transcribe

Should We Be Harsh to Build Resilient Kids? | DR. ISHINNA SADANA | TEDxKharadi

TEDx Talks · 9m · transcribed 22d ago
More from TEDx Talks Family and Health
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

The Debate on Resilience and Harsh Parenting

Do we need to be harsh on our children to make them resilient?

The speaker questions the belief that harsh parenting is necessary for resilience, sharing personal experiences and societal discussions that suggest a gentler approach may be more effective.

  • Resilience can be nurtured without harshness.
  • Gentle parenting may lead to better emotional outcomes.
  • Personal experiences can challenge traditional beliefs about discipline.
# 1:53

Supporting Emotional Growth

How can parents support their children's emotional resilience?

By being present and validating their feelings, parents can help children face challenges without resorting to harsh discipline.

  • Emotional presence is crucial for children's resilience.
  • Facing discomfort together strengthens the parent-child bond.
  • Children can develop resilience through supportive relationships.
# 3:46

The Importance of Facing Challenges

Why is it important for children to face difficult situations?

Children need to experience challenges and consequences to develop responsibility and resilience, which can be achieved through a secure attachment with their parents.

  • Facing difficulties helps children learn problem-solving.
  • Secure attachments promote resilience.
  • Parents should allow children to experience natural consequences.
# 5:40

Consequences of Harsh Parenting

What are the long-term effects of harsh parenting?

Research indicates that harsh parenting leads to emotional and behavioral problems, suggesting that it may do more harm than good in the long run.

  • Harsh parenting can result in conduct and emotional issues.
  • Children learn emotional dysregulation from harsh practices.
  • Long-term consequences of discipline methods must be considered.
# 7:33

Modeling Resilience for Children

How can parents model resilience for their children?

Parents should demonstrate emotional regulation and resilience in their own lives, as children learn more from observation than from instruction.

  • Children learn resilience by observing their parents.
  • Modeling emotional strength is essential for teaching resilience.
  • Kindness and resilience can coexist in parenting.

Transcript

0:08 we all want resilient children don't we we want children to be emotionally strong in when there is some difficulty we want them to face it withstand it recover from it but the question that I want to raise today is do we need to be harsh on our children to make them resilient so that they can face the world so I was sitting at a birday party with a few moms and we were discussing how difficult it is to be calm with our

0:34 children and one of the moms said that which meant I have raised my children by hitting and yelling at them to discipline them and she also said that that is how I was raised and because of which I am emotionally strong today it is because of this gentle parenting that children say that they have depression now tell me truly how many of you you believe to what believe in what she said to certain extent

1:05 anyone and I have to be honest myself sir because these thoughts have found a way in my mind as well in spite of being a parenting expert and a firm believer in calm parenting I have had these thoughts especially when my son entered his first standard one whole month he cried every day before going to school he would complain that the teacher schs a lot there are no toys in the in the class I don't like it over there I could

1:34 see that he was struggling from a playway method of teaching where teachers were loving they were more understanding he was entering a more Traditional School System where teachers were stricter they had to sit at one place they had to follow certain rules and that's the time when I started thinking that oh my God is my son not able to take the scolding of the teacher because I am always soft and calm with him is that the reason he is not able to

2:01 face the world in spite of these thoughts I kept following what I believed in I validated him he would say I don't like it there I would say I know I know it's hard teacher scolds me and I would say that I know but you'll get over it I would listen to him I was emotionally present for him but I was firm about not missing school time passed next year in his second standard I got to know that the

2:28 new teacher is even Victor now this made me nervous how will my son face it now but to my surprise he was completely fine with the teacher he when I asked him how's the teacher does she scho he said yeah but it's okay and that's when I realized that oh my God my son is becoming emotionally strong and resilient he is able to face the world with A New Perspective and I did not need to be

2:54 harsh on him for that you know what I needed to do I needed to be by his side while he faced the world and it was not an easy task I did not talk to the teacher or tell the teacher to be softer with him I did not even consider changing his section I did not let him miss a single day of school I was just by his side while he faced and endured the discomfort and it is not an easy task to

3:25 do because as parents you know we are programmed in a way where we just want to protect our children we want them to be comfortable happy we want to instinctually solve all their problems we would do their homework we would let them win in a game so that they are not feeling upset about it we would give them more screen time because they're crying we would talk to the teachers on their behalf we would give them

3:49 permission to things even if we don't want to but just because they're upset we will do that for them we do not want them to experience difficult emotions we don't want them to be disappointed frustrated we don't want them to be angry and you know what even if we are parents who are following harsh parenting practices we still protect them and do things for them so my point over here is that if we want children to be responsible and

4:16 resilient we need to let them face the world we need to let them face difficult situations they need to make mistakes they need to find solutions to their own problems they need to face consequences we need to hold a safe space and you know why how we can do that by building a strong and secure relationship with them when they know that we are there for them they can face the discomfort with more strength so research says this research says when we

4:46 have secured attachment in our childhood with adults that promotes resiliency a metaanalysis review published in June 2018 by Sage journals reviewed 33 studies and concluded that secure attachment is associated with the presence of resilience and do you know what research says about harsh parenting the Millennium cohort study done with more than 14,000 children published in 2022 concluded that harsh parenting practices like hitting and yelling resulted in conduct problems

5:18 like throwing temper tantrums being hyperactive or showing inattentive behaviors and emotional problems like depression and anxiety another study in published in 2022 in child development exam examined the brain functioning of children who were spanked and children who were not and they found out that spank children exhibited greater brain response which was similar to severe forms of maltreatment that means children who were subjected to

5:49 severe forms of Mal treatment even sexual abuse their brain functioning was similar to children who had gone through these practices can you imagine and these studies are very very important you know know because otherwise harsh parenting seems pretty convincing like sir said it's pretty convincing and not only because we want to raise resilient children there are so many other reasons that it is convincing and to name a few reasons one very important it seems to be working when we are harsh on our

6:19 children how many of you think that it works when we yell at them when we get angry at them they do what they are telling them to do it helps us meet our short-term goal but we all also understand now what are the long-term consequences how that is bringing more harm than good to our children another reason we think that if we'll be calm we'll not show our Authority like that we'll be taken for granted that does not mean that just

6:47 because we are calm we are being lenient with our children we do have rules and regulations for them another reason is that we think that if we will be we will be harsh we will be able to teach our children the right values they'll be able to take us more seriously they'll be taking what we are teaching them but you know what before they learn the right values what they learn they learn emotional disregulation because we showing it to

7:13 them they learn Anger from us and last very important we believe in harsh parenting practices because we were brought up like that and we think that if I am fine then things are fine I should just continue practicing like that but are we really fine did we really turn out fine if I tell parents to be calm with their children they say we can't I can't we can't regulate ourselves with our children why what's happening and another thing is that the

7:43 generation today how many of you believe it's a little different the world is different I think we need to update ourselves do you know what our children actually need if you want them to be resilient they need to see us being resilient how much resilience do we show in our day-to-day lives when something goes against us in our families with our spouses with our children in our workplace how do we respond do we start complaining lashing out losing our

8:14 emotional control or do we face the situation with emotional strength and patience regulate ourselves because children are watching that when things do not go according to my parents when I do not do what my parent is telling me to This Is How They behave now next time when things will not go according to me at school or when my parents will not listen to me this is how I will also behave and that's what they're learning

8:39 from us by watching us not by what we are telling them no matter how so I don't know if harsh parenting practices are making children resilient but they are definitely making children be harsh on themselves and on others and maybe that is the reason the world has become such a harsh place because for children to learn to be kind they need to experience kindness when they are children and trust me being kind and

9:11 being resilient can go together in children and we start when we start raising resilient children with kindness we can actually have a Kinder world thank you

Summary

The discussion centers around the misconception that harsh parenting, such as yelling and hitting, fosters resilience in children. The speaker shares personal experiences and research findings that highlight the importance of supportive parenting in helping children develop emotional strength and resilience without resorting to punitive measures.

- Resilience in children can be nurtured through supportive, calm parenting rather than harsh discipline.
- Personal anecdotes illustrate the speaker's journey in maintaining a calm approach while navigating challenges with their child.
- Research indicates that secure attachment in childhood promotes resilience, while harsh parenting leads to emotional and behavioral problems.
- Harsh parenting practices are often mistakenly believed to yield short-term compliance but can have detrimental long-term effects.
- Children learn emotional regulation by observing their parents; thus, parents must model resilience and emotional strength.
- The belief that harsh methods instill values is flawed; children may instead learn anger and emotional dysregulation.
- A kinder approach to parenting can contribute to a more compassionate world, as children who experience kindness are more likely to exhibit kindness themselves.

Questions Answered

Do we need to be harsh on our children to make them resilient?

The speaker questions the belief that harsh parenting is necessary for resilience, sharing personal experiences and societal discussions that suggest a gentler approach may be more effective.

How can parents support their children's emotional resilience?

By being present and validating their feelings, parents can help children face challenges without resorting to harsh discipline.

Why is it important for children to face difficult situations?

Children need to experience challenges and consequences to develop responsibility and resilience, which can be achieved through a secure attachment with their parents.

What are the long-term effects of harsh parenting?

Research indicates that harsh parenting leads to emotional and behavioral problems, suggesting that it may do more harm than good in the long run.

How can parents model resilience for their children?

Parents should demonstrate emotional regulation and resilience in their own lives, as children learn more from observation than from instruction.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram