transcribe

The Committee's First Rankings + Why Ohio State & Notre Dame Are in Danger

The Audible · 45m · transcribed 16d ago
More from The Audible
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Introduction to the Audible

What is the Audible and what can listeners expect?

The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week during the offseason. The hosts encourage listeners to subscribe and engage with the community.

  • The Audible is a regular podcast for college football fans.
  • Listeners are encouraged to subscribe for updates.
  • The show aims to build a community around college football.
# 9:06

Analyzing Ohio State's Performance

What are the concerns regarding Ohio State's defense?

The discussion highlights inconsistencies in Ohio State's defense, particularly in their performance against USC compared to their game against Indiana. The hosts question the narrative around Ohio State's strength and the implications of their defensive struggles.

  • Ohio State's defense has shown weaknesses this season.
  • There is skepticism about the team's overall strength.
  • Comparative analysis of performances against different teams is crucial.
# 18:13

TV Ratings Decline in College Football

What is causing the decline in college football TV ratings?

TV ratings for college football have dropped by 6% compared to the previous year, with the Big Ten experiencing a 10% decline. Factors include the performance of major teams and a lack of compelling matchups.

  • Overall TV ratings for college football are declining.
  • The Big Ten is particularly affected by this trend.
  • The quality of matchups and team performances impact viewer interest.
# 27:20

Impact of Team Performance on Viewership

How does team performance affect college football's popularity?

The hosts discuss how the performance of traditionally strong teams, like Clemson and Michigan State, has declined, affecting viewer engagement. They emphasize that the sport isn't dying but faces challenges.

  • Declining performance of key teams can negatively impact viewership.
  • The sport is not dying, but it faces significant challenges.
  • Fan engagement is tied to the success of popular teams.
# 36:26

Coaching Decisions and Their Consequences

What challenges do coaches face when making personnel decisions?

Coaches face immense pressure when making decisions that affect not only their careers but also the lives of their staff and their families. The increasing visibility and financial stakes in college football complicate these decisions.

  • Coaching decisions have significant personal and professional ramifications.
  • The pressure in college football has intensified over the years.
  • Visibility and financial stakes influence coaching behavior and decisions.

Transcript

0:00 Welcome back to the Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine. Three times a week during the season, twice a week during the offseason. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and xaudible show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.

0:31 >> >> Welcome back to the latest edition of the Audible presented by Trader Joe's. I am Bruce Felman joined as always by my colleagues from The Athletic, Ralph Russo and Stu Mandel. Today we are going to get into answering your mailbag questions. We'll also talk about Stu's big story on what the heck happened to this year's TV ratings and why they have dropped so much in college football.

1:03 but first, over Tuesday night, Stu and I came on and had a quick live show reaction on YouTube for the Audible about the first iteration of the College Football Playoff Committee's rankings. Ralph, you were not with us, but we've had some time to digest it. What was your biggest takeaway from these? my biggest takeaway is bullying works. The SEC basically put everybody in a headlock in the off seasonason and said our strength of schedule, you have to respect our strength of schedule.

1:36 It's going to get even harder. You have to we are different from everybody else. And you know, we spent a lot of time during the offseason because the SEC hasn't hasn't even played in the last three championship games. hasn't necessarily played very well in the postseason and thought, "Hey, maybe the SEC won't get the benefit of the doubt like it used to anymore." When we're judging these teams, when it comes to playoff committee time, especially when it really matters, like the people who really matter. Us giving it the benefit of the doubt doesn't really matter.

2:06 The the committee giving it the benefit of doubt matters. And last night, the committee totally gave the SEC every bit benefit of the doubt. the SEC I I you know I I kid around bullied its way into these rankings but the fact of the matter is they do seem like they were listening to the SEC claim we are better we are the best you must respect us you must respect our authority here and here we go with Alabama as the fifth ranked team I don't even think they frankly got the SEC teams right in the right order that's another issue I don't I don't know if they they got the SEC teams right But it was a little surprising just how much difference they gave to the SEC. I do think the SEC has been the best conference this year. All the numbers suggest they have been the best conference, but boy, when you have UCLA sitting there behind multiple two multiple teams with two losses from the SEC and US UCLA sitting there unbeaten, all I'm thinking of is like somewhere Tony Patiti is raging.

3:13 >> Yeah. And it it it really changes my feelings about what how many teams each conference might get, right? I've been thinking all this time, four SEC, three Big 10, probably two Big 12. And you see that how high those SEC teams are. And by the way, now they're going to beat each other and some will move up and some will move down. But like if they all kind of stay in that range, if that conference stays in that range, they're probably going to get five. And then you look at the Big 10 and it's like, well, wait a minute. They're not even that high. They're highest on Indiana.

3:46 They're not that high on UCLA, relatively speaking. And Ohio State guys, when I saw that flip up, both them at number 12 and Notre Dame, which was to me the story of it, at number 11, wow, they're playing elimination games this weekend now. We thought we thought, you know, based on the AP poll and frankly how people have perceived Notre Dame for a while now, cuz they're very they're like number one in Sagarin and number three in they're number 11.

4:14 So if they lose to Miami, they're done. If Ohio State loses to Oregon, >> Do we have a problem with that though? They wouldn't have any good wins. >> I don't have a problem with that. >> I don't have a problem. There's no good wins then. I >> I've been saying it since the BYU game. we're done with, but they're high in the computers or >> what? You have to beat somebody. They don't schedule anybody that good. They have two opponents. One of them they lost to the other one they're going to play at home this weekend. You got to beat that team. If you don't, it's not good enough. Yeah.

4:46 >> Say what you will about Hunter and the the having to twist himself into knots on some. But that one was pretty simple for him. He's like, "Well, they played two teams with a winning record and they lost to the they lost to like they they have one win over a team with a winning record and they played one top 25 team and they lost. So, if they play the second top 25 team and lose, they really they don't have a case. but yeah, it really it it you know, on the one hand, it kind of takes some of the luster off Miami Notre Dame that it's not a top five matchup, it's number one versus number 11, but the stakes are now higher for Notre Dame. Ohio State Oregon kind of felt like when we talked about it during the picks like yeah, you know, this isn't what we thought it was going to be. Well, suddenly it's an elimination game, frankly, for both of them. And the fact that Oregon showed up at number 23 means if they do win and win out and look good doing it, they might have a shot after all.

5:39 >> Yeah, it was the only good news I think from the Big 10's perspective was Oregon landing where it did. >> well, Indiana's Indiana's four are with no good wins, by the way. >> Thoughts about that, Bruce? >> Yeah. Yeah. You go on Indiana there for a second there. I I understand Indiana is still You say they have no good wins. I mean, they've beaten some good they've beaten, I think, a bunch of over somebody asked Hunter Urek to compare Indiana to Notre Dame and there is a significant difference there. like Indiana at least has beaten a bunch of teams that have played that are over 500 and they've beaten a few >> North Texas is one of them. Western Kentucky like he's he's treating that the same as you know >> Northwestern or Minnesota is their best win. Those are those are not ranked teams. They're they're decent teams.

6:28 They're pretty good teams, but they're not ranked teams. >> They're still probably better than what in what Notre Dame is. And and you know, and listen, he even mentioned >> the foot out of bounds. I can't remember it was on TV or on the on the conference call, but he even mentioned the foot out of bounds against Ohio State, which suggests to me he's thinking like, you know, Ohio State was lucky to beat Indiana and so I'm going to give Indiana a little credit that we're going to give Indiana a certain amount of credit for that. Now, >> they basically treated it as an Indiana win because Ohio State is so far behind them.

7:01 >> I think they're looking at it though as they're 0 and one. I think that's weighing on Ohio State more than anything else. And look, there's going to be a chance for Luke Fahhee, but the rest of the Buckeyes seem to go, "Hey, we're going to support the new quarterback. We're going to play our butts up. We're going to play a lot cleaner games." They have the opportunity to do that. It's not late November. It's early November. But again, Indiana, the thing that I thought about a little bit after our show was the committee gave them the benefit of the doubt. They put them at number four with no great wins and no really good wins, but they also could say, "You know what? UDI didn't schedule anybody in the non-conference."

7:36 >> Yeah. you know, like why are we why are we giving you the benefit of the doubt? They're giving them credit for that win that win over, you know, over 500 North Texas. >> Well, I mean, they might be the best team in the American for whatever that's worth. Here's my another one of my issues, too. You mentioned the Ohio State because that that came up a lot, the Ohio State that the head-to-head thing, and you guys mentioned this on the show. Go back into your feed and listen to it. I think it's going to pop up there if it hasn't already on YouTube. on and on YouTube you guys made the point that like the headto-heads were just non-existent.

8:08 We're just not even like well not maybe not completely non-existent but in many cases it was just like yeah we don't care about that stuff. Well, they were very insistent that Alabama be ahead of Kentucky, >> but other than that, >> yeah, even that, but you know, the funny thing is I can almost kind of see that one. but that but the way Tennessee and Alabama have gone that did just didn't make any sense that there was a big disparity there and it really hung them out to dry with the Ohio State Indiana one and that but and I think they could have explained the Ohio State Indiana situation better. They alluded to it had they Hunter your alluded to they're a different team a couple of things but man just come out and say it because a lot of AP voters including myself did the same thing. We looked at Ohio State this week and said you know this Ohio State team might be very different from what the Ohio State team that beat Indiana. So, let me put them aside for a second and let's get a little more information this month over what Ohio State is going forward. And I wish they they just would have said that.

9:19 >> They kind of alluded to it, but I don't know why they wouldn't have just said like we're still gathering information on Ohio State and we're not sure that the Ohio State team that we that lost to USC would have beaten Indiana. But here's the weird thing, Ralph. both in on his TV interview and especially on the teleconference, he talked way more about Ohio State's defense. He almost gave Ohio State a little bit of credit. Well, they got down towards the red zone and then they had to settle for field goals. He talked way more about how bad their defense looked against USC, which it did, but that same defense held Indiana to what was the final score? Like they >> I don't remember, but it was definitely less than 20.

9:58 >> Yeah. You know, so it's like I can understand saying, "Oh, they're a different team because they have a different quarterback, but why to Bruce's point, why are they 0 and1 because of the defense?" >> The only the only thing on that, Stew, if you start looking back, take Ruters out of here. Last week, Minnesota, you know, they held them into the teens in regulation. Michigan, they beat them 13-6. You know, you said what Ohio State was 19 to 15 game. At R at Nebraska, it was a 2017 game. This has not been, as you guys know, a very dangerous offense, even with two first round receivers at at Indiana. So, I think pump the brakes a little bit on I mean, I don't know if the Buckeyes are more like what he was saying or what we saw last week when USC kind of embarrassed their defense.

10:50 >> but but their defense has played a bunch of games this year and mostly been pretty good. Even last week, their defense wasn't that horrendous against USC. I know we were like, "Oh, they were so bad." Look at the numbers. They weren't that terrible against USC. They had a terrible a bunch of penalties. >> They a bunch of big plays and they had a lot of and they had a lot of penalties. But again, if you come out and say the team that we saw last week is not exactly the team that we have seen all season, so we're going to put them here and sort of see how things develop over the next couple of weeks. I think it makes for a more palatable answer.

11:28 That's all I'm saying. >> Yeah. Now that I'm thinking about it, it actually would have helped his cause if he had said and you know, by the way, remember they they choked in the second half against Texas. like that. If you're going to say this is the problem here is the defense, you got to I think you got to allude to more than just last year. >> Can I give you guys a quick reminder? >> This is this is not a guy who probably should be in that position as the chairperson. We saw that last year. Ralph, I don't want to hear contrarian Ralph for a minute. You can circle back. I'm going to be the fact of the matter is no matter who you put in that position, he's talking for an entire week.

12:03 >> I get it. We've never had We have never We now have had enough time. We have had enough time. >> I don't know if he's any worse than anybody else. >> He's the worst one they've had in that position. I'm not saying he's the worst AD they've had. I'm just saying this is not this is a thankless job, >> but we talk about how inarticulate he is at defending and explaining these things. >> All right, Ralph, we're going to disagree. You can disagree. You can drink all you want in Fagville next time. This is I thought Hunter was really bad last season. I didn't really have a problem with him last night. I'm guessing there were some of those decisions that he had he wasn't on board with. but we'll see going forward because one thing that also came up of course Alabama I think if he gave Kaylin Debor truth serum he'd say we're not the number five team in the country. I mean they've had some good wins and that's what they're giving him credit for. Boy, was he really insistent that Mississippi State with Kamario Taylor like they get credit for that. Mississippi State had Kamario Taylor then. Okay. Taylor came into that game banged up by the way.

13:08 >> Yeah, that's I was a little >> I thought it was a little odd that they gave you after the game. He didn't he hasn't really played since then. Well, what I was going to say about Alabama is, you know, is we've been we've been wondering like, okay, is there going to be a three loss team? They're number five. If they lo let's say they lose to LSU this weekend, it's on the road, you know, against a good team and let's say they lose in overtime. They're not going to drop 10 spots.

13:40 >> Yeah. >> They will probably still field next week with the three losses. >> And look what they have left on their schedule. Yeah, they have they have the maybe the easiest remaining after if I remember correctly. It's Vanderbilt SoCon Saturday game and Auburn. >> Wow. >> So they so they might they might have already clinched a playoff spot regardless of what they do against LSU this week. Now the committee as we know they can make it up as they could. They turn around next week and say >> they're number 18. I don't know.

14:10 >> Can I ask you a question here as we brought this up the other night? Tennessee is going to play Kentucky. If Kentucky, you know, is a one loss team, they're in the top 10. If all of a sudden Kentucky, which they beat handily, you know, was whatever they won by four touchdowns in the final score. If Kentucky ends up like number 21 in the final rankings, and then you're really looking at this going, "All right, who have they actually beaten?"

14:32 You're not going to give them a big credit for Texas A&M. You know, it's like their resume as a three loss team. I think there'll be other three loss teams. Now, look, they're going to play LSU if they win this game. completely different conversation, but it just feels like they have been sputtering for the last month. And that's why I was like, man, they're sitting there at five. They're giving them the benefit of the doubt. Maybe they earn it this weekend. If they don't, I think there'll be other SEC 3 loss teams that'll get slotted ahead of them.

14:59 >> It's an interesting point you because you just referenced St. like the committee if you wanted to be conspiracy theorist guy they put Notre Dame and Ohio State in places where they could easily be removed from the conversation right if we don't rank them too high and they lose then we can easily remove them from the conversation but you clearly did not do that with Alabama >> right you just as you said you have now stuck Alabama in a place where you're going to have to drastically punish Alabama for if it loses is to LSU or you're going to have them in at 9 and3 >> and and you know some of this will sort itself out Bruce like I think if Texas wins out they would definitely be a higher 9 and3 team but you know it's frankly the same as Miami Notre Dame last year when he said the thing about well they weren't in the same pod about Alabama Tennessee headtohead well they weren't in the same pod they weren't in the same >> that's the excuse we considered we compared so it didn't come now if you have the same thing as last year and they start close in.

16:04 Good luck. >> What's happening is they're in the same conference with the same record. >> It's not like one's a Sunb Belt team. >> It would be impossible. The one thing I'll say is it would be There's so many of those two loss SEC teams and they all beat somebody who beat somebody else who beat the like it would be pretty much impossible to have it in strict order of headto-head. Right, Ralph? You've been trying to sort that out.

16:25 >> I've been doing it with Yeah. With the APA. >> Yeah. Yeah. And I've been Yeah. you do struggle with it and it is a good argument for hey we can't have headto-head mean any of everything cuz we'll tie ourselves into knots. Here's the last thing I'll say on this. What happened last night with the committee is exactly why Tony Patiti in the Big 10 won a 2014 playoff because they do not trust the selection committee. Not that they think the selection committee is evil or biased or bad or bad faith actors here. They just believe this is an impossible task. It cannot be properly done by 12 people, 13 people in a room looking at a bunch of numbers.

17:07 You'll ne there's not enough connectivity between the conferences to make real sound judgments in who should be where. So if you expand it to 24, the decisions at the bottom are far less impactful and generally speaking, you'll just get everybody. You'll just get everybody and a few extra in. You'll get everybody who deserves to be in and a few extra. And that's how you make the selection committee less impactful, less important. And that's exactly why we're getting 24 teams or that's the that's the impetus of what where 24 came from.

17:41 And that's why we're going to be there next year. And that is classic college football short-sightedness because give me a break. You think people aren't are going to be less mad next year if they see like I I forget who who pointed it out, but like if you take the rankings from last night and turn it into a 2014 playoff, SEC would have nine of their 16 teams in, people are going to be like, " that's fine." You know, they're No, people are going to be mad about that.

18:09 They're going to be mad that in this case, like number five Alabama's getting a buy, but number 13 Tennessee has to go on the road to play. these decisions will still >> you won't eliminate the MAD, but you will get all the teams in that need to be in. I I don't think they'll look at it. I think they'll very quickly readjust to I can't believe our number our eight our nine and three team is not going to the playoff, but that 8 and4 Arkansas team that didn't beat anybody is like this is it just moves the goalposts. But you know, we everybody knows how I feel about it. All right, on that note, we are going to take a quick break on the other side. We will get some mailbag, but we'll also dig into Stu's story about what is up with the plummeting TV ratings this season.

19:00 And we're back. Okay, as I said, Stu had an interesting story on The Athletic earlier in this week. It is about the TV ratings of for the first basically half of the season and they are troubling. At least they look like they're troubling. Ste, why don't you for the people who haven't read it, give us the gist of it and what they should know. >> Yeah. And it started with I mean I feel like the last couple years every week it was there was some press release about this is a record and that is a record and anecdotally I kind of noticed that had stopped and also like I'm the guy who tweets out every week here's the most watched games and they seemed a little softer. So, let's actually look at the data and what it says. And sure enough, across, and this is through week eight, by the way, I didn't have week nine yet when I did this, across ABC, NBC, CBS, Fox, and ESPN, down 6% from the same period in 2025.

19:55 The SEC games still doing very well. The top 10 games still doing very well. but the Big 10 games are down 10%. The Big 12 is up. Congratulations to them. the ACC plummeted 44.5%. Now there is a extenduating circumstance there in that their big early non-conference games that were home games last year flipped to away games this year. And then I also have some data about you know which types of games for instance top 10 games are still very high or they went up they went up another 6.4%.

20:30 Everything below that, top 10 versus 11 to 25, 11 to 25 versus are all down by at least double digits. So, doesn't mean the sport is dying necessarily, although a lot of my commenters took it as an excuse to to rant about that. But I do think it's a bit concerning because for several reasons, and one of them is Neielson changed their the way they do their ratings last year and it had a and it had a a lift for everything for all live sports. And last year, college football's growth went even beyond that, right? Great news for them. They made another change before this year that also bumped the kind of the baseline by about 3%. And yet they're down 6%. So it's more it's almost like they're down 9%. Which is pretty significant. Is it significant? And I guess that's what I'm trying to get my head around. Like I it feels almost like a a recalibration.

21:28 It's interesting. It's it's without question interesting. Like I I'm not I'm not saying that this isn't something that we should be in like kind of looking at and going hm wonder what's going on there. But but I think you were teasing out some of the possible symptoms here of this sickness and is it just the early season games weren't wonderful and things along those lines. But I also wonder if are we re-calibrating, you know, reccalibrating in the terms of the way Neielson is is is rating these games, right? There was a there was a bump last year. Are we are we setting a new normal? Maybe last year was a bit of an outlier for whatever reason that everything was a little inflated and maybe next year we'll see no, this is what sort of the the new standard is.

22:15 That's why I guess I don't find myself like pressing a panic button here because I just wonder if we're setting a new a new standard for where the ratings will be going forward. You know what it reminds me of, Stu? Remember the first CFP, the first four team CFP? The ratings were bananas. Just outrageous for Ohio State, Alabama, Oregon, Florida State, and then the Oregon Ohio State championship game. And I think it was just new and everybody for years it was like well they're they're not as good as they used to be. They're not as good as they used to be. And it was like well maybe that was an outlier and now we have a new and after a few years now we know what where the water level is on this. And I guess that's what I'm wondering is if we're just trying to find a new water level on the ratings too. Yeah. I mean it could it could be totally a one-off like we could be right back up next year.

23:12 it has been going up almost every year though since 2020. but to your point, Ralph, like I threw out a couple. First of all, the non-conference thing was definitely a huge factor. I mean, it just wasn't as good a slate this year. Non-conference rankings are down or non-conference games are were down 9%. So, well above the 6%. but yeah, I mean also throughout the idea that like the novelty of the 12 team playoff has worn off, right? The first year it kind of everybody was really energized by that. It was also the first year of the new conferences and oh look at that USC is playing Michigan. That's cool.

23:48 Oregon's playing Ohio State. Now that's normalized. So there could be some of that wearing off as well. >> Ste, can I ask you a question? I saw this come up from Bud Elliott our our friend from CBS and he had said in in short, you know, why why was the demarcation like week eight when week 10, this is by far the biggest week of the season? There's matchups all over the place. You would think this was to be a huge weekend for the TV ratings.

24:20 explain why you picked when you picked it knowing that we all were pointing at this November 7th weekend for a while, but also on top of it, do you think that would make a big difference if the ratings are, you know, significantly up? Would that tip it from 6% to maybe a flat line? I mean, I I don't know your m I don't know the math. I don't say your math, but explain that, please. >> I mean, it's going to be a it's going to be a huge weekend for TV ratings.

24:47 There's no qu I think Miami Notre Dame could be the most watched game of the year. You LSU Alabama will do very well, etc. >> And the Miami Notre Dame game obviously was the opener last season. It was unable. >> That's Yes. you know, I I I this the simple answer is week eight is around halfway and I did the work last week for the most part and we you know there was some thought should we wait a week should we wait a week to get last weekend's results? but no, I thought it was worth doing because of kind of that that landmark in the season. to your to your point, Bruce, I don't know the answer to that because I don't have handy or would know what was because we're if you say you waited till the end of next week and now you have 10 weeks.

25:28 You're going to compare that to you're also going to have two more weeks of data from last season to compare that to. So, I don't I mean it will be I am sure that number will that gap will close a little bit after this weekend. I don't think it would erase the whole thing because >> somebody will do a story about it if you somebody will do that story if you don't. By by the way, >> the updated story.

25:48 >> Yes, >> I'll I'll do a sequel if need be. >> Well, just real quick. So, did you through Twitter or other methods have because you you talk to people in the TV industry, some of the same people I talked to. Did you get any feedback from people at the networks or you know just sort of work in the industry saying whoa whoa whoa >> yes but a little bit of that but mostly there was just kind of like well that's the data like we can't really spin it that's the data there is a stat that Michael Moill at Fox loves to throw out about minutes watched and the minutes watched are about the same I think but there's actually I was a little there were a lot of things I was surprised to find out on kind of the nuts and bolts of this. One of the things that surprised me initially when I had the data for all of the networks is that there were 40 more games than there were last year on national television and a lot of that is the Pack 12 deal that wasn't, you know, like now they have USA and CW and all that. And so that's frankly why I ended up focusing on just the top five. It's like how do you compare when there's 40 games that didn't exist last year? So, but that's a long way of saying like that minutes watch thing might just simply be because there's more games on television.

27:02 there's more there's more games to watch. no, people weren't really trying to spin it. The non-conference thing was the main thing people brought up like, well, of course, the ratings were down in September. We didn't have all these marquee games we had last year. And by the way, some of that is just bad luck, right? LSU Clemson was a 10 million game last year to start the season cuz they were both top 10 teams. A year later, Clemson stinks and it's 51 to10 and it doesn't do nearly that much.

27:29 But it's also, you know, what we've talked about for a while, the national champs. Think about if Indiana had opened the season with somebody good. Like that that would have been a huge game, but they didn't play anybody. USC dropped Notre Dame. Penn State didn't play anybody. and also, by the way, some of the biggest TV brands in the sport >> aren't very good this year. >> Michigan State for the most part. >> Yeah, exactly. >> So, that has an effect as well.

27:55 >> Interesting stuff. But the sport is not dying. Are you sure the sport's not dying? >> I don't think it's dying yet, but if you go on the comments of that story, you will get Well, one thing was like the single biggest thing was because of all the commercials. There's too many commercials. I don't want to sit through the commercials. Seth Emerson and I actually did a kind of a a data driven one on that a couple years ago. There actually aren't more commercials, but it might feel that way because the games are shorter.

28:19 >> So, because we're in a political season and there's nothing about political hats. >> Awful. Awful. But not anymore. But, you know, I also got the NIL portal, all that stuff as well. >> Oh, speaking of political season, should I should I should we do our election coverage? >> Just get it out. Yeah, just get it out. >> Cuz you don't have to be like John King or Steve Cornaki to give this to give this little bit of political analysis. The Protect College Sports Act, what happened in the midterms, not good. Not good for the Protect College Sports Act. can it still pass through a lame duck session? Sure. Like I I think I will do we we we we've already heard from people Stu and I who've said yeah maybe but the way the House flipped and the way the Senate flipped high made it a lot harder for that bill to pass. So just want to get squeeze that in there. And that concludes the Audible's election coverage. All right, guys. On the way back, we will take your questions from the mailbag.

29:24 And we're back. as always, send your questions to the audible pod@gmail.com for your opportunity to win the $24 Trader Joe's gift card. I'm going to start with Ralph for this one. This is from Sam Quint. You three were talking pretty casually about quote the next wave end quote of realignment. Is there something that I've missed? there's always the spectre of more changes, but the vibe on the pod was that more movement is absolutely happening and we're just waiting for the announcements.

29:58 Not quite. Not quite, Sam. You can you can relax. There definitely nothing imminent. I think there is an accepted conventional wisdom that while we might have a couple of years of peace here within conference realignment, there will be I don't even want to use a word realignment, there's the possibility of a of a reorganization of college football where whether it is a super league, whether it is the SEC and the Big 10 adding teams, or maybe there will be some stability. You know, the president of the University of Miami talked about maybe going independent.

30:40 There's obviously a lot of tension within the ACC that's come out through the process of the Protect College Sports Act that's tried to tamp down on some of the conference movement. But I think it's it would be naive to think that there will not be another iteration of college football in 10 years with let's just say within 10 years. Maybe there's more movement within the 10-year period. Again, a lot of people in the ACC are sort of focused on 2030 as to what will happen around that. There's a Big 12 TV deal coming up around then. I think the Big 10's is 2031 or so. So around TV deals, there's always a little bit of anxiety about more movement. What I would also say though, Sam, is it's really hard to predict right now. And it is cuz we don't know if it will be traditional realignment where teams just jump conferences or something that looks very different. Again, looking a little bit more like a super league where schools kind of look at themselves on their own and say, "We have a lot of value. maybe we should align ourselves with schools that are just like us regardless of the conference. And I don't want to get anybody panicked here as to what is coming. But I think the part of the part of what is interesting about this is it's kind of hard to tell what might be coming and and whether a bill gets passed and and and things along those lines could impact it. But no, no, no, don't worry. We're not going to have a massive realignment announcement in the next couple of days.

32:14 But I think it's just accepted that there will be more shuffling within the next 5 to 10 years. And it is it it's like the last big blow up happened in large part cuz the Big 10, the Big 12, the pack, like all those TV deals, the CFP all came up within a couple years of each other. There's going to be another convergence like that in the early 2030s. But when it but last time the the movement started like two years before that, right? So could we see something later this decade? Yes. But to your point, Ralph, like I have no idea what that's going to look like.

32:53 >> I would just be surprised I what I don't think it'll be, but what Florida State and Miami think maybe it'll be is okay, now the Big 10's going from 18 to 20 and the SEC is going from 16 to 18. If if it's going to happen, it's going to be non-traditional. It might be outside the traditional conference structure. It might be the Big 10 and SEC say, "Bye-bye, guys. We're off doing our own thing." Like, I mean, this model that we've had for our whole lives is could not be on more shaky ground. I mean, you have how much longer can you like keep throwing together schools that are on completely opposite sides of the country? Now you're getting rid of the conference championship game, which is one of the biggest reasons to have a conference in football. It's I mean I think it's on its last legs, but I but that doesn't mean to your point like stay tuned because there's going to be a big announcement next week.

33:51 >> Yeah, the non-traditional was a great word you used there. I think whatever's coming next could be non-traditional. Okay. >> All right. We'll go to Brandon in Austin, Texas. This one has Bruce's name written all over it. he has a fundamental question. Does being a college football coach make you crazy over time? Lincoln Riley's strange end to the conference season is just the latest example. Coaches make odd statements to the media, pick fights with reporters, and do plenty of other headscratching things. Every one of them also has a philosophy of trust the process, row the boat, do your job. But if you look across those philosophies, you find a lot of cliches and frankly a fair amount of hypocrisy. Maybe the stress would make any of us a little crazy. So here's my question. Is the pressure of these jobs so intense that any normal person would eventually crack or are these coaches a little bit off before they take the job?

34:42 >> Yeah, I think the pressure makes most of these guys changes them in some way. Lincoln Riley is a good example. Like I I've known Lincoln Riley since he was a college student on Mike Leech's staff at Texas Tech and knew him when he was at East Carolina. and I you can tell the pressure has definitely changed him and affected him. and I get that. And I think he's not alone. I think he might be more of an extreme example of it. cuz I think what ends up happening is you start insulating yourself and you hear all all the all the chatter. And as much as you want to say you're blocking out the noise, you don't care what happens outside the walls. You know, we talked about this a couple of weeks ago with like McAfee and I, you know, I even, you know, I said also, I get the thin skin part. I have it, you know, like a lot of us, not just some of us, a lot of us are wired that way. We're vulnerable in that way. And there was a comment that Matt Rule made the other day at his press conference talking about, you know, an adult, you know, basically yelling at his 13-year-old daughter. you know that you know you hear those things and it definitely hits home because that's not the most that's not a a big part of the Nebraska fan base, but there's enough crazy or delusional out there that can make people want to put up walls. I think of a lot of guys who, you know, just from knowing coaches when they were assistants and seeing them go up the ranks and seeing how it affects them and maybe how it doesn't. for the most part I think it ends up where you know now all of a sudden there's a lot more money involved and there all of a sudden now it's like there's not just the players but there is dozens of coaches families that are affected by it and sometimes you have to and I think of going back to Lincoln Riley he ended up firing Benny Wy who was a longtime strength coach he knows that family in you know intimately and it's a you It's a those are hard decisions that coaches have to make.

36:50 where you're firing not just a friend, but you're firing, you know, you're basically making a big life change to those families. and I think that is why it's so much harder now than it was 10, 15 years ago. The money's gotten way bigger, the pressure's gotten way bigger, the visibility has gotten way bigger because of social media. There's all this other stuff that comes with it. I'm not making excuses for him, but I think it brings out a lot of a lot of probably not the most attractive qualities in some coaches when they get put under pressure. I mean, just thinking aloud, Ralph, like there's a handful of guys I would say, "All right, Patton Ardusi seems to be the Patton Arduzi I knew back when he was at Michigan State, you know, like and there's a handful of guys who were like, "Yeah, that's still him, you know, but like I knew Kevin Sland before he was the hottest thing at Texas A&M and I also knew a lot of the a lot of the external things that he was dealing with and all of a sudden those things be it can be really combustible and then they don't end up being the best they are."

37:54 And so I think we all know coaches who probably feel like they changed a lot with the money and with the expectations and but we all know probably a couple of guys who probably haven't or at least they seem like they haven't. Like you know I always think that there's you have to be wired differently to want that job and to attain that job such a high-profile job. So I think it so to to the emailer's point, it does attract a a personality that might be we talk about this all the time. I use the word I I don't like to use the word crazy.

38:28 Are they crazy? But like how many coaches just you often feel like can you just be like a regular guy like like can and and we all talk about like Kaylin Dbor has got a lot of regular guy in him. >> Pete Lemo got a lot of regular guy. >> Yeah. like who has the most regular guy? >> Yeah, >> Mark Helfridge. >> Mark Hell has a lot of regular guy, but but you lose. So I don't know if there is a lot of regular guys who get attracted to that. I think you you I think if you you have to be wired a certain way to want that scrutiny and and that and then when you get in the cauldron, how could you not? You're just there's so much attention on you. so much of your life is lived publicly, your warts or your oddities are going to be exposed. So, I think it's a combination of your it it's a business that attracts people who are maybe wired a little differently and then it enhances that part of their p those parts of their personality. I mean, I think actually Brandon hit the nail on the head when he said, "Are they just a little bit off?" And I would say a lot most of them are a lot off.

39:38 It's just And you know, and you know, a great contrast, and Ralph, you've covered a lot of basketball, Bruce. You used to college basketball coaches for the most part, are fairly normal. They're they're >> so much more chill. >> They know, they're chill. They know what's going on in the rest of the world. They have outside interests. football co I mean, what was it, Nick? We mentioned this, I think, recently, like Nick Sabin, the year he said he didn't know it was election day.

40:04 you've got all these coaches who are I haven't watched a movie since 1983. and just the fact that they, and this starts well before they become a head coach, but the normalization of, well, my wife and kids are living 800 miles away cuz I had to take this job, right? Like, >> there's a lot of that football. >> Yeah. Yeah. Such a Let me just explain that super quick. Like a lot of times guys will get a job and because they move around so much, especially with assistant coaches, their family might not move with them. The family might stay behind because they don't want to pull their kid out of high school or something like that. So yeah, there's a lot of examples of like coaches living away from their families, which is not the like that's a little weird, right?

40:50 >> Or they or they do live with their families, but like I haven't made it to one of my son's high school baseball games since in 3 years. like just the normalization of this job and by the way that is a big thing that comes up in the saving doc right Terry and and talking about like it was just a given like we're not going to see him during football season >> and it's like >> it's like why I mean you guys aren't doctors right like you're not on you you're not on call cuz somebody's life is in danger like you're football coaches but it's just part of football culture it's just a normalization of I'm going to spend 18 hours in the office and I'm if The other guy's waking up at 4:55 a.m. I'm going to wake up at 4:45 a.m. They're all nuts, guys.

41:34 >> We did a story when I was back at ESPN magazine on the life of the coach's wife and it was Robin Kein. That's Lane and Chris Kein's mom and she and she since passed. She was a very sweet, vibrant person and I I knew her quite a bit when I was working on Meat Market. So, we would talk and there was a time where obviously her husband Monty Keiffen, legendary defensive coordinator in the NFL. and Chris is younger than Lane.

41:57 Chris is also, for people who don't know, is like an LSU assistant. And, they were two moves behind Monty. So, I think Monty is either was in New Orleans and they're still in Minnesota, but he's going to move to Tampa and they're trying to finish school and sell a house. And at one point, he's like, "Don't even bother coming here cuz I'm going to go there." So, at one point, like, you know, they were two almost going to be two moves behind him. And I think that's the nature of it. One quick anecdote cuz I just think the tease of it will be better than probably the telling of it. years ago, so as we know, Sue and I both really like Seinfeld. This was in the Seinfeld heyday. the for for fans of that show will remember the George opposite, you know, life philosophy.

42:45 >> Yeah. So, he's going to do everything the opposite. So, they end up firing Lane at USC. Ojan takes over and he basically was like I'm doing everything the opposite of Lane, you know, like Lane was doing this, I'm going to do that. You know, he's like he's not letting him have sweets, bringing in Rosco's doing all this stuff. And so I'm telling it, so I have this conversation when I go up to the office and we're talking. I was like, you're basically like doing the George Castanza. And I had to explain it. I think he knew like the only other TV show we had talked about that I knew he watched was Desperate Housewives. And but this I was like I told him you're doing the Castanza and he goes yeah yeah yeah that's what it is. It was so funny to just kind of like talk about like what it was at time at that time very mainstream TV but something so out of his world >> and it all related and sometimes you know it's good if coaches drop their guard and that sometimes those guys just don't feel like they can at that point.

43:44 In fairness, Bruce, if I quoted something from mainstream TV right now, I would never get it. >> Minimal. Minimal. >> Is Seinfeld the last sitcom you watch regularly? >> No, I watch VEP. >> I watch VEP. I watch Curb. You can see the pattern. that kind of stuff. >> On that note, guys, who's who's getting a gift card? >> I vote for And I feel like I never get the chance to vote. You guys always lock me out. I'm voting for I'm voting for Brandon and Austin because I think that's a fun question. Lincoln Riley was definitely in the news this week for for his reading of the statement. That would get my vote.

44:22 >> I'm going to second you and block out Ralph. >> That's fine. >> Brandon from Austin, send your mailing address to the Audible pod atgmail.com. By the way, we got a cool picture this week on Twitter from somebody outside the I finally got to use my Trader Joe's gift card and he's standing right next to the sign outside the store. So yeah, if you live in a college town and you walk over to your local Trader Joe's, you're you might see a sign for the Audible with the Audible logo and our names.

44:50 >> The chalkboard. Yeah. So if you love the auto if you love the Well, if you love the Audible, please subscribe on Apple Podcast, Spotify, wherever you get your shows. Audible show on YouTube. But if you want the $24 Trader Joe's gift card, send your questions to the Audible podgmail.com. Guys, it's going to be an amazing weekend. Seven top 25 games thanks to Oregon moving up into it. No political ads during the commercial breaks. Amazing. Just in time. We'll see you guys for our live show about all these great games. That'll be Sunday morning, 11:30 a.m. Eastern, 8:30 a.m.

45:28 Pacific at Audible Show on YouTube. We'll see you there.

Summary

The latest episode of The Audible discusses the current state of college football, focusing on the College Football Playoff rankings, the SEC's influence, and a significant drop in TV ratings this season. The hosts analyze the implications of the rankings, particularly how the SEC's strength of schedule is perceived by the committee, and explore the reasons behind the decline in viewership, including changes in Nielsen ratings and the impact of non-conference games.

- The SEC's dominance is reflected in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, with the committee giving them significant benefit of the doubt.
- UCLA's unbeaten status contrasts sharply with multiple two-loss SEC teams ranked higher, raising questions about fairness in rankings.
- TV ratings for college football have dropped 6% this season, with the ACC seeing a staggering 44.5% decline, attributed to weaker non-conference matchups.
- The novelty of the 12-team playoff format may be wearing off, contributing to decreased viewer interest.
- The hosts discuss the pressures faced by college football coaches, suggesting that the intense scrutiny and expectations can lead to changes in their behavior and demeanor over time.
- The conversation touches on the potential for future conference realignment, hinting at a non-traditional restructuring of college football in the coming years.
- The episode concludes with a mailbag segment, addressing listener questions and highlighting the impact of coaching pressures on personal lives.

Questions Answered

What is the Audible and what can listeners expect?

The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week during the offseason. The hosts encourage listeners to subscribe and engage with the community.

What are the concerns regarding Ohio State's defense?

The discussion highlights inconsistencies in Ohio State's defense, particularly in their performance against USC compared to their game against Indiana. The hosts question the narrative around Ohio State's strength and the implications of their defensive struggles.

What is causing the decline in college football TV ratings?

TV ratings for college football have dropped by 6% compared to the previous year, with the Big Ten experiencing a 10% decline. Factors include the performance of major teams and a lack of compelling matchups.

How does team performance affect college football's popularity?

The hosts discuss how the performance of traditionally strong teams, like Clemson and Michigan State, has declined, affecting viewer engagement. They emphasize that the sport isn't dying but faces challenges.

What challenges do coaches face when making personnel decisions?

Coaches face immense pressure when making decisions that affect not only their careers but also the lives of their staff and their families. The increasing visibility and financial stakes in college football complicate these decisions.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram