Section Insights
Interviewing Tactics
What are some effective tactics for interviewing?
Practicing before interviews is crucial, especially before approaching top companies. It's advisable to gain experience and confidence through practice interviews before targeting your top choices.
- Most people need practice to excel in interviews.
- Avoid interviewing with top companies until you're prepared.
- This is a guideline, not a strict rule; use your judgment.
Understanding Product Leader Archetypes
What are the different types of product leaders?
There are three archetypes of product leaders: the operator, the craftsperson, and the visionary. Understanding these roles can help companies identify what they need in a product leader.
- Recognizing the archetypes helps in hiring the right product leader.
- Each archetype has strengths suited for different stages of product development.
- The framework is valuable for both founders and hiring managers.
Product Leadership Across Stages
How do product leader needs change across different product stages?
In the Explore stage, a visionary or craftsperson is ideal. As the product expands, a craftsperson is needed to implement the vision, and eventually, an operator becomes essential in the late expansion and extraction stages.
- Different stages of product development require different leadership styles.
- Visionaries are crucial in the early stages, while operators are needed later.
- Flexibility in leadership roles can drive product success.
Key Questions for Interviews
What questions should candidates ask during interviews?
Candidates should ask about the company's vision, culture, and specific expectations for the role. These questions can lead to meaningful conversations and set candidates apart from others.
- Asking insightful questions can differentiate candidates in interviews.
- Understanding the company's vision and culture is crucial for alignment.
- Candidates should focus on what is best for the company, not just personal interests.
Clarifying Role Expectations
How can candidates clarify their role expectations during interviews?
Candidates should ask about the requirements and expectations for the role to ensure clarity. This helps signal their commitment to the company's needs over personal interests.
- Clarifying role expectations is essential for mutual understanding.
- Candidates should focus on the company's needs in their inquiries.
- Effective communication during interviews can enhance candidate positioning.
Transcript
0:00 Okay, so these are the principles for tactics for Outbound right now on interviewing, the first tactic is this. Look, I want you to understand almost everyone, and I certainly include myself in this category, needs some practice before they can get good at interviews. Okay? So if you can help it, avoid interviewing with the top five companies on your list until you've had some practice. Now this is not possible in every environment and for every individual. So please use your judgment, okay?
0:31 This is not some rule. Don't see the words on this slide. And said Shreya said you should never interview with your top five companies. That is not what this is saying, okay? This is just a guideline. This guideline might apply to 70% of the people out there, right? If you are not in that 70%, it's okay, just go ahead and interview anyway. Right? But the point is you have to likely be on your absolute A game when you are interviewing with your top five companies on the list.
1:01 Presumably they are harder to get into, right? And the practice is very useful. Everyone I've talked to has said they were very rusty in the first couple of first two, three interviews they did.
1:14 Right? Okay.
1:14 So next, if you are interviewing at a startup, chances are that the founder can even use some help in figuring out what they're looking for. Okay? Or even a senior exec, even if it's not a founder. So if as a candidate with your questions and your perspective, you can give them some clarity, guess what, you will stand out as a candidate versus everybody else. Because see, everybody else is just trying to prove like why I am the best person for the job.
1:39 So if you take the approach, and again this is more for startups and midsize companies, not for very large companies. But if as a candidate with your questions and your perspective right, you, if you can give them some clarity on what it is they should even be looking for, that is going to make you really stand out right now doing this. Now note, doing this requires a genuine understanding of what a product person, especially ahead of product or a senior product person does at a non faang company at a startup or, or a mid sized company.
2:16 So if you do not have that understanding, don't fake it because then it'll be obvious that you don't understand what you're talking about. But if you do have that understanding, perhaps I can then share some vocabulary which can help you have a high quality conversation with the founder or the exec. Okay, so that vocabulary is basically it's something I've written about publicly, so I'm not going to Spend too much time on it. But I've talked to more than 100 founders at this point on this kind of three types of PM leaders, and almost every one of them that I've talked to has found this framework very enlightening.
2:48 Right?
2:48 So basically the three types of product leaders are the operator, craftsperson, and the visionary. Okay? But basically the point here is that understand these archetypes, okay? And then help this company understand what it is they should be looking for in this role. Okay? So to further go on this point, I also wanted to share, like, another framework, and I wanted to marry this with the most powerful framework for product people, okay. Which is not many people know about it, unfortunately, but It's Kent Beck's 3X framework on product stages.
