transcribe

Why the US Needs Nuclear Energy | Jordan Bramble, CEO of Antares | Ep. 11

Uncapped with Jack Altman · 45m · transcribed May 2026
More from Uncapped with Jack Altman Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Transcript

0:00 It was really around the 1970s that things slowed down. We we built something like 100 uh reactors uh between, you know, roughly 1950 and the early 1970s. I think we've built and turned on three since in the US on the grid. Wow. All right. Really excited to have this conversation with Jordan Bramble, CEO of Antar's. Jordan, thanks a ton for doing this conversation with me today. Thank you for having me. Yeah. We're going to talk all about nuclear today. Maybe before we get into it, could you give me like a little overview of like the nuclear market, the history in the US, you know, what's happened over previous decades and kind of catch us up to speed on where we are today.

0:34 Let's start from the beginning. So, um, the first, you know, artificial humanmade nuclear reactor ever was, um, the Chicago pile. So, 1942, I think it was. Um, they actually built it at the University of Chicago underneath of the football field. So, you know, right in the city in the middle of Chicago. And the idea was you stacked um something like 45,000 graphite blocks in order to moderate neutrons. Um I want to say it was like 50 tons of natural uranium in order to sustain a critical reaction.

1:05 And they actually only produced like a half watt of power, but that was the first um you know first kind of academic research reactor ever built. Um and the motivation behind it was was really um uh the Manhattan project was going on, right? So we're exploring nuclear fision for the development of weapons but then later actually for the production of plutonium because plutonium production is a byproduct of nuclear fision uh uranium fision. So built built a couple reactors after that um and you know by 1945 um 4547 so we're still in the 40s um we had plutonium producing reactors both um at Savannah River and at the Hannerford site in Washington all to support the weapons program. And then in parallel uh a naval officer by the name of Heyman Rickover started the naval nuclear propulsion program and I also want to say 1945. So you know all all these things are happening really fast at this point. He eventually became Admiral Rickover and is kind of the father of the nuclear navy. You know 1952 we had the first nuclear submarine. So the Nautilus which was a water cooled reactor and then in parallel to that they built the um the Seawolf which was a sodium cooled reactor. That was the first non-weapon application of nuclear with submarines. C certainly first first naval application. We'll actually get into it. The first uh kind of you know power producing civilian power producing reactor was actually a spin-off from a naval reactor core that they didn't end up using was the shipping port reactor in Pennsylvania. Uh they built it in like 18 months. So it's kind of spin-off from uh the nuclear navy programs. It's actually only a 60 megawatt reactor. Not long after that, we got the uh Yankee Row in Massachusetts, which which I want to say is like 100 megawatts, 120 megawatts, something like that. So, significantly smaller than what we um what we build today. I imagine at some point talk about small modular reactors.

2:55 You know, one thing I would highlight is actually the the kind of small concept is actually how we originally built reactors when we first started doing it. So, the Seawolf and the Nautilus both ran for something like 5 years. Um the Navy eventually settled on the um uh the water cooled reactor designs. Um and you know in part for just pragmatic reasons they were easier to build. Um it was easier easier to conduct maintenance on. You know also sodium like reacts violently with air and water and submarines go underwater, right? So there safety considerations as well. But you know, maybe one of the things kind of kind of takeaways of all of this is um the history of atomic energy actually came out of government-led sort of military focused programs and that's where the commercial sector um kind of originated from. So in in parallel to all of this um you know sort of mid50s going into the 60s um the Air Force and NASA also had their own nuclear program.

3:48 So at the Nevada test site, which is where we test uh or historically tested our nuclear weapons, um we had uh the Nerva program, which was a nuclear thermal rocket. So you circulate um hydro uh um liquid hydrogen through a nuclear reactor and exhausted out the back of a rocket engine. Uh and um it's like twice as propellant efficient as a chemical rocket. So you could get to Mars in half the time. We were actually building this stuff and testing it in the desert in in the 50s going going through the 60s. We also had a rover and Pluto which were um like nuclearpowered jet engines. Um the Air Force actually looked at developing a nuclearpowered um uh airplane which could basically stay in the air indefinitely. Wow. Um did that ever get built? uh ground tested and and we also there are examples where we flew airplanes with operating nuclear reactors on them to like you know shield the pilots and just kind of test all of that. Um, so there's some history there, but I don't think an actual nuclearpowered airplane has ever flown, I'm pretty sure. Going into the early 60s, so we had the SNAP program, which uh produced a reactor called the SNAP 10A, um, which uh, in 1965, uh, was actually launched into space and is still up there to this day. Um, so we as Americans publicly, you know, only ever launched one space reactor. Um the Soviets did something like 37, 38, 39 um even going all the way into the late 80s, early 90s. Uh where they would put um vision reactors in orbit in very low earth orbit because they have lower drag than solar panels. Um and they would do I believe it was it was it was radar either for um uh detecting missiles or tracking ships um the ROSAT satellites.

5:36 you know, going back to what I was saying earlier, really the um you know, the pressurized water reactor designs that that um ultimately ended up being commercialized originated out of the naval programs. Um it's kind of, you know, generally what we have on the grid today, the lightwater reactors and the PWRs. It was really around the 1970s that um you know, things slowed down. We we built something like 100 uh reactors uh between you know, roughly 1950 and the early 1970s. I think we've built and turned on three cents in the US on the grid. Wow. BWXT, the company that produced, I guess, all or the majority of those nuclear, you know, reactors for the Navy. When did that get going? Was that around the same time? So, BWXT primarily fabricates the fuel and other components of the reactors. And the reactors themselves um have always kind of varied either between um uh Westinghouse and General Electric uh that makes those. Um but you know by I want to say by the 50s or 60s um those you know those vendors were kind of baked in into those programs and they've always sort of split back and forth who's who's who's making the companies are obviously much older than that.

6:45 Yeah. Like 100 years old, right? General Electric may even be like 120 years old or something like that. Yeah. And so so we had this period where we're building a ton since then we've slowed down wildly obviously. What was the climate like? why why in your sort of you know telling of the history why did that happen? You know there's a lot of different reasons that people will cite and I almost think it's like overdetermined in a way. It was kind of all of these different things happened at the same time. Um so one you know we had um you know a couple safety incidents and um the you know what was so we didn't have a department of energy. We actually had the atomic energy commission. So all you know what is now the DOE all they did was nuclear energy and they were um you know for most of their existence actually all of these programs that I cited they were involved right so they were both um the regulator and the builder at the same time eventually you know congress decided that's probably not the best from a safety perspective and then you know the AEC became the department of energy and then they created a congressionally uh an independent agency the NRC the nuclear regulatory commission to have regulatory oversight over nuclear energy development At the same time that we were getting a new regulator, we were also losing demand for nuclear. So historically uh you know nuclear had kind of been catalyzed by the government by government funding and if you if you go back in time to the 1960s 1950s like R&D spend as like an overlay of the entire federal budget was something like you know it would fluctuate between 12 and 15% or something like that. Today it's probably around 3%. And those cuts really came in the early 1970s. And it was it was um some ways it's like 1971 we went off the gold standard. Not long after that we had the or really at the same time we had the like Iran energy crisis with the hostage crisis. Uh interest rates were skyrocketing. You know, service payments on the federal debt went up. And so this was like just budget austerity, right?

8:48 Um, so like you know we sometimes talk about how did we do all these things in the 50s and 60s. Well, you know, if you adjust what we spent on nuclear thermal rockets back then to today's dollars, it would have been like $10 billion in today's dollars. We just we're not doing large government-ledd programs of that scale anymore. Um, in fact, the naval nuclear program as it exists today, I would I would almost view as a little bit of a remnant of that era where, you know, it's tens of billions of dollars, you know, earmarked for those programs.

9:16 They have dedicated nuclear energy labs where we have national lab employees that are solely focused on serving the Navy. Um Oakidge and Idaho National Lab both both also have a dedicated workforce focused on naval reactors. They come up with the designs in house then they bring in their vendors and it's like you know billions of dollars to make these right. Um it's kind of unlike the broader discourse around defense tech now where um you know it's more like how do we get venture capital into this so that so that you know private capital sharing some of the cost of tech maturation with the taxpayer.

9:45 Yeah. You know that's happening for the first time in nuclear now. Yeah. Um it's actually you know I would be hesitant to say that like you know nuclear is going you know startup nuclear is going to look just like SpaceX where you know you've got these companies building rockets. It's it's it's a very different technological development arc, but you know, sort of the starting point is very similar, right? Where we had the Apollo program in space, just like we did with the Manhattan uh project, largely government-ledd, right? Lots of taxpayer dollars that go into this. Uh and then, you know, for various reasons, we just stopped doing it. Yeah. Right. And so, we stagnated in our ability to send tonnage to orbit to send people to space. And it took decades for SpaceX to come along and finally recitalize that.

10:26 Right. Largely funded by private capital. Yeah. I've seen a lot of people have talked about regulation in nuclear. They've talked about um kind of public sentiment, right? Like environmentalists killed nuclear, but I've seen very few people really comment on the the kind of financial changes that we went through in the 70s y and how we went from being something that was governmentled to not really having a true private sector to to to kind of carry this. Right. Yeah. I want to get into the technological arc that we're kind of on, but maybe right before that now fast forward to today.

10:59 It does feel like there's now like a much, you know, bigger drive for nuclear. You hear it in the sentiment in the ether a lot. You see it in how venture is operating now. Yep. what's sort of the lay of the land at the moment in terms of like what the appetite is for investment from you know the the public sector both in terms of you know the demand for it and like the willingness to sort of fund these efforts and things. Yeah, I would say we're seeing maybe three different drivers of this. One has kind of arisen more out of the like what is going to be our solution to climate change. I think we've as a society, we've gone far enough down that path that we've realized net zero is probably not possible without significantly more nuclear energy, right? Probably fusion orision. Well, fision is here today, right? But do we need fusion to get there or even fision has a path to get us to that kind of environmental impact?

11:54 Oh, we can certainly do it with just fision, right? Um I mean fision is carbon-f free power can do it. Yeah, the benefit of fusion is uh we'll set aside whether I agree with it or not, but the claimed benefits of of of fusion are um you can have atronic uh fusion reactions. So um you know a lot of the problems that you get from nuclear fusion like how do you shield against radiation? Um uh what do you do with the waste products? Um you don't have as much of that in fusion, right? problem with fusion is that it's, you know, perpetually 30 years away and you're working with novel materials in order to withstand the temperatures. Um, and those are kind of all unsolved technical problems that exist, right? You know, the kind of answer to climate change is is sort of the first part of that. The the second one is um, you know, just growth, right? So if you look if you if you look at like GDP per capita historically it correlates directly with um many kilowatt hours of of energy we're able to consume per capita. Um and we as Americans today actually consume less energy per capita than our grandparents did. So we've gotten more efficient. Um but we actually haven't really been able to drive new progress through unlocking new things with energy. You know some would say we've picked all of the lowhanging fruit but like I would disagree with that. Um, you know, like like Peter Teal has spoken a lot about this. We we actually travel slower on airplanes than we did in the 1970s. Like we used to have supersonic travel. Now we don't.

13:20 Right? So, you know, nuclear energy in many ways is another example of that. Like what we're seeing right now is an artificial intelligence. There's this new demand for infrastructure. We're going to need, you know, this large scale data center build out throughout the US. And the fundamental question is how are we going to power it? Are we really going to build out all of this transmission? uh we're not going to do it with solar and wind because the energy density is just not high enough to support that level of infrastructure.

13:44 So people are looking at nuclear again, right? And now you're seeing companies like Meta, Amazon, Google, they all have internal programs focused on, you know, how are they going to partner with the advanced nuclear industry and buy and deploy these reactors. And then the third maybe driver I would say is national security. So when the cold war ended, we also went through this arc of you know cutting back federal programs. So when Clinton was president, you know, really cut back a lot of defense spending from where it was historically and nuclear was actually particularly affected by that. Um and then we ended up in the war on terror where um you know in a lot of ways um like energy resilience uh was just not really a focus, right? We'd like fly diesel around on helicopters and stuff and you know just kind of do whatever it would take. But now, you know, we've reshifted our orientation where China is uh kind of the pacing factor for the war in the future. And um it's forcing us to think a lot about energy resilience here in the homeland. So like the way we would conduct operations or the way we would defend this country, most of the assets for that are here inside of the US. And so, you know, an example I'll give is like our nuclear weapons, right? The ICBM silos were built in the 70s. We didn't have the internet back then. So like planning for a cyber attack on the civilian grid wasn't really a thing that you had to plan for. Now you do. You know all of our targeting and command and control those run on you know compute facilities that also have to be able to operate even if there is no commercial power. Y you know Vandenberg Air Force Base uh we host our groundbased interceptors there which is how we would defend against incoming missile attacks. Same thing right that's also where national security space launch takes place. We launch things to space there. We need to be able to do that. Um, you know, even in times of whether it's a natural disaster or a cyber attack or something. Um, you know, you need that mission assurance. You know, broadly the DoD has started to think a lot more about energy resilience. You know, one of the things I would highlight about that as it pertains to nuclear is like the DoD is spending dollars on supporting tech maturation in this industry today, right? Um, which you aren't really seeing yet from some of these other markets. So there's a lot of hype about the data center nuclear opportunity. I think it's a great opportunity, but they're not really spending real money yet, right? Whereas the DoD is. So yeah, I would say that that's, you know, broadly what's driving um and actually I would add a a fourth to that, which is so I mentioned space nuclear earlier and how we did some of it in the '60s. Um we are seeing a lot of activity in space nuclear power and propulsion again and um in my view the thing that is driving that is the weaponization of space. Right? So, we started the Space Force in 2018. It's now 2025. You know, we went from like the the kind of first um iteration of the Space Force was we're going to send a lot of mass to orbit so that like, you know, if our adversaries take out our critical assets on orbit, we can reconstitute. We've got redundancy.

16:44 We've got survivability in numbers. And now it's very much moved to like you can publicly talk about putting weapon systems in space, which funny because when Space Force was announced, I remember like a lot of people kind of I feel at least my memory of it is people kind of made fun of it. Now it seems obviously important not that many years later. Yeah. There were all sorts of memes and stuff. Yeah. If you go back to 20 2018 to 2020, what was one of the best like federal government decisions we made? I think creating the the Space Force was was was probably one of them, if not the best one. Space is absolutely going to become a war fighting domain, right? Like if if if we went to war with another great power, the first thing they would do to us and one of the things we would try to do to them is, you know, we do targeting from space, right? We detect in incoming missiles from space, communications, GPS, everything that you rely on to fight a war is in space now. Yeah. Right. And so you would want to be able to take that out. Doing that by launching missiles from the ground is bad. Creates debris fields which can disrupt the commercial sector in space. It's also really expensive. you want to be able to drive down the cost of that and do it in maybe a way that has less long-term lasting impacts, right? And so that means increasingly being able to generate those effects um from orbit in orbit.

17:57 You're now seeing General Lighting and General Saltzman stand up publicly and speak at conferences and say, you know, uh we need offensive capabilities in space. We need space fires, you know, weapons in space. Um and they even specifically say non-kinetic effects. So things like lasers, high powered microwaves, particle beams, just zapping each other in space basically. Yeah. And um you know physics will tell us that once we are doing that the way that you gain a competitive edge is to have more powerful beams, right? And the way you do that is you generate more power. Do they need to be more powerful than the ability like once you can fry a satellite like why do you need to get more powerful at some point? You can engage over longer distances. Got it.

18:40 Right. How far can these things go in space? Like thousands of miles kind of thing. Yeah, about a thousand kilometers. Um so, you know, depending on how much power you're generating and and the size of the spacecraft and um 10 km up to 1,000 km. Um so, and and actually the president signed an executive order on at the time it was called Iron Dome for America. Now it's called Golden Dome. So, it's um sort of this return of space. Yeah. Well, um, you know, I think it's it's it's probably land space, you know, all the above, right? Um, and and we should actually get some guidance on what that architecture is going to look like in in, you know, kind of the coming months or so. But one of the things that calls out in that executive order is space-based intercept. And um you know the history of space-based intercept going back to the 80s was um you would use things like particle beams or lasers in space to shoot down the re-entry vehicles um from ICBMs right so you disable them you could make nuclear weapons obsolete a lot of that same technology that was you know kind of it was infeasible in the 80s because we didn't have the launch capability the the um you know directed energy itself was too immature back then. if you shrink some of that down, you know, by like an order of magnitude by a factor of 10, you know, it could be viable in the near term as like an ASAP and an anti-satellite capability. So, you can talk about these things now. The military is starting to speak publicly about them. Um, it becomes a no-brainer that you would want a nuclear power source to scale this technology up. And and actually again if you look back at the history of it in the 80s the vision was always kind of space reactors would be used to power these systems because um if if if you look at a solar powered system how does mass scale against kilowatts of power generated? It's like a linear relationship with a solar powered system. Um it's sublinear with nuclear.

20:32 So, you know, as you get to like around 175 to 100 kilowatts or so, um, you end up with a spacecraft that's much more mass inefficient or much more mass efficient than doing it with solar where you start to get huge solar panels basically. Yeah. The International Space Station is about 100 kilowatts and it's like the size of a football field. Wow. Yeah. And and we had to construct it on orbit, right? Can you talk a little bit about um the technology of like small modular reactors just like you know this is obviously what you're building but can you give us a little bit of the context on what this size you know this size of power delivery is what's the technology going into them what needs to happen from here to make this sort of feasible you know repeatedly yeah maybe I'll take it back to the history again so one thing I mentioned in the beginning is so you'll hear different definitions from different people on what is a small modular reactor. Um, you know, maybe we'll just kind of say sub 100 megawatts and below is is is an SMR.

21:29 100 megawatts and below. Yeah. And you know what we're doing, um, we like to refer to it as a micro reactor, which um, again there's different definitions from different people. Some people will say like below 20 megawatts as a micro reactor. Some people say below 10 megawatts as a micro reactor. You know, you're seeing people develop it, you know, singledigit megawatts. Now we're we're actually a kilowatt scale system. So targeting between 200 and 300 kilowatts. Um which is the equivalent of that you know 100 the football field of solar panels got you 100 kilowatts.

21:56 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean nuclear energy is one of the most power dense forms of energy that that you know known to man right that we have available to us. And this thing's how big just to put it in contrast to the football field. You could fit it on a truck bed 18 truck bed. Um so about the size of a sedan. So it's a truck bed versus two to three football fields of solar. Yeah. For space we would actually be developing something even smaller than that. Solar is something like 60 acres of land per per megawatt if I recall correctly. With a micro reactor you could do something similar in like an acre to a half an acre. You know going back to um the original question on like SMRs. So you know the the basic idea is um in order to drive down the cost of electricity and make it competitive um you know what we did in in sort of the first arc of um like grids scale deployment of nuclear was we just made these plants bigger and bigger right so the AP 10000 is a gigawatt scale plant what's kind of plagued the industry and so this sort of goes back to like what killed nuclear originally I would argue that you know we had like a multi-deade loss of demand which really killed a lot of the workforce And you know, we lost the ability to to do these things and we've never had enough demand sense to do things in quick enough succession that like you can cultivate the workforce needed to do them efficiently. So you get cost overruns, construction, you know, takes two to three times as long as you know it's originally planned to be. If you look at grids scale nuclear, like financing costs and the construction costs end up being like the vast majority of you the total plant costs, right? Um so as you're selling electricity like really what you're doing is paying up paying down that upfront capex. So um how do you solve this problem? One idea is uh you make these systems much smaller such that they can just be fabricated in a factory and then sent out to the site with minimal site prep and construction.

23:47 Right? So that's generally the idea around um SMRs. I would say with the larger SMRs, it turns out that they're generally not all that different than um like you're still end up doing a construction project. And so micro reactors are sort of a recognition, no, let's make them even smaller such that they can be truly factory manufacturable like the way we make cars, right? There are some people that that that you know would maybe make the claim that um making reactors in that way is actually going to make them cost competitive against gridscale nuclear. It's really heavily dependent on the fuel cycle because in a grid scale reactor, the fuel cost is like a singledigit percentage of of the total plant cost.

24:23 In a micro reactor, it's probably more like 40 to 50% of the total cost. So, you know, we're not really sold um us at Antar's, we're not really sold on, you know, you can do micro reactors at like 10 cents a kilowatt hour anytime soon. But what we're convicted about is like there's actually a very very large market for expensive power. Yeah. um to do things that you know you can only do with nuclear. Right. Right. And then there's all these factors where it's valuable that are not just about it being cheap. Y resilience. Exactly. And that's really what we've chosen to focus on as a business. It like nuclear really struggles to compete in commodity markets, right? Um and also, you know, I tend to think this is just, you know, my philosophy, but like spending a lot of capital to develop a product then to turn around and sell it at a as a commodity is just like not really an exciting business anyways, right? So what we've done is we've really tried to say you know what are the use cases what are the opportunities where um there's some mission effect some outcome that's really valuable you know to the end payer and you can only do it with nuclear right and you will pay a premium to have that um and that's really been our focus and you know commercial applications you know we're a dual use company there's commercial applications but um in the near term we're really excited about military and DoD nuclear both earth and space you know what we found by and large when we were getting started is a lot of the mission critical facilities or critical assets on our military installations um are actually kilowatt scale or you know you need megawatts of power but it's it's distributed in some way and so you would actually benefit from having multiple hundreds of kilowatt systems um you know deployed on an installation generating power close to the point of need you know it's very unlike what a lot of the other sort of commercial uh or or other developers that came before us are are focused on right um the use cases that we're most excited about.

26:12 Broadly, what I'll say is a lot of it is missile defense related. So, you know, I think I mentioned earlier like Vandenberg, you know, we have our groundbased intercept silos. Those need to be able to launch regardless of whether there's commercial power or not, right? Uh in the Arctic, we have our missile warning radars. So, we have the the longrange radar sites that that dot the Arctic. And Arctic, this way you don't have to like bring diesel up and down all the time. Exactly. And you even look at like civilian communities in those regions, they often many of them rely on diesel and they pay like 60 to 80 cents a kilowatt hour for electricity. You can definitely do micro reactors that are competitive with that.

26:46 So it's like even though it's premium power, it actually is competitive with like the commercial markets in some of those environments. One of the things that we found was when we really indexed, you know, kind of as much of these different assets as we could find in the DoD, um there's really an opportunity to build like thousands of these one day. that's that's the scale of of what's out there. Um and then you know you add in space and other opportunities as well where we kind of hit on it earlier right like if if if you want to power you know 100 kowatt laser uh or or something like that on orbit nuclear is really the best technology that you have to do it in the word you know SMR there's like modular I'm curious about like what are like the break points of the technology you know like the company that makes something that does 100 kilowatts you know you can do 200 like 300 like where do you where are the moments where you switch over and say like a whole different architecture is best when you get to a different size of like energy delivery.

27:40 It does depend on the design itself. Um so in our case, we're a heat pipe cooled design and I would argue it is single-handedly the best technology for you know very small reactor designs like ours. The best coolant technology. Can you share what that is? The heat pipe. Yeah. So, a heat pipe um they were actually invented in the in I want to say 1958 u maybe it was the early '60s but um they were actually invented at Los Alamos National Lab specifically for space nuclear. So, the idea is uh it's a pipe with a vapor chamber and then in the in the inner lining of the pipe there's um like a wick structure and um there's a working fluid in it. So, in our case it's sodium. reactor heats up, sodium vaporizes, which causes it to travel down the pipe and um move heat as it does. So when it gets to the cool end of the pipe, it condenses again and um capillary forces, so surface tension in the wick actually brings it back. And that cycle just repeats uh and the pipe gets to one consistent temperature and you're just relying on phase change to move heat. So there's no pumping. Um there's kind of no active mechanism to do that. It's like a fascinatingly simple technology, yet the physics is is complicated. And um the other thing I think is really cool is despite being invented for space nuclear, there's heat there's copper water heat pipes in your laptop. They're in our smartphone. Like it's like a ubiquitous technology. Um uh heat pipes are being used in radiators on satellites in space. Um you know, it's kind of started from nuclear and then branched out into many different applications. Um, but another thing that we really like about it is, you know, we build them ourselves and test them ourselves and it's fast and iterative.

29:19 It's it's very unlike, you know, going out and having to design a new turbo pump every time you want to change something in your design. So, um, it allows us to iterate much faster on electrically heated prototypes. You know, the issue with them is um, as you scale these designs up, you end up with just a lot of metal in your core that eats neutrons and um, it just becomes less efficient. So the reactor size just kind of explodes as you go to larger larger sizes. And so you typically want to move to another another coolant. So different reactor designs have a different degree of scalability in them themselves. Um but what we can do is uh we can actually pair these systems up into a bank of systems as well. Right?

29:58 So if you needed a couple megawatts of power um you know we could put you know let's call it three to six of them together right in a in a bank. Those are kind of the options that you have. Cool. Yeah. So, as you think about like selling to defense, I'm curious what you've learned, what goes into this. You know, obviously this is like um a very hot area right now. You know, probably second after AI is like defense and American dynamism and obviously the way that you need to work both with the product you're building and who the customer is is very different than like building a SAS app and selling it to a SAS customer, you know? So like what what have you sort of experienced so far and what does it take to sort of work with like the DoD? You know, it's funny that you mentioned SAS apps because um I actually do think there is an opportunity to bring more like kind of like product style thinking that exists in SAS to hard tech. It's like one of the things that we found to be very successful is you know we don't just come in and like sell a box of power and you know try to get someone to figure out what to do with it. like we actually invested a lot of upfront effort with many of the folks we work with in the military in like understanding what problem that they're trying to solve in the first place. We actually started doing this before we even had a reactor design, right? Um which is hard by the way because like how do you get people to talk to you when you don't have a technology yet, but like you also want to build the right technology for them in the first place. For for us that was kind of like an iterative like credibility building exercise where like you know you start out you ask some questions and then you come back with something and then like over time people get comfortable with you where they can kind of chart your progress right so I would just say like obsessing over the problem the end user is is extremely important you know working backwards from like what what mission effect is trying to be created here. The hard part about selling to defense is is like there is no like customer persona, right? There literally is not one.

31:51 There's like an end user who is a beneficiary of your product. They may, you know, either benefit from it or use it in some way, but they're not the person that buys it, right? Someone else is going to be responsible for buying it. Um, and then there's probably people in the Pentagon that have some kind of policy or regulatory oversight or they serve some planning function that decide when those budgets exist for uh, you know, ultimately an office to be able to buy it. Uh, and then Congress has a say in that too. And so a lot of what you do is actually you connect the dots, right?

32:21 Which, um, there there's kind of different philosophies on defense tech. One is all of that is really really hard. So rather than like have to do all of that, what you you do is you just, you know, you look at the budget justification books that get published every year and there's kind of a three-year budget forecast in there and you just look at what is the DoD already going to be spending money on and you know which of those programs do you think have lasting effect and you just go build something that you can sell to one of those, right? There's a lot less market risk in doing that. problem though is um once those markets are baked, there's like 50 other companies that are trying to do the same thing.

32:57 And I tend to think if you look at like the history of companies that have been really awesome like venture returns, they were doing something transformational, right? Like that's the only like that's the only predictable way to win is to just do something absolutely transformational. Yeah. So I I tend to think the way to do defense tech is you definitely don't just like show up with the best product in the world and say you know how do we spend years getting someone to buy this because that doesn't work but rather you you develop an information edge where you have some insight into how the budgets are going to evolve in years to come. Uh and then you can be developing a product before the before the market is really there. Right. Does the fact that it sort of like starts with like a mission that they're trying to accomplish and then you're working backwards. Did that lead to you naturally building multiple products over time? I think you really have to.

33:47 Yeah. Um I I I actually think this is really important in defense tech because one way to think about a program office in the DoD is like you just think of it like um like sales channels. There's a lot of work that goes into getting your foot in the door. But um once you've established a relationship, you know, they could be 10, 20, 30 year relationships that you're compounding on top of, right? It's actually like high value and smart to find a way to get your foot in the door, start solving a problem for them. Yeah. And then figuring out what the synergies are between that and other things that you're doing. That's what it seems like cuz so much of the work is not just about this project at this time. It's about partnering with them to like really help them solve some large set of problems probably around some center.

34:30 Yep. Exactly. Why do you think LA has become such a hub for hard tech? Is it related to this at all where there's, you know, some deep set of learnings and relationships that are required or some set of people or is it an ethos or like what's happening that's making LA seem to become, you know, such a hot bed for hard tech companies right now? I would say it's it's kind of all of the above. Um, a lot of people will say SpaceX is there and you've got spin-offs from SpaceX, but I would say actually go back further like why was SpaceX there, right? Primes. Well, that uh but you know it's Hughes Aircraft was started there, right? Um the South Bay of LA has just always sort of been a a hub of Boeing, right? Always been a hub of aerospace and defense. The workforce is already there, right? It's like one of the you know, if you look for like a machinist wel welding workforce, it's like one of the largest in the country in the South Bay of LA. The availability of industrial real estate that's zoned for manufacturing. Um it's one of the best places in the country. A lot of people don't think that when they think LA, but like it's just and it's been that way since since, you know, the Cold War, the end of World War II. Um, you've got the Port of Long Beach there, right?

35:38 So SpaceX and other companies are making rockets. They're sending them down to the port. They go through the Panama Canal and then they make it to the Cape. You know, it's workforce, it's industrial real estate, it's, you know, some of the other just um kind of key advantages that the the city has, right? I I think if you really studied it like probably even like the roadways and the interstate highways there are just like better for trucking than like doing it in San Francisco for instance, right?

36:01 You know, I think there's some really interesting history uh in in LA even as it pertains to nuclear. So we talked about the Nerva programs, the nuclear thermal rockets. Those the rockets were actually built by um so Westinghouse made the reactors, but Aererojet made the rockets uh at the ISUsa plant um you know kind of in the LA suburbs and then sent them out to the Nevada test site. Uh I also mentioned SNAP, the reactor that went to space that was actually built in the Santa Susanna Hills. Uh and they did other ground tested reactors there too. Uh we didn't really get into this, but the army actually had a nuclear power program that ran um from like the 50s into the early 70s. Um and it was another one that was kind of cut when when we had budget austerity. Um one of the things they prototyped was a potential mobile reactor called the ML1 that was uh brought to Idaho National Lab. But either the reactor or at least a significant amount of the componentry was also built by Aererojet at the ISUsa plant. So, there's just always been a kind of a deep history around these things that, you know, we've we've probably both heard people talk about the history of Silicon Valley and why it has such staying power and it's really just like the network effects and the natural advantages that compound, right?

37:10 Yeah. It's really hard to undo those things. Totally. I guess maybe that kind of goes into my next question which is around like the type of company culture, you know, and I uh you know, LAS was a software company. I've spent a lot more time with software companies than here and there's a certain cadence to those companies. There's a certain culture and obviously each one's different but there's things in common. When you think about, you know, building a hard tech company, y working with defense, you know, doing nuclear energy, there's all these things that are really different.

37:38 Like the timelines are very long, the stakes are very high. It's serious work. There's science involved. You know, there's engineering involved. What are the things that you found most notable about building the team, the culture, the operating cadence? you know our market defense typically slow nuclear also typically slow and it's the total opposite like maybe the extreme other end of the spectrum is like if you work at a marketplace business like Door Dash or something and like when those kind of companies work the pace of the company is largely dictated by the customer right like the customer is just pulling you to move as fast as you possibly can to keep up y um it's like you get a network effect going and you're just like holding on for dear life and like you go to sleep and then you wake up the next day with more work than you had the day or there's a fire overnight or something. Yeah. You just do whatever you can to keep up, right?

38:26 Businesses like ours, I think the locus of control is actually much more internal, right? Like you set the pace, right? You dictate it. And you know, maybe the mindset shift is like you have to be doing things every single day, small things to like make things go faster. So, you know, we have long timelines to develop a product. We want to turn a reactor on by end of 2027. Um, you know, very ambitious. Um, but we talk about that timeline every single day. sound, you know, in some 2027 sounds futuristic, but it's not that long from now. It's not that not that far away, right? Um we talk about it every single day. We um break down a lot of our technical development into smaller milestones that we're using to just create a constant sense of urgency.

39:02 So, a lot of the culture building is really around creating and cultivating this sense of urgency. One of my favorite values that we have is um we say just make it happen. And it's kind of a recognition that like the industry is slow. The customer is not going to drive our pace. it's actually up to us to come in and do something every single day to drive the pace. Um the interesting thing about this too is you know what I've come to really believe is like why is there not already more money for nuclear in the federal budget? Why is Congress not already appropriated more funds? Why is the DoD not already doing more to buy this technology? And overwhelmingly, you know, the feedback that we've received and what we think the answer is is actually just the tech isn't built yet. It's just not mature enough for them. like when you plan your budgets 3 years out, you're not really going to set aside large amounts of money until you know that you're going to be able to buy something, right? And so the speed at which we move is what is ultimately going to cultivate our market. Um, and I think there's something like really powerful and exciting about that to come in and think about that every day. For sure. Um, the other cultural thing I think about a lot is what we do is incredibly multiddisciplinary. So um yes there's nuclear engineering but there's material science there's thermodynamics um turbo machinery electrical engineering structural engineering like if you can I mean we develop in-house software if you can name an engineering discipline you probably have to do it to build a reactor there's competing priorities between all of those uh different disciplines right so like the reactor design that's the best on paper from an economics or performance perspective when you Just look at neutron economy from a nuclear engineering perspective is almost never perhaps universally never the reactor design that's going to be the most manufacturable and the quickest to build. Right? So you always have a a tension between those different groups.

40:56 So one thing that's um we think a lot about is like you know how do we make sure that um like there's no like priest class, right? Like everybody has an equal voice. We also have this cultural value that we say let great ideas beat great great arguments. And so like we really try to deliberately bring back to the Yeah. The you know the the idea itself the merit should be how well somebody argued something. Exactly.

41:19 Yeah. I used to always say that like a very uh persuasive person with a bad idea is super dangerous. 100% agree. Yeah. Especially in something like this where there's so much like interdicciplinary complexity. you know, you almost have to force yourself to argue like the other person's perspective, right? And I think you just make better decisions when you do that. So, we've really tried to be deliberate about that. How do you find and assemble like the teams for all of this? It's so interdisciplinary. There's such, you know, deep knowledge in various areas.

41:48 There's government, there's, you know, there's all this different stuff like how are you how are you spending time figuring out how to assemble these teams given the wide range? So we talked earlier about like what are the things that are driving this new interest in nuclear, right? So one of the things that I think is just amazing, so rewarding, so inspiring about what we're doing is, you know, this technology has great national security implications. It's going to make us a safer, more powerful country. You know, it will be a part of the solution to climate change.

42:22 It's also going to expand, you know, humanity's reach into space. Like can you name another technology that allows you to do all of those things that you get to come in and work on? Pretty hard. Pretty hard. Right. So the mission is like incredibly inspiring to a lot of people. Yeah. It's the type of company where you don't have to work very hard to explain why this is important versus you know with other companies you have to like really go to great lengths to get the mission to resonate. This one it sort of speaks for itself. And I think a lot of the people that we get that show up are default missionary right like they they they want to work on something that's incredibly inspiring and motivating. Um, and you often want to do it at the intersection of like hard and interesting technical challenges, which I kind of got out earlier like the interdisciplinary nature of this and the complexity of it is a lot of what makes it really fun to come in and and and work on every day. So, you we did an on-site interview recently where um someone works at a really awesome company currently, but like the technology problems are kind of already solved, like not the best use of a skill set anymore, and loves that like there's true novelty in what we're doing. We lead with that a lot. And then the other thing is um you know we're a 2-year-old company at this point. Um I'm incredibly proud of the progress that we've made in a really short amount of time. You can look at our momentum and compare it to some of the other like options um in the nuclear industry and we kind of stand out in that regard, right? So I think that's like pretty exciting and appealing to a lot of people. on that pacing thing. Once you get a nuclear reactor turned on for the first time, does scaling up go quickly from there or do you need like a lot of time then to like get into like the manufacturing side and is that like a whole another problem for like you know 3 years from now? Jordan, definitely another problem.

43:59 But one of the things that um you know I'll just kind of tie it back to the customer. the the reason um for small reactors the reason we're seeing this new customer demand um is you know it's resiliency right and what that what that often means is like when someone says I want resilient energy and they want nuclear uh to be the solution to that what that often means is they're familiar with the fact that our grids scale nuclear power plants have like 93% capacity factors it's like the highest uptime of of any energy production method that we have, right? So, the expectation is micro reactors are going to have that. They're not going to have that right off the bat, right? We're going to have to have like iterative development cycles to get to that. Um, so you know, we see ourselves building multiple test reactors and using the first test reactor to actually drive down the cost in the timeline of doing the second and the third, which by the way is another huge benefit of building such a small scale system is we can build our first reactor and iterate to the second and third with like sums of money that are very reasonable to raise with venture capital. If you start with like the, you know, SMRs, hundreds of megawws, um, kind of large grid scale reactors, you can't really do that, right? because you might need, you know, billions 10 billion just to get to a first of a kind. It's really hard to then say we're going to turn around and then do the next thing after that and, you know, maybe this time we won't need 10 billion, but we're still going to need like five, right? But in parallel to that, yeah, we see ourselves scaling up manufacturing as well. Um, and we eventually want to be able to make like, you know, over a hundred of these a year. Um, which, you know, again, for us is, you know, that's like 30 megawatts a year of production. So it's it's it you know it's crazy kind of in volume of assembly but not crazy in terms of the size of uh you know power that's being produced. Awesome. Well, it's uh it's very inspiring. Yeah, this conversation was awesome. I really appreciate you making time to to have it and yeah, thanks for spending the hour. Thanks for having me.

Summary

The conversation with Jordan Bramble, CEO of Antar's, delves into the history and future of nuclear energy in the U.S., highlighting its evolution from military applications to potential civilian use. Bramble discusses the stagnation in nuclear reactor construction since the 1970s, the recent resurgence in interest due to climate change and national security, and the innovative approach of developing small modular reactors (SMRs) and micro reactors.

- The U.S. built around 100 nuclear reactors from the 1950s to the early 1970s but has only constructed three since then.
- The history of nuclear energy is deeply intertwined with military programs, particularly during the Manhattan Project and the development of naval nuclear propulsion.
- The decline in nuclear reactor construction is attributed to safety incidents, regulatory changes, and a decrease in government funding for R&D.
- Current drivers for renewed interest in nuclear energy include climate change solutions, energy resilience, and national security concerns.
- The development of small modular reactors (SMRs) is seen as a way to reduce costs and improve manufacturing efficiency by allowing factory production.
- Antar's focuses on micro reactors, which are smaller and designed for specific applications, including military and remote community power needs.
- The company emphasizes a culture of urgency and interdisciplinary collaboration to drive innovation and meet the complex demands of the defense sector.
- Bramble highlights the importance of understanding customer needs and building long-term relationships within the defense industry to successfully introduce new technologies.
© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram