Transcript
0:03 is there a lot of technical challenges to go from hydraulic to Electric you know I had been in love with hydraulics and still uh love Hydraulics uh you know it's it's a great technology it's too bad that the somehow the the world out there looks at it like it's oldfashioned or that it's um icky and it's true that you do it is very hard to keep it from having some amount of dripping from time to time uh but if you look at the the
0:30 performance uh you know how strong you can get in a lightweight package and of course we did a huge amount of innovation most of hydraulic uh control that is the valve that controls the flow of oil had been designed in the 50s for airplanes it had been made robust enough safe enough that you could count on it so that humans could fly in airplanes and very little Innovation had happened you know that might not be fair to the
0:59 people who make the value I'm sure that they did innovate but the basic design had stayed the same and there was so much more you could do and so our Engineers designed valves uh the ones that are in uh in Atlas for instance that had new kinds of circuits they sort of did some of the Computing that could get you much more efficient use they were much smaller and lighter so the whole robot could be smaller and lighter
1:24 uh we made a hydraulic power supply that had a bunch of components integrated this tiny package it's about this big you know the size of a football weighs five uh kilograms and it produces 5 kilowatts of power of course it has to have a battery operating but it's got a motor a pump filters heat exchanger to keep it cool some valves all of all in this tiny little package so Hydraulics you know could still have a ways to go
1:54 one of the things that stands out about the robots Boston Dynamics have created is how beautiful the movement is how natural the walking is and running is even flipping is throwing is so maybe you can talk about what what's involved in making it look natural well I think having good Hardware is part of the story and people who think you don't need to innovate Hardware anymore are wrong in my opinion um so I think one of
2:24 the things certainly in the early years for me taking a dynamic approach where you think about what's the evolution of the motion of the thing going to be uh in the future and having a prediction of that that's used at the time that you're giving signals to it as opposed to it all being servoing which is servoing is sort of backward looking it says okay where am I now I'm gonna I'm gonna try and adjust for that but you really need
2:48 to think about what's coming so how far ahead do you do you have to look in time uh it's interesting I think that the number is only a couple of seconds for spot so there's uh limited Horizon uh type approach where you're recalculating assuming what's going to happen in the next a second or second and a half and then you keep iterating you know at the next even though a tenth of a second later you'll say okay let's do that
3:15 again and see what's happening and you're looking at what the obstacles are where the feet are going to be placed how to you know you have to coordinate a lot of things if you have obstacles and you're balancing at the same time and it's that uh limited Horizon type calculation that it's doing a lot of that but if you're doing something like a somersault you're looking out a lot further right if you want to stick the
3:36 landing you have to get the you you have to at the time of launch have uh you know momentum and uhh rotation all those things coordinated so that a landing is Within Reach how hard is it to stick a landing I mean it's very much underated like you once you've in the air you don't have as much control about anything so how hard is it to get that to work you first of all did flips with a Hopping
4:06 robot if you look at the first time we ever made a robot do a somersault it was in a planer robot you know it had a boom uh so it could only it was restricted to the surface of a sphere we call that planer so it could move for and half it could go up and down and it could rotate and so the calculation of what you need to do to get a to stick a landing isn't
4:27 all that complicated you have have to look at you know you have to get time to make the rotation so how hard you jump how high you jump gives you time uh you look at how quickly you can rotate and so you know if you get those two right then when you land you have the feet in the right place and you have to get rid of all that rotational and uh linear momentum but you know that's not too
4:51 hard to figure out and we made you know back in uh about 1985 or six I can't remember we had a simple robot doing somersaults to do it in 3D really the calculation is the same you just have to be balancing in the other degrees of freedom if you're just doing a somersault it's just a a planer thing R Rob was my graduate student and we were at MIT which is when we made you know a
5:14 two-legged robot do a 3D sumers salt for the first time um there we in order to get enough rotation rate you needed to do tucking also uh you know withdraw the legs in order to accelerate it and he did some really fascinating work on on how stabilize more complicated Maneuvers remember he was a gymnast a champion gymnast before he'd come to me so he had he had the physical abilities and he was a you know an engineer so he could
5:41 translate some of that into the math and the algorithms that you need to to do that he knew how humans do it he just had to get robots to do the same unfortunately though when you humans don't really know how they do it yeah right we we're coached we we have ways of learning but do we really understand in a physical in a physics way uh what we're doing probably most gymnasts and athletes don't know so in some way by
6:09 building robots you are in part understanding how humans do like walking most of us walk without considering how we walk really right and how we make it so natural and efficient all those kinds of things that still doesn't walk like a person and it still doesn't walk quite as gracefully as a person even though it's been getting closer and closer the running might be close to a human but the Walking is Still a challenge that's interesting right that running is closer
6:36 to a human it just shows that the more aggressive and kind of the more you leap into the unknown the more natural it is I mean walking is kind of falling always right and something weird about the knee that you can kind of do this folding and unfolding and get it to work out just a human can get it to work out just right there's compliances compliance me spring in the the design that are important to
7:02 how it all works well we used to have a motto at Boston Dynamics in the early days which was you have to run before you can walk uh that's a that's a good motto CU you also had wild cat which was one of the along the way towards spot which is a quadruped that went 19 M an hour right on flat terrain is that the fastest you've ever built oh yeah might be the fastest quadruped in the world I don't
7:27 know for a quadruped probably it was probably the loudest too so we had this little racing go-kart engine on it and we would get people from you know three buildings away uh sending us you know complaining about how loud it
7:58 was
Summary
- Transitioning from hydraulic to electric systems presents significant technical challenges.
- Hydraulics, despite being seen as outdated, offers strong performance in lightweight packages.
- Innovations in hydraulic valve design have improved efficiency and reduced size.
- Achieving natural movement in robots involves advanced hardware and dynamic predictive algorithms.
- Robots must anticipate future movements rather than simply react to current positions.
- The complexity of maneuvers, like somersaults, requires precise calculations of momentum and rotation.
- Walking remains a challenge for robots, while running has become more natural and efficient.
- Boston Dynamics' motto emphasizes the importance of mastering running before walking in robotic development.