Section Insights
Introduction to Whimo
What is Whimo and why is it significant?
Whimo, formerly the Google self-driving car project, has expanded its operations significantly, now testing in cities like New York. The conversation highlights the excitement around its technology and the challenges it faces.
- Whimo is the independent successor to Google's self-driving car project.
- The company has expanded from three cities to five, including testing in New York.
- There are growing concerns about the implications of autonomous vehicles on jobs and public safety.
Safety Comparisons: Whimo vs. Human Drivers
How does Whimo's safety record compare to human drivers?
Whimo's data indicates that its autonomous vehicles are five to ten times safer than human drivers, based on millions of miles driven and insurance data.
- Whimo claims to be five times safer than human drivers based on their own data.
- An insurance study suggests Whimo is ten times safer than human drivers.
- The safety of autonomous vehicles is a key selling point for Whimo.
Product Offerings and Market Strategy
What are Whimo's plans for vehicle offerings and market expansion?
Whimo plans to offer a variety of vehicle types tailored to different customer experiences, aiming to scale both in the US and globally.
- Whimo is developing a range of vehicle types for different use cases.
- The company is focused on scaling its operations in various markets.
- Future offerings will cater to diverse customer needs, from casual rides to special occasions.
Data Privacy and Law Enforcement
How does Whimo handle data requests from law enforcement?
Whimo follows a strict legal process for sharing data with law enforcement, ensuring that requests are not overly broad to maintain community trust.
- Whimo is transparent about its data-sharing policies with law enforcement.
- The company prioritizes community trust in its operations.
- Whimo actively pushes back against broad data requests.
Autonomous Operations Explained
How does Whimo ensure its vehicles operate autonomously?
Whimo's vehicles operate fully autonomously without remote driving assistance, relying on onboard software to navigate and respond to road conditions.
- Whimo vehicles are designed to operate without remote human intervention.
- The technology allows cars to autonomously handle unexpected road conditions.
- The focus is on ensuring complete autonomy for safety and efficiency.
Transcript
0:00 Well, Casey, today we have a very exciting interview on the show. a conversation I've been eager to have for quite a long time. >> Yeah, this is one that we have been trying to make happen for months, and I'm so glad that we finally got to talk to somebody who runs a company that you and I are both taking advantage of quite a lot, I would say. >> Yes. Today, we are having on the show Tea Maakana. She is the co-CEO of Whimo.
0:22 that is of course the former Google self-driving car project that was spun out as an independent company and has been steadily scaling and pushing into more and more cities. Over the last year, Whimo has gone from operating just in San Francisco, Phoenix, and LA to having a small fleet in Austin and Atlanta. And just this past week, we learned that Whimo is beginning to test its cars on the streets of New York City. That's right, Kevin. But at the same time, as Whimo has expanded, there have been more and more questions about what it means that there are more autonomous vehicles on the road. Will they be taking jobs away from human drivers? And in June, five Whimos were destroyed during ICE protest. And some questions were raised about what sorts of camera footage Whimo was sharing with law enforcement. Yes, I think this is one of the most fascinating companies in all of technology right now. and I think the problems that they face are genuinely new and interesting and so I'm excited to talk to to Tahedra about it.
1:20 Let's bring her in. >> Thank you. Thanks so much for having me. >> We're so excited to talk to you and we have a bunch of questions for you. but I want to start with a question I saw online recently which is why did they call it Whimo and not Google Drive? >> Oh. so it was Google self-driving car project before it spun out from Google. And I wasn't here when the decision was made to name the company Whimo, but I was really surprised when I showed up for my interview that such a decision had been made because obviously it spent like all of these years being the Google self-driving car project and then we had to make the world figure out what in the heck did Whimo mean.
1:59 >> Another huge win for the Google marketing department. >> so Casey and I live here in the Bay Area. We're used to seeing Whimos all around. I don't even really notice them anymore. but this is not the experience that most people in America are having. give us a sense of where Whimo is in its expansion. which cities are you in? Where are you going next? >> Yeah, so right now we're right here in San Francisco, also Los Angeles as well as Phoenix where it all started. We're also in Atlanta as well as Austin and we've already announced that we'll be in Miami later this year and in Washington DC next year. beyond that, you know, we're really excited. You're going to start to see our cars in a lot of cities. if you think about our business as as far as scale, we're currently giving hundreds of thousands of rides every week. And, in all likelihood, by the end of next year, we will be offering around a million rides per week. So, if you just think about the scale of where we are now to then, and we're just really excited to start bringing this technology to more people. So you you recently announced you were doing around 250,000 paid rides a week. So you're saying like in a year or so you think that that's going to quadruple?
3:11 >> Yes. >> So I'm so interested in what's driving that. I was somebody who was going down to the Google Plex like 10 years ago to take rides in some of like the early prototype cars wondering when they would finally, you know, reach the sort of scale even that they're at now. It took a while and I remember the engineers down there telling me things like it's really hard for these things to drive in the rain. it's really hard for them to drive in the snow. every day they're seeing all sorts of interactions on the streets that they've never seen before.
3:41 so what what have you all managed to do that has kind of helped to figure out those problems and let you launch in more places? Yeah, I mean I think one first and foremost I think it's pretty well known now that we're like a super safety focused company and culture and so we put out years ago our safety framework and so everything has always been guided by that but on the other hand we have all of these really really brilliant engineers and in the early days of Whimo there was a decision made to put ML into the original tech stack and so what does that mean the machine has learned and over time humans have been identifying edge cases and feeding those back into the machine.
4:20 And we've been addressing those over time. And so I can remember, you know, a few years ago when it would rain hard in San Francisco, not something that would happen often, you know, we would pause service just to be sure it could be safe. And we don't do that anymore. We don't even think about it anymore. And so it's exciting to think about. Same thing once you see us in the Northeast, you'll start to see us tackling snow.
4:41 You know, that's not something that's currently in any of our cities. and then freeways is something that we've been super focused on. You know, we have a lot of employees posting their videos online. Employees have been taking rides in San Francisco as well as Phoenix and LA. but you're going to see freeways. >> You mentioned the safety data. I've spent a lot of time digging through the various reports that you all have put out and some of the third party studies.
5:05 but most people, I think, have concerns, especially if they've never ridden in a Whimo before, about safety. It feels weird to get into a car with no human driver in it. Give us a sense of what your current up-to-date safety research says about how safe these cars are versus say a human-driven car. >> Yeah, I think our last report was from 71 million fully autonomous miles and our data shows that we're five times safer than a human driver.
5:36 and and this is in incidents that would normally involve either injuries or airbag deployments, which is sort of the way the data is split. But that doesn't even take into account who's at fault. And I think normally when we think about accidents, it's not just did it happen, but it's also who caused it. And if you use insurance data as a proxy for who's at fault. and one of the largest insurance companies in the world, Swiss Reed, did this work on 25 million miles of autonomous data. And they actually found that we were 10 times better than humans. And so this kind of like whether it's five times or 10 times better than humans, I think, you know, we know that we're on this trajectory to make every community in which we drive safer. I I'll tell you like the way that I feel this is as somebody who lives in San Francisco, a city where a lot of people walk. I'm often a pedestrian. I'm often just walking down the street and there's Whimos cruising all over my neighborhood and there are a couple crosswalks I walk, you know, across every day. And when I see a human-driven car, I always have that moment of being a little bit scared of is this car going to slow down for me? When I see a Whimo, I'm like leaping into the cross like I have no doubt, you know, cuz I know you don't want to pay me what it would cost if you accidentally hit me. So that's how I >> that strange man you've seen leaping in front of cars on your security footage in the Castro. That's Casey.
6:54 No, this is an interesting question because u Malcolm Gladwell recently had a a very sort of interesting and funny take on this where he said that the reason that Whimo and self-driving cars in general will never work is because they're effectively too safe. that people are just going to start jumping out in front of these things, pedestrians won't sort of give them the right of way because they know that the minute that the the car sort of senses that they're in front of them, they're going to slow down and stop. So, he said basically there's sort of a a sort of deterrence effect that is lacking here because these cars are so safe that it's just going to end up clogging up streets and people be jaywalking all over the place. What do you make of that argument?
7:31 Yeah, you know, I think I think it's important to like ground this in the why, right? Like it's so depressing and no one likes to think about it, but 40,000 people killed on the roadways, >> you know, whether people are every year, >> every year, in the US. And so I think if you ground it in the status quo and you say to yourselves like okay let's imagine a world where yes some number of humans are going to create congestion by believing that these cars are part of a gamification opportunity but for a lot of people it's just going to make everything safer. And so that's really what we stay focused on. It's like do is the status quo acceptable? No. Can this technology improve road safety? Yes.
8:20 Can we figure out also how to like delight people who otherwise have other options? Yes. And so that's really what we're focused on. And I think the writers continue to give us the feedback that like this is meaningfully improving their lives. You know, we launched the teen product in Phoenix this year and it's just, you know, there's so much demand for working parents who just want a safer option for their kids. And so, you know, I think more people are going to benefit than not.
8:50 >> Now, tell us about this teen option cuz I don't have a teenager, but my understanding is that a lot of parents want to send their kids to school or soccer practice or whatever, and they want to use a Whimo, so they don't have to like get in the car and drive them all the way there. So, that's allowed. You're allowed to like send your kid unaccompanied in a in a Whimo >> in Phoenix. Yes. Got it.
9:09 >> Yeah. So, we rolled that out there. >> I was a teenager once. I had a car once. I did a lot of things in that car. Some of them maybe more legal than others. >> Like what? >> We don't have to get into it here, but what are like is are there different safety precautions with teenage riders? Do the cars drive safer? Are there restrictions? >> They do donuts to impress the teens? >> No. Like are teens doing teenage stuff in the way?
9:33 >> no. The everyone who rides in a Whimo complies with our policies. >> No, that's not true. No, but I mean seriously, like getting people safely from point A to point B is what we're focused on. And the Whimo driver doesn't behave any differently. with teenagers, you know, we still want to make sure you have on your seat belts and that you keep them fastened and you get from where you're going to where you're going. So, >> you know, I I think one reason why the why is very popular in the Bay Area is that it feels like a very fancy experience. You know, you're in these like souped up Jaguars with hundreds of thousands of dollars of sensors on them.
10:11 And so when you're like, you know, going to McDonald's, you feel like a king, you know, in in your Whimo. I'm wondering if you guys can keep that up, you know, because at some point you're going to want to turn a profit on these things. And I'm imagining you would love to make a much cheaper version of this car. So how are you thinking about the trade-offs that you make between getting to profitability and having this kind of premium experience? Yeah, I mean, think about us as in these early days. You're right. We have we used to have the Chrysler Pacifica minivans when we first launched in Arizona, then we moved into these JLRs. We then have the Zeer vehicles coming off the line. We have Ionics that'll follow. And then think about in the future state, we're going to have tiers of products available, right? Like there's going to be people who want the date night experience. that's going to be different than the people who have the soccer team experience. And so we're are thinking about these as like product offerings over time and that's how you'll see us scale not only in the US but globally.
11:15 there are going to be cities across Europe where we need a small vehicle form factor. So we're really thinking about not only the experience once you get in the car but what is that use case that people are most likely to adopt. M >> I want to ask about two bottlenecks or potential bottlenecks that I see coming for Whimo that are already starting to play out. one is the supply chain. Whimo has been interested in sourcing vehicles from a Chinese company Zeer for many years now. I believe you already have some of those up and running. but the Trump administration has not been a fan of bringing in Chinese electric vehicles. There are these new tariffs on top of some older tariffs that now make the tariff rate on a Chinese EV imported into America something like 250%.
12:02 How is Whimo dealing with that with its Zeer deal? Are you just swallowing the tariffs and the additional cost of this? Have you found some waiver or exemption or way around that? What is the current state of your Chinese supply chain? So we are like everyone else staying a breast of all of the developments that are happening with the administration. We have a number of the cars in the US already and we've been testing them and our plans haven't changed. We still plan to scale with those vehicles. At the same time like I mentioned earlier we have a whole host of OEM partners.
12:39 So, we are also focused on how to make sure we're scaling with them in order to have the right amount of diversification on this on this specific issue. But for all of our cars, we actually apply the Whimo driver at our facility which is run by Magna in Arizona, Mesa, Arizona. And so all of our technology happens here in the US. And that's really important, right? I mean at the end of the day what you know we think about a global supply chain is what pretty much every company has to deal with but where this technology was born where it's applied where it's understood is right here in the US. The other thing I wanted to talk about is some of the opposition that Whimo has been getting from unions in some of the cities where you all want to operate.
13:25 including New York City where the TWWU international president John Samuelson recently said New Yorkers be warned. Whimo will turn pedestrians into cannon fodder and will block streets for emergency responders. Whimo isn't ready for NYC streets, and the end goal is to replace rid share drivers, taxi drivers, and transit workers with robots. Obviously, this is not something unexpected. You all have faced opposition before from people who say you are coming into our cities and trying to replace all of our drivers with robots. But how do you respond to that complaint? And more generally, how do you think about the political opposition that you are facing?
14:04 I think you know I would point to next month actually October will mark 5 years since we removed the drivers from every Whimo vehicle in Arizona and there continue to be a host of people with driver jobs and we didn't take those jobs away. I think at the same time we're creating jobs, right? Like as I mentioned, we have, you know, people who are manufacturing and and integrating the Whimo driver onto automotive vehicles. We have we have fleet techs who are maintaining the fleets. You know, we have depot leaders as well as depot workers. and so there are jobs that are being created and there are jobs that will go away. I'm not I totally agree with that point. It's just not the case that they're all going to go away because of autonomous vehicles.
15:00 And I and I think just like I can agree that some jobs will change, I think, you know, hopefully they can agree that the road should be safer. >> Let's talk about another kind of opposition that we've seen to Whimo. in LA in June, you lost five Whimos during ICE protests and it seemed that there was a feeling that Whimos either were or could become a part of the surveillance state. So, what can you tell us about how Whimo interacts with law enforcement and whether these protesters are right to be concerned that if a Whimo drives by them, that footage could go straight to ice?
15:43 I think we didn't view what happened in Los Angeles as in any way targeted to Whimo specifically. I mean five Whimos were harmed but you know so was a lot a lot a lot of other property you know parking structures and other people's cars personally owned cars etc. And so we didn't think that that's related. I think on the question of, you know, when and how law enforcement gets access to our data, you know, we make that publicly known, we follow the sort of legal process to receive footage, from our vehicles and, you know, we narrow the scope of that as needed because like at the end of the day, we need communities to be able to trust us. not just trust us for the safety of our drive, but it's also, you know, trust us that you understand what it is that we're doing with what we've captured. So, >> so you're just saying that you are pushing back on law enforcement requests that you think are too broad, >> overly broad. Of course.
16:44 >> Of course. And you know, not only is it burdensome, but also that's just our process. >> I'm curious how you see the political dynamics playing out over the next few years. I mean that the last time cities in America were really faced with like a wholescale change to transportation was ride sharing when companies like Uber and and Lyft would come in and and you know in some cases kind of surreptitiously sort of in just insert themselves into a city's transportation system and they would sort of try to get really big so that by the time city council or the mayor or whoever sort of caught on they already had this mass of customers who they could then mobilize to like defend them and they sort pioneered this model of like blitz scaling or just going really fast and and hoping that you can sort of work out the regulatory issues later. Whimo is obviously taking a different approach.
17:34 you can't really do that the same way. The cars, you know, identify themselves visually. So you can't just like sneak in the way that Uber did in some cities. You have to get permission and you have to go through the procedural hoops and you have to get city council on board. So, I'm just curious whether you you sort of think that's the path forward that makes the most sense or whether you wish you could kind of do it the way Uber did.
17:57 >> I think I so I'm I'm kind of on neither extreme. You know, one of the reasons we were able to launch in Arizona is because Governor Dussy issued an executive order. I think the bar of what you have to have already demonstrated you can do should be very high in that case. I don't think it should be your first market. I don't think it should be your second market. I think you should have a lot of data. But I do think if you're willing to be transparent with the public and enter that market, you know, I don't think that that the bar needs to be a complicated regulatory framework. So, this is sort of the debate that's happening is like how much regulation do you need in order to get to that sweet spot. I think it's going to depend. I think there's some places that aren't going to take a heavy hand there. I don't want safety to be sort of a race to the bottom though. I don't think that doesn't help any of us if a lot of bad things start happening with other autonomous vehicle companies.
18:55 And so, this is where we're trying to strike the right balance. But like move fast, break things, absolutely not, you know, in any way the way we think about it. It's more like be super deliberate and deep engagement but where we could have a fast movement on the policy side. That would be great. >> Let's talk about Tesla. they have rolled out their own robo tax. >> Speaking of race to the bottom on safety, >> they are now operating autonomous taxi services in Austin, one of the cities that Whimo is also in. they are clearly trying to compete with Whimo. They're taking a different approach using only cameras on their vehicles instead of these more expensive LAR sensors. do you see Tesla and what they're doing as direct competition? Are you worried about it?
19:39 Are you making any changes to your plans based on what they're doing? >> You know, we have sort of always thought there would be many many players. I mean, remember it was a crowded field for a long time >> and >> and then Cruz got into one accident and the field got less crowded. But anyways, >> it's a little more than that, but >> it was one accident. >> It was I'm just saying there were more factors than that.
20:03 >> Well, yes, but anyway, I'm sorry for interrupting. >> I thought you were saying there were more companies than that. >> Oh, yeah. >> so, you know, more companies trying to make the road safer. That's a positive thing. and we welcome that. I, you know, our approach is a full sensor suite. We think that's really important. it's been really important to get us here and there isn't another company that's been able to remove the driver and scale to where we are do freeways and surface straits without a human in the in the car to take over or without an extremely limited OD.
20:39 >> Yeah. Speaking of the sort of remote assistance, sometimes I see skeptics online who believe that there is a remote operator driving a lot of the time in these Whimo cars. Can you speak to that at all? Like on on my median ride going two or three miles in San Francisco, is the remote operator getting involved or is that happening in much more limited cases? Yeah. So we have there's no ability for anyone other than the vehicle to drive. We do not do telea operations. We do not do remote driving. It is all onboard software system. So that is >> to us that's the definition of autonomous. It's like it is operating fully autonomously. what will happen is you know there's two sort of ways that data can be shared in your experience. One is writer support. You know you push the button someone talks to you. That's a group. They have nothing to do with the driver function.
21:35 The other is, you know, in kind of to the conversation we were having before, you know, there's a flooded road a year ago. You know, the there's no road anymore. That's a place where the car might stop and then it'll ping. This is all like technology. It'll ping saying the road went away. And then you can have a remote assistance dispatcher send a Q again coding. and then the drive the car has to decide the safe route to take. Now that happens, it's happening automatically. So this wouldn't happen today. So it's just these are the edge cases or the long tail of what you encounter on the road, you know, and so they become more and more and more edge caseike and less and less frequent over time.
22:22 >> That's it. I actually did not know that. I thought that there were still like remote tea operators. So if I like encountered some blockage or something, somebody grabbed the wheel and drove it home from the building. >> I think like gamification of driving, you just don't you just don't have enough context >> to do it safely. And so we we feel very strongly that this needs to be fully autonomous, which is why sometimes the car pulls over because it's trying to resolve the issue, but it has to resolve the issue itself.
22:49 >> Well, I'm a little disappointed because I was going to ask you if Kevin and I could spend a day remote driving the Whimos. >> No, you can. I thought it'd be a fun team bonding experience. Like >> you're stepping on my other pitch, which is that every Whimo in San Francisco should automatically start playing the hardcore podcast whenever you get in. Just an idea. >> Speaking of product feedback. >> Oh, here we go. Kedra, the other day I was trying to get a Whimo to go to dinner with my good friend Casey Newton and I opened up my Whimo app and I pressed you know hail car and it told me that it would be 52 minutes until I could get a Whimo and that it was also going to cost about twice as much as an Uber. So >> that happens to people with low rider scores. I think you're only about 35 in the app.
23:33 >> So two separate questions here. What is happening with weight times in San Francisco and why is it more expensive to take a Whimo than an Uber if Whimo is not paying a driver? >> So, first on your experience, thank you for the feedback. We saw your tweet. >> and sorry that you had that experience. >> I assume always rolling. >> no, we take we take rider feedback super seriously. There was a bug that ETA was caused by a bug. So, it was actually really helpful to know because you do not see weight times like that on the Whimo app. Period. Full stop. It's not We have enough cars. It's not a we're not supply constrained. that every car was not in use at that moment.
24:18 why is it more expensive? It's algorithmically determined, but like this is a consistent fleet experience. Like we, you know, really want this to be a premium experience for writers. And like I said earlier, over time you'll see us kind of have these tiers of products, but right now it's, as you guys said, it's a nice JLR IPACE. They're clean. They're consistent. and so you will see it competing with Ride. It's not competing with Uber X or, you know, sort of the lowest tier of Lyft.
24:52 >> yeah. If you want a low tier experience, Kevin, maybe try Uber X. Okay. >> Yeah. No, I I feel this way. I actually I I do I am willing to pay more for a Whimo than >> if you don't have to wait too long >> if I don't have to wait too long cuz I do I do prefer the experience and also it feels like you're in the future still I still have that little moment. but I I'm not willing to pay three times as much.
25:15 >> Yeah. Yeah. And I I think that's fair and fine and obviously we have a fixed fleet and so you're going to see you know dynamic pricing happening based on our demand. but I am happy to hear you say, you know, you think of the experience as sort of value based, which is how how we think about it. >> Here's the be the best feature to me about the Whimo is that it has never once asked me about my politics at 4:30 a.m. on my way to the airport.
25:40 >> I don't know how you guys came up with that one, but it's incredible. Maybe you should have a mode where it does ask you about your politics. Just for people who feel nostalgic. Yes, you press P press a but instead of music, you could just have somebody like monologue about what's going on in Congress. >> Thank you so much for talk with you and thanks for tolerating our feedback. >> Yeah, of course. Thank you. >> Hey, that's the end of this clip. If you liked what you saw, head on over to our page and subscribe and you can get the full podcast. We do a show like this almost every week on Tech and the Future. Head on over there now and subscribe.
26:19 I'm about to be
Summary
- Whimo has expanded from three cities to five, with plans to enter Miami and Washington, D.C. soon.
- The company is currently providing around 250,000 rides per week, with projections to quadruple that by the end of next year.
- Whimo's autonomous vehicles are reported to be five to ten times safer than human-driven cars based on extensive safety data.
- The company faces opposition from unions and concerns about job displacement, but Maakana emphasizes that Whimo is also creating new jobs in manufacturing and fleet maintenance.
- Whimo has protocols in place regarding data sharing with law enforcement to maintain community trust.
- The company is navigating supply chain challenges, particularly with tariffs on electric vehicles from China, while also diversifying its partnerships.
- Whimo aims to provide a premium experience, which is reflected in its pricing compared to traditional ride-sharing services.
Questions Answered
What is Whimo and why is it significant?
Whimo, formerly the Google self-driving car project, has expanded its operations significantly, now testing in cities like New York. The conversation highlights the excitement around its technology and the challenges it faces.
How does Whimo's safety record compare to human drivers?
Whimo's data indicates that its autonomous vehicles are five to ten times safer than human drivers, based on millions of miles driven and insurance data.
What are Whimo's plans for vehicle offerings and market expansion?
Whimo plans to offer a variety of vehicle types tailored to different customer experiences, aiming to scale both in the US and globally.
How does Whimo handle data requests from law enforcement?
Whimo follows a strict legal process for sharing data with law enforcement, ensuring that requests are not overly broad to maintain community trust.
How does Whimo ensure its vehicles operate autonomously?
Whimo's vehicles operate fully autonomously without remote driving assistance, relying on onboard software to navigate and respond to road conditions.