transcribe

Will The SEC Actually Leave The NCAA?

The Audible · 45m · transcribed Jul 2026
More from The Audible
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Michigan's Athletic Department Scandal

What is the current status of the Michigan athletic department scandal?

Michigan's athletic department is facing scrutiny due to a recent investigation, with the release of a statement that lacks detailed information. The timing of the release has been criticized as cowardly and insulting, especially given the ongoing attention on the department's past issues.

  • Michigan's handling of the scandal is seen as evasive.
  • The public deserves more transparency regarding the investigation.
  • The athletic department has faced multiple investigations in recent years.
# 9:08

Rivalries and Scandals in College Football

How do rivalries affect perceptions of scandals in college football?

Rivalries, particularly between teams like Michigan and Ohio State, influence fan perceptions of scandals. While Michigan faces scrutiny, Ohio State also has a history of issues, suggesting that no program is entirely free from controversy.

  • Rivalries can amplify the significance of scandals.
  • No college football program is without its baggage.
  • Fan loyalty often clouds judgment regarding program integrity.
# 18:16

SEC's Strength of Schedule Debate

What are the current discussions around the SEC's strength of schedule?

The SEC is emphasizing the importance of strength of schedule in the College Football Playoff discussions. Despite criticisms, data shows that the SEC consistently has the toughest schedules, which impacts their playoff positioning.

  • The SEC argues for recognition of their challenging schedules.
  • Strength of schedule is a key factor in playoff discussions.
  • There is ongoing debate about the relative strength of the SEC versus the Big Ten.
# 27:24

Changing Dynamics in College Football Recruitment

How is the recruitment landscape changing in college football?

The recruitment landscape is evolving as players are increasingly attracted to programs based on their potential to reach the NFL rather than traditional powerhouses. Indiana's recent success in sending players to the NFL exemplifies this shift.

  • Players prioritize NFL development over traditional school loyalty.
  • Programs like Indiana are proving they can compete in recruitment.
  • Financial incentives are becoming less of a differentiator in recruitment.
# 36:32

Coaching Longevity and Performance Expectations

What happens when a successful coach's performance declines?

As a coach's performance declines, there is a tension between appreciation for past successes and frustration with current results. Programs may tolerate a few years of mediocrity, but there is a limit to how long they will wait for improvement before considering a change.

  • Successful coaches face pressure as performance declines.
  • Fan patience can wear thin with repeated underperformance.
  • Historical comparisons highlight the challenges of transitioning from a successful era.

Transcript

0:06 Welcome back to the latest edition of The Audible presented by Trader Joe's. I'm Bruce Helman joined by my colleagues from the Athletic Stuart Mandel and Ralph Russo. All three of us are here today. we're now pretty much neck deep into into college football media days. The SEC is going on right now in Tampa, Florida as we speak. We will get into that. We will get into kind of maybe some closure with the latest Michigan scandal as it relates to AD Ward Manuel. we're going to talk about has Indiana coming off a national title elevated itself. Could they be on the cusp of becoming wide receiver U?

0:46 all that and some postcards from ACC media days which Ralph was at. He's got some good stuff from there. Guys, let's start though. Monday morning, we woke up to Ward Manuel is not out the door, but he will be soon. Michigan released a statement. They released some summary of their big whatever $12 billion investigation. Not a ton of details, guys. Where do we stand with this right now? We surprised?

1:18 >> Well, I mean, of course, they released it right. They released it right in the middle of Greg Sanki's in state of the SEC speech, right? They released it like 4 days after their board meeting, right? So, no reporters were around. They just released a statement from the president and here's some details. We can't give you all the details, by the way. So, I don't know. I mean, it feels a little cowardly by Michigan the way they're doing this, but here we are.

1:52 >> It's I mean, cowardly is a good way to put it, but I would also just say really insulting. you know given how much attention has been around that that athletic department over the last let's say four to 5 years and how many NCA investigations and you know even worse than that criminal investigations I feel like your the public deserves answers. I wonder if any media outlets will sue them to try to disclose that. They'll probably just say oh attorney client privilege. and you know, the report, the I'll air quotes report that came out Monday wasn't even really, it was like a a sum a very vague summary of the findings. But no, look, at the end of the day, the upshot is Ward Manual is stepping down at the end of the year. He's not completely going away. seems like they kind of split it down the middle between you know they the president said nobody had any direct knowledge at the time like hard proof basically that there was this Chiron Moore relationship going on but >> maybe some people should have known or should have acted quicker right >> so we can't totally throw him under the bus for this but we know we probably should so we'll just you know quietly push him out the door >> yeah the biggest issue there and We said this on the podcast, I think both times last week was that there was basically no oversight when it came to the football program at the highest levels.

3:22 Now, there were people who went to HR. We know that from our reporting at the athletic with concerns about the relationship dating back to 2 years ago. All this stuff kind of leads us back to where we thought we were going to end up, guys. So, here we are. I don't know if this is closure, but it's probably the best you're going to get for Michigan at this point. So, here's the big question. Was it all worth it, Michigan fans? Like, you've had five years of scandal, championship, scandal, championship. Beat Ohio State four times.

3:55 But Ohio State fans still think you cheated it cheated. But you can tell them, you know, blow off. We don't care about what our cheating, I guess. Yeah. Like like Bruce, like I I don't my sense of this I've had arguments with Ari Wasserman, our pal, since way back when the cheating scandal started that like listen, if I'm a Michigan fan, I got slapped on the wrist a couple of times. I got a little NCAA stuff, but like generally speaking, hey, flags fly forever.

4:30 We're the champions. Like like none of this stuff really matters cuz we are the champions. So, was it all worth it? I I don't know. I I I think that the if you ask Michigan fans that the answers may vary and and Ari has has told me, well, you know, Michigan does things a certain way. And now they can't say that they do. The whole Michigan aura, Michigan men, we do things the right way. That's out the window. To which I would say, I don't know. Do Michigan fans really care about that? you know, so we were had our obviously our our group text between us earlier this morning and I thought it was interesting, you know, you framed it as such. In my head, I feel like we all talked to fans of varying schools and whether it's Michigan or whatever and it's like they almost look like the scandal as red as redacted wins, right? Like where or vacated wins. It's like no, we we we celebrated when it happened. Whatever somebody says years after that, we still got the joy of whatever that is. It's not as bad as the media made it out to be, it's not whatever whatever happened at our rival is worse. But I, you know, what you said, Ralph, I sent it on to I have a a buddy of mine who is a former walk-on huge Michigan fan. We talk all the time about stuff, and I asked him this, and this is his response to Ralph's question. And if you're a Michigan fan, all this stuff is an annoyance, but would would they trade it for the last 5 years? Wouldn't trade it for the last 5 years or anything. He wrote back, "As a fan, yes. As an alum and former player, I feel meh. There are some unsatisfying parts of all the wins.

6:10 The scandals and failures to keep coaches makes it feel like a blip instead of sustain sustained success." And then he added, "Right now, we feel more like the alma mater of Dave Portoy than the alma moater of Tom Hayden." And a very Michigan answer. A >> very Michigan answer. >> There's always some cognitive dissonance that comes with being a college sports fan. I mean, if you dwell too much on the the underbelly of this sport, it's harder to just sit back and enjoy the game. So, and also it's hard to the Michigan fans, you know, there's a lot of them, first of all, millions of them, I think, and they don't all feel the same way. Certainly, if you were to get caught up in the comments and the message boards and whatnot during the Connor Stallions thing, it was total what aboutism. It was total any sort of conspiracy theory you could come up with. Defend, defend, defend. I don't know that that represented everybody. I don't know that it represents everybody today, but I think the text you got pretty much sums it up, right? Like you're not going to trade those championships. That was a, you know, unbelievable run for Michigan athletics, for Michigan football in particular. But that doesn't mean you don't feel a little queasy about how it all went down. And I hate to say, Ralph, I do agree to some extent with Ari. I mean, was Ari saying they should trade the championships for having avoided all that? because he's right about the Michigan man aura is all gone. It's it's gone. Nobody that you know anybody there that used to hold their head like, "Well, at least we don't cheat like the SEC." Like, forget about it. You're you're one of them now. but that doesn't mean they should have they should feel bad about winning those championships.

7:55 >> Well, I I guess yeah, Ari's point was like it takes away from the winning of the championships. And I always felt like I'm very cynical on these lines. like like I don't care one way or the other about Michigan, but I'm very cynical and and think that fans like, "Hey man, as long as we win, y'all can do whatever you want, right?" Like like within maybe reason, but even within reason, it's like you got to be pretty bad for me to like leave you behind. And right, flags fly forever. We got our championships. you can you can vacate our winch, but you can't take away our championship hats that and and t-shirts.

8:32 So, like I don't know, but but like yes, Ari's point was more of like if you're a Michigan fan, deep down this is probably unsatisfying. And I was like, come on. Like they can like they can they can rub it into Ohio State's face. Ohio State won the damn national championship and they're still like but you didn't beat each other. >> That's ex That's exactly right. because they had that stretch for about a thousand days where they stuck it up Ohio State's butt. And they could they could also point the finger back at at the SEC, right? And in their hearts of hearts, if you ask any Michigan fan, I think they feel like the SEC cheats anyway. So, we we bettered them. And I I feel like there's probably a part of the fandom that clings to that, especially when you have hated rivals like they do, whether it's Michigan State or certainly Ohio State. And I feel like that like m Michigan comeuppance on Ohio State is probably, you know, no matter what they find from Jenner Block and $12 million.

9:32 That's not that's not diminishing that. It's not like Ohio State's, you know, hands are totally clean either and we all lived through the Zach Smith situation. Urban Meyer got suspended for that. Could have easily gotten fired. This is 20 years ago now. But I covered a basketball scandal where Jim O'Brien, their coach time, just literally handed a recruit $6,000. I don't know if it was in a bag of cash or not. So like there was the Maurice Clarett stuff. Everybody has baggage, right? Let's be honest. You You want to think your school is squeaky clean. Nobody's school is squeaky clean.

10:06 In fact, if they are squeaky clean, they're probably not winning, you know? in fact, we're going to get into a program that's like that a little bit later in the ACC. though. at least >> you >> at least they're moving like what this investigation is. It's the end of the era. It's the end of the Harbaugh Chiron Moore feeling dirty about everything era. They can move on. >> All right, perfect segue to the SEC by the way. or maybe Greg Sanki wouldn't think that's a perfect segue to the SEC, but we woke up to Greg Sanki's It is SEC media days. We are not at SEC media days. We have fine colleagues holding the fort down. Matt Baker and Seth Emerson. It's in Tampa for some reason. So that alone is like what? What? Why are you guys in Tampa?

10:52 There are no >> I can't believe they don't do it in Hoover anymore. >> And apparently they're not going to. So I mean that's another thing. That's a whole another thing. So we woke up to Greg Sanki this morning talking about he was asked so this whole SEC breakaway thing. We've been hearing about how they're going to make their own rules and they're going to say if you if we can't get governance out of the NCAA and we can't get a bill passed in Congress to sort of give us some national rules, we're just going to say goodbye and go on our own and we're going to make our own rules and we're going to play amongst ourselves. Now, there's a way you can make your own rules without necessarily like breaking away from the NCAA. I know the Big 10 has I've talked to some sources within the Big 10 and some other places who think that yeah, we can make our own rules. That doesn't mean we have to like not play those guys anymore. However, what Greg Zeni said is no, this isn't just like Saber Rattling. We are very frustrated with the way things are going and if it comes to it, we might just say we're going to start making our own rules and maybe we'll even break away.

11:54 And I I mean, I guess we have to take the threat seriously, but I I don't know, man. like it it I it still also still feels like a threat. It still feels like more of a threat than reality even if we should take it seriously. >> So Ralph, what what realistic chance are we talking about? Like is this a Hail Mary? Is this 10% likelihood of this happening and it feels like it's a little bit of bluster and pounding our fist at the table. I mean, I get where Sanki or the Big 10 would be coming from. I mean, I get it. They're the ones who should have the most power in college football because they're the ones who are the most committed to it and they're the ones who honestly play it the best. But if this goes in the direction they don't want it to go, then what? Then what do you think actually happens? So, I think that first of all, we have this bill that may go to the floor next week or it may not because they're still negotiating some terminology with the some wording with the SEC and Big 10. if the bill gets passed and it's to their liking, I think a lot of this goes away. If the bill gets passed, but it gets passed without the things they want in it, which is a possibility, I think we could start hearing a little more about this like, hey, we're going to make our own rules. But again, I don't think the we're going to make our own rules and we're going to break away from the NCAA, that's a big jump. And I just want to make sure that we understand you can make your own rules and still play like you can have transfer like that's been done in the history of college sports d like like these conferences have all had some of their own rules. So my guess is if if the first step of this would be we're going to make our own rules but we're not going to completely break away. We're going to set certain standards within our conference that we will hold our conference members to. But yeah, we'll still play in the NCAA tournament in the college football playoff and all that other stuff. We'll still take part as an NCAA member. I think that's the first step toward this.

13:59 I guess my question is if they do decide to make their own rules, what rules are they looking to make? Because if you say, "Okay, the CSC doesn't work, you know, just within the SEC, like we're going to have a hard cap and we're going to limit transfers and all this." Well, and the Big 10 doesn't. How quickly do they realize they're putting themselves at a disadvantage? There used to be a rule in the SEC when back when grad when the only like flexibility in transfers was that grad transfers could play right away. The SEC had their own rule that you couldn't do that within the conference. If you try, if somebody wanted to transfer within the conference, they still had to sit out a year. And of course, they eventually got rid of that because the other conferences could do that. They were putting their own teams at a disadvantage. So, it's look I from what I understand from people in the conference is that there are presidents in particular, I don't know about ads and coaches, who genuinely want this.

15:03 They do want to be able to make they're they're they were counting on CSC and the House settlement. I mean, sorry, the >> the scorement act, which hasn't happened. it probably won't happen and and it doesn't and they're getting frustrated and so they want to >> they basically want the the I guess the the spirit of the CSC and if if it's not doable, but like your own conference teams are the ones. How about, you know, do you want you know, if you want rule, like there are rules. You're just refusing to follow them. So, I think it's just one of those things that sounds good in theory until you actually have to do it and then you get like I could see them going to Destin and saying to the coaches, "All right, this is how it's going to work." And the coaches going, "Wait, you're saying all of my competitors in the other conferences can do this, but I can't."

15:58 Sorry, guys. >> That is the biggest problem, right? If the SEC says, "Well, we're going to have a hard cap of 45 million." And the Big 10 says, "Oh, we like 55 million." What? okay. That's that doesn't sound great, right? So, so yes, you Stu, you nailed it. You hit on the perfect and I still think there's some possibility there, but I but I think you kind of nailed it. When you start doing your own thing, how do you avoid doing your own thing, but it puts you at a competitive disadvantage? And then if you start doing the exact same thing as the other conference, well, now you're colluding.

16:35 Anyway, >> all right. So, with Sanki's comments, day one kicked off, but even really before any of it, Eli Drinkowitz, head coach at Missouri, he's done a good job there, and he's definitely not shy of the microphone. he had a conversation, I believe, with our friend Brett McMury because Brett had tweeted this out early in the morning. Missou's Eli Drinkit said, "Part of the reason the Big 10 has won the last three national titles." Quote, "When you don't play a non-conference A4 game." Wow.

17:06 Okay. So, with this, it feels like the start of we're going to hear 4 days of a lot of grousing about the SEC shifting to its conference schedules. Do we think these are like, is this just more whining or is there something to this? I felt like Eli starting out the week setting this tone, you know, again with this start, this tweet got a bunch of traction. and then I felt like I saw him I watched some of the coverage where he was at the desk with the SEC Network guys. Then he was at the podium. I think we're going to hear a lot more about the scheduling as it relates to strength of schedule as it relates to the CFP.

17:47 where do we think this is all headed, guys? >> This is just a continuation of Destin. I mean, we were hearing about this in Destin. They are going to hammer the hell out of we play nine game conference schedules now. It's the They were already we're the hardest league in the country. Now you play a nine-game conference schedule. I think the coaches may have feel like they kind of were sold a little bit of a bill of goods with nineame conference schedule, but a 12 team playoff that doesn't work very well. The the Big 10's kind of going out there and not demanding their teams play A4s. So, Sanki followed this up, not directly followed this up with this idea that the CFP still hasn't really answered our questions about like properly valuing strength of schedule and properly valuing our strength of schedule. St., so I know this feel we're ramping this up again, but for me who was in Destin, this is just more of the same. Now, we're just elevating the the rhetoric.

18:48 >> They were already doing this a year ago, right? in in Destin. I remember there was presentations, there were slides about how difficult their schedules are, and that was before they went to nine conference games. But here's the thing, like they have any, you know, number of any they have several sets of data that say that they absolutely are right. And you may disagree with that or or poo poo it, but like the the FBI preseason strength of schedule top teams are almost all SEC. It's it's 15 14 of the top 15 strength of schedules are in the SEC, the exception being Ohio State.

19:27 people are going to roll their eyes because the SEC has not been as strong the last few years. but we've talked about this many times out here. We think the top of the Big 10 is stronger than the top of the SEC, but the middle to the bottom of the SEC is still stronger. And so if you're playing nine games and you're playing more of those types of teams, then yes, your schedule's going to be stronger. I do think it's interesting the the sentiment we're hearing and and it was even before media days that hey, when when we agreed to nine conference games, we were told the thing was going to 16. you know, the SEC the Big 10 wanted 16, the SEC wanted 16, and then as soon as we did it, the Big 10 moved the goalpost to 24. And so now we're stuck playing these nine conference games and it looks like we might be stuck at 12 for a while. So selfishly guys, as a as a anti-204 playoff guy, I hope the SEC gets all the bins this year. I hope I hope they get everything they want and more because if they don't, if their nine and three teams get excluded for teams they think played a much weaker schedule. You know what they're going to say? Well, we need a bigger playoff. This is why I've been telling you guys for, you know, for months that like telling you the folks in the SEC like they're they're feeling a little duped here. They need more playoff spots. There's definitely coaches and and ads in the SEC who think a bigger playoff is is better. yes.

20:54 And I that it is interesting, Stu, because I do think like this idea of what the playoff looks like when a bunch of SEC teams that would have finished 10-2 now finish 9 and three is fascinating to me. I think it will hang over the whole season. Bruce, I wanted to give you a pop though on something that you had mentioned when we did our overunders. and then we can get on out of here. You had said I think the the brunt of this will be taken by the bad teams, the teams at the end like like actually the t teams at the top will be okay, but the teams at the bottoms will just be crushed. The Arkansas's and the Mississippi State and I've talked to a couple of other people.

21:37 Our our buddy my buddy Bud Elliott who hosts the Cover Three podcast who kind of looks at things through a little bit of an analytical lens because he likes to bet a lot. kind of really agreed with you and the more I look at it, the more I think you might be right. I think that it might be the where the SEC feels it is fewer teams get bowl eligible and and some of the bad teams all of a sudden go from like five or six wins, four wins maybe to like two or three.

22:03 >> Yeah. I mean, look, we're doing our conference or college football preview and I started working on it. One of the teams I have is Arkansas. They were a two- win team last year. You look at their schedule. Yeah. They're going to beat I think North Alabama because that was a bad FCS team and they have a four- win Tulsa. After that, where are you getting the other wins? Right. So, I don't know. I like I said, I definitely see it going that way.

22:27 guys, >> a lot of whining though. A lot of whining out of the SEC this year. It just I'm just preparing everybody. Expect a lot of whining out of the SEC this year. >> And on that note, we're going to take a break and when we come back, we're going to talk some ACC. a little bit of whining in the ACC as well as some Indiana talk. And we're back on the Audible presented by Trader Joe's. So last week guys, Indiana landed a fivestar wide receiver.

22:57 Like Indiana in the evolution of Indiana, the next step is oh now they're doing the recruiting thing too. And there they landed a five-star wide receiver. Bruce fill us in on the player and what it means. >> So the player is a local kid from Indianapolis Showtime sales. He is a fivestar. He is a big receiver. Everybody in wanted him including all the you know Ohio State who by the way got Terry McLaren out of that same area of India Indiana. Alabama, LSU, all the big ones. Well, Curt Signetti got him. And it feels like, guys, this is the next step in where Indiana goes, right? They went in the portal and got some big gets out of it this year, coming, you know, on the national title run. What's interesting to me is now we have something of a track record here with Indiana, not just for developing quarterbacks and and elevating them, but with the receiver position, right? You look at what they just had on that team.

23:59 and they produced a first round pick and Omar Cooper Jr. Charlie Becker, I think our friend Dane Buger, who does a great job on the draft, is very high on Charlie Becker, who is back. Showtime Sales looks like he would be one of those guys you say, "Oh, that guy can be a future first round pick." Now, that that's not to say all of a sudden they're going to be wide receiver in the Big 10 and Ohio State's not. I mean, Ohio State obviously still has Jeremiah Smith. They just got Chris Henry Jr.

24:26 into the program. But Brian Hartline, the guy who helped stock and develop that receiver room that has been incredibly loaded in Columbus, he's now the head coach at USF. Now, they're still recruiting well. I don't want to diminish that, but it's it's interesting of like how big of a deal do you guys think this is? Is it a warning to the rest of the to the rest of college football that they are here to stay as if they didn't need that? Is it going to change how is it going to is it going to change the recruiting landscape in the Big 10 that they were able to keep this kid home? I think it it it it kind of indicates that they it will shift it a little bit. It's been interesting to see the evolution of Indiana from, okay, we're doing it with James Madison guys at first to, oh, now we can go get a Fernando Mendoza and now a Josh Hoover to oh, maybe we can get him out of high school, too. Now, to your point, Bruce, I think we have to see is this a one-off because unique situation, local kid, by the way, not a lot of it's not like Indiana, the state of Indiana is loaded with big-time recruits every year, right? So, and frankly, it's I guess very huge that they don't get that opportunity very often and they did get him. so was it a one-off or are we really going to see their entire recruiting profile change? Because, by the way, that rarely happens. you know, if you you look at a top 20 or let's say top 10 recruiting rankings from 1995 and now, they're probably going to be a lot of the same names. It it's hard to break that cycle. But if anything could break the cycle, it's a 16-0 national championship season. I think if they have another really good season and you're third in a row of being this kind of a level of a program, I there's, you know, now you're starting to get into the kids who don't remember when you were when Indiana was bad, right? So, Ralph, do you think, what what do you what do you think is this a sign that, hey, in a landscape where everybody can now pay the players, the built-in advantages of an Ohio State, or LSU or whoever don't aren't as strong. I feel like it's that has been the case for a while or or we're starting to move to that point, right? When when when money is the deciding factor, all your banners don't mean as much. And with with Indiana here, where I come in is this like, you know, it's the Happy Gilmore line. Oh, Happy learned how to putt, right? Like, is this is this is Indiana is this Indiana's like, hey, now we can recruit five stars, too. Now we have this other thing that we're good at. Again, I don't know if this is a dramatic change, but there does seem to be a little bit of like signetti learned how to recruit five stars, Happy learned how to putt, you know, moment here. We'll see if it actually plays out that way. But the the the thing that is already happening is your tradition, your banners, your helmet, that doesn't mean as much in college football anymore. And you know what? For all the people who are out there like, well, they're just paying players. Yeah, everybody pays them now.

27:30 It doesn't matter. Like I don't like that is not an like that complaint lands with me. Not at all. I do not care about these people who are like Alabama fans and Ohio State fans who feel like it's their birthright as if their five stars were going to their school because we really love Alabama and Ohio State so much. Come on. Like that's never been why they came to your schools. They came to your schools because they thought they were that was the best place to go to the NFL. Like that dynamic is changing. There are a lot of places where that'll send you to the NFL. and and and Indiana having not just Omar Cooper but like nine other draft picks is also proof of concept.

28:06 >> But yeah, that's what exactly what I was going to say. You hit on those three those three words. It's proof of concept. I mean this is you've seen a first round receiver. It's not like somebody can say who who have they developed cuz that comes up a lot with recruiters when they go into the home and it's like if you can show that I mean how often did we hear oh we're going to be you know we're NFLU Jed Fish tried has tried selling that at Washington Bill Bich's obviously tried to sell that at at at North Carolina a lot of schools try to try to harp on that we can get you ready for the NFL and obviously Signetti has not just that he's won but he can also say look at the guys I've developed and sent to the NFL as receivers.

28:45 >> And I agree with you, Ralph, the money thing, it's frankly outdated because now you have revshare. So everybody, at least in the power four, has at least $21 million as their starting point, right? And this is why it's frustrating to me that the the salary numbers aren't public cuz it would be so fascinating to know how the various schools are allocating that money, right? We don't know. We don't even know if Indiana made the the best offer, first of all. You know, it might have been, well, he just needed X to feel comfortable staying home. But you also, but every program has their own big board. They're not just like going down the 247 rankings.

29:24 And for all we know, this he was Indiana's number one receiver target and he was Ohio State's number three. Like, we have we have no idea. in the NFL, you would know that cuz you would see how much they're allocating to this position versus that position. And I I've said this with Indiana the last couple years, right? This you know it's not as obvious with a fivestar, but how signed got it to here is that this new way of the world rewards coaches who are really good at evaluating and really good at prioritizing how to allocate their resources. So but those are details we're just we're just unfortunately not going to know.

30:03 But yeah, don't don't use the money thing as an excuse anymore. You're all This is how it works. Nobody's no literally nobody. Even your 25th guy in the recruiting class is coming to your school for free. It's just who's spending it the the most who is spending it smartly versus maybe just throwing money at whoever the big name is to to get that recruit. All right, we're going to take a break and when we come back, some interesting news and nuggets from ACC media days.

30:35 And we're back. Okay, as I said earlier, Ralph was at ACC Media Days last week. there was some interesting comments, especially from Davos Sweeney, who's not going quietly into the night. Ralph, >> no. Listen, ACC media days were very fun. we very productive. Thanks to all the folks at the ACC and all the schools for helping us out, not just with what was publicly available like the, you know, the podium stuff, but also helping us get some time with some coaches and players offline. but Dabo sort of stole the show of all the things that were going on down there.

31:11 You know, he's he's very easy to get fired up these days. you know, we we got him myself and our colleague David by ourselves for a little one-on-one time and like it doesn't take much to sort of wind dabble up and get him rolling on all the things that have been on his mind over the last few years, which is what is the direction of Clemson? Can he get it back to where they're a championship program? Especially after last year where the expectations were kind of high. They had nine, eight or nine guys drafted. They had two first rounders and they only won seven games.

31:47 But Dabau is again like Dabau is defiant. Dabau is very much like, "Hey, what am I going to do? I'm not going I'm 56 years old, by the way. I'm 56 years old. I told Davo like you can't retire. I'm You're the same age as me." But Dabo, I'm not retiring. We're in great shape. Clemson's in better shape than it's ever been before. So, while it's fun to get Dabau sort of wound up a little bit and he does it himself, it's also when he goes off like this and starts defending himself and defending his time and telling you like Clemson's never been in better shape, it also allows his critics to pass. Imagine if Clemson was a publicly traded company and you know publicly traded company has a earnings call and the CEO gets on and he either has to say like this is why things are going great or this is why we had a rough quarter and every time they had one of those and they weren't doing well the CEO said >> but guys like remember what I did in 2019 remember when we had that you know that that great year of business in 2019 come on give me credit for that right like the further we get each passing year that we get from his peak years.

32:55 People want to hear that less and less. It just it just Look, you're he's going to go in the Hall of Fame one day. He had the greatest run in Clemson history and he deserves all the accolades for that. But that doesn't explain why you went seven and six last year. How are you you went seven and six with a bunch of dudes that got drafted. You have a question at quarterback this year. Like tell tell us about that. tell us what you have done since the end of your disaster season to write this thing cuz we just we don't want to hear anymore about your accomplishments from 10 years ago.

33:27 >> You bring up great points, Ste, and that was, you know, again, like it's not like he's saying anything where you go the light goes on and you go, >> "Oh, yeah." Like he Well, he listen, he did change coordinators, right? He he brought in Chad Morris. new new guys on the defensive side. >> Chad Morris did a really good job for him the first time. Yeah. >> Brought back Chad Morris on the offensive side like to to bring in this new quarterback. Now the the quarterback who's likely to start this year, Chris Vazina or Yeah. Chris Vzena. I don't know if he's the guy, but I mean again like they talked about how hey like I got a guy. It was typical Davo like he's been here. We like our guy. There was no reason to go into the portal. Okay, we'll see. Guy guy was, you know, sitting sitting around for four years, not not playing. I do think Tate Reynolds, the kid behind him, there's been a lot of buzz that maybe he is the next big deal at Clemson at quarterback and he's a true freshman. But I I would just say this, Stu, you know, again, like the the playing the resume thing, I also wonder if we're just entering into a new phase of Dabau's career. And I'll maybe throw this to you, Bruce, where maybe should we like is it going to be okay if he just contends for ACC titles? Like, are we going to be okay with the fact that maybe it's not going to be what it was, but it could still be okay. I mean, whatever it is, but like I mean, he won two national titles. He did stuff nobody thought he could do. He beat Alabama head up. you know, he's a Hall of Fame coach. He is a legendary. Yes, he's a Hall of Fame coach. He is a legend for that. you know, a lot of stuff changed for him. It wasn't just the portal. It was like the the staff shakeup. He lost a lot of good assistance. There was a there was a kind of a core to that. And I think it moved on moved on from him. My gut is, and I don't I I know Stu feels the same way, even stronger, is that he probably will never win another national title at Clemson. If you can get back to where they were a couple of years ago, which were at least winning 10 games and competing for playoff spots where the playoffs big, there's certainly no shame in that. I think what also has changed, and we're going to get into a little more of this in a second, is that right now it feels like Miami is running at the superpower level, I mean, they've won like five games in a row against SEC teams or programs. So, I think that maybe shifted within the ACC where Clemson was the heavyweight with with with FSU running on the side of it a little bit. I think that's what what has changed. Stu, I don't know how much if you feel much differently, but you know, again, you can't take away what he has done as an all-time great coach in the ACC no matter what happens from here.

36:20 Let me just jump in for one second, Sue. Let me ask you this like cuz I think that's what you just said is interesting. It's not up to me. It's up to Clemson fans, right? It's up to like will they accept a new reality? And I I guess I would also think and I'm putting you on the spot here, Sue, like I can't think of a coach who made that transition like he hit the highest of high notes.

36:43 You could have you could have argued that Clemson's 5-year run was one of the greatest 5-year runs quite literally in the history of college football. Are you allowed to age out of that and then just become like another good coach and another very good program? >> Generally, once it starts to go south, it keeps going south. There you go. Ralph, you asked if he if he wins the ACC, is that enough? You know, right now he's he's I mean, he went four and four in the ACC, too, of the last three years. So, I think Clemson fans are still very appreciative of what he did.

37:15 He's very he's still pretty beloved there, even if they're frustrated. And if so, if he were to just start going 10 and three, make the playoff, lose in the first round, like they're going to be okay with that really. I mean, I don't think anybody expects them to go back to being the dominant player. His problem is, what if seven and six becomes the norm? How long are you willing to put up with that before saying, you know, maybe it's time for a fresh start? And it it just it's starting to remind me of that last decade of Bobby Bowen's run. And I realize his run went much longer than Davos, his his superiority, but he he stuck around for almost a whole another decade where there were a lot of seven and six type or eight and five type seasons and every and but it was awkward, right? Nobody wanted to run off the greatest coach in in history.

38:04 Ralph, the other one that really I think the story that interested me most from there is everybody teeing off on Miami, but in particular Pat Nardusi, who is not afraid to speak his mind, the pit coach Pat Nardusi, who flat out accused, Miami of tampering with their quarterback, who ended up staying and then of course Mensah ended up going. Duke obviously not thrilled about that either. There were some comments to that effect. I don't think Manny Diaz said they tampered even though we all know they did. but he said, you know, he had started to get rumblings even before Daren Mensah actually went in the portal that he was going to go to the portal and go there.

38:42 So, what was the vibe like there? >> Yeah. So, our time with Pat Norduzi, who you know is never shy. at some point he just as we're talking about a bunch of things, he's like, "Yeah, you know, Miami talked to our guy, our guy being Mason Heinch, a couple of days before the portal." And then, you know, I called Manny. I said, "They're coming after your guy next." And I I I suspect Hechill was he did not say this. This is me connecting dots. I suspect Hinchel was like a part of backup plans like if the Mensah thing does not happen, if we can't land that plane, this is where we might pivot. But Pat was very proud of saying we we we held him off and we kept our guy. you know, with a couple of things. Pat had mentioned this in like a local availability earlier in the off season, but because it wasn't covered by national media, it kind of got it kind of got ignored a little bit. The other thing was like he walks out of the room and I talked to his SID who was kind of with him. I'm like he knew he was on the record and and and the SID is like yes yes he knew he was on the record. We kind of had a feeling he was going to bring that one up so do what you want.

39:51 so yeah, it just speaks to this idea of like first of all, there's the tampering aspect which I'm like I don't know, man. Like I I feel like everybody does it and I don't know if you can control it. But it also is like is everybody in this conference pissed off at Miami? Is it like is it the is it Texas Tech level of pissed off? I don't think it's that. But there definitely is an absolute recognition that Miami is playing by not by different rules, but is is playing this new game differently, that they are pretty far out ahead of everybody else in the paying players portion of college football now. And I do think that there is an element of frustration that comes with that because they can sort of swoop in.

40:40 >> The controversy at the time wasn't that they just that they took their quarterback. It was that Mensah was under contract for another year, right? His his $4 million a year contract and Miami still got him. Now Duke ended up suing the kid and I think got close to what you know what what get got ended up being able to, you know, scrape back close to the $4 million. But you know it's it's when you can do that and and I think there was frustration that Jim Phillips behind the scenes didn't really >> do anything about it, you know, just kind of stood back and let it happen.

41:17 yeah. Can I also say something that was interesting is like the way like again Nordi comes out because he's Nardooi and is like yeah Miami tried to steal our quarterback and Manny and Duke I think have very much tried to take a I think they have my sense of this is they are trying not to get involved in this. They're they're trying not to get dragged into like accusing, hey, like it happened. We got our money back. Not thrilled, but like we're not going to get into the public back and forth of it all. Because when Nordi says, hey, I called Manny, then I got to go over to Duke and say, you got to comment on this. And I think the general comment out of Duke was like, we're not we're just >> at least probably Duke got ticked at their own they didn't get ticked at Miami or they didn't try to accuse Miami anything. They just got mad at their quarter at Mensah for for bailing on them. Yeah.

42:08 >> Well, they also got m they also got mad at Mensah this week it sounded like for some revisionist history of some of the comments he made at ACC media days about when he got there from two lane he was kind of this money guy and how that set in the locker room cuz from the comments I saw from their tight end they weren't thrilled at how he categorized that this past week at ACC. Mensah said there was he he indicated or hinted that there was some resentment toward him when he first got to Duke and that he wasn't fully accepted because of the big contract and then I guess the reporters then went to the Duke players and they're like no that's not that's not a thing.

42:44 >> That wasn't a thing. Yeah. >> Men is an interesting character. It was the first time I had a chance to talk to him one. Yeah. >> He's a good >> super comfortable in his skin. Very confident kid. Like I think it'll play well. Like I think it'll serve him well throughout his football career. We'll see. Ultimately talent will play it out, but I think it will serve him well throughout his football career. >> Ralph, I just wanted to finish on this point with you. you're there for you talked to a lot of coaches and players around the league. Was there one or two schools that you now look at maybe a little differently coming out of this?

43:18 Maybe you're more optimistic, maybe you're a little bullish, or maybe you're down on something that you heard. I think two that I was a little more down on that I came out thinking like, yeah, I could see that. I could see that a little more optimistic maybe now after talking to some folks. Georgia Tech when we did our overunder game, I had picked them as one of my unders at 6 and a half. After talking to Brent Kei, like I think he's got it down on what he wants to do offensive linewise. They change offensive coordinators. We'll see how that works. But I don't know, maybe just being around Bren Key, he's a pretty confident and cool customer, too.

43:55 And he got got me feeling like the most interesting thing I heard out of Brink Key, I asked him what went wrong last year. And he kind of looked at me as like I don't know if anything went wrong. We just lost to some good teams. And I kind of like that because I what what it tells me is like he didn't look at what happened at the end of last year as like a a systemwide failure.

44:17 Clearly things need to be improved. Clearly things need to be tweaked. The other team, sitting down with Fran Brown, I really do like, you know, he's an intense guy. They have a tough schedule, but I do wonder if the change of defensive coordinator to Vince Cares who came from well, previously coached Mount Union, but he was at Toledo. The the the change the change of defensive coordinator bringing in Jelly back. I think that maybe I might have been underelling how Syracuse could conceivably take a step forward this year. It's again, it's going to be rough. They play most of the best teams in the ACC on top of Notre Dame at the end of the year. but I I I felt like I came away after talking to Fran a little more confident that he might be able to bounce back this year.

45:07 >> Okay. it was good to get some ACC talk into the podcast. We had Big 12 last week. I assume when we come back for our second episode this week, we'll be talking more SEC because by then 16 coaches will have talked. And of course, our Thursday episode is mailbag episode. We got some great questions last week. So, let's keep it up, guys. Send your questions to the Audible pod@gmail.com. And don't forget to subscribe to the Audible wherever you get your podcasts.

45:35 And while you're at it, give us a fivestar rating. We'll see you next time.

Summary

The latest episode of The Audible discusses key developments in college football, focusing on the Michigan scandal involving AD Ward Manuel, the SEC media days, and Indiana's rise in recruiting. The hosts analyze the implications of these events, including the potential for Michigan to move on from its recent controversies and the SEC's ongoing frustrations with NCAA governance.

- Michigan's AD Ward Manuel is stepping down amid a scandal, with the university criticized for a lack of transparency in its investigation.
- The hosts debate whether Michigan fans feel the recent scandals overshadow their recent successes, including multiple championships.
- SEC media days highlight Greg Sankey's comments about the conference's frustration with NCAA governance and the possibility of making their own rules.
- Coaches like Eli Drinkwitz of Missouri express concerns about the SEC's scheduling and its impact on playoff opportunities.
- Indiana's recruitment of a five-star wide receiver signals a potential shift in the program's trajectory, showcasing its ability to attract top talent.
- ACC media days featured Dabo Swinney defending Clemson's recent performance while facing skepticism about the program's future.
- Pat Narduzzi of Pitt accused Miami of tampering with players, reflecting broader frustrations within the ACC regarding competitive balance and recruitment practices.
- The hosts discuss the evolving landscape of college football recruiting, emphasizing the importance of adapting to new financial realities.

Questions Answered

What is the current status of the Michigan athletic department scandal?

Michigan's athletic department is facing scrutiny due to a recent investigation, with the release of a statement that lacks detailed information. The timing of the release has been criticized as cowardly and insulting, especially given the ongoing attention on the department's past issues.

How do rivalries affect perceptions of scandals in college football?

Rivalries, particularly between teams like Michigan and Ohio State, influence fan perceptions of scandals. While Michigan faces scrutiny, Ohio State also has a history of issues, suggesting that no program is entirely free from controversy.

What are the current discussions around the SEC's strength of schedule?

The SEC is emphasizing the importance of strength of schedule in the College Football Playoff discussions. Despite criticisms, data shows that the SEC consistently has the toughest schedules, which impacts their playoff positioning.

How is the recruitment landscape changing in college football?

The recruitment landscape is evolving as players are increasingly attracted to programs based on their potential to reach the NFL rather than traditional powerhouses. Indiana's recent success in sending players to the NFL exemplifies this shift.

What happens when a successful coach's performance declines?

As a coach's performance declines, there is a tension between appreciation for past successes and frustration with current results. Programs may tolerate a few years of mediocrity, but there is a limit to how long they will wait for improvement before considering a change.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram