transcribe

How Senior PM Leadership Interviews Actually Work: Part 2

Shreyas Doshi · 29m · transcribed Oct 2026
More from Shreyas Doshi Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

The Role of Empathy in Interviews

What is the key to succeeding in interviews?

Success in interviews hinges on understanding and demonstrating empathy, particularly cognitive empathy, which involves grasping the interviewer's needs and perspectives.

  • Empathy is crucial for interview success, not just storytelling skills.
  • Cognitive empathy focuses on understanding what the interviewer wants.
  • The same empathy skills are essential for product development.
# 5:57

What VCs and Boards Look For

What do VCs and boards prioritize in candidates?

VCs and boards prioritize a candidate's track record, execution capabilities, and complementary skills to the existing leadership.

  • Highlight your track record to demonstrate impact.
  • Showcase your execution skills to address complex challenges.
  • Emphasize complementary skills to the hiring manager's strengths.
# 11:54

Building Rapport with Interviewers

How can candidates effectively connect with interviewers?

Candidates should convey empowerment and investment in the growth of their team while aligning with the hiring manager's vision and demonstrating complementary skills.

  • Empowerment is key to gaining trust from potential team members.
  • Aligning with the hiring manager's vision enhances rapport.
  • Demonstrating product insight is crucial for impressing leadership.
# 17:51

Preparing for Interviews with Research

How can candidates prepare for interviews to improve communication?

Candidates should familiarize themselves with the interviewer's personality and style through research to enhance rapport and make communication more natural.

  • Researching interviewers can reduce awkwardness in conversations.
  • Familiarity with the interviewer's style aids in building rapport.
  • Advanced preparation can significantly improve interview outcomes.
# 23:48

Navigating Take-Home Assignments

What should candidates know about take-home assignments in interviews?

Candidates should be aware that take-home assignments often require more time than suggested and should proactively address any uncertainties about their candidacy during the interview process.

  • Take-home assignments can be time-consuming and challenging.
  • Candidates should establish rapport with hiring managers early.
  • Addressing concerns about candidacy can clarify the hiring process.

Transcript

0:00 So this is a very useful thing to understand. Getting great at interviews is basically all about empathy. So if you are not great at interviews, don't think that you have a storytelling problem. Storytelling story. No, you have an empathy problem. Okay? If you are not like highly successful in your interviews, it basically means and it's everybody likes to think they have empathy. Okay? You might also have empathy. I'm not saying you don't have empathy, but what I'm saying is you do not have the requisite empathy and not the emotional empathy and the oh we are all good people and like everybody the world peace all that not that empathy it's cognitive empathy it's what does this person actually want this person's problems what are this person's real needs by the way all of these are the same skills you need to build highly successful products consistently Okay, where the person is the customer or the user, right? So again, we're not talking about oh the world rainbows and unicorns and all that stuff. We're not talking about that empathy, right? We are talking about just practical empathy of what does this person want? So the observation is especially for senior roles, especially for senior roles, most of the people who will be interviewing you will be these crossf functional people, right? like head of marketing, head of sales, head of support, head of customer success, whatever. Does this make sense? Like you'll get a lot of head of engineering, head of design, head of data science, like that sort of stuff. Does that make sense? Now, the problem is most of these people, including even your potential team members, they don't actually know what the product role is. They are not at all qualified to even interview somebody who would be in a product role.

1:57 But yet that is how interview processes work. So they will ask you pretty shitty questions. Your job is to turn those shitty questions into responses that get them the information they are truly seeking. What I'm about to share with you in the next slide will profoundly change your interview efficiency, effectiveness and performance. But only if you pay attention and only if you take it seriously and only if you think hard about it. But I will also say it is better than doing five courses in how to do interviews and watching 50 YouTube videos of stupid star framework case studies. I'm not saying you should not do that. You can and should do that. If you do whatever it takes to get a job, okay? So, it's I'm not saying you should not do that. All I'm saying is there are 500 other people who are also watching those YouTube videos about the stupid star framework. Okay? So, it's not going to differentiate you. Is this logically making sense? So, what you are about to see in this next slide I'm going to render for you is going to differentiate you, but it'll require you to pay attention. and truly try to understand it. Okay. So with that this again if you understand this you will your interview success will skyrocket especially for senior roles.

3:25 All right it's a big if but just stay with me. So what I wanted to share with you is what each type of interviewer tends to care about. And I'm going to use like startup midsize company lingo. But this also applies to large company interviews. Especially for leadership manager roles, leadership roles at larger companies. This also applies. You'll have to just change the language. All right. So here's you in a PM leadership interview. Okay. Now, this is generally the set of roles and adapt this to larger company if you need to, but this is generally the set of roles you'll speak with. Does this make sense?

4:00 All right. I'll repeat. Not everyone is a good interviewer of PM leaders. So at senior levels, you need to understand what they are looking for whether or not they have good questions to figure it out and then guide the conversation in a way that they get what they're looking for. Yeah, I'm ignoring the recruiter cuz if you can't clear the recruiter screen, it's like pointless. It's like that is very basic stuff. So I'm ignoring that. All right, cuz you have to understand the bar for the recruiter screen is never high. The recruiter is looking for what? What is the recruiter looking for? What is the inter? No, no.

4:34 In the interview, what is the recruiter looking for? Yeah. That that the hiring manager should not get upset at the recruiter like why are you sending me these people? That's the bar the recruiter wants to clear. Does it make sense? This is this is not like some really advanced stuff like you have to understand this stuff. The recruiter is simply looking to make sure that they are bringing candidates that the hiring manager will not get upset. this why you wasting my time that's it okay so yes I have not rendered recruiters here but again if that is a problem then it's a entirely different problem okay so what I'm talking about is how do you actually get the job right not like that you clear the recruiter screen okay these are the roles you'll typically be speaking with in intermediate and advanced rounds in interviews okay so what you have to understand is you have to give these people what they are truly looking for even if they're questions are just nonsense questions.

5:33 Okay, this is tell me about a time when you had a conflict with a coworker and what did you do? It's like stupid questions. People ask stupid questions in interviews. Doesn't matter. You can't change their questions. Never once should you say that this is a stupid question. Never once should you even indicate any disgust or any judgment of the question. You should answer every single question with all the enthusiasm, all the gusto that you can gather. Okay.

5:59 So this is what you do. Okay. Now this is the most important part of this slide. So what are VCs and board looking for? VCs and board they don't have taste in this actual product craft. All right. So they use proxies. So the proxies that VCs and board use is your track record because you can't get blamed for bringing in a candidate or hiring a candidate who has a good track record. Okay. So when you talk to VC's board and again if it's a larger company then it's usually the SVP the final interview right what you want to do is you want to make sure they understand your track record they understand that you have a track record of making impact okay so that's one thing second usually VCs and board they're looking for somebody who's great at execution cuz when they are bringing in somebody senior it's usually because the founder or the CEO has reached their limit on execution things have become very complex tax. So you also want to share you are the answer to the execution wos this company or or is facing. Okay. And lastly, they're looking for complimentary skills to the leader who's going to be your hiring manager. Meaning they don't want a complete carbon copy, a clone of the founder or the hiring manager. They want somebody with complimentary skills. So when you talk to the VCs and board make sure you highlight through your answers that you do have that complimentary skill whatever those complimentary skills might be. Okay. So that's what you try to that's the message you through your answers that's the message you are it doesn't matter what questions they ask you. Of course give them the impression that you answered their question but as you answer the question make sure that these three things are clear at the end of the interview. These three things should be clear to the VCs of the board. Next, cross functional peers. XFN is crossunctional. All right.

7:49 So, examples here are head of engineering who's going to be your counterpart, engineering manager, tech lead, design manager, senior designer, research lead, sales lead, marketing lead, etc. Okay. Do you think these people know how to evaluate a head of product or a senior product leader? No, of course they don't. So, what are they actually looking for? What they are looking for is they are looking to understand does this person have empathy with my function. So through your answers you have to convey that you absolutely understand the challenges of the marketing function that you absolutely understand the challenges of the sales function. You absolutely understand the challenges of the design function and so on and so forth. You have an understanding and appreciation of those challenges. Okay. So that's the empathy part. Second is this person needs to feel like we will have a high degree of alignment. I the head of design, I the head of sales, I the head of customer success, whatever that if we hire this person, the product function will be very aligned with my own function. I did not say 100% agreement.

9:06 I'm merely talking about alignment. So this person needs to feel confident at the end of the conversation that yes we are going to have a high degree of alignment because why is that why does that matter because what is the biggest frustration for these cross functional people? What is the biggest frustration for these other functions? Yeah like the biggest frustration is like they don't understand the bigger picture. They don't understand we're not aligned right. Goals are not aligned. We're not on the same page. So if you come across as the solution to that problem which is okay if we hire this person there's going to be a great alignment they are going to love it. Okay. And then lastly again because they don't have a formal basis for actually testing your actual skills. They are going to use your track record as a proxy for that. Okay. So make sure you they understand the track record the impact you made. Okay. So, if you do this well in a cross functional PR interview, here's what I've found.

10:01 Moments after they get off the call with you in this interview, they are going to ping the hiring manager on Slack and they're going to say, "Oh my gosh, we should just hire this person." Okay, that is the effect you will have if you do this well. All right, now your team. Now, when I mean your team, I generally mean people who will report to you. But even if this is not a manager role cuz I know some of you here are not managers, your senior IC's etc. Right?

10:29 So even if this is not a manager role, it applies if it's the broader engineering team or whatever. Okay? What is your team looking for? So your team is looking for these three things. Clarity, empowerment, and growth. Okay. So again, all of this just requires simple empathy. Like what is the biggest problem for like PMs on in in some team that is growing? What is the biggest problem? Yeah. They feel like there's no direction. Exactly. Especially if they're hiring somebody's like they feel like are they getting pulled in 50 different direction. So you have to come across as somebody who's going to be again you have to convey this in your answers. You have to come across as somebody who's going to bring a lot of clarity because that's what PMs will appreciate. Okay. Now you also have to understand another thing about PMs. PMs are highly competitive. Okay. And in some cases even cutthroat. So think about it. Is the most ambitious and let's just say very competent PM on the team going to be happy that a manager is getting hired above them or unhappy?

11:32 Happy or unhappy? Yes. How do you overcome this? Because you know what some of these cutthroat PMs do? What do you must have seen this? What do they do in interview processes where their boss is getting hired? What is their feedback usually? Yeah, they will purposely give negative feedback. They'll try to I've even seen well-meaning PMs otherwise like basically trying to sabotage the process because they don't want to get layered. But of course the senior vice presidents the CPOS they know this. So they discount some of their feedback saying of course he's going to say that or she's going to say that right? Does that make sense? Okay. So what your job is to preempt this. See this is what empathy is. You have to understand this stuff. Again empathy is not oh yeah vulnerability this that oh imposttor syndrome nonsense. That's not empathy.

12:19 That's just virtue signaling. All right. Real empathy is to understand where a person is coming from without judging them. Okay? To truly understand an individual and not judge them, not pass judgment. All right? So what you need to convey in your discussions with them is that even though you will be coming in as a manager of theirs, you are all about empowerment and you are in fact if you get hired, they are going to have more empowerment, not less. And lastly, they you need to come across as somebody who will be sincerely invested in their growth. Okay, so that's with the team.

12:57 And then lastly with the hiring manager, the founder, exec, CEO, