Section Insights
Introduction to The Audible
What is The Audible and how can listeners engage?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the off-season. Listeners are encouraged to subscribe and follow on social media to build a community.
- The Audible is a college football podcast.
- Listeners should subscribe for regular updates.
- Engagement on social media is encouraged.
Listener Feedback on Playoff Expansion
What are listeners' opinions on the 24-team playoff expansion?
Listeners have mixed feelings about the playoff expansion, with some supporting it and others expressing concerns about the devaluation of bowl games and the playoff's impact on the sport.
- Listener opinions vary on the playoff expansion.
- Some believe more teams should be included in the playoff.
- Concerns exist about the meaning of bowl games in the current playoff context.
Impact of a 24-Team Playoff
How would a 24-team playoff change the dynamics of college football?
A 24-team playoff could lead to less dramatic weekly narratives in college football, as more teams would have a chance to qualify, potentially diluting the significance of individual games.
- A larger playoff may reduce the drama of weekly games.
- More teams qualifying could change the focus of media coverage.
- The playoff format could affect coaching job security.
Coaching Performance and Recognition
How does recency bias affect coaching recognition in college football?
Recency bias can influence how coaches are evaluated and recognized, with recent performances overshadowing past successes or failures, impacting votes and perceptions.
- Coaching recognition can be affected by recent game outcomes.
- Past performances may be overlooked due to recency bias.
- Evaluations of coaches can vary significantly based on timing.
Evaluating Team Performance for Future Planning
When should a college football team evaluate its roster for future seasons?
Teams should evaluate their roster when playoff hopes are diminished, allowing them to focus on younger players and future recruitment strategies, especially in the context of NIL and transfer portals.
- Roster evaluations are crucial when playoff chances are low.
- Teams should consider future investments in players.
- NIL and transfer portals have changed how teams approach evaluations.
Transcript
0:00 Welcome back to The Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine three times a week during the season, twice a week during the off-season. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and X at Audible Show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.
0:26 >> >> Hello and welcome to The Audible presented by Trader Joe's. Don't forget to like and subscribe wherever you get your podcast and follow us on social media. We're on Instagram and X these days. Gentlemen, Stewart Mandel, Bruce Feldman, my colleagues from The Athletic joining me, Ralph Russo today.
0:58 we were planning on talking about picking up our conversation from last week, the the likely expansion of the playoff to 24 teams, and then Greg Sankey did solid. We're going to get to some user, listener viewer feedback on the 24-team playoff. By the way, it's also mailbag day. We'll hit that and we'll have interesting story that Bruce did on if you had the game to if you had the one game to win, who would you want as your coach?
1:28 Anyway, Greg Sankey helped program the show today cuz we were all ready to talk about playoff expansion and then at SEC basketball media days he said to paraphrase, the league is open to a 24-team playoff if SEC scheduling expectations are met nationally and that a decision on the playoff should come sooner rather than later. None of this is a surprise, but when Greg Sankey says it out loud, Stu, it makes a little news. but we're kind of interested in what our our audience has to say about all this playoff expansion talk.
2:04 >> Yeah, I mean it's certainly inevitable at this point. I think I'm still in shock. I haven't I haven't fully processed it yet. But on on our episode last week when we talked about this and we kind of each gave our opinions on it, I said, "Look, I may be totally off base, right? I've run these Twitter polls, other people have run them, and they would say, you know, 15% want a 24-team playoff, something like that."
2:28 So, let's open it up to our listeners. Our listeners are college football, right? Like certainly if you run a Twitter poll, there could be bots, there could be somebody who's never watched a college football game responding to it. You have no control over that. But our listeners are the you know, to to make it through an hour of us talking every episode, you must really really like college football. So, basically I took all the emails we received in that kind of open call, and I tallied it up. Also, we There were some comments left on YouTube. We we incorporated those as well.
3:04 and it is it is more popular, guys, with our listeners than it is with the Twitter users. But not that popular. the final tally was 30% are pro 24-team playoff, 70% are not. So, how do we quantify that? What What is the What is the significance of 30%? Well, I went looking for other comparisons and I happen to lock into the perfect one. I have an article here from July 12th, 1985, which was the day Coca-Cola abandoned New Coke.
3:40 New Coke, for our younger listeners, is is widely considered to be the biggest product change failure of all time. Coca-Cola replaced the recipe that it had been using for its entire history with a new sweeter recipe and people revolted. And 76 days later, they brought back old Coke and and rebranded it as Coca-Cola Classic. >> So, how did they make that decision, guys? >> Well, every week they would do a tracking poll of 900 consumers.
4:10 And it actually started out okay cuz they had done all these blind taste tests and people had actually indicated they liked it. But something about it actually becoming reality and seeing the label and feeling nostalgic for old Coke, the tide turned on them. And by the time they decided to pull the plug, this is what the spread was. 60% preferred the old and only 30% liked the new. So, a 2014 CFP is exactly as popular as New Coke, Bruce.
4:45 >> I hats off to you Stu. I think this is this is this is your wheelhouse, right? So, I I would say this cuz it's interesting. Like when we did our episode a week or so ago, I am close like my feeling on it is closer to yours than it is certainly to Ralph's. but where I landed on this as Ralph winces cuz he's trying to figure out what how do I actually feel as opposed to what am I defending?
5:15 That's that's Ralph land. but when I think about I think about this and I use the analogy of the frog's already been boiled because we got into an expanded playoff and we're already heading down, you know, headed to that road where yeah, it's probably still the best regular season, but it ain't what it used to be, right? And that's the thing that I was clinging to, but you know, we cover the sport and at some point I always feel like, you know what? They're going to do this whether the fans or people in the media are upset about it. They're going to do it.
5:47 cuz it's to to them it's all about the money. The money matters most. And so, here we are, right? whether it's 30% or 9% or 15%. I'll be honest, Stu, I was a little surprised it was as high as 30%. And again, that's not scientific either. I don't even know what scientific is when it comes to polls these days, right? But I don't I think Twitter polling was probably because as you said, the bots, the you know, there's just a lot of trolls on there and everything else. I feel like it's kind of to quote Mike Elgo it's a cesspool over there.
6:24 so, I don't know. You know, like it we're we're going there, you know, the three of us are going to still be really passionate about college football. We're going to we're you know, I mean, shoot, I watched two games last night, Tuesday night, you know, I watched FA FIU play and I watched God, I can't even remember what the other game was now. >> It was another Conference USA game. >> another conference Delaware. I watched I watched the Blue I watched the Blue Hens against the Blue Raiders, right?
6:54 so, we're not I I feel like we're you know, we're college football fans, but I feel like we're also in the media and we react to it. And Ralph, I would ask you this cuz I brought this up, you know, offline and I you know, we can you know, peek behind the curtain. I was like, you know, if Stu and I, for whatever reason, were were all on board for Yeah, we got to go to this because the September game schedule sucks and whatever, would you have been able would you have like put on your fencing hat and like parried and put your hand on your hip and go, "I'm going in the other direction right now."
7:31 >> Okay, so probably, but let me also walk that out a little bit. So, so what you're saying is would I flip-flop my position and be more likely to be against the college football playoff expanding to 24 because we are if Stu was adamantly for it, right? And to which I would say, yes, but you're also I think I might I'm being mischaracterized here. I I am a reporter. I am just reporting the news and part of that is just sort of presenting the sides here. So, if you guys were going to be saying this is why 24 is great, my job would be to say, well, here are the pros for staying at 12 and here are the cons for moving to 24. And that has been my position on this all along is simply saying like, hey guys, like this is going to happen.
8:24 That's not me saying like I'm leading the charge and listen, I understand fans want Stu. They want Stu's version of this and I they're not going to get that from me, but they do want lead the resistance, call them out on it, hold their feet to the fire. And I'm like, listen, my job is to report the news here. Like and and dissect it and explain it and explain why it's going to 24. Like so, I haven't had necessarily a passionate defense and I don't really love being painted as the passionate defender of this because like it puts me in a really like unpopular position. But listen, I get it. That's the one thing I would say.
9:04 One thing I think that has made me somewhat more I don't know, more rigorous in in any defense if you want to call it a defense is I think what I tend to defend is this. I don't love we should do something cuz we've always done it this way. I think that there's a there's a knee-jerk reaction to being like to clinging on to what like we've always done and to being nostalgic especially as old people, older guys being nostalgic and really fighting for the the things used to be. I think that's like a generally a bad place to be in and I don't where I find myself is I I just I I push back against that.
9:45 That's I push back against the idea that we need to keep things the way they've always been because damn it, that's the way it was when I was a kid and it was awesome then and that's the way it just always be and I just generally push back against that type of thinking and I'm not accusing you of doing that Stu, but I feel like I hear a lot of that in the in the rally against the 24 is a lot of like I just want things the way it used to be darn it.
10:09 >> >> Can Can I ask you something just to clarify though? Because I get it, this is a story that it's an developing story. You're taking the position as to present the story little different than the contrarian the total contrarian where like let's say Stu gets on here goes, you know guys, I'm not feeling great. I'm giving up soda. It's just like and and then all of a sudden you come on and go Stu, soda's really good for you. You need all the sugar you can get and just all of a sudden just like >> I'm not a default contrarian. I I do tend to have a contrarian bent to me. I do think it's part of my nature to sort of say, you believe this? Well, let me present you the other side even if it's not something I'm passionate about.
10:50 >> How frustrated were the Russo parents go, you went to Fordham, you have this really good education. Go to law school Ralph, it's in your DNA. Don't sit in press boxes with these other schleps. >> No, that trust me, nobody ever thought Ralph was going to be a lawyer growing up. That was >> But you would be well suited for it because like you said, you can take either side. So one day you get a guy as your client who who is definitely guilty of murder. You're like, okay, I can argue in in his defense. And then you next week you get somebody who's clearly innocent. I I don't know. That that analogy doesn't work on the other direction. No, no, no.
11:25 I think in all fairness because and this is especially true of podcasts, but also TV shows and other frankly media, everybody has a take. So, a listener listens and they expect us all to have a take. And I think Ralph, coming from the AP, just the facts background, just wants to give you the facts. And the And the two sides And because of that, because that's so rare, comes off as I'm always going to take the other side.
11:53 >> Yeah. And And again, I don't mind. It It makes for a better podcasting with somebody arguing for the other side. So, but let's hear from our listeners and our viewers. >> going to say, you guys have all heard our opinions, especially mine, many times. >> Yeah. >> So, we took just a few representative emails. By the way, these do not count toward the Trader Joe's gift card, just so we can be clear. We're going to do >> Sorry, guys.
12:14 >> We'll mailbag questions later. All right, so let's read a few of the ones that are for the 2014 playoff. Here's Troy Hunter. I respectfully disagree with Stu and all the other national media who seem to be against the 2014 playoff. I am very much for it. I'm a Washington fan and was always fine with a trip to the Holiday or the Sun Bowl in a good, but not great, season. But we, as a college football ecosystem, have decided that bowl games don't matter. If nothing matters except for the playoff, then more than 12 teams should be able to feel like they had a good season.
12:44 All right, I'm going to go on to the next one. Save your Save your comments for the end. Dan in Washington, D.C. I am on team the ship has sailed. We're already at a point where blue bloods can make the playoff with three losses. Games of the century are devalued and the bowls are meaningless. 24 teams is a corrective action to re-engage the middle class fandoms from those existing problems. And this last one's a little bit longer, but I'll try to keep it short. Oh, shoot, I cut off the listener's name.
13:12 We'll look that up and give you credit here in a little bit. I think Stu's arguments are wrong. I'm all in favor of an expanded playoff for these reasons. College football is professional football now. College, relative to other professional sports, has the smallest set of qualifying teams for the post season. The days of playing for the Sun Bowl are over. Why am I worried everybody keeps bringing up the Sun Bowl? Providing meaningful games for teams that are spending 20 to 40 million is going to be a requirement for these programs. The polls, even the CFP poll, is not close to an accurate measure of the strength of these teams. SMU getting into the CFP in 2024 as a first is a 9 and 3 Alabama team and a 10 and 2 Miami team was dubious at best.
13:47 And we've seen how the 12-team playoff creates more meaningful games at the end of the year. Traditional rivalries are going away. There are less good games than ever and having teams fighting for playoff spots is a way to continue to generate fan interest. so I will open it to the floor. >> I mean I I I don't think he I we could have said it any better myself. Honestly, like that that he those guys really did nail the crux of the argument here, which is the sport has changed in so so much different ways. And I've always felt like the best argument for it is this has always been a sport where the postseason had lots of opportunities and lots of trophies. You know, I know that people hate that. Like everybody gets a trophy. College football, everybody has always gotten a trophy. It's always been a lot of trophies. And they were bowl trophies and people were excited about that and that's just gone. So why not turn these bowl games into into playoff games? Has always been like the very simple way that I would describe. And I think those those emailers, you know, nailed it essentially.
14:52 >> the last person whose name is to cut off is actually Chris >> Chris Haynes. >> Haynes. >> Yeah. And I think he made some very compelling points about it you know, how he how he laid it out. I would I I do want to start with go back to this one point which, you know, I feel like folds into this cuz we're in just such a different era than when all of us honestly when we started when we started this podcast 10 years ago.
15:18 it's this. I think the sport because more teams can win it now and win the national title is a is a better sport than it was in 2012, 2015 when it felt like it was like Alabama, Georgia, or Clemson. Felt like those three schools, maybe Ohio State could get in, but it was like nobody was touching those schools. Then I felt like it was very reflective of the I keep going back to like the So Fi national title game, Georgia TCU.
15:52 Georgia won by 60. It felt like they were 60 points better than, you know, TCU had no business in there. And then things started to change a little bit. Like Michigan wasn't a a a big heavy portal team, but they were a developmental team and a continuity team. And I I you know, I get it that, you know, there's going to be a a component of that that everyone's going to be like, all right, yeah, they were also the the Connor Stallions team and that's why they got it. But like I felt like because of that the sport is is better because more teams have a have a chance to do that. So an expanded playoff, you know, I can see where people land on that and maybe that's that's part of it. Also, the other thing I'd say before, you know, I you you jump jump back in, Ralph, is for a lot of fans, they did not grow up the way the three of us grew up watching the sport. They're younger. They're also like they don't, you know, like I go back to this one game. You know, Notre Dame, it was when they were on top of the college football world and David Gordon, the Boston College kicker, you know, beat them and ruined their perfect season and, you know, whatever. Well, that was like 1991.
16:59 You know, Tom Coughlin, I think was the head coach at BC. >> Yes. >> You know, that was a That's What is it? 35 years ago? That's a long time ago. So I get it. Maybe there's some evolution needs, you know, is okay. >> Yeah, and the one thing I would also say is I think more teams have a chance to win the national championship. I also think more teams that could win the national championship could also lose a playoff game, right? In other words, what I'm saying like it's not I think some of those Alabama teams and Georgia teams were so loaded, they could only lose to each other.
17:30 I actually think if I look at the teams that I think could win a national championship this year and I could see them stumbling to a another team that might not be able to win the national championship, but is good enough to knock out one good team, right? They're good enough to knock So just the margins there also make it more compelling as well, Stu. >> Well, I think it's true that more programs than ever can win a national championship like Indiana just did. But in a given season if you aren't good enough to be in the top 12, you're not going to win the national championship. The only way I could see like a 18 seed winning the national championship if it's like Ohio State the rare year they go 9 and 3 and then the playoff starts and they flip a switch. You know, it's not going to be some plucky underdog.
18:15 >> Did any of those Did any of those emails make you go, "Hmm, that's a good point, Stu."? >> Well, yes. I think that and it's what you said before. If we all have decided to collectively devalue the bowls and that's not a reward, then there is merit to maybe more fan bases should get to experience something more meaningful. I just wish we could find a way to do that without lowering the bar for the playoff.
18:45 You know, there's been never there's never been any real attempt ever since the players started opting out of the bowls to make them worthwhile enough to stick around and play in the bowls. And you can literally pay them now to do that. and also people like to say they're meaningless, but what then why are so many people still watching them? 9 million people watch the Pop-Tarts Bowl last year. >> a lot of gambling. That's There's nothing else to watch on TV. I mean, look, we had we had a Friday night game last week that got 3.5 million viewers easy.
19:17 You know, it's like it's a big number. It's like are people staying home on a Friday night? There's you know, remember that like, hey, there's all this high school football that, you know, don't put games on Friday night. People watch football. >> People watch football, but a lot of people, relatively speaking, watch the higher end ball the the the non-playoff bowl games in kind of like that upper tier, the Citrus Bowl, Outback Bowl, whatever. So, >> I wish you a merry Christmas, man.
19:41 There's nothing else to do during that time of the year. >> were concentrating more on >> All right. Read some Read Read some that agree with you. Get Get to that to that part. >> the way, there were a lot of those, but I still tried to cut down on it. >> First of all, my ego is definitely growing as I as I read these. Brandon Becker, long-time listener, first-time emailer here, but I couldn't pass up the chance to let Stu know how right he is about how much fans don't want the 24-team playoff. Not a single person I know who actually call it follows college football wants it. At best, a few are ambivalent like Ralph.
20:15 Steven I've got to look up the name on this one for me. I am personally not in favor of the 24-team playoff. I agree with Stu that it devalues the regular season to a point where it is not worth watching until the playoff unless you are a hardcore fan. Attendance will fall as early season games are meaningless. Look no further than the USC game earlier this year. Ralph has always questioned whether the G6 belongs in the playoff.
20:36 How is having an 8 and 4 middle-of-the-pack Big Ten team different? That's an interesting one. We'll get back to you on that, Ralph. Jamie Stoddard. I'm a Utah fan. The 24-team playoff is built for teams like Utah that consistently finish in the 11 to 24 range. Since 2014, Utah would have made a 24-team playoff eight times. That being said, I'm very much against the 24-team playoff. I completely agree with Stu on this one. It further diminishes the value of regular season games, which is what I've always loved about college football. I'll be a a either way, but my preference would be to stay at 12.
21:09 and then we'll end with Alan Myers in New Orleans, even though I could keep reading these for days. >> Well, of course you can because you feel great. >> >> Alan Myers, I hate the 2014 playoff. I don't know why Ralph feels the need to be the devil's advocate. Yes, as a UGA fan, I will always watch the Georgia game. I'll probably watch SEC games, but when the 2014 playoff hits, I probably won't be paying much attention to any other league. I probably will listen to about 80% less podcasting hours as our walk being >> Oh, no. That's bad. Wait a second.
21:40 >> >> Now you're spreading your lies there. >> Now I completely disagree with the 2014 expansion. >> Well, the recurring theme here seems to be the devaluing of the regular season. and yeah, he said to Ralph, "Actually, I think that's a separate issue about the G6. Let's start with the idea of the devaluing of the regular season. Even a Utah fan who knows his team would go to the playoff more often thinks he doesn't want it cuz he knows it'll devalue the regular season."
22:11 >> I mean, listen, I've sit in press boxes the last few weeks and honestly, like I'm not I'm not going to argue. I'm It is an inarguable point that you are making cuz I will sit in press boxes thinking, "What am I going to write about this game?" and realize that the the one thing I can't write is the urgency of it and sort of and the grandness of this the the stakes, right? That has been removed and that has been the lifeblood of covering college football, especially in the way we do on a national level, where we tend to focus on the big games, the biggest games and the big and the national championship race and what it all means every week and there will be less what it all means every week in a 2014 playoff.
23:02 it will be more incremental as opposed to big statements. >> You know what it will bring though, Ralph? Like, you're covering Penn State-Michigan this weekend, right? You're going to that >> No, I'm not. I'm not. >> No, no, no. >> Well, I know. >> It's all I I always get that one. >> I couldn't make it. >> So, I feel like I've been on the road a lot. >> I feel like what we get out of this is okay, who wants to who wants to put the spotlight on the dumpster fire, right?
23:27 Like, you get more of oh man, they're at three losses. They ain't making the playoff. Should this you know, like I think I think what had gotten said a lot was oh, if more teams are in the playoff, that means more coaches' jobs will get saved, right? Like, if Brian Kelly had 2014 playoff, does he make the playoff once? Lincoln Riley would have made the playoff already once. You know, like that year when Caleb hurt his hamstring in the Pac-12 title game, they don't you know, they don't they don't miss the first you know, I don't know if that changes anything in terms of like you know what, you're one of these teams. If it's 2014 playoff, that ain't asking too much for you to make make it.
24:06 I don't know. So, there's like there's a lot of different little like things that attach to it cuz you were you brought up Ralph about like, what am I going to write about? I think we would pivot to something along those lines anyway. >> Can I just ask you Stu like this cuz one of the emailers said something about I'm not as hardcore, so I will watch less. And I that does trigger me on something of this idea of like beca- And again, everybody hates when you compare it to the NFL, so I'm bracing for this. But, the idea of I'm enjoying this game because it's two good teams.
24:41 Right? Georgia-Alabama is just like a game between two awesome teams, so I'm going to watch and enjoy these games, and I'm going to sit there from noon to 2:00 in the morning on a Saturday enjoying these games. I understand the stakes are lessened, but I would also question how much you love the sport if all if you if you can't enjoy it without those higher stakes. >> So, I I addressed a question like this in my mailbag on Wednesday, and it was actually a pretty interesting exercise for myself to do, which was we have six top 25 games this week.
25:20 How differently would they feel in a 2014 playoff? And what I realized is I think Ohio State Indiana would feel exactly the same, right? Because of what you just said. Just for the same reason an NFL fan wants to watch 49ers Seahawks in week five because those are just two good teams. I want to watch these two top five teams play each other just to see which one's better. I think Notre Dame BYU would feel pretty similar because it's a Notre Dame and everybody wants to see if they're going to lose.
25:50 I think where you start to feel the the feel the the the the dampening is it's number nine Ole Miss versus number 13 Missouri this week. That game has stakes. One of those teams is going to be on life support for the playoff. Not anymore. LSU Mississippi State, Florida Texas. These games don't have much urgency. Like they're not the best teams except for maybe Texas. They're not the worst they're not like the low top 20 they're just kind of in that middle of well, I'm interested in this game cuz it has some stakes and now I'm not. and I don't know how far down the chain that would that effect would have, but yeah, when he says he wouldn't pay attention to any other games, I don't know him.
26:32 but I think he would still pay attention to those top two games I mentioned. I don't know about the others. By the way, the first email about he agrees with Stu. actually, we need to bring up this point at the end. It was from Barry Rhodes. Ralph, you've always questioned whether the G6 belongs in the playoff. How is having an eight and four middle of the pack Big 10 team different? >> I will adjust this super quickly. I do not believe the G6 doesn't belong in the playoff. I believe that the system that the way college football is set up gives the G6 very little chance to compete in the playoff and that is the problem. So just again, I want to correct the record here. Often my often I mischaracterize in my positions. So I would correct the record there and say like I want the the the the question is not does the G6 belong in the playoff? It's the is the system of college football allow the G6 to be competitive and right now it doesn't. So then you ask the question, what are we going to do about that?
27:30 >> All right, so I just want to touch on this one quick thing. Your point is valid, but I feel like in these games, whether it's, you know, a 9-13, a 11-22, which end up having is if people are going to watch, it's it's such a personal thing. It's almost like the way you're talking about it and we're in mid-October now. It's not mid-November. It's like this isn't like watching soap operas or watching a reality show where if you miss an episode, you can't get caught up. Like I think if people like the games, they're going to go, "Okay, I'm definitely tuning in." If you're a real football college football fan, you're going to watch those games.
28:06 You're not going to be like, "Eh, it really doesn't matter to the big picture, so I'm out on that." >> Yeah, and look, I may I may be wrong. It may turn out that there's no effect that kept people watch as much college football as they used to. I just don't I but I don't think what's going to happen is it's going to grow. It's going to be like, "Oh, okay, we got all these new people cuz now they can watch the number 20 team in the versus the number you know, see if they're going to make the playoff."
28:29 I would just I would just end it with this and by the way, this was a good discussion. I really like the I mean, it's been very informative for me to read the comments. In fact, some of you whose names we just read are going to be in print on The Athletic very soon. I think the shame of all this is that we did find a sweet spot. You know, I don't think it was in the saving doc. I got to the point of the the one versus two LSU Alabama game.
28:51 Like I don't think it was particularly great when you know, as much as we like the stakes of one loss could end your season, like the fact that that loss didn't end their season, but it did end but one loss did end Oklahoma State season was not ideal, right? That's why the BCS was so unpopular. But it's also 24 is like too far in the other direction. 12's the sweet spot. We found the sweet spot and we're going to abandon it after 3 years and I and I think that's a big shame of it. So we are going to take a break now.
29:25 When we come back, we are going to talk about a really interesting story that Bruce did. >> All right. You are the athletic director, the a fan, somebody invested in a college football team. You have a game to win. You have you get to pick one coach to win that one game. Any coach, who do you pick? Bruce Feldman posed that question to a bunch of other coaches. Like hey, you got to I don't know if you posed it as you have a game to win for your life. I kind of like doing that sometimes, but you posed that posed that question to a bunch of coaches and they came up with the answers. What did you get, Bruce?
30:05 >> Yeah, so we got about three dozen responses from all coaches at basically all levels of Division 1 football. It was a lot of head coaches at both FBS and FCS level and there was a lot of assistants and GMs at the FBS level. And two names got mentioned way more than the rest, right? So Kirby Kirby Smart got got over 50% of the votes. and Kurt Cignetti got over 30% of the votes. Those two guys dominated it. And then there was only three other coaches mentioned. Bob Chesney, who I'm not sure, you know, most of our college football audience would have known who that was a year ago at this time.
30:51 he got three votes. Jason Eck from New Mexico got two votes, and Willie Fritz got one vote. you know, and I mentioned this to Stu at one point. I think I I like kind of not quizzed him, but I was like, "Hey, there's two other guys at the time, you know, in addition to Chesney." And I said, "I bet you get one." Cuz I know he's been you know, he's on been on the Willie Fritz bandwagon for a while, and he even he didn't come up with I gave him a bunch of choices. You know, so it's just interesting to hear the rationale of why guys picked who they picked.
31:21 and it was a fun exercise in that regard. >> I would wonder if the Eck Fritz Chesney, especially, but Eck and Fritz is a lot of I know these guys can coach with anything, right? Whereas the Kirby And this also speaks to who didn't make the list. I I wonder if like some guys are answering that question as, "Hey, if I if I just give them he can take mine and beat his, and he can take his and beat mine, right?" The old expression. And that And guys like Fritz and and Eck look like good game coaches in that matter. But Stu, a couple of notable names that didn't make the list there. Who stood out to you that that what that didn't get any votes?
32:08 >> 2024 national championship coach Ryan Day for one. so which tells me that a lot of coaches feel the way Jim Harbaugh did. Born on third base, you know, kind of I don't know. He He's a guy that hasn't always gotten maybe the credit that you would think he would. What's one of yours? >> Kalen DeBoer. And yeah, Day, there's definitely a like a born on third base thing there. Kalen DeBoer. And And the reason why Kalen DeBoer is we see his record in these big games. Like even a game that that Alabama lost over the weekend to Georgia, he coaches very aggressively. He seems to in a lot of these games win the big moments. That was definitely their MO at Washington. Like so many close games in big games come down to situations and managing those situations, and I feel like DeBoer does a really good job of in-game coaching, managing situations, and being aggressive. Like how how am I going to run this play or this situation that best gives me a chance to win this game? It seems like DeBoer is good at that part of the game, Bruce.
33:22 >> I agree. And you know, it's funny. Before I started working on this story, I talked to some of the Alabama coaches leading into last week's big game against Georgia, and I said, "Why is he you know, his record is exceptional in top-10 games?" I said, "Why is he so is just so good?" Cuz you look at what he did against Washington, got the best of Dan Lanning, you know, you know, repeatedly and and and whatnot. And they they had come back to me and basically said, "Because he is so even-keeled and kind of gets the players to be confident, gets the players to be comfortable. It's like, "Hey, this is why you came to this school, to play in these kind of games." Now, it's ironic because the the image people are going to remember most of the Georgia game is him going full Saban in that moment. And so, I think there was there was that. But but by and large, Kalen DeBoer is a very cool customer. He's very creative and very clear-headed, and it shows up in that regard. Now, there was a there was an interesting answer cuz I I One thing that I think jumped out at me is there felt like there's a lot of recency bias that can happen, right? So, I just you know, if if there's not that pass interference if that pass interference gets called and and Alabama beats Georgia again, which they'd I think it would have been three out of four times for Kalen DeBoer in that, I wonder if Kalen DeBoer gets, you know, a half dozen of those first place votes that Kirby Smart got.
34:51 >> I wonder if he did the survey at the beginning of the season when UCLA was zeros zero and zero, whether Bob Chesney would have gotten three votes. >> I don't know. The one of the guys gave me a very oddly specific reference to why Bob Chesney. And what happens is there's a handful of guys who know these coaches way before any of us ever did. And one of them coached against him at a couple of different levels and was like, "You know what? I felt I've never been able to beat him. I felt like we had him one year and then in overtime he calls Philly special on a two-point play and we lose 53-52.
35:24 You know, he's just got a lot of guts and he's pretty fearless and confident and it comes through on his teams. And so, there's that. But But one of the guys I, you know, talked to who gave a very detailed answer about you know, why to me it's Sig. To me it's going it's it's going through everyone else and asking who would be better. And then this guy goes, 'Kirby, very good very good but more at all since NIL. Marcus Freeman went 0 and 2 in big games last year. Mario Cristobal lost to Sig. Ryan Day lost to Sig. Kalen DeBoer 0 and 2 in last two.'
36:01 >> criteria is lost to Sig, nobody's going to get a vote. >> Yeah, well, what's what's what's interesting to me is yes, he did but >> Freeman beat Sig and Ryan Day put it on him the year before when he won the national title, right? So, there's the recency bias piece of it that I think is, you know, like these are opinions and everything else, but it was it was definitely interesting of of you know, I asked one one of the coaches who had said Ryan Day would actually be third on his list, you know, after he was let me just go to this quote for a second.
36:37 he had Signetti first and then had him slightly ahead of of Kirby Smart with Day third. Quote, this is on Day. He's detailed plans well and he's he's best when he stays aggressive, especially now with the monkey off his back. End quote. And I think that feels pretty spot-on there to be honest. >> So, I think if you're picking Kirby, your mindset is I want to have the best team going into that game and I know Kirby will bring the best players with him. So, which is always the best way to win the big games is have the best players. I just want to ask a follow-up on Day. I like how many coaches do you think cuz I think I get this sentiment a little bit when I talk to people is man again, but we're going back to the born on third base thing, but but maybe expounded on it. If I had that job I'd beat Michigan more often. I I would have done like in other words, I I get the feeling there are coaches who probably sit back and say Ohio State is the crown jewel of all jobs.
37:40 I could do better I could do that job. I could do it as well as he could because man, like Ohio State's always good. It just feel I mean that's not fair towards Ryan like the thing doesn't run itself, but there is a feeling that Ohio State does kind of run itself. >> There is but there is that, but I think you go back like Urban, say what you want. Urban won three national titles, was a great college coach. And Urban's issue was they would get so tight that they got they got destroyed by Purdue and got destroyed by Iowa and like Ryan Day's doesn't feel like he's losing those games.
38:14 You know, and >> make an argument that the best team of the playoff era not to win a national championship was the 2015 Ohio State team that lost to Michigan State and and Urban just kind of blew that one. The the 2015 team with was the follow-up to the national championship team. They brought back Bosa, brought back Ezekiel Elliott, and they screwed up the quarterback situation. And that's only to say like this stuff doesn't run itself, right? And Saban created a an illusion that like you should just knock out national championships every year, and that's very hard. And I think that gets held against Ryan Day, but I do wonder if there's a whole bunch of folks who are like, I could do that job. Like >> I think you're right, Ralph. I think there are people who look at it and say that. And by the way, I want to go back to your point initially about Kirby and well, he has the best players, you know, by our our NIL database of he doesn't get the most expensive roster. Now, he has a very expensive roster, but not relative to Texas or LSU.
39:12 so, it's it's interesting in that regard where you know, it's like you see guys who are, you know, Mario Cristobal was not expecting him to get a vote, but I think people know that he has a very high-end roster that he's working with, right? And so, they've been they've made some cold-blooded decisions on, hey, this quarterback, we're not sure he's going to be the guy. Let's go get that guy, you know? And And that's kind of operating, but in the context of this question, it's not like who's running the best program, it's who do we want for that one game.
39:47 >> Yeah, I I wonder I wonder if people took those instructions literally or not, but to your guys' point, to Ralph's point about I mean, the bar is so high for Ohio State that it's almost impossible for the coach to get credit. And I will say tell you that in 2019 Ryan Day tied with P.J. Fleck for Big Ten Coach of the Year. Tied, so shared national championship, if you will. That was the first time an Ohio State coach won Big 10 coach of the year since Earl Bruce in 1979.
40:21 Jim Tressel never won it. Urban Meyer never won it. >> Yeah. >> No matter what rate they won at national championship, it was still seen as not as impressive as for example the year 2014, the year they Ohio State won a national championship under Urban Meyer. Do you want to know who won Big 10 coach of the year? Jerry Kill. >> Jerry Kill for going eight and five at Minnesota. Paul Chryst won more has won more Big 10 coach of the years than Ryan Day.
40:52 I mean coach of the year awards tend to be very like well who overachieved, right? Who did more with less? And I guess because of that it's impossible for an Ohio State coach because they're always doing more with more. All right, guys. I know Bruce only asked for one, but let's do for each of us our top three, like our Heisman ballot of coaches. Top three coaches you would want coaching one game starting with Ralph. >> I'll go with DeBoer. Again, I like the way he manages games and his aggressiveness. I'll go with Signetti because I think his teams are less likely to blow it.
41:28 To to to screw themselves up. and then listen, it it's it's it's boring and it's hard not to go with Kirby, but Kirby wins a lot of games and >> Yeah. >> you know, I I I don't think he's a brilliant strategist, but he also doesn't Again, he tends not to screw things up, >> Bruce. >> He seems to be a heck of a motivator. Seems to really know how to give that pregame speech. >> Without question.
41:52 >> a little skeptical that that was leaked intentionally and someone was behind it? >> way that was leaked without his knowledge. The fact that it keeps happening, that guy would be fired by now, whoever was doing that. No way do I believe that Kirby doesn't know they're leaking that. >> this is one of the coaches I talked to as a head coach had I referenced the leaked the leaked speech and his rationale and he was like that's a window into, you know, that about like, hey, don't worry about the scoreboard, but a very Saban-ish thing, but don't worry about the scoreboard, just be way more physical than them. That's the thing that you hang your hat on in those kind of games and thought it was for me, I would say it's hard for me to go against Signeti at this point. I mean, the guy's a wizard in my eyes at this point. You look at what he's done with with with his evaluation quarterbacks we you know, we get into this where it's he he takes Mendoza, you know, a two-star guy who was like pretty good at Cal and he wins the Heisman. Then he goes and gets Hoover who was a turnover machine and he's got 17 touchdowns and zero picks in the first six games, you know, it's amazing. I would go DeBoer number two. I think everything Ralph said I agree with and I would go Kirby number three. Let's do.
43:05 I have the exact >> No, I have Sig one, Kirby two, DeBoer three. And it's it's interesting that we all said DeBoer when or mentioned him when when not he didn't get a single first place vote, but if you're if you're really just saying win the game, right? So, all the roster construction, all that is irrelevant for this question, right? that guy has more awesome fourth down calls than anybody. You know, the one that always stands out to me was the Apple Cup in the national the season that they went to the national championship.
43:36 >> Thing of beauty. >> Oh my gosh, the panic >> split, yeah. >> Yeah. >> Kind of reverse thing, yeah. >> last season, the four you know, they could line up and kick an easy field goal to take the lead on Auburn on fourth and two. No, we're going to go for it and get it. And then even in the game the other day, right? Right before halftime. That was a I wouldn't call it surprising cuz I'm never surprised anymore when he goes for it on fourth down.
43:59 and that worked. So, that kind of speaks to me. Actually, you know what? I'm flipping them. DeBoer two, Kirby three. Nothing against Kirby, but like you said, Ralph, like there's not I don't have a lot of like specific in-game things to correlate to him. I'm sure they do great stuff. I'm not trying to discredit it. I just don't have like a vivid example of that other than they scout the heck out of the teams. There was a game against Tennessee when Tennessee was undefeated with Hendon Hooker, like eight and oh, nine and oh, they're playing Georgia who's also undefeated. And to that point, Tennessee's offense was like unstoppable.
44:34 And Kirby and Georgia go out there and just like >> They decimated them. >> And they're moving the ball on us. Now, that was a great team, obviously. That was the same team that beat TCU 65 to 7. >> One last thing on this, since we talked about the leaked speech, one thing I noticed on Instagram, which is like kind of, you know, Kirby's personality, it's hard to get too much going out of there, right? And there was a cool video, I think Georgia posted, where it's like him kind of walking around at practice, and you see you see his personality, like one of his players is stretching, Kirby Kirby puts his ass on him, and he's like, "That's 221 lb of steel on you." or whatever. And then you But you also see the detail stuff of him coaching defensive backs to the point where like, I'd be lying if I didn't say I took it off Instagram and showed my kid this. I was like, "Watch what he says here, cuz it's good messaging." You know, it's like he knows exactly what he's doing, and that's why they've stayed, you know, a national title contender throughout whatever this dips and everything else with that NIL.
45:34 >> I think >> Georgia practice is actually quite entertaining because he walks around with that with that microphone. >> Mic. >> Not a megaphone, a microphone. And it's PA, and you can hear him chewing people out from like a mile away. So. All right, we'll take a quick break, and when we get back, mailbag. All right, guys, it's time for the mailbag. As always, guys, you can send your emails to the audiblepod@gmail.com. I would definitely do it because one of you every week wins a $24 Trader Joe's gift card. Our first question is from Joe Rogers.
46:04 And I'll direct it to Ralph. If a team has effectively been eliminated from the playoffs and he uses Texas A&M as an example and has players that were expected to do well but are underperforming expectations, should the team take the opportunity to evaluate for the future? When is an appropriate time to see what is on the roster now to determine what financial investments they should be making for retention, recruiting, and the portal for next year? Ralph.
46:27 So I think this falls under the header of I don't know if this is actually different from the way it used to be. It might feel different. The decision-making is different cuz it involves money, but I don't know if teams aren't hadn't already been doing this in the before times, right? In pre-NIL and pre-money. I I I I think at a certain point during a season even before teams were spending millions on players, you would pivot to all right, like season's kind of gone off the rails here. We're probably not going to win a conference championship. Let me start looking at my freshman quarterback and not worry about this senior. Let me not worry about these transfer like now it's transfers, right? I brought in a bunch of transfers who I have no obligation to next year. Let me start looking at my younger guys. Like I I the without question the scope of the conversation and the and the evaluation is a little different cuz you would literally are talking about money spent, but I'm not sure that's drastically different than what we've had before when it wasn't a 2014 playoff or it wouldn't excuse me when it wasn't a 12-team playoff and you were out of conference conference contention and things along those lines.
47:45 So So you the answer to your question is yes, teams should start doing that and I think they do, but I also don't know if that's that much different from the way it always was. All right, next up we have Blaine in Virginia. I'm going to direct this one toward Stew. Coaches being fired after one season is common in the NFL. I have to say I'm not sure it's that common in the NFL, but it does happen.
48:12 >> I was going to say getting fired after one year for the 49ers. The Browns have also done it, too. >> Okay. I stand corrected. Now that college football is professionalized, could we see it here? There is no justice. The AD that hired Pat Fitzgerald bolted and now gets to oversee Will Stein. That is Jay Bat who made that hire for Michigan State. Fitz is now a 2 and 20 in his last 22 Big 10 games, lacks NIL experience. Could you see the AD, the new AD at Michigan State saying, "I have no idea what the the last guy was doing.
48:47 We are taking a write-down and starting anew." And again, that's Blaine in Virginia. >> You guys know who Pat Fitzgerald's playing this weekend? Northwestern. I do know that. >> Oh, that's right. >> Yeah, I mean it the juice is not there cuz Michigan State's not good, but I mean it's it's it's unbelievable. Like he's going to go play against the team the school that he played for, he coached for 16 years, and then got fired from and won a massive settlement with.
49:22 do I think Michigan State's going to fire Pat Fitzgerald after one year? Probably not. But what's interesting there is when they hired him, they did the kind of contract that I've always said more schools should do, which is low salary, lots of incentives. He's only making 5 million this year, which is a complete bargain for a Big 10 coach. Probably more likely to agree to that when you've just won a huge settlement from your former employer.
49:50 and the buyout is 72%. So, that's actually the buyout is to fire him after 1 year would be less than what it was to fire Jonathan Smith after 2 years. That being said, 18 million is not an insignificant number when you're already paying Jonathan Smith. You remember what the number was, guys? It was pretty high. Was it like 30? >> 25 million or something. >> Yeah, could have >> This would also, by the way, if they did fire him, that would be four head coaches in 5 years cuz remember they didn't have they had Mel Tucker and then they bounced on Jonathan and Smith super fast, too.
50:21 >> I mean, it's halfway through the season. They lost Illinois by one point in overtime. Like, let's just not assume they're going to go two and 10 or whatever it may be. But, so no, I would think he'll be back next year. Now, if it were a school where the AD who hired the guy is still there, could it be it could be done, but with the way these contracts are made, it would just be so expensive. Like, that con- that Pat Fitzgerald contract is an outlier. For the most part, schools are still doing the thing, guys. Like, Penn State did that thing again of here's a fully guaranteed contract that will be almost impossible for us to get out of.
50:59 >> Does Jay Bat get to claim the Will Stein hire and and not the Pat Fitz hire? >> no, but it is interesting that he, of all places that he walked into, the guy who's like the shining success story right now. All right, Bruce, this one's for you. It's literally for you from Mark from Pittsburgh. This one is mostly for Bruce. I was excited when Penn State fell backwards into Matt Campbell after a botched coaching search last fall.
51:26 However, the season has completely fallen off the rails. Campbell has inexplicably been wasting timeouts and has me missing James Franklin's clock management. The team has no identity. I know you are a big believer in Campbell. Can you give a hopeless Penn State fan any hope? >> A little bit, in this regard. I I Penn State with Matt Campbell especially this year was was going to be living in the margins probably more than most teams and you looked at it they lost two of probably their most dynamic if not their most dynamic offensive and their most dynamic defensive player. Kobe Howard who'd been really good for the first three games and he gets hurt and that short-circuits the offense and they also lose Max Granville who's their most explosive edge rusher who was a guy that you know other coaches I'd talked to played Penn State were like that guy's big time and they lost him.
52:17 Now you should be if you're Penn State you should be able to survive that but what's happened is they also don't have for the first time in a long long time they do not have like an elite running back or you know at times Penn State's had two of them like they had two of them the last couple of years and then obviously going back to like Saquon and you had this run of big time running backs. They don't got that. I mean as one of the coaches I talked to was like they're very average there. So you put very average without a special player outside which they hadn't had you know big big time receivers in a minute and they finally get one and then he gets hurt. There's a lot on Rocco Becht. Rocco Becht has really struggled.
52:57 You know he played a lot and he played good football in the Big 12. and it's not even like the schedule has gotten that thick for them yet. I mean they're playing solid teams but it's not like oh my god, you know it's not like USC's defense is not putting the putting the fear of God in anybody. >> He was better last week against USC too. >> Yeah, I mean yeah that's true. For the first three quarters he looked like he was in a comfort zone, right? But they're very limited and the one thing I would say is look this guy was the best coach in Iowa State history. I mean he did stuff nobody was expecting them to do. He also was good in relative to what Iowa State had been he was good against top teams. You know his record was surprisingly good you know are off giants when he played them or top 10 teams, you got to give him more time than this.
53:47 I get it what what what you said is true. It was a very botched hiring process. And Ralph, I know you've you know, you've spent a bunch of time in Happy Valley and it ain't that happy with with the AD right now. And so there's a lot of things that make this thing pretty complicated going forward. >> All right. Before I wrap up, I do want to say this. Sometimes we get it right and sometimes we get it wrong. So there was a lot of folks who were like, how they going to win the in the Big 10 with a bunch of Big 12 players? And I think a lot of us, I think maybe all of us were like, well, give it a chance. I think it's good work out okay. The people who were saying that turned out to be right. And we, you know, I will I'm not going to force you guys to take the L, but I took a I'm going to take a little bit of an L there. The people who who said that this roster wasn't going to be good enough were right. Though I will say that both Stu and I tamped down on those expectations a little bit. I think a lot of people were out over their skis on Penn State in a way that I that we weren't. But I just hey, I want to acknowledge like sometimes we get it wrong and I think on this one we got it wrong.
54:51 >> So are you out of the So you're out on on Matt Campbell? Are you not think it's >> I but I do think he's going to be a good coach. I think he's going to be a good >> of >> They think this is how he's going to build his roster every year. Like you're telling me every single year Matt Campbell is going to go find some an eight and four team in the Big 12 and raid their players. I would say no, that's not a good strategy. But like when you take over a job on short notice like that, sometimes you don't really have a choice. You're how are you going to fill a roster if you don't bring some players with you in this in this day and age, especially given how many guys were walking out the door. Now the counterpoint is, well, Bob Chesney got the job pretty late too and he brought his guys and look at them now, right? So but I would I would agree with you Ralph, like I'm not saying no Big 12 players would ever succeed in the Pac-12 I mean the Big 10. That would be really snobby.
55:41 But this particular set of Big 12 players is not turning out very well. All right, guys. We've got to pick a Trader Joe's gift card winner. I just feel bad for Mark from Pittsburgh for having to suffer through this this awful season. So, I say we give him the gift card. >> I I'm going to go with Joe Rogers. I thought that was an interesting I I just think it's interesting the way people are are looking at the current state of affairs and how it might have been different before then.
56:04 >> I'm going to back Stu. I think Stu's heart is in the right place. So, enjoy the enjoy the Trader Joe's and Pittsburgh. >> for the We don't want people to think that the only way to win the gift card is to send the My first game ever was the Wing-T. What was your guys' first memory, right? Like sometimes we just go like you know what? I feel bad for the guy. Let's just give him the gift card.
56:29 so, Mark, the the suffering Penn State fan, send your mailing address to audiblepod@gmail.com. Ralphie's in >> Pittsburgh. He'll probably go to the same Trader Joe's as your daughter goes to. >> Hopefully, yeah. So, she >> Everybody else can always send their email questions to audiblepod@gmail.com. We will be back Sunday morning live at 11:30 a.m. Eastern to react to this great set of games we have this weekend. That's on our YouTube channel at audibleshow. We'll see you next time.
Summary
- SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey indicates openness to a 24-team playoff if scheduling expectations are met.
- Listener feedback shows 30% support for playoff expansion, while 70% oppose it.
- Concerns are raised about the devaluation of regular season games with an expanded playoff.
- Comparisons are made to Coca-Cola's New Coke failure to illustrate public sentiment on playoff changes.
- The hosts discuss the impact of playoff expansion on fan engagement and the significance of traditional rivalries.
- A segment features a survey of coaches on who they would choose to win a single game, with Kirby Smart and Kurt Cignetti receiving the most votes.
- The hosts reflect on the challenges faced by coaches like Ryan Day and Matt Campbell in high-pressure environments.
- The episode concludes with a mailbag segment addressing listener questions and concerns about team performance and coaching strategies.
Questions Answered
What is The Audible and how can listeners engage?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the off-season. Listeners are encouraged to subscribe and follow on social media to build a community.
What are listeners' opinions on the 24-team playoff expansion?
Listeners have mixed feelings about the playoff expansion, with some supporting it and others expressing concerns about the devaluation of bowl games and the playoff's impact on the sport.
How would a 24-team playoff change the dynamics of college football?
A 24-team playoff could lead to less dramatic weekly narratives in college football, as more teams would have a chance to qualify, potentially diluting the significance of individual games.
How does recency bias affect coaching recognition in college football?
Recency bias can influence how coaches are evaluated and recognized, with recent performances overshadowing past successes or failures, impacting votes and perceptions.
When should a college football team evaluate its roster for future seasons?
Teams should evaluate their roster when playoff hopes are diminished, allowing them to focus on younger players and future recruitment strategies, especially in the context of NIL and transfer portals.