Section Insights
Introduction to the Audible
What is the Audible and how can fans engage with it?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the offseason. Fans are encouraged to subscribe on YouTube and follow on social media to build the community.
- The Audible is a college football podcast.
- It airs three times a week during the season.
- Fans can engage by subscribing and following on social media.
Playoff Rankings Discussion
Why did Indiana drop in the playoff rankings?
Indiana dropped in the rankings because they had a bye week while other teams around them won, and the teams they had beaten also lost, affecting their strength of schedule metrics.
- Indiana's drop was due to a bye week and losses by teams they had beaten.
- Strength of schedule metrics significantly impact playoff rankings.
- The committee's evaluation can lead to surprising outcomes.
Future of the 2014 Playoff
What are the implications of the new 2014 playoff format?
The transition to a 12-team playoff format has been a long process, and while it was initially met with skepticism, it is now a reality that will change how teams are evaluated and ranked.
- The 12-team playoff format is a significant change in college football.
- The process to implement this change took several years.
- Initial skepticism has turned into acceptance of the new format.
Nebraska's Coaching Situation
What is the current state of Nebraska's football program?
After losing four straight games, Nebraska fired their offensive coordinator, raising questions about the job security of head coach Matt Rule, just a year into his tenure.
- Nebraska has lost four straight games.
- The offensive coordinator was fired following the losses.
- There are concerns about the head coach's job security.
Ranking Process Insights
How does the ranking process for teams work?
The ranking process involves a consensus-building exercise where committee members vote on teams, and the initial groupings are based on polling the room rather than a simple tally of votes.
- The ranking process is a consensus-building exercise.
- Committee members cannot vote for their own teams.
- The process is more complex than traditional voting methods.
Transcript
0:00 Welcome back to the Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine. Three times a week during the season, twice a week during the offseason. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and xaudible show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.
0:32 >> >> Welcome to the Audible presented by Trader Joe's. I'm Stuart Mandel joined as always by Bruce Felin as we go into week 11 guys. Some more coaching news this week. Ruckers bringing back Greg Shiano. We'll get to that. We'll talk mailbag. we're going to start with the playoff, both the 12 team playoff and the 2014 playoff. By the way, if you like the Audible, please subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and on YouTube, Audible Show. You can also follow us on Twitter, on Instagram, Audible Show. All right, so the new rankings came out on Tuesday nights and we saw Indiana have the world's worst by week and drop by five spots. we saw Miami drop from 1 to seven. We saw Ohio State plummet. We saw Oregon get back in the mix. Bruce, what was your main takeaway?
1:29 >> Why does the committee not respect Tennessee? I'm sorry. They had him way too low last week. And then, as we said, they were going to play Kentucky, who, by the way, that was the best win Alabama has. And they and they whipped Kentucky, right? So, this is a team with the exact same record as Alabama. They beat Alabama handily. wasn't like it was like a one-point game. They beat Alabama handily. They beat Kentucky handily. and they're doing this thing where it's like we don't even want to consider that head-to-head because we've separated them into completely different realms of our thought process as if Tennessee is a Sunb Belt team. It's ridiculous. And so when Hunter Urac the committee chair was asked about it in his press conference afterwards I want to just quote it here in ex this is a question in explaining one of the difference between Alabama and Tennessee used Mississippi State as a quality win at the time. Jeff Webbby said after the game that it was pretty obvious Kamario Kamario Taylor couldn't do anything with his legs. Fluff Bothwell their star running back only had one carry. Are injuries being considered in Are injuries being considered naming Tennessee a quality win? Hunter Urchek, I don't know that we've listened to Jeff Leby's interviews, but Kamario Taylor played in that game and Alabama dominated that game. Mississippi State at the time was 4-0 on everybody's radar screen in college football. All right.
2:59 Well, he was banged up coming into the game as was Fluff Fluff Both. Fluff Bothwell didn't play. Again, if you're going to give them credit like it was a it was Kamario Taylor at full strength, which it clearly was not one thing, but also you're saying, "Oh, they have four great wins and miss and Tennessee only has two and you're including Mississippi State, which has not been the same since and which has been a shell of itself since." I think that's really kind of stretching too much. And this comes back to my overarching point of why I hate this stupid friaking show. Because you have to twist yourself into knots to try to justify stuff that we don't really need to know who the committee thinks is number 11 and number eight at these points in the process cuz a lot of it's going to change. But instead, they get themselves into this in these stupid positions. And he steps all over himself as he, you know, does pretty much weekly. In this case, it was getting into Tennessee versus Alabama. Look, Tennessee may face Plant later in the year, but they shouldn't be that far behind a team they beat by 16 points.
4:09 And they have the same record, Ralph. >> Yeah. And just to be incredibly clear, when I rank teams for the AP, I have Tennessee ahead of Alabama. I have Texas, Tennessee, Alabama in a in a group of three in that order because that's what the results said >> because you're a logical person, Ralph. >> Yeah, I like to think so, but you know, others may others might disagree. Mileage may vary. but what I would also say is I think I understand where they're getting this at here. I I suspect they are leaning more into a couple of metrics this year. And they're giving hints of this. I don't just I'm not just guessing here cuz he literally said in an evaluation of Alabama, strength of record, strength of schedule. Alabama's in those two metrics is is actually a lot better than Tennessee. Like they they have they rate their schedule is tougher than Tennessee's their strength of record.
5:04 Tennessee played a terrible Georgia Tech team in the in the non-conference. Florida State is better. I know Florida State ain't great. Florida State is definitely better than Georgia. >> What are we doing? What are we doing here? They play head to head. But time out. Time out. Time out. I I All I'm doing, Bruce, is trying to give you an explanation. I'm just I'm just trying. You can reject it, but please let me explain it. You can totally reject it.
5:27 If you're looking at these numbers and you're looking at metrics, Tennessee is actually a lot lower than Alabama in most of the metrics. So, if that's what you are leaning into, that's how you get. We think Alabama is one of the top four teams in the country and we are going to examine them against the top four teams in the country. We think Tennessee is more along the lines of an 8 to 12 10 to 11 10 to 12 team in the country. So we are going to examine them in that and that's it. Like again now I I think it's wrong and I showed it wrong being wrong on my own AP ballot. I don't I don't I am not getting that hung up on those metrics. I'm leaning into the actual result on the field, but I I think that's why we're getting the result we're getting with Alabama and Tennessee. Respond to that with respond, but just don't yell at me.
6:23 >> I won't. so I think what what you're insinuating the committee is doing is the committee has a big juicy steak in front of it and instead it's looking outside and it sees a picture of some kind of fake meat and they're going, "We're going to go eat that instead >> because that's weird." But but no, what I'm saying is what I'm saying is this and this is where I will push back on you. I think >> Let me finish that point though. All I'm saying to you is >> All I'm saying to you is if the teams hadn't played each other, I'm fine with it. If the game was tied, they decided in overtime, eh? Yeah.
7:04 >> But it wasn't close. It was a 16-point game, right? And so I just think you got to keep the main thing the main thing. And for whatever reason, the people who do this show, not our show, >> the Tuesday night moronic display that it is, who like twist themselves in knots, they never they seldom keep the main thing the main thing. And that is maddening to me. And that's it. I'm done with that. So, I think the overarching problem with the rankings this year, if I'm going to find a problem, though I didn't necessarily have a problem with the Indiana thing that became a big talking point yesterday, is I think so much emphasis has been put on strength of schedule that now you're ranking teams really leaning into the who they played, Stu, as opposed to the how they played. And I do wonder if you're overcorrecting on that this year since you've been hammered over the head over the last couple years about strength of schedule.
7:57 >> Yeah, I mean they are definitely citing I don't know if this was the first time I've ever heard this but it was pretty rare. Hunter Urchek was citing specific strength of schedule numbers when talking about this Tuesday night which I think is great except they don't publish those rankings. So we just have to take his word for it. Guys, this is the biggest fake controversy because it's going to work itself out just like Miami Notre Dame last year. If they both finish 10 and two, Tennessee will be ahead of Alabama. I have no doubt about it. T Alabama's remaining schedule is light. Tennessee plays LSU next week.
8:30 Their resumes will be enough that the head-to-head will trump everything. And by the way, if they're both 10 and two, they will both be safely in anyway, and it's really not that important. But I I actually was thinking about how like in this cont nobody's stopping to think like wow they have a two loss team number three in the country in the entire history of the CFP rankings. We've never had a two loss team in the final top four of the CFP rankings and they they have them now like with you know seven and two and I don't know I mean they're coming off a great win don't get me wrong but you know the fact that the fact that they have a two loss team that high Ralph tells me yes they are putting much more of an emphasis on strength the schedule than they used to otherwise UCLA would be above them right you undefeated two loss two loss ahead of undefeated and not from, you know, the group of six from the Big 10 is definitely is definitely interesting to me.
9:27 >> Well, think about what happened with Indiana and we talked about strength of schedule. The reason why Indiana dropped, which made sense to me because again, I did the same thing on my ballot. Everybody around them won while the Hooers was were on vacation for a week and all the teams that Indiana has beaten lost this week. So again, if you're using metrics that that evaluate strengths of schedule and strength of record, those metrics are going to take a hit when Ohio State loses and bing bing bing bing bing, all these teams lose, right?
9:58 >> Also, I think a lot of people looked at that going, why isn't Indiana that high in the first place? Like last year was a little bit of an adjustment, I think, too. >> So, moving ahead to next year and the 2014 playoff, we talked about it a little bit the other day. Ralph, you and Chris Fanini, I thought had a really good story that went up. So, this was announced on Monday, so your story went up on Tuesday of the behind the scenes of how the heck did this happen. I mean, I vividly remember where I was the day that the first report came out that the Big 10 was trying to sell a 248 playoff and just being like, like that's just silly, right? And I think a lot of people reacted that way and now it's here and it and it's pretty it it's a it's you know given we've all covered this sport for a long time.
10:49 Usually things move very slowly. They take years. You know when they went from 4 to 12 that was a 5year process I believe from from the first we're going to get a working group together to it actually happening. Right. Also, as you know, I've been very the thing I've been very bothered by is that they've totally ignored the fans. And Ralph, describe the lead of that story. >> Yeah. And I'll I'll this a hat tip to Chris Vanini cuz he contributed this part of it. specifically contributed this part of it is the the CFP did some internal polling, right, which we hear a lot about in political campaigns. and their internal polling showed that the fans didn't really want this. I think it was 10 15% >> less than 10% wanted 24 >> had had a had an approval rating of of you know less than 10% on 24 >> but yet they were undeterred by that because also within that polling I believe if I remember correctly it showed that well we'll watch it anyway right we're going to we're probably going to watch it anyway >> watch the playoff anyway or we'll watch >> we'll watch the playoff anyway right we'll watch that my thing has always been the regular season.
12:04 >> So, they plowed ahead knowing that it would be unpopular with the hopes that, as often happens in other in pro sports, yes, it's unpopular, yes, we don't want this, but once it's there, we quickly adjust and we and we get it. And again, I think what if you haven't read the story, I would encourage you to do so on the athletic, but I think the main takeaway from me that I've always been pushing that I tried to get across in the story was amazing how gently this thing fell into place. As you said, in February, in November of 2025, this thing was presented to the Big 10 to the other A4 commissioners and it generally received we don't really love this. Like that's like what are we doing here? Are you crazy?
13:01 by February when they reconvened after basically saying in December, hey, like we're just going to stay at 12. We're not going to expand because the SEC and Big 10 can't can't come to an agreement here. SEC wants 16. Big 10 once bigger than that, so we're just going to stay with status quo. When they reconvened in February, the ACC all of a sudden was like, "Hey, this 24 thing sounded pretty good." Like everybody started to quickly pivot. most notably Notre Dame because I think Pete Bvakqua has a good relationship with both Sanki and Petiti and he became something of a bridge. I think Notre Dame sitting in a chair of Notre Dame, you realized I think what Pete would would say is he realized that a I need these teams to continue scheduling me and if this helps them be more bold in their non-conference scheduling, I want that.
13:53 And B, we need to keep more schools engaged like and and give carrots and and rewards to schools who are going to be we're asking to invest 3040 million into their football roster. And it just was so interesting how in February there was a pivot on a in April they decided, okay, let's dig into this. And it just very like without a lot of fan fear from the outside. I don't think we realized from the outside how much progress they were making and how there was really no debate after April. It was just like, hey, can we get this done? And if the money works, we're going to get this done.
14:34 >> Okay, Ralph, like I want to ask you guys both this. What are the things that maybe cuz obviously we've talked a lot about how Stu feels about it and about the polls and everything. We know now conference championships for the power leagues are going away. What are the other things that maybe people who aren't reading the detail stuff will be because it's happening next year. It's not like there's like a big acclamation period, right? So, what are the things you guys think that maybe either people haven't taken note of or will be like, whoa, this is this is a change.
15:04 >> Bunch of starts too. >> Well, you know, start with the calendar, right? start with the fact that and it had already been announced, right, that week zero is now week one next year and I think teams are kind of adjusting their schedules to that. The other scheduling thing is now you have to play a 10th power four opponent and so those most most were already doing that but like the schools in the Big 10 that weren't are having to scramble to find somebody to play next year. I did get a little chuckle out of the fact that Florida canceled Notre Dame. this is the big thing that's supposed to improve everybody's schedules and they immediately cancel that one because they're already playing Florida State.
15:42 but then in terms of like when the games are being played. So, we are so conditioned to the first weekend of December is the conference championships and the second week in December is the Heisman and the Army Navy game. And then since we started doing 12, the third weekend in December starts the playoff. Push that all back up a week. First weekend of December is now basically a by-week for everybody except Army and Navy. And now the playoff's going to start the second weekend of December, like December 10th or whatever, whatever that might be next year. And then from there, right Ralph, it's the same as what we have now.
16:19 Right. The the existing quarterfinals and semifinals as they are currently scheduled will stay where they are even beyond the ones that are already scheduled out. Simply put, it just they don't have a lot lot of room to move. You can't continually move up the season. So for the the next six year and also they're going to remain at bull sites. That's going to continue to be locked in through the rest of the five years. So two round the first two rounds on campus quarters semis and bowls neutral sight national championship game that's all going to that's going to stay the same. The big changes will be the first two weeks of the playoff when you have eight first round games, eight second round games, all of them on campus. That's a lot of games, Ralph. We have four right now on the first weekend. Now we're saying eight, both of the first two weekends.
17:19 When are they going to be played? >> They're going to be played Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. folks, get ready for some playoff football kicking off at 6 pm Eastern time on a Thursday, right? They're going to try to create exclusive television windows for each game. There's going to be some overlap. There's going to be a game ending while another one is kicking off, a game ending on ABC while another one's kicking off on ESPN or on ESPN, and the other one's going to get bumped to kickoff on ESPN, too. Ralph, it's also going to be opposite NFL on Thursday night.
17:54 >> It It will absolutely be opposite NFL on Thursday night. It will absolutely It will. Now, if you start on the earlier Saturday, you won't get Saturday NFL games. So, that's >> the Thursday night. And the Thursday night games typically aren't great, but >> no doubt. But that it does help on that that first Saturday of December which would norm excuse me that second Saturday of December. Remember that usually is Army Navy Day. There's no NFL. So the the the NF the college football playoff first weekend won't go head-to-head with the NFL at least on the Saturday. That's a good thing.
18:32 They're going to squeeze in four games. All I would say is they >> is there 10:30 Eastern game. Please tell me there's going to be a 10:30 Eastern game. >> I I don't know how. This is what I would say, Stu. They better hope there's some West Coast teams and Mountain Time Zone teams that they can work in here or it's going to be pretty weird. >> Well, they've had, if you notice the last couple weeks, ESPN has had a and it's always Texas Tech for some reason, a 9:30 Eastern game that kicks off at 8:30 Central. And you can be very confident you're going to have teams that could play in that window.
19:07 >> No doubt. Hey, listen. I remember when I was in covered Mississippi State and Old Miss, we had games that's that kicked off at 8 o 8 8 local or even 8:30 local. So, that's not that crazy. Nonetheless, yeah, they're going to try to squeeze in a lot of games in a small window of time. And that was one of the things that was that was that was tricky about this. Listen, we have a lot of time to answer more of your questions about how things work. I'm sure we're going to have to talk about it 10 more times and maybe even 50 more times.
19:37 start because I know everybody's going to forget that. Oh my god, there's 2014 playoff. How does this thing work? >> We're going to take a break and when we come back, we got a couple things to discuss, including a little bit of a belated discussion about Nebraska. All right, we originally planned to talk about this on our Sunday episode. We didn't get to it. Nebraska has lost four straight and after this most recent loss to Illinois, Matt Rule fired Dana Hogerson as his OC. Now, there's a lot of talk, Ralph, about how hot is Matt Rule's seat, which is pretty crazy given we are barely a year removed from him getting a huge contract extension, which means he has a 60s something million dollar buyout. Is his hot seat really hot? I don't think so because he just got that contract extension, Bruce. I I I think the point of giving him that contract extension was to avoid going down this road for at least another couple of years and you're going to lean into stability, but you know, bestlaid plans and him firing Dana Holerson and calling him an offensive genius.
20:51 Okay. you know, again, I I don't think Matt Rule's seat is hot. Bruce, >> the the writing on the wall, I felt like we were So, on last Friday night, it's our game Nebraska, Illinois, and we're watching the game in our green room. We're like, this does not look like a Dana Hogerson offense. What they were running, how it looked, it just didn't look that way. And so you start to go, okay, this is taken on a little bit of a twist here where it's like, all right, Matt Rule's definitely gotten involved in the offense. You know, you can feel like Dana's fingerprints aren't quite on it now. they had started out and it's kind of been some version of this for most of Matt Rule's time in Nebraska. Get out to a good start. Maybe there are a lot of empty calories in there. You know, a couple of the years they were 5 and two. This year they were 5-0. And then they have given Indiana a good game and then they end up losing 2017.
21:45 Then they lose, you know, to Ryola at Oregon. Then they have that dud of a game against Washington. And obviously this now they haven't scored more than 17 points in any of these games in this four-game losing streak. They got to go to Ruters this week. And then it's Ohio State and Iowa. I mean, I think they'll get to six and six, you know, I mean, because they got Ruters, but it's crazy to see how this program, you know, on top of this, I didn't even mention this, you know, we've heard rumblings that they paid a fortune to resign Anthony Kandria, their quarterback, and did you have to rush out and do it at mid-season right in the middle of this? Because it just seems like things are not functional. And if you go back to Matt Rule's time now as a recent head coach, you know, Dana Hogerson's not the first coordinator.
22:35 He's already fired at Nebraska. You go back, I mean, Joe Brady is clearly a really good offensive coach. You fired him with the mention that, >> you know, so >> I don't know, man. If I'm a Nebraska fan, I am not comfortable with the direction of this program right now, Stu. I don't know how you could be. I mean, and you guys remember how critical I was of the contract extension at the time and and Nebraska fans weren't happy with me because at that time they felt like things were going in the right direction. The contract extension was entirely about the Penn State job coming and fearing that Matt Rule was going to be hired away by Penn State. Ralph's making a face to suggest he doesn't think that.
23:15 >> Well, I I I think there was part of that though. So, my reporting when I was talking about the Penn State search last year, which went a little off the rails, was I I think by that point there was some enough signals realizing that that wasn't going to fly at Penn State. So, while I still think that was part of the calculation, because I also know as the Penn State search lingered, there was some fear at Nebraska what that Penn State would pivot back to rule even though he had signed the the contract extension. I do think it's a little like and it's not working out as well like Alabama with Kaylin Dbor right last year Burn Greg Burn G if I think remember it was after last year or or maybe two years ago >> Michigan coming open >> right and they and they put a big a big contract extension on Kalin Dbor but it was also Greg Burn's way of saying folks we're not doing this like this guy's won a bunch of games we're good we're going to let this roll we're going to lean into stability now it's one thing to do it when you've just come off a playoff.
24:22 It's another thing to do it when you're seven when you're only a seven- win team. But I do feel like a lot of schools are just trying to tamp down a little bit on the pull the plug, try something else. Pull the plug, try something else cuz it costs so much money. Nebraska's rebuilding a stadium. They're putting a lot of money into that, too, Sue. I mean, they are they are six and eight since that USC game when Raola got hurt. They're six and eight. And now the the buyout is $63.9 million.
24:50 >> Yeah, it's just not happening. >> Bruce Bruce mentioned this with in relation to the Jason Beck news. This is why I have zero sympathy for we're all going broke because of NIL. Save college sports. We're all going broke. You're going broke because you make stupid decisions like this. In the worst case scenario, if Penn State had hired him away, Nebraska would have been fine. they would have gone out and find another coach who might also be six and eight in the last 14 games. I don't know me. Hopefully, he would be better.
25:20 >> Can I say this since you guys brought it up a minute ago? I think Alabama would be in a trickier situation. Like who you're going to hire at Alabama to me is a even more complicated question cuz you have a way smaller pool realistically than you do if you're in Nebraska. >> Fair. Well, yes. I 100% agree. Kaylin Dbor took a team to the national championship game, took Alabama to the playoff last year. I realize people weren't happy with him because the the al the way it ended, right? The blowout loss to Georgia followed by the blowout loss to Indiana. But, you know, if you're Greg Burn, you have pretty good mountain of evidence to suggest this guy's going to be okay.
26:02 >> Matt Rule still very much was a was a qu open question. Speaking of schools not wanting to pay a buyout, Ruckers announces this week that Greg Shiano is coming back. We thought he was going to get fired after the very first game after they lost to UMass. Got killed by UMass. Just a totally inex excusable result. And they're not that bad, but they are two and seven. So Ralph, why why is he coming back? >> I think this really was a money thing.
26:30 They owe him They would owe him $18 million. That's a that's real money for Ruters. This is a program that is still grappling with finances and the cost of being in the Big 10 and the the benefits of being in the Big 10 and the cost of being in the Big 10, they're still trying to balance, right? Yes, they make more money, but to be competitive in the Big 10, Ruckers has to spend more money and they still are chasing their tail a little bit. I was a little surprised. I've heard that maybe even Greg Shiano might have been a little surprised that it landed this way. though I haven't quite confirmed that. The fact of the matter is I think the new athletic director, that relatively new athletic director there, Kelly Zinn, who came from LSU, I think, like again, you look at the books and you say, do I want to spend $18 million plus what it costs to bring in a new coach, another 50 million or 40 million on a new staff, and whatever other ancillary money around bringing in assistance when I could just come up with a plan. Shano's still well respected generally speaking within the state there has support I think from some boosters. Why don't we come up with a plan to try to do this better next year and then Greg if it doesn't work next year we all know what's going to happen. I think Ruckers has is a poster for everybody thinks if we go to the conference that makes more money it'll be roses, right? And you find out real quick, oh, but we have to spend a lot more money now to get up to speed in this conference. And suddenly, I mean, Ruckers was even getting an advance, if you remember, for years, like >> the Big 10 does it where you don't get a full share, or they used to do it where you don't get a full share for like eight years, and the Big 10 was loaning them an adv advance on the money they would eventually make. And they're still in this mess. Ruckers is a little bit of the dog that caught the caught the car, right?
28:30 What do I do with this thing now? >> That's my cat. My cat My cats are like begging to run out the front door anytime you open the door. If you give them even an inch, they'll run out and then you know what they do? They hide under the car. What do they do? >> You have multiple cats, too. >> We have two cats, Ronald and Luigi. >> Yes. >> Our our precious cats. Well, let's take another break and when we come back, it's mailbag time.
28:55 All right, it's mailbag time. As always, you can send your questions to the audible pod@gmail.com. By the way, that $24 Trader Joe's gift card, which goes to the our favorite question of the week, was raised from $16 to 24 by our friends at Trader Joe's in anticipation of the 2014 playoff. And here we are. This first one comes from Matt Kilfoil. You've answered a few of my questions in the past. Thank you. So, it's great to reach out again. I'm an a I'm a Michigan alum and genuinely struggling to think of any other program in my life that has experienced the to turmoil which Michigan has created for itself in the past 5 years. The only comparable amount of disorder I can think of is the Mike Price chapter at Alabama. Total chaos entirely unforced in of its own making. I'm genuinely asking genuinely asking can you recall any other program experiencing the abject chaos and upheaval that Michigan has brought upon itself over the past 5 years?
29:48 I got one and I thought about this and I was like, "Ooh, this is a this one is one that has a series of gut punches and cell phones and everything else." It's also one that is connected sort of like Michigan is to the to the Ruters coach Greg Giano we were just talking about and that is Tennessee. Tennessee had a absolutely debacle of like a past dozen years before they hired Josh Hypel. So much so that in 2021, I went back and remembered this story that I did with David about Tennessee's the 30 most bizarre moments of Rocky Top of this decade. I'm going to read a few of them. Number one, Shano Sunday.
30:32 You guys remember that weekend in November 2017 when all hell broke loose in Knoxville because they were about to hire him. >> Obviously, that didn't happen. There was a mutiny. then we get into number two. Tennessee fires Jeremy Puit after an internal de investigation. There was so many things in there that were just mindboggling with Jeremy and everything else. We didn't mention the Lane Keifin riot. That's number three. Fulmer's second takeover and Wade. Oh, then there was the John Curry Mike Leech interview.
31:08 That wasn't >> when John Curry got fired while he was on the plane, >> right? >> The neverending groomers. Remember John Gruden was spotted at Dead End Barbecue or the every other place or Calhoun. and my personal favorite, I think this was like number 18 on the list, the Douly stool. not not anything kind of gross, but when Derek Douly, who was constantly stepping in it there, was a horrible hire that they had talked themsel that the fans had kind of talked themselves into because Lane left them the way he left them and he was a disaster and he was like one embarrassing gaff after another. So >> shower discipline, remember discipline.
31:51 >> Yeah. Oh my god. so anyway, Tennessee fans came through it. They found, you know, credit to them. They got they got a coach who got that that program out of the ditch. Michigan, at least you won a national title amid your chaos. >> We can't do that all that without talking about Butch Jones and Brick by Brick. >> And the fact that even though his teams weren't very good on the field, they won the championship of life. That That was an infamous infamous quote.
32:18 >> compared to the other guys around him, Butch Jones was Bear Bryant. >> Pretty normal, huh, Bruce? I mean, that was great. Thank you for that. It's hard to top that. I thought you were going to say USC. They went through about a decade of some would argue they're still not through it, right? But I'm referring to the era of hiring Lane after Pete Carol left who had you know was not remotely prepared for that job. the sanctions obviously which predate lane and they happened under Pete Carol but the way USC administration fought that and they just made it all that much worse for themselves I truly to this day believe Paul Dropped the hammer on them because they were so uncooperative and obstructionist you had >> fight the f fight the f on Stark's infamous words at the at the Trojan huddle >> yes you had the Audible has been around long enough that I distinctly remember we were recording a show and Bruce was driving somewhere in the South >> and I told him in real time, you're not going to believe that. I told him this on the air. USC just hired their new ad and you're never going to believe who it is and Lynn Swan.
33:34 >> Lyn Swan >> and Bruce, your reaction was >> Yeah, I I almost drove off the road. I was just like cuz it's this school where like they it wouldn't surprise me if you know like they someday hired Liner to be the the AD you know it was like we got Mike Garrett he was the AD before that Pat Hayden was coming in there and then Lynn Swan it was like man USC come on give me like hire somebody who's like a proven administrator or whatnot. Yeah, I will throw in that cre that weird Hollywood video when they were first la when NIL was brand new and they were >> that was the S Brendan SA >> the the the you know glamorous Hollywood video that during co you know so there was like most of most of this part of the country certainly was like very much still in lockdown and they did this video of everybody parting it up in in Hollywood.
34:30 >> and at the end of that video, by the way, they they put up a note thanking the person who I think got them all the helicopters or whatever. And that person, I think, is a fugitive from justice wanted overseas. There was like for embezzling like tens of millions of dollars. >> Also, one last one, and I don't remember the details, but Bruce Will, I just remember this was so personified that era. Josh Shaw, you remember that one?
34:57 >> Oh, yeah, >> I could. Yeah, there there was Yeah, that was a nutty little story. Yeah, Joshua was a DB. >> Yeah. Prior to his senior season, he was suspended by USC after he lied about how he suffered injuries to both his ankles. He had originally told the team he injured himself while jumping from the second story of an apartment building to save his nephew, who is drowning in a pool. In reality, he suffered the injuries after jumping from his balcony to avoid the police who had been called by a neighbor after hearing an argument between him and his girlfriend.
35:29 You're not alone, Michigan is all we're saying. Like instead of voting, it could be worse. Instead of voting on a gift card, I think we should vote on which one was more dysfunctional, USC or Tennessee. All right, on that note, Bruce had to jump. So Ralph and I are going to handle the rest of the mailbag on our own. >> All right, this one is for you, Stu, and it hearkens back to the Alabama Tennessee thing. And this is just one of our listeners, James, wants to get a little explanation on the mechanics of this. We keep hearing how teams like Alabama and Tennessee don't have head-to-head considered because they weren't in the same group of teams being considered against one another by the selection committee. On paper, that makes sense. But in the committee room, how does that actually go down? We've both done a mock, so we kind of understand how this can happen. Could you briefly sum it up, Stu?
36:20 Yeah. So the way it works is it's not, you know, they don't just sit there and go 1 to 20. All right, who should we rank six? Okay, now who should we rank eighth? It's actually a pretty thorough process where you compare like to like teams. So you start with let's say six. I think it is I think it's six teams. You start with the teams that they think are going to be toward the top. Compare those to each other. Okay, we've decided these teams are going to be one, two, three. the other three get moved into a new pool with the three below them.
36:54 Right? So, you're you're comparing small groups of teams at a time. You're not trying to compare all 25 at once. I actually think it's a pretty smart process, but that's how you get to situations like this where they must have started with Alabama in the very first group and Tennessee didn't come up till later. And by the time you said, "We're going to move these three up and these three down. Okay, now we're going to move the next three down." they just weren't ever in the same voting pool.
37:21 it's how they do it in basketball where you have so many teams that it would just be impossible to like rank the 57th team compared to the second team. but that's how that happens and that's why, by the way, I said earlier it'll work itself out because eventually there won't be enough teams in between them to avoid them being in the same pot. >> Yeah. And the the one thing I would add to that, how do they start the groupings? Like the initial Okay. how do we build the groupings is they they do poll the room and say give us your top 25s >> but instead of just doing it the way the AP does and counting up the the individual top 25s then it becomes a consensus building exercise where you start comparing these teams. So again it's a very different process than the AP poll which is just one voter one vote and that's it. They do have this cool software where you, okay, it's time to vote on these six teams. Nobody can see who anybody else is voting for. And if you're, you know, the Michigan AD and Michigan's in the group, you're blocked out from voting for them.
38:26 >> So, they do have some cool bells and whistles there. all right. Last one is from Blaine in Virginia, who is a common name here on this podcast. it's hard to believe that last year, just last year, Texas A&M beat Notre Dame and Southbend and started 11-0. Arizona State and Arkansas are the only P4 teams they've beaten since. And&M has a tough remaining schedule. Tennessee, OU, Texas. I didn't realize that. Ouch. >> Yeah. What What went wrong for the Aggies and can they get back on track next year?
39:02 >> So, a couple things. micro what went wrong for the Aggies and I think some of us saw this coming right I think I was a little down on Texas&M this year you Stu >> identified boy they lost a lot of NFL players here like how the how's this going to work like when your entire offensive line that was very good last year is rebuilt in the portal and yes you have a bunch of like seemingly interesting defensive linemen but you lost a bunch like they lost a lot of players in a lot of key positions and were then you add in a new offensive coordinator. There was just a lot of turnover.
39:43 So I think we all a lot of us expected some regression out of Texas A&M. The macro though is what does that mean in today's college football? I think a few years back a step back might have been we went from 11 and one or whatever they were finished last year 11-2 I think was the final record. >> We have to replace a lot of good players. We're going to take a step back. Maybe we'll be eight and four this year, right? I think that's what a lot of people expected. The problem is when the SEC gets to the point where now it has&m and Oklahoma like the and and plus the flat we talk about this all the time. Flattening of the talent curve is also a factor here. More competitive teams all over the place within the SEC especially. Now all of a sudden your regression year, your stepback year, your year where you don't get a couple of breaks, instead of going seven wins, now you're in danger of winning four.
40:44 And I think this is just something that's being felt throughout all of college football. I think Oklahoma's going through this. Like what does it mean for us to have a a a blip year, a setback year, a regression year? And in years past, I think there was a a a little bit of a safety net for some of these teams because of the schedules where we could maybe we cobble our way to six, seven, eight wins and it's just not there anymore. And I think this is the reality. I think a lot of Ohio State fans are facing it right now. A lot of turnover on the roster, one key injury, and all of a sudden you go from, "Oh, shoot. We might only win eight games this year. What the hell?" So&m is the best example of this, but I also think this is being felt like this recalibration of where what success is and what nonsuccess is and what's possible is being felt all throughout college football. I agree with that in general, but I think&m's got is is way is has a way worse situation. I mean, how can Marcel Reed be that bad now, right? And so they lost two coordinators, Goo and Colin Klein, and we've talked about this before, I think, that Mike Elco whiffed on who he replaced those guys with. I would also say that to your point about the bigger conferences now you have these your schedule can can flip so drastically from one year to the next. We talked about it at the time last year&m was 11 and1 so of course they're going to be whatever they seed they were in the playoff and and get all the acclaim but like the schedule worked out crazy where they played like seven of the bottom eight teams in the in the SEC last year. They only played like one team that I think they only beat one team that finished in the top 25 out of all those, you know, very very glut of ranked teams in the SEC. Clearly, it flipped on them this year. Like they're playing all the best teams in the SEC this year and and it's showing in the record. So, they were a very hard team to forecast in the preseason. I think the voters may have just defaulted to, well, they were in the top 10 last year, so they'll be in the top 10 this year.
42:56 I had a suspicion they would take a step back for the reasons you talked about. Never would have guessed it would be this bad. Like why would we guess that Marcel Reed would go from, you know, he wasn't elite, but he was a pretty good SEC quarterback to they can't score 10 points in a game. >> Yeah, they are the worst case scenario. But again, I think we have to rethink about what the worst case scenario means nowadays. And and the the the fact of the matter is the bottom is deeper than it's ever been. If you have a bad year and you have your worst case scenario, schools that were not used to finishing with three or four wins might actually only finish with three or four wins. So to the second part of the question, can they fix it next year? Yeah. I mean, they he's obviously going to have to hire better coordinators. You know, he's going to have to change the staff. And then the danger of relying heavily on the portal is some years you're going to hit on all your guys and some years you're going to miss. Florida State being a perfect example of that under Mike Norbell.
43:58 so I mean it's he's clearly he's going to have to go to the portal again and he's going to have to do a better job of evaluating these guys. I will say that this was another example of and this is why it's also very hard to forecast these teams when we talk about oh they got this guy and they got that guy in the portal. Like the thing I kept hearing from the&m people was, "Well, yeah, we lost four really good offensive linemen, but we got four guys with SEC starting experience, but were they good?" I mean, just cuz they they started, does that mean they're good? And so, I think the only way to really you have to talk to to PE you basically have to talk to other people who recruited them and say like, "Hey, how how good are these guys, right?" and you might hear like they're overrated, you know, or or whatever the case may be.
44:46 >> And there's also an element of will these all these mix mix and match pieces fit together, right? Especially on an offensive line when jelling and cohesion has to be is a big part of and again matching your offensive system is such a big deal. The last thing I would say before we get on out of here and give away a gift card is Texas A&M has the currently has the number one rated recruiting class in the country for 2027. So maybe that's a way to help figure your way out as well.
45:14 >> Oh, for sure. I know people kind of downplay that now, but look at USC. Like those some of those guys can have a huge impact right from the jump. All right, Ralph, who's getting the $24 Trader Joe's gift card? You know, I know he was asking about Michigan, but our emailer who brought us down talking about Tennessee and USC and all the nonsense and chaos that's gone on at those two programs over the last two decades.
45:40 Yeah, we we got to go with that one, right, Stu? Yeah, I I really kudos to Bruce for coming with all the receipts on Tennessee. And then I try tried to remember all the USC stuff off the top of my head. Matt Killfoil, please send your mailing address to the audible@gmail.com. Everybody else, send your questions for next week to the audible pod@gmail.com. We will be back live on Sunday morning at 11:30 a.m. Eastern, 8:30 a.m. Pacific on our YouTube channel, which is Audible Show to recap this weekend's games. We'll see you then.
Summary
- Tennessee's ranking is questioned, especially after their head-to-head victory over Alabama, with hosts arguing for their higher placement.
- The committee's reliance on strength of schedule metrics is critiqued, suggesting it may lead to skewed rankings.
- The transition to a 12-team playoff format is discussed, highlighting scheduling changes and the impact on the college football calendar.
- Nebraska's struggles under Matt Rule are analyzed, including the firing of offensive coordinator Dana Hogerson and the implications of his contract extension.
- Rutgers retains coach Greg Schiano due to financial considerations, reflecting the challenges of maintaining competitiveness in the Big Ten.
- The hosts emphasize the importance of evaluating coaching hires and the impact of the transfer portal on team performance.
- Texas A&M's disappointing season is attributed to significant roster turnover and the challenges of rebuilding in a competitive SEC landscape.
- The podcast concludes with a mailbag segment, discussing chaos in college football programs, particularly Tennessee and USC.
Questions Answered
What is the Audible and how can fans engage with it?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the offseason. Fans are encouraged to subscribe on YouTube and follow on social media to build the community.
Why did Indiana drop in the playoff rankings?
Indiana dropped in the rankings because they had a bye week while other teams around them won, and the teams they had beaten also lost, affecting their strength of schedule metrics.
What are the implications of the new 2014 playoff format?
The transition to a 12-team playoff format has been a long process, and while it was initially met with skepticism, it is now a reality that will change how teams are evaluated and ranked.
What is the current state of Nebraska's football program?
After losing four straight games, Nebraska fired their offensive coordinator, raising questions about the job security of head coach Matt Rule, just a year into his tenure.
How does the ranking process for teams work?
The ranking process involves a consensus-building exercise where committee members vote on teams, and the initial groupings are based on polling the room rather than a simple tally of votes.