Transcript
0:00 Lake cruset versus stove why does it have to be one or the other what about Lake cruset and stob hi guys and welcome to Uncle Scott's kitchen today we are taking a look at some high-end enamel cast iron Dutch ovens and trying to decide should you buy a stove or a lake rusay or maybe if you're like me is it less stressful and produces more happiness especially more delicious food if you get at least one of each now
0:29 recently I purchased a 9q lake Crusade and a 9q stove and what I thought we might do in this video is use those two new dutch ovens to kind of compare and contrast the two Brands and show you the real world differences between the two but more importantly than that try and determine if those differences are indeed a big deal or really not are they nothing to worry about we'll talk a little bit about buying strategy after
0:55 all they don't give these things away if you're going to have more than one what's the best way to do it and if you stick around to the end I will tell you the story of the black interior Lake crus and how I came to acquire this piece but I warn you it includes a little marriage advice so you younger viewers not married yet you may want to grab a pen and piece of paper and take notes so you know what's
1:21 coming now the brands themselves don't need a whole lot of introduction uh both are French made high-end beautiful uh they come in a variety of colors and shapes and sizes and both have a reputation for fantastic cooking performance and they're often similarly priced often in life when two items are very evenly matched it makes it difficult to actually choose it leads to indecision after all if someone asks me would you like to have a Porsche or a
1:53 Nissan I would choose the Porsche easy decision if someone says would you like an Audi or a BMW then then you start Heming and haul and thinking about it now conventional wisdom says that the biggest difference between the two are the interior colors L cruset is known for having a lighter interior whereas stove is known for having a darker interior and people say that that lighter interior on the lake Cruses
2:23 makes it easier to see down into the pot when you're doing some cooking whereas maybe the stove with the dark ER interior makes it a little bit better and easier to brown meat maybe baking a uh an artisan loaf maybe get a little bit better crust with that darker interior is that true so let's take a look at those interior colors and see if this is a big deal or not with a little real world cooking in both Brands going
2:48 to start with the L cruset um got a neighbor under the weather and my wife wanted to make her some chicken soup nice thing to do and I'm going to start out here by Browning some bonan SK skin on chicken thighs got the lake ruset nicely heated in go some oil and go the chicken thighs and first thing I note here is that these are Supermarket GMO thunder thighs these things are mutant big almost scary but they fit in the 9q lake
3:17 Crusade with no crowding at all after 5 6 minutes or so I give these guys a turn and they did not stick that's nice and I got nice Browning in the leg Crusade Brown the other side remove those then in goes a safo with some carrots onion and celery and this is going to be part of the base of the
3:48 soup and indeed I can see down in that lakeer sa very well so the lake crus say nice Browning and you can see down in there what about the stove here Browning some beef to make a little proposal in a stove and I think the stove did a fine job at Browning that beef here making a base for another soup some rolita which we'll talk about here in just a moment got another Saito in there more carrots
4:14 onions and [Music] celery and indeed I can see down in my stove just fine so for me as a home cook that difference between light interior and dark interior is more of a nuance it is not a big fat hairy deal as they say and I can turn out delicious food in either Dutch oven and that also leads to indecision which way should you go light versus dark if you get one of each you
4:44 don't have to worry about it you can choose either one depending on the dish you're going to make now let's further compare in the weight category now both of these dutch ovens are solidly in the booty pan category they have thick wide heavy bottoms the stove with lid empty over 17 pounds holy cow the lake cruset uh with lid empty right around 16 and I had the lake ruset full of reita last night
5:16 tried to weigh it on the kitchen scale too heavy for that scale I had to go grab the bathroom scale and your wage is 29.1 lb 29 lb full of reita but I do note my wife says that bathroom scale does tend to lie from time to time let's look at the handles uh the stoves are a little smaller than the lake Crusades but I can get all four of my fingers on each
5:47 hand through the loop handles on the lake Reay a little bit more room and also can get all my fingers through there so not a big difference there what about the knobs some some of the leg cruset come with plastic knobs I think if you are paying up for a l cruset make sure you get one with one of the metal knobs a little bit more oven safe and the standard knob on the lake rusay is
6:15 [Music] bigger then the standard knob on the stove stob is a metal and oven safe but in here there's a little bit of a nuance and a difference between the brands um with the stoves you can get these decorative knobs and replace the uh the standard knobs and for example I've put the cowl on this one and I think that gives the stoves
6:47 perhaps a little bit more personality if you get the rooster knob and use that when you're cooking chicken or the cow knob when you're cooking beef etc etc it kind of makes the stoves Maybe a little more fun to use sometimes whereas the lake Rus may have a little bit more of a classic play uh let me make another argument for having at least one of each let's hearken back to the great philosopher R king who posed the
7:13 question can't we all just get along after all are these Brands Rivals they are in the marketplace on the store shelves in Internet videos but once you buy one of each and have them going on the stove top at the same time I often use both simultaneously in preparation of a single dish no longer are they Rivals we are all buddies and on team good food together case in point reita a delicious Italian Tuscan vegetable soup
7:46 absolutely delicious soup maybe my favorite soup in the entire world and one of the five or so dishes that I ate in Italy that actually inspired me to learn how to cook 15 20 years ago highly recommend it and I'll put a link to to the recipe somewhere around this video but it's a big soup and there are a lot of steps and a lot of ingredients I like to have two dutch ovens going at once uh
8:09 rolita it includes uh cabbage kale Don't Fear The kale uh Saito potato Tomatoes stock or broth or water depending on if you want to go uh vegan or not and also importantly calini beans white Italian kidney beans and when I'm doing the real deal reita I start with dried beans and I will often get those going in one of the Dutch ovens and dried beans are always a variable because depending on the age of The Bean you never know
8:41 exactly when they're going to get done and then I prepare everything else in the second Dutch oven um back here are 7 qu Lake Cruses and 7q stoves I used to make this rebita using both of those but because cabbage comes in an entire head and kale comes in bu lunches uh trying to get all that in the pot and keep everything else in proportion things got really tight and the soup was all the way up to the rim there so with these
9:08 nine quarts I can easily use an entire head of cabbage the entire uh bundle of kale and keep everything else in proportion and there's plenty of room in [Music] there [Music]
9:58 I [Music] are we done though no because reita means reboiled uh on day one it is simply delicious Italian vegetable soup we have to do a few more steps to make it actually into reita and if you know anything about reita there is bread in the [Music] soup
10:29 [Music] so what I do is line that Dutch oven with bread add some olive oil then Ladle in the soup on top of that [Music] [Music] bread
11:00 [Music] then make successive layers all the way on up so this reita ended up with an entire loaf of crusty uh artisan bread in the soup now are we done now no we have to wait overnight and the next day you bring this back up and reboil it bring the heat back up and then and then is it re bolita now of course you don't have
11:32 to have a fancy uh expensive French Dutch oven for that interim step of transferring the soup back and forth with that bread step but I do have to say that um having nice stuff in the kitchen and seeing these guys flying in formation and working together really does make me happier as a home cook every year my wife hosts a Christmas cookie party she makes blank cookies and puts them in the dining room and her friends bring their kids kids over and
11:59 the kids all decorate cookies in there and in the kitchen here I run the wine swelling excuse me the uh wine tasting and I'm in charge of all the food I made a couple of batches of kind of week night chili and here again I have both dutch ovens going at the same time 2 lbs of beef in each Dutch oven and I can't tell any difference in the Browning between the two add my onions add my
12:27 kidney beans add my tomatoes the seasoning and the stove and Lake crus produce virtually identical batches of week night chili so how do you decide um it worries me if I were to choose one or the other I always have a little bit of indecision and doubt did I make the right decision did I make the right choice would I been happier with the other one for me the type person I am and the type cook I am it just makes a
12:54 lot more sense for me to buy one of each I'm happier I can produce more delicious food and I like having both Brands so okay smart guy they don't give these things away how is anyone supposed to afford these fancy French expensive dutch ovens I do have a buying strategy and one thing I do is I keep a list and it's kind of like a game and I may have 40 or 50 items on that list frying pans
13:22 Chef's knives uh kitchen gear dutch ovens on and on and I kind of wait and when sales arise I am opportunistic and I jump on them when I get the opportunity for example these 9qt models normally $450 $500 it just so happens on this this past Black Friday this Green Lake rusay went on sale for $259 I jumped on it these stoves for
13:54 example went on sale at Costco and I saved um about $120 on this model now it varies from sale to sale and often it's one particular color or one particular size but if you're not too particular and you have your list ready to go that is when you add that second brand okay now how about the story of the black interior Lake cruset how in the world did I come to get one of these here is where we're going to talk about
14:24 marriage just a little bit um if you're young and you're going to marry your high school sweetheart early on or you get out of graduate school and get married early typically neither party has much stuff I got married after age 30 my wife was over 30 as well and when you get married over 30 each party typically has some stuff so my wife's stuff and my stuff when we got married became our stuff and one of the things
14:58 she she brought to the marriage other than a 96 Nissan with a hood that didn't match the rest of her car was this guy a lake rusay enamel cast iron Dutch oven and I don't want to say that sealed the deal but it didn't hurt so we moved into an apartment together and I was doing some cooking and I got the lake ruset out and I'm standing at the stove top minding my own business and out of the corner of my
15:27 eye I know she's sitting over there giving me the old scowl I didn't think much of it and kept cooking and I looked over her again and she's just just scowling and grimacing at me and finally I said you know what in the world is going on and it turns out that this Lake crus was given to her by a now dearly departed relative and I wasn't to touch it and I thought it was our L Crusade
16:00 but apparently some things were grandfathered in and this went back and forth and after all I have a YouTube Cooking Channel I should have a relatively decent reputation for taking care of cookware but no I was not to touch that Lake Rus and we kind of bickered back and forth and finally I said fine I'm going to be the mature one here I'm going to take the high road I'll just get my own stinking Lake ruset and you
16:28 can't touch mine either and that my friends is marriage and takk you my own advice I had my own shopping list and I waited and waited and after about two years these guys went on sale one Black Friday and I jumped on them I got a stove and then at Costco I ordered a lake ruset and at Black Friday I run a cookwar channel here I load up on stuff to review and I had a stack of stuff and it
17:00 was sitting there for a couple of months and I hadn't opened either Dutch oven and I had another friend that wrote me and um said he he and his wife had just renovated their kitchen want to get a nice dutch oven what did I think L crus your stove I said well I got a couple of them sitting here I will open these up and send you some pictures so I opened up the stove dark interior and I opened up the lake rusay
17:26 expecting a light interior and got this and you don't see these and what I think happened is that maybe Lake crusade did a special run of Dutch ovin for Costco they were only two colors in one size and with those darker interiors and they did that so that they could sell a bunch of them at a discount through Costco and it was a screaming deal without ticking off all their other Retail Partners the had the traditional
17:59 light uh interior colored uh Lake Cruses so the moral of the story never get married no no no do get married so moral of the story only touch your wife's stuff when she is not looking moral other story is when you buy anything from Costco double check to make sure it's exactly what you want if it's exactly what you want usually the deals are unbeatable absolutely streaming deals but if you're looking
18:30 for in the case of Dutch ovens a wider selection of sizes colors Etc you may have to shop around just a little bit so should you buy a stove or a lake ruset instead of agonizing over the decision the choice that made me the happiest was not one or the other but at least one of each so what do you guys think are you stove people are you Lake Crusade people are you kind of like me
18:58 kind of Kumbaya let's all get together and hug this out and cook something delicious type people let me know in the comments section below make sure you subscribe to the channel thank you for watching we'll see you again next time on Uncle Scott's [Music] kitchen
Summary
- Le Creuset features a lighter interior for visibility, while Staub has a darker interior that may aid in browning and crust formation.
- Both brands perform similarly in cooking, producing delicious results in dishes like soups and stews.
- Weight differences are minimal, with Staub being slightly heavier than Le Creuset.
- Handle and knob designs vary, with Staub offering decorative knobs for personalization.
- Uncle Scott advocates for having both Dutch ovens to avoid indecision and maximize cooking versatility.
- He shares a personal story about acquiring his Le Creuset and the importance of communication in marriage regarding shared kitchen items.
- A buying strategy is suggested, emphasizing patience and opportunism during sales to afford these high-end items.
- The video encourages viewers to embrace both brands for a more enjoyable cooking experience.