channels with customers we call anyone like I sometimes go answer the questions there I also see when they complain about something I think so I think the first part is like the whole team kind of has to be really understanding the product and the the customers and the the problems people are facing and kind of have that like empathy and as well as like the understanding like what is the state of things today and then we we talk about
46:49 that and then sometimes we we don't might pull up stats and see like oh Wonder like is there some kind of patterns we see like like okay this kind of companies are using this thing more and what what do we think about it but usually we have some kind of question we want to answer it's like I wonder what what what is going on and then we look at it versus like let's just P some metrics and then decide that we should
47:09 increase this metric and then the magic part is like what happens when you kind of build this understanding like everyone company builds it's not like everyone has the same understanding but like everyone builds more of that customer and product understanding then like we have discussion like what should we be doing or like how what decision we want to make here then everyone is much more like kind of informed of the actual reality of the the customers or the or
47:39 the product and then we think like you can much more like use your Intuition or or thinking to to do those decisions so you don't have to use data or metrics to to back those things up so that's like I think the main thing is like the whole company kind of has to like be with the customers or like like talk to them and and then like understand like where the product might work well or where it
48:03 might fall short that's what I imagined you were going to say and I love hearing that for someone that wants to create a similar culture is there tactically anything you find to understand if your employees and Engineers designers have enough of that context and really understand the problem I mean I think it's always like a different people like different people in a company will have different understanding so it's not like you can expect like everyone like will
48:29 every day like go to see everything and like uh has has this but like we we do sometimes like sessions with the with the team or we do record videos with the customers we kind of write notes and we share this with people I feel like again it's like fairly a burent like if people like if you know your customers or the product like it's it's very different way you can talk about it versus like if you don't have any idea
48:55 like I think think like if you don't have any idea you probably don't even know what to say um so I think it's like kind of apparent if people have that and it's not like every projects like we need like everyone to have this like understanding um it probably usually enough if one or two people have that understanding or have different understanding of different things so I think it's again I feel like it's like a culture thing and I think the other
49:20 thing is like you kind of have to have the you just have to kind of believe in it like I think sometimes people use data a lot or too much because they just are they're worrying or they're afraid that will I make a wrong choice and and like I'm using data to like make the choice for me but then like you might still feel like this is not the right choice but the data is selling me is the
49:43 right choice and then turns out maybe it was the right choice or not but it's it's more like again like a practice thing like you need to be I think the company and you need to be okay that like sometimes we make mistakes and like we made the wrong choice and then we just can fix it but at least we made that choice and the data didn't make that choice for us it's interesting about this is if you've heard the
50:06 episode on ramp and how ramp builds product with Jeff Charles there's such different ways of Building Product ramp is all about velocity shipping all the time metrics measuring everything and your approach is almost the opposite and I think what's interesting there is as a takeaway is just there's many ways to do it you just have to do it almost fully and you have to have really specific people I feels like the people want to work in a certain way and a lot
50:31 of it I think also is the founder has to has to be like natural to the way the founder operates and thinks about building and building a company yeah and for sure and then like if you look at like successful companies and like Amazon is very different than Apple and like how they operate and I think both them are successful um but not in the same way so I think it's again it's like a yeah it's a decision you make as a
50:53 company or as a Founder like what kind of company want to build I do think there is like some aspects of like the domain that you're in like what what does that domain and the problem space require from from the company and for us I think it's like we are in the I think we are in the retention business like it's like and the trust business kind of that ideally we have a company starting use linear very early on and then they
51:19 stay with us forever and I think the only way we can do that is like we need to continuously kind of deal with for them like good quality product and like kind of maintain that trust that we are that that that we don't like fail them or or somehow otherwise like mistreat them and I think like some businesses are much more like transactional where it's like yeah we just need to make this e-commerce sale and then once it's done
51:45 like we don't care what happens so our case it's more like we we really need to like build this relationship over time and then that's why like I think some of the choices we make are also like kind of like more about respecting the customer versus like we're just wanting to drive the revenue of the company awesome such an important point this episode is brought to you by pendo the all-in-one platform for product light companies building
52:10 breakthrough digital experiences with all the tools you need all in one simpl to usee platform pendo makes it easy to answer critical questions about how users are engaging with your product and then turn those insights into action with product Analytics lowco inapp guides user feedback and session replay customizable road maps and AI generated insights and campaigns pendo is the only solution you need to build ship and optimize a successful product L motion but don't take my word for it create
52:39 your free pendo account today and start building better experiences across every corner of your product PS want to take your product Le noow a step further check out peno's lineup of certification courses led by top plg experts and designed to help you grow and advance in your career learn more and experience the power of the pendo platform today at pendo.io Lenny that's pendo.io Lenny something you're really good at personally is focus I find that just
53:10 trying to get you on this podcast was a lot of like hey Kye hey have you thought about this yet and I know that a lot of VCS are just like reaching out to you all the time all these really fan cvcs that are just like trying to talk to you and get close to you and I just know you're really good at avoiding shiny objects and staying really focused and really heads down and I've always wanted
53:29 to just ask you what do you how do you do that do you have any tricks systems processes approaches to staying focused other than just ignore ignore the inbox mostly yeah I I don't think there's any like complicated like processes and so I think like one of the things like I I was in yay in 2012 and one of the like things the main thing they say there is like what you should be focusing on when
53:50 you build a startup is like talk to customers build the product exercise and like like if you if you're not if you find yourself doing something else than those three things it's probably like the wrong thing to do and third when you said exercise or yeah yeah and the the exercise is that like it's important for you to be healthy or just not just like burn yourself out so I think there is like uh it was like a balance like
54:15 advice to to that love it um so so I'm doing those three things and uh but I so so I think the thinking there is like I think we often as a company also talk about this and and like very early on and and I use this the same way and like I think the company can use it the same way it's like I think there's always things that you're supposed to do or like it sounds like a good idea to do
54:41 and like it could be like yeah like come to this podcast and I actually think like before it wasn't like or like I always have this questions like is this important to do now or is it important to maybe do later um so I think like for example question on this podcast it's like I didn't feel like it was important to do it earlier because we weren't at the stage or scale or something that it I think could be like as interesting or
55:04 or or something so I think like it was a better timing to do it later similarly like when we built the product where like initially we were just very like focused on like is this really important thing to do there's always like yeah like you could get like sock two like security kind of certificate but and we know that like eventually we need to get it but we don't need need it today um so we just
55:28 say no to that and like if customer asked for it so we say like we don't have it and we will have it one day but not now and see like and a lot of times people are like okay like that's fine and then like inter internal we also talk about this like you know in like RPG games you have the main quest lines and then you have the side quest lines and and we often talk about the
55:48 companies it's like avoid the side quests like like there is always like ideas people have and and it's a good thing it's like people have ideas but then might be like yeah let's make like this t-shirt so like let's make this thing and then we're like well is it does it help the customers does it help the product like this sounds like a side quest to me and like basically means like we should do it like this this
56:09 doesn't progress the main quest line which is like building this product and and like making it awesome for for this customers so similar to me it's like I I operate this way personally too that I think about like is this important for the main quest line in in building this company for me or or is this something that uh I can ignore for now or something I can do later and it makes more sense then that is such incredibly
56:36 good advice basically ask yourself how important is this to do now and is this the main quest or is this a side quest amazing okay so let's talk about hiring as with most areas you're very very very deliberate about hiring the bar is so insanely high at linear and you also hire very few people so just a few questions along these lines just one is when you're hiring people what do you look for that you think maybe other
57:05 people are not looking for enough and where do you spend a lot of time I think one of the things we all of us Founders kind of saw in this high growth companies that sometimes like the the high growth is like especially on the employee side is not that great uh it it can create a lot of kind of chaos or just messiness or or just like in my past and working in companies it's almost never it was always easier to
57:31 work with a smaller team very high quality people than with a very large team of like more average people it's like almost like it's always faster and better output when you have like more much more like smaller team so that was kind of like the thing with linear 2 is like we we just believe that you can actually build better with less people than you can with more people so that's like the basic belief we have so then
57:54 when it goes to hiring we we've been like taking very like kind of like slow steps on it that like in the almost like the first year we didn't hire anyone then like the second year we hire like a couple people and then the second year we hired more few more we never D more than doubled in a year and that's kind of like been our like guideline that like we shouldn't more than double uh and and this might be something we Chang
58:16 in the future that we actually might do less than that but like what we look in the hiring is is is like a couple things like one is also the it obviously depends on the role but basically I would say like every with every role we often talk about like the there needs to be some taste or some like this kind of understanding of the like how things are done or how how what's the like people
58:42 have more like a broader perspective than like whatever their role is so like we talk about the engineering before that like they they do need to do some of this BM type of stuff and and so what we look for in them like is that like they have some of this like skill set or product thinking or they can articulate why some some choices are better than some others or like in their past like did they disagree with some of the
59:05 company's choices or the team's choices or like so we want to have this like uh obviously they need to be good developers but also like do they have this like a product sensibility or or can do they have like a judgment around that and this goes similar to like for example like a marketing highers like we we think about like yeah we do need the marketing skill sets but then we also want to see that this person also like
59:32 like maybe it's a good Storyteller or like they have like this like kind of appreciation for for uh writing or stories or like they have a taste of what's what's like interesting and what's not so I think like with or like when we hire like operations person we also like to see that they they maybe like have understanding on HR and maybe it's not their role but they they understand it and what happens is like when you have these people that
59:59 are a little bit more than their title it's like the company is I think much more easier to manage because it's like people can like pick up things more easily or they can like work together more easily because everyone has more like a share like a more like a shared areas or or it's not like it's not you rarely get to the point like people say it's not my job it's it's more like people understand okay yeah I'm I'm kind
60:24 of in operations but today I kind of need to help on this HR thing so which is okay um and so that's kind of like what we look for people it's like they they are more than their um they can take more scope than their skill set would assume or like what what normally is expected from them so essentially you're looking for kind of these vend diagram overlappings across different functions and teammates yeah and then I
60:51 think it's the other thing is like I said before is like like we want to build much I think like a company that has less employees which means that it's it's like like like I said before we don't want that many like specialized roles or like two specific areas of ownership or something we just think that um we could build this like we could have less people and those people can take on more scope and they can own
61:18 more scope I think like traditionally I feel like in companies like how do you get more scope is that you advance in the levels of the company because there's like a lot of different teams and different levels and then to get any kind of scope you need to like rise in into this like higher levels and what we try to do is like you don't actually you don't have to have that many levels but like people can just like already when
61:41 they when they start they can start like owning more areas and I think that can be like much more like also like interesting not to everyone but like I think interesting to many people and it's kind of like how I also like always felt about as being a designer is like I don't I didn't feel like my job is purely like just looking at the designs I also thought like I I actually need to be helping this business or helping this
62:05 other area as well so I think it's just kind of also like natural to me awesome uh so one thing you did mention is you have a really unique way of interviewing which is a paid work trial can you just talk about what that is and also just while you're in that area you talked about testing for product sensibility so whatever you can how you actually do that would be awesome yeah so we we do with all of the employees we've done
62:30 like a bait work trial and depends on the role what it looks like how long it is and depends on also sometimes on the person but basically like we do fairly like standard like interview Loops where where we test like we have some like hiring manager interviews and then like skill interviews and or tests and and then the last step of the process is the work tral and basically yeah we we they basically come as like a
62:57 mini contractor to the company and we give them a very like usually fairly vague problem statements like if you're engineer like hey there's this feature that needs to be built like how would you build it and like go build it um and so basically they need to first like understand the problem then they need to to scope it down to something that they can do in the time frame that they have and then they actually like go they get
63:22 the access to a code base they can actually go and go and like build a version of it and then like at the end they can present the work they did and why we do this is that like we just seeing that like it's a very good way to see like for both of us like both for the company and the candidates to see like how we work together and like for I think for the candidate what they can
63:44 see is that like what kind of company are joining like what is it like to work here and how are the what is the my ownership or like how do I approach approaches like I think a lot of Engineers also like that they see the code base and they're like oh wow this is like really clean and like it's not like some kind of spaghetti code type of thing situation so I think like it it helps the candidates as well understand
64:08 like what what are they signing off for which I think can be like very risky sometimes with especially with startups like it's it's really hard to tell like how the startup is operating just from the interviews and you know large companies I think things are more standardized so it's like I think they're more similar and it's easier to make that choice but with startups it can be like very like different how companies operate yeah that is so unique
64:33 and I I rarely hear of a company being able to hire that way I imagine one of the reasons you can get away with that where people are like don't have a full-time job for a while while we're doing a pay trials because linear is such a enticing place to work I imagine for a lot of companies they can't really do that but I guess any thoughts on just maybe more companies can actually pull this off yeah I mean I think it's always
64:52 like if if you don't ask like you you don't know like I I think like in our case we that's just been the standard and we we try to work with the candidate like let's figure out maybe we do it on the weekend or maybe we do at some other like a vacation holiday or something so there can be ways we can like schedule it so that it it causes as little kind of problems to the the candidate as
65:15 possible and I think we only had like only a few people probably have ever declined it like it's it's not like I think everyone else has been at is after the fact they've been happy that they did it because they they felt like they had a much better sense of the company they're joining and then also like doing that workd drop they can actually join our meetings they they get access to our slack and notion and they also have
65:40 one-onone chats with the rest of the like some of the other people on the team so they already get to know people so it's it's a good way for them to like evaluate us as well and then for us is obviously we can see like what is important for us to see is like how does this person operate in this kind of environment and like how do they approach problems like how do they think and like are they able to make progress
66:02 in a very short time frame which I always think is like very important for startups like you know large companies you have maybe all time in the world to to do stuff but I think like in any kind of startup even even with us when we like take our time doing things sometimes it's still important like we can do things quickly if we if we have to super cool just to close the thread on products and ability is there
66:24 anything you could share of just how you actually help understand someone's strength and and ability there yeah I would say like we we have like some kind of very scientific or some some like special way figured out for this so I think it's a lot of it's like a it's like a discussion of of and like I often think like ask people that like we asked about their projects and I try to go deeper it's like why was this decision
66:50 made like why do you think the decision was made and like um I might ask like do you think it was the right decision and like or do you did you agree on it or um ask them like what what do you think you would have done that differently or something so I think it's more like I'm trying to see if they do do they have thoughts in this area and like what their answers is and people's answers
67:12 can be very like different levels like some people might be yeah just like I didn't like it which I don't like yeah it's an opinion but it's not based on anything it's just like you didn't like it you should be able to expand on it saying like well I don't like it because in this case like it would not work well for this kind of users or in this kind of context or for this kind of purposes
67:36 so they they have like more of this like reasoning or some kind of rational like why they think this way and they can articulate that so I think that's like kind of like what I'm we often like testing for is is like can they can they do this and how well they can do it then it's it's can be like very yeah there can be like very wide ranges of how people do it and when when you see
68:01 someone who really thinks about this stuff it's very clear to see that they they can just like talk about it forever and they can go deeper and deeper and then some people that maybe don't haven't had the experience or don't think this way they're like yeah I don't I don't really know like I just I just build it and then seem fine let's transition to the third area I wanted to spent some time on which is growth and basically I'd
68:26 love to just understand how linear grows and what you figured out around growth especially in B2B SAS so first question here is just how long did it take from starting to work on linear to launching say V1 something that number of people can use so we started like officially in 2019 some I think months before that we were already exploring and prototyping the product so it wasn't so I think we we prototype different kinds of designs
68:54 a little bit and and then we also um one of the things we really wanted to solve is like we wanted to make the application really fast and the way we figured out we do that is like we have more of this like a local based data structure where all the data lives in the client and and then it gets synced on the on the back ends like with this Delta packets and and back then we were
69:18 just exploring like different off the-shelf Solutions and and systems but there was nothing really there so so we ended up like building our own and so we we spent some time like prototyping that and then once we we've officially I think started working on the company in April 2019 and then we announced the company like roughly mid April and we had this like little website up with with the wait list and and then I think by may we could use it ourselves and
69:46 then um we we already we started inviting some friends like try it out but then I think in in June J I think we started more like inviting people from the waight list and and around June July I think we had about I don't know 100 200 users on it and and maybe like about 10 companies or something and and then we were in this private beta stage for almost a year and the way we did it was
70:13 just like we had this weit list of people on the wait list there was like few survey questions like what kind of tools you use today and and then like why do you want to use linear and then we just and what's the company size and we invited People based on like we invited more like smaller companies using the tools we we currently support it and then also like I was trying to see like who is more like interested versus I
70:37 don't know I just want to try it out type of Pur and then a year later in June we we launched it publicly and back back then maybe we already had like I don't know several hundred of companies using it um and and then we also launched the pricing and I think like almost all of them maybe one company didn't subscribe but everyone else subscribe to that pay plan okay there's a number of really interesting things
71:05 here so one is you're in private beta for a year and then a year later you launched how was long was that period between starting to like incubate and starting to build to that private beta Milestone yeah I think it's just like few few months like I think just a few months of building the V1 yeah wow okay I thought it it was a lot longer that is so interesting okay what a team you've got over there okay and
71:31 then this survey piece is really interesting I've heard a little bit about the story so essentially you launched it on Twitter you had kind of a following your Founders had a bit of a following so I think that helped build up the initial weight list but what you did there wasn't just like hey go sign up for a weight list and then you just add email addresses it's a survey asking them what tools they use like whether
71:49 it's GitHub or something else and then also the size of the company and their interest and that helped you basically prioritize who to go after and who to onboard is that right yeah um and that the reason we did it because we we know that like we didn't support everything and like what what I said before in the focus is like we we want to like also like be focused on on like let's just like build a version that can work for
72:14 some people or some companies we don't have to like try to address everyone in the world in the in the first months of the of the business and even before after that so it was very like selective process and I think we yeah we we were fortunate that like we were able to get people sign up on a wait list and I think after after a month uh or so we had like maybe 4,000 people on the
72:36 waight list and then we had this like internal I think initially it was just like a very manual process but eventually we built this like invite tool that we could just uh send invites but in the beginning I would go read the actual surveys like in a spreadsheet then I copy the email and then I email them the invite link from my personal email and then like I would just like email them like after like few days or a
73:02 week and it's like hey what do you think and the reason we and so we we would invite only like in the beginning we maybe invited like 10 people a week and like eventually we increased those amounts but the reason we did it that way was that we thought that like if you just invite everyone at once or a lot of people at once all of those people going to probably hit the same problems in this kind of software that is very early
73:27 stage so like I don't know they they hit the same bug or the same problem in the software so then they will all send us feedback like hey there's this problem and then we felt like it was kind of like waste of the effort so we would just do this cohorts like let's invite these people and then they say like like hey this is a problem like I don't this doesn't work or or something then we go
73:47 fix that then after we fix that we invite the next cohort people then they say like well there's this thing that need is needed or this doesn't work then then we fix that so for that year we did this cohorts and then always get the feedback from the cohort saying like this is like wrong or this doesn't work and then we'll fix that so So eventually I think it it was much more like a I think like a effective way of doing the
74:11 initial development then um just like inviting or letting everyone to use the product right right at the beginning there's so many interesting lessons from this I wanted to ask how you got your first 10 customers and what I'm hearing essentially was from this weight list you launched it on Twitter people signed up you picked people to let on board you worked with them over the course of a year to make it what they needed and then eventually started
74:35 charging yeah I think like the first 10 like people companies using it I think maybe a little over half maybe there was like three friends that like friends that have startups and they used it and then I think the majority of them were just from this weight list but they didn't like pay us anything like we didn't have pricing in the beginning and or during the private beta at some point we start building the payment function
75:00 so we just like added a added a page in the settings that like you can optionally pay and then we just give you a slider that like how much do you want to pay per seat and then uh we is like see like if I don't know some people pay like $28 per seat and some people pay like $1 so um so we but like it do really matter we just wanted to test the functionality and see like what people
75:25 people think and then like yeah like after a year when we launched we already had like in the I don't know first week of launching like we we had probably like some hundreds of customers I've never heard of that approach to pricing is just act an actual uh sliding scale where people can slide the scale themselves on how much they want to pay did that help you figure out what to charge or is it mostly just an
75:47 experiment I don't think it's like give us like enough data to like decide like I think it's but I think think it was like good to see that it it's like there was some people that went I think the 20 was probably the maximum that people could pay so I think there was some people that went to it and they felt like actually like yeah I really love the products I'm happy to pay like $2 so
76:07 I think at least it gave us some like confidence that if we charge for this and and it's like something under $20 it's it's it's there's going to be like market for it I want to hear about the story of how you've started to feel product Market fit whatever that means to you when did you start to feel like oh wow this is actually G to work and maybe this is going to be a real business yeah I think like we always
76:30 been kind of I don't know some like paranoid or SK like yeah I guess maybe a paranoid is good way about the product Market fit I think like it's it's like a baroid in a way like we're always wondering like do we really have it like and like with who do we have it and I think it's it's true in our kind of business this that like I think I think we started feeling it very early on and
76:53 and like when people first like started using it and we could see like oh now the whole company is using it and they they seem like happier using it and the feedback is good and they might have some additional ask for them for for us but but we started feeling like there was definely like product Market fit with certain kind of customer and this these were like more like smaller like early stage companies maybe where still
77:16 the founder is still running the the the product and and they care about the speed of the shipping or they they kind of have like a certain values in a way so it was like a good fit with them and then I think we we always like know that we we want to like address the whole market and not just like these early stage customers but we knew that like I don't like if if a Fortune 500 company came to us then or
77:44 even like today we might not be like I don't think we can like provide them the solution today that works for them so I don't think the fit is there so for us like the way I think about is like do we have the do we have the fit in this specific segments and like how strong that fit is and so like in the in the company's like journey I think we the first year we kind of just focused on
78:07 like can we get the fit in the the first two years we focused on like can we get the fit in the in the early stage like startup kind of segment and like basically the goal is like we want to be the default for for startups like the default tool that the startups pick and I think we were able to accomplish that but we just purely focused on that segment and getting the product Market fit there and then like after or at the
78:33 same time we started getting some larger companies and we saw like yeah it's not like like really great for you right now but like let's work on it making it better and so I think the last two years we've been like focusing on that it's like how do we make this software work better how do we get the product Market fit better like stronger in this larger company segments like uh that are like thousands of people or like hundreds of
78:55 people or like a thousand people I think this is such a good way and smart way of thinking about product Market fit a lot of people see product Market fit as this like binary I have it or I don't and like when am I going to really feel product Market fit and what you're describing is what I often here is it's more of this spectrum of like more and more confidence that there is product Market fit and even more specifically
79:15 it's like product Market fit with segments of the market it's kind of like this map of the world and you're just like slowly acquiring territory in the market with specific elements and then over time it grows and grows yeah I think like a spectrum is a good way to think about it too I think it's I feel like there's this block Post in the like written in the past where it's like you know when you have product Market fit
79:34 and I think it's it's probably like it's like that for some I don't know social consumer apps like you know like if it's taking off or not then you you don't really have like a lot of Defense segments or like you don't really think about it like you just have users and you have millions of users so and then you see like it's taking off and so you have a product Market fit but then I think like in a more like a B2B
80:00 world I think there's always like you can have different sizes of customers you can have different domains the customers are in or there's different kind of like categories where it's like you might be doing really well in one category and and then not that well in another and I think like maybe the counter ined things is that like actually if you're doing really well in some category just like kind of double down on that this is something like I I
80:26 talked to to the zoom founder Eric at some some point in the company's life cycle and this is also what he said like is like when they were like building Zoom early days they would get this one type of customer like I don't know maybe it's like a university and then they like really it worked really well for them then they're like well how do we get more of the universities so they would always like focus on a certain
80:47 kind of customer rather than like let's just try get everyone or like let's focus on everything which is not possible so again like it's about the like the focus is like if you have some like you see that something's working really well then it's almost like you should focus on doing that more until you hit some kind of points like okay now we do have that category like captured or or handled as much as we want um and we should like expand to to
81:14 new area essentially look for poll and just follow that and pay attention to that yeah and I think there's like a for us it's often like there can be sometimes like for example now we have most of the AI companies are like are using us so I think like it's always and before that I was like a crypto company so I think there's like when we see these kind of things happening then we start to think like
81:37 oh could we do something differently or like should we um could we like get more of these AI companies um on board such a great lesson just a few more questions you mentioned that you launched on Twitter and that to a large weight list and a growing weight list is there anything you did before that to kind of build this following you know that sounds like really like really amazing cool we just announced it on Twitter and
82:01 we have this large weight list and then we grow and we get all these customers is there anything you did ahead of time in anticipation of this launch would you recommend people work on building some kind of following online before they were going to start it was it just like hey we happened to have this kind of following and it worked out anything along those lines you would recommend to Founders these days yeah I mean I I
82:20 think definitely if you have a following and and like obviously depends what kind of following but uh I think like my my background as a designer I was say like at at Airbnb and coinbase and other places and I I did some like talks in in conferences and and write some PL blows so I was definitely like out there and then kind of had that some of that following which which was helpful but it wasn't like I have like thousands of
82:44 like hundreds of thousands of followers or millions or something I had maybe like 10,000 or something which is like a significant number but then I think like the other thing is is I think with the announcement like one of the things we we did I think well it's like I think sometimes startups to try to like emulate successful large companies too much and and you kind of like do this like fancy announcements where it's like hey now we're like doing
83:14 this fancy thing and then it's like sounds very like corporate or something and I think with the with our announcement we we try to like wrote it more like direct or authentic to us like this is like what we're going to do and this is why and like this this are some of the things we're going to do then on on a Twitter we did the same thing like all of us Founders we wrote our own reasons why we're doing this and
83:37 I think it was like just much more like and I think like people could res people like us could resonate more with it so we were kind of writing to the Right audience and like I think that's the probably the first thing like when you're announcing in your company is like you think about like who is my first audience like who would be the best users like early users for this product and like where are they and and
84:02 then like how do they think about things and like what what kind of language they use so for us it was like very it came very naturally because we we are these people we've been building software and these companies and and we've seen like other people have seen similar things we have seen so I think it that the way we announced it like resonated with lot of people and then I think we we did have some friends and um I said like we got
84:29 some did like Angel round where we got some like friends involved and the main reason we did it was that we just felt like it's it's in the early days it's good to have like a you feel like a real company in a way that like you you have someone to answer for in a way even though the investors don't really run your company or that they don't have that much power it's more like oh I I I
84:49 took someone's money so I now need to like make it worth it kind of um but then like I think with the announcement again like we could use some of those people to like spread the message as well to kind of close out our conversation just a couple more broad questions you have a pretty unique culture at linear and I know one fun thing that you do is you have this kind of baking competition can you uh can you
85:12 talk about that and what it is you do there yeah so so so since we are like a fully remote and distributed company so we have people in Europe and us like lot of like kind of like group Gatherings are kind of challenging um uh like remote group sessions are kind of challenging because the time zones are so different um so like some of the basic things like happy hours it's not really like like doesn't really work
85:37 that well and also like Zoom happy hours is probably not that fun anyway so um so what we I think a lot of people in the company watch The Great British baking show and so we we decid like maybe we do something like that like where basically we would just pick pick a recipe first it was like baking now we expand it to cooking recipes too and so we just pick a recipe that is like somewhat
86:00 reasonable to do in in an like in a few hours in a couple hours and it doesn't like require like tons of equipment or skill or something and and then we we just tell people I go buy the ingredients use the company card everyone has a company card and then um then like hop on zoom on this day and and for me it's us like since I'm in California it's like 8:00 a.m. in the morning so so we start like
86:27 the baking or cooking then so so we made things like like a roll cake and um lemon Maring pie and and we made some like bastel NADA which is like Portuguese like Bas Tre and um and then like we we just hop on the zoom everyone's like doing their thing following the recipe and then like sometimes people have like questions like hey I'm I don't know stuck with this or like my dough looks weird like does your dough look like this and
86:56 people can kind of like help each other and then also like chatchat about whatever random things at the same time and then like we we do the thing and then we we everyone takes pictures and post this on this like slack channel it's like what they what they achieved and I think we have like kind of friendly competitions like who who did it better and like or who did it best so people sometimes put a lot of effort
87:16 into the into the decorations and and visuals so in a way it's again like a a craft thing that we do it's it's like I think baking and cooking and these kind of things is also a craft so we we likeed it that way and yeah we've been basically doing it quarterly since the beginning of the company um and yeah the latest thing we were a little bit like I think didn't have that much time so we
87:43 we decided to do like easier thing which is like a summer drink recipe so I think it's it was like people made like matcha drinks and and some like um coconut drinks or white iced tea or something so even that was kind of like interesting to do you ever won one of these competitions yourself we don't I don't know if we clear like uh declare winners that much but um I I do think like uh I
88:08 do since I'm a designer I do have some advantages on the on the visual presentation so I think that I generally do well on that and obviously that's like with this remote competition it's that's the only thing you can c like look for um it's not not necessar about the taste or the texture because you can't really taste it uh through the zoom maybe it's a last question just again broadly you've gone from being an IC designer manager of designers to the
88:37 CEO of very fast growing company what's something that you've learned about leadership over the Journey of linear that maybe you didn't expect for some reason it was surprising to me I think that like being a CEO or or some of this like leadership roles is that you end up doing so many different things and um I think like even when I was a designer like even if I would be like like some like high level designer in some company
89:03 it's still like you're just mostly focusing on the design and and that's like your job um but then like when you're a CEO then it's like every week or every day there's some some different thing going on it's not like there's sometimes there can be like problems but a lot of times it's like hey we need to like figure out how are we going to do this like how do we going to do this like compens or how are we going to do
89:23 this marketing plan or like how are we going to do this like offsite thing and and so it's just like to me what is like challenge like definitely like a challenging for me is is handling that like different kinds of things that that come to you um and like staying somewhat focused still still on something so I think it's I haven't necessarily fully figured it out but I also like learned figure it out that like yeah hi like
89:52 hiring and delegation helps with this that like if you can find other leaders that can like take on certain areas that that's that's helpful that that's the like the the main thing that that like how what is the it's like a very wide range of things that you maybe didn't have experience before but also I think it's interesting to me to learn about these things and like you learn about financials and you learn about legal things and then you start to feel like
90:17 oh actually I know something about these things like over time for actual final question before we get to very exciting lighting round what's just the future l or what's coming what's happening in the future anything you can share yeah I think there's always always things we're working on and and improving um one like a newer thing we're working on is is this feature called asks and and basically what it is is that we we see that like in in a company there can be a
90:43 lot of lot of different people that needs to interact with the product team or different people that needs to interact with this team but they are not necessarily like in or part of this team so we would we've been building this like an Ask feature which which is like an integration to slack where you can very easily like go to a slack Channel then then ask like your question like you need something from this team like
91:07 maybe it's it team that like you need like a laptop or maybe it's like the like infrastructure team and you need like help them like you need something from them then the team that is is is handling the request um they can very easily send it to to linear into this like triage that we have and then like they can start like doing stuff with it and if they have like questions or or disc like additional questions to the
91:33 actual person who requested it we can like send those messages back to the person through slack so they don't actually have to go to to linear or they don't have to be a linear user to use it so we think like this is like just like a good way for the company or or the whole company to be more potentially involved in the in the company like the product operations without like having to be like a like a power user of lineer
91:59 or or because not every function really uses it or or needs to use it awesome what a cool peek at something coming out soon or maybe out by the time this comes out and with that we've reached our very exciting lightning round I've got a bunch of questions for you are you ready yeah I'm ready all right well what are two or three books that you've recommended most to people Timeless way of building by Christopher Alexander like he he's this
92:27 like a uh he wasn't really an architect but he he I think thought in Berkeley and I think he he has this like interesting thoughts about like building things and like he focuses on buildings and and towns and these kind of spaces but I think there's a lot of like things that are also interesting for building software the other the other book that I like is like the the Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance because it's also
92:52 like talks about the quality of things and and I think that's one of the main themes of the book and like the the thing is also that quality is so hard to Define it it's like if you actually like start thinking about it it's like how do you define it it's it's like it's kind of like it's really hard to pin pin down but it's kind of like when you try something or see it then you kind of
93:14 know if it's quality or not what are some recent movies or TV shows they've really enjoyed I think that the the movie is like probably the John Wick for I think it's a it's it's like kind of feels like I mean LPC it's like there's no l story in that movie but it it's like a I think it's very true to its nature so I like that fact and then also recently I started watching The Silo on
93:38 Apple TV and I think I kind of like it it's like a good mystery and then also um it's kind of reminds me of the Fallout game so so I kind of like it that way too I actually read The Silo books and I was really excited for the show to come out but mentioned this on a previous podcast the show is like so little to do with the actual books like the core ideas are the same but there's
93:58 all these stories that they're just making up on the show so I kind of stopped watching because I was just like that's not what I was hoping for but okay interesting maybe I I need to check the books later like once I watch the watch the show definitely read the books but there's three of them and only the first one is actually good the other ones are not actually very good and I should not have read them because it
94:16 just just went off the rails a little bit anyway next question what is a favorite interview question that you like to ask candidates when you're interviewing them I think usually I like to ask like what is what is the candidate most proud of and why um like what like on their professional life or otherwise like what they're most proud of and why and then I think we we can go deeper on that but I think it's kind of
94:38 like gives you a little bit indication like what the person values and and like how they think about things and and also like I think it's always nice that people can share something like they think they did really well and we can spend time on it versus just like asking something like more like negative things what are some favorite products you recently discovered that you really really like um not sure if I discovered them recently but like I recently I've been
95:04 in in this home office I've been installing some of this H lights and I I really like them because like throughout the day I can like have more like kind of harsh lighting because it's I'm I'm in meetings or something and then like in the evening I can kind of like change the temperature like I make it much more like red or orange or something so it's just like I think it's nice that like you can kind of transition to space it's
95:28 like okay now I'm working and now I'm like doing something else and and you can use the lights to kind of like indicate that that is so cool do you like automate the schedule or you manually change the color yeah I just manually Chang it so I have like a like on my home app I have like scenes that like so there's the night scene and then there's the day scene or like the morning scene and so I just like click
95:50 that button and then then it turns changes the lights that is extremely cool I'm gonna try that myself what is a favorite life motto that you like to repeat yourself or share with people something you kind of come back to a lot go slow to go fast is um I think for me it's it's it's about that sometimes people have tendency to rush into things and especially in I think in startups but other other places too that you you kind of have this like
96:19 I think urgency is important but but then sometimes you you have like too much urgency and you are rushing things and what happens is that you you rushed it and then now you need to come back to fix it so I think sometimes we I like to think that like you should take some time to actually like think about it and like what are you going to do and then do it because then it's in the end it's
96:39 going to be faster that way than like going back and forth and fixing things what is the most valuable lesson that your mom or your dad taught you I think it's like respecting people and things so I think it's I mean I think the people respect this is pretty obvious but I think the I think with the the things you have also I think like you should take good care of them like when you when you use them you should like I
97:03 don't know clean them or put them away and then they're like ready for the next time so I think I like that though like you rather than like you treating things like that they're trash or or kind of like not that valuable you should kind of like treat things that they are they are valuable final question you were born in Finland I think you grew up in Finland what is a finished food that people should definitely try to get as
97:27 soon as they can one is like this uh salmon soup and it might sound weird like a fish soup like maybe it's not going to be that interesting but it it is like a it's like a creamy soup with some like potatoes carrots and and other things and it's kind of like almost like a sweet little bit like sweet flavor to it so that's one thing like you can you can make it yourself at home or or you
97:50 can like if you go to Finland there's probably like a few restaurants that offer it okay amazing is that something we can get here or you have to go to Finland to get it I don't think I've never seen it here in in in Us in any restaurant but it's not very hard to make it yourself if you can probably Google recipe it's it's basically you just need some salmon and and um some some like basic spices and and some
98:13 cream and and some fruit fet the BS all right Next Episode we're going to do a a cooking show with Ki KI thank you you so much for being here you're building a very special company in a really unique way and I think many Founders and many product Builders can learn a ton from watching you operate in the business that you're building so again thank you so much for being here two final questions where can folks find you
98:35 online if they want to reach out maybe ask you some more questions and how can listeners be useful to you yeah so I'm on Twitter my my name Ki snn and and and we also have the ler account which I think is interesting so that's just at linar and then yeah I think like I hope everyone can like check out check out linear and like see if it could work for them in their company and like figure out if there's a
98:59 pilot like I think we always happy to assist on those things that like if you just want to try it out and and try it with the team um we can set help you to set it up and and and like help you to like understand how to use the product awesome and it's just linear that app right is that the URL yes awesome okay easy peasy uh amazing krie again thank you so much for being here bye
99:24 everyone thank you so much for listening if you found this valuable you can subscribe to the show on Apple podcast Spotify or your favorite podcast app also please consider giving us a rating or leaving a review as that really helps other listeners find the podcast you can find all past episodes or learn more about the show at Lenny podcast.com see you in the next episode
Summary
- Design is crucial in competitive industries; initial iterations can be basic, but high standards are necessary for long-term success.
- Linear prioritizes craft and quality over metrics and A/B testing, focusing on user experience and thoughtful design.
- The "Linear Method" promotes building opinionated software and working in defined cycles to maintain focus and efficiency.
- Hiring at Linear involves a rigorous process, including a paid work trial to assess candidates' skills and cultural fit.
- The company has successfully grown through a waitlist strategy, inviting users based on their interest and feedback during a year-long private beta.
- Sarin believes in the importance of understanding customers and maintaining a culture that values quality and collaboration.
- Linear's unique culture includes fun team-building activities, like cooking competitions, to foster connection among remote employees.