Section Insights
Introduction to Salem Ramji
Who is Salem Ramji and what is his background?
Salem Ramji is the CEO of Vanguard, previously worked at BlackRock, and has a strong academic background in economics, politics, and law. His unique perspective in wealth management comes from his diverse experiences.
- Salem Ramji has a rich background in economics and law.
- He has significant experience in the wealth management industry.
- His insights are shaped by his previous roles and education.
The Resilience of Index Investments
How did index investments perform during market disruptions?
Despite warnings about potential failures of indexing and ETFs during market dislocations, they proved resilient, particularly during the market downturn in early 2020.
- Indexing and ETFs held up well during the 2020 market downturn.
- Market disruptions can occur unexpectedly, but robust systems are in place.
- Continuous effort is required to maintain the effectiveness of investment systems.
The Vanguard Effect and Fee Reductions
What is the Vanguard effect and how does it relate to fee reductions?
The Vanguard effect refers to the benefits clients receive from lower fees due to Vanguard's client-owned structure. Recent fee cuts on numerous funds have resulted in significant savings for investors.
- Vanguard's client-owned model allows for lower fees.
- Recent fee cuts have saved investors billions.
- The Vanguard effect is a longstanding tradition of reducing costs for clients.
The Role of Financial Advisors
What value do financial advisors provide to clients?
Financial advisors, particularly fee-based fiduciaries, can help clients avoid costly mistakes and provide guidance that extends beyond core investments, emphasizing the importance of long-term strategies.
- Advisors can prevent clients from making detrimental financial decisions.
- The value of advisors often goes beyond just investment management.
- Research supports the positive impact of fiduciary advisors on client outcomes.
Expanding the Vanguard Effect to Private Markets
How is Vanguard planning to extend its low-cost model to private markets?
Vanguard aims to negotiate institutional fees for private market investments, making them more accessible and transparent for individual investors, potentially including them in 401k plans.
- Vanguard seeks to bring its low-cost model to private markets.
- Negotiating institutional fees can benefit retail investors.
- The inclusion of private market options in 401k plans is being explored.
Transcript
0:02 Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio, news. >> This week on the podcast, yet another fascinating conversation. I sit down with Vanguard's CEO Salem Ramji. Previously, he was at Black Rockck helping to oversee Eyesshares and indexing. he's got a fascinating background and really one of the people in the wealth management industry who is so uniquely situated to see all of these different things that are going on.
0:34 what a great perch to observe the future of wealth management. I thought this conversation was fascinating and I think you will also with no further ado my conversation with Vanguard's Salem Ramji. Welcome to Bloomberg. >> Well, thanks Barry. It's great to be back. I think we did this about half a dozen years ago >> right in the middle of Yeah, we we it was it was a frightening time. I want to talk.
1:08 >> It's nice to be in a studio. >> Yes. I want to talk about your career and what led you to Vanguard. Yeah. >> But I I have to start by asking about your academic background, bachelor's in economics and politics from the University of Toronto and then a master's in law at Cambridge. And I'm assuming a master's in Cambridge is like a JD here. Is that right? >> Kind of. >> Kind of. was the original career plan becoming an attorney?
1:37 >> Neither of my parents finished high school. my dad used to run a grocery store that I worked in as a kid. And and from my parents point of view, they just wanted me to go to college. >> Mhm. >> And and so I don't think there was any great kind of original plan other than I thought like going to college would be a good thing. and I I was drawn to the law and ultimately my first job was at a law firm in London in part because there were so many exciting and interesting things happening in the world of kind of law and business in the early 90s in Europe at the time. And so that for me was kind of a compelling piece. But I wasn't one of these kids who was like, >> you know, from the age of 10 they wanted to be a lawyer from the, you know, from from that. it was more it felt like a really interesting time at that point with like markets liberalizing and lots of new markets opening up all over the world.
2:41 >> I'm curious how your upbringing affected how you look at money. You mentioned you worked in your dad's grocery store. Both your parents were immigrants working and living in British Columbia. How did that affect how you have a relationship with money and work? it probably, you know, some of these things you don't really truly understand until years later. >> but, we didn't always have a lot of financial security, growing up. And I'm in a at a company, and that cares very deeply about people's financial security. And you can sometimes abstract kind of that away in terms of what it means, but at least for me, I know what having it is and I know what the absence of it is.
3:26 obviously having some financial security is far better and and I think it really drove home for me the real importance at a kind of very personal level as to what financial security means in somebody's life or somebody's family and the importance of it to so many other things in terms of like the general kind of happiness of the house the levels of stress in the house the the freedom to be able to do things kind of once you've attained it And so financial security isn't a it's something that that that I know kind of deeply because I know its absence too.
4:04 And and so I think it makes it meaningful for me. Even if you you ask the 20-year-old version of me, I wouldn't have thought of it in that way. >> I think a lot of people don't realize the first checkbox is lack of financial stress is a huge weight off people's mind. So if you could solve for that, everything after that feels like gravy. >> Yeah. No, I I absolutely agree. >> So So you're you're working in London in Clifford and Chance. You also spent some time in Hong Kong. I did. Was that doing legal work or was it >> doing legal work and then how do you transition from that to McKenzie? What led to that?
4:39 >> It was, you know, I like I I enjoyed the business part of being a lawyer. Mhm. >> Like I'd work in financial markets, I'd work in M&A and I was always interested in what happened after the deal closed in the business aspects and and McKenzie for me kind of offered the chance to still be in a professional services firm which I liked still serve clients which I liked but also to get a little bit deeper on kind of the business of things and and I I had a kind of a wonderful career there for a dozen or so years really learning about financial institutions and working and advising a whole range of financial institutions in in New York and and beyond that.
5:23 >> So I'm fascinated because attorneys and consultants advise people running businesses and then you made the transition to actually running a business at Black Rockck. What is and when you were at Mackenzie, you were running their asset and wealth management practice. So, it wasn't a radical jump to go to Black Rockck, but how different is it offering advice versus actually, you know, where the rubber meets the road actually? >> It's really It's really different. It's a and I'd worked kind of with them as a client for a number of years before joining them and it's a very different aspect when you're owning the outcomes, when you're having to lead broader groups of people and when you're you're having to kind of sweat every single detail, every single moment of every single day. and it was a great learning experience for me because I joined them you know my early 40s and and it's a chance to really learn a whole new set of skills even though you know the industry and you you think you know a thing or two about kind of the firm you really don't until you're kind of deep into it and for me it was a great source of you know renewal revitalization a whole series of things that that that even to this day I'm very grateful for.
6:48 >> And I think if I if my research is correct, you started in 2014 at Black Rockck as head of corporate strategy. Yeah. >> Which is probably the most adviceoriented position >> within Black Rockck. You're advising the board. You're advising management. Hey, this is our strategic outlook. Here's how we should proceed. From there, you end up running US Wealth Advisory and eventually taking over Eyesshares and Index Investing in 2019, which I want to say that was about $3 trillion more or less. I don't know if it started there or finished there.
7:23 >> That that's some real money. >> Now, you're actually really running a business as opposed to offering advice at at Black Rockck. tell us what it was like taking over such a massive part of the firm. >> You're talking about at atares index investor. >> You know, it was all of it was a bit of a journey. I probably spent about a year in corporate strategy >> and that was really you know I I got to learn the culture of the firm. I got to learn the people at the firm. I can't say I had tremendous impact in that year. but it really led to the the business of serving kind of a whole range of financial adviserss all across the United States. and that for me was fascinating because I got to spend time with financial adviserss in every major city several not so major cities all across the US and just understand kind of how they were looking to grow their practices, grow their businesses. many of them were were effectively midsize business owners >> and the chance to really understand what their needs were, how they served their clients was was really meaningful and you know for Eyesshares it was just really expanding that on a on a much more global scale given the global breadth of that firm. So, Eyesshares has become legendary. It it's probably the single most successful M&A action taken by any >> asset manager and has just grown into one of the most important parts of the world of advisory. when when you assume leadership role at a division like that that's so important and has been running on all cylinders for so long is there any reluctance to interfere with what's working? You on the one hand you can't just rely on its momentum because eventually that peters out. How do you figure out hey we want to step on the accelerator without you know killing the goose to mixed metaphors that laid the golden egg?
9:38 Well, you know, the thing about any markets business is that the momentum sometimes interrupts you and so you don't have a great choice in terms of how things evolve and the like. And you know, when we last spoke six years ago, >> kind of right in the throws of COVID and the pandemic. that that a few months before were also big dislocations that were happening in the bond market. Mhm. >> And and so one of the things that I learned was just about how to maintain the resiliency of investments that millions of people rely on, particularly in moments of stress. And and some of that kind of translates, you know, through to Vanguard today because even at moments that look kind of like they're not going to have kind of big disruptions, that doesn't mean that they might not kind of a few months from now or a few years from now. And and the thing about investments and particularly things like index investments or ETFs, people naturally expect them to work kind of not just some of the time, but all of the time. and that's an inherent part kind of in the operation of it. But there's just a a a whole range of underlying pieces whether it's in how our portfolio managers manages the assets, whether it's in in how kind of the system of broker dealers and exchange providers and index providers kind of help maintain an orderly system. But one of the things that it really struck home to me, you know, back in 2019 and especially in 2020 was you can't take any of that for granted and and that requires work every single moment of every single day to make sure all the investments work as they ought to.
11:25 >> It's kind of funny because we had been warned, hey, just wait for the next dislocation. Indexing's going to fail, ETF's going to fail. And it turned out, especially down 34% in about six weeks in the first quarter of 2020, indexing and ETFs both held up great. >> Yeah. >> What what do you attribute that to? >> Well, one of the books I've been reading was, a guest you just had on the show, Robin's book about, you know, fabulous debt and the and the bond markets.
11:54 >> And and and I think with each of the dislocations, and let me go back to the dislocation in 2020. I I thought the most interesting set of things that happened back then was what happened in the bond market. The bond market was dislocated. The ETF market was not. And and what really catalyzed kind of that dislocation was a whole series of movements towards ETFs, towards electronic kind of venues, towards more exchange traded versus over-the-counter pieces. And the bond market even today six years later is still in need of modernization. But that was a real catalyst to help the bond market modernize. If you go back even earlier to the financial crisis, markets dislocated, but more and more investors moved into index investing and particularly ETF investing and we saw that kind of in in Vanguard's flows at the time. and each dislocation kind of results in learnings about the market structure and and and at least in more recent history it's made market structure better because you learn a few things consumers and investors learn a few things and it's how do you make sure that the system remains resilient through each one of these but I think ETFs whether it's bond ETFs or equity ETFs and even if I look back over the past 15 years have kind of weathered most or almost everything that's been thrown at him.
13:27 >> I have so many questions for you about running Vanguard and the future. Yeah. >> Of that company. >> But last question before we get to that, right? >> You worked very closely with Larry Frink. I did >> for for nearly a dozen years. Yeah. >> how did his leadership affect how you think about running a company? What what did you take from him? Well, you know, founders are different, right? Founders and and you'll know this too kind of given your role at at Rit Holtz, >> but but founders are different than CEOs. And I think the things I really learned from that whole experience was was really just about the need to always be able to reinvent and look around corners and anticipate kind of a series of things. and and I think learning from a founder of a company that's that's built the company up at scale >> was a a really great way in my kind of broad business experience to learn something new and learn it from someone who started a firm.
14:30 >> Really really interesting. Coming up we continue our conversation with Salam Ramji, CEO of Vanguard discussing what it takes to run one of the largest asset managers in the world. I'm Barry Rhaltz. You're listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. I'm Barry Rhaltz. You're listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. My extra special guest today is Solom Ramji. He is CEO of the Vanguard Group, helping to oversee running about 12.5 trillion, is that about right, in client assets. By the time this airs, it'll be 13 and change.
15:08 So, I have been fortunate enough to have interviewed every Vanguard CEO back to Jack Bogle. and now that you're here, I'm actually interviewing you as CEO. You're the first outsider to run Vanguard, which is kind of fascinating. And you never worked directly with Jack Bogle. So, so the first question I I have to ask about operations at Vanguard is how do you win the trust of the crew as an outsider?
15:40 Yeah, it's a great question and it's a you know about three just under three years ago probably like I guess it was May 2024 and the board had appointed me but I was now kind of meeting the crew for the first time and and you know the thing about Vanguard and and I'd always I'd always kind of seen this from the outside about the culture and the mission orientation. Vanguard's always had that in its reputation.
16:11 >> it's hard to explain, Barry, but from the inside just how real that is. And you know, whether I go back to May 2024 and just really kind of seeing it and feeling it, >> you know, I almost felt like the you know, there's that David Foster Wallace speech that he gave at Kenyon College about this is water, right? And the big fish goes up to two small fishes and kind of asks them how's the water and one of the fishes after one of the small fishes asks, you know, what the hell is water?
16:42 >> And and for us, our culture was so real and so unusual. It's quite unlike any other company I've worked at or even advised earlier in my career. and I think the extraordinary thing about it is that it's been several years now since Bogle passed. I'm the fifth CEO since him. The company's a lot bigger than it was 10 years ago or 25 years ago, but the culture is very real. And so I spent a lot of time in my first year meeting crew members at our different sites across the United States and outside the United States.
17:18 understanding kind of what is it about the culture that made it so pervasive and so real even at our scale and giving them an opportunity to ask me a bunch of questions which were really do I believe in the mission in the culture and in the values of the company I probably met more people in my first six or nine months at Vanguard than I've met in my entire life kind of beforehand but a lot of it was just around me coming to appreciate what went into building that. I think for the crew to understand what made me excited and what made me tech and and starting to connect both of those things in terms of you know how do we preserve maintain the mission the culture while being able to kind of develop and do a whole new set of things strategically. I >> I think a lot of people either get Vanguard or don't. I'm curious once you were on the inside.
18:18 >> Yeah. >> Did anything surprise you as a former outsider like what what is being done at Vanguard be it culturally or just as an operational shop? What what kind of surprised you from the inside? >> I would say be beyond the sense that the culture was kind of real which I I wasn't sure >> right. and I I would say it's two things. You know, one of them was when I asked people about the culture.
18:47 it wasn't written down anywhere. and you know, last year was our 50th anniversary. >> Mh. >> And so we really took the opportunity we engaged about 4,000 crew members in the process. We went back to all the old Bogle memos and and kind of books and the like to really distill down not just in words what our cultural tenants or pillars ought to be but also the behaviors that underpin it. And so it was this unwritten language and this unwritten code and and for people who were joining us out of college or people who were you know might have joined us 5 years ago or more recently it's kind of helping understand what the Vanguard culture was about. So, it was surprising to me that it wasn't it was this unwritten piece. and and really it was very enriching for me and hopefully enriching for for for all of the crew to really be able to put it down and be able to kind of gain a sense of some consensus and some inspiration kind of out of it. I'd say the second thing, this is more strategic rather than cultural was that we had so many opportunities to if you will extend the vanguard effect even in existing areas that we were in. So, I sat down. I remember it was July 2024 with Sarah Deero who's the CIO of our fixed income team >> and she took me through our fixed income performance index and active.
20:21 our fixed income performance is extraordinary. I honestly had no idea. I I knew of Vanguard from prior lives as a index fixed income manager. I didn't know how good we were at active fixed income. And I certainly didn't know that we started Active Fixed Income in 1981. And so we'd been in the business for a long time. And and so one of the very early things I was able to do was, you know, put a little bit more marketing resources, put a little bit more client time against fixed income, to be able to help clients understand the value that they could get from lowcost active fixed income just as they could from lowcost index fixed income. but there were some of these things that I thought were just really near-term opportunities to to help people understand that even by changing things a little bit, we could really extend the Vanguard effect, we give clients a better deal, we could help them kind of look at their total portfolios in a much more cost-effective and a much higher quality way.
21:25 >> So, so let's talk a little bit about the Vanguard effect. one of the first things you do is cut fees on 53 funds, creating about a4 billion dollar in annual savings for your investors. >> Am I reading this possibly right? The average expense ratio at least on a market cap weighted basis is 0.06%. Is that possibly right? That's astounding on almost $13 trillion. tell us what motivated you to lean even harder into low cost.
22:00 >> Well, you'd say some of it is honestly Barry just a function of our business model. We're owned by our clients. and so the way one of the ways in which our clients benefit from the scale that that Vanguard's able to generate is they get lower fees. Right? So there was something very unoriginal in what I did because we've cut fees more than 2,000 times before on those before we made the fee cuts on those you know 50 plus funds a couple of years ago and and long may that tradition continue because it's an inherent part of being a Vanguard investor that they get to benefit from the scale investors that we generate and most companies as they gain scale it's the shareholders that benefit not the investors in our case the shareholders and the investors are one and the same which is part of the I think the original genius >> of the model Bogle put into place.
22:57 >> and so that was just a natural progression kind of of things. At the same time, we were also able to make a series of reinvestments back into our technology, back into, you know, areas like fixed income and being able to launch new offerings like our cash offerings. and so many of these investments, even if you just take the example of technology, that's been a multi-year, multi-billion dollar investment. It started before I arrived. we continued it and it was really to take the move us off of a a myriad of legacy mainframe kind of platforms >> onto a much more unified cloudnative platform >> which enables us to do a whole range of things to benefit clients and the client experience. And so we're always trying to balance both of these things, which is how do you maintain low cost because that's part of the proposition of why a Vanguard investor is a Vanguard investor and at the same time how do you also reinvest back in the business to be able to find new ways either to enhance the client experience or help people realize the Vanguard effect in newer areas whether it's fixed income cash or even areas like advice. So, you've been very aggressive about addressing things like customer service and technology.
24:21 There were some problems that had been bubbling around before you arrived, some customer service outages and some tech failures, and then there was the again all this predates you. you settled the the regulatory situation on target date funds and capital gains and again this is all in effect before you arrive. Clearly, you've made customer service a priority. >> Yeah. What's the response been like? How are you going to continue to put things like this into effect?
24:51 >> The response so far has been good, but we're not done yet. I think the technology underpinnings which began before I started but we we just completed the the self-directed ones just a few weeks ago. I think that to my mind gives us an incredibly resilient and incredibly modern underlying technology stack which solves some of the issues of the past but also gives us a lot of opportunities to innovate in the future including through AI but also in terms of the web experience, the mobile experience and and a whole range of other things. I think the other piece that we were able to do was also reinvest back into client service. Mhm.
