Section Insights
The SEC vs. Big Ten Propaganda War
What is the current state of the competition narrative between the SEC and Big Ten?
There is an ongoing rivalry between the SEC and Big Ten regarding the strength of their schedules, with Laura Rutledge highlighting the SEC's struggles in the playoffs due to the tough competition within the league.
- The SEC's internal competition may hinder its playoff success.
- Laura Rutledge's comments sparked discussions about the SEC's performance.
- The narrative around schedule strength is heavily influenced by media representation.
Media Influence in Conference Narratives
How does media representation affect perceptions of the SEC and Big Ten?
The SEC has a more robust media presence, which shapes public perception, while the Big Ten's response to this narrative has been less aggressive.
- The SEC's media strategy is perceived as more effective than the Big Ten's.
- There is a notable difference in how each conference promotes its strengths.
- The Big Ten's recent pushback indicates growing frustration with the SEC's dominance in media narratives.
Performance Metrics in Conference Rivalry
What are the performance metrics that differentiate the SEC and Big Ten in the playoffs?
The Big Ten has outperformed the SEC in playoff metrics, with a better overall record, despite the SEC's claims of superiority based on competition strength.
- The Big Ten has a significant advantage in playoff performance metrics.
- SEC's claims of strength may not be substantiated by playoff results.
- The ongoing debate highlights the importance of actual performance over narrative.
Calls for Humility from the SEC
What should the SEC do in light of its playoff performance?
The SEC should take a step back and allow its performance to speak for itself rather than continuously promoting its strength, especially given its recent playoff results.
- There is a suggestion for the SEC to tone down its self-promotion.
- Winning should be the focus rather than just talking about strength of schedule.
- The Big Ten's approach emphasizes earned respect over hype.
Future Implications of Conference Rivalry
What does the future hold for the SEC and Big Ten rivalry?
The rivalry is expected to intensify, with ongoing debates about strength of schedule and playoff selections, particularly if the SEC continues to promote its narrative without backing it up with results.
- The rivalry will likely lead to more complaints and debates as the season progresses.
- The SEC's propaganda advantage may not translate into playoff success.
- The Big Ten may need to enhance its media strategy to counter the SEC's narrative.
Transcript
0:00 All right, Ralph, we are almost to the end of talking season, the media day circuit, and certainly it's been noticeable over the last couple weeks kind of the war of propaganda between the SEC and the Big 10 over schedule strength. And normally we're used to the commissioners doing it and the coaches certainly, but our good friend Laura Rutledge, podcast former podcast guest at ESPN, boy did she step in it, right? on Pat McAfee show. Now, Laura has been the host of SEC Nation I believe for like a decade, but she is moving on now.
0:36 She's obviously spent a lot of time in the SEC, around the SEC. And here's what she had to say this week about the SEC's recent CFP struggles. >> I think one of the reasons why the SEC maybe has not advanced as far in the playoff as some SEC fans would like to see, is because the competition within the league is so difficult that nine games of craziness week in and week out, little different than other parts other other conferences. I'm not I'm not dissing on the Big 10.
1:04 >> each other. >> Right. And so by the time they get to the end, there's not many left for one, they eliminate each other, but furthermore, they're gassed, they're injured, they have issues. I'm not making excuses, I'm just pointing out facts cuz you were pointing out facts. >> Rutledge, the Florida grad, punctuated that with a Gator chomp. So, I I it's just the SEC has this very big platform media-wise, and it often feels like they have a far more well-structured propaganda machine than the Big 10 does. If you just even watch the SEC network compared to the Big 10 network, like I could just never imagine Dave Revsine doing what she just did. Like just touting the party line in a way that is seems so blatant. By the way, there was no nine game schedules yet. They've been playing on eight game schedules and getting their asses kicked in the playoff.
2:03 >> Right. >> Well, I think the Big Ten officially got tired of it because and I don't remember this happening anytime recently, but Carrie Kenny Tony Petitti's right-hand man chimed in about that on Twitter. >> What did he have to say? >> Yeah, I'll just read the top of the tweet here. The amount of time spent trying to convince you about the grind or that a road game in Williams-Brice, that's where South Carolina plays, automatically means more than a road game in Kinnick, where Iowa plays, is overwhelming and subjective.
2:36 and I do think it's Carrie's acknowledgement that again, the SEC has this bigger propaganda platform and the Big Ten probably needs to step up a little bit into it. >> Yeah, I mean, the SEC, we knew this would happen, right? They're they're preemptively starting the blitz. you know, now that's going to nine game conference schedule, harder than ever, and teams are going to pick up an extra loss, all heading toward December and the selection committee, who by the way watches ESPN and reads articles like they're human beings, get that message out. You know, this is Look, we have said on here like you and I both kind of think like objectively the middle and bottom of the SEC is better, but I don't I don't I don't mean, I don't have a strong lean.
3:22 And but regardless, like the Big Ten with them the ultimate thing the Big Ten has going for it is scoreboard. And I don't just mean the three straight national championships. The discrepancy between the Big Ten and SEC's performances in the CFP since they went to 12 teams is vast. It's crazy. I mean, congratulations SEC on beating a three loss Texas beat three loss, ACC champ Clemson last year.
3:54 And then they beat Arizona State. We'll give them that one. And then, you know, this year Old Miss beat Tulane. And that's about it. Because they they had a lot of games against each other. Whereas the Big Ten is 10 and three in the CFP. So, here's what I would do if I were the SEC. Why don't you just take chill for a year, right? Like let and try to let the results speak for themselves. I mean, if you're so confident how good this league is, maybe just go away for a while from the get off the mics and the whatever.
4:26 And then just go do it. Like go win the national championship. Go you go 10 and three in the CFP. And then you can go back to reminding us all of your crazy gauntlet. But it just comes off right now as so unnecessary. Well, and back in the Big Ten, of course, today, a little bit of retort from Kirk Herbstreit, of course. We don't run a hype machine up here in the Midwest. We believe everything is earned, not given. And when we fall short, we say we fell short. We don't cry a river, whine, and complain. That's why we're the best.
5:05 Punctuation, full stop. Scene. And he gets to do that, by the way. He gets to If anybody gets to cry scoreboard, oh, I was also going to say, it seems odd to be going this way to go go all in on this when you just have five teams in the playoff last year, right? I know Greg Sankey probably thought they wanted they needed they should have had seven. I don't know that's ever going to happen for any conference. So, it's not like there was some injustice with the selection committee this past year.
5:33 Unless you're just, you know, wholeheartedly believe that Texas and Vandy should have been in there, too. But by the way, yes, Texas beat Michigan in their bowl game. Vandy lost to Iowa. And it was not a oh, they are they had a of opt-outs. I think they had one opt-out. It was full strength against full strength and Iowa won. if this is what's going on in August, Ralph, what do we what are we going to what are we going to have to endure in November?
6:00 >> It's going to be a long season of complaining and whining and the strength of schedule wars will continue. I'm not really looking forward to it, Stu, but I do know one thing where the SEC has an advantage. It's in the propaganda. >> Well, they just need to Kurt Zgonina, and you know, he's the head coach of Indiana, he's the GM. Maybe he could also be the Minister of Propaganda for the Big Ten Conference as a whole.
6:28 >>
Summary
- Rutledge suggests that the SEC's internal competition leads to injuries and fatigue, impacting playoff performance.
- The SEC is perceived to have a stronger media presence and propaganda machine compared to the Big Ten.
- The Big Ten's officials have started to push back against SEC narratives, emphasizing the subjectivity of schedule strength claims.
- The SEC's transition to a nine-game conference schedule may lead to more losses, complicating their playoff aspirations.
- The Big Ten has outperformed the SEC in the CFP since the playoff's expansion, boasting a 10-3 record.
- Kirk Herbstreit emphasizes that the Big Ten values earned success over hype, contrasting with the SEC's approach.
- The ongoing debate over conference strength is expected to intensify as the season progresses.
Questions Answered
What is the current state of the competition narrative between the SEC and Big Ten?
There is an ongoing rivalry between the SEC and Big Ten regarding the strength of their schedules, with Laura Rutledge highlighting the SEC's struggles in the playoffs due to the tough competition within the league.
How does media representation affect perceptions of the SEC and Big Ten?
The SEC has a more robust media presence, which shapes public perception, while the Big Ten's response to this narrative has been less aggressive.
What are the performance metrics that differentiate the SEC and Big Ten in the playoffs?
The Big Ten has outperformed the SEC in playoff metrics, with a better overall record, despite the SEC's claims of superiority based on competition strength.
What should the SEC do in light of its playoff performance?
The SEC should take a step back and allow its performance to speak for itself rather than continuously promoting its strength, especially given its recent playoff results.
What does the future hold for the SEC and Big Ten rivalry?
The rivalry is expected to intensify, with ongoing debates about strength of schedule and playoff selections, particularly if the SEC continues to promote its narrative without backing it up with results.