Section Insights
Understanding Bond Allocation in Retirement
What is the right bond percentage to hold in retirement?
The question of how much bond percentage to hold in retirement is often misplaced. Many Canadians already have inflation-indexed income through sources like the Canadian Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS), which should be considered when determining bond allocation.
- Many Canadians have guaranteed income sources that function like bonds.
- CPP and OAS provide significant monthly income that can replace bond income.
- Calculators are available to help individuals assess their retirement income needs.
Calculating Guaranteed Income Costs
How do you calculate the cost of guaranteed income sources?
The cost of guaranteed income sources like CPP and OAS can be substantial, with estimates suggesting that these benefits could cost around $500,000 to purchase. It's important for individuals to calculate their own guaranteed income based on their specific circumstances.
- Guaranteed income sources can significantly impact retirement planning.
- Individuals should calculate their own guaranteed income to inform their investment strategy.
- Defined benefit pension plans can also contribute to guaranteed income.
Impact of Guaranteed Income on Equity Allocation
How does guaranteed income affect equity allocation in retirement portfolios?
As guaranteed income increases from 5% to 75% of a person's wealth, the optimal equity allocation can shift dramatically from 30% to 95%. This highlights that the presence of guaranteed income provides a safety net that allows for a more aggressive investment strategy.
- Higher guaranteed income allows for increased equity allocation.
- Different individuals can have vastly different optimal portfolios based on their guaranteed income.
- The stability of guaranteed income influences investment risk tolerance.
Withdrawal Rates and Retirement Income Risks
What are the risks associated with withdrawal rates in retirement?
Withdrawal rates are critical in retirement planning, with research indicating that a 40% stock allocation can lead to running out of money less than 3.5% of the time over a 30-year retirement. However, factors like clawbacks on OAS and individual spending habits can complicate this.
- Withdrawal rates significantly affect the longevity of retirement funds.
- Clawbacks on OAS can impact income for higher earners.
- Historical data can guide expectations for withdrawal rates.
Determining the Gap in Retirement Income
How do you determine the income gap that your portfolio needs to cover?
To determine the income gap in retirement, individuals should calculate their guaranteed income from sources like CPP, OAS, and pensions, then subtract their expected retirement expenses. This gap is what the investment portfolio needs to cover.
- Understanding guaranteed income is essential for retirement planning.
- Calculating the income gap helps inform investment allocation decisions.
- Many people overlook the importance of this calculation in their retirement strategy.
Transcript
0:00 Someone always asks, "How much bond percentage should they hold in retirement?" Let's break this down or take a step back first, so usually the wrong question. A lot of Canadians already own something that pays inflation indexed income for life, which is what a bond is supposed to do for you. You just don't see that number in your actual portfolio. So maximum Canadian pension plan at 65 is 1,500 a month. full old age security is just about 750 a month. Call it 2250 all in. And I'll say there's very good calculators out there to help you calculate yours. Now let's think about pricing that. A Canadian insurer this month single life registered escalating at 2% pays about $450 month per $100,000. that CPP or old age security costs roughly about almost $500,000 to buy two people in a house close to a million. Calculate yours for yourself.
1:04 I'm not telling you what yours is for you. Some people have a defined benefit pension plan, too, that could go into the mix if it's inflation indexed, but this stuff changes your allocation completely. Blanchett and Frink modeled this back in 2018. As guaranteed income goes from 5% of your wealth to 75%, the optimal equity allocation goes from 30% to 95%. Two people, identical portfolios and completely different right answers. The difference isn't the nerve that someone has, it's the floor underneath them of guaranteed income that shows up no matter what the market does. Two things can break this. First, it works because CPP and OAS are tied to actual inflation. Most Canadian private sector pensions aren't fully indexed, but if it is, good for you. A $60,000 pension with no indexing buys about a third less in 20 years. It's just something to factor in, but it protects you during your highest sequence or orders of return risk at early retirement. And as everyone knows, old age security starts getting clawed back once your income gets closer to 100K and above a certain point, it's gone entirely. If you have a lot of money and lower spend, you have a low withdrawal rate. Javier Estrada tested 30-year retirements back to 1900 and found anything from 40% stocks up ran out of money less than 3.5% of the time. Back to the researchers I quoted in an earlier video of this series, the All Equity Paper published this. 38 countries, a 65year-old couple accepting a 5% chance of running out of money can withdraw 2.31% a year. 4% rule does not always hold.
2:56 2.31 low withdrawal rates are harder to reach than the American numbers suggest. Before you pick a mix of what you buy, price that floor of guaranteed income you have, add up your CPP or OAS, maybe a pension, rental income, subtract what you actually spend in retirement. I have a separate video on that on the replacement rate. That gap is what the portfolio has to cover. That's the number the allocation question was always about. Most people have not worked out the math. Please take your time. Take care.
Summary
- Many Canadians have guaranteed income sources that function similarly to bonds, providing inflation-indexed income for life.
- The maximum CPP at age 65 is approximately $1,500/month, and OAS is about $750/month, totaling around $2,250 monthly.
- The cost of purchasing equivalent guaranteed income can be substantial; for instance, $450/month per $100,000 invested in a single life registered annuity.
- The optimal equity allocation can vary dramatically based on the percentage of guaranteed income in a retiree's wealth, ranging from 30% to 95%.
- Guaranteed income protects retirees during periods of high market volatility, especially in the early years of retirement.
- Many private sector pensions are not fully indexed to inflation, which can erode purchasing power over time.
- High-income retirees may face clawbacks on OAS, affecting their overall income strategy.
- Calculating the gap between guaranteed income and retirement spending is crucial for determining the necessary portfolio withdrawal rate and asset allocation.
Questions Answered
What is the right bond percentage to hold in retirement?
The question of how much bond percentage to hold in retirement is often misplaced. Many Canadians already have inflation-indexed income through sources like the Canadian Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS), which should be considered when determining bond allocation.
How do you calculate the cost of guaranteed income sources?
The cost of guaranteed income sources like CPP and OAS can be substantial, with estimates suggesting that these benefits could cost around $500,000 to purchase. It's important for individuals to calculate their own guaranteed income based on their specific circumstances.
How does guaranteed income affect equity allocation in retirement portfolios?
As guaranteed income increases from 5% to 75% of a person's wealth, the optimal equity allocation can shift dramatically from 30% to 95%. This highlights that the presence of guaranteed income provides a safety net that allows for a more aggressive investment strategy.
What are the risks associated with withdrawal rates in retirement?
Withdrawal rates are critical in retirement planning, with research indicating that a 40% stock allocation can lead to running out of money less than 3.5% of the time over a 30-year retirement. However, factors like clawbacks on OAS and individual spending habits can complicate this.
How do you determine the income gap that your portfolio needs to cover?
To determine the income gap in retirement, individuals should calculate their guaranteed income from sources like CPP, OAS, and pensions, then subtract their expected retirement expenses. This gap is what the investment portfolio needs to cover.