25:33 >> so even beyond web and mobile, which accounts for the vast majority of our client service interactions, people missed things like their flagship advisor. and that's been something that's been part of Vanguard since the late '9s. we just relaunched it on October the 15th. so this is a couple weeks old. but but the client feedback so far has been tremendously positive. because now flagship clients can get access to their own dedicated advisor, they can get better cash rates and a whole host of of of other things. And we've also been reinvesting back even for our non- flagship clients into people and having well-trained licensed professionals being able to serve Vanguard clients. And so, you know, the pendulum swings from time to time between efficiency and experience.
26:28 we've really made it a big and important part to invest back into client experience and and our clients have responded kind of very positively. There's still a host of things that we're coming out with next year and the year after. and so the thing about client experiences you're never done. but but we're certainly committed to having a really easy really intelligible client experience and and and something that is a reason why clients come to us for. in addition to all the funds and all the other benefits that they get from being a Vanguard investor.
27:01 >> You mentioned advice. You took direct oversight of workplace and advis advisor services, which is about $3 trillion. That is a a key part of what Vanguard offers, but it never was the direct report to CEOs back in the day. Why did you think it was so important that you wanted to be that involved in in advisor services? >> Yeah, it's a look, some of it was just we had a natural kind of retirement of one executive both of the executives who worked for that person are superb. And the other reason if you think about things like advisor services, workplace was pretty intuitive because workplace you know is the place that most investors invest with us for the first time >> meaning their 401ks >> their 401ks and and we'll be the workplace provider for many Fortune 500 companies, many private companies, many professional services companies.
28:04 And so having that direct connection made a lot of sense both because we're dealing with a lot of companies and and it it has a central importance to Vanguard's mission the financial advisors business. So this is the business that serves advisers that don't work at Vanguard but use Vanguard funds. I naturally have a certain place in my heart for for that segment. U not just because I'm talking to you Barry, but you know in my prior career as you talked about >> and and what has happened to Vanguard over the past I'd say it's been it's been going for the past 10 or 15 years.
28:40 >> it's probably started by Bill McNab and and really was a catalyst for this like 15 years ago is that really paying a great deal of focus on feebased financial advisors. And what we found is that if you have a fiduciary financial advisor whose only interest is the client's interest that one they're a really good partner for Vanguard and two the Vanguard funds do just fine as a piece of their overall portfolio because then they're really focused on all the empirical evidence that Bogle and many others have been talking about for years in terms of highquality lowcost investments for the long term. And so that's become a a much more important segment for us over the past 10 years, over the past 15 years. and and so that was another kind of piece to it. And it it also ties into and I'm sure you'll get to it at some point, kind of the logic behind the altruist acquisition. We >> we're definitely going to talk about that. But before we do, I know you think of yourself as a bogal head.
29:44 >> I do. And I can hold two conflicting ideas in my mind at the same time. I sometimes find the Bogle folks don't grasp this. Vanguard put out a white paper years ago called Advisor's Alpha. Yes. >> Talked about how, hey, here's what you get for your fee, and we're estimating this if they keep you from jumping off the ledge at 200 250 basis points a year. The Bogleheads are not fans of this.
30:14 I've always said, hey, if you can do it yourself and you're disciplined and you enjoy it, go do it yourself. But if you this isn't for you and you want to pay someone to do it for you, get a fiduciary and run it that way. What is beyond that, what is the best argument for someone hiring an adviser as opposed to just being self-directed? >> It's a look in Vanguard, clients tend to skew self-directed. but we also have we've also seen over the years that is that that as our clients became more affluent as our clients became older as our clients needs changed and became more complicated they sought a financial adviser. and you're right this advisor's alpha kind of both white paper and research which has been going on for 25 years. so it's not a new thing that we started. something we update every single year really points that for certain clients that fit that profile having an advisor provided they're a feebased adviser and they're a fiduciary which is a big provided can be really helpful to clients and and in many cases it's beyond kind of even just the core investments right if I if I give you an example this is anecdotal so it's not in the advisor's alpha research like you know about 11 years ago my father passed away my mother didn't really have much to do with their investments and she wanted to put all of their investments into cash. her feebased adviser really talked her out of it, explained to her that there was a better way to do it. and served her needs well. now I'm probably the worst nightmare in the sense of like if you've got a client and their son is me in terms of giving this adviser a hard time about fees and active funds and the like. But nonetheless what he really did is that he helped her stop making what could have been a very costly mistake.
32:15 and and and there's a lot of advisors who are in a sense the unsung heroes because they're helping clients avoid really costly mistakes. It may be selling when the markets are are kind of hitting a low point, buying when markets are hitting a high point rather than staying the course and kind of taking a long-term view. it may be keeping clients away from the more speculative excesses that we see in certain aspects of the market. and and it's very hard to quantify those things but but what I can tell you from all of our advisor alpha research and even my own personal experience that these things really matter and they can make a huge difference and and so there's a really important role for a feebased adviser to help individual adviserss throughout the country. If anything, my biggest worry, Barry, today, 25 years after, is that too few people have access to financial advice, >> only one in five Americans today has access to a feebased advisor.
33:16 >> It's that low. That's amazing. >> Yeah. And if you look out over the next 10 years, and we did this research, and it was part of the catalyst for altruist, but if it's one in five today, that number gets worse, over the next 10 years because more advisers are retiring. >> Mhm. people are getting wealthier. which is a good thing if you're one of the wealthier people, but what it does is that it takes makes that ratio worse rather than better. And so, from our vantage point, if if a good feebased adviser is helpful, and we know that from the research, our own surveys with clients tell us that they want access to more forms of advice. many of them want it kind of with a human in the loop. then what can we do to really change that math? just as I think Vanguard has done over the past 50 years, it's helped more people become investors. How do we help more people get access to good sound feebased advice through whatever means we can particularly using technology.
34:19 >> Huh. Really interesting. Coming up, we continue our conversation with Salam Ramji, CEO of Vanguard, discussing the future of advice. I'm Barry Rhaltz. You're listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. I'm Barry Rhaltz. You're listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio. My extra special guest this week is Selen Ramy. He is CEO of Vanguard and has driven some significant changes for the better at the firm. When I was doing my prep for this, we had spoken previously when you were at at Black Rockck and I had interviewed Bill McNeb and all all of his prior predecessors, but I came across four themes just in all the public statements you made and all the things you've written about, it showed up and and I want to work my way through these four and then talk a little bit about the future. The first was simply cost and simplicity as a quality argument rather than as a race to zero.
35:25 Lower cost drives up quality which goes against the orthodoxy today of complexity which for decades has masked higher fees. >> Yeah, >> pretty pretty fair. >> That's fair characterization. And look, I was just echoing Bogle who made all of these similar statements in the 80s and in the '9s and and and and the like, which is that the the financial services system tends to trend towards complexity.
35:57 >> Mhm. the reason and again this is one of Bogle's insights almost the reverse of AAM's razor which is that the simpler answer may be better but the more complicated answer can justify higher fees >> and and and it's bringing it all back to first principles as to what's the minimum that the client kind of needs to be able to achieve their outcome so that you can keep costs low and keep the efficiency levels high around that and and as you keep looking back to the facts and the evidence whether it's from the 80s or 90s or 2000s or even in the past 5 years simplicity tends to outperform complexity all the time and so it's it's how do you maintain that core principle not just because Bogle said it or because it's part of Vanguard's ethos but in in the vast majority of cases it's empirically true and it and it will help the client over the long term.
36:58 >> I I love the Morning Star report years ago that sort of undercut the Star model that said, "Hey, if you don't know anything, just pick the lowest fee." Yeah. >> And the data very much supports that. >> Yeah. And you know, Vanguard's got active funds and it's got index funds. And we have since 1975. And sometimes now people will often think of us about index funds because we invented the index fund. but but the debate between active and index to my mind and in Morning Star's mind is it's not so much about a style of management it's actually just about the fee right so lowcost active funds tend to outperform high-cost active funds and it was you know Bogle's insight that again he he sort of put it is in investing you get what you don't pay for and that's true in active it's true in index but fundamentally this is a debate about pricem It's not a debate about one style or the other. and I think that really just goes back to the simplicity argument and the cost argument.
38:00 >> Let's talk about another fairly simple argument, the cash flow test. We don't like things that don't produce cash flow, be they crypto, meme stocks, or prediction markets, >> or even for that matter, gold, which has got a 3,000-year track record, right? around it. But we think an investment is something that kind of generates cash flow or has the prospect to generate cash flow. and that's true in in equities, it's true in bonds, it's true in public markets, it's true in private markets, but it's not true in any of the aspects that that you talked about. And even even if you get kind of beyond the the piece of gold and commodities that have long track records but are nonetheless not investments in our orthodoxy, >> many of the other things that you you listed >> aren't even like I mean they're speculative and they're they're gambling >> masquerading as investments. and a and I think they can be quite corrosive to the overall trust and long-term nature that's been built over the past 50 years of of great investments and a great investment culture here in the United States. Let's talk a little bit about private markets where again I'm paraphrasing some exposure could make sense for very high netw worth investors but it must be good quality low fee and intelligible or or >> transparent. Yeah, it's a and and and and for this one again if you take a step back we've got a term within Vanguard within our CIO office that Greg Davis leads which is does it load >> and so anytime we look at a new product could be an index product it could be an active product fixed income equities public private we look at it relative to the efficient frontier of a index 6040 7030 8020 portfolio and does it have the the possibility of generating something on the that's better than the efficient frontier of what that can do. The vast majority of products fail that test.
40:14 >> vast majority fail that test. >> Right. Wow. and and because a 6040 7030 index portfolio 8020 you can pick the different allocations actually does quite well over long periods of time for for all the reasons that you know and that Bogle's written books about and we continue to publish research about but there are certain circumstances where some private markets load in Vanguard's parliament and there's a long list of caveats that then comes with that piece at the top of the list, it wouldn't surprise you, is cost and transparency. And if you think about what Vanguard has been doing actually back to our founding, right, because our first Vanguard funds were Wellington funds.
40:58 >> Mhm. >> And and we have a a a group of institutional active equity subadvisors that we've worked with for 50 plus years. but we try and seek high quality managers and we try and buy at institutional prices. And so it's a way of extending the Vanguard effect into active equities. Private markets is a branch of that same thinking which is can we negotiate institutional fees >> because the fees in private markets particularly for retail investors are far too high. Can we pass that on to our individual investors or through their adviserss and can we make the overall fee structures more transparent? And so that was kind of the the the the logic behind whether it was the the fund that we launched about six years ago with Harborvest, >> whether it's some of the offerings we're researching and exploring with other firms like Blackstone for example.
42:00 but it's really with that lens of can we help bring the Vanguard effect to privates just as we have to public markets. Do you think at some point over the next decade or so privates will be a widespread option for people's 401ks? >> I think it'll be an option in people's 401ks. Again, I can give you a long list of caveats regulatory and otherwise. >> whether it's widespread or not really depends. and I think some of it depends on that efficient frontier kind of that I talked about. For many clients, an index target date fund suits them just fine, right? Simplicity matters >> and and and for many people, particularly in retirement plans, simplicity gives them a sense of safety, even a safe harbor, kind of from various things. I don't think that's going to change, but I do think that there are segments of 401k plans that do want access to some of the long-term return profile for some of the for for some of their participants.
43:08 And I think we're provided it meets all of our conditions around does it load, I think we're open-minded to to to being able to explore that. But I don't think it's going to be widespread in the way that an index target date is widespread. I think it can generate more superior outcomes to the active target date market than the active target date market provides today through public market investments. but but I think that the index target dates will still be the leading kind of solution for the industry.
43:41 >> Let's talk about acquisitions. You mentioned Altruist and and full disclosure, I'm an investor in Altruist. I believe you >> we were an early not not not me personally but Vanguard Vanguard was an investor and altruist in the series A round >> and your your predecessor Bill McNab was one of their early advisers and investors and a prior guest on the show. >> This is a giant relatively giant acquisition for Vanguard that's not known for doing big multi-billion dollar buys. There have been a series of tactical or strategic little one other one other than >> nothing like this. So tell us what you think the altruist purchase does for Vanguard the company and for the investor base.
44:26 >> Yeah. Well, I I'll give you kind of some of our thinking, Barry. I may not be able to answer all your questions because the transaction has yet to close. but >> sometime this year. >> Yeah, I hope later this year. and so I can give you the part two. Either myself or Jason, we can both give you the part two at a future date. But let let me give you some of the let me answer the first part of your question which is really about the why and and and the why really came down to a couple parts some of which we've talked about before. At at the broadest level we saw a scarcity of we saw a real problem of access to advice. It's back to this one in five Americans have access to a feebased financial advisors today and and how do we help change that? So two out of five or three out of five like most Americans can have access to some form of guidance or advice.
45:19 altruist for us played a really important role or plays a really important role in that for a couple of reasons. One, they're already serving several thousand independent financial adviserss today. and we really believed in their growth trajectory tomorrow. kind of having had a ringside seat since shortly after their founding. we could really see the client loyalty they're building with adviserss, the the ways in which they're equipping adviserss to to help do better things. And the second piece which relates to the first is just their technology.
45:54 and their technology is really built for advisers, helps take out some of the day-to-day but also helps augment things that advisers can do for their clients. And so we think it can make a real dent in the access problem because if they can help advisers serve twice as many clients that really starts to scale and if you can get more people have access to more feebased advisors by using better technologies like Altruist or Hazel we think that's a really important component to to being able to solve this question of access.
46:33 the second part of it is that it gives us a direct connection to a client base that's been you know 15 20 years ago was a small client base and is now a really important and growing client base of Vanguard's which is the the independent financial adviser and it allows us to serve them with products which we've been doing for about 15 plus years now but also with enabling technologies around portfolios and rebalancing and a whole host of other things just like we have in our workplace business and just like we have in our direct to consumer business. And so so those were kind of two of the reasons why I will also say and this was really unusual which is that because we've known Jason as an institution as a company for you know six seven years because we had a a Vanguard person as an observer on their board because the connection back to Bill there were there were a lot of cultural similarities between what Jason's trying to Jason and altruist are trying to do for adviserss in Vanguard's own mission. And so kind of our sense of cultural affinity, let's just say, was strong.
47:48 and certainly as I got to know him and meet him over the past year or so, that really just that conviction grew in in my own judgment as well. >> So we see a lot of public companies that have publicly traded stock gives them a cheap source of paper to acquire other companies. I am not going to assume that Vanguard's going public anytime soon to to start making more and more acquisitions. Yeah. this way. Do but in all seriousness when you look at the competitive landscape does Vanguard have any disadvantage for not being able to do those sort of either large or mega acquisitions that your competitors have been doing with their publicly traded stock. You know, the the one of the beauties of Vanguard is that we've managed to to generate economies of scale, grow the company, serve our clients, and 99.9% of that has been organic.
48:52 and what Altruist really was was a unusual set of circumstances of an opportunity we saw to help people get more access to advice, an enabling technology whether it's Hazel or a whole series of other workflow technologies that they've built. and a series of needs that we had that that also tie with a good sense of cultural affinity. I don't think you're going to find those circumstances kind of come together. I've done a lot of deals in my past lives.
49:29 >> Mhm. this is an unusual set of circumstances and and so first I don't think you should view this as any great departure kind of in in Vanguard and and our thinking which is going to be nearly all organic. >> I talked to all the bankers that came to visit me after we after we announced it that like this is going to be an unfruitful place for you to visit you know for the next half a decade or decade. but I think more importantly, we've been able to do a lot of things, organically, that, that have surprised people. I mean, I I think Bill talked about it on your show just a few months ago, >> you know, if you go back in history in 2009, Eyesshares went somewhere else as part of the acquisition. Vanguard built an ETF business organically.
50:22 we've done rather well over the past 15 16 years because if we stick to these core tenants of giving clients a fair deal keeping it simple and really sharing the economies of scale that we're able to generate with our clients turns out clients really like that and and that formula works and it's worked for us for the past 15 years I think it's going to work for us for the next 15 years and so that that's I think altruist you I'd see as a very unusual set of planets aligning at the right time >> makes a lot ofense Since we have been speaking with Selen Ramji, he is CEO of Vanguard. If you enjoy this conversation, well, be sure and check out any of the 676 we've done over the past 12 years. And you can find those at iTunes, Spotify, Bloomberg, or YouTube. I would be remiss if I didn't thank the Crack staff that helps put these conversations together each week. Noah Freriedman is my video engineer. Anna Luke is my producer. Sean Russo is my head of research. I'm Barry Britz. You've been listening to Masters in Business on Bloomberg Radio.
Summary
- Salem Ramji's background includes a law degree and extensive experience in financial services, including roles at BlackRock and McKinsey.
- He highlights the personal impact of financial security from his upbringing, driving his passion for helping others achieve it.
- Vanguard's business model is unique as it is owned by its clients, allowing for lower fees and a focus on client benefits.
- Ramji emphasizes the importance of simplicity in investing, arguing that lower costs lead to better outcomes for investors.
- He discusses the challenges of maintaining investment resilience during market dislocations, citing the effectiveness of ETFs during the COVID-19 pandemic.
- The acquisition of Altruist aims to enhance access to financial advice for more Americans, addressing the current disparity in access to fiduciary advisors.
- Ramji is focused on improving client service and technology at Vanguard, ensuring a better experience for investors.
- He believes in the potential for private market investments to be integrated into 401(k) plans, provided they meet cost and transparency criteria.
Questions Answered
Who is Salem Ramji and what is his background?
Salem Ramji is the CEO of Vanguard, previously worked at BlackRock, and has a strong academic background in economics, politics, and law. His unique perspective in wealth management comes from his diverse experiences.
How did index investments perform during market disruptions?
Despite warnings about potential failures of indexing and ETFs during market dislocations, they proved resilient, particularly during the market downturn in early 2020.
What is the Vanguard effect and how does it relate to fee reductions?
The Vanguard effect refers to the benefits clients receive from lower fees due to Vanguard's client-owned structure. Recent fee cuts on numerous funds have resulted in significant savings for investors.
What value do financial advisors provide to clients?
Financial advisors, particularly fee-based fiduciaries, can help clients avoid costly mistakes and provide guidance that extends beyond core investments, emphasizing the importance of long-term strategies.
How is Vanguard planning to extend its low-cost model to private markets?
Vanguard aims to negotiate institutional fees for private market investments, making them more accessible and transparent for individual investors, potentially including them in 401k plans.