transcribe

Elon’s Tesla and SpaceX Merger | A $3.5 Trillion Breakdown

Run the Numbers with CJ Gustafson · 32m · transcribed 4h ago
More from Run the Numbers with CJ Gustafson Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

The Merger Discussion

What are the implications of a potential Tesla and SpaceX merger?

The discussion revolves around whether merging Tesla and SpaceX would create a more valuable conglomerate or if they would be better off as separate entities. The potential merger is highlighted by their combined market valuations and the historical context of conglomerate discounts.

  • Elon Musk aims to create a highly valuable conglomerate.
  • Tesla and SpaceX together could be worth approximately $3.5 trillion.
  • Historical examples show that some companies benefit from separating rather than merging.
# 6:33

The Conglomerate Discount

Why might separating companies be more beneficial than merging them?

The conglomerate discount suggests that companies may be valued higher individually than as a merged entity. The example of Kellogg splitting into two companies illustrates how separating can allow each business to pursue its own growth strategies and be valued on its own merits.

  • The conglomerate discount can hinder growth potential.
  • Kellogg's split allowed for better valuation of its snack and cereal businesses.
  • Separation can enable companies to focus on their specific market dynamics.
# 13:06

Revenue Architecture Challenges

How is the AI economy affecting revenue models?

The AI economy is shifting traditional revenue models away from fixed subscriptions to more flexible pricing structures. Companies need to adapt their financial systems to accommodate these changes, which can impact their market success.

  • Traditional revenue models are becoming outdated in the AI economy.
  • Companies must innovate their pricing strategies to stay competitive.
  • Flexible revenue recognition is crucial for adapting to new market demands.
# 19:39

Value of Common Ownership

What are the potential benefits of merging Tesla and SpaceX?

Merging Tesla and SpaceX could streamline capital allocation and enhance operational efficiency. The combined entity could leverage Elon Musk's vision and resources more effectively, potentially leading to greater innovation and value creation.

  • A merger could improve capital allocation between the two companies.
  • Elon Musk's leadership could drive more cohesive strategic decisions.
  • The combined expertise of both companies could lead to significant advancements.
# 26:12

Shareholder Value Considerations

How would a merger affect shareholder ownership?

In a potential merger, Tesla shareholders would own about 45% of the combined entity, while SpaceX shareholders would hold approximately 55%. This distribution raises questions about the actual value created for shareholders and the complexities involved in the merger process.

  • Shareholder ownership would be split based on current market caps.
  • The merger's value distribution is complicated by existing cross-holdings.
  • Understanding shareholder implications is crucial for merger negotiations.

Transcript

0:00 Should Tesla and SpaceX merge? Elon Musk wants to create the world's most valuable conglomerate at a time when everyone else is getting divorced. Today, we're talking about the potential mega merger, the strategic ration for maybe doing so, and analyzing if these companies would just be better off partnering. Let's dive in. Is this thing on? >> YESTERDAY'S PRICE IS NOT TODAY'S PRICE.

0:33 There's a scene in Ozark where Marty Bird is standing in front of a washing machine teaching his son Jonah how to launder money. He's giving him the 101 on how to move funds between businesses, shapeshifting it through a bunch of transactions, and voila, eventually nobody knows where the hell it came from. When I think about Tesla and SpaceX merging, I picture Elon Musk having a similar conversation with one of his 28 kids, explaining how the Terrafab joint venture works and how this semiconductor factory can receive billions of dollars from multiple companies he controls. On Thursday, Bloomberg reported that Tesla and SpaceX are progressing in merger negotiations with a potential announcement coming as soon as December. SpaceX, which went public just 5 months ago, is trading at a valuation of roughly 1.9 trillion and isn't even through their full lockup journey yet. Tesla, which has been public since 2010, is worth another 1.6 trillion today. Combined, we'd be looking at a 3.5 trillionish company before adding any value the merger itself creates. Now, for decades, some of the world's largest companies have been doing the exact opposite. General Electric, Johnson and Johnson, Kellogg, and eBay all decided at various points that their individual businesses might be worth more to shareholders separately rather than together. Wall Street even has a name for this. It's called the conglomerate discount. It's partly why I think Bloomberg still exists as a private company because how would the market logically separate the media brand from the you never ever ever rip it out Bloomberg terminal software. So, in a world where we've seen more companies divest into separate, more clearly understandable business narratives, Elon Musk is considering putting an electric vehicle manufacturer, a satellite internet provider, a rocket company, a social media company, and a collection of AI businesses under one big roof. So, is this genius or stuffing 10 pounds of into a 5B bag? In my mind, the merger comes down to two questions.

2:27 First, does combining them actually create value? And second, who gets that value? Oh, and I'm gonna do this analysis to the soundtrack of some of my favorite late 90s and early 2000s pop punk songs because I don't have an editor and the caffeine is strong right now. Let's look at the two businesses side by side to the soundtrack of Are You In by Incubis. Let's look at the numbers for the 12 months through September 2026 separately and combined.

2:54 You have Tesla on the left, SpaceX on the right, and then the combined column which shows those market caps I went over. I'm going to subtract out any net cash to get to the current enterprise values today. You can see that the revenue for Tesla is about 104 billion on the last trailing 12 months and for SpaceX about 32 billion. So combined it would be a company of 135 36 billion. And the revenue growth for Tesla in the last quarter was actually flat. For SpaceX, in the last quarter, it was up 161%. A lot of that admittedly from the Cursor acquisition and some of the AI acquisitions they've done. The adjusted IBITa on a trailing 12-month basis for Tesla is positive. It's 14.5 billion.

3:36 And then it's also 14.9 billion for SpaceX after a litany of adjustments. So, they get to 2930 billion in adjusted EBA if you believe all those adjustments. And that would leave them with a margin of about 22%. Which is awesome. The capex investments on a trailing 12-month basis for Tesla have been 15 billion and it's been an astonishing eyewatering 55 billion for SpaceX. So if you add those together, that's 70 billion in combined capex over the last rolling calendar year. Free cash flow from Tesla, a positive 3.3 billion and a very very very negative negative 39.2 billion for SpaceX. So combined they would definitely be underwater. Negative 35 36 billion employees. This is crazy. 135,000 at Tesla, 22,000 at SpaceX. That would be now a city larger I think than Portland, Oregon. 156,000 employees. That's bonkers. Elon likes to fire people though, so you know, asterk there. Revenue per employee of Tesla right now about 770,000 per employee.

4:40 And then for SpaceX, 1.5 million. a balanced 800 900,000 per employee which is really strong. So what's the EV to revenue multiple currently for Tesla? It's just under 15x. For SpaceX, it's just under 58x. The combined would trade at about 25x. Really really strong. And the EV to EBITA multiples, these are these are really high. 105x for Tesla, 124x for SpaceX for a combined multiple over 100x EV to EBIT. I mean, the first thing that jumps out is that Tesla generates more than three times as much revenue as SpaceX, yet SpaceX is worth about 350 billion more. And while Tesla generated positive free cash flow over the last 12 months, SpaceX burned through almost 40 billion largely because of unearly amounts of money that they're pouring into AI infrastructure.

5:30 Now, I recognize that the current revenue and profitability don't capture much of what investors are paying for in either company. They're underwriting what these businesses could become. Both trade at more than 100x EBITA, so neither is being priced, I would say, on what it earns today. And SpaceX's 161% revenue growth last quarter certainly gives investors a lot to salivate over. But I mean, that is consolidated growth with a big chunk coming from its super intelligence segment, including AI, infrastructure contracts, and the cursor acquisition. Starlink's connectivity segment grew a still impressive 69% over the same quarter. But the difference in financial profiles is really staggering.

6:08 SpaceX spent 55 billion on capex over the last 12 months, more than three and a half times Tesla's 15 billion on less than a third of its revenue. So let that sink in. For a Tesla shareholder, the question is whether trading your existing shares for a minority interest in a much larger, considerably more capital intensive company, if there was a thing, is actually a good deal. Particularly when you can already own Tesla without having to fund SpaceX's ambitions of putting data centers in orbit just by going and separately buying the shares from your Robin Hood account. I want to talk about the conglomerate discount to the soundtrack of come out and play, keep them separated by the Offspring. So, is it better to Yeah. You got to keep them separated. This whole Tesla on SpaceX merger reminds me of cereal. Not because I first heard about it while eating one of those organic protein filled Froot Loop substitutes that my mother-in-law bought for my kids, which I can confirm tastes like absolute fruity trash, but because of the company Kellogg. In 2023, Kellogg decided to split itself into two publicly traded companies. Kellanova became the global snacks business, including Pringles, Cheezits, Pop-Tarts, and International Serum. W K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K Kellogg, a way more boring name, got the more mature North American cereal business, which included Frosted Flakes, Froot Loops, and Rice Krispies. Apparently, even Tony the Tiger wasn't enough to keep the family together. But, I mean, to his discredit, I heard he had a gambling problem and drank too much.

7:34 >> Good. There. >> The financial rationale was very straightforward. The snacks business was growing faster and looked a lot more like Hershey, Mandles, and Fredo, which commanded considerably higher caloric valuation multiples than traditional stale ass cereal companies. But with both businesses under one roof, investors weren't giving the faster growing snack portfolio the multiple that management thought it deserved. So, they split them up, allowing each business to be valued on its own merits and pursue its own capital allocation priorities. A more techforward example is eBay and PayPal, which separated in 2015 after spending more than a decade together. There were obvious benefits to owning the payment processor that handled transactions on your marketplace, particularly when eBay was responsible for a meaningful portion of PayPal's payment volume. It was a classic vertical integration argument.

8:21 PayPal also had opportunities to process transactions for other merchants, including some that competed with eBay, which was kind of like frowned upon at the time. The companies eventually determined that they could preserve the commercial benefits of working together through operating agreements without requiring them to share an ownership structure. Investors could own the marketplace, the payments business, or both, while each management team could allocate capital towards the opportunities that made the most sense for its respective business. Which reminds me a ton of SpaceX and Tesla.

8:51 Both companies have very different growth rates, margins, capital requirements, and expectations baked into their valuations. Combining them introduces the possibility that the market applies a more conservative multiple to the entire enterprise, particularly if investors have a difficult time separating the financial performance of its individual businesses. As many valuation experts would tell you, when investors can't clearly understand something, they do not reward it with the larger multiple. They take the floor. So, here's revenue and IBITA by segment. I've got Tesla first, and I break it down by automotive and services, energy generation, and storage. and then it gets to a Tesla total. So the automotive and services was 91 billion. The energy generation and storage was 12.3 billion. Automotive and services grew 2% in the last quarter and then energy generation and storage is actually down 16%. The first segment had about 11 12 billion of IBITa. Second one had about 2 or 3 billion of IBIDA. I had to allocate the cost there a bit and it gets you to a margin of 13% for auto, 22% for energy and a combined margin of 14%. Okay, so 103 billion business 14% margin. Then if you look at SpaceX, they break it into launch connectivity which is Starlink and then super intelligence which is XAIX and cursor. So space is 4.2 2 billion growing at 6% but that's really the enabler you got to remember for the connectivity segment which is Starlink which is the subscription revenue which is super sticky that's growing 69% on a base of 16 billion over the trailing 12 months it has a crazy margin of 10 billion so that's 64% IBITA margins which is incredible the super intelligence group that's an amalgamation of a lot of AI stuff that's about 12 billion in revenue it's growing and eye watering plus 800 100% I can't even read that with a straight face with 5 billion in IBIT. Okay. Wow. 43% margin. So even better than I thought.

10:47 So SpaceX total 32 billion in revenue growing 161% in last quarter and about 15 billion in adjusted IBIDA. So that's 47% margin. If you combine these two companies, like we said, you're going to get to something around 136 billion in revenue on a trailing 12-month basis. That's 27% growth. and then adjusted EBIT of just under 30 billion. But you would expect that to go up a lot based on the synergies of back office and employees that can work on similar stuff. So that 22% EBIT margin I would expect to go up substantially, maybe even double. So this all raises the question that shareholders should ask.

11:24 Why should I be forced to buy SpaceX to get Tesla exposure or vice versa when these companies already partner very very closely? Still in budget season? My condolences. If you're only on V40 of the plan, you're doing better than I ever did. Keep it up. Here's what I'd want in the trenches right now. Something I can hand a question to that already knows the context of my business. Not a chatbot that's never seen my P&L and not a bunch of AI features that are hiding in five side panels that I really don't know what to click. That's what Abom just launched.

11:57 It's called Abra, like Abracadabra. I hope they let me keep that in. And it's one agent for your whole finance team. Ask it something like, "What happens to runway if we push ads spent 25%." Or, "What changes has my marketing leader requested to their 2027 budget?" Abra pulls together your actuals, your models, and your business context, calls in the right agent to model, analyze, or draft the board pack, and comes back with the answer, plus the trade-offs and the next move. That's incredible. And for the control freaks, which is all of us, if we're being honest, and you listen to my podcast, it shows its work.

12:31 Abacom's engine does the math, not the AI. Abracadabra only sees what you're allowed to see, and nothing saves until you approve it. Here's the best part. It's included in Abacom as is. There is no extra charge, no add-on. And I have known Abacam's founder and CEO, Julio Martinez, for more than 3 years. He and his co-founder, Jorge, came out of finance, and this thing shows their work. Most AI makes one person faster. Abra makes your whole team AI native. I could read you a short code to go type in, but honestly, just tell Jorge and Julio CJ sent you. They'll hook you up.

13:04 Remember when pricing was simple? One product, one subscription, one invoice every month. Those days are over. The AI economy is changing how everything gets bought and sold. We're seeing usagebased pricing, hybrid contracts, and something called a credit. The finance systems built for vanilla subscriptions weren't designed for this. This isn't just a Revreck problem anymore because outdated revenue architecture can kill a great pricing idea before it ever reaches the market. RightRerev lets you recognize revenue in whatever shape it comes in.

13:35 Whether you're launching consumption credits or testing entirely new commercial models, RightRerev gives finance the flexibility to support whatever pricing model comes next. So product teams can keep on innovating and finance teams can keep pace. If you're architecting revenue for the AI economy, learn how Wright Rev can help. Visit writerev.com/cj. That's me. That's rightrev.com/cj. A wise man once told me that every startup is really just a loosely functioning disaster. Ain't that the truth? If your startup needs a little extra support, and let's be honest, who doesn't need a little help now and then?

14:11 You're in for a pleasant surprise with Fidelity. Fidelity Private Shares helps early and grow stage companies stay investor ready with cap table, data room, and scenario modeling all in one place. A messy or missing cap table might not just slow you down, it could cost you your next fundraising round. VCs are flooded with pitches, and if your equity is confusing or missing, they'll move on fast. Fidelity Private Shares gives founders the structure and simplicity to focus on what actually matters, building your company. If you stay investor ready, you don't have to get investor ready. Check out fidelityprivateshares.com to learn more. That's fidelityprivateshares.com.

14:48 Would a merger reduce complications to the soundtrack of Stay Together for the Kids, Blink 182? I have to admit, after going through the related party disclosures in SpaceX's S1, I can see why Elon might want to simplify the corporate family tree he's assembled over the years. And I'm not referring to his 28 kids. Rumor is US intelligence forces terrorists to handwrite the related party transaction section of SpaceX's S1 over and over and over again before receiving any food and water rations. Needless to say, Tesla and SpaceX already do a considerate amount of business together. Tesla actually recognized 626 million of revenue from SpaceX in the first nine months of 2026, primarily from selling mega pack energy storage systems. At the end of September, it also had 729 million of receivables from SpaceX and another 648 million of deferred revenue associated with those contracts. Tesla also invested two billion what was originally XAI preferred stock which subsequently became an ownership interest in Space X following the combination of those businesses. It's like a Russian doll.

15:49 That gives Tesla a stake of less than 1% in SpaceX which like sounds small but you have to remember we're talking about a company worth almost 2 trillion. On shared projects like the Terraab chip factory the companies have to work out who contributes what who owns the resulting intellectual property and how future capacity gets divvied up. From a resource allocation standpoint, putting megawwatts and chips to their next best marginal use case is a sticky wicket. And I can imagine those conversations are considerably more annoying when you have multiple boards and shareholder groups to answer to. A merger would remove some of those complications, particularly around approving related party transactions and coordinating shared investments. So what's the case for vertical integration? To the soundtrack of Into Deep by some 41.

16:32 There's a legit argument for combining Tesla and SpaceX if you believe the future of deep tech and AI involves a lot more physical infrastructure than the software we've become accustomed to using. Elon's vision is to own as much of that infrastructure as possible. From the chips that power AI models to the data centers that train them, the satellites that connect everything, and eventually the cars and robots that put those models to work in the physical world. SpaceX brings a Starlink satellite network, the launch capabilities, and plans to put computing infrastructure into orbit. And then Tesla brings energy storage, advanced manufacturing, and two enormous potential applications for AI in autonomous vehicles and humanoid robots, which kind of scare the out of me.

17:12 And then there's Terapab. It's this massive semiconductor manufacturing project that's being developed by Tesla and SpaceX in Texas with the goal of producing their own AI chips rather than relying entirely on suppliers like Nvidia and TSMC. The initial investment is estimated at 16.8 billion with plans for more than 100 million square ft of manufacturing space. So, I had to look this up, but to put that in perspective, that's the equivalent of roughly 3.6 square miles of floor space. SpaceX describes it as what will become the world's largest chip manufacturing facility. Like, oh my goodness. Kind of looks like a Starship, too. The chips would eventually go into everything from Tesla's autonomous vehicles and Optimus robots to SpaceX's satellites and proposed orbital data centers. So, both benefit enormously, and there's a solid economic argument for owning all of this. Every time Tesla buys chips from Nvidia, computing capacity from a third party, or connectivity from outside provider, someone else is making a margin on a product that Tesla needs.

18:12 Bringing more of those capabilities in house gives Elon greater control over supply, pricing, and the pace at which new products can be developed, which is honestly maybe like the most critical element in today's ultra competitive rat race, how fast you can get to market. Of course, you also inherit the cost of building and maintaining all that infrastructure. And I'd argue semiconductor manufacturing is a considerably more expensive hobby than negotiating with Nvidia over purchase orders. Jensen, Jensen, wait, Jensen doesn't work here anymore. Netnet, you're trading supplier dependence, which admittedly does suck, for some pretty enormous capital commitments, which are like also really scary. The other potential benefit is speed. Tesla has spent years figuring out how to manufacture complicated physical products at scale while SpaceX has developed its own expertise in materials engineering high volume satellite production. There's already engineering talent working across the companies that are entangled in these projects that do not cleanly fit on a single W2. If the same engineering teams are developing chips, computing infrastructure, and the devices that consume that computing power, there's a reasonable argument that they can make better decisions together. I buy a lot of the industrial logic behind this. Not that I'm an engineer or anything. I actually had a hard time installing a new bell onto my daughter's Elsa bike yesterday. What I'm less convinced of is how much of it requires a merger. Tesla and SpaceX can already share engineering resources, enter into long-term supply agreements, jointly fund semiconductor development, and purchase products from one another.

19:40 We've seen them do that over and over again. The eBay and PayPal example comes back to mind because there were substantial benefits to having payments integrated into the marketplace, but those benefits didn't vanish when the companies separated. In fact, PayPal's GMBB actually went up. So, how much additional value does common ownership actually create beyond what Elon could accomplish with the companies he already controls? More efficient capital or Elon allocation to the soundtrack of if he's here, who's running hell by four years strong. I think the biggest benefit of combining Tesla and SpaceX is the whole Elon allocation problem. Elon wants to own an absurd amount of the infrastructure required to make physical AI work. And building the factories, the data centers, the rockets, the satellites, and the humanoid robots requires a shitload of capital. But all that concrete and steel is only as good as the people deciding what to build with it. What actually compounds at both companies is the intelligence of a relatively small group of engineers who know how to land a rocket booster, design a chip, or train a self-driving model, which makes capital allocation here a form of human and CEO allocation, too. SpaceX does about 1.46 million of revenue per employee, which is nearly double Tesla's 768,000.

20:53 Granted, Tesla's headcount is mostly factory workers. And under the current structure, each company has to finance its own investments. And while Elon has considerable influence over both companies, he can't simply say like move 10 billion from Tesla's bank account to SpaceX's because he thinks orbital data centers are a better use of that money today. Tesla has its own shareholders, board, and fiduciary obligations. A merger changes that equation considerably. A combined company could fund investments across the portfolio without negotiating a separate transaction every time. If SpaceX has an investment opportunity expected to generate a 25% return, while Tesla's next best project is expected to generate only 10, you'd ideally want to put that money towards SpaceX. And the same logic applies to the people and Elon. And he's shown that he would just move people around whenever it suits him. Actually, after closing that Twitter deal in 2022, he pulled more than 50 Tesla employees, mostly autopilot software engineers, into Twitter to review code. And he later told a Delaware court they had volunteered after hours and weren't quote Tesla assets. That's hilarious. In 2024, internal Nvidia email showed he had redirected 12,000 H100 GPUs reserved for Tesla to Axe, pushing back more than 500 million of Tesla's chip deliveries by months. Tesla shareholders were kind of pissed about that. Under separate companies, every one of those moves turns into a related party question. In a combined company, moving an engineer from autonomy to orbital compute is just a I don't know, just a staffing decision. And the scarcest person in the whole operation is Elon. He has spent years spreading his time between Tesla, SpaceX, XAI, and whatever the hell else he's gotten himself into that week, like the leading branches of the US government. And I'm sure SpaceX investors would prefer he wasn't spending his afternoons arguing with strangers on acts about immigration policy from the toilet. A merger won't give him more hours in the day, but every hour he spends on Terraab, Optimus, or orbital data centers would acrue to the exact same shareholders.

22:50 But here's like what I also disagree with myself on. I'd push back on the assumption that combining the companies automatically leads to better capital allocation because making capital and people easier to move around doesn't actually guarantee they end up in the right place. In fact, one of the benefits of keeping these companies separate is that they're forced to compete for capital in the open market. SpaceX has to convince their own investors or lenders that its next 10 billion of investment is worthwhile rather than relying on cash generated elsewhere in the Musk universe. I've always thought one of the harder parts of capital allocation is deciding what not to fund. Having access to a few trillion dollars of market cap and a seemingly unlimited list of things you could want to build doesn't make that decision any easier, especially when the guy making the decision also happens to be the guy who came up with most of the projects. kind of a circular reference, but that's what AI is, right? It's all a circular loop. I got news for you. The ERP category is finally getting disrupted. And if you haven't heard of reallet yet, please pay attention. It's the AI native ERP built specifically to replace Netswuite, and it's already won over hundreds of finance teams. Their mission is to make the zeroday close a reality, and they're actually doing it.

23:59 We're talking teams closing the books at 1:35 p.m. on the first day of the month. Companies like Windsurf, Merore, and hundreds of others run their entire finance stack on really revenue recognition, close management, multi-entity, native stripe, and Salesforce integrations. Woo! Everything a scaling company needs. They've got 5.0 star 50. Wow. 50 stars on G2. They're backed by A6Z and Sequoia. Heard of them? And CPAled implementations that get you live in 45 days. That is simply unheard of in the ERP space. If your books aren't running as fast as your business, check out. Book a demo at rit.com/cj.

24:37 That is r i l t.com/cj. That's me. You are what your gross margin says you are. Sorry, my kids are tired of hearing me yell that at the kitchen table. Dad, I'm too I don't know what cloud costs are. Well, I do. And cloud infrastructure is the second largest line on most tech P&Ls. And yet, most finance leaders couldn't tell you how it's priced. And as a CFO, I understand there's a nonlinear impact to your company's valuation when you improve your gross margin. And the path of lease resistance is through your AWS or GCP bill. Because like anything you buy, cloud gets cheaper when you buy it in bulk. In fact, you can get the rate down by 20%, 30%, even 60% in some cases. The flip side is getting saddled with a bunch of capacity you never touch. Happened to me once. I think I still got some megawatts in the kitchen cupboard somewhere. That's exactly what cloud capital solves. Cloud Capital underwrites the risk so you can realize the same savings of a deep long-term commitment sands the downside. Oh, and it takes no engineering work. Bingo.

25:41 I've known Edward since back when he was just starting the biz, and it's incredible how much they've saved customers on their cloud bills. That could be you, too. So, head over to cloudcap.co. That's cloudc capital.co and find out how much you could save. When somebody asks, "How is business?" What they're really asking is, "How are your finances?" Because every single decision a company makes is inherently a financial one. I've said it a thousand times. Finance isn't just keeping a tally of what went down. You are not the person piecing together what happened the morning after in the hangover.

26:15 You're the person deciding whether bringing Mike Tyson's Tiger back to the hotel is a good capital allocation decision. Which means your team can't afford to be living in the past, placing a $30 software charge, or slogging through a clothes that drags on for weeks. Remember, there's a tiger in the living room. That's why you need Brex. BR built an intelligent finance platform that combines global corporate cards, expense management, banking, bill pay, and travel into one system with real-time controls. AI handles the grunt work, enforcing spend policy at the point of sale and reconciling continuously so your best people can chase growth instead of chasing paper receipts. Defense handled Terry Tate office linebacker style. So go play offense. Throw the ball deep. Thousands of top companies including Anthropic, Door Dash, and Coinbase already run on Brex. Join them and take back your team's momentum at brex.com/metrics.

27:09 That's brex.com/metrics. Or just tell him CJ saying are we headed for a dysfunctional marriage to the tune of I write sins not tragedies. What a banger by panic at the disco. All right let's assume for a minute that Elon is right and putting Tesla and SpaceX together creates more value than keeping them separate. There's still the question of how much of that value occurs to the shareholders of each business. At today's market caps, Tesla shareholders would own approximately 45% of the combined business with SpaceX shareholders getting the remaining 55%.

27:40 But that assumes a straight combination of market value before accounting for Tesla already owning a small piece of SpaceX. And it's some very simplified back of the napkin math given the litany of cross holdings, related party investments, transaction costs, and other adjustments we'd have to account for. Not to mention whatever premium SpaceX might have to pay to convince Tesla shareholders to give up their stock, which I'm not entirely convinced they should receive in the first place.

28:05 Does Tesla need a premium? Well, I did the math and a 23% premium gets Tesla holders to a 50/50 split with the other side of the transaction. Looking at historical comps here, premiums on public companies, they usually land somewhere between 20% and 40%. So, that wouldn't be absurd. So pay Tesla holders a normal premium and SpaceX shareholders the side doing the buying actually could end up owning less than half of the combined company which is usually how you end up with a merger of equals where nobody gets a premium and the two sides just split the board. Both sides have a good argument. I mean Tesla brings 76% of the combined revenue about half the EBIDA and the only positive free cash flow in the building while SpaceX burned close to 40 billion over the last 12 months. But SpaceX holders would counter that they're bringing the growth 161% last quarter versus a flat growth rate at Tesla at more than three times the margin. 47% adjusted EBIT versus 14%.

29:01 And growth is what the market is paying for today. On that view, 55% looks about right and a premium on top might be generous. So I mocked up who brings what and who gets what. This is a contribution analysis and we split it up. So what each side brings, we went through the revenue before. 76% of the contribution of revenue will come from Tesla, 24 from SpaceX. Adjusted EBIDA, it's almost 50/50. 49% Tesla, 51% SpaceX. Free cash flow, like we said before, Tesla plus 3.3, SpaceX minus 39.

29:35 Net cash 41% from Tesla, 59% from SpaceX. And then the employees about my goodness 86% of the employees would be coming from Tesla. 14% from SpaceX. So the ownership at market caps without a premium, 45 Tesla, 55 SpaceX. But let's go through what the premiums might look like. So I flexed it based on none, 10%, 20% and then 23% because that's the 50/50 break even, 30% and 40%. And what you can see is how much the Tesla owners have, the SpaceX owners have, and therefore the value that is shifted to the Tesla shareholders with each increase in ownership here. So goes up by 82 billion at 10%, 157 billion at 20%. At that 23% break even to make them 50/50 partners, 175 billion in value transfers to the Tesla shareholders and it keeps going up from there. And then on the right, you can see what Elon's value does because he has differing stakes in both of those. For some context, let's say the two companies are worth 3.5 trillion independently and investors believe the merger creates another 1 trillion of value or roughly 29%. The combined company would now be worth 4.5 trillion with the additional value split between the two shareholder groups according to their ownership percentages. At a 4555 split, Tesla shareholders would capture approximately 450 billion of that incremental value.

30:58 SpaceX shareholders would receive the remaining 550 billion. And I'm just splitting that trillion by those percentages. Now, at that size, even the smallest change to that kind of moves a needle. 1% of ownership in a 4.5 trillion company is worth 45 billion. So, that's a lot. I'm also very interested in how Elon's personal ownership factors into all this because he owns roughly 18% of Tesla and about 48% of SpaceX. So, every point of ownership that goes to Tesla holders comes disproportionately out of his pocket. If the combined company is worth the same 3.5 trillion, the two trade for today, Elon stake is worth about 1.2 trillion with no premium and about 1.1 trillion if Tesla holders get 30%. So that's roughly 70 billion of personal incentive to keep the premium small. And so that raises the corporate governance question I would love to see the boards dig into when the same guy controls or heavily influences both sides of the transaction. Who is negotiating against whom? Tesla and SpaceX have already said that they've formed special committees of independent directors to evaluate a potential deal. And Elon said he's too conflicted and probably too busy to be part of those discussions. I wonder how much Tesla and SpaceX shareholders actually care about any of this. They've already bought the ticker Elon, El N, regardless of which corporate entity happens to be attached to it. It's kind of like watching two of your friends who've been in a dysfunctional relationship for years decide to get married and have kids. You can tell them it's a terrible idea, but they've kind of already made up their minds. And given how much of these companies are already sleeping together, I'm not sure a marriage certificate fixes anything.

32:33 It might just make the eventual divorce a hell of a lot more expensive. Stay tuned for the potential merger announcement. We will be covering it all on this channel and at mostly metrics.com. Thanks.

Summary

Elon Musk is exploring a merger between Tesla and SpaceX, aiming to create a massive conglomerate valued at approximately $3.5 trillion. While the merger could streamline operations and enhance capital allocation, it raises questions about whether combining these distinct companies would truly generate value or simply lead to a conglomerate discount, where the market values the combined entity less than the sum of its parts.

- Tesla and SpaceX are reportedly in merger negotiations, with a potential announcement expected soon.
- The combined market cap of Tesla and SpaceX could reach around $3.5 trillion, but both companies have different financial profiles and growth rates.
- Tesla generates significantly more revenue than SpaceX, yet SpaceX has a higher valuation and growth rate, leading to concerns about equity distribution in a merger.
- Historical examples show that conglomerates often face valuation discounts, suggesting that separating distinct business units can sometimes yield better shareholder value.
- The merger could simplify operations and capital allocation, allowing for more efficient resource management across both companies.
- However, there are risks involved with merging, including the potential for increased complexity and governance challenges, particularly regarding Elon Musk's influence over both entities.
- The merger's success hinges on whether it can create additional value beyond what is achievable through existing partnerships between the two companies.
- Shareholder interests may conflict, particularly concerning ownership stakes and the distribution of any newly created value from the merger.

Questions Answered

What are the implications of a potential Tesla and SpaceX merger?

The discussion revolves around whether merging Tesla and SpaceX would create a more valuable conglomerate or if they would be better off as separate entities. The potential merger is highlighted by their combined market valuations and the historical context of conglomerate discounts.

Why might separating companies be more beneficial than merging them?

The conglomerate discount suggests that companies may be valued higher individually than as a merged entity. The example of Kellogg splitting into two companies illustrates how separating can allow each business to pursue its own growth strategies and be valued on its own merits.

How is the AI economy affecting revenue models?

The AI economy is shifting traditional revenue models away from fixed subscriptions to more flexible pricing structures. Companies need to adapt their financial systems to accommodate these changes, which can impact their market success.

What are the potential benefits of merging Tesla and SpaceX?

Merging Tesla and SpaceX could streamline capital allocation and enhance operational efficiency. The combined entity could leverage Elon Musk's vision and resources more effectively, potentially leading to greater innovation and value creation.

How would a merger affect shareholder ownership?

In a potential merger, Tesla shareholders would own about 45% of the combined entity, while SpaceX shareholders would hold approximately 55%. This distribution raises questions about the actual value created for shareholders and the complexities involved in the merger process.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram