transcribe

Why Everything Kept Breaking Last Week | Lightwork

Lightspeed Venture Partners · 22m · transcribed 3h ago
More from Lightspeed Venture Partners Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Cyber Outages and Accidental Prepping

What are the recent outages affecting major systems, and how are people reacting?

Recent outages have impacted Microsoft, the FAA, banks, and the NSA, leading to speculation about their causes. While some believe these are cyber attacks, others suggest they are due to routine maintenance and legacy systems being updated. The conversation also touches on personal reactions to these events, with one participant mentioning their shift towards 'accidental prepping' in response to perceived threats.

  • Recent outages are affecting major organizations, but not all are due to cyber attacks.
  • Legacy systems are vulnerable and often require updates that can lead to outages.
  • Personal reactions to these outages include increased preparedness among individuals.
# 4:35

Legacy Systems and Cybersecurity Updates

Why are recent outages occurring in major systems?

The outages are attributed to the updating of legacy systems, which often leads to complications. Companies are reassessing their cybersecurity measures due to vulnerabilities identified in older code. The speed of AI technology allows for quicker updates, but this also increases the risk of errors during the process.

  • Legacy systems are often problematic when updated, leading to outages.
  • Recent vulnerabilities have prompted companies to reassess their cybersecurity.
  • AI technology accelerates code updates but can introduce new risks.
# 9:11

The Role of AI Agents in Consumer Transactions

How are AI agents changing the landscape of consumer transactions?

AI agents are beginning to perform tasks traditionally done by humans, such as booking flights or making purchases. However, there are concerns about the implications of these agents, including the potential for errors and the need for clear permissions and accountability in transactions.

  • AI agents are increasingly used for consumer transactions, but their role is still evolving.
  • There are concerns about accountability and decision-making in transactions involving AI.
  • Companies are exploring ways to integrate AI agents while ensuring consumer protection.
# 13:46

Personal Agent Protocols and Consumer Trust

What are the implications of personal agent protocols for consumer transactions?

Personal agent protocols aim to establish clear identities and rules for AI agents, allowing them to interact with businesses on behalf of consumers. This approach seeks to enhance trust and security in transactions by defining what agents can and cannot do, thereby protecting consumer interests.

  • Personal agent protocols can enhance trust in AI transactions by clarifying roles and permissions.
  • These protocols allow for better integration of AI agents into existing systems.
  • Establishing rules for AI agents can help mitigate risks associated with automated transactions.
# 18:22

SpaceX's Achievement in Rocket Recovery

What recent achievement has SpaceX made in rocket recovery?

SpaceX has successfully caught the upper stage of its Starship rocket after a descent from orbit, marking a significant step towards making space travel more sustainable through reusability. This achievement is notable because catching a ship is much more complex than catching a booster due to the high speeds and heat involved during re-entry.

  • SpaceX has made a significant advancement by catching the Starship's upper stage.
  • Catching a ship is more complex than catching a booster due to speed and heat challenges.
  • This achievement aligns with SpaceX's mission to make space travel more sustainable.

Transcript

0:00 It can't all be routine maintenance, Kenneth? No, I actually do not think these are all cyber attacks. I am Claire's agent. I'm a delegate of Claire. I'm not pretending to be Claire. This is the first time they've caught the ship and with a pair of chopsticks. We are basically throwing away a airplane every single time we launch. It feels like we're living in the future even though we're in our retro future studio.

0:31 We're back with another big week. A string of outages hit Microsoft, the FAA, banks, and even the NSA. And so far, none of them look like cyber attacks. A law firm insured its AI agents just as United moved to block unauthorized ones. And for the first time ever, SpaceX caught Starship's upper stage after a fiery plunge from orbit, making the company one step closer to a reusable rocket. Let's get into it. Josh, have you been prepping for this Armageddon that we are experiencing? not like you have. You're like the prepper queen. I feel like I have sort of descended into accidental prepping. Yeah. I mean, look, Chase was down, United was down, Apple was down, the NSA's system. It can't all be routine maintenance, Kenneth? I was on that prepping train all the way. Let it be known, I was on that prepping train all the way since the PHP vulnerability came out and then I started spiraling since then. Yeah. when you started?

1:29 Yeah, but I I okay, also all of this is like fully just me being paranoid and succumbing to the doomerism that exists on the X timeline. Who do you think influenced you? Is it like TikTok? What's the No, no. I think it was fully like I started I started clicking through a couple posts that were like, you should have a couple days of water. And then there was that phase where all these countries were doing these like national routine alarms testing. I I think there was one in New York yesterday. And so I saw that and then it just felt like coincidence and I was okay, I might as well have three days of water and food in my home. Okay, so we're on our way to a meeting and the subway's out. Like, what do we do first? What's the what's the move? How are we getting out of the city? prepping? Yeah. Oh my gosh. Well, my understanding is the first thing you want to do is leave the city. However, I'm Do you have a central meeting point? Like are we do we avoid Grand Central? Are we going to Grand Central? out a a meeting point with whoever you would like to escape with. But you want to avoid heavy places. Like I think actually the most dense places are the most dangerous, like New York City. And me and my friends were sort of plotting and we were deciding, do you like parachute off of your building? Do you get a motor boat? you live on a very high floor. This is not an easy thing just to get out of your building. Yeah. So now I have all this prepper equipment to like fend people off, but I'm going to be in a very, you know, cushy apartment in New York City and, you know, it's I I think very much so not not a full-blown prepper.

2:56 Okay, so what's the thing that you've bought that I might make fun of now but might buy later? I have a ferro rod. have you seen Alone? yeah, I love Alone. Alone's great. good. so I've been watching well, I've been watching Alone for many years now, but now I'm finally using some of that knowledge. I have no clue how to use a ferro rod. I've seen it used many times. Yeah, I've seen an Alone Yeah, but now I can start a fire in my New York City apartment in case I need to. I mean, just what you need to do in a high-rise building. Yeah, but to answer your question, no, I actually do not think these are all cyber attacks and that we as a collective, including myself, may be freaking out a little bit too much. Yeah, sometimes coincidences are just coincidences, but it is hard when there are so many that you can be like the first outage, I'm like, you know, okay, I'm going to screenshot the boarding pass. Like the second outage, I'm checking X and like falling down conspiracy like rabbit holes and by the third, I'm getting my news from Lisa Simpson.

3:53 Exactly. And so I think I've been seeing some tweets that were like this is like the Advent calendar, but each day there's like another infrastructure piece that's broken. Well, it does feel like we're at the advent of the new like agentic apocalypse, but maybe. Yeah, but I actually I mean so I think my analysis of this whole situation for for those as I'm sure many of people tuning in or or many of my friends have asked me is just what is going on. And I think what is actually happening is a couple of things. So we could actually trace this back all the way to maybe Mythos even and OpenAI hugging face incident. And I think what's really happening here is yes, because of AI, but not in the way that you might think. It's not because of AI agents suddenly deciding to autonomously hack systems, nor is it, you know, external other parties attacking these systems. Rather, I think what's happening here is you have a couple of things happening. We have a lot of legacy systems like the FAA. That's very old code coming. anytime we all know that you update an old system, Exactly. things seem to spiral. And so I think given all the cybersecurity vulnerabilities where we did actually see some flaws like PHP, there are a couple in Linux and Java in October, Black October that we discussed. I think that led a lot of companies to reassess their security systems and their code and as part of that they defensively decided to update a lot of things. And I think with AI it is now faster than ever to update code. It is faster than ever to identify flaws in your code and therefore all of these systems are routinely systems that maybe for the last five to 10 years we never really looked at are now going through these routine cyber updates. And because of that, when you do update to what you mentioned, there's a lot of opportunity for things to go wrong because you're just sort of rewiring things.

5:49 And that's where we're seeing outages rather than some malicious actor coming in and actively trying to attack Apple or bank system or airlines. It does seem like there's more to patch than ever, so I feel like that actually makes a lot of sense. I also feel like there's so many agents now running around these systems. You can also see why someone like United is starting to ban them, right? Like, it's just more drain on these systems that are already maybe not as like current as they could be. Yeah. I would I would argue though that I feel like those are two separate ones.

6:24 Yeah. Like I think one is very much so a consumer agent. The mechanism there is that they want to defend against like price scraping and and you know scalpers and and people who are just applying bots to buying tickets. I think any platform with inventory has experienced this Ticketmaster United versus I think everything happening right now with Cyber is much more of a sort of like underlying infrastructure issue. I think I saw somewhere that you know Microsoft which had that major outage on Friday about for their monthly security update last month they fixed about 1,400 flaws which is a record. A year earlier it was about 170. So that goes to show I think what's happening here is every major platform like an Apple, like a bank like an FAA is going through the same change of going from patching only 140 things to 1,700 things. And you can see where when you go from 140 to 1,700 that 10x you're going to have 10x the number of potential breakages.

7:24 so I think that's what's happening here. But I think the other side of it is to to what you mentioned yeah a lot of new agents which also introduce a lot of issues on the consumer end too. So Claire, did I tell you I got banned from Resy last week? Oh really? Yeah. I think I gave I think Pratik on our team also. Oh really? I gave I gave my Resy credentials to probably half a dozen Resy agents. And now I just sort of have them running around trying to get that table for two at 7:00 and they came on to me and then now I'm banned. I'm officially banned.

8:02 Did they say explicitly it was because of the It is specifically like it's clearly agent use. And what am I going to say? Like, no, I didn't just give it to one agent. I gave it to like seven different ones that I was playing with. Yeah. But it does make you think about one like consumer protections. And I think there's a lot that got a bold new world there, right? Like, your agents that are acting on your behalf, like if if they get you banned from Resy, it's not their fault. It's your fault. Yeah. And so what does that mean when I don't know your instinct goes and makes a purchase of something that maybe you weren't yet sure that you wanted to order and it even get a refund if it's final sale. Yeah. if it's final sale? Like, is there a bold new world for maybe insurance in this interesting space? I think there's going to be a whole stack of tools that need to rewire for agents, including payments, insurance, identity, manners even, reputation. Like, is there some sort of level of not credit risk, but like agent risk or agent reputation as it navigates the web? Because these are entities that are making decisions on your behalf. And it's not just buying stuff. It's agent performed work. Yes, exactly. And so yeah, I I understand why to what we were discussing earlier, some of these players like a United or a Resy might block some of these agents cuz it is very frustrating to deal with, you know, 100 different entities fighting for one seat. and we've had that before with bots, but not at at this scale.

9:39 Yeah, when there's 12 Josh matches is running around trying to nail down a a a table Yeah. versus the one person actually using the Resy app, I can understand why they they got that. I do think these platforms will have to adapt to agents because people are actively using them. I think right now the scale is small, right? Like, I think United and DoorDash both said that they aren't It's like even like sub a thousand orders or purchases through these agents. So I don't think the scale is there, but I do think the reality is, as a consumer, eventually I will want to just say, "I would like a I'll see in this class and a flight at this time," and hopefully have an agent execute on that, because I don't necessarily need to be the person who's logging in, manually picking everything. At the same time, I think there's open questions around one where the sort of like human decision sits. Is it in the checkout layer? Is it in the sort of original prompt? And then to what we were mentioning earlier, what happens when all of this actually goes wrong?

10:43 Absolutely. And I think there's some staff around like permissions and like what you're authorizing it to do and and who's actually acting when it's doing it, right? Like are you to blame for the the errant purchase that it makes when it went through and bought something that maybe you weren't yet sure you wanted to buy? Yeah. And so I actually think there are companies filling this gap. specifically, for example, in insurance, the idea that you need to trust agents with real work. Now you have a couple players that are underwriting and able to price that risk. Mhm. and so AI error can then become sort of this like cost that businesses can plan for instead of this sort of like Wild West open-ended unknown. And then I think for payments, this is where we're seeing I would say probably the most robust activity. you know, for example, Hark is giving them like debit cards, right? Like prepaid debit cards where basically your agents can go and overspend. Seem like Instinct kind of created like almost a limit option where you can kind of go up to a spending limit. It's starting to seem like Muse, Instinct, Hark, Grogbot, they're all starting to think about the fact that all of these agents buying things on people's behalf affect their wallets. Yes. And how do you make sure that they're not overspending the way we hope we're not overspending?

12:04 Yeah. I'm really curious where it sits in the sort of purchasing workflow, right? Like does do these limits get enforced by instinct? Like, is it Instinct's job to tell you you've spent $400? Or or to make sure that your agent doesn't go beyond that? Or is it the protocol's job? Or is it the like if you're if you end up Is it the bank's job to have some sort of offering for agents? Is it at the payment rail level of like a Stripe is supposed to be enforcing this or is it, you know, United who's ultimately receiving that money? Like, I'm very curious who owns the payment and liability aspect of all of this. I think there's a lot to be discovered, right? Like, we're talking about like Crosby Legal is thinking they're using Lloyd's of London to underwrite their paralegals. Like, just like there's lots of places where there could be underwriting in the liability of working with agents regardless of what the work is. And so I think that there's potentially many players in this space that it feels like is, you know, kind of ripe for innovation.

13:16 Yeah. I think one that's been catching my eye is definitely Poppy, which is came out of Sierra, this personal agent protocol. In short, it's basically like sign in with Google, but for agents. of sense. Yeah. It's basically the standard way that agents can show up. Do you feel like that's the one that's gaining traction right now? I think there are a couple like, you know, I think in the last year when I believe Stripe and OpenAI had a partnership, Visa and MasterCard have all come out with their own protocols, but this feels like the one that's quite horizontal.

13:48 Yes. I, you know, a couple of our portfolio companies I saw like Profound, a couple others were also on Poppy. but basically it's the standard way that personal agent can show up at a business, say who it is, who it's representing, who it's working for, and then find out what it's allowed to do. So sort of like identity plus rules for the agent. Does seem like an elegant solve for a very complicated problem. Yeah. And I think what 's cool is there are a couple ways this solves for. So I think if you think about this workflow of like book me a flight to London, now today with Instinct or Muse, you are having your agent use computer use in a really janky way where it's like clicking through things, going very slowly. It clicks around like a person would. And to reach your account, it has to use your actual password. It has to basically pretend to be you in order to do anything. And then it gets blocked by United because it can't fill captcha and you can't you just can't do it. So that's like our current workflow today. I think with something like Poppy, how that changes is if United say becomes part of the personal agent protocol, then I would now again use Muse or Instinct and say book me a flight. This time the agent arrives and says I am Claire's agent. I'm a delegate of Claire. I'm not pretending to be Claire. You sign in and United's own page will give it limited access to search and book, but it can't touch miles, it can't cancel.

15:20 So it can't do things over 50k miles. So you can see how you're starting to be able to one give it identity to say okay, I'm not pretending to be Claire, but two here are rules around how I can use your website. And then from there you can for example in personal agent protocol enforce that United can require that it check with you first before you execute on any purchase. and then I think that's an interesting case where it's like okay, the vendor has decided that the human needs a sort of final in the loop, yes, and the liabilities of the human. I think where this gets really interesting is when you apply something like Poppy with agent insurance with Hm. agent cards. So maybe you have Poppy which gives you all the identity, the rules, but then it's like you give the agent a card that only works with United and it's capped at $900. And then if an agent goes rogue or United systems get breached, then that damage stops.

16:19 or if it books the right airline, but the wrong thing, then someone can underwrite that risk. So, it's kind of interesting. I think we're right now in phase one, but like phase two, phase three, you can see how it flows into that. Claire, SpaceX had an incredible weekend. We've seen them catch the booster before, but this is the first time they've caught the ship and with a pair of chopsticks. Can you explain to our viewers, help them understand what was different about this SpaceX mission than the past? Yeah. it was really, really cool. Did you get to see the video? gosh, the video is incredible. It feels like we're living in the future, even though we're in our retro future studio. I think I saw a couple people post like the 100 I think it's like either 120 122 year difference of humanity's first flight to rocket ships being able to catch a rocket ship is insane. and just the the massive step change in such a short time in, you know, the entire like this was not going to be a thing for a while. I I actually didn't think that I mean, I think we're all rooting for it, but we didn't expect that it was going to be so soon that we were going to be able to retrieve this. And for SpaceX, the company, this is a big thing because this is a very expensive thing to catch. Yeah, and we'll explain it, but I I think what was interesting for me for the video was like it it was so cool cuz it's obviously been never been done before, but then even look real. I was like, is this yeah, oh no, we're watching a live stream.

17:50 But the other part of me was like it is quite like primitive in how it's just it's just like Yeah. wedges in between, you know, it's like I I think on one hand, it's like, oh my gosh, I've this is sci-fi, I've never seen this or but on the other hand, I'm like, wait, this is like a pretty simple mechanism. Obviously very hard to execute. so for those who are less familiar with SpaceX's model, their big push has just always been reusability. Mhm.

18:14 right now, if you think about the ways that we run our space transport systems, we are basically throwing away a airplane every single time we launch. And that's just not sustainable. And so, SpaceX as a company, their big mission has has always been to make reuse cheap. and so instead of, you know, the idea that you're like flying to London and throwing away the plane, the idea is that now you can fly it back and apply that same thing to rockets. And historically, SpaceX has been able to catch boosters before. Sure. However, the ship itself has never been caught. And why haven't they been able to catch the ship? Or it's just the technology wasn't there yet? Yeah. there are a couple of really hard parts about catching a ship. So, to understand the difference between a booster and a ship, the booster is basically the part that really only goes up and down. It's like basically it boosts up there. And so it's actually okay or or relatively easier to catch because the booster just goes up and then for a couple minutes you let go of the ship and then it falls back down. And so that's a very different dynamic versus for a ship, that keeps going until it circles Earth and it's going often around 17,000 mph. Booster again just going boop, back down. Ship gets released into space, speeding really quickly around Earth.

19:37 And in order to come back home down to Earth, it has to slam back into the air at that speed. Hm. And when you slam that into air as fast as it's going, you are creating a huge amount of heat. So, think of like a a meteor burning up or when you rub your hands like really really quickly but million times higher temperature. And for a ship, the only protection it has is a heat shield which are these thousand special tiles that sit on the ship. And historically on past flights, the tiles have either cracked or they've fallen off. fall off. And it's just hard to catch this thing. So, we finally did it which is really really exciting because the vision for Starship, there are a couple notable SpaceX vehicles. Falcon 9 has we've caught a booster there before, but Starship the idea is that you have both the booster and the ship as reusable.

20:26 Incredible. Well, an amazing day for humanity and certainly for SpaceX. Yeah, and it means that the costs of reaching orbit is hopefully getting a lot cheaper. as we know, the costs of reaching orbit limits everything we do in space. And what does it cost SpaceX to make one of these ships? I'm not sure the actual price. What I do know is the cost per kilogram of getting something up there. So with a space shuttle, the ones that you throw away and discard after, that's like $50,000 per kilogram. Falcon 9, where the booster is reused, again, the ship gets discarded. The booster, that would probably be around 2,500 to 3,000. These are all ballpark number estimates.

21:06 And for Starship, which is SpaceX's target, which hopefully we're getting there, it might be $100 to $200. Wow. So compare that to space shuttle, which is $50,000 per kilogram. I mean, for all the companies working with SpaceX, this is a huge opportunity and being able to bring things to space at a much lower cost. And it's really important for SpaceX's business because, as we know, Starlink is where they make a lot of their revenue. and Falcon 9 is the reason that Starlink as a business even exists. And so if you can get Starship going at this sustainable pace, which if Starlink pays for everything, then you need Starlink's next generation satellites, which are too big for Falcon 9, but can fit in Starship. And Starship can carry many more of them per launch. And this Starship was able to put, I believe, 26 of them?

21:55 I believe so. Yeah. It's really exciting in that step towards reusability. And I think in terms of just like where we go from here, I believe NASA's Artemis program is also going to use Starship as the lander that carries astronauts to the moon. So that's exciting. And there's all these new businesses in orbit, right? I think there are all these businesses that historically are extremely uneconomical at today's prices. But if you do actually get that reusability, not only Starlink, but also data centers in space, which Elon has been pushing. manufacturing in orbit. I think I saw recently I went down this whole rabbit hole around being able to create drugs in space. There are all these things like drugs, fiber optics, semiconductors that turn out a lot better in zero gravity. So manufacturing in space might be a whole thing.

22:43 and then of course things like private space stations which might replace ISS which is due to retire around 2030. So only a couple years until we have to figure that out. Well, it sounds like we need to do an updated whiteboard on like all the things you can build in space. Yes.

Summary

Recent outages affecting major institutions like Microsoft, the FAA, and banks have raised concerns, but experts suggest these are not cyber attacks but rather issues stemming from outdated systems and increased cybersecurity measures. Meanwhile, SpaceX achieved a milestone by catching its Starship's upper stage after a descent, marking a significant step towards reusable space travel.

- A series of outages across various sectors are attributed to legacy systems undergoing updates rather than cyber attacks.
- Increased cybersecurity vulnerabilities and updates have led to a surge in system failures.
- AI is accelerating the identification and patching of code flaws, contributing to the frequency of outages.
- SpaceX successfully caught its Starship's upper stage, a first in space travel, enhancing the company's reusability mission.
- The cost of launching payloads into space could significantly decrease with the successful implementation of reusable rockets.
- The Starship can carry more payloads than previous models, which is crucial for future missions, including NASA's Artemis program.
- The potential for manufacturing in space and the establishment of private space stations is growing as costs decrease.
- New protocols for AI agents are emerging, focusing on consumer protections and liability in automated transactions.

Questions Answered

What are the recent outages affecting major systems, and how are people reacting?

Recent outages have impacted Microsoft, the FAA, banks, and the NSA, leading to speculation about their causes. While some believe these are cyber attacks, others suggest they are due to routine maintenance and legacy systems being updated. The conversation also touches on personal reactions to these events, with one participant mentioning their shift towards 'accidental prepping' in response to perceived threats.

Why are recent outages occurring in major systems?

The outages are attributed to the updating of legacy systems, which often leads to complications. Companies are reassessing their cybersecurity measures due to vulnerabilities identified in older code. The speed of AI technology allows for quicker updates, but this also increases the risk of errors during the process.

How are AI agents changing the landscape of consumer transactions?

AI agents are beginning to perform tasks traditionally done by humans, such as booking flights or making purchases. However, there are concerns about the implications of these agents, including the potential for errors and the need for clear permissions and accountability in transactions.

What are the implications of personal agent protocols for consumer transactions?

Personal agent protocols aim to establish clear identities and rules for AI agents, allowing them to interact with businesses on behalf of consumers. This approach seeks to enhance trust and security in transactions by defining what agents can and cannot do, thereby protecting consumer interests.

What recent achievement has SpaceX made in rocket recovery?

SpaceX has successfully caught the upper stage of its Starship rocket after a descent from orbit, marking a significant step towards making space travel more sustainable through reusability. This achievement is notable because catching a ship is much more complex than catching a booster due to the high speeds and heat involved during re-entry.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram