Section Insights
Introduction to the Audible
What is the purpose of the Audible podcast?
The Audible podcast aims to engage college football fans by providing regular content during the season and offseason, encouraging community participation through subscriptions and social media.
- The Audible is a college football podcast released multiple times a week.
- Listeners are encouraged to subscribe and engage with the community.
- Hosts include Stuart Mandel and Bruce Feldman, with Ralph Russo occasionally joining.
Alabama's Performance Analysis
How does Alabama's recent performance impact their rankings?
Alabama's wins are scrutinized as their opponents struggle, raising questions about the validity of their ranking and the overall strength of their schedule.
- Alabama's recent victories are seen as less impressive due to the poor performance of their opponents.
- Criticism arises regarding the college football ranking process and its transparency.
- The discussion highlights the inconsistency in evaluating team performances.
Critique of the College Football Playoff System
What are the issues with the College Football Playoff (CFP) system?
The CFP is criticized for its lack of transparency in metrics and rankings, leading to confusion and frustration among fans and analysts.
- The CFP has been deemed overdue for reform due to its opaque ranking system.
- There is a demand for clearer metrics to justify rankings.
- The reliance on ESPN's rankings adds to the confusion regarding team evaluations.
Dabo Swinney's Coaching Situation
What is the current status of Dabo Swinney's coaching position?
Dabo Swinney faces scrutiny as Clemson's performance declines, prompting discussions about potential changes in leadership.
- Clemson's struggles have led to speculation about Dabo Swinney's future as head coach.
- Historical context is provided regarding coaching changes and their timing.
- The financial implications of firing a coach are discussed in relation to program stability.
Cal Football's Coaching Future
What are the prospects for Cal football's coaching staff?
There is growing sentiment among fans that Cal football may need to make coaching changes to improve the program's performance.
- Fan frustration is evident regarding the current state of Cal football.
- Potential candidates for coaching positions are being considered.
- The outcome of upcoming games could influence decisions about the coaching staff.
Transcript
0:00 Welcome back to the Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine. Three times a week during the season, twice a week during the offseason. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and xaudible show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.
0:35 >> >> Welcome to the audible presented by Trader Joe's. I'm Stuart Mandel, joined as always by Bruce Feldman, my colleague at the Athletic. Our third colleague, Ralph Russo, is once again traveling. He's a very he he's just always somewhere with a suitcase and some residence in somewhere. so he couldn't join us for today's episode. As always, if you enjoy the Audible and you haven't done so yet, please subscribe, especially on YouTube, Audible Show. And you can follow us on Instagram and Twitter as well, Audible Show. We had another set of committee rankings this week that tick everybody off. That's just kind of like how it works. We'll talk about that. But we'll talk about Davos Sweeney who just keeps recycling the hits to the point where it's getting really really embarrassing for him.
1:26 but we had some significant AD news Bruce that could have some significant coaching news as well. Yeah. So, this news broke on Tuesday and that is that Trev Alberts, former Nebraska great pass rusher as well as former Nebraska AD, now the Texas&M AD, he has signed and accepted, as we can report, to become Michigan's new AD. And from our sources, this came together a lot, probably faster than folks on the inside were even hoping it would. Now, where there's real significance here, Stu, is I think almost all Michigan fans are kind of over Kyle Whittingham being the head coach. This has not worked out.
2:07 It seems like it's gotten worse as the year has gone on. the expectation was Michigan might not be able to have a new AD in time to be able to go through a coaching search at the end of this year. Well, now with Trell Alberts there, I think he'd be on the job formally on December 1st. that timetable has changed. As one person really connected at Michigan put it to me. I said Albert's getting the job. That's probably bad really bad news for Kyle Whittingham. And this person was like them hiring any AD was going to be bad news for for Kyle Whittingham. And so, look, Michigan had a coaching search after, you know, around Christmas time last year, and they're going to be in the I don't want to say they're having a you know, they're going to punt on him before they play Michigan, before they play Ohio State. but I would be surprised if they do not make a change there, Stu. It's pretty it's a pretty stunning turnaround of of what what has proven to be a really bad hire at a bad time and it's kind of gone in all sorts of directions. I don't think anybody close to Kyle Whittingham probably would have thought but maybe they would maybe there are some folks who are like yeah this doesn't shock me.
3:23 >> I'm curious just what you think about Trev Alberts in g the Trev Alberts hire in general. this is now going to be his third job in the last, I believe, four years or so. and he seems to always get out ahead of the the the the posi like things, you know, things were going bad at Nebraska. Oh, first of all, remember he like fired Scott he kept brought Scott Frost back. Scott Frost starts off the next season terrible. They could save 15 million.
3:53 >> Brought brought Scott Frost back. He was not the one who hired Scott Frost. No, but he had a decision to make whether to let him go when things were already pretty bleak and so now we'll bring him back next year, see how this goes. I think it was three, four games of the season, they he pulls the plug and he could have waited like two more weeks and saved $15 million. Now, let's go ahead and do it now. And then with this rebuilding football program, this mess, he jumps to &M. He's only been at&m since March of 2024. and obviously last year went great and Mike Elco took him to the playoff. Things have turned south in a bad way. I don't think he was going to be making a decision whether to fire Elco this year, but who knows? Off to the next one at Michigan.
4:36 it's weird. That's the only way to put it. And so, like, what has he done that make you say, "Oh, he's the guy that's going to turn Michigan around." >> I don't know. ADS are hard to evaluate. You know, I go back to the story I did. I don't That was back when I was at SI maybe 10 years ago about who we in the media think are good ads compared to who the ad other ads thinks are think are good ads and a lot of things that are valued in it. Ultimately I feel like they're going to be really graded externally by did this football coach hit or did they bomb, you know, what kind of deal did you give them, right? I mean, you know, did you overpay for somebody that all of a sudden it broke, you know, it kind of broke the athletic department to try to get out from under it? I think those are investments and seeing it, but also obviously development, how much money you can raise. I mean, Michigan is one of the rare places where like money doesn't ever seem to be an issue because of the big money folks. it's obviously the bluest of the blue blood programs. I think the timing of it is really interesting, Sue, in that, you know, you've had Ward Emanuel has hung around. I mean, I think based off of everything with the Chiron Moore scandal that that became untenable. they had a lot of success, but they've had a lot of scandal there. I think what you're looking for in the new AD, in this case, Trev Alberts, is who can bring stability and who has a vision. you know, like I think they wishful thinking was going to be that Kyle Whittingham was gonna be that and it's feels like it's just been the opposite because you know again I think from some of the things we've heard in our reporting is a lot of folks high up at Utah were like no he's checked out this is probably going to go the opposite direction which that's proven to be the case and so you know this first move or first and second move I guess the first move would be making a coaching change and the second is is leading a coaching search. I mean, you know, that's again, it's not a a lock that they're going to make that coaching change, but it feels like that's where things are headed, and that will be a huge move to see who they could get because we don't expect it to be a very hectic year on the coaching carousel. It hasn't to this point, but that could change it right then and there because that could be a domino, you know, a big domino effect having, you know, with a Michigan job coming open potentially.
7:06 We'll see. I mean, that's that's a lot to take on. I mean, he'll he'll be basically like still learning his colleagues names and, you know, getting the key card to the gym and like, oh, let's make a huge coaching change. You know, it's less important than getting the key card to the gym. >> I know, but like less so about whether to fire him and more so about who to hire next cuz a lot of that, as we've seen, has to do with fit. And I think Michigan more than most places is very, you know, the Michigan man trope is dead. it died, but you know, there's still like a kind of a a suspicion cast to outsiders and he has zero like familiarity yet with the Michigan culture. So, I could see it go either way, like, oh, we got him in place just in time. Go fire the guy versus this is too, you know, this I can't do this yet.
7:56 I need to familiarize myself more. >> But then do you just sit there and stay with Kyle Whittingham for another season? >> Like, >> how do you recruit to that? I mean, you can't >> I'm not I'm I mean, I think they probably should or they should convince him to go out on his own. but you got to it's like we always say, right? The easiest part is firing the guy. The hard part is hiring the next guy and and is does he know the the the environment well enough to do that to go ahead and and and be the guy to decide who should be the next head coach of Michigan? Like that's that's my bigger concern than it could be awkward to bring him back for another year. All right. I know you love the Tuesday night ranking show. I know you love Hunter Euro. before I say my piece, I'm going to give you the floor. What What irk you this week? All right, Stu. It's basically been this same story as in the past few weeks and it relates to Alabama.
8:52 I have nothing against the Tide, but they have gotten Teflon essentially. They're sitting there at number three. A week earlier, Indiana falls in the ranking from four to nine because everyone around them, even though when they were off, everyone around them there who they had beaten lost and that affected their resume. And I understand why that is. But here's now what happens with Alabama. And again, my issue with Alabama relative to the rest of the rankings has been for the last couple of weeks from the start of these rankings.
9:27 Why are they so far ahead of Tennessee? Tennessee beat them handily. It wasn't like a one-point game. Tennessee beat them by 16 points. They have this exact same record. Tennessee is not a Sunb Belt or Conference USA team. They're in the SEC. Okay, so fast forward to Tuesday night and here is Alabama's profile and through the prism of Hunter Euro. The teams that they that were their best wins on their resume. Kentucky lost again, this one at home to Florida. You know, the Wildcats are starting to be revealed to be not a anything close to a top 10 team. South Carolina got hammered on the road by a 4 and6 Arkansas team. I get it. They did not have Lenor Sers and some other top players, but they, you know, got drilled. Mississippi State now has lost six games in a row. Whether they have their quarterback or not, this team is far from anything you want on your your resume as a big win. Texas A&M also lost, by the way, to Tennessee. And LSU, as we know, lost again, and this time it was to Texas. And then when Hunter Uric gets asked about it because Alabama beat Vandy and Vandy's the worst team right now in the SEC, this is what he said.
10:47 quote, "We've seen throughout this college football season after a big win like Alabama had at LSU, a team will let down and lose those games." Again, LSU is now 6 and4. They're not even in the top 25, but I continue. Credit to Alabama not playing their best in Nashville and quote finding a way to win end quote. I mean, that that just doesn't hold up. And again, this this goes back to what I always say. This show is stupid. we do not need to have it in November cuz all of a sudden it's like a lot of goalpost gets moved. They put some poor guy out there in front of it who has to defend it and come up and twisting himself and knots and that's what Hunter Euro did again. there's my beef.
11:32 >> I definitely was surprised Alabama State exactly where they were. I thought this would be, you know, the combination of kind of an ugly win at Vanderbilt and and everything you just said about the teams, like maybe this would be a week to move UCLA, at least move UCLA up. but at the at the risk of being trashed for doing anything that sounds defending the committee, you know, Alabama is the poster for what I wrote a column about on Wednesday, which is this committee is leaning into schedule strength metrics more than any I've seen. and and Hunter Urchek citing specific numbers, which by the way, they don't publish those ratings. So, when you say, "Oh, this team is 54th in schedule." We just kind of have to take your word for it, but they do, you know, they're very similar to the ones that are published like Sagarin and and FBI and whatnot.
12:21 and so he said on the show, he said specifically, "Well, Alabama's number is still in the top five in schedule strength and strength of record." And so while I think Alabama's a little too high, I would rather have him defend it that way and and he used it later. He used numbers for the Ohio State, Oregon, Iowa thing. I mean, don't Isn't this what we wanted for the committee to finally reward teams for playing tough schedules rather than, well, UCLA's undefeated, so UCLA has to go this high, right? UCLA has played one team all season in the top 25 on Sagron. I believe Texas has played seven. I don't have Alabama's exact number, but it's definitely more than one. So, you know, all those years where people were saying, "What's the eye test?" Like, that's ridiculous. You're mentioning the eye test. You're mentioning body clocks.
13:12 You're mentioning everything other than who have you played and who have you beaten. Now they're doing it and it's not being wellreceived because guess all who you know first of all I mean it's benefiting the SEC because all those metrics out there say the SEC is just playing the top of schedules and it's specifically benefiting Alabama the one team that seems to be teflon every year no matter what. And I think they're really good but I don't know that they're the number three team in the country. And I do agree that they've got to I said last week the Alabama Tennessee thing will work itself out at some point. They will jump ahead of them, but it's going to be awkward cuz they're waiting so long to do it. My biggest issue is the separation between them and Tennessee. It's feels really fake. They should not be that far apart. You're just doing it because you know you don't you can't justify it. I mean I I have a broken record on this. Headtohead when the teams are similar has to matter.
14:12 that game wasn't close. You can't just throw it out. And they are at this point. And you can say it's gonna you can say it's going to work itself out, but that's like saying you're there's a blind faith in it, >> right? >> So, let's correct it in real time. You know, >> does that mean you would like them to move Tennessee up from number nine to number three? Do you want Alabama to fall back? And if they do, >> like I'll just say, all right, Tennessee, you want Tennessee ahead? Do you think, put Alabama for a second, do you think Tennessee should be ahead of Indiana?
14:45 >> do I think Tennessee? I don't know about that. >> What about Miami? >> No, but I think Alabama should be further down. That's my my beef with it. >> Okay. So, you want to move Alabama below UCLA? >> Yes, I do. >> What about Texas? >> yeah, they beat Ohio State. they have better wins >> because if you're going to do this head-to-head thing, you know, you're going to have to keep Texas out of Tennessee. So, >> and that's fine. I would have Texas, Tennessee, Alabama.
15:20 >> Then where would you have and what I'm saying is to make that happen, you're moving UCLA up from four to three. You're moving Texas, >> which isn't which isn't like an out which isn't like a, you know, hard mental gymnastics there. >> You're moving Texas from 5 to 4. Are you moving Notre Dame higher or is that where Alabama lands? >> I would put Notre Dame above those teams. They beat Miami. M, you know, even without Malachi Tony, that's a very good win.
15:47 >> Okay. So now Alabama's going to be >> So what's the win you are most excited about? If you're in on Alabama's resume, >> they've those wins have definitely deteriorated, right? I mean, a week ago, I would have said the win at L the the convincing win at LSU, but there's now in their top 25 anymore. >> That's my point. That's why you have to move stuff down. You did it with 10. You did it with Indiana. You do not course correct for whatever reason with Alabama.
16:15 >> So, it sounds like what you want to do is drop Alabama all the way to >> seventh, maybe seventh or eighth. >> You want to keep them above? You're keeping them above Notre Dame. Are you keeping them above Miami? >> I'm not keeping them above Notre Dame. >> No, >> no, no, no. Sorry. You're not keeping them above Notre Dame. So, now they're down to at least sixth. Do you Do you want Miami ahead of them?
16:39 >> Maybe. I mean, Miami has one loss. It was at Notre Dame. It was really close. Miami also beat Wake Forest by double digits at Wake Forest. Alabama's down to seventh. And I can't remember what you said. Indiana higher or lower than Alabama? >> I'm to I'm torn on on Indiana cuz it's like they've >> they were big win is USC. >> Yeah. >> I don't know if that's much different than the teams Alabama's beaten. >> It's not. That's the problem. Who has Alabama beaten?
17:12 >> All right. So, you have Indiana 7, Tennessee 8, Alabama 9. >> That would look a lot different for sure. that Alabama, if you did that, Alabama goes from hosting, I'm sorry, from having a buy to going on the road in the first round. >> Look, I mean, the the issue is, and this is my problem with the show that you seem to like love so much. >> I do not love the show. I wish they didn't have it.
17:39 >> They get locked Thank you for clarifying. They get locked into these positions where you're like, "Oh, you're going to drop Alabama so much." No, Alabama didn't need to be that high at that point. It's been >> you don't have enough intel on it. >> And so now what's going to happen is they're going to have to come up with a concocted reason why this is the week Tennessee moves ahead of Alabama. This would be the week to do it. By the way, Alabama's wonderful strength of schedule is going to be dinged because they're playing Chattanooga. Tennessee has a chance to beat LSU, who yes, is six and four, but if they beat six and five.
18:11 >> Yeah. So I think what also ends up happening, Stu, and I didn't want to wasn't going to bring this up, but now we might as well. You know, you watch the show and I see this where, you know, they brought our friend Heather on there who covers, you know, who's covers the CFP probably more than anybody in the media and she's brings something up about whether there's a new metric, whether it's new or not, and whether they're using it more. And this process is so murky that everybody gets twisted in knots because you're giving people a peak into it, but you're really not because it's just not it's like eating a cake that is raw, you know? It's not like it's sitting in the oven. You pull it out. Here, try it. No, this sucks, you know, or whatever. It's like let the cake be baked and then you serve it to people because then all of the food analogies every week.
19:07 >> This is the second straight week you've had a The last one was about steak. >> >> Oh yeah, I didn't even think about that. >> Heather's put in a no-win situation because she has to explain what they did and what they did is always going to benefit the SEC and she's on ESPN. already thinks ESPN's in bed with the SEC, you know, and there's nothing you can do to talk people out of that. >> But they're also looking for explanations. And if you give something that is not to to back myself up, something kind of halfbaked and they're like, well, what does this mean? Then they're they're going to interpret it how they want to. And then Chris Vanini is trying our colleague Chris Vanini is trying to explain it's no, it's this.
19:46 And I think that's why this process is maddening. Well, the CFP is 12 years overdue. They insist on not publishing the metrics that they use. Like they don't use it. It it's, you know, because they don't publish. It's their own like Sports Source Analytics does it. It's their own metrics that were created for them. And because they don't publish it, ESPN uses their own rankings. So, everybody thinks, well, this is the strength of schedule because this is what it says on ESPN. And Chris Manini mentioned him last night on their teleconference. He pressed them about that. Like when are you guys going to release these things? Because now they're citing them. Hunter Uric citing specific numbers like I was 58th or whatever. Nobody can see that. That's ridiculous. Like you want your explanation. There's your explanation.
20:34 Show us the math. And so far they won't do it. We need to take a break and when we come back it's Davo time. And we're back. Okay. As Stu alluded to in the beginning at the top of the show, Davos Sweeney kind of can't help himself. His team is coming off a brutal loss to a reeling Georgia Tech team. They lost 20-6 last week at home, no less. St. Davo's team is 6 and4.
21:06 It's been a long season already. The season's not even over. we've talked about Davo a lot on this show this season, but again, after some comments he made after that game earlier this week. he got you riled up and I think he got a lot of other folks just kind of like shaking their head. So, Stephen, our producer, why don't you play the clip and then we will react to it >> because we built it to last and we've had 18 winning seasons in a row. 18 winning season, not losing. 18 winning seasons in a row and we're going all I can tell you is we're going to have a lot more and we're going we're going in we're going in a new era next year. We and we've won in every era. Everyone DCS final four 12 team. We made it. We're going to be in one out of three of those. That's going to be history. And the 24 starts next year and we'll have a bunch of those too. We've won two national championships in the last 10 years. So we're averaging one every five years. We won one in a 100 years.
22:13 We're averaging one every five years. So by 30 20 31 we're going to win another one. >> Davo I'm going to I decided I'm going to come up with my own elaborate analogy to cuz you you're so good at them. So Davo is a guy who is in a pool and he's drowning and people are saying Dabo you need help. You need help here. Let us help you. And he's saying what are you talking about? I'm an Olympic champion swimmer. I'll be good. I got it. Don't don't worry. like I'll be back. Like it's I don't know if I mean how do you how do you live in such a ridiculous state of denial? Like he never says how like how are you going to get back? Apparently he's going to get back by just reminding everybody about national championships they won almost a decade ago at this point. And so for years, well, not for years, but these last couple years as they've clearly started to get into a bad place, we said, I just can't imagine Clemson firing Davo. Like even when we talked with Ralph, he was down there for a story earlier this season. He's talked to the power brokers and he's told us that they really don't want to fire Davo. They want him to make staff changes, but they really don't want to fire him. And I just feel like this week was a was a new low. I mean, you lost at home by two touchdowns to a two-7 football team. I realized the quarterback got hurt early in the game.
23:35 You still don't lose 20 to6. And and and then he comes in and you're looking for some sort of accountability, some sort of, yeah, we we need to do better. we're going to look at things in the offseason, blah blah blah blah. It's look back at my resume, guys. Like, what are you talking about? Look at the resume. you know, I'm going to win another national championship. Does this make it almost untenable at this point, Bruce? Like, I know it's $57 million, but this guy's never going to change.
24:05 No, I don't think he's going to change. I think the hard part for Clemson is they are, you know, he's two years removed from going 10 and four. Last year they were a seven win team. This year they'll probably be a seven or maybe they'll be six and six, right? do you fire and shove out the door somebody who is so resistant to evolve? We're not even talking about change. We're just talking about evolve, right? Because if your last winner, and we've talked a lot about how slow or totally resistant he was to embracing the portal and what what would that have looked like this year? I'm not talking about go turn around and and be Texas Tech about it or be Miami about it or be LSU, but just go bring in another quarterback who's played somewhere so you have somebody who has real game experience. Go in, try to get a couple more Dlinemen, try to get some more O linemen because clearly that has been a problem for them for the last few years, right? I mean that has has backfired on them. I don't know though Stew if do you just shove him out the door and go you know what seven and five you know those you know he's the last two years he's clearly back the program has backslid. I don't think he's winning a national title or getting close to one in the next 5 years. I'd be shocked if that happened the way things are going.
25:39 But do they completely yank the plug? They're going to have to pay him every cent of $57 million. >> Do they alter that kind of >> The alternative is is you is you let him like take the, you know, lay in the hot tub and just lounge while everything while everyone and the music keeps playing and he's just very casual and you're going seven wins, six wins. They're not going to go two wins cuz they're still have access to talent.
26:07 They're going to they're going to be a average ACC program and maybe one year they'll win nine games. I don't know how you can do I don't if if you if if everybody in power believes that's what's going to happen that there's nobody that's thinking oh he's just you know give him a couple players he's they're you know that they're almost two touchdown underdog at home to Duke this week like this team is not na we're not talking national title we're talking >> no they're a very average team right now they're a very average team >> I think what I don't think you just run and fire but I think you know there's going to be a hard conversation after the season with of this isn't working, Davo. We need better. Here's what we need you to do. And if he says no, then yes, you have to let him go because there's too much at stake. You know, Clemson is one of these schools that >> What do you Sue, what do you what do you think the fixes are? Do you do you do what USC did and say, "Hey, we're going to hire another GM who is going to operate not outside of the head coach, but basically run that side of it and Davo, this is what you're getting. Do you know like at Oklahoma, they probably have a more symbiotic relationship between Jim Naggie and Brent Venibals, but you have an experienced personnel guy who oversees that. And again, even if you have those things, it's not like either one of those programs are competing for national titles, right?
27:35 Like they're fringe top 25 teams now and they're storied programs. I'm just saying it's like like I don't think there's any easy answers to this cuz if if Dabo's buyout was $27 million, that's still a lot of money for Clemson, but it's not. It's more than double that. And we're talking about like this wasn't Brian Kelly. This wasn't like Mike Norll. This is a guy who's going to be a no doubt about it Hall of Fame coach. He is one of the like say what you want, you know, you and I have covered college football for around 30 years. If we were to make a list of who are the five best coaches, head coaches who've been in that in that time, Davos Sweeny's one of those five.
28:20 There's no way around that. and also like Davos said, he didn't have, again, I'm I'm not caping for Davo, although it's about to sound like it when I say this, he he didn't have like the three and N season. You know, occasionally, like even, you know, whether it's Brian Kelly or Whittingham, you know, they have those oneoff years where the bottom drops out. Like he didn't have those. so I don't know what they do though. I think they are stuck with unless Daba wants to leave and it doesn't sound like he wants to leave.
28:53 they're getting they're going to have to ride it out. Just to be clear, there is no fix. Bring in a GM, not bring a GM, doesn't matter. It's a lost cause at this point. the but all I was saying is if you want to avoid the appearance of you know we're just like kicking our our you know hall of fame national championship coach to the curb by see you later you can soften that a little bit by well let's talk about some possible changes let's have a conversation and if that doesn't lead to anything now you're gone for you know longtime Florida AD Jeremy Foley had a had a famous quote this is gosh more than 20 years ago at this point when he fired Ron Zuk, which at the time was, you know, he fired him I think in the middle of his third season, which at the time was like, whoa. Now they now he'd be he would have been gone a year earlier, but it wasn't going well.
29:47 And his famous quote was what should be done eventually must be done immediately. And that's what this is. You're just if you bring them back for another year, you're just delaying the inevitable. And >> what are you saying? What are you saying though? They're going to like if they don't have $57 million, what do you do? There's always money in the banana stand. You Everybody says like, "Oh, we can't possibly afford that." They always find it. And here's why they need to.
30:13 They are one of the ACC schools. Remember, they sued the ACC. They have made it no secret they want out of the ACC as soon as they possibly can to try to get an invite to the Big 10 or SEC. They're not going to get an invite to the Big 10 or SEC if they have a floundering football program. You know, if if this were before, let's let's go back in time to like Clemson of Tommy Bowen era, right? Before Davo, nobody considered that to be one of the most prestigious programs in the country.
30:44 Like that was they were they were Georgia Tech. They were who else was in the ACC at that time. you know, nobody thought of them as a as a national power. And as long as Dabo is the coach, it's going to continue to be that way. So there's a lot more than 50 mill $7 million at stake if the next big wave of realignment comes and you get left behind. That's what's at stake. It's not just well we got to go eight and four instead of six and six. Like there's there's much more at stake there. And I don't know how they're going to do it. I don't know how they're going to massage it. But when you hear him say stuff like that where he's just like off in Looney Tunes land, I'm sorry. It's not going to work. Just one thing to keep in mind before we go to break. Guys in their 50s don't change.
31:31 The guys on this this podcast are in their and we are living proof of that. Although I am starting to dress better. I don't know if you noticed. I'm not showing up to this podcast in my my lettered t-shirts anymore. >> Okay, I'll leave that lie. All right, so after the break, we will get to your questions and see who gets the $24 Trader Joe's gift card. And we are back. It is mailbag time. As always, send your questions to the audible pod@gmail.com.
31:58 And if we like your question the best in a given week, you will get a $24 Trader Joe's gift card. Our first question is from Brian. Gents, it's been a roller coaster of a year for fans of the six teams in the SEC with firstear coaches. By early October, Florida, Kentucky, and Old Miss were all headed to the playoff, and Auburn, and Arkansas were already wondering if they picked the wrong guy. As we're nearing the end of the season, almost everyone is six and four. No one's heading to the playoff. Auburn has the best victory of them all. And it's LSU wondering if they picked the wrong guy. So, everyone loves a good ranking.
32:30 Rank these six programs from whose fans should be most excited for the future to who should be the most despondent. >> did you already make a list? I made a little mental list. >> I made a mental list, too. I like this question a lot because of how he framed it. I'm I'm factoring in how what I thought going in, but also how I feel about this. I would go the first two for me is Kentucky guys. One is John Srell at Florida. Two is Will Stein at John Sol's alma mater, Kentucky. Those to me are the top two. The the ones who have gotten better than I was expecting to be honest. And I don't know if they would I would go number three, Alex Golish at Auburn. As he said, he does have the best win of anybody in the SEC. They went to Georgia and beat the number one team in the country. And they're 6-4.
33:30 You know, whether they beat Alabama or not, Alex Gish did a really good job. USF was struggling and he's brought his uptempo offense, a bunch of his dudes from Tampa with him, and it's been a it's been a promising first year. Then there's Ryan Silverfield. We looked at this and we like this this looks like it is going to be tough sledding, you know, and they just blew out South Carolina. They had a couple wins. I think relative to what you you know, they were wearing paper bags on their heads in September. The guy had been there for like a couple of weeks on the job. So I would put him four.
34:10 and I would put Pete Golding five. And some of this is honestly, you know, I thought of putting Pete Golding higher just because I was going to give him credit for what he did on the job as the head coach in the playoff, but nobody else was in the playoff other than, you know, other than him. Obviously, Summer was at a different school in the playoff. But, I would put Pete Golding five. This has been a really disappointing year where it started to spiral down. That was a bad loss the other day, to Oklahoma. And then it's six at Lane. I don't know how you can't have Lane how you'd have Lane higher than this. They have, you know, almost a $50 million roster. They're paying him over $90 million. you're LSU. You inherited some talent, whether you wanted to acknowledge it or not, from Brian Kelly.
34:56 And you had the number one ranked portal class, and you you've lost every significant game that you've been in. So, that's my list. Lane, you know, and again, I wouldn't be shocked if at some point Lane Kein hasn't playing for for a national title down the road, but this year, no way to slice it. It's been a big disappointment still. >> My list is almost exactly the same. There's only one difference. And but starting with I have summer as well. And I think what he's done there is one of those it's one of those things where when you ride the week toe roller coaster in the season, you know, when you have a couple of those bad losses, everybody jumps off the bandwagon. I actually got tweets and comments from Florida fans ready to fire some after that Oklahoma loss. But if you look at it as a whole, they beat Miss 52 to 38.
35:47 They won at Texas who's now in the top five and last week they won at Kentucky who was ranked 11th at the time. If they beat Vany and Florida State to finish the season, they're 8 and4 given where they were under Napier. That's a big improvement. I would next go with Gouish because or Auburn because of the Georgia win. Like that was a big time win and at a place that hasn't had any big- time wins anytime recently. But Will Stein's right after that and I they're kind of they're very close together. couple of those big Kentucky wins early this season have been devalued especially Texas A&M who was ranked in the top 10 at the time but it's still been obviously a really encouraging season. And then I'm the same from there with Arkansas with Miss with LSU. I am concerned that the Pete Golding thing might have been it was absolutely the right move to make at the time when you're trying to go win a national championship with that team, but it's definitely disturbing how much they've regressed this year and especially trying to add Jambas. it seems like a wasted opportunity with that guy that you're going to miss the playoff.
36:57 But Lane has been a you know, not only has Lane been a bust, but at a place miss is not national championship or bust, right? LSU is and nothing about this first season is giving them any confidence that he's the guy to win a national championship. Doesn't mean they won't have better seasons than this one. but you know, he hasn't won big games. He didn't win big games here. Is this really is this guy for all the hype and the hoopla really going to lead us to a national championship? And if he's not, you know, I hate to say it, but that's going to be a disappointment for them. I think Stu You can look at the rankings in in this prism too. I think it's like what's the messaging come down to? The reason why I've been so bullish on summer roll for a long time. There's a good example of this like the other day they have a game where there's at the end of the game after they win there is footage of him just tearing into his O line coach Phil Troutline who is a former UFO lineman and you know been a you know done a good job with their O line. They're definitely better than they were last year but he is just lighting into them.
38:03 So he gets asked about it and he's at the podium basically talking about at the end of the game when the you know when it's basically kneel down situation what he's seeing from his position what what his lineman he's looking at how the Florida linemen are handling it and he's like I couldn't go out on the field and yell at them so I yelled at their their position coach to basically you know get this figured out and get this you know like we're not going to be doing this the next time kind of thing. And I think that stuff and how you articulate, how you message things and how you are with the details matters way more now than it probably ever did and it always mattered. And I think that's an example of why I I'm a believer that eventually they're going to win a national title and they're going to be a powerhouse.
38:46 And on the other side, when again, it's different to talk you're coming out of a win versus coming out of a loss, but you just come out of like some of the stuff with Lane this week where it sure like it sure felt like they were throwing Levit under the bus and, you know, Levit, you know, like his comments. It just it didn't do much to inspire any confidence coming out of that loss, you know, and again, I'm curious to see how this goes. I I don't think they'll be as bad as they were this year coming coming going forward, but it was definitely a head scratcher given this. I don't think any like I'm not surprised they're not a top five team. I'm surprised that they're battling to not be six and five going into their, you know, final game of the regular season. All right.
39:34 So, this question is from your in your backyard is from Lawrence C. Ross Jr. Lawrence is a quote long-suffering Cal alum who has watched a lot of bad Cal football and some dubious coaches. One memory he brings up is Joe Cap, former Cal quarterback, unzipping his pants at a presser during Lawrence's sophomore year. That comes to mind. Okay, I'm not familiar with that. >> I'm familiar with that story, but now I got to look into it.
40:01 >> I know. but this year and Tosh have taken the cake and I lived through the Tom Homo era. Do you think Cal will fire TSH? And if so, who would you recommend to finally awaken the comeomaos giant that is Cal football and get us where we need to be, which is in the CFP each year? I can only think of two folks, E or Huff. And by Ek and Huff, I think he means Jason E and Charles Huff. Stu, what do you think?
40:28 >> I do think it's heading that way. Now, maybe that changes if they beat Stanford this week. Obviously, that would that would be a very positive development for the fan base, but you know, wrote a lot about this last week when we were looking into frankly rumors. Was it last week or was it two weeks ago? >> It was two weeks ago. >> Okay. I mean, there were rumors flying at the time that he was going to get fired that week, right? So, we looked into that. and no, there wasn't truth to that, but you come across a lot of other really alarming details. I just think the situation is so awkward there.
41:03 Cal has kind of it's almost like they outsmarted themselves. You know what would be a great idea? We'll make Ron Rivera the GM and we'll give him hiring power and firing power over the head coach. So when he goes and hires a completely inexperienced head coach who then hires completely inexperienced coordinators, we're gonna get this really awkward dynamic where Ron Rivera goes on radio show and you know throws Josh under the bus and then they have a joint press conference together the next week that looks like a hostage video.
41:34 Cal by the way this week sent out some tweets with like AI graphics of the axe for the Stanford Cal rivalry and had the wrong scores on it. it's just the place is a mess. And as as unusual as it would be to hire to I'm sorry to fire a coach after his first year, it does sound like that's a a very strong possibility. Again, things can change in a hurry. If you beat Stanford and stop the bleeding, maybe people feel differently, but I mean they've gotten outsc scored like 8,000 to zero in the second half during this losing streak.
42:08 Bruce, I don't have a great answer for who you bring in next. Do you? I don't either. Huff has no connections up into the Bay Area. I would have seen him maybe as a more possible if he was going to move cuz again, Huff's if Huff leaves at the end of this year, that would be the fourth team he would coach in four years. I would have thought maybe Maryland might be a more viable option for him because he's from the state of Maryland. EK would be a really good hire for anybody and EK has, you know, spent a bunch of time on in the western half of the United States and I think he's a great evaluator and I think he is a leader. you know, you look at even the guys he recruited at Idaho. I mean, it's funny. I didn't I didn't think of this until like talking to some coaches about Wake Forest this week. and Wake Forest best defensive player was in his recruiting class at Idaho a couple years ago, you know, and it's just like you take that, you take Andrew Marshall, who's like, you know, Nebraska's best defensive back, was in the same recruiting class for the Idaho Vandals. So, to me, yeah, he would be a I think he would be a home run hire. I don't know if he would want to jump in and go, "Oh, yeah, I'll go work for Ron River and go navigate this mess." Cuz that's what it is. It's been a mess.
43:29 >> I think given that I think you need I think the ideal would be an experienced power four head coach. and so I'll throw one out for you. Jonathan Smith. >> Hey, that's an interesting one. I didn't thought of that. >> It feels like a much better sensible fit than Michigan State was. >> Did you just pull that out of your >> I made it up on the spot. Yeah. I was thinking in my head of power four, who's a experienced power four head coach who would be available and there's a guy who spent, you know, almost all of his career up until recently on the West Coast.
44:01 >> Yeah. a guy who would have made sense for them but but now is doing a really good job someplace else is Brent Brennan, >> you know, but I think he's got it going at Arizona, but he did really good at San Jose State and he's killing it now in at UVA. All right, I'm going to tee you up on the last question, Stu. This question is from Maine. We don't get too many questions from Maine. This is from Chris. he is a West Virginia fan up there and he points out that they are in a serious dilemma this off season cuz they essentially as he puts it has a Heisman contender at quarterback in Michael Hawkins, the Oklahoma transfer who has put up huge numbers in Rich Rod's offense. Chris thinks it may cost them somewhere around $5 million to keep him. Now, West Virginia could probably find that money, he says, to make that happen, but would it come at a significant cost to the rest of the roster? So, he his question is, is it worth resigning Michael Hawkins if it means sacrificing the rest of your team?
44:59 As I've already said, our defense is an absolute shambolic, as he puts it. What's the point of having an allural quarterback if you can't feel the defense that's better than most ma MAC teams? And it seems like this is a dilemma that's only going to become more common, especially for mid-tier P5, P4 programs. I'm all for players getting paid this these days, but it's certainly coming at a cost from a fans perspective. What a terrible situation.
45:25 All right, Sue, what do you think of Chris's question and what would you do if you were Rich Rod's GM? So, West Virginia, in our reporting on NIL budgets this offseason, we have their budget at 18 to 22 million. That's not obviously Ohio State Oregon, but it's the same range we have for Utah, the number two team in the country. it's not that different than it's more than Iowa. It's around the same as let me look here. It's not >> It's not close to Texas Tech and BYU.
46:00 Well, BYU is 20 to 25, so West Virginia is there's a little bit of an overlap there. I'm guessing BYU has more. Anyway, my point is why does it have to be either or, you know? I mean, Devin Dampier is probably making close to or what, you know, I don't think he's making 5 million, but he's making if that's really Utah's whole budget, he's making a good chunk of it. I don't think it has to be either or. I don't think you have to spend a gazillion dollars to have a good defense. You just have to pick the right guys like Utah does, like Wake Forest does. I mean, Wake Forest has an even lower one. Wake Forest is, I believe, 16 to 20. and they have a playoff team or a possible playoff team. You just have to be smart about the guys you find. like Rich Rod and his GM are going to have to go scour the maybe the G6 or other conferences and find guys that fit their system who they don't have to pay an arm and a leg for and you can have a lot of success that way.
47:02 But I do think they need to retain Michael Hawkins. Yeah. >> All right. Stu, who is going to win the $24 Trader Joe's gift card? I know who I'm voting for. Who would you vote for? >> I think it was pretty obvious as soon as you said the words, I love this question. from our SEC coach rankings question. So that was from Brian. >> You in agreement with me? >> Yes. Yes. >> All right, Brian, please send your mailing address to the audible pod atgmail.com and you will receive the $24 Trader Joe's gift card. Stu, interesting slate of games this week. A lot of stuff going on around the sport this week. the coaching carousel heating up and we will be back with you guys on Sunday morning for our live show.
47:51 Hopefully Ralph will be with us. I know he's been traveling a bunch and on assignment. anything else? I >> think he'll be there. >> Okay. that live show as always 11:30 a.m. Eastern, 8:30 a.m. Pacific. My prediction is there's going to be some some chaos or some some upsets because this is the first Saturday, first November Saturday since 2009 with no AP top 25 matchups. So, it's always those weekends where something unexpected happens.
48:22 >> All right, we will see you next time. >>
Summary
- Trev Alberts has been hired as Michigan's new athletic director, potentially signaling a coaching change for Kyle Whittingham.
- The hosts express skepticism about Alabama's high ranking in the committee's standings, questioning their strength of schedule and recent performance.
- Dabo Swinney faces criticism for his team's poor performance and lack of accountability, raising questions about his future at Clemson.
- The discussion includes the financial implications of retaining key players versus improving the overall team, particularly for mid-tier programs like West Virginia.
- The podcast emphasizes the importance of effective coaching and recruiting strategies in navigating the current college football landscape.
- The hosts predict potential chaos in upcoming games, noting the absence of top 25 matchups this weekend.
Questions Answered
What is the purpose of the Audible podcast?
The Audible podcast aims to engage college football fans by providing regular content during the season and offseason, encouraging community participation through subscriptions and social media.
How does Alabama's recent performance impact their rankings?
Alabama's wins are scrutinized as their opponents struggle, raising questions about the validity of their ranking and the overall strength of their schedule.
What are the issues with the College Football Playoff (CFP) system?
The CFP is criticized for its lack of transparency in metrics and rankings, leading to confusion and frustration among fans and analysts.
What is the current status of Dabo Swinney's coaching position?
Dabo Swinney faces scrutiny as Clemson's performance declines, prompting discussions about potential changes in leadership.
What are the prospects for Cal football's coaching staff?
There is growing sentiment among fans that Cal football may need to make coaching changes to improve the program's performance.