Transcript
0:01 why is it important that the president that the candidates continue to actually have debates even when it's two candidates we've already seen look I think that seeing somebody engage with someone who they disagree with gives you a window into who they really are as a person and I also think that especially in the modern environment where so much of what people learn about political leaders is filtered through intermediating channels to be the chance to be able to see it directly coming
0:27 from one candidate versus another is is a path to truth that we're actually missing in modern American politics so I think it's vital we've always had presidential debates for a reason I think we need to continue to have them it's part of who we are we need to bring back that Spirit of the Lincoln Douglas debates we need to bring back the spirit of people who are able to travel this country go to different places together
0:47 and to be able to say even though we disagree like hell on certain policies we're still committed to the best interests of this country the United States of America and once we lose that I don't think we have the same country left I truly believe that hardest thing about the formality of that debate structure and I know there's lots of different rules that you can be part of in in the high school level there's all these different formats at
1:11 the big National stage you've got these different formats what's the hardest part you know you you've been through it yeah what was what was the most challenging hard part I think the hardest part in the political context as opposed to you know in a high school debate context the hardest part in a political context is there's a certain artificiality to the way the exercise is actually constructed right if it's oneon-one that's I think a pretty good
1:33 setting actually but when you got 10 Republican candidates on stage it ends up being literally a theatrical production disguised as a debate you have 30 seconds to make a point you're designed to do it to be able to capture realizing that most people aren't simultaneously watching it how do you generate the shortest moment in which the other 9 million people who you want to see it or the other 100 million people who want to see it actually end
1:56 up seeing it it ends up becoming more of a theatrical exercise disguised as a debate so I have no problem with theatrical exercises just call it a theatrical exercise but I think the Slate of hand in calling that a debate when in fact it's a it's a social media production or a or a multimedia production I think creates a kind of dishonesty and I think that's one of the things that makes certain forms of those presidential debates worse than others I
2:19 think a one-on-one debate between two general election candidates is a different story two hours isolated format and really going directly at the two candidates who have fundamentally different ideologies from one another I think is actually far more productive what else would you want to share especially with parents about how to help our kids use debate as a tool to set them up for success in life why is it important for me as a parent or for
2:46 the viewer as a parent to to look at this issue and say this really matters and I need to make sure that my son or daughter is capable of engaging in discourse yeah look I think that it starts at home start starts at at the dinner table for me one of the experiences early on in my childhood came from my own parents my father ended up going to law school when I was in Middle School he did his night school
3:09 though he worked at GE at the GE plant in Evendale Ohio under Jack Welch's tenure where he faced layoffs they laid about laid off about two-thirds of the people at the plant but his way of being able to keep job security was they were short on patent attorneys and he was an engineer so if he went to night school all the way in Northern Kentucky 45 minutes from where we lived and did that for four years he would have a secure
3:30 job well my parents didn't have child care or child support or anything like that so often my dad would take me with him to those law classes at night I was in sixth grade I would sit in the back of the class but I remember the way my dad would use those long drives back home those 45-minute drives back home would be to sort of engage me in debate right he he would lean maybe a little
3:52 left of center and so he would criticize what Clarence Thomas ranton and Scalia had to say and as a you know 11-year-old 12-year-old myself I was able to take the other side of that debate and it was a great way that even to the point you raised earlier about Unity that brought me closer to my dad that's actually something debating at the dinner table and those long car rides actually brought us together in a way that we probably wouldn't have
4:15 happened if we weren't engaging in that type of debate and I think that's the friendliest setting in which to begin because it teaches kids kids who know they have the love of their parents but are able to then learn to say that even if you disagree with them dealing with one another as peers and as adults in the context of a debate that allows you to see that how much you love or regard a person is separate from whether or not
4:35 you disagree with them and that's where the role of the family here in Reviving debate is maybe even more vital is definitely even more vital than that of our schools and so I think parents who take that opportunity with their kids at least for me in my upbringing in the way we think about raising our boys now is it's a great chance to treat your kids not just in the disciplining sense or the or the pedagogical sense as a parent
4:57 but the beginnings of also showing them you see them as a real person with their own views by engaging them in that debate and I think it's a great way to not only bring a family together but to teach kids that against the backdrop of loving somebody if you can disagree then you can go into the world and have a relationship with your fellow citizens who you may not agree with too but who you can still respect and dare I say
5:19 have a a type A special type of love and relationship for your fellow citizen as well that I think we're missing today yeah that resonates so deeply with me I I have my son's graduating high school this week and um debate has been such a big part of our relationship and it is funny that trust and a sense that there is a shared objective that's bigger than the debate that's being had seems to be so important for the potential to learn
5:49 in that debate process is there anything else you'd want to share about this topic and and this concern I'm optimistic that this is going to sort itself out right that the assault on this culture of debate that I think was at our country's founding we're going through a little bit of a adolescent period where we're rebelling against that with the censorious culture but there's something native about us as human beings that resists that right one of the things that makes us human beings
6:17 is the idea that we're able to have these beliefs and it's foundational to who we are as human beings as free agents with free will to want to express those those thoughts and Views with others and I think that's been true for all of human history and it's true today and so as dangerous as it might feel at times to live in a culture that suppresses that I don't think that's going to naturally last for long because
6:38 we as human beings have been wired it's how it's it's in our very nature to want to express ourselves and I think that is part of what's going to bring us together as a country again and do you think that's baked into the American DNA is it is there something uniquely American about discourse is it our diversity is it our the nature America was a country built on the idea of the marketplace of ideas America as an idea was built on
7:05 the idea that every idea deserves to be expressed every opinion gets to be expressed they put the First Amendment first for a reason you're free to practice your faith and you're free to express your opinion no matter how heinous your peers might think that opinion is so yes they put the First Amendment first for a reason it was core to the founding of our country it's core to the DNA of our country and and the beauty of America is it was founded on
7:27 the attributes that make us human ourselves eles our Free Will endowed in Us by our creator was written into the very Declaration of Independence that formed the DNA of America's own founding and so this idea of debate bringing us together that's a distinctively American idea I won't call it uniquely American because we've exported that idea to other countries around the world but it is distinctively American and we think about what makes America great again we got to maybe remember what made America
7:56 great the first time around and the openness and the love of open dialogue and debate and Free Speech yeah that's absolutely what made America great the first time around and that's what's going to make America great again if we have a shot at Reviving this country if you like this clip you should check out the full video and all the other great content we've got at dad Saves America so be sure to hit the like button subscribe and ring that Bell so
8:19 you won't miss our new stuff as it drops each week
Summary
- Presidential debates provide direct insight into candidates' beliefs and character, fostering a culture of truth in politics.
- The theatrical nature of modern debates can detract from genuine discourse, particularly in multi-candidate formats.
- Engaging in debate at home can strengthen family bonds and teach children the value of respectful disagreement.
- Parents play a vital role in encouraging debate as a tool for personal growth and civic engagement.
- The essence of American identity is rooted in the freedom to express diverse opinions and engage in open dialogue.
- Reviving a culture of debate is essential for overcoming current societal divisions and fostering unity.
- The First Amendment embodies the foundational belief in the importance of free speech and discourse in America.