3:22 Okay? So Kent Beck is the creator of extreme programming. He came up with this 3x framework when he was working at Facebook. And so his point is very straightforward. He's a product can be in one of three stages. Explore, expand, and extract. And the names are obvious. And you can see from how this is rendered what each stage represents. And if you've been working on products for a while, none of this should seem like, unfamiliar to you.
3:49 But what is very profound about Ken Beck's framework and the point he makes is that each stage is very different. And so therefore, because each stage is so different, your approach to goal should be different. Your approach to what to prioritize should be different. Your approach for what are you optimizing for in each stage should be different. Everything. Your entire leadership, product leadership ability relies on your recognition of what stage we are in and therefore, what do we need right now at this stage.
4:24 So it's not about copying playbooks from Notion and Canva and all that nonsense, right? Like, it's about understanding where are you right now, right? And then figuring out what the right approach is. All right, so one of the core things that I will say is that your approach to what type of product leader to hire should also be different. Okay? So I like if we show the 3x framework as this kind of just line, right? Which.
4:48 Where the green represents explore, red represents expand, and blue represents extract. So if we simplify it like this, then here's something you need to understand which is in the Explore stage, you probably want a visionary or a craftsperson archetype as the product leader. Often usually this is the founder. In the expand stage, a visionary is going to struggle, and you need a craftsperson to translate the vision into concrete product features that will help differentiate your product further and create a massive Lead.
5:22 But actually, as you get into the late expand stage, you will start to now need an operator, okay? And then definitely as you get into the extract stage, you're going to need an operator, okay? And at some point, if you need some huge revitalization or revitalizing of your product, of your business, you need reinvention, you need a turnaround story. Now at that point, you might want to bring back a visionary in the extract stage, okay?
5:56 So again, these are not rules, but these are general patterns. And by the way, this is why, remember I told you in my career story, I told you that, like, at some point I decided that I would not even apply for the head of product role at Stripe, even though when I joined Stripe, I was like, I really want the head of product role when they open it up. So why is that? It was very simple.
6:16 When I joined Stripe, it was around here. So at the time they needed a craftsperson. And I am primarily a craftsperson archetype. So, okay, this will make sense. But by the time they opened up the head of product role, we were like, somewhere here. So now I saw very clearly that Stripe no longer needs a craftsperson to lead the entire PM team. Stripe needs an operator. I can wear the operator hat, but it is not my preferred hat.
6:44 It is not the hat that gives me energy, okay? And plus, there are many other better operators than me. Operator archetypes than me. I knew this by this time. So that is one of the core reasons why it made sense for me to say, let's just hire. And then luckily we got an amazing operator who was our cfo. Actually, it was just brilliant. And then he became my boss. And so that's basically the explanation for why it worked out that way.
7:09 Okay, now before we move on to the next tactic, I want to leave you with three golden questions to ask
7:16 a founder or a senior executive. Again, this applies to most situations. Okay?
7:21 It probably doesn't apply to if you're.
7:24 If the prospective hiring manager is a
7:26 GPM at a FAANG company, right?
7:29 Because a GPM at a FAANG company
7:31 is just not going to like, basically have that kind of visibility, right? So it doesn't apply to that situation,
7:39 but it actually applies even to say,
7:42 if you're talking to a VP at
7:43 a FAANG company, right?
7:45 And the VP is hiring somebody on
7:47 their team, this framework still applies. Okay?
7:51 So even though I've used the head of product role just for the sake of being able to communicate it, you can use it as a.
7:59 At a faang company, but at a Very senior level.
8:02 Not at.
8:02 If you're getting hired as a PM3
8:04 who reports to a GPM.
8:06 Okay, these are the three big questions to ask, all right? Now each of these questions, like they were simple questions, but they can lead
8:15 to very interesting conversations and will completely differentiate you versus every other candidate in the interview process.
8:21 What are the common questions people ask
8:23 at the end of.
8:23 So do you have some questions for me? What are the questions people ask? Yeah, what's the vision? What's the culture? Tell me, walk me through a recent product launch and how it went. This is like, what nonsense questions. Like just you're getting an opportunity like to ask like good questions and you're asking nonsense questions, right? This is like stupid, okay, so don't do this. Don't waste this precious time. First of all, most interviewers, they just leave five minutes at the end for what questions do you have for me?
8:51 So can you change that? No, you cannot change that. It is what it is. I wish it were different, but it is what it is, right? You can't change that. But, but what you can change is
9:00 how you use those five minutes, right?
9:02 And how in some cases you might convert those five minutes into a follow up conversation. Okay? So understand that most of these questions that candidates ask at the end are just like complete useless questions, all right? So here's what you ask, okay? Especially again when you're talking to somebody senior, okay?
9:22 What aspects of the product make sense for you to continue owning after you hire the head of product?
9:27 Okay, this again, if it sounds like, wait, why are we asking this question? This is a very important question. Because this is the reason why conflict happens in most companies. Whereas, oh, I didn't agree with the
9:37 founder's vision and then I got fired
9:39 in six months or I left in nine months or whatever, right? It's because of this issue, right? So by asking this question, you are not only getting some signal, but you are making the individual think, which is like, what should I. Yes, what should I continue owning? And if they say, no, I don't want to own anything, that's a problem. Then maybe you can have a conversation which is actually, it might make sense for you to continue owning some aspects because you are the one who's brought the product thus far, right?
10:09 You are the one who's brought this product to 100 million in ARR. So you are having a meaningful conversation like a colleague might. And what entity are you optimizing for with this question? Are you optimizing for yourself, for the hiring manager, or for some Other entity. This is a slightly advanced question. By asking this question, what are you signaling about? Which entity you're putting top of mind? Company. Yes. Or the org. What you're signaling is it's not about what I get to own or what you are owning or like working styles and all that other stuff.
10:47 It is about what's right for the company. That's what you're signaling with this question. Okay, next, get clarity. See, people ask, what are your requirements for this role?
10:59 What do you want?
10:59 What are. What is the most common question about what are your requirements for this role? What does your ideal candidate look like? Have you. Like, does that sound familiar? What is your ideal candidate? This is nonsense question. Then the person will make up some nonsense like just say some just. Or just say, wait, did you read the job description? Don't ask such questions. Instead, make them think which is what is the one superpower you want this person to have that's going to make them think?
11:27 And now it's going to give you useful information. Right. For the next conversation. All right, the third question is this.
11:37 Okay, this is a slightly longer question, but again, instead of okay, you read the question and then I'll ask you what is the common version of this question that is not as powerful? You know this. The common version of this question that is not at all powerful. It's 50 candidates have asked.
11:56 Yes. What does success look like in this role Isn't nonsense.
12:00 Again, it's like, why are you asking
12:02 what does success look like in this role? Like five other candidates before you ask that exact question. And also like when you say what does success look like? You're again making it about yourself.
12:13 You don't realize it, but what you are saying is you're making it about yourself. Or what are your criteria for success for a person in this role? You sound too corporate also. Right? So instead frame it this way. This will make the individual think, what are the one or two things that truly matter that this person needs to score an 11 out of 10 on?
Summary
- Practice interviewing before targeting top companies to improve performance.
- Candidates can differentiate themselves by helping clarify what the company is looking for in a role.
- Understanding product leader archetypes (operator, craftsperson, visionary) is crucial for effective hiring.
- Kent Beck's 3X framework (explore, expand, extract) helps identify the right leadership style needed at different product stages.
- Three powerful questions to ask hiring managers:
1. What aspects of the product will you continue to own after hiring a head of product?
2. What is the one superpower you want this person to have?
3. What are the one or two things that truly matter for success in this role?
- Avoid common, unproductive questions that other candidates might ask, focusing instead on deeper, more strategic inquiries.
Questions Answered
What are some effective tactics for interviewing?
Practicing before interviews is crucial, especially before approaching top companies. It's advisable to gain experience and confidence through practice interviews before targeting your top choices.
What are the different types of product leaders?
There are three archetypes of product leaders: the operator, the craftsperson, and the visionary. Understanding these roles can help companies identify what they need in a product leader.
How do product leader needs change across different product stages?
In the Explore stage, a visionary or craftsperson is ideal. As the product expands, a craftsperson is needed to implement the vision, and eventually, an operator becomes essential in the late expansion and extraction stages.
What questions should candidates ask during interviews?
Candidates should ask about the company's vision, culture, and specific expectations for the role. These questions can lead to meaningful conversations and set candidates apart from others.
How can candidates clarify their role expectations during interviews?
Candidates should ask about the requirements and expectations for the role to ensure clarity. This helps signal their commitment to the company's needs over personal interests.