Section Insights
The Misconception of Strength in Parenting
What if our efforts to strengthen children are actually harming them?
The speaker reflects on the pressure parents feel to make their children stronger, questioning whether this approach is truly beneficial. They suggest that instead of pushing children to handle adult problems, parents should recognize that children need support and understanding.
- Children are not ready to handle adult problems.
- Parents often revert to old parenting methods out of fear.
- Strength should not come from suppression of emotions.
Understanding Resilience vs. Defense
How can we differentiate between a resilient child and a defended child?
The speaker explains that a defended child is constantly on guard and suppresses emotions, while a resilient child feels safe expressing their emotions. They emphasize the importance of fostering resilience in children rather than teaching them to defend against their feelings.
- Resilience allows for emotional expression; defense leads to suppression.
- Parents should create a safe emotional environment for children.
- Recognizing emotions is crucial for healthy development.
The Importance of Witnessing Over Fixing
What should parents do when their children express discomfort?
Instead of immediately problem-solving, parents should witness their children's feelings and validate them. This approach encourages children to share more and fosters a trusting relationship.
- Validating feelings without offering solutions builds trust.
- Children need to feel heard, not fixed.
- Empathy is key to emotional connection.
Modeling Emotional Regulation
How can parents teach emotional regulation to their children?
Parents should model their own emotional struggles and show that it's okay to feel overwhelmed. By being open about their emotions, parents teach children that it's normal to experience and express feelings.
- Modeling vulnerability teaches children emotional regulation.
- Children learn more from observing behavior than from words.
- It's important for parents to show that asking for help is okay.
Embracing Struggles and Emotions
Why is it important for children to experience discomfort?
Allowing children to feel sad or struggle helps them learn that these feelings are survivable. Parents should act as anchors, providing stability while allowing children to navigate their emotions.
- Struggles are essential for emotional growth.
- Children need to learn that feeling sad is part of life.
- Creating a safe space for emotions fosters resilience.
Transcript
0:00 Transcriber: Ngọc Thanh Phan Reviewer: Nguyễn Hào What if everything we are doing to make our children stronger is actually breaking them? So I'm serious here. When this this become normal. I was at a PTM for my six year old and the teacher told me, ma'am, he cries in class sometimes when he is not able to complete his worksheet.
0:30 Or sometimes if a friend takes something, we need to make him stronger so that he can handle the real world problems later. And that made me thinking, okay, he's six, but I told the teacher that yeah, we'll work on it. But later, when I was thinking more about it, all I could think was that my child is just six years old. He cries because he gets frustrated. And that's a problem that we are trying to fix.
0:57 So when I thought more about it, that why is this happening? One thing clicked for me. Maybe the world doesn't need stronger children. Maybe the world needs adults who stop asking children to handle things they are not ready for yet. When we became parents, we all have a notion that we will parent a little differently, a little better than how we were raised. So we say yes to everything. We remove all the harsh boundaries that we grew up with and everything works, you know? You follow all the great Instagram accounts like mine, and you feel that, okay, I am getting everywhere, right?
1:38 But then your child turns around 5 or 6 and you tell them no, and they start crying and you feel, oh no, I've made a mistake. The fear is creeping inside of you. My child is not strong enough. I need to make him strong. So what do you do? You follow the path that you were raised with. You suppress. You know, you. All of us do that. If your boss says something to you in a meeting, you suppress. You tell yourself I'm strong.
2:09 Your husband says something to you at home. You suppress. You think I'm strong? Mother in law says something in an argument. You suppress. I am strong and we do it all day long. But at night, when our child does something that we don't like, we explode because we have been carrying it all day long and we call it strength. That how much we are able to suppress and hold everything together. But neuroscience tells us that the nervous system, which is under threat, doesn't build resilience.
2:44 It just builds defense. And there is a difference between a child who is resilient and a child who is very, very defended. A defended child is always scanning the room before showing their emotion that am I safe here? Can I show my emotions or should I just suppress it? A resilient child knows that all their emotions are safe. A defended child always asks, Will I be too much? AM I doing something which will trouble others?
3:15 A resilient child knows I am not alone in this. A defended child is always performing for strength. A resilient child knows that he has that strength. So what do we do differently as parents to help our children? So I'm going to give you three things today. The first one is stop fixing and start witnessing. My son came back from school. He was in a really bad mood. He just threw his bag and he started crying.
3:46 And then he said something which sounded ridiculous to my adult ears. Mama, my friend didn't save me a seat on the bus. And I was like, okay, I want you to all to notice something, you know, as parents or as adults in the next 4 or 5 seconds, we start problem solving. You could have told the DD in the bus She ought to do. And I tell you now, don't be dependent on one friend all the time.
4:14 It's a good lesson for you. We do all this because we love our children, and when we see them in discomfort, we just want them to move ahead of it, you know? We don't want them to feel that pain. Their pain is a problem that we have to solve as parents. But think yourself as an adult, when you go to your friend or to your husband and you share some problem that you are facing, and they immediately start giving you advice.
4:44 The better. And how are you feeling in that moment? You don't feel that relief. You feel that shame. Okay. I couldn't think of that. So children are no different. When every problem that they have is met with a solution, they stop coming to us. And it's not because they don't trust us, it's because they don't want to be a problem to be fixed. So what can we do instead? We just name the feeling like your child tells you, Mama, my friend didn't save me a seat on the bus.
5:16 That's not fair. That's it. No. No solutions. No silver linings for him. And what will happen next? The child will share more because he knows that my parent is there for me. When we show that empathy to our kids without any problem solving, we are just there for them. So the second thing that we can do for our children is let them watch our struggle sometimes. So it's a Tuesday evening at my house. I came back home. I was really tired and I was done, like completely done.
5:50 If it was the old me, I would just go in the kitchen and start prepping dinner, do my child's homework on assignments on the side with him while, you know, correcting him and telling him again and again. But that day, I just told him that I'm really overwhelmed. Today. I just need to lie down for 15 minutes and then we can play together. I know what you all are thinking. I don't want to burden my child with my problems, so I am not telling you to share your mental stress with your child.
6:22 I am telling you, let your child see that you are also human. You know a human with emotions and I am not saying that. Share with your seven year old, your marital problems or your financial problems, just your emotions and showing them that these emotions are survivable. Because if we are as adults, showing our kids that we don't need help, we can push no matter what. We never cry as adults. What are we teaching them? Isn't it a wrong lesson?
6:54 Our kids are learning from us how to be adults. See, as parents, most of us complain, my kids don't listen to me, but our kids are always watching us, always watching us. How we are the adults, how we are living our life. And that's a beautiful way to teach them also, because when we want to teach anyone, being resilient. We just have to model it for our kids also. Like when I told my son, I am overwhelmed, I need to lie down for a few minutes.
7:25 I taught him emotional regulation. When I yell at him, sometimes I tell him I'm sorry. I should not have behaved like that. I am teaching him accountability. When I ask my husband for help, when I'm done, I am teaching him that asking for help doesn't make me a burden on anyone. So our kids might not listen to all our words, but they are seeing how we are living. The third thing that we can do for our children is let them feel bad sometimes.
7:54 In a world where we want to create a perfect everything for our children, we have removed all the obstacles from their lives. I get parents who tell me, ma'am, we shifted the school because the teacher was very strict. Ma'am, we stopped his art class because he was feeling very stressed. Or we only gave him fancy food to eat because he doesn't eat dal roti at home. And I get it. You want to give your children the best.
8:19 But when we are removing all the obstacles, we are teaching them that uncomfortable is not the right thing for me. You know, when our kids are around the age of 1011, they start understanding that my parents cannot protect me from everything. So now they have two paths. One where they think that I can't handle it alone. And the world is very scary. And the second is where the child feels, I have done hard things. I can do this. Like when I was coming for this talk and my son also had a presentation.
8:55 He was telling me, Mama, please write to the teacher that I can't do it. I just told him, you know, I am also feeling very scary of going there. So I hope we both will be able to do it for each other. So just telling our children that yes, you can be there. So I was just being there for my child and not solving the problem for him. So that's what we need to do for our kids more that we let them struggle a little and let them have that uncomfortable feeling where they feel sad sometimes because let them learn that feeling sad is also survivable.
9:32 You know? Think of yourself as the anchors for your children. And an anchor doesn't push the ship to the shore. The anchor holds the ship steady and doesn't let it drift away. I think about the future a lot, the future that we are building for our children. So are we building a future full of people who can handle everything alone? Or are we building a future full of people who are terrified to need anyone? Because when I think of the future, I think of my six year old, the one who cries in school, and I don't want him to be like me.
10:07 I don't want him to be so strong that he hides his own emotions. I don't want him to be so resilient that he cannot understand his own pain. I don't want him to perform that. He's okay when he's not. I want him to be struggling a little. I want him to cry when he feels frustrated. I want him to be strong enough to be soft. Because maybe the world doesn't need fewer sensitive children.
10:38 Maybe the world needs fewer adults who forgot how to feel. Maybe the world needs few people who are not suppressing their feelings, but are okay to show all their feelings and feel that all feelings are okay. So next time when someone asks you, make your child stronger. Ask them stronger than what? Stronger than their need for connection, stronger than their need for safety.
11:08 Stronger than their struggles to be loved even when they are not feeling fine? Because honestly, that's not strength. That's just loneliness with a better PR. Thank you.
Summary
- Children should be allowed to express emotions like sadness and frustration without immediate problem-solving from parents.
- Resilience is about feeling safe to express emotions, while being defended means constantly scanning for safety and suppressing feelings.
- Parents should model emotional regulation by sharing their own struggles appropriately, teaching children that emotions are survivable.
- Allowing children to experience discomfort and face challenges helps them learn that they can handle difficult situations.
- The goal is to raise children who are emotionally aware and capable of seeking help, rather than those who feel they must handle everything alone.
- The speaker emphasizes the importance of connection and emotional expression over the traditional notion of strength.
- Ultimately, the future should focus on nurturing sensitive, emotionally intelligent individuals rather than suppressing their feelings.
Questions Answered
What if our efforts to strengthen children are actually harming them?
The speaker reflects on the pressure parents feel to make their children stronger, questioning whether this approach is truly beneficial. They suggest that instead of pushing children to handle adult problems, parents should recognize that children need support and understanding.
How can we differentiate between a resilient child and a defended child?
The speaker explains that a defended child is constantly on guard and suppresses emotions, while a resilient child feels safe expressing their emotions. They emphasize the importance of fostering resilience in children rather than teaching them to defend against their feelings.
What should parents do when their children express discomfort?
Instead of immediately problem-solving, parents should witness their children's feelings and validate them. This approach encourages children to share more and fosters a trusting relationship.
How can parents teach emotional regulation to their children?
Parents should model their own emotional struggles and show that it's okay to feel overwhelmed. By being open about their emotions, parents teach children that it's normal to experience and express feelings.
Why is it important for children to experience discomfort?
Allowing children to feel sad or struggle helps them learn that these feelings are survivable. Parents should act as anchors, providing stability while allowing children to navigate their emotions.