Section Insights
Career Development as a Bingo Card
How should one approach career development?
Career development can be viewed as filling in spots on a bingo card, where each role offers different business situations and technical challenges. It's important to gain diverse experiences rather than repeating the same year of experience multiple times.
- Think of your career as a bingo card, aiming for diverse experiences.
- Seek roles that present new challenges and business situations.
- Aim for genuine growth in your career rather than repetitive experiences.
Timing for Going Public
What factors determine the right time for a company to go public?
The right time to go public is when a company has achieved substantial revenue, demonstrated growth, and has clear future expansion plans. Investors look for a proven track record and potential for future upside.
- A company should go public when it has a strong revenue base and growth trajectory.
- Investors seek companies with demonstrated ability to deliver and future growth potential.
- Timing is crucial; it should align with the company's operational readiness and market conditions.
Valuation Process for IPO
How is the initial offering price determined for an IPO?
The valuation process involves considering multiple factors, including setting a strong valuation, managing investor expectations, and ensuring a positive aftermarket performance. Trade-offs must be made across these factors.
- Valuation for an IPO involves balancing multiple conflicting factors.
- Strong investor relationships and market conditions are crucial for pricing decisions.
- The IPO pricing strategy should support long-term success post-launch.
Building Investor Relationships
How should a company build its book of investors before an IPO?
Building a book of investors involves establishing relationships well before the IPO roadshow. This trust-building process is essential as investors seek confidence in their investment decisions.
- Start building relationships with investors early to establish trust.
- Investors are not just funders; they provide valuable insights and partnerships.
- Trust is critical for investors when committing significant capital.
CFO Career Path Considerations
What experiences should one seek to become a successful CFO?
Aspiring CFOs should seek diverse experiences across various financial disciplines and business situations. This includes exposure to hyper-growth environments, turnaround situations, and major transformations.
- A diverse skill set across finance and business operations is essential for a CFO.
- Experience in different business situations enhances empathy and leadership skills.
- Strategically filling in 'bingo card' experiences can lead to a well-rounded career.
Transcript
0:00 over time the way I think about a career is filling in different spots in bingo card and so any new role that you're going into you want to think about is it going to be a different business situation and a different set of technical challenges that I've had and then how do I build that out over time some of the best advice I've gotten on that front was Mark Hawkins who has this phrase of if you're going to
0:23 get 10 years of experience in your career make sure it's 10 years of experience and not one one year of experience 10 times ooh that is really good that is really good is this thing on yesterday's price is not today's price hey everybody Welcome to run the numbers with CJ this is a awesome
0:54 interview coming straight at you I interviewed the CFO of clavio Amanda whan and they did a very Brave thing last year they went public when other companies were not we go through the criteria that her and the management team looked at to pull the trigger and go public in a macro environment that was not the hottest they still performed really well we go through valuation criteria that CFOs may use to figure out what a company should be worth we talk
1:19 about the bankers how they decided to lead left who would be on the cover that's my dog Walter who's growling below me for another treat and loves IPOs we talk about how dual voting shares work how she went about building the book for investors and gives us the inside scoop with a funny story about The Road Show so for all you IPO nerds out there we go deep into the road show the IPO process and ringing that Bell we
1:44 also touch upon the qualities of CFOs she has this term I really like it I might steal it don't tell her H the CFO plus role we talk about how CFO and Co rules are converging in a way and the qualities that separate the good CFOs from the great ones this is an interview you're not going to want to miss Amanda is one of the best in the game all that and much more after a short word from
2:07 our sponsors okay serious question for all my accounting Pros here today are you doing what you were hired to do what I mean is do you have time to actually be a business partner or are you buried in tedious manual tasks just to get your journal entries prepared every month I know how that feels leap Fin's here to help with that leap finin is accounting automation software that automatically prepares and posts reliable journal entries and that's just the beginning high
2:32 growth businesses like Reddit canva and SEI choose leap fin to eliminate manual tasks accelerate monthang close and enable accounting leaders like you to provide faster insights that will help your company grow if you're battling messy transaction data from stripe Aden Shopify Apple pay and other PSPs and then battling again to get it all into Nets Suite go to leaf.com to watch their short product intro video and if you like what you see request a 15-minute conversation to learn how accounting
3:01 automation can help you and your team check out leap.com today that's leap like jump fin like shark I just made that up I hope they're okay with it leap.com ready to PL confidently close faster and Report more accurately here's what sets planful apart imagine purpose-built applications for every Department from fpna to accounting marketing to HR all with built-in Financial intelligence it's easy to implement planful in just weeks and with minimal it involvement so you can rapidly and seamlessly engage
3:32 everyone across the business on your key financial progress best of all planful grows with you it's unparalleled scalability ensures that no matter how fast your business expands planful can keep up see why over, 1500 customers worldwide choose planful as their flexible userfriendly endtoend financial performance management platform oh yeah go to planful docomo that's plan.com
4:03 metrics Amanda welcome to the run the numbers podcast thanks so much happy to be here I've been a clay VI fan for quite a while as a Boston native myself so this is truly a bucket list interview thank you we are excited to be here the feeling is mutual I have shared episodes with the Pod with my team our CEO reads your substack we're huge fans and happy to be here I'm going to clip that and
4:26 send it to my mom because she doesn't know what I'm talking about half the time on these so Mom I think I made it Amanda you did a really Brave thing last year so you went public when other companies were not so what were your criteria like what were you going through in your head to be able to pull the trigger and say this is the time yeah so you know we always had a saying internally that going public is kind of
4:50 like a high school graduation it's an important Milestone that you need to go through at some point but it's not the be all and end all and the exact time is less important than that it happens overall so you know when we look at many of the Great companies who we admire companies like Microsoft and Salesforce and Adobe they're all public so we knew that we wanted to be public someday we were in the fortunate position that we
5:15 were already cash flow positive Andrew likes to say in his mind that we'd go public sometime between 2030 and the reason or you know before 2030 and last year felt right to us because it was the right time for the business we were really confident about where we were as a business we were growing quickly we had strong unit economics we've got a long run way for growth ahead of us and so that made it the right time and then
5:40 you know we also thought about a few different other things we thought about we knew that being public would provide benefits from a customer perspective it helps increase awareness of the company give us credibility as we're selling to larger and larger companies out there we also knew it was important from an employee standpoint one of our core values is that all of our employees are owners and so it was a really important Milestone from that but number one was
6:03 really all about is the company ready and is it the right time for the business Amanda I love the analogy to graduating so if I think back so I graduated from high school in 2009 College in 2013 and both those periods there were macro considerations of like what job market am I coming into and at the time you know you look at it and you say this is like the big this moment is so big or this time period is so big but
6:27 then you say well my career hopefully knock what it's going to be you know 40 years or something like this is just a blip on the radar if you look back at other companies like you said like Microsoft who went public they said like this is just part of us entering a new chapter that if if we're doing things right and we're confident like this is going to go on for a long time that's right that's right and so the way we
6:46 thought about it was really what's the right time for the business and as a business where you want to be when you're ready to go public is you want to have enough scale that you've got a track record of growth you want to have a really clear strategy of where is growth going to come from in the future with enough proof points that investors know that it's something that can actually really happen and then you want
7:08 to be laying you know planting the seeds for future growth that's going to you know help you on into the future and that's really where we were you know at this point last year as we were thinking about going public so it was less about you know what exact year does it happen it was more what's the right time for the business how do we make it through this important Milestone and then importantly get back to running the the
7:29 business and building a generational company because that's what it's all about and one of the probably underappreciated things about going public at a time when there aren't many others is you get a lot of airspace right so one of the big benefits is that hey if you want to sell to the Enterprise and you want that advertisement I mean it it is kind of like this big Gala or party or not really a political event but you you get
7:51 all this you get all this publicity and if you maximize it at a time when there aren't that many others in the market like that's pretty cool it is it was pretty cool you know we had a lot of attention from potential customers ones who before had said what is this how do you pronounce your name who are you and all of a sudden you know the credibility that comes with being publicly listed you know and publicly
8:13 listed on the New York Stock Exchange it's a big important event and now customers say okay you guys have the credibility you're clearly here to stay let's talk about how we can partner together to grow my business and you'd mentioned it before like the the financial Prof you were incredibly cash flow positive and so in doing my research I saw that you raised about 450 million from inception IPO but I think you only needed like 15 million to get
8:40 where you were at like that that's remarkable yeah thank you that is one of the statistics that we are most proud of so I love that you picked up on that you know and for me as a CFO I've got to say it's one of the beautiful Parts about working with our two co-founders Andrew and Ed is because that's how they've built the business from the start our belief has always been that you can do can and should do three things at once
9:04 from a financial standpoint that we should be growing rapidly at scale and doing it in an efficient manner and that it's not an either or of do I want to grow quickly or do I want to be efficient that it takes creativity it takes thoughtfulness it takes intentionality but you can do all of them and that enabled us to you know not only grow so efficiently through our history but to have a financial profile that investors looked at and said okay
9:28 this is a business profile we like I mean you as a CFO I and it's it's kind of rare to have Founders at the outset like if I have three pillars here one of them's efficiency was that a selling factor for you it was great yeah I mean for me it just made my my role as CFO so much easier because Andrew and I we literally had dinner on Monday night and we were talking about this about heading into next year's
9:51 planning cycle and how do we you know continue driving growth where is growth going to come from and how do we make sure we're efficient through the planning process and that's just it's in their DNA so it makes my job that much more straightforward and so we hit on it before why go public and some may be saying at home like wait you're printing so much cash Market environment wasn't that great like why do it then you're
10:16 still making money and this may not necessarily be the criteria for for why clavio did it but if we could just take listeners through so like Enterprise awareness is one benefit employee liquidity is another what are some other reasons why company would want to go public yeah I mean Enterprise awareness is important it does help from a customer perspective it helps from an employee liquidity perspective but the number one that I would anchor back to and that I would encourage all CFOs and
10:41 CEOs thinking about going public is what's the right time for the business and for us it was we had gotten to a scale where we clearly you know were a substantial you know company last year we had closed to $700 million in Revenue yeah we had a demonstrated track record of growth in our core markets historically we have you know started out primarily serving retail and e-commerce businesses and serving a lot of small businesses but we were also
11:09 starting to see really good Traction in the places that we're going to drive growth going forward and for us in our business that was expansion internationally and growth in the mid-market and then we were just starting to plant the seeds for that future expansion of adding new products and expanding into new verticals so it really was from a business perspective the right time where you had that track record you have the proof points and you have the runway ahead because
11:36 investors want to know that you've got the demonstrated ability to deliver but they also want to know that there's upside so that they can share upside with you going forward if I was to play that back it was like your core engine that had got you to this point was very predictable and it was firing all engines and it was doing well and then what you had outline Amanda were different growth vectors whether it be segments or geographies that there was a
11:58 lot of meat on the bone and investors like that because they don't want to come in and like you've gone through every opportunity that's out there like they they want some Runway exactly they want that Runway ahead they want the confidence that you can deliver on the runway but they want to know that you know there's plenty of room for growth for you going forward you'd mentioned that your CEO had jokingly said like maybe before 2030 we'll go public in all
12:19 seriousness once you did say you know I I think it's shaping up to be that time how long did it take from from that first conversation to actually ringing the bell yeah I joined about a year and a half before we went public and we started having conversations about getting ready even before I joined so I think one thing you know for other CFOs who are thinking about going on this journey is just recognizing that the
12:41 journey to get ready to go public happens long before you kick off the official process and the way that I would think about that Readiness is I would generally say think about it in three different groupings there's what we would call technical Readiness there's strategic and business Readiness and then there is investor and communication Readiness the technical Readiness is all of the pieces that most people usually think about when they think about getting ready to go public
13:06 it's do I have the right accounting systems in place can I close the books you know when I'm subject to socks am I going to be ready from a control standpoint it's is my forecast accurate and so right as I was joining we were implementing a new Erp system we were Staffing up our accounting team we actually already had in place a Cadence with our board where we issued guidance once a quarter and then judged ourselves on how would
13:31 we perform relative to that guidance and we started doing that a couple of years before we went public the Strategic and business Readiness piece I talked about it's about do you have that track record of growth and the growth ahead of you and then that investor and Communications Readiness piece is all about building relationships and investors and telling your story and so same thing we started a couple of years before we went public going out to
13:56 conferences meeting with investors getting to know them you know not only at conferences but on non-deal road shows and getting practice and how do we tell the story and then we actually put that practice even more from a practical standpoint we started doing quarterly mock earnings calls where we wrote up our scripts we told the story at a quarter we got onto the phone with our board and our bankers and they asked us questions just the same
14:19 way that an analyst would so starting to act as if we were public long before we actually kicked off the process and then once we actually kicked off the process I would say it was a little bit more than six months from officially kicking off and you know selecting Banks to going public I'm super proud of the fact that when we mapped out when we kicked off the process we put together a project plan and a road map we hit every
14:44 single date on that plan exactly as planned which folks said they had never seen before but I think the reason we were able to do that was because we'd started it a year or two before I love how you said you're doing the mock earnings calls because it just really goes to to show how prepared you want it to be and people I think underappreciate the amount of work like we spoke with son PR of ring central and she was
15:08 walking us through how she gets ready for an earnings call we did a whole episode basically on just how CFO prepares for earnings calls yeah and and like doing them before you go public is so important because you kind of get down the rhythm of how the call goes because people probably don't realize like there are certain blocks where you know different people speak and it's expected that you'll go over this but not that I wanted to ask did any of your
15:31 board members who were who were playing the analyst try to trip you up on purpose they asked some hard questions they really did they said you know they asked some ones that they knew would be tricky with them just the same way that we actually do today you know we're very metrics driven as part of why we like like you know listening to to you and reading the things that you write we measure our hit rate on you know how
15:53 well how accurately did we predict the questions that are going to come up in Q&A no way and so and we score ourselves every quarter on it and so yeah the board members and bankers they asked us some tricky ones but we for the most part had them prepared and the scripts themselves are so important those can take a while to write I know can you take us through like how how you went about that did you did you have people
16:17 in your group research hey print out a bunch of scripts from other companies that are out there and and maybe we'll try to say hey we like how they do that but we don't like how they do this we did you know and Andrew our CEO is also you know has strong opinions on this so we read other people's scripts we talked to folks about best practices we had Jack who was our head of investor relations you I was looking at lots of
16:39 examples and then part of also the script is getting into a rhythm you want there to be enough flavor and color on the current quarter but also predictability so investors know what they're going to hear each time and so part of what we're working through when we went through those mockings calls was getting into our own Rhythm on that and finding our own voice I like how you said that Amanda because to a degree you are training the analysts and investors
17:04 listening to it to expect certain metrics and to expect certain pieces of the story to get an update on right yeah for our business you know one of the things that we've heard from investors they appreciate is we have four key lovers that drive our growth adding new customers expanding with those customers growing internationally and growing in the midm market and each quarter we give them an update on how are we making progress against each of those and then
17:27 they probably start to that in their model so what's great about that is the repeatability drives a model that actually reflects the reality of the world that you operate in yeah it does and so that's you know back to part of the reason for getting ready early is really thinking about knowing are we crystal clear as a company on what those gross drivers are going to be so that we can be consistent over time and then
17:49 what are the metrics that we're going to use to demonstrate that so we can have consistency in those metrics you know as as some of our favorite investors we work with always remind me of Manda really important to be consistent say what you're going to do do what you say we want to you know to have that predictability from the business hey thanks for listening we'll be right back after a word from our sponsors Mercury knows your financial
18:13 operations are complex Founders and finance teams have to pull together different tools reconcile transactions from different sources and struggle to get accurate answers with Mercury you can simplify your operations with Banking and software that power your critical Financial workflows all within the one thing every business needs a bank account and with new bill pay and accounting capabilities you can pay bills faster stay in control of company spend and speed up reconciliation apply in minutes at mercury.com and join over
18:42 200,000 wow ambitious startups that trust Mercury to provide the Precision control and focus they need to transform their financial workflows so they can perform at their best Mercury the art of simplified finances Mercury is a financial technology company not a bank banking services provided by Financial Group and evolved Bank and Trust members FDIC I'm getting good at that voice what does the future hold for business can someone invent a crystal ball until then over 38,000 businesses
19:15 wow that's a lot of companies have future proof their business with netsuite by Oracle the number one Cloud Erp bringing accounting financial management inventory and HR into one platform with realtime insights and forecasting you're able to peer into the future and seize New Opportunities download the cfo's guide to Ai and machine learning for free at netsuite.com metric that's netsuite.com metric me t r i CS metrics please guys I
19:46 really need this cash is King as a CFO of ass SAS company I know firsthand how important it is to maintain a healthy AR balance if can't effectively manage cash you can't service debt make payroll or invest in growing your business that's why I'm so excited to partner with the sponsor of today's episode maxio the leading billing and financial operations platform for B2B SAS maxio helps top SAS companies like Chile Piper crunch base and stack Overflow get cash in the door
20:17 Faster by automating Collections and Dunning gone are the days of manually chasing down invoices join the 2,500 Plus subscription businesses using maxio formerly SAS Optics and charger to eliminate Revenue leakage and streamline order to cash it's never been easier to get paid visit maxio docomo in 2024 not only does requesting a demo using the run the numbers link help support this podcast your boy you also receive a 10% discount on your
20:48 first year with maxio woo that's maxio dcom SL runthe numers that's M ax io.com slash run the numbers I'm curious could you hit on maybe the valuation process for the IPO how did you come up with an initial offering price because everyone has to do it but I know that there are multiple paths to get there yeah you know I can't get into too many of the specifics on the decisions of it as it relates to our company but I will say
21:17 here's kind of the framework for how we thought about it which is what I always appreciate learning from other CFOs we were thinking about six different factors that went into decisions on pricing and one of the things that was really important as we went through the pricing discussions not just on you know the week of the IPO but even in the months leading up to it was thinking about as a company how are we going to
21:41 make tradeoffs across all of those so here's the six one is you want to price at a strong valuation you also want to set expectations in a way that supports being successful post IPO want to allocate to a strong core group of investors but you also want avoid excess dilution and not take on more Capital than you need and you want to have strong positive aftermarket trading once you launch but you don't want your pop to be too big and as you
22:12 can hear when I go through those some of them are actually directly in conflict with one another and so that for us the the valuation process was you know working with our banks talking to investors and importantly thinking about how did we prioritize and make trade-offs across each of those different levs and having that conversation with our management team and our board okay that's one of my favorite moments from all the podcasts have done so far that framework that was
22:37 that's the inside baseball that people come here for like you said some of those are in contradiction with one another can you can you maybe just explain to listeners why you don't want too big of a valuation pop because someone say don't you want the stock to just you know go as high as possible on day one that one I would say the part of the reason for not wanting too big a pop is one of the other ones that I pointed to
22:58 which is avoiding excess solution because if you have a pop then implicitly you've left some money on the table which means that you know that's capital that the the business could have raised on the other hand you're bringing investors into your business and it's really important to share that upside with them so you want to make sure that they are getting upside these are some of the trade-offs there it is a delicate balance it's like you want it not too
23:21 hot not too cold and then you also want the news to signal that it was a positive you know outcome and that it went up so it's it's almost like there's an art and there's a science to it that's right absolutely absolutely it's the importance of also having really strong advisers who can help you through navigating that you don't have to say any specifics here but like were there changes leading up to it and I asked
23:42 because we interviewed Adam antie CFO of payor and he told this funny story of how like at the last minute they were going through with Goldman they're like should we do it at 26 or $28 a share and he's like 27 and it ended up being like 25 million more for the company and it was kind of just a funny anecdote but like was the price set or did it move it around at all I mean you could see
24:02 through the public filings that as we went through it it moved around a little bit Yeah so the banker is running the process what are deciding factors that a CFO will look at to determine who gets the lead left spot similar to the way that I talked about the process of getting ready for an IPO not just being about once you've officially kicked it off but it's also all of the process that leads up to it it was the same with
24:26 Banker selection which was the outcome of having gotten to know the teams across the various Banks across a period of you know in some cases multiple years so we spent time getting to know we literally looked Bank by Bank making sure that we not only had relationships with all the banks who might be in the consideration set with their banking team but also with their Capital markets team and also with their analyst and bankers are eager to help you and we
24:55 took advantage of that as a way to get to know them and see what was it really going to be like working together so if we had a tricky issue we were working through or something where we wanted to see some analysis we would ask different banks to help us out on it as a way to get the experience of what was it going to be like working with these guys we went on non-deal road shows
25:18 with different groups to see what was the experience of being on the road together and so you know by the time we actually got into the conference room the selection process process wasn't really about just that 1H hour presentation in the conference room it was also about this relationship that we' built with folks over time I like how you kind of framed it as you're playing a long-term game with the bankers there and you're looking deeper
25:42 like at the institution that's doing it it's not just your investment banking team it's who's your saleside team who's your you know Commercial Banking team as well that's right yeah because you have to think about you know the different capabilities that each Bank brings and you know some of them have outstanding advisory teams but they don't NE necessarily offer Commercial Banking so in some cases you might want to have a bank who you're working with who can
26:04 help you on the commercial side the analyst is critically important you know they always say you date your Banker but you marry your analyst and so you you want to make sure you are building those relationships with the analysts and know what they're going to be like to work with and we've got a great team of analysts we work with and they really are Partners as you're going through the process you know the banking teams were
26:26 extensions of our team on the inside we had nicknames for each other they were but you know you are working together a lot so it's really important to know that these are folks you're going to be want to be in the trenches with for a while yeah those are people that you have to pick up the phone and maybe call at like 11: p.m. on a Friday so you end up having a pretty good relationship with them oh yeah oh yeah Friday
26:48 Saturday you name it so I I mentioned the lead left but I feel like not many people talk about like the third line in there where the unit economics aren't as strong and maybe they're not doing as much of the work but what what goes into those relationships what are kind of like the value props for for each side to be included on you know the the the last line there yeah same thing as as for the the overall there you're looking
27:13 at the the strength of the advisory team you're looking at how do they complement from a capital Market standpoint and then really importantly the the analyst relationship there as well this is maybe a silly question but the the geographies of where the banks like sit matter at all like did do you actually think to yourself like I want a bank in the midwest as well we thought about the different relationships they would have with different types of investors of
27:37 which geography is one piece of it but we did think about having a you know a a total Syndicate who was complimentary to each other in multiple ways like that right I remember someone saying to me once like oh well you know if you want to get investors from Chicago or something then you should probably work with this bank because that's the pipeline to get there but I didn't know if you know the world's truly Global now
27:58 that didn't really matter yeah no it was one of the things that we thought about other than Bankers what other types of advisers do you work with during an IPO so multiple different types of advisers so we worked with our lawyers were important parts of the team and so we had a great legal team who was supporting us through the process we had accounting Partners who were helping us you know on the audit side and in
28:22 preparing for getting ready for eventually being ready for stocks and then we another critical adviser for us was was our capital markets adviser we worked with class 5 group and they have deep IPO experience and so we're a tremendous help along the way and then the other you know I think important advisory role for us was our board as we were we had you know an outstanding board before and then as we got closer to IPO we were adding additional board
28:49 members you know folks who were bringing go to market strategy customer success Finance operations different perspectives within SAS I felt incredibly fortunate that I have not one but two CFOs on our audit committee who had taken companies public before and having that strong board who you can turn to when you say how did you handle this situation how would you think about framing this was just incredibly important would you mind touching on the work that that Capital markets group
29:17 does is is that investor relations related or am I getting that wrong it's a little bit investor relations related and a lot helping just to navigate the overall IPO process and so helping think through what's the timeline going to look like how do you think about structuring The Syndicate really playing a strong advisory role to me as the CFO because this was the first time that I had been through an IPO and that that group had been through you
29:45 know hundreds and so you know just had great experience of here's what's going to happen next and then I think the other thing that you you're doing it with this the podcast right now is building a network of other CFOs I had a group of CFOs Who U primarily ones who our investors had introduced me to who had taken their companies public who same thing I would call them on a pretty regular basis and say okay now we're
30:11 entering this phase walk me through how you thought about that and the the CFO Community is so incredibly helpful to each other so definitely tap into the network of other CFOs as well yeah what do they call it having like your own kitchen cabinet exactly exactly so this one's more of a technical question but how did dual voting shares work what are the mechanics of that yep so the mechanics of the Dual class is that our
30:38 co-founders and our pre-ipo investors hold shares that have higher voting rights and the reason for having that is that it lets us focus on the very longterm and be making Investments and making decisions that are going to help us build a generational company over many many years and so as we put in the structure we put it in in a way that was very similar to what other tech companies had done so we looked at other examples from companies who had
31:07 ipoed over the last decade and put in place a very similar structure including an important provision which is that it sunsets at seven years after the IPO oh okay I never thought about it that way so it kind of gives you the stability or security to know that the choices you make today like I'm making them for the long term I don't have to like play into necessarily some like activist investor or a hedge fund that may be you know
31:33 short or something like that is is that how to think about it yeah it it gives you that ability to be focused on the long term but again importantly it's not forever because you know that you know that I think is really important to investors as they're looking at it knowing that you know that there's also that accountability I think Google and Facebook were two of the ones historically who you know was it was news when they did it but now it's
31:58 becoming more common place yeah how did you go about building the book for investors because like I said you didn't actually need to raise that much money heading into IPO but I imagine you still had a lot of relationships with you know investors who wanted to get in so what was your kind of thought process of building that book of different types of investors yeah our thought process was you know as we talked about before we
32:20 had started getting to know investors well before we actually headed into the road show itself so by the time we started the road show for many investors it was the second time or even the third time that we'd met those investors and that was really important both for us and for them for a couple of reasons first is for them they're making an investment in you this is a lot of money that they're putting into the company
32:45 and that requires a lot of trust and building that trust doesn't happen just in one meeting and so we wanted the chance to get to know and build those relationships and that trust over time and then the second is that we wanted to get to know them because investors don't just bring funding the great investors are great Partners to the business they give us really important perspective and really important guidance because they've seen and they think about so
33:11 many different companies and they've seen good execution they've seen bad execution and so because of all of that they've got really good and helpful ideas about how to create value so you know for us it was us getting to know them them getting to know us and then at the end of the day it's just a tough process we were so fortunate our IPO was significantly oversubscribed so we had to make a lot of tough decisions but you
33:36 know we were really thankful that we'd had the chance to build all of those relationships and get to know each other is is there like a Target mix that you go for for everybody says they're a long investor these days but like the the long investors institutional like mutual fund type you know Financial sponsors versus the hedge funds was there like a mix you were looking for you know for us it was based on those things that we
33:58 talked about before just getting to know investors over time and the relationships that we'd had all right so give us the inside scoop what's a road show like oh the road show such an adventure so Road show started on a Monday okay runs through the ran through the following Monday then we priced on Tuesday and we started trading on Wednesday we kick it off it opens on day one with a big group meeting with the sales teams who are going to be out
34:26 helping you sell throughout the process walking them through the business and then it's a series of you know one-on-one and group meetings with investors across the country we went to I can't even remember right now how many cities we went to it involved a lot of travel more than five not that weak because I think we had done testing the waters in some before so you know we tried to make sure that wherever we could we'd been able to
34:55 meet with investors in person and so some of those we did before in testing Waters and some during the road show itself but we did do ours for the most part in person that being said anytime you are in person and you're traveling it comes with adventures and headaches that come with travel and so you know one of our funny stories during the process was we had done our first day in New York we were supposed to fly up to
35:21 Boston for our second day our headquarters is in Boston so it's where Andrew our CEO lives so he had packed for the day for New York and then our flight to Boston got cancelled and there were no other alternatives to get up there we thought about you know driving or taking a train but the weather was really bad it turned out it was going to be impossible so we ended up staying in New York but Andrew only had a day's
35:44 worth of cloth packed because he was supposed to be going home to Boston so we made a quick call we talk about Banks being your partners we actually had to make a quick call to one of the bankers on our team and say we think you're about Andrew's size can we have your shirt no way so literally you know one of the members of our banking team gave us you know the shirt off his back he he did
36:10 technically go home they were clean and pressed shirts but you someone else's monogram on there that's a great partner oh man thanks for sharing that story that's awesome I I want to transition into talking about the qualities of CFOs you would use this term when we were preparing for this it's called the CFO plus role can you break down that term yeah you know I think the CFO plus is that the role of a typical CFO these days has evolved so
36:40 it's not just about reporting the numbers the numbers matter deeply and we love our metrics but it's about how do you use those metrics to really be a business leader you know play a key part in not only reporting the news but how do you set the overall strategic direction of the company and work with the CEO and the entire leadership team on you know what is the the choices and the Strategic direction of the business
37:06 so you know I think one of the biggest parts of that is having a real customer focus as a CFO so before I even started at clavo I had talked to customers read customer reviews understood the things that they liked about the product the things that we can be doing differently you know I try and talk to customers on a really regular basis because it just gives you that perspective where you're not you know just the one who is telling what's
37:33 happening on the p&l you're really helping to think about how do we drive this business and this p&l into the future I like how you hit on understanding the product because that is so core to actually understanding the story behind the numbers we talked to shuy Lanka CFO of public and she said like I trade on this platform I was user of this platform I understand the data that's not just financial data but operational data and more importantly
37:57 the production data because I don't feel like I can make calls in the business if I don't understand what we're selling yeah that's right you know I've got a clo account and in our leadership team meetings on a regular basis we will go in and you know work through okay we just launched clavo AI let's work through how do you build an email using clavio Ai and how do I use it to create an automation it's just you need to
38:21 be able to be in your customer shoes yeah I've become more and more comfortable in the last couple years with being the person who says hey I'm going to ask you a really stupid question can you explain this about the product to me but I learned the hard way that you want to ask it then because you don't want someone from the outside asking asking you that question that's right that's right what qualities do you think separate the good CFOs from the
38:44 great CFOs two things come to mind for me so the first is an analogy that actually someone who worked for me taught me but I think has been incredibly value over time that the best CFOs are like Dolphins so one day you are up on the surface above the water scanning The Horizon you know driving the business Forward Thinking About You know where are we headed and the next moment you are diving deep below the surface understanding each number where
39:14 does it come from how does it work how do I have confidence that this is the right one and the best CFOs move seamlessly up and down between the two and can pivot you know not just from one day to the next but from one moment to the next from this big picture long-term strategic thinking to highly operational and detail oriented and the other thing that I would say is the best CFOs who I have known and worked with are amazing
39:42 talent developers you know I'll call out specifically Brett BS who I worked for at Walmart was just incredibly thoughtful and intentional about how did he build and grow and develop his team and I've seen that same thing you know Carol to at Home Depot Mar Hawkins at Salesforce they are just you know not only great business partners and great operationally they're also great developers of long-term CFO Talent speaking of talent I've also come to appreciate that there's difference in
40:10 the skill set of being able to recruit really well as a CFO and then be able to develop Talent internally yeah I think there is I think you know you need to be able to do both but you know ultimately I view part of my success as how many future CFOs am I helping to groom and that's not just hiring them in It's thinking about what skill set is everybody developing and how am I helping them round out their portfolio
40:34 over time I love that analogy because I too think about it like I I hope someday my legacy is like they look at it like an NFL coaching tree of like you know who came up under like Bill bellich like that person became a head coach someday I think that speaks volumes about whoever they came up under yeah that's right I will say I'll have to give away one of my my secret sauce in recruiting is I've got a a group of
40:57 CFOs who worked for me in Prior Lives who whenever I'm recruiting someone to work on my team I say you know don't just take it from me that I will help develop you into a CFO I'd like you to call these four people and hear their names and their numbers and they're all amazing CFOs in their own rights that is such an unfair Advantage I love that but it it took a lot of hard work to to get to that point
41:20 so we deserved well speaking about developing Talent versus recruiting how do you balance the need for specialized knowledge versus you know going deep on only a few topics because there are a lot of people out there and I get this question a lot like CJ to become a CFO I'm not sure if I should position myself as someone who like knows one or two things down pat deeper than anybody else or if I should kind of be a jack of all
41:43 trades I think it's important to get a mix of breadth and depth and the way that I tend to think about a career and the way that I tend to coach people to think about their career is to think about your career as almost a bingo card so it's got two axes one axis is probably the things that you're thinking about and asking about how do I get exposure to all of the different technical parts of being a CFO right so
42:10 have I worked in fpna do I have a deep understanding of accounting and controls have I had exposure to tax to treasury to investor relations to m&a and then importantly I'll lay out a controversial one on there have I had some experience outside of Finance so that I have empathy for what does it mean to be trying to lead a business on a day-to-day basis and then the other access is the things that you might not
42:33 think as much about it's more the type of business and the situation you're in have you been you know part of a team leading a company through hyper growth have you been part of turning around an underperforming team have you had to lead a major systems integration or a major change transformation have you been part of m&a integration and you know over time the way I think about a career is filling in different spots in the bingo card and so any new role that
43:03 you're going into you want to think about is it going to be a different business situation and a different set of technical challenges that I've had and then how do I build that out over time some of the best advice I've gotten on that front was Mark Hawkins who has this phrase of if you're going to get 10 years of experience in your career make sure it's 10 years of experience and not one year of experience 10 times
43:27 oh that's deep deep that is really good that is really good Amanda you mentioned getting experience outside of Finance if you're a person who is in finance and says I want to get to the CFO role but maybe I take a detour for a bit where would you go I would think about the business that you're in and think about what is core to that and how do I get experience in those core functions so in our industry
43:54 I would think about have you spent time maybe in go to market market so you know my our head of fpna now spent time in sales Ops she actually had to build up a sales Ops Team from scratch when she was at one company or I would think about have you spent time in product and is there a role in product operations where you might be able to help but just thinking about how do you get closer and
44:15 get experience with working in those core drivers of the business so that when you're part of that leadership team when you're giving you know advice and counsel and being that strategic partner you have an understanding of what is it like to be on the other side I love how you called out the product operations that's something that I looking back probably took for granted or should have dug deeper on I got a ton of experience on like the sales operations side
44:41 deploying quota running pipeline calls but that's right the more I've learned like being in this seat is how you need to understand the product and how the Sprint cycles and stuff go and how how you kind of overlay resources and and in alloc in that direction so I'm so glad you called that out yeah if you were to go deep on one topic though to prepare to be a CFO so someone else also told me think about your career as like
45:07 a te so you want to have breath across the top and then maybe you pick one area maybe this isn't even a letter anymore maybe that's two pillars one or two pillars to go deep on which which one did I'll ask did you choose to go deep on if there is one or or would you recommend others to so my background I started off with a decade at Bane and Company so started off in strategy Consulting and therefore you know from a
45:30 finance perspective but I would say the fpna and operational Finance was my home and then broadened out that te as the I was the treasur of Walmart and had of you know which also included responsibility for tax a lot of cash there lot of cash there lot cash big capital structure so you know I that is you know my home structure although I would say if I think about it maybe take even a step back from that if I were to
45:59 go deep and make sure that you build expertise in one thing over the course of your career it is learning how to learn it's learning what you just talked about which is getting comfortable asking all the stupid questions so that you know how to get up to speed on something quickly it's breaking things down into first principles understanding the industry understanding the competitive environment what are customer needs finan is changing so rapidly the technology that enables our
46:29 you know function is changing so rapidly our businesses are changing so much there's no way that you're going to be expert in everything that you're going to come across in this sour over the course of your career so the most important thing is learning how am I going to get up to speed on this quickly so that I can make informed decisions to drive to good outcomes I also think there is a skill in operating an
46:51 ambiguity like that that that is ambiguous just even saying that but I think one of the big benefit is you build this confidence that I can be thrown into something I'm just going to figure it out I'm gonna figure it out I'm going to be able to learn this yeah you get this confidence that says I've seen enough back to that you know the bingo card I've seen enough that I can have a little bit of pattern recognition
47:11 and then I'm going to be comfortable in IGA and I know I can figure it out and I know how to learn because I know how to ask the right questions find the right people folks are always willing to help yeah yeah that's why I have this podcast because I got people on the Rolodex now I'm GNA be calling you Amanda I'm G I'm going to take you into what we call our long ass lightning round so you're you're a successful
47:33 person but I ask everybody what's an example of something you screwed up on the job could be this job or a different one it was right before I had my first CFO role I was leading a post merger integration we were doing a whole bunch of systems implementations as part of it and in one of the systems implementations I just made a bad system Choice didn't really fully understand the requirements and it caused all kinds of operational headaches when we
47:59 went live and so you know I learned very quickly you know one how to dive in and own the problem we were Hands-On getting it fixed for you know a week how to own the responsibility of guys this is my bad call and we're going to make it better and you know how do you take responsibility fix the problem fix it fast and then figure out what you learn from it I have not made that mistake
48:25 ever again I the big takeway I took though is that you jumped in and said this is my bad from the beginning yeah that's right that's so important well why is that important for people who are trying to become leaders yeah because everyone's going to make mistakes at some point there you don't gain a lot through finger pointing you gain actually you know interestingly I got promoted into my very first CF CFO job not long after that which a little bit
48:54 ironic I just made this big mistake but part of the feedback that I got was we saw how much you owned it and took ownership and responsibility and said I am going to get this fixed and that builds confidence and that builds trust even ironically though despite the fact that it was because of having just made a big mistake well I think it also shows that you're human and that you're the type of person that they'd want to work
49:16 with when stuff isn't going right yeah that's right that's right all right next one if you could tell your younger self something knowing what you know today what would you tell her what I would tell her is taking risks is risky sometimes they don't work out that's the Dirty Little Secret everybody tells you take some risks in their career and they they tell you about the thing that worked out amazingly sometimes you take some risks and they
49:40 don't work out but you over the long term will end up in a better place because of it and so it is worth it even though you know not everything always pans out exactly as expected risks like what like picking your next job or rooll or yeah exactly picking your next job or rooll taking the leap and you know moving outside of Finance for me it was taking a leap in some cases and you know working for companies or industries
50:04 that I hadn't been in before and yeah some of them worked out exactly as I'd hoped even better than I'd hoped some of them not quite so much but they helped along the way risks are risky I like it can you walk me through your finance software stack what tools do you use today to get the job done yep so net site our Erp procurement we use coupon zip for fpna we use planful we use worka for our public filings we use
50:33 audit board for internal audit and I think our most recent implementation was we just put in flowcast for close management love it Rach jallo CFO flowcast friend of the Pod you had a that's a strong finance software stack there you didn't Implement any wrong in that one as I said we learned learned all right last one I got for you what's the craziest thing you've ever had someone try to expense yeah you know it's interesting I I don't think I've seen
51:01 much I've had people ask some questions about things that were questionable but I guess it's a good sign of the companies I've worked with and you know worked for and the people I've worked with that I really haven't seen that much that that is that crazy from a expense standpoint I had someone ask recently if they could expense dog walking because they had to go to a conference I've had that type of question yeah I haven't seen them
51:25 actually put it through but I've I've gotten the question about that yeah another one I saw somebody actually expense jeans because it was kind of like what happened to your CEO like they traveled and they had to stay longer like well I'm staying longer here I mean I'm I'm balling out I'm getting a new outfit I it this has been this has been a pleasure I've learned so much from this and like I said big fan of
51:44 the company and appreciate you being generous with your time thank you so much so happy to join run the numbers is a mostly LLC production yelling an intro by Fat Joe artwork by some AI a jig podcast and video editing is done by cleanc at clean.i nothing said on this podcast is intended to be business or investment advice it's the sole opinion of me a guy who feeds his dog too much ice cream and has a history of net operating losses
52:09 LOL if you like this podcast please hit subscribe it would mean a lot to me and also check out mostly metrics.com that's my newsletter where I explore business models and financial metrics thanks for riding with me share this with your friends peace
Summary
- Amanda describes the IPO as a significant milestone akin to high school graduation, emphasizing readiness over timing.
- Klaviyo went public when it was cash flow positive and had a strong growth trajectory, focusing on customer credibility and employee ownership.
- The valuation process involved balancing factors like strong pricing, investor allocation, and avoiding excess dilution.
- Amanda highlights the importance of mock earnings calls and investor relations in preparing for the IPO.
- She introduces the concept of the "CFO plus" role, where CFOs must be strategic leaders beyond just reporting numbers.
- Amanda advocates for a diverse career path, filling in a "bingo card" of experiences across different business situations and technical challenges.
- She stresses the value of building relationships with investors and the importance of learning how to learn in a rapidly changing finance landscape.
- Amanda shares a humorous anecdote about the challenges faced during the roadshow, illustrating the unpredictability of the IPO process.
Questions Answered
How should one approach career development?
Career development can be viewed as filling in spots on a bingo card, where each role offers different business situations and technical challenges. It's important to gain diverse experiences rather than repeating the same year of experience multiple times.
What factors determine the right time for a company to go public?
The right time to go public is when a company has achieved substantial revenue, demonstrated growth, and has clear future expansion plans. Investors look for a proven track record and potential for future upside.
How is the initial offering price determined for an IPO?
The valuation process involves considering multiple factors, including setting a strong valuation, managing investor expectations, and ensuring a positive aftermarket performance. Trade-offs must be made across these factors.
How should a company build its book of investors before an IPO?
Building a book of investors involves establishing relationships well before the IPO roadshow. This trust-building process is essential as investors seek confidence in their investment decisions.
What experiences should one seek to become a successful CFO?
Aspiring CFOs should seek diverse experiences across various financial disciplines and business situations. This includes exposure to hyper-growth environments, turnaround situations, and major transformations.