Section Insights
The Importance of Individual Worldviews
How does an individual's perspective on optimism and problem-solving impact their worldview?
The speaker expresses interest in how personal worldviews shape one's understanding of optimism and problem-solving, especially in the context of societal challenges like AI fears. They highlight the tension between individual perspectives and broader societal issues.
- Individual worldviews are crucial in shaping responses to societal challenges.
- Optimism can be a personal lens through which problems are viewed.
- The tension between personal and societal perspectives can lead to deeper insights.
Understanding Knowledge and Belief
What does it mean to believe or disbelieve something according to the philosopher Khal Pa?
Khal Pa argues that belief and disbelief cannot be willed into existence; they must arise from reason. Thus, labeling disbelief as immoral is misguided.
- Belief is a product of reason, not willpower.
- Misunderstanding can often be attributed to a lack of clarity in communication.
- Philosophical insights can challenge conventional views on morality and belief.
The Complexity of Fictional Knowledge
Why is creating realistic narratives in fiction challenging?
Crafting a believable story where characters face dire situations requires skill. Authors must avoid easy resolutions and instead provide meaningful insights that enrich the reader's understanding of life.
- Realistic storytelling demands depth and complexity.
- Easy resolutions in narratives can lead to audience disappointment.
- Good fiction should impart knowledge about life and human experience.
The Nature of Creativity
How does the speaker define creativity?
Creativity is defined as the ability to generate new knowledge. Unlike other species, humans possess explanatory creativity, allowing them to articulate reasons behind their choices.
- Creativity involves generating new knowledge, not just novel ideas.
- Humans have a unique capacity for explanatory creativity.
- Understanding the nature of creativity can enhance our appreciation of human intelligence.
Learning Through Challenge
What analogy does the speaker use to describe the learning process?
The speaker compares learning to mountaineering, emphasizing that true learning involves overcoming psychological challenges and should be pursued with passion, rather than through forced discipline.
- Learning should be a passionate pursuit, akin to mountaineering.
- Psychological challenges are integral to the learning experience.
- Forced learning often leads to disengagement and superficial understanding.
Transcript
0:00 I'm kind of fascinated in your worldview from a a personal perspective, from a person's perspective. You know, we can talk about how important it is for a society or for civilization or for humanity as a whole to think about the importance of optimism and our capacity to solve problems and stuff like that. I'm kind of interested in how an individual takes that as well. I think that might be an interesting tension. obviously we've had all of this most recent stuff about anthropic researchers leaving and and over fears of AI and and then super intelligence and recursive stuff. I don't know if you're interested in that or if you're kind of a little bit bored of it. I've been talking about it a lot. I'm also interested in how your worldview's changed over the last 15 years since the last book, human potential and stuff like that. So, we can we can start off and then scurry down whatever rabbit holes sound interesting if that seems good to you.
0:51 >> Sure. >> Wonderful. Oh, by the way, I I think I agree with that maxim. So, you know, whenever someone doesn't understand you, it's your fault, not theirs. >> Unless they're a golden retriever. >> That's literally. >> Are you telling me that I've got to get out of jail free card today? >> yeah. Yeah. You You're human. Yes. >> Say more on that. Why Why is it the the fault of misunderstanding? Why does that lie in an odds direction to >> so I'm as you will know I'm a follower of the philosopher Khal Pa and he has a theory of knowledge which is in my view streets ahead of everyone else in the in the 20th century. He he he's he's a strange strange kind of reputation because he's very well known, highly respected. You know, people always put him on the list of the 10 top philosophers or something like that. And in science especially, they always talk about Papa's criterion for distinguishing science from philosophy or from pseudocience.
2:07 And yet his actual philosophy is not very well understood. And and one of the tenets of his philosophy is that there is only one way of creating knowledge. The the details are different but knowledge as created by the process of evolution as created by a scientist, a mathematician, a child learning to speak their first language. those processes are all more alike than they are different. The the differences are pretty inessential.
2:44 And in in particular the the process of learning something new like learning a new law of physics that one has discovered or learning an existing piece of knowledge like from somewhere someone else that is all the same process mentally in all of them. the the knowledge that is learned comes from within the learner.
3:15 So you're you're learning something. You can't download it like a computer. You have to guess what the other person means and at first you will guess wrong and so you will have to test those guesses and and so on. So the the if if that process goes wrong, it is because the the the teacher or the professor communicator. Yeah. >> Yeah. The communicator >> has not pitched it to meet your problem situation.
3:55 >> So yes, go ahead. Why? What is it that most people misunderstand about being wrong? I think we all have this aversion to making mistakes, to not understanding, to putting errors into the way that we understand the world or how it is that we're interpreting something else. Is there a better framing for how people should think about wrongness? >> yes. so, as Papa said, I I going to have to stop me quoting him every minute or two.
4:30 we are all alike in our infinite ignorance or or longer. we may all know different things, piece different pieces of knowledge, but in our infinite ignorance, we are all alike. So this all comes from the idea that since there's an infinite distance to go and we all have different finite amounts of knowledge. we we are all at like I say in in my book we're all at the beginning of infinity. We're only ever at the beginning.
5:06 And so we we have something in common with everyone else who is also at the beginning. and and to hold oneself up as an authority is a philosophical mistake as well as a a a a what can you call it a sociological mistake or a cultural mistake. It's it's it's a power play rather than a participation in the growth of knowledge which which we should all be participating in.
5:39 >> >> How should someone hold strong convictions if we all kind of need to remember that we can be completely mistaken at all times and we're vast in our ignorance and partial in our knowledge? >> Yes. well, as you're suggesting here, it's it's a psychological matter. So, we should not be looking for certainty. We should be looking to correct errors. So when when sometimes when people say oh I'm certain about something it it means that they have investigated all the possible ways it could be different and they satisfied themselves that those are all wrong and they have their reasons and they but more often certainty is regarded as as a a virtue in in in past times faith obedience that sort of state of mind was regarded as virtuous and people judged not only each other but themselves according how to how much of that they had. Now in modern times especially with the growth of knowledge accelerating more and more in the last couple of hundred years everyone's had the experience of well every every adult let's say has had the experience of being proved wrong about something that they were sure was right or something happened that they were sure would never happen. that that's and and so one should infer from that experience. People don't but one should infer from that experience that the subjective sensation of being certain is no guide to the truth. It's it's no guide at all. And neither is and this this is a bit even harder to like internalize.
7:44 Neither is the extent of knowledge or ignorance because somebody can be very ignorant or even very malevolent and yet on a particular thing they might have the truth and you might not. >> So it's no good saying that's a bad person. I won't listen to them. because you might be missing the the one truth that would save you. So, again, like I say in the book, if if if your enemy says that he's going to come and kill you, it might be advisable to believe your enemy when you disbelieve your friend who says, "Oh, don't don't mind him. He he's he's just the bark is worse than his bite." Mhm.
8:34 >> So you see it has nothing it has nothing to do with being knowledgeable. It has nothing to do with being benevolent. We are all alike in our fallibility. So the only way to judge ideas is not by someone's authority or by one's own authority or by how sure one is but only by the criterion of whether you have a good explanation for why that truth is is has had its errors corrected better than all the other truths you've heard or can think of. I can imagine a situation where this this becomes or at least it feels to an individual very effortful to go through the entire working of the equation in order to arrive at the truth as opposed to using the shortcuts as opposed to saying well this person seems to be from an illustrious background and they have been right about other things before seemingly or other people seem to respect their opinion or they're saying it with a level of fervor that implies that they know what they're talking about. what is a practical way for people to not take half of the afternoon to decide which sandwich they want or which would be a more optimal yogurt to purchase?
9:51 How can people sort of apply this to life without it becoming clunky and and slowing them down? >> So, so we we have a theory about situations that we're in. you know, you talk about sandwiches. So, I I go, into town and buy a sandwich from from a sandwich shop. And how do I know it's not poisoned? How how do I know it's not off? how do I know that that I haven't been handed the wrong sandwich and and so on? Well, as you say, if I went back to first principles to work all that out, it would take all afternoon and I would be starving to death by the time I ate anything.
10:34 So the the rational thing to do as I said is to form a theory. I have a theory about how chains of sandwich shops work, how how they are regulated for example by the government or by the market or or the the shop may have a particular ethos that I think they really do have rather than are pretending and so on. In the case where I can't say that then I will have to use different criteria and in that particular case I myself would not buy a sandwich unless unless I had those that kind of history and that that kind of idea of where this is coming from where it's coming from intellectually as well as where it's coming from physically in mind. so you don't you don't have to go through the whole thing because in short, not only can I am I able to criticize ideas myself, I'm able to formulate and criticize ideas about other people. Mhm.
11:48 >> It's just that when I formulate an idea about about the knowledge of you know the doctor or or the the airline engineers who who prepared the airplane that I'm going to fly on. the the I don't go by their reputation. I go by that theory. And a small fact can destroy a large reputation.
12:19 >> Like if if I'm due to fly and then I I read in the newspaper in the morning that that airline has had a scandal where their engineers have have been shoddy in preparing the plane, I may well not fly. Even though I may also think that the chance of the plane going wrong with me on it are actually tiny. But, you know, maybe now they're only one in a thousand. And ideally, I'd like it to be one in a million.
12:49 >> Mhm. >> But I could be wrong. >> Always. >> Does that mean is certainty something that we should ever aspire to? >> Oh, no. We should aspire not to have any. >> Should we aspire to uncertainty then? >> yes. I mean if if you want a a life of scientific research then it's highly desirable that you enjoy the sensation of being baffled of of being in a state of conflict of thinking well now it looks like this this is true but it can't be true and that sensation is for example what what attracts me to to u to scientific research I I I don't think one should even aspire to believe anything. I think belief is a is a corrupt kind of category that has come down to us from from Plato and and later from from Christianity and Islam and so on. Most religions don't ha don't value belief. They they value ritual and conformity and ways of life. belief was something introduced by Christianity. And it's rather weird if you think about it as as Percy Shelley said in the in the in the essay for which he got expelled from Oxford University, he pointed out that you you can't believe or disbelieve something by an act of will. It's got to become via your reason. Therefore, calling disbelief a an immoral thing doesn't make sense.
14:39 >> Yeah. Do you know Oscar Wild's idea of the Oxford manner? Have you come across this? >> Don't think so. No. >> Beautiful. It's just this one one line. He refers to the Oxford manner as the ability to play gracefully with ideas rather than sort of falling into violent or rigid opinions. And I think in my world, which is significantly less cubrious than academia, but maybe just as cutthroat and as much backbiting, the internet is really quick to show its own smarts by pointing out the flaws of others. And one of the problems that I found is that the ability to put on a a hypothetical hat or in in my parliament a bro scientist hat. look, I'm just I'm trying to play gracefully with ideas.
15:32 Please give me enough degrees of freedom here to maybe be wrong. but because how would you say like production and publication of ideas are one and the same on the internet. So you're coming up with things in real time and then they're kind of broadcast out into the world which means there is no there is no scratch pad. There is no whiteboard that's not publicly available. The whiteboard and the lecture kind of become one and the same. and that means I that's been lost at least in a way that a lot of people consume ideas and and understand information and sort of see the debate go on. And I get the sense that kind of what's happened over the last decade or so is a slow increase in this seductivity of certainty and a deriggation of uncertainty or in congruence or you know like lack of coherence or something like that because it becomes a target immediately for people on the internet or or critics or naysayers or enemies or whatever to kind of point the finger.
16:37 Look, he doesn't know that much about this thing cuz he was pontificating and playing in trying to play gracefully with ideas. Therefore, that means that he must be wrong about da da da da da da as well, which is I guess in one way we could call this weaponized uncertainty that it is being used as a tool to kind of dismiss someone as a a wider a wider thinker as opposed to hey like this is cool like he's prepared to I mean he missed the mark with that but it's fun. He's he's able to try and play gracefully with ideas. I thought that kind of related here.
17:09 >> Yes. ideally Twitter or X is is the ideal medium for conjecture for just throwing ideas out and then having them criticized and come back to you and so on. But because of the phenomenon you're talking about, you can't really do that. And I I have long ago stopped doing that on Twitter. So I I think twice and three times and four times before putting something on Twitter on X.
17:44 and one thing that's possible to I it's possible to take a middle ground and say I either ask it as a question. Does anyone think so and so is true? Or you could say, I guess so and so might be true. or if so and so were true, then it might it might answer this other question. So >> look at the throat clearing land acknowledgement that we need to do before we actually put an idea out in a desperate attempt to dampen its impact.
18:15 >> Yes. Yes. Well, I I I think it's it's inevitable. I mean there there are plenty of other places to to publish conjectures. >> >> the dinner table maybe. >> Yes. in private or or in a private chat or or in a a more public thing where one labels it as conjecture. For example, I I have just I'm just finishing a book on the Fermy paradox or the the Fermy problem and I have I have some conjectures there which I think are well it's it's slightly strange. I I think they're poss they're possible solutions to the to the Fermy problem, but I am sure certain, you know, which I shouldn't be, that they are not true, >> but I I just would like to put them out there in the form, look how easy it is to make up ideas about this and for them to be wrong. That's the idea. So, so I've written it as a science fiction story set in another universe, not in our universe. So, I don't have to answer for the for the discrepancies between this universe and our universe. So, that I I just mentioned that because that's one of one of many ways one can get criticism of conjectures. But also always it is one should think carefully about when to expose an idea to to criticism. If one does it too early, it may cut off lines of lines of thought which although false would lead to something true if one seriously.
20:06 >> So cool. That is so cool. A quick aside, you've probably heard me talk about Element before, and that's because I've started every single morning the same way for the last 5 years now, which is a cold glass of water with Elements in it. Element is an electrolyte drink mixed with everything that you need and nothing that you don't. It's a sciencebacked electrolyte ratio of sodium, potassium, and magnesium. No sugar, no coloring, no artificial ingredients. It reduces muscle cramps and fatigue, supports brain function, and helps to regulate your appetite throughout the day. I genuinely notice the difference when I take it versus when I don't, which is why I don't shut up about it and also why it's used by everyone from Dr. Andrew Humeman to Olympic athletes and FBI sniper teams, the the good sniper teams, not the bad ones. Also, they have a no questions asked refund policy. So, if you don't like it for any reason, they'll just give you your money back. Plus, they offer free shipping in the US. Right now, you can get a free sample pack of Element's most popular flavors with your first purchase by going to the link in the description below heading to drinklnt.com/modern wisdom. That's drinklnt.com/modernism.
21:07 So you're saying that if you have this nent early stage idea and you put that out, somebody comes in with a certainty in criticism which cuts off at the knees the progress of this particular idea of yours. You rob yourself from the opportunity of being wrong in a new way or wrong in multiple new ways which would give you the idea. That is so fun. also I I' I've got to call you out for this. The fact that you have been able to deal try and play gracefully with ideas with regards to the Fermy problem by constructing an entire new fictional universe in an attempt to get yourself a few million lighty years of distance away from potential criticism is is kind of hilarious. What did you what have you come to believe about the It's also cool that you call it the Fermy problem, not the paradox, I suppose. What have you come what have you come to believe about the Fermy problem?
22:05 we don't know the answer. it it's it's you could also call it the firmy mystery or but but you know it's not so unusual. We we we don't know most things. So we don't know whether whether we are alone in the universe. We we might be or we might not be. the point I wanted to make is that that it's easy to come up with explanations for why why the why the aliens or their their robots are not here yet. It it's so this is this is not of the form like I said of of the form of problems I like namely it looks as though it must be so and so and yet it looks also looks as though it can't be so and so. Yeah.
22:55 >> So that that that's the kind of thing that I I enjoy thinking about because they there are two things which appear to be in collision and like quantum gravity and and no matter how you think about it, no matter how whatever angle you look at it, it's still it still seems like a collision. So that's the but but the Fermy problem is not really it's really a collision between one fantasy and another fantasy. It's it's we just don't know. get over it.
23:31 >> Okay. getting back down to terapirma, is it fair to say that you hold optimism as a philosophical stance? >> Yes. Yes. Although by optimism I don't mean having a cheerful outlook on life or thinking that everything is going to be all right as a matter of principle. I I mean that whenever something goes it it's more of a explanation for failure than a prophecy of success. It's it's like whenever something goes wrong it's because we had not yet created the knowledge to make it go right. It's always a matter of knowledge. M >> so what you asked earlier about when when you fail to persuade someone of something or when you fail to teach someone something, it's because you haven't yet thought of the way of meeting their problem and of whether you really should be meeting their problem or maybe you should both go and do something better.
24:34 M >> so you know why why why does is it really necessary for this other person to agree with you on this thing so so that that's a uniform application of optimism and and pessimism is the opposite. It's it's where you regard failure as a barrier as a barrier to ever getting out of the situation or solving the problem or get going from bad to good. Going from bad to good is is only is is always possible and when we fail it is always because we don't yet have the knowledge to succeed.
25:22 Should this broader worldview around optimism, should that extend to how we feel about our own lives individually? Because I have to assume that if you see failure as a a way marker on route towards success, that's quite a sort of personal determination. I have some sovereignty here. I I imagine it must be difficult because you you mentioned it's not just having a sort of cheerful rosy outlook on life, but I imagine it in some ways it must be quite difficult to maintain a non- rosy non- cheerful outlook on life if you have a worldview that is predicated on this kind of optimism because you're going to see your own personal struggles through the lens of well I I just need some more knowledge and I'm sure that I can overcome this thing or I can make the decision that I don't need to overcome this thing. I'm interested in how this sort of relates to the individual and how they do deal with adversity and and and challenges in their own life.
26:21 >> so optimism is no guarantee that you will solve the problem. You you you know you might have a terminal illness and and the the doctor says to you've got x time to live and you might think well you might think correctly that's because we don't yet have the medical knowledge. Okay, that that doesn't mean that there there exists a way of you to quickly bone up on on all the relevant medical knowledge, solve that problem, cure that disease, and then survive. Although that has happened remarkably often.
26:56 >> Somebody who's been diagnosed with something that's supposedly terminal has just speedrun the the solution for it and fix themselves. >> Yes, it has happened. So, it's not impossible. That's like those those wartime medics where they were the only medic available in the tent and somehow they got shot and you see these guys without anesthetic with a scalpel out operating on himself. It feels a little bit like that. >> Yes. Yes. and and the the lack of knowledge there might extend further than just the knowledge of how to perform an operation on yourself. I mean you know there's a war going on. That in itself should not have happened. With better knowledge, it would not have happened. But again, that that's not a formula for correcting it yourself in the tent.
27:46 >> So, on the other hand, you can't say what what you will solve. You you you might you might you might solve it, but the the in regard to what you do, you do not think this is insoluble. You do not think this is how far reason can reach and from now on reason doesn't have any access. That's always false.
28:18 >> Mhm. Yeah. I wonder why do you think it is that pessimism so often masquerades as sophistication? >> I thought you were going to ask a different question. Yeah. Why it why it masquerades sophistication because it so say you're writing a story about some characters who who the you the you're making the reader like the characters and and suddenly one of the characters is going to get killed and you know and and and you're thinking can they be saved? Can they be saved?
28:56 And then in the last chapter they're not saved. M >> now that is easy to write because knowledge in fiction is very hard to create just as in real life. if to to make a realistic story about how this situation which you've set up to look as though that favored character is going to die, how that can end up with with them see being saved >> is is is hard. It's it's similarly hard to solving it in real life. So some authors just pull the the the solution out of a hat. this a deosex masha as the ancient Greeks presumably didn't say. so if you do that the audience will be disappointed. they'll they'll say, "No, you know, we we've been had I've just I've just spent, you know, two hours watching this movie or or several days reading this long novel and and the author has led me along and then he's tricked me at the end.
30:11 He's he >> for example. Yeah, that's another that's another way of doing it. So, it it's all a dream. So, but similarly what is not really realized is that the opposite tactic of saying not only does he die but everybody dies like in Hamlet. that is equally a copout. Anyone can write that ending just like anyone can write the deosex machina ending. What you need to to do is to solve the problem so that you will have told the reader some knowledge some and you know if it's a good novel it's it's it should be knowledge about life in general which they can use to understand the world and their own life and their friends and and so on. It should enrich the person. But having it having it end unhappily is always a cheat.
31:12 and that's that's that's true whether it's a happier or a sad ending pulled out of a hat. What's a current problem that you think people are most unnecessarily pessimistic about right now? >> well, I guess it's the AI doom scenario. it might be the it might be the climate catastrophe scenario. I'm not sure exactly whether it's the same people who who who are worried about both or different.
31:46 >> I think the ven diagrams probably got a a good bit of crossover. Yeah. >> Yeah. they are both examples of of looking at a problem and thinking of it as a barrier. So you you have you you say so and so could happen. We could all die. You're not taking into account that that is true. That is always true. That has always been true every day that the human species has existed. >> It's always been true that we could be hit by a comet and all die. in fact, just recently, the probability of that has gone down drastically because we've finally turned our attention as a species to the problem of diverting comets and asteroids. But if they're big enough, we still can't do it. but but still the the probability of it has has gone down. people used to worry about things like the oxygen will run out of the air because we're consuming oxygen and you know where's it going to come from and and and people have worried about things that aren't even a rational fear like like the apocalypse or you know the world is going to end on such and such a day and we'll all be judged wanting and so on.
33:10 so, yeah, at at the moment I think it's the AI thing and and the, climate catastrophe thing. It's it's not that those fears couldn't come true. It's that when you see them in perspective, you see that it's an arbitrary choice to pick those things in in in a slightly different universe. We're we're we're still worrying about something else or we're we're worrying about whatever the next thing is which we can't predict yet.
33:41 >> You hold, I would imagine, a rather unpopular opinion in the modern world, which is that AGIS aren't going to pose much greater risk than than humans already are. What's your what's your perspective at the moment on this AGI thing? mentioned to you earlier on this Jacob Coxin guy who was at OpenAI I think for about three years and he was at Anthropic recently and he tweeted yesterday I resigned from Anthropic today I spent the last three years doing pre-training research at both open AI and Anthropic neither company is acting responsibly they are racing towards self-improving super intelligence and gambling with our lives some other safety researcher from anthropic said there's a more than 10% chance that advanced AI could kill all humans within the next decade models potent like have a lower risk at moment but future systems could become more capable etc etc. What how do you come to given your background quantum computing etc. What how do you come to think about this conversation?
34:38 So, I I I think it's it's it's not a justified fear as as I've just said for reasons I've just said, but you know, I'm old and I remember when people were saying this about nuclear reactors and they said it so loudly and so often that people stop making nuclear reactors, thereby causing the present climate problem. So they they they didn't know they picked from my point of view they picked at random one of the many bad things that could happen but we don't know whether they will whether they will or won't but there's no particular reason to think that they will even though they could. and they picked that one at random and they alarmed everybody and people took drastic action to avoid that alarm with catastrophic results. the the the worst effect on the environment that the that our species has ever had was the the turn away from nuclear power.
35:42 So, if we turn away from artificial intelligence, because of a similar fiction, will it be? No, I was I was going to say it might well be a bigger catastrophe. I think I was a bit tempted to say something dramatic. No, I I think it would be a big catastrophe, but not as big. >> Mhm. Mhm. >> Tell me if this sounds familiar. You train regularly, you eat reasonably well, you feel fine, but you're just kind of going off vibes. Most people have absolutely no idea what's going on inside their body. And that is why I partnered with Function. Function gives you access to more than 160 advanced lab tests spanning hormones, heart health, kidney function, and even detects early signals linked to more than 50 types of cancer. To put that in perspective, your typical annual physical might test 20 markers. Function runs over 160. It's huge. Best of all, you test twice a year and everything lives inside of a simple dashboard. So you track trends over time, make sure you're moving in the right direction. And this level of testing would usually cost thousands.
36:44 But with function, it is $365 per year. Just $1 a day to actually know what's happening inside of your body. And right now, you can get $25 off, bring it down to $340 bucks. Get the exact same blood panels that I use and save $25 by going to the link in the description below or heading to functionhealth.com/modernwisdom. That's functionhealth.com/modernwisdomd. I don't know. I I spent a good bit of time over the last few months in in SF and and talking to people on every side of the fence, including sort of with the fence up inside of them as well, straddle straddling both sides.
37:18 certainly at least a a relatively uncontroversial opinion seems to be LLMs are not the architecture that can get us to something that is very scary that that is going to be able to take over the world. Is that something that you would agree with? >> Absolutely. I think that follows directly from Papa's epistemology because the the LLMs do not have a module in them capable of creativity.
37:53 So they they they are I mean they they can do remarkable things and a few years ago I wouldn't have guessed that this kind of functionality is on the horizon for another 50 years and yet it came all at once and everything worked one after the other and the people who did it think that AGI is going to work as well for the same reason but the the present the present LLM based AIS, not only have they not shown any sign of AGI, but we know how they work, or at least some people know how they work. I don't, but but but we do know that that the people who designed them did not say, "Now we know what creativity really is. Now we can program it and all we need is some supercomputers and we'll be able." They they they didn't say that. They they said now now we can build a language model which will be able to speak English properly. And I would be like good luck with that.
39:02 >> And and they did. But it it's one thing to achieve functionality that makes sense epistemologically and to achieve it much faster than was thought. And it's another to achieve a functionality that violates our best theory of what knowledge is. And that's another thing. People who think that LLMs are going to deliver AGI don't say for example, well PA had only an approximation to the to the true theory of knowledge. He he didn't realize that that there's there's there's a gap in his theory and this gap we have filled. We know how to fill that gap. And so if you just use his old theory, you'll say that AGI is impossible this way. But if you if you know what we know, then then you'll see why it's possible. They're not claiming that. They're saying it'll just happen.
40:04 >> Yeah. if they have more compute if they have more computer power available. but it's it's a previous kind of slight blip of the same type was when chess engines first started defeating grandm the best grandmasters at chess. So, a lot of people were saying, well, some people were saying no, they'll never do it because humans have got some special thing in their brains and whatever and and other people were saying no, it's just a matter of giving it more computer power. But that's different because they had a theory of why it just requires more computer power. And when they achieved it, this is the thing that's hardly ever hardly ever mentioned. When a when a chess engine beats a grandmaster, they're doing it in a different way. The the computation that is going on in the chess engine is a radically different kind of computation from the computation that's going on in the grandmaster. the grandmaster is is doing only like 1 millionth of the amount of computing power of of computation that than the than the chess engine does and yet can reach a very high level. Not quite as high as the as the machine as the program but still they are doing a completely different thing. And although we know how to write the program of a chess engine, we do not know how to write the program of a grandmaster.
41:48 And this is this is why grandmasters can write a book, you know, my greatest games and how I won them or you know, something like that. And a chess engine can't. If you ask a chess engine how it won, it will say, "Well, if you do this move, then that will happen. And if that happens, this will happen. If that happens, this will happen." Down to, you know, however many steps it can do nowadays. and a grandmaster will not say that. A grandmaster can't follow it down to anywhere near as many steps as a as a as a chess engine can. But a grandmaster will say something like, "Well, I saw that if I give up this pawn, it's going to create a weakness on the G file."
42:43 And by weakness, he doesn't mean that he's followed down all the u all the possible continuations. Whereas something that has can follow down all the continu and by the way, some of those continuations may not lead to victory. he he might say, "I thought this might work, but then five moves later, the bastard found a way out of it." and that that that can also happen. That that also can't happen to a chess engine.
43:16 >> So there are different types of program. We do not know how to write the grandmaster type of chess program, let alone an AGI. Yeah, >> you know, when the grandmaster gets up, he's then starts performing computations of orders of magnitude greater complexity than playing chess. It's it's just that that he he he's not engaging competitively in in something that requires insight.
43:46 >> What is creativity in your opinion? How do you think about explaining that simply? the way I use the term is perhaps different from the way philosophers and others use it. creativity I I think is not a not that impressive a thing. Just creativity by itself. I I use that word to mean the ability to create new knowledge. So, evolution is creative is a creative process in that sense in that it it starts off with an animal that that can't fly and then then a few million years later it's it has created an animal that can fly and it it can fly because its genes encode knowledge of how to fly, including implicitly knowledge of aerodynamics and all sorts of things that we don't even have a a handle on yet. But so it has created knowledge.
44:45 The thing that humans have and that no existing other species has although there were species in the past that had this is explanatory creativity where we can like like with the chess master we not only we can say I prefer this move to that move. You can say why. So I I I want to pick up this burning branch from the from the wildfire like the say the first person who invented a a a campfire.
45:24 I was just writing about this in my in my forthcoming book actually. I I I I want to pick this up because I want to carry it with me. And if I carry it with me, maybe the predators who might otherwise attack me and I'm carrying food from the latest kill will run away from me instead of me running away from them. Now that idea, that's not that's not induction. that that's not any of the pre-popa ways of thinking of the growth of knowledge. He he's not doing something he's seen before. He's he's he's imagining something that he's never seen before, that no one has ever seen before, namely carrying a branch in for protection against against predators.
46:14 And then as as as he walks home with it, then he's saying he he'll say, "Oh, well, it's getting dark, but I can still see. Maybe if I get this all the way home, we'll we'll all be able to be protected from the from the wild animals and so on." And that that's a kind of thinking that is not it cannot be characterized as optimizing for a given outcome like checkmate or like proving a mathematical theorem.
46:48 >> Mhm. >> It it's it's more like discovering a new mathematical object which is interesting. But you can't you can't give a computer a criterion of interesting. So you you Humans can change the axioms to better axioms and that's that humans are not just meeting a fixed criterion and also humans can change their mind. he might decide well we might we might scare off the the the predators this way but we're getting burnt by the flames and it's not going to last us all the way home. So we better throw it away now and run home. That that that that's the sort of thing you can think if you have a genuine problem situation in mind rather than a criterion to meet.
47:43 >> What do you make given the importance of understanding education modesty or sort of nobility humility when it comes to learning? What do you make of the current education system? so I think that the our society's present attitude to education both for children and for in universities and and and for everybody in their own life is is based on a wrong theory. It's it's what Papa calls the bucket theory of the mind of the mind which which is that knowledge is a kind of fluid which some people have and some people don't have of a particular kind and the task is for the person who has it to pour it into the bucket that is the the the recipient is a kind of bucket for knowledge which is initially empty and you pour the knowledge in.
48:41 So that is very bad in a number of ways. In in fact educ education is is the last hold out of pre-enlightenment theories of knowledge. Everywhere else we at least give lip service to enlightenment theories like you you don't give someone authority to override the wishes of someone else. you you you don't necessarily respect the opinion of someone else just because of their status and and so on. This is we may not enact this perfectly as we were saying earlier in this conversation but but it's it's it's largely agreed that this is what we should be doing in education is the other way around. We we judge education by how well and how accurately you fill the bucket. And so one of the things that's wrong with that is that when something goes wrong, which it nearly always does, then you will immediately jump for the to the conclusion. So what has gone wrong?
49:46 Well, the bucket, it's either leaky or it it didn't want to receive the fluid. But there can't be anything wrong with the fluid because the fluid is knowledge. That is by definition what we want to transfer. >> By definition, transferring it is success. So we measure success according to say exam results or something and then because of the natural the natural arms race or or the self self sustaining situation that that happens in many human situations that aren't rational.
50:28 the incentive is to spend more and more time on meeting the criterion and less and less time on things that can't be measured which are the important things. So at least with chess you can measure how good a grandmaster is. Although you cannot easily measure how good a grandmaster is at explaining or at teaching >> or at giving a running commentary on on chess games. There is no criterion for that. There's no mechanical way you can say, well, I I've got 93% on the explaining my explaining my moves test, so I must be good at explaining my moves. There is no such thing. And everything that is important in education is of that type and not of the testable type. I I omit things where where being able to execute this execute the criterion perfectly is the task like being an airline pilot. But even an airline pilot, you know, an airline pilot who doesn't know the what the different controls do is not going to be a good airline pilot. But even with an airline pilot, understanding is extremely important. It may not be as important as being able to operate the controls, but it is extremely important.
51:58 >> but things that we learn in school and in most university courses are are not like that. The the course and the exam are designed as proxies for the thing that you actually want and they are very poor proxies. The only reason they are proxies at all is that people who really want to do the thing are willing to waste their time learning to pass the criterion. Before we continue, how many times have you found yourself hugging the toilet, throwing up not because you drank too much alcohol, but because the non-alcoholic beers that you drank tasted like garbage. And that is why I'm such a huge fan of Athletic Brewing Co. Their non-alcoholic brews taste just as good as the real thing.
52:38 And the best part, there's no hangover. No headaches. No more ruining your daughter's dance recital. I didn't want to stop enjoying tasty drinks. I just wanted to stop paying for it the next day. And you can too. Find Athletic Brewing Co.'s bestselling lineup at grocery or liquor stores near you. Or best option, get a full variety pack of four flavors shipped direct to your door right now. Get 15% off your first online order by going to the link in the description below or heading to athleticbwing.com/modernwisdom using the code modernwisdom at checkout.
53:05 That's athleticbwing.com/modern wisdom and modern wisdom at checkout. Nearbeer. Terms and conditions apply. Athletic brewing company fit for all times. What is a better approach then for somebody who wants to learn a lot from people who know a lot? Should people exit formal education as quickly as possible? We presumably can't upend the entire system right now immediately. What's your advice? I I I I upending is outside my wheelhouse like you know I I don't I don't know how to formulate good political policies.
53:41 >> Mhm. >> That will gain wide acceptance but technically we can we we do now with the internet we do have the means of completely upending the system and not having any compulsory education certainly for children. But I think there are more and more ways of adapting university education to to technologies like the internet and also collaborative technologies where where you where you have for example access to somebody. access to somebody is can be very valuable where compulsory subordination to that very same person would would be very bad for you.
54:30 >> So you today you know you you can write an email anyone can write an email to any famous person and have a reasonable chance of getting an answer even if it's only read my book you do. >> Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. >> But but but even that even that is is a lot better than than what things used to be like say even 30 years ago. >> Mhm. >> But even 30 years ago it would have been better in my opinion not to have compulsory subjects and not to have compulsory education of any kind.
55:06 >> What do you think about discipline and forcing yourself to do things? I've seen that you appear to be very anti- this despite it being kind of the one of the most popular worldviews at the moment to put your feelings to one side and push through and sort of ignore how you feel. What's your perspective on discipline and >> like many things in in epistemology and in psychology the same words the same terms can be used to describe absolutely opposite things. So for example, take a mountaineer who enjoys climbing Mount Everest or or difficult mountains who who looks looks for difficult climb where other people have failed perhaps other people have been killed and he goes on the climb and on the climb he underos severe privation and what would be suffering to almost anyone else but but to to him it's just privation. It's, you know, it's it's getting cold. every fiber of his being wants to go back down and and go get back in the warm, but he wants to get to the top. And all the pain and suffering and discomfort. It's just it's it's not just it's not that he overrides it, though in a sense he does, but what's really happening is that that's what he's there for. That's why he chose this climb.
56:40 If if it were easy, he wouldn't have chosen it. now, so what is for one person the very you know this is the reason he's alive. This is the reason he gets up in the morning. It is it is in anticipation of doing this thing for for almost anyone else. It would be torture. What's more, almost anyone else couldn't do it well enough. They they would eventually fall off. It's only because he loves it that he has put in the the amount of practice and work and thinking and and analysis and so on that allows him to reach the top of this difficult climb.
57:23 This is in the case of of mountaineering we're talking about actual pain and so on but most things don't don't have actual pain >> physical pain but they do have psychological pain boredom despair fear and all that kind of thing which and and so in in that sense I think the Mountaineer is a good analogy to all learning. All learning should be like that. It should be something that you would you would pay the price to have it just like the mountaineer does or like I was talking the other day to Formula 1 driver and I was saying God you know the in Formula 1 racing you have to have reactions that are approximately 1/ half the length of a human reaction time.
58:29 So that means that you you must start doing the the thing before you have the information in front of you because you have understood the course and the vehicle and so on well enough. And you must do that again and again and again during the race and every so often you will spin off and you will risk your life and so on. And so most people again would hate to do that. you know, most people would would pay a lot to have to not have to do that, but also if they were forced to do it, they wouldn't do it well because they do not love it.
59:08 So, I think having discipline and forcing yourself could be a form of words that describes this mountaineer >> and in that case it is wonderful. it is in a sense the best thing in the world. Whereas somebody forcing themselves to get a GCSE maths thing and spending the the whole summer preparing for the for the GCSE maths and and just scraping through and then starting the very next day forgetting everything they knew. That is the epitome of something bad. That's something that shouldn't happen. It's it's in a in a rational society that would never happen. That would be if if that happened even once it would be headline in the newspaper and and heads would roll. So from an individual's perspective, obviously we are still contending with and navigating the world and it is in some ways scarce or misaligned to what it is that we want to do. So sometimes you have to do that.
60:23 You have to use your I will get it done muscle. You don't want to take the you don't want to take the trash out. The trash sucks and and it smells and you don't want to do it, but you have to do it. So you're going to do it. Your perspective here is that if we were to construct a rational society, it would be people doing things that are in alignment with what they want to do. And in the interim between where we are now and hopefully a future world where that's the case, you're going to have to apply some of this. But the goal is to use less and less of it over time, >> less and less. That's less and less over time, but also less and less in your life. So, so first of all, the answer is to get it get it over with. So, you should be leading your your good life, not not not being overwhelmed by the bad things. And then once you've once you're getting it over with, you you can improve the situation. There are no situations or almost no situations in everyday life that cannot be improved a little. So you can apply knowledge to getting it over with a little, you know, I don't know, buy buy a better rubbish bin which is not so disgusting to empty.
61:40 >> Mhm. or live in a place where the rubbish bin emptying is easier or is a shorter way or >> by a different type of bag that you enjoy seeing briefly as you take it toward the Yeah. >> Exactly. Exactly. so and then there's there's also the opportunity to just learn to enjoy it. So the even taking the rubbish out has aspects that one can enjoy. You for example if one has been working on the computer all day and and one's one's limbs are are have forgotten how to move.
62:26 >> Mhm. >> Then at least going out with with the rubbish takes you into the fresh air. >> Mh. and and you can see the neighborhood and you can say hello to the person across the road who is also taking out their rubbish and so on. So there there's nothing that that can't be improved at least a bit and and it's it's bad to be in the state of mind that I should have discipline and therefore reducing it is reducing the good thing.
62:57 It's not reducing the thing you don't like is always good. >> You mentioned the the good life. What have you come to believe about how people should prioritize their focus in order to achieve something that resembles a good life. >> Like with many things, diversity is the key. So I don't think there's a formula which applies to to everybody. In fact, I don't think there's a formula that applies to any two people. Any two people are very different. In fact, more different than we are really capable of understanding. h humans are individual humans are as different from each other as humans in general are from other species.
63:46 It's a person is like a different species. So what what some people like to live a life of intellectual problem solving. There there is a a wonderful passage in Papa's autobiography where he says that the the thing to do in life is to find a problem, fall in love with it, live with it for the rest of your life.
64:19 Get get married to it, live with it for the rest of your life until death do you part. And if you happen to solve it, then the tone in which he says that is if you're unlucky enough to happen to solve it, then there will be delightful problem children. M >> so and and it's quite interesting that he uses the phrase problem children deliberately to highlight the fact that problem in his philosophy has these two opposite meanings. So we can say you know problem children is is a term a sort of euphemism that was invented for children that you would not want to live with whereas he is using it for something that you really ought to live with and and a lot of people who are the survivors of doing unusual things and then advocate that people should do these unusual things.
65:22 They often gloss over the difference between you know good discipline and bad discipline good problem and bad problem and they will say things that are exactly right for them because they were following the the good path if I can put it that way but it's often taken to mean that that you have to knuckle down and do your chores and then your homework and then go to bed and that's which is the opposite of what you should be doing even though it can be described in the same words.
65:59 >> Yeah. I there's this line from John Steinbeck which is pretty fun. He says, "I wonder why progress looks so much like destruction and when doing a little bit of thinking about my golden retriever translation of your worldview on mass, civilizationally across time, individually, you know, existentially." it kind of I think that's that's probably that's not a bad summation. I wonder why progress looks so much like destruction or you could say feels so much like destruction or is accused of being so much of destruction.
66:34 >> Yes, the last one is perhaps the best because what it feels it could feel either way. That's the trouble. You can't really tell from the outside necessarily because people can force themselves as well as being forced by other people >> and they can be pursuing a very hard path which they want to pursue which is joyful to them without that being noticeable either. The the only time that that's noticeable, the only times that that's noticeable is when the thing they're pursuing happens to have a good reputation.
67:06 like like if somebody spends 10 hours a day practicing chess or or practicing some martial art or whatever it is, people will see what they're doing that they they are they are adopting the discipline and making themselves power through to to being good at this thing which which society thinks is a good thing. But a very similar thing like a video game which is almost the same thing psychologically but which is socially frowned on. People will say that's not a good thing to be devoting yourself to. They will be blind to the effort and creativity that's going into it and they will instead try to apply discipline in the opposite direction.
67:59 >> Mhm. Mhm. I've learned from over a thousand podcast episodes, the easier that you make your health routine, the more consistent you'll be. It's like golf, right? You want to keep it simple and not mix a bunch of pills. You want the eye of the tiger, not the DUI of the tiger. That's why I'm such a huge fan of AG1. One scoop contains 75 vitamins, minerals, probiotics, and whole food source ingredients in a single daily drink. And that's why been taking it every single morning for nearly 5 years now. And they've taken it a step further with AG1 NextGen, backed by four clinical trials. In those trials, it was shown to fill common nutrient gaps, improve key nutrient levels in just 3 months and increase healthy gut bacteria by 10 times even in people who already eat well. Plus, if you're still unsure, they've got a 90-day money back guarantee. So, you can buy it and try it every single day for 3 months. If you don't like it, they will give you all of your money back. Right now, you can get 20% off a welcome kit and that 90-day money back guarantee by going to the link in the description below or heading to drinkag1.com/modernwisdomd.
68:51 That's drinkagg.com/modernwisdism. You mentioned that you were working on a book that's a fiction book. Have you got anything else that's in the pipeline as well or is that it? >> Yes. at least two other books. One is a textbook on quantum mechanics, quantum theory rather, which I'm writing with Sam Kypers and Kiara Maltto, my colleagues. And because we we think that existing textbooks and existing ways of teaching quantum quantum theory are just misconceived in many ways and we we want to get it right. So that's one thing.
69:31 Another thing is I'm I'm writing the third book in my sort of sequel to my first two books u fabric of reality and the beginning of infinity. >> I'm writing another one very difficult. It's I I I I I don't I think it's an example of mountaineering rather than being false. But >> yeah but it's tentatively called irrationality though I don't quite like the title because it gives the wrong impression at least at first. the the subtitle at the moment is how thinking works and what the obstacles to it are.
70:20 So that's I think a better title but it's a bit clunky >> and whilst doing textbook plus difficult third album two previously quite complex initial two books you also got the fiction book put together as well. Yes, I've also I've also got my day job. So, apart from those three, yes. >> Oh, well, at least you're keeping yourself busy. David Deutsch, ladies and gentlemen. David, you're awesome. I appreciate you. It's very nice to hear a fellow accent as well. what should people be looking out for over the next couple of months? When is this something going to drop before the end of the year? One of the books, one of the fiction book. Do we know when that's going to come out?
70:59 >> I think that's unlikely in the next couple of months, but in the next year, fingers crossed. Yes. One of one of them may drop. >> Beautiful. David, I appreciate you very much. Thank you for today. >> Thank you for having me. Very pleasant. >> A quick note, lots of people tell us that YouTube unsubscribes them from the channel even though they already pressed it. So, just check down there and see if the subscribe button is pressed. You get access to episodes before anybody else.
71:25 If you do, supports me and the show helps me to bring you bigger and better guests and it makes me very happy. So, just go and give it a tap for me. I thank you.
Summary
- Knowledge is created through a process of evolution and personal engagement, not merely transferred from teacher to student.
- Misunderstandings arise from the assumption that knowledge can be downloaded like software; true understanding requires active participation.
- Certainty is often mistaken for truth; one should prioritize correcting errors over seeking absolute certainty.
- Optimism, according to Deutsch, is about recognizing that failures are opportunities for growth and knowledge acquisition.
- The education system is flawed, operating on a "bucket theory" that views students as empty vessels rather than active participants in their learning.
- Creativity is defined as the ability to create new knowledge, which is distinct from mere problem-solving.
- Pessimism often masquerades as sophistication, especially in narratives that focus on failure rather than potential solutions.
- The current fears surrounding AI and climate change are examples of arbitrary pessimism that overlook humanity's capacity for problem-solving and innovation.
Questions Answered
How does an individual's perspective on optimism and problem-solving impact their worldview?
The speaker expresses interest in how personal worldviews shape one's understanding of optimism and problem-solving, especially in the context of societal challenges like AI fears. They highlight the tension between individual perspectives and broader societal issues.
What does it mean to believe or disbelieve something according to the philosopher Khal Pa?
Khal Pa argues that belief and disbelief cannot be willed into existence; they must arise from reason. Thus, labeling disbelief as immoral is misguided.
Why is creating realistic narratives in fiction challenging?
Crafting a believable story where characters face dire situations requires skill. Authors must avoid easy resolutions and instead provide meaningful insights that enrich the reader's understanding of life.
How does the speaker define creativity?
Creativity is defined as the ability to generate new knowledge. Unlike other species, humans possess explanatory creativity, allowing them to articulate reasons behind their choices.
What analogy does the speaker use to describe the learning process?
The speaker compares learning to mountaineering, emphasizing that true learning involves overcoming psychological challenges and should be pursued with passion, rather than through forced discipline.