Section Insights
Introduction and Community Engagement
What is the purpose of the Audible show?
The Audible show aims to engage college football fans by providing regular content during the season and off-season, encouraging subscriptions and community building.
- The show airs three times a week during the season and twice during the off-season.
- Listeners are encouraged to subscribe and follow on social media to build a community.
- Engagement with the audience is a key focus for the show's hosts.
Impact of Expanded Playoffs on Game Intensity
How will the new 24-team playoff format affect game intensity?
The new playoff format may reduce the urgency and intensity of regular-season games, leading to a gradual decline in viewership and attendance over time.
- The sense of urgency in games may diminish with the expanded playoff format.
- Viewers may become less engaged, especially casual fans.
- The impact on viewership will likely be gradual rather than immediate.
Challenges for Quarterbacks in Transition
What challenges does Bryce Underwood face as a quarterback?
Bryce Underwood is struggling due to a lack of stability with coaching and systems, which affects his performance and development.
- Underwood has faced multiple coaching changes and systems in a short period.
- His ability to read defenses and process plays is currently inadequate.
- The situation highlights the difficulties young quarterbacks face in adapting to new environments.
Evaluating Five-Star Recruits
What are the implications of recruiting high-profile players?
The pressure and expectations on five-star recruits can lead to challenges in their development and performance, raising questions about the value of such investments.
- Recruiting five-star players involves significant financial and developmental risks.
- Progress for young players is not always linear, and expectations can lead to mental strain.
- The market dynamics around high-profile recruits complicate their development.
Game Predictions and Team Performance
What are the predictions for upcoming college football games?
Predictions vary for upcoming games, with discussions on team performance and potential upsets, particularly focusing on Texas and Ole Miss.
- Predictions are influenced by recent team performances and injuries.
- There is a debate on whether Texas can bounce back against Ole Miss.
- The unpredictability of college football makes game outcomes difficult to forecast.
Transcript
0:00 Welcome back to the Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine three times a week during the season, twice a week during the off-season. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and X at Audible Show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.
0:38 >> Welcome back to the latest edition of the Audible presented by Trader Joe's. I'm Bruce Feldman joined as always by my colleagues from The Athletic Ralph Russo and Stu Mandel. we are going to be giving out our picks as well as upset specials. lots of quarterback news to kind of dig into in in that and also we'll get into some news but the top line item Ralph we have a 24 team playoff headed our way. what's the latest?
1:09 >> Sure, late last week we had negotiations kind of winding down with ESPN and the CFP. By Friday we had numbers to put on this. I said "Nearing a deal" is is the best way you can describe it which is essentially just hey there's a lot of lawyering need to do, right? You talk >> But we had graduated from nearing a deal to they have reached a deal. >> Exactly. an in a a preliminary agreement, a handshake deal, an informal agreement, however you want to word that, they have it sort of set up and but again there's multiple contracts, multiple billion-dollar organizations that need to that need to sign off on this so that takes a little bit.
1:54 The magic number is $345 million, Stu. That's that's the the number ESPN is going to pay for the new games, but it should also be noted, as we have reported, about 140 million of that is already being paid out by ESPN. So, they have a bit of a discount because they already pay for conference championship games that are going away. The playoff games will replace the conference championship games. So, ESPN already had a credit here. And which is one of the reasons why ESPN was not just a favorite to do this, but was the big favorite to to nail the to to to land this package. and it's not particularly shocking that they're not going to go to market cuz I don't think there was a ton of value in the market.
2:46 So, Stu, this is not necessarily and again, official announcement, great that's always a great sign for your new your new exciting product that there just wasn't that much interest from the other TV networks. The problem, Stu, is the value in the playoff is the at the end. I mean, you know this, right? It's the championship games and the semifinal games. That's what the other networks are dying to get into. For the other networks, these first round games, mm that's a mets, right?
3:18 It's not exactly like the the most valuable stuff. But it also there are times when something has more value to you, Stu, or to you, Bruce, than it does to me. And that's what ESPN is in. It the stuff has more value to ESPN cuz they want to control it all, Stu. So, >> you know, and I wrote this, I think, on Thursday is this is a rare moment in college sports where they are not doing it to get rich. There is not a big pot of gold at the end of this. By the time you divide up By the time you subtract the 250 million or so that they owe back in conference championship games when you include the other networks.
3:58 And then you divide that extra 100 million, 50 million, 75 million, whatever it is among 138 schools, like that's that's pocket change. Just something to keep in mind for what you said, Ralph. So, back when I used to work at ESPN, there was a short stretch. It was probably I don't know, 3 years or so where we, ESPN, did not have the post season really. We had a bunch of bowl games and we had the Rose Bowl, but that was it. Fox had the national title game. And I remember we had our big offsite at the beginning of the year.
4:31 And we had like focus like our groups were all broken into like how can we frame it so we're still the home of college football? And how can we make the Rose Bowl bigger? And it was just kind of we're all twisting ourselves in knots to try to claim that ESPN is still the home of college football. And the point being, I think as much as anything else, yes, ESPN has liked to get in the business of getting a Super Bowl and getting the NFL and being more of a partner with the NFL and has other sports.
5:01 But, you know, we didn't have, even though we had a ton of college basketball, it was CBS who had, you know, the tournament. And so, I think it was such a badge of honor, you know, the worldwide leader in sports to have that, to not have everything when it comes to college football, I think is something that was not unfathomable, but I think that was such a source of pride that I think in regard to, look, ESPN with the sublicensing deal they did a couple, you know, a couple of years ago, wasn't going to be to Fox. It was going to be to TNT. So, I think that's also part of you know, the ESPN ethos as it relates to to trying to keep everything and making sure that this is of such value to us that maybe more so than it is to other TV partners.
5:48 >> Totally nailed it. The other thing is ESPN doesn't have as much financial commitment to the NFL where other networks have to have a little make sure that they are holding on some cash heading into the next few years when and the NFL does start coming up. The other thing is too yes, it's not for a big windfall of playoff TV rights money, but they do think that there's money in the banana stand to tap into. And it's the money that will come from more engaged fan bases locally on campus throughout November.
6:23 Stadiums that will have more people in them that through Again, we poopoo although do we really care about eight and four Minnesota? But if eight and four Minnesota has more people showing up like there's money there. It's just not directly through the CFP. It's more through campus. Let me throw this at both of you guys. I tried watching the playoff Excuse me, I tried watching the games this weekend. A monster weekend, an awesome weekend of college football.
6:52 Constantly bringing into my mind, what if this was a 2014 playoff? Would I still be enjoying this as much? And I I must admit there was a there was a tinge of sadness, right? It's no longer a tightrope walk from the regular season to the post season to playing for a national championship, right? It's now more of like well, even now it's more of a plank walk and by next year it'll be like a sidewalk walk, right? Like you won't the balancing act won't be tried quite as treacherous. But I do I don't know like I I found myself feeling a little sad that we might miss that, but I also found myself thinking like I'm living in the moment. I love this game because it's a great game at BYU and it's It's scene and it still feels like it's sort of like living for the game as opposed to living for the consequences of the game. I'll I'll throw it out to either of you. You guys can sort out which one which one which one of you wants to talk.
7:53 >> you go first cuz I think you were coming from the same perspective as Ralph, and then I'll kind of >> Yeah, you know, I make fun of you make fun of me if you want, but like I was pretty sad Thursday, Friday, you know, dealing with like I can't believe they actually are doing this. And then even Saturday morning going into that first window of games, I still hadn't really shaken it. And then the game started, and like you said, Ralph, like you're enjoying the games themselves.
8:18 yeah, I thought about it, and I think first of all this is everybody's so black and white about things. This is not even for somebody me who thinks this is a terrible idea. It's not well, then everybody's going to stop watching college football, right? The people who say they'll be resting the starters in Ohio State-Michigan. No, they won't. They're They're those big rivalry games will still be big rivalry games. where I think you What I think you lose though is a little bit of urgency.
8:44 So, Texas is in full-on, you know, crisis mode right now cuz this team that everybody thought would contend for the national championship just suffered their second loss. And if you put yourself in the headspace of next year oh, they lost to Florida. That's a bad loss. But they could lose two more games. You know, like it's it's not a crisis at all. you know, Alabama, same thing, right? Like now they're they're right on the teetering right on the edge. Not anymore. So, that doesn't mean like I would watch that same Ohio State-Indiana game and still be oh my gosh, one foot out of bounds. That was crazy, right? The Florida State two Hail Mary's, that's crazy. But I just don't think it will feel as urgent. Like Ohio State was on the verge of getting their second loss, which would have been a really big deal.
9:32 If they'd gotten their second loss next year eh Doesn't mean you're not going to watch the game. Doesn't mean you're not going to enjoy the game. It's just not It's going to feel muted. And so that being the case, like there's not going to be if if if I if my worst fears come true and this has a really negative effect, it's not going to be immediate. It's not like all of a sudden next year the games that got 10 million viewers are now getting 3 million viewers or stadiums are half full. It's not going to be that immediate. It's going to be a gradual erosion. By the way, I hope I'm wrong. I hope I'm totally wrong, but it's hard to imagine the intensity will still be there. Like maybe somebody like we're all going to you the three of us are going to watch all the games, but like somebody who is like a couple notches down who maybe watches two or three games on a Saturday might only watch one.
10:22 Something to that extent, Bruce. >> first of all, I have this this imagery now of you on Friday of the like Charlie Brown slumped shoulders walking over with the little stick with his laundry tied up in a bag. >> Pretty much. That's pretty much how I felt. And so did a lot of people, by the way. >> It's and and I'm heartsick for you, Stu. But I disagree to this standpoint. To me, one of the like holy crap moments of Saturday had nothing to do, at least in my mind, of are they going to make the playoff or not? Are they in jeopardy or not? Was Auburn beating Georgia. That was not a oh my god, now Georgia's on the brink of that ruined their season.
11:00 It was the Auburn game It was the Auburn way they won. You know, and I think when it comes to Texas, and Texas is a really and we'll talk more about Texas a little later, but Texas is a fascinating team to me, you know, because as we said in the last show, they have this one terrific win over Texas. And it's kind of hard for me to think they could go eight and four. And if they're nine and three, they probably still make the playoff. But just to see how they lost, you know, I still think there's something about, like, all right, if you still make the playoff, but you're making the playoff like that I think the chances of the team that backed into the playoff and winning the title, whether it's Ohio State, which was kind of like a a little bit of a unicorn situation...
11:49 but I just don't think there's, like, last year it felt like Oklahoma and Alabama both backed into the playoff. They had no chance of winning the playoff realistically, right? They weren't Miami, you know, who had won good games, you know, slipped up at mid-season and then kind of cruised the rest of the way, like and barely got in. That's why I think I think we're maybe overstating it a little bit, Ralph, about just the ramifications. Again, I'm not saying, Stu, you feel how you feel and I would totally respect that. I also think somehow you're in a unique position where you know, you do this Sunday Sunday morning column or Saturday night column, which is like incredibly analytical on how everything fits and all this stuff.
12:33 The average fan, and even like probably the average person who's sitting in the press box, I don't really think their wiring is as such to think so much about that where they're detached from, like, I'm sitting there with other, you know, football people and you're just like, "Man, Auburn just knocked off Georgia." How did that happen? >> Yeah. >> You know, like to me that's just and that's not related to what you're saying. >> goal, like it's it's I don't think that's going to be >> Yeah, that's why I feel like >> the little overstated to to say that, maybe.
13:03 >> I I also feel like the landscape is changing with these massive conferences and massive teams stacked into these conferences, mostly looking at you, SEC, to a extent Big Ten, where you're going to have so many teams lose so many more games that we are going to get; we are, we might recreate that urgency. We might be underestimating the urgency because you you're saying, oh, well, they're only lose they'll they'll win they'll go nine and three and waltz in. Hmm, maybe it's going to be a lot harder to go nine and three. Maybe I again, I still have a feeling that Texas in a 20 I still have >> with in the Big Ten and SEC.
13:47 Like I'd ask you guys this, don't you think so you know, you see anytime this topic comes up people say, here's what it would have looked like last year, right? Here's it look look at the last five years of playoff rankings. This is what it would have looked like. I think it fundament the committee will change, too, because 13 to 24 matter now. >> A thousand percent >> think it'll be just like right now, sorry if I'm keep cutting you off.
14:14 >> No, it's okay. >> Right now, right? Like last year, they said nine and three Alabama trumps 11 and two BYU. The year before it was nine and three Alabama was ahead of 10 and two Miami. Why would that one game difference not keep going right down the rankings to the point where all of the eight and four Big Ten and SEC teams are ahead of all the nine and three Big 12 and ACC teams? >> I I would suggest that maybe there it becomes harder to go eight and four.
14:40 I I still think there would be a crisis in Texas right now if it was a 2014 playoff and they were sitting there with two losses with a very distinct possibility that they might not even get to eight wins. Like if you the idea that we're sitting here going, well, Texas would be fine. They would just finish eight and four. Really? You sure they're going to get to eight and four? I I, we we, will not know until we get there.
15:05 But I do wonder, if this the general sense of urgency, we have not grasped fully what the, what the new world is with stacked conferences, flattening talent, dispersed talent, to the idea that maybe there will still be a certain sense of her. I think we're going to have the same exact sense of urgency, but I also I'm not sure we're going to have, you know, the it's going to be exactly It's just going to all go out the window. I I I just I'm not sure it's going to completely all go out the window. Well, whether we're right, whether we're wrong, I don't know, but I couldn't help but notice that, you know, I think it was Thursday, right, that we were that it was the Pete Thamel tweet, and then I think we were the ones who said 95% there, like, was the moment that college football Twitter was like, I can't believe they're doing this.
15:56 And it felt like a funeral. And it's a Friday, too. I mean, yes, there are I What I've noticed is the people who are most for it are fans of teams in the Big 12 and ACC who feel like, finally, we have a chance to get more than one team in. But rat national college football people who follow the whole sport, people who, frankly, some of those fans, too, like, it was all anger. And I just I I cannot believe that's the main reason I can't believe they're doing this is that you are going to transform your whole sport over something that nobody asked for.
16:33 Nobody asked for this. Like, BCS, they spent six public spent 16 years clamoring for four. It got to four, almost immediately everybody started clamoring for eight. And they skipped past that, right? They went to 12. And 12, as I keep saying, they finally found the sweet spot. They finally found the spot where people think it's not too small and it's not too big. And now they're blowing it up. And and people of all ages and all fan bases, they're mad. So, this will continue to come up. I will I am purposely trying to avoid my own rants. I'm going to let the people speak for me as a whole. We have to take a break, and when we come back, some QB controversies.
17:19 And we're back. We're going to get to our picks in a bit. Two of the teams that have big games this weekend are Michigan and Texas. They're also two of the teams that have had a lot of quarterback drama this season. And Texas is more ongoing right now, guys. it has created an interesting discussion that we've had offline a little bit about you had two five-star like the bluest of blue-chip recruits, one in Bryce Underwood earlier in his development cuz it's year two and he was playing as a true freshman. Then there was Arch Manning at Texas who sat and waited and we thought he was going to be ready and there were some growing pains last year and now there's even more growing pains it feels like and Sark is struggling with all of it. guys, Stu, I know you have not been a believer in Arch or really a believer in Bryce Underwood.
18:12 how do you think this is going to play out first in Austin? >> Well, first of all, I put the two of them in different categories. Like Arch has proven to be not the second coming, inconsistent. He did beat Ohio State. He has had his moments. A&M last year. Bryce Underwood has just really There's no other way to put it. He's just been bad. And >> He also was playing as a true freshman, has had two two quarterback coaches, two two different systems. It's way different. I'm not making excuses for Bryce Underwood. Bryce Underwood's in a way different situation. Like it's hard I don't want to say he was set up to fail, but this is a this is a bad situation in terms of, you know, he's basically been the quarterback there for like 16 games and you had two different head coaches, two different offensive coordinators, two very different systems.
19:01 I don't deny that probably had a factor, but this is a case where you can just see like he can't read defenses, he can't process. if not for the Larry Ellison factor, he probably would have been benched earlier. Sark, you asked about Texas, Sark said, "I think there's no about no This was on Monday. I think there's no doubt about it. Arch can play better for us. He's our starter. I need to see a better version of Arch Manning."
19:28 Correct me if I'm wrong, guys, that's about as critical as he's been of him. >> Yeah, I'll say that. >> defending him. >> Right, but nonetheless, that's not overly I don't know. I feel like we may have heard We may have heard something similar on Saturday. So, I I don't want to say if this is the most critical. I mean, he said on Saturday, "We need to evaluate everything including the quarterback." So, but you're right. >> that thing if his name was Joe Smith, you know, like >> Right. Right. Right. Last week he said Last week >> week ago he was saying, "Hey, if this guy had another name, people would be praising him."
20:04 >> And there's been some reports out there that KJ Lacey, the backup quarterback, is taking more first team snaps. Sark commented today that he always takes first team snaps. So, I I don't know what that means. And what I would also say is if if you think the backup quarterback is the solution, and I tend to defer a lot to the coaches here, they see that guy in practice. If he was better, he would be playing.
20:32 If he was clearly better, he would be playing. This goes back to, you know, you talked about Nico, and well, UCLA won't miss Nico that much cuz he wasn't playing that better. He was the guy they were playing though. So, how good is the guy behind Tim if if if he still keeps playing? So, that's where my my my >> Can I give a counterpoint to that? >> Of Of course. >> I'm not saying this is true all the time, but there have been a lot of times where you know, the guy he doesn't practice the way he plays in the game, right? How many times have we seen a guy who they didn't feel comfortable putting him in yet cuz he doesn't look great at practice and then they put him in in the game and something about the moment he shines and vice versa, right? Maybe Bryce Underwood always looks better than Tommy Garne practice and then he gets in the game and he can't handle the moment.
21:20 Like that we hear about stories like that all the time. >> Trinidad Chambliss exists, right? Like that was, I mean, those stories do happen; but I, I tend to think that they happen we we mythologize them happening more that if we just get our backup quarterback in there, he's going to unlock everything. And I, I tend to be a little more skeptical, and I think, "Hey man, if you're going to your backup, your season might be screwed." That means like the the guy you expected to carry you can't and the guy who now isn't as good as going to be expected to be suddenly as good. But you're right, it's it's it's it's a different path for every five-star, Bruce, and we're seeing two of them there and the fact of the matter is just cuz you're a five-star doesn't mean you're going to hit.
22:06 >> In fact, it definitely doesn't. I mean we went back and did this research I don't know five or six years ago about the hit rate of five-star quarterbacks. It was optimistically about 30% of five-star guys. What's your definition of hit? Hit means you're like at least an an all-conference first team all-conference quarterback. You're a five-star, there's very few of them. You should be at that level, right? So, who delivered? Trevor Lawrence, absolutely. he is you know, he was a terrific you know, highly rated guy. He definitely lived up to it.
22:42 >> Caleb Williams? >> Caleb Williams, yes. Bryce Young, yes. >> Yeah. Bryce Young, yes. >> Justin Fields, yeah. >> You know, but then you start going through the list. DJU, absolutely not. Quinn Ewers, no. >> You know, Spencer Rattler. >> You have to be I think if you're a five-star, you were a guy who are at least a first-team all-conference quarterback. You are a upper-level guy. You're not a seventh-round pick. >> Right. >> I mean, you are like It's the difference between a four-star and a five-star guy, right? And so, >> And there's guys who don't even do that, right? There's the same people >> There's the Malachi Nelsons like you never even played football. You never even >> Ricky Town, one of the USC fans will remember the same thing. At one point going into his senior year, he was the number one overall recruit.
23:29 >> That's a That's a good pull. Ricky Town is a good pull. >> Yeah, I mean, there's plenty like look, our friend, you know, Max Browne was a huge recruit. it didn't work out great. Wasn't mean he was a disaster, but like it it happens, right? And there's all the QB book. >> You cover Elite 11 every year. How? Because this is not the 1970s where you're throwing like a film projector up and try like they see these the recruiting guys see them in camps, in person, Elite 11 obviously. They have no shortage of opportunities to evaluate these guys. The only thing though, right, is this is the one position more than any other that isn't all about physical talent.
24:12 >> Well, a lot of them are not all about like, you know, I use this you know, you know, example yes or two days ago on our last episode. We're talking about, you know, Tennessee has a three-star running back who's really, really good. Well, it's like I don't think he's blazing fast and he wasn't super big, but his vision is like elite. His patience, like those are more intangible qualities. >> More so with the quarterbacks though.
24:37 This stuff that the intangible stuff is way more valuable with the quarterbacks. >> It is. It No, it definitely is, but it's also harder to see. You have guys who are fantastic in seven-on-seven. You have very different circumstances they're put into in terms of like how they can manage things. You know, I had a note in my what we're hearing column from Eric Morris about Drew Messemaker. And I was like, when do you He clearly was was it was a excellent evaluation. He was like, we took him as a fifth string quarterback. We didn't know what he was going to do. I didn't know until I started seeing him in scrimmages and live reps in practice where all of a sudden he goes from five to four and four to three and maybe we got to put him in more. And we still don't know until he's actually in out there. You just don't know in terms of that. Like the guys who are Cam Newton is such a small, you know, percentage of somebody who's so gifted physically, right? I mean, look, Joe Burrow is one of the most impressive college players I've ever seen.
25:42 Urban Meyer, who has a you know, a great track record as a college coach, didn't go with him. Now, he went to a quarterback who was also a talented passer in Justin Fields. Not I'm Justin Fields, sorry. >> Dwayne Haskins. >> Yeah, Haskins. Yeah. Now, Haskins was not the athlete that Burrow was in terms of like some of the things Burrow can do, how he operates, all of those things. But it's really hard. Like, you know, again, LSU beat Cincinnati out to get Joe Burrow. You know, and he's arguably the greatest quarterback any of us have ever covered in college football. It's really hard, I think, to nail losing time. By the way, Joe Burrow didn't look like Joe Burrow the first year at >> Yeah, I don't think that was I think it's a revision of history to think Ohio State made the wrong choice there cuz in the 2018 season Dwayne Haskins was awesome. He was, but I think what was 4,000 something yards and he played himself into a high draft pick.
26:33 >> What was different and Burrow told me this at one point was, you know, that's whatever 74-72 game against Texas A&M, you know, Joe Brady was not there yet, but it was like the stuff that he was the way he thrived was like, I don't want max protect. I want everybody out. I'll figure it out. It gives me more space. All of it. Like certain guys are wired in a certain way where I think, you know, every every button is checked and it fits for them, right? And I think that's the other part that's really hard to get at is, yeah, this guy could be really talented. Like who knew if Drew Allar went to Ohio State instead of Penn State or if, you know, this guy went to USC instead of Texas. I mean, Trintin Chambliss, nobody may have ever heard of him if Austin Simmons doesn't get hurt and now he could be a first round pick just because Lane didn't know. I I'm sure Lane knew he was good. Lane didn't know he had this, you know, right? It's just It's just really It's a really fickle process.
27:33 >> And and a perfect example right now. We all wanted to crown Keelon Russell, who was a five-star a couple of weeks ago, and we had him in our Heisman straw poll. And two weeks later, kids I, might I might suspect the kid's going to be great and he's going to be a first-round draft pick, but you know what? Progress isn't linear and the last couple of weeks he's looked like a guy as a first-year starter. It looks like it it's it's not all coming together perfectly for him. There's There's a There's a question behind this conversation, too, about like the value of these guys, especially in a world where you have to pay for them, right?
28:07 Should you be paying so much for the five-star? Should you pay up for the five-star and how much you should should you dedicate your roster budget and then, you know, that's that's a hard thing to pin on, too, but it raises the It elevates the conversation and elevates the urgency on these guys hit it. >> It also elevates the like what goes in their head, right? Like this is a story I'm going to bring up a name that, you know, none of us have probably heard all year, but at one point he was a hot name because of all the off-field stuff. That was Jaden Rashada. Jaden Rashada becomes a big commodity because he has an agent floating wild numbers out there to try to raise the market of what people are paying. How does Jaden Rashada as a whatever he is, 17 or 18-year-old, now handle all of that? That's why I said it's way it's going to be way harder for the five-star guys cuz now they are such big commodities of how they deal with everything else. I'm not saying if Bryce Underwood was not did not get a $12 million deal all of a sudden it's like Larry Ellison's wife is involved and all this other stuff doesn't up your inner circle and create all kinds of other headaches. But it's very different than Tom Brady's process and Tom Brady about like being the fist string guy and just trying to have the best one rep. If you get it, you better do it. And then be in the guy who gets in just cuz Mo Lewis, you know, blasts Drew Bledsoe and now all of a sudden, "Oh god, we got to play this guy." And we got the pictures of him where he looks, you know, like anemic, you know, at the combine. it's a lot of stuff that is very humbling. And I think that's the opposite of of being the commodity guy.
29:51 All right, we need to take a break cuz we got to do some picks. Okay, and we're back. We're going to get to our picks. A little update on the standings. The records still stink. Ralph's just doesn't stink as much as us. We all went three and three last week in our picks. So right now Ralph is in the lead at 15-15 and one. Stu and I are tied for third at 13-17 and one. When it comes to the upset special, I am leading. I am four and four. Stu is second at three and four and Ralph is dead last at one and six. Guys, we got to do better than this. All right, Stu.
30:28 we talked a little bit about Bryce Underwood. We'll see who Kyle Whittingham decides to play this week cuz they got the defending national champs, number five Indiana, a seven-point favorite against Michigan. How you feeling about the Wolverines? I mean, first of all, if Bryce Underwood comes out there to start the game, the Michigan fans are going to boo relentlessly. I I I have to believe it'll be Tommy Carr. This is a tricky one. It opened at eight and a half.
30:52 And my I was immediately like Michigan. Because let's be honest, Indiana's not been blowing people out this year, right? Then it goes down to seven and it's huh, that's a lot tougher. Can I pick a push? I will I will take the Hoosiers to cover and bounce back from the Ohio State loss. Ralph? >> I same exact deal. I was absolutely ready to pick Michigan just to cover this thing. now I find myself thinking that Indiana defense is pretty good. What is Michigan going to do to score against it?
31:26 I will sort of reluctantly take Indiana here because that number came down. figuring they can get to, you know, 21-13, something along those lines. By the way, scores offense seems to be down all across the the big-time conferences. >> I am going to take Indiana. Although, Michigan does have good cornerbacks and I think they could match up decent with the two really good receivers that Indiana has, but I will stay with the Hoosiers. I'd say more confidence in them right now.
32:01 I will go on now to LSU, number 18. They are an eight and a half point favorite at Auburn. Tigers are obviously coming off that huge win at Georgia. Stu, can they make it two in a row? >> That's another one that moved quite a bit. it was LSU by a touchdown and now it's eight and a half and that is a big number because of exactly what Ralph said, everybody's scrunched together in the SEC. so, I'm going to take Auburn to cover. LSU to win, Auburn to cover, close game.
32:32 LSU's been in several close games already this year and it's gone on the other, you know, it's gone against them. This one goes for them, Ralph. >> Yeah, I feel like SEC home dogs probably a a pretty good way to go. my instinct is LSU is a little outside of the teams that we have been talking about a lot in the SEC, but maybe in a few weeks they are more embedded into this race and we're talking about them as potential playoff team and things even though they've got two losses already. So, again, we talk about that tightrope. They have to walk the tightrope the rest of the way.
33:09 I also man, I don't know if Auburn's going to get those three turnovers and miss field goal block field goal that they needed to beat Georgia last week. It was a great win for Auburn, a a great moment for Alex Golish's program in in year one to sort of have a little proof of concept there, but I also think that this could be a spot where LSU is just a lot better than Auburn. So, I'll it's a lot of points, but I'll take LSU. Maybe a little come down weekend for Auburn, too. We've seen a lot of that in the SEC, right? Great win, come back next week, not so great.
33:44 >> All right, I'm going to take Auburn. LSU is both losses came on the road. They've seen some really good running quarterbacks. They did well against Marcelo Reed. Now they got Byron Brown who's a load to try to bring down. I'm going to go with the Auburn Tigers here. I wouldn't be surprised they actually won this game. I know it's a big number, but I mean, I think there's going to be a rush of confidence coming out of what they just had. I think that place gets underrated for how loud it gets and how raucous it can get.
34:15 Sam Laporta played well last week, but again, this is a this is a team that did a did a pretty good job against a very talented physical team. I think they could get in there, especially if the LSU offensive line doesn't play better. So, >> Can I just say one quick thing, Bruce? If if LSU has three losses a little more than midway through the season on Sunday, we are going to be talking a lot about LSU on Sunday.
34:38 >> All right, guys. We're going to go to the Big 12. Number eight Texas Tech has been playing a little better, a little more impressive. 10 and 1/2 point favorites. They go to Cincinnati. Obviously, there was a huge subplot this offseason involving the former Bearcats quarterback Brendan Sorsby, but he will not be in the game. But, let's affectionately call it the Sorsby Bowl as Ralph dubbed it. Ralph, I'm going to go to you first since you coined that.
35:02 How we feeling about the Bearcats? They get a little revenge on the on the program that kind of dragged them through the mud to some extent? >> Yeah, you know, there's a lot of folks who are, you know, have cactus in cacti in their Twitter handles who are very still very very upset about Cincinnati and that they felt like they, Cincinnati, kind of did Texas Tech dirty with the Sorsby situation, that they knew all about the Sorsby, Sorsby's gambling problem. Like, there's no evidence to back that up.
35:32 >> Yeah, the NCAA cleared them. >> NCAA cleared Cincinnati, but nonetheless, there was a lot of folks in Lubbock who are not pleased about Cincinnati. Now, does that impact this game? Not necessarily sure that's the that's the case, but I also know Cincinnati's defense is very bad. Texas Tech's offense has been coming around. Texas Tech looked a little bit more like last year's Texas Tech last week against a an Arizona State team that is not very good. I know it's a road game, but I think Texas Tech is is is sort of coming into its own here and will unleash holy hell on Cincinnati.
36:13 >> Stew? To to your point, Ralph, yes, Brett Cody Campbell. It got so nasty that it came out that Cody Campbell texted Brett Yormark that he had receipts on Cincinnati. And in the spirit of not publicly airing family disputes, somebody should inform coach Satterfield that Texas Tech has gone out of its way to not drag Cincinnati on the Swords B deal. We have plenty of receipts, and he wants no part of it. This is not a fight he should start.
36:44 >> That wasn't recent, right? Just a Just a >> Just to point that out. >> Yeah, that was way back when we were actually dealing with the Swords B mania and talking about Swords B almost on every show. >> So, the receipts come to Cincinnati this weekend to Nippert Stadium. It's going to be nasty, and I am taking the Bearcats not just to cover, to pull the upset. >> Wow. >> Nice. >> you Tech is going to come back to earth at some point, and this seems like the logical place for it to happen.
37:12 >> Cool. Wow, I feel I'm guilty saying this, but I think Texas Tech's going to win and cover. So, >> Guilty of what? >> Cuz you you you you just basically dropped the mic there after your Cody Campbell research. And >> Well, I might be dead wrong, so. >> Okay. >> lately the So far the the record indicates that I'm wrong more than I'm right. >> All right, guys, one of the best games of the weekend, Ole Miss riding off a big win. Trina Chambers playing at a high level. going to the aforementioned Texas Longhorns.
37:46 Longhorns are struggling guys, and they are still a three and a half point favorite in Austin. Stu, do you think we got a bounce back game from Sark and Arch and whoever else he's going to play? >> Possibly, but how do you How do you How do you go against Ole Miss at this point when they're rolling and Texas is reeling, and Trina Chambers is coming to town? And by the way, I mentioned this on the show on Sunday, but Colin Simmons looks like he's going to be out for at least a few weeks. So, give me the Rebels.
38:19 >> Yeah, Sark wouldn't confirm a report that Simmons has a high ankle sprain, but it also he said wait for the availability report which comes out in a couple of days. it but it didn't look good. I will do the thing that I will probably get burned on, which is I think Texas seems to be due. All the power rankings and metrics are that's why the line is what it is because a lot of the metrics are leaning Texas here.
38:49 Ole Miss's defense was great last week, but it hasn't been great throughout the season. Listen, I picked Texas to get get right against Florida and that didn't happen. I'm getting sent to Austin this weekend, which I love. I I will indulge in the Tex-Mex and barbecue. Yeah, Tex-Mex and barbecue. I'm all sent I'm all up for that. but I also think that, you know, I'm probably going more because of what happens if Texas does lose a third straight game. I will take Texas here. I I I I will go but with the numbers instead of my head and heart. And and and and and go with Texas to to get back on track.
39:31 >> I feel like whenever Ralph shows up somewhere, you know, the drags end up happening, right? You went to Western Michigan, that didn't go great for those Broncos. >> I'm the Grim Reaper is what you're trying to say. Yes. Yeah. >> I think I think Sark's going to take a newspaper if he can find one and just backhand you in the face and be like, "Hey, go back to Queens, Ralph." I'm going to go with Ole Miss pretty much for all the reasons Ralph said.
39:56 He just was like whether whether he was trying to do it or not, he was basically pointing out like like I felt fairly confident about the Rebels until Ralph started talking. Now I feel very confident about them. Last week wasn't a get right game. It was a get wrong game. It got worse. Doesn't mean that they don't have talent enough to to recover. Something is clearly wrong with that, you know, with what's going on there. I don't think it's going to get fixed this week and I think Ole Miss is good enough to take advantage of it. So, I'll take the Rebels. All right, we're going to go to a big game in the Big 12. Top 15 match up, number 14 Houston at number 10 undefeated the Utah Utes are a 6 and 1/2 point favorite. Stew, you're big in the Beehive State. You think the Utes stay undefeated and win this?
40:45 >> I think the Utes will win, but I think it's going to be a great game, a close game, so I will take Houston to cover. >> I am going to go I feel like I've been underestimating Houston this season a lot, so I'm going to pivot and stop doing that. and I'll take the Cougars to absolutely, I'll just take the I'll just take the points here. I don't like the way Utah's run defense looked last week against Colorado.
41:12 Connor Weigman's playing tremendous ball and again, I just feel like I've been sliding Willie Fritz's team, so let me take those points and expect a really good game and we'll see what happens in terms of who wins or loses, Bruce. >> Yeah, I'm going to take the points, too. I'm I've we've seen a lot of Houston in our studio this season, very impressed by not just Weigman, but all their skill guys. They've been great with their portal additions.
41:36 I would not at all be surprised if they went in there and won this game cuz I think they played they played more games against really good teams this season. So, but I feel pretty confident that the the Coogs are going to get out of there at least and make us look smart cuz it's too big of a spread. All right, guys, as we said, Ralph has been awful picking upset specials. He has a chance to I don't want to say redeem himself, but let's see if he can finally get a get right game on this side of it, Ralph.
42:05 Give us something. >> Yeah, so I feel like I put the malarkey on Navy at the beginning of the season. I wrote this big article about how they were the favorites coming into the season and they were talking playoff and it's been a rough season for the midshipman. They've lost a and not only not only have they lost a bunch of games. I think they're three and three coming into this game or two and three or two and four coming into this game.
42:33 They've lost a bunch of games by one score. It's it's a five-point loss, a seven-point loss, a three-point loss. It's been a brutal year. However, they're an underdog against North Texas this weekend. I believe two and a half. I think Navy has it's not like they haven't played they they played terribly. Their defense hasn't been good, but I'll take Navy to get off the schneid, get a big win in the American. I don't think they're going to the playoff this year. I don't think they're winning the conference, but I just feel I just have to come clean here. This is just a mea culpa. I feel responsible for Navy's terrible season cuz I again, I am the Grim Reaper.
43:11 >> Do you know the the mush reference? >> Of course, yeah. Of course, I am definitely a mush this year. >> the bathroom, Ross. Got to get him right. Sorry, Stu. Go ahead. >> This was a rare week where there were several that I considered. It wasn't like a a mad hunt for an upset, but there's one that's just like reaching out to me, begging, you have to do this. USC on the road, guys. We know how that usually goes. Unless they're playing an awful Penn State team, they are a three-point favorite in Madison, Camp Randall.
43:44 Badgers. Got to take the Badgers, Bruce. >> Jump around. >> Guys, do you think there's anything to I don't want to say this is this should not be a trap game for them, but they do have a kind of a wounded Ohio State team coming in there on Halloween. They just had a bye week. >> Isn't every USC game a trap game? >> okay. >> Jacob Ullman, our friend at Fox, is going to be listening to this. He's going to give me so much crap. They're 6 and 1. Why do I keep disrespecting them?
44:11 I just I think it's one of those things where I will trust Lincoln Riley when he gives me a reason to trust him. >> I have like it's not just Jacob. I have like two other guys who are like bosses of mine at Fox who are also USC grads. I think they're semi-realistic about it. You know, I think they've been there enough where it's like, "Eh, we've seen this story again." I think they know it's not the Pete Carroll era, but you'll still probably get craps, too.
44:34 I struggle >> a little bit find that an upset here. And but I looked and I was like, "All right, Duke just had a kind of a tough loss against North Carolina." I think they're going to beat Virginia. These two teams are really close. I don't think there's a huge bit of difference. I am going to go with Manny Diaz getting a bounce back. And I feel like Virginia's been kind of like since the opener when they thumped NC State, I feel like it's been a little bit teetering. So, I'm going to take No.
45:00 It's been very eh. Very meh. The ACC, it's all meh, too. >> Ouch. Now you're going to get an angry text from Jim Phillips. >> Jim Phillips knows I am a huge fan of Jim Phillips. At least I was as as when he was the AD at Northwestern. I think he's got a tough hand to play right now in in his job at the ACC. guys, anything else to get into before we bounce out of here?
45:23 >> I think we hit a lot. and we've got more to get to later this week, guys. >> So, send your questions cuz the next week in the next episode we will get into the mailbag. Send your questions to the Audible pod at gmail.com. Remember, it the best question will get you a $24 Trader Joe's gift card. guys, remember to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel at Audible Show. And we will see you next time.
Summary
- A 24-team playoff format is nearing finalization, with ESPN expected to pay $345 million for the rights.
- The playoff's value may shift, with less urgency in regular-season games as more teams will qualify.
- Quarterback situations at Texas and Michigan are under scrutiny, with Arch Manning and Bryce Underwood facing criticism.
- The hosts debate the impact of the new playoff format on fan engagement and the overall intensity of college football.
- Predictions are made for several games, including Texas vs. Ole Miss and Michigan vs. Indiana, with varying confidence levels.
- Upset specials are discussed, with Navy and Wisconsin being highlighted as potential surprise winners.
- The podcast emphasizes the unpredictability of college football and the challenges of evaluating young quarterbacks.
Questions Answered
What is the purpose of the Audible show?
The Audible show aims to engage college football fans by providing regular content during the season and off-season, encouraging subscriptions and community building.
How will the new 24-team playoff format affect game intensity?
The new playoff format may reduce the urgency and intensity of regular-season games, leading to a gradual decline in viewership and attendance over time.
What challenges does Bryce Underwood face as a quarterback?
Bryce Underwood is struggling due to a lack of stability with coaching and systems, which affects his performance and development.
What are the implications of recruiting high-profile players?
The pressure and expectations on five-star recruits can lead to challenges in their development and performance, raising questions about the value of such investments.
What are the predictions for upcoming college football games?
Predictions vary for upcoming games, with discussions on team performance and potential upsets, particularly focusing on Texas and Ole Miss.