transcribe

Did Canada Just Win the Midterms?

Economics Explained · 19m · transcribed 6d ago
More from Economics Explained Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Escalation of Trade Tensions

What has been the impact of recent trade tensions between Canada and the US?

The trade tensions have escalated significantly, with the US imposing tariffs on Canadian goods and Canada retaliating with matching tariffs. This has led to a deterioration in relations, with a notable increase in Canadians viewing the US as an enemy. Despite the tensions, a majority of Canadian goods still cross the border tariff-free, indicating a targeted rather than a total trade war.

  • US tariffs on Canadian goods have led to retaliatory measures from Canada.
  • Public sentiment in Canada has shifted negatively towards the US.
  • Most Canadian goods continue to cross the border without tariffs.
# 3:54

Canada's Economic Dependence on the US

How is Canada's economy structured in relation to the US?

Canada's economy is heavily reliant on the US market, with a significant portion of its exports directed there, particularly in oil and automotive industries. The infrastructure is largely designed to facilitate trade with the US, making it challenging for Canada to diversify its trade relationships.

  • Canada exports a large majority of its oil to the US due to pipeline infrastructure.
  • The automotive industry in Canada is deeply integrated with the US market.
  • Canada's economic structure is built around supplying the US rather than competing globally.
# 7:48

Trade Deficits and Economic Interdependence

What does the trade deficit between Canada and the US signify?

While the US runs a goods deficit with Canada, the overall economic relationship is more balanced when considering services. The deficit is largely due to energy imports, which the US benefits from by refining and selling. This interdependence shows that both countries gain from their trade, albeit not equally.

  • The US has a goods deficit with Canada, primarily due to energy imports.
  • The overall trade relationship is beneficial for both countries.
  • The US economy is less dependent on Canadian exports compared to Canada's dependence on US imports.
# 11:42

Challenges in Canada's Economic Growth

What economic challenges is Canada facing amidst trade tensions?

Canada is grappling with inflation and a slowing job market, which complicates monetary policy. The reduction in immigration is also leading to a stagnation in population growth, impacting consumer spending and economic activity. These factors are occurring at a time when Canada is already facing challenges in productivity compared to the US.

  • Inflation is rising, complicating the Bank of Canada's monetary policy.
  • A slowdown in immigration is leading to fewer consumers and economic activity.
  • Canada's productivity has been declining relative to the US for decades.
# 15:36

Diversification Efforts and Economic Bottlenecks

What steps is Canada taking to diversify its economy, and what challenges does it face?

Canada is attempting to diversify its export markets, but much of the recent growth in non-US exports is driven by commodities rather than industrial goods. The country faces significant logistical challenges, such as bottlenecks at its ports, which hinder its ability to expand trade with other nations effectively.

  • Canada's diversification efforts are largely focused on commodities, not industrial goods.
  • Logistical challenges at ports are a significant barrier to expanding trade.
  • Meaningful diversification would require substantial economic growth and infrastructure improvements.

Transcript

0:00 It's been 83 days since Canada's closest ally and biggest trading partner slapped 50% tariffs on about 20 billion US worth of Canadian goods. And in that time, things have escalated pretty quickly. Trump told every Canadian company doing business with America to move to the United States immediately, banned imports of Canadian alcohol, dairy, and motorcycles, threatened to block Jet Maker Bombader from the US market before deciding he'd actually take good care of its workers, and just for good measure, renamed a lake. Now, Canada hasn't exactly been sitting on its hands either. Prime Minister Mark Carney matched the new tariffs dollar for dollar on 27.6 billion Canadian dollars worth of American goods, and the mood up north has soured just as quickly with 41% of Canadians now seeing the US as an enemy, up 15 points from just over a year ago. All of this is happening along a border that Trump has called an artificially drawn line. Something that somebody drew, like with a ruler, just a straight line right across the top of the country. which is a bit ironic because his trade war is making that line more real than it's been in decades. But despite all the headlines, roughly threearters of Canadian goods still cross that line without paying a scent in tariffs, which means this is a targeted battle rather than anything close to a closed border, at least for now. So, what would happen if that border did close completely? It sounds like kind of a ridiculous question, and taken that far, it probably is. But answering it reveals how dependent Canada really is on its neighbor and how healthy its economy is beneath all the noise. It also has every other US ally watching closely to find out what happens when two economies this intertwined try to pull apart. Now, before we get into it, there is one pretty big caveat.

1:32 The US midterms have just happened and Democrats have won control of both the House and the Senate, which means a lot of what we're about to talk about could change or at the very least slow down now that Congress has a lot more say in how this trade war plays out. But the economic fundamentals underneath all of this are exactly the same as they were last week. And that's what we're interested in here. So, as always, we've got some important questions to answer. Who actually needs whom more in the Canada US relationship? How is Canada's economy really doing underneath the trade war?

2:02 And finally, could Canada close its southern border and become economically independent if it had to? Have you ever gotten to the gym and right when you're about to start your workout, your headphones die? I don't know if it's just me, but it feels like it happens every other session. That's where the sponsor of this video, Raycon, comes in. Raycon's Everyday Earbuds Classics are premium quality headphones at an affordable price. I've only had mine for 3 months, but I've used them pretty much every day since I got them at the gym, running errands, or just working from home. They're the ones I actually reach for over my other earbuds because they let me tune everything out and focus on what I'm listening to. They have up to 32 hours of battery life, and every 10 minutes of charging gives you 90 minutes of play time, which saves me anytime I forget to charge them.

2:45 Honestly, at this point, they've just become part of my daily routine. It's almost Black Friday, and this year, the decision is easy because you can get up to 50% off sitewide. Click the link in the description box or go to buy raycon.com/economics expplained to get up to 50% off sitewide during Raycon's Black Friday sales. This video is sponsored by Raycon. So to understand what closing this border would mean, you first need to understand just how much stuff actually crosses it. Canada and the US have one of the biggest trade relationships on the planet with the US spending about $454 billion on Canadian goods and services last year and selling roughly as much back the other way. For Canada though, that relationship is almost everything. Trading goods and services accounts for about 2/3 of its GDP and exports alone make up roughly a third of it. And most of those exports go to just one place. About seven out of every $10 Canada earns from exporting goods come from a single customer, the United States. That's pretty unusual for an advanced economy. If a business had 70% of its revenue coming from a single client, its accountants would be having some very nervous conversations. And that's basically the position Canada's been in for decades. Now, to be fair, the relationship used to be even more lopsided. The US share of Canadian goods exports has fallen from over 3/4 to about 72% which is the lowest it's been in over four decades. But the basic deal has always been simple. The world's largest consumer market sits right next door with no ocean to cross, a shared language and similar legal systems. So Canada built its economy around supplying the US rather than competing with it. The clearest example of this is oil. Canada produces roughly 5 million barrels a day and exports about 4 million. Those crude exports are worth about $140 billion Canadian dollars a year and about 90% of them go to the US.

4:29 That's partly because the vast majority of Canada's pipeline capacity points south. Less than a fifth reaches a port where the oil could be shipped to other countries. So for much of Canada's oil, the infrastructure effectively chooses the customer. That also helps explain a strange detail. Canada exports millions of barrels a day while still importing hundreds of thousands, mostly from the US. Because producing oil in one part of Canada doesn't mean there's an easy way to get it to a refinery in another. The system is built around trading with its neighbor. Then there's the auto industry. The car industries in the two countries are so tightly integrated that a single part can cross the border several times before it ends up in a finished vehicle, which means a tariff can get paid again and again on the same part. A great example of this is a striker plate. That little metal loop your car door latches onto. One made by a company in Windsor, Ontario crosses the border four times. It starts out as Michigan steel, gets shaped in Windsor, heat treated in Bmpton, plated back in Michigan, inspected in Windsor again, and then finally gets sent off to a US assembly plant. It's exactly that level of integration that makes Canada so vulnerable at the moment. US tariffs are hitting its most important industries.

5:34 Take steel and aluminium. US tariffs on those industries run as high as 50%. For autos, it's 25% with a threat to go even higher. and lumber and copper are also caught in the dispute with a 50% search charge on billions of dollars of other goods adding to the bill. Since the major tariffs took effect, goods exports to the US have dropped sharply. Exports of cars and parts fell nearly 6% and Stalantis has told the union that it's looking at selling or closing its Bmpton assembly plant. Canada's retaliation isn't free either. Counter tariffs raise prices for Canadian consumers. And by some analysts estimates, matching the US dollar for dollar has pushed Canada's effective tariff on American goods back to late 1970s levels. The problem is that it's kind of impossible to target key US states, hurt US producers, and protect Canadian households all at the same time. But even now, most Canadian exports still cross the border duty-free. After the August escalation, only a fraction of Canadian goods face any US tariff at all. So, the damage is real, but it's also pretty targeted, which raises the obvious question.

6:32 What's at stake for the US here? What does it get out of this relationship? Trump's position is clear. America doesn't need Canada, but Canada needs America. And the trade data does back him up partly, but not entirely. Canadian crude makes up about 2/3 of US crude imports, and refineries in the American Midwest are specifically configured for the heavy crude that Canada produces. This means that in order to replace it, you'd need to reconfigure the refineries themselves.

6:58 And the timing for that really couldn't be worse. After large draw downs following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the US strategic petroleum reserve is still well below its pre2022 levels despite some partial refilling, which makes replacing Canadian supply particularly difficult in the short term. Canada also supplies about 80% of America's potach imports. And potach is a fertilizer with no real substitute. On top of that, Canada holds dominant shares of American aluminium, uranium, and electricity imports. And Trump himself acknowledged how reliant the US is on Canadian aluminium. What makes this even more revealing is what happened when the US imposed its new tariffs. It exempted energy, potach, fish, and critical minerals, which is a pretty good indication of where Washington thinks its leverage is and where the dependency runs the other way.

7:41 Canada is also one of America's biggest customers. It's the top export market for more than half of US states and the largest market for American manufactured goods. In recent years, border states like Montana have sent nearly 50% of their exports north. And for North Dakota, it's more than 80%. Then there's the trade deficit at the center of the White House's complaints. The US does run a goods deficit with Canada, but once you net off its services surplus, the overall gap narrows to a little under $30 billion, which is pretty modest for a relationship worth nearly 900 billion. It's also worth looking at what that deficit is made of.

8:14 The US imported far more energy from Canada last year than it sold back. And if you take energy out, by most estimates, the US runs a good surplus with Canada. So the deficit the White House keeps pointing to is mostly just the US buying oil it needs. And the interesting thing is that the US doesn't just burn that oil, it makes money refining it. American refineries turn Canadian crude into products like gasoline and diesel, then sell them at home and abroad. Some even goes back to Canada, which gets most of its imported refined fuel from the US. It's a bit like a tailor complaining that he spends more at the fabric shop than the fabric shop owner spends on suits. So, both countries benefit from this relationship, just not equally. The two sell each other roughly the same amount.

8:55 But for the US, exports to Canada work out to less than 1.5% of its GDP. While for Canada, exports to the US are worth about 19% of its entire economy. The US could replace most of what it buys from Canada, of course, at a cost. Fuel prices would be higher in the Midwest, fertilizer would be pricier for farmers, and aluminium more expensive for manufacturers. For some inputs, it would take years because you would need to build entirely new supply chains. But Canada would have a much harder time replacing its biggest customer. Now, Canada does have some cards to play here, but it really doesn't want to play them. When the US warned Ottawa not to use energy as leverage, Prime Minister Carney rejected the premise outright.

9:35 Ontario tried a search charge on electricity exports to three border states early last year and then suspended it the very next day. The leverage is real, but Canada needs the revenue from selling oil and electricity just as much as the US needs the supply. And that is the fundamental problem with resource-based leverage. When you depend on the income from selling something, cutting off the buyer hurts you, too. Then there's the question of who can hold out longer. Most Canadians support their own counter tariffs and twothirds say they back them even if prices go up.

10:03 Meanwhile, a majority of Americans oppose Trump's tariffs on Canada. And with Congress now in Democratic hands, the bigger economy isn't necessarily the one with more patience. Which brings us to the second question. Underneath all of this, how strong is Canada's economy on its own? Last year, we said Canada's economy wasn't nearly as healthy as it was a decade ago, and we highlighted housing, productivity, immigration, and the threat of tariffs. Well, the tariffs arrived. On the surface, things don't look too bad. The first quarter was flat. The second quarter grew 0.8%.

10:33 Exports jumped with car and light truck exports up 27% from the same period a year earlier. And corporate profits posted a sharp increase led by energy companies. But as always, things are never quite as simple as they seem. Car exports were bouncing back after production was disrupted over the winter. Meanwhile, household incomes got a boost from a onetime GST credit topup. And the World Cup gave a small lift to things like spectator sports, transit, and broadcasting. This is all well and good for a quarter, but it's not exactly something you can repeat every year. If you strip those situational factors away, the underlying momentum was a lot weaker. Where that really shows is in the labor market.

11:08 Canada lost more than 100,000 jobs in August and September combined, wiping out most of the year's gains. Today, unemployment is sitting at roughly 6.5% and still rising. The hardest hit sectors, though, weren't the ones you might expect. The biggest losses were in education, healthcare, and social assistance, linked partly to cuts in international student permits, which is a good reminder that not every problem Canada has right now is coming from Washington. And the challenges aren't hitting the whole country evenly either.

11:35 Quebec and Ontario are shedding jobs while Alberta, the oil province, is one of the few still adding them, helped by firm crude prices and new pipeline capacity. A weakening job market would normally give the Bank of Canada a reason to cut interest rates, but inflation is pulling it the other way. By midyear, it had climbed above 3% driven by counter tariffs on American imports and higher gasoline prices. Then on October 28th, the bank actually raised rates to 2.5% warning that persistently high energy costs could spread through the economy. That's the challenge here. Supporting growth risks feeding inflation while fighting inflation risks weakening growth. The immigration slowdown has arrived, too, and the reversal has been dramatic. Last year, we warned that cutting immigration could ease pressure on housing and public services, but it would also mean fewer workers, fewer customers, and less spending. Long-term, it's probably the right thing to do. But short-term, it's going to be painful. And that's what's happening. After a population growth of over 3% in 2023, driven largely by temporary residents, the government slammed on the brakes, cutting the annual permanent resident target from 500,000 to 395,000 with further reductions planned.

12:39 Meanwhile, the number of temporary residents has dropped about 7%. The result is that population growth has basically ground to a halt, and fewer people means fewer consumers, fewer renters, and fewer buyers, which isn't great timing when your biggest customer is already buying less. Now, housing is finally correcting with prices expected to keep falling, particularly for condos in Ontario and British Columbia. But the long-term problem hasn't gone anywhere. Since the late 1990s, Canada's productivity relative to the US has fallen by about a quarter. For a while, Canada papered over this by working more hours and riding high commodity prices.

13:11 But since the oil price crash in 2015, GDP per person has been falling behind, too. Nearly two decades ago, Canadian businesses invested about 90 cents per worker for every dollar their American counterparts invested. Today, it's about 55, which means Canadian workers have less equipment, less technology, and less capital behind every hour they work. Over time, that gap compounds into lower output and lower wages. And on top of everything, the government doesn't have much room to help. The federal deficit is running at roughly 65 billion Canadian dollars for the current fiscal year, and debt servicing costs are growing fast. So, Canada is facing its biggest trade shock in a generation from a position that is a lot weaker than the headlines suggest. So, with an economy that's weaker than it looks and its biggest customer turning against it, could Canada actually close its southern border and go it alone? Well, nobody has seriously modeled a full closure, which by itself gives you a good sense of how impractical it would be. You would be cutting off about 70% of goods exports, roughly 90% of crude exports, and an auto industry whose parts cross the border several times per car. The more realistic version of this question is, what happens if Canada loses its preferential access to the US market, meaning the free trade deal collapses entirely? And that's not really a crazy hypothetical anymore.

14:24 Kasma, the trade agreement that replaced NAFTA, has a six-year review built into it. If any party declines to confirm the deal's extension at that review, the agreement stays in force until 2036, but faces a joint review every single year after that, kind of like a lease the landlord can choose not to renew. And at the first review this July, that's exactly what the US did, declining to renew the deal in its current form, even though both Canada and Mexico had backed a full extension, which means the worst case is now on the table every 12 months. Deote modeled what happens if KSMA dissolves entirely. And in their analysis, Canada's real GDP ends up about 1.6% 6% lower over a decade with significant job losses every year. Some sectors get absolutely hammered with electronics down 21% and autos hit even harder. Deote described the overall impact as severe but not cataclysmic.

15:10 Although for individual sectors, the damage could be exactly that. Oxford Economics modeled what a full collapse would look like and over the next decade it reckons Canada's economy would lose about 1% of its output compared with less than half a% for the US. But in raw dollars, it's actually the US that loses more, around1 trillion US. But it just has a much bigger economy for those losses to spread across. Now, what about diversification? Carney's stated goal is to double non- US exports within a decade. And on paper, it's working. Non- US exports hit a record last year, and their share of total exports was the highest it's been in over four decades. The problem is what's driving it. A large share of the increase in non- US exports went to the United Kingdom, driven almost entirely by gold and other precious metals, and shipping bullion to London isn't exactly opening up new markets for Canadian industry. Then there's China. Canada cut its tariff on Chinese electric vehicles, and China cut its tariff on Canadian canola in return, but Trump threatened punitive tariffs in response. When trade talks with the US collapsed in August, Carney said one of America's late demands was a veto over Canada's trade deals with other countries. The US denies making any lastminute demands, but either way, diversification itself has now become a point of conflict.

16:19 Canada has signed multiple new economic and security agreements with countries outside the US. But the scale of what's needed is daunting. Doubling non- US exports would require new growth worth about 5% of GDP, which is roughly the combined output of Canada's entire mining, quaring, and oil and gas sectors. And right now, Canada's ports are a bottleneck. Vancouver, Canada's busiest container port, ranked near the bottom of the World Bank's container port performance index, placing at 375th out of roughly 400 ports globally. That's not exactly where you want to be when your whole plan relies on shipping more stuff out. In fact, even Deote's best case diversification scenario adds far less to GDP over a decade than what Canada would lose without preferential US access. So, if diversification alone is not enough, what would it take to make Canada meaningfully less dependent? For starters, Canada would need to improve its pipelines and ports. The Trans Mountain expansion has already sent about 2/3 of the tankers loading at its Vancouver terminal to Asia. And a new pipeline from Alberta to the BC coast called Pacific Link was declared a project of national interest last month.

17:22 But it's still in the very early stages and a long way from completion. And even if it gets built, the non- US share of crude exports only rises from about 15% to 23%. Which is better than nothing but still a long way from independence. then improve the trade between Canada's own provinces. Removing internal trade barriers could raise Canada's GDP by anywhere from 1% to as much as 7%. Which is a pretty wide range, but either way, it's money being left on the table. Now, there has been some real progress here because provinces have started accepting each other's product standards, and most now allow at least some direct to consumer alcohol shipping across provincial lines. But the problem is just how much there is to untangle. Every province has its own rulebook, and there are so many overlapping regulations that one professor from the University of Ottawa is now using AI just to comb through them and flag where they clash. And some of what he's finding is, well, a bit ridiculous. Ontario, for example, is the only province that requires public toilets to have a U-shaped seat, a rule that happens to line up with US industry standards, which limits who else Ontario can actually buy them from.

18:23 Now, this is a bit of a silly example, but it shows that the barriers are real, and even finding all of them is a big job. The third thing, and this is the big one, is productivity and investment. Remember, Canadian businesses are investing about 55 cents per worker for every dollar American firms spend. And that investment gap limits their ability to compete beyond the US. Unless Canadian businesses narrow it, diversification just means trying to sell less competitive goods to customers farther away. So, can it be done? Could Canada close the border entirely? Not without enormous costs to both countries, but especially to Canada. Canada could become a lot less dependent, though. Trump may have done more to push internal trade reform, and new pipeline construction than countless policy reports ever did. Whether that urgency survives a new Congress, the annual KSMA reviews, or simply the pressure easing off, well, that remains to be seen. Now, Canada isn't the only US ally getting caught in the crossfire. We have already made an entire video on how Europe is getting squeezed between a war in the Gulf and a tariff war to the West. If you're interested, you should be able to click to that on your screen now. Thanks for watching, mate. Bye.

Summary

The ongoing trade tensions between Canada and the United States have escalated significantly, with the U.S. imposing 50% tariffs on Canadian goods and Canada retaliating with matching tariffs. This conflict highlights the deep economic interdependence between the two nations, as Canada relies heavily on U.S. markets for its exports, while the U.S. benefits from Canadian resources. Despite the tensions, a complete closure of the border seems impractical due to the intertwined nature of their economies.

- The U.S. has imposed 50% tariffs on approximately $20 billion worth of Canadian goods, prompting Canada to retaliate with matching tariffs.
- Approximately 70% of Canadian exports go to the U.S., making Canada highly dependent on its southern neighbor.
- Despite tariffs, about 75% of Canadian goods still cross the border duty-free, indicating a targeted trade conflict rather than a complete trade shutdown.
- The U.S. relies on Canada for significant imports, including crude oil (about 2/3 of U.S. crude imports) and potash, which are critical for American industries.
- Canada’s economy is showing signs of weakness, with rising unemployment and a struggling labor market, particularly in sectors like education and healthcare.
- The trade relationship is complicated by a significant trade deficit for the U.S. in energy, which is primarily sourced from Canada.
- Canada is attempting to diversify its trade relationships, but challenges such as infrastructure bottlenecks and regulatory barriers remain significant obstacles.
- Long-term economic independence for Canada would require substantial improvements in productivity, investment, and internal trade reform.

Questions Answered

What has been the impact of recent trade tensions between Canada and the US?

The trade tensions have escalated significantly, with the US imposing tariffs on Canadian goods and Canada retaliating with matching tariffs. This has led to a deterioration in relations, with a notable increase in Canadians viewing the US as an enemy. Despite the tensions, a majority of Canadian goods still cross the border tariff-free, indicating a targeted rather than a total trade war.

How is Canada's economy structured in relation to the US?

Canada's economy is heavily reliant on the US market, with a significant portion of its exports directed there, particularly in oil and automotive industries. The infrastructure is largely designed to facilitate trade with the US, making it challenging for Canada to diversify its trade relationships.

What does the trade deficit between Canada and the US signify?

While the US runs a goods deficit with Canada, the overall economic relationship is more balanced when considering services. The deficit is largely due to energy imports, which the US benefits from by refining and selling. This interdependence shows that both countries gain from their trade, albeit not equally.

What economic challenges is Canada facing amidst trade tensions?

Canada is grappling with inflation and a slowing job market, which complicates monetary policy. The reduction in immigration is also leading to a stagnation in population growth, impacting consumer spending and economic activity. These factors are occurring at a time when Canada is already facing challenges in productivity compared to the US.

What steps is Canada taking to diversify its economy, and what challenges does it face?

Canada is attempting to diversify its export markets, but much of the recent growth in non-US exports is driven by commodities rather than industrial goods. The country faces significant logistical challenges, such as bottlenecks at its ports, which hinder its ability to expand trade with other nations effectively.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram