Transcript
0:00 - I think of that story of this guy stepping out and having some aha moment, and it just doesn't align with something I've actually heard quite a bit from Silicon Valley folks, people who are more of an engineering mindset. - Right. - And that is a kind of agnostic determinism. A sort of all of human existence is like that little game of life. There's a couple basic rules. - Yeah. - Stephen Wolfram actually believes this literally to be true 'cause I had a conversation with him about it, that no, there's no such thing as free will.
0:34 - Right. - All of reality is a predetermined sort of game of life. Maybe there's a multiverse element to it or maybe there isn't. - Right. Well, maybe a softer version of that when it comes to scientific discovery and invention is a lot of the pushback is how much does any individual matter versus just the zeitgeist and the times? The number one case brought forward is this simultaneous independent invention. One of the most famous examples is Newton and Leibniz discovered the Calculus or not, it's debated.
1:07 But because Newton kept his discovery secret, it lasted like, I think it like a decade or so before. And then Leibniz came out with his, and it was a big fight as to who found it first. But it seems uncanny that people would arrive at something like that at the same time. So, a number of researchers have said, well, oh or Alexander Graham Bell and Elisha, is it Elisha Gray? It's like minutes at the patent office difference.
1:33 - I think with the light bulb there's even more- - Okay yeah. - If you go global- - Different countries- - Yeah. - And so on. So, there does seem to be like how much does the conditions of the time matter? There are these ideas that are just floating in the air. Sometimes you hear this idea, the adjacent possible. And so maybe inventions have to proceed in a deterministic clockwork action. I think it's actually, I don't agree with this story at all.
1:57 - Tell me why. - A couple of reasons. One of them is if you look more closely at some of these supposed cases of simultaneous invention, the amount of time between that is quite a bit. So with Newton, it could be more than a decade. And maybe you say time doesn't matter but I don't know with more existential threats appearing on the horizon with pandemics like COVID, I think we can all agree that every month matters.
2:21 And so I almost think in sports there's this, in baseball they have this statistic known as wins above replacement. So, it's like how do you judge how good a player is on the field? One way to do it is to just compare them to who the average replacement would be. You just call some guy up from the minors and if we had that guy in the field how many more games would we win? Well, if we add John Papola, it looks like we get one, two more games.
2:45 - It goes down dramatically, just on a- - Right. - Technically speaking. - The statistic doesn't exist. But I think for science and invention there should be something similar where it's like wins above replacement. How many years in advance of the next person did you find something? So, Einstein discovered special relativity and general relativity. Some people say Henri Poincaré was close behind maybe by five years. Well, maybe those five years matter. If I have a computer that predicts the weather in three days but it takes four days to arrive at the answer, that's useless.
3:16 We need people pushing as fast as possible to get these things because it may be a matter of life and death. So, that's my first pushback. So, people talk about the adjacent possible. Like it's just something someone will see no matter what. But there's one outlier. I think that is striking to me. And it's in the field of medicine. So, you have Van Leeuwenhoek with the microscope discovers bacteria. He looks at his own sperm. He looks at the plaque on his teeth.
3:41 And so, he basically had everything to understand germs but it isn't until 1865 that the Germ Theory of Diseases discovered meaning. Before then, doctors didn't know what the origins and causes of diseases were. I mean, they didn't know viruses but they certainly did know bacteria. Everything was in place for over a hundred years to understand the causes of some diseases. And yet no one put two and two together. And if you just think of the amount of lives lost in that period of time from sanitation to infection, it's quite tremendous.
4:12 So, I don't believe that we just see every idea. I think there are tons of inventions out there that could have been invented long ago and weren't. Among them could be like the glider or the hot air balloon. There's no reason Romans couldn't have had a hot air balloon. I'm not convinced that things are inevitable 'cause some things could have been invented and weren't.
Summary
- Agnostic determinism suggests that human existence follows predetermined rules, akin to a game of life.
- Historical examples like Newton and Leibniz's calculus discovery illustrate simultaneous invention, raising questions about individual versus collective contributions.
- The concept of "wins above replacement" is proposed to measure the impact of individual inventors based on their timing relative to others.
- The delay in recognizing germ theory despite existing knowledge highlights that not all ideas are inevitably discovered.
- The speakers argue that many inventions could have been realized earlier but were not, indicating that timing and individual effort matter significantly in innovation.