transcribe

Independence cannot be pushed. Dr. Gordon Neufeld on Kids and Independence

Neufeld Institute · 1m · transcribed May 2026
More from Neufeld Institute Family and Health
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Transcript

0:01 It's natural to be concerned about independence,  because that's the ultimate agenda of development. But that's what we need to remember: that all  the developmental processes are yearning for a child to become viable as a separate being.  Our job is not to push independence; in fact, independence cannot be pushed. The more we push  it, the more the child is alarmed, and panics, or transfers dependence to another. It's paradoxical.  We need to be able to meet their dependency needs.

0:33 The problem is, is from the 1960s and 70s, a myth  began to be part of the parenting literature; totally ignorant of the developmental process.  And the myth was that you must never do anything for a child that they could, or should,  do for themselves. Because if you did it, you only reinforce dependence, and they would  never become their own persons. In actual fact, the opposite is true, and the research shows  this: that, when we are generous about providing for their dependency needs – in fact, when  we invite dependence, even with the toddlers, invite to carry them, and so on – that they're  preoccupied with walking on their own two feet.

1:13 It's all rather paradoxical. Our job as parents  is to be able to fulfill their attachment needs; their needs for contact, closeness, love,  belonging, significance, to be generous about meeting their needs of dependence. It's  nature's job to shift gears so to speak, in the amygdala – the command centre of the limbic  system – and move them to venture forth to become their own persons. We need not be concerned about  this: if we do our job, nature will do its job.

Summary

The discussion emphasizes the importance of nurturing a child's dependency needs to foster true independence, countering the myth that over-supporting children leads to dependence. It argues that by meeting these needs, parents can help children feel secure enough to explore and develop their autonomy naturally.

- Independence in children develops naturally and cannot be forced.
- Pushing for independence can lead to anxiety and increased dependence on others.
- A myth from the 1960s and 70s suggests parents should not do anything for children that they can do themselves, which is misleading.
- Research indicates that fulfilling a child's dependency needs encourages them to become independent.
- Meeting attachment needs—such as love, closeness, and belonging—is crucial for healthy development.
- Parents should be generous in supporting their child's dependency, which paradoxically fosters independence.
- Nature will guide children towards independence if parents adequately meet their emotional needs.
© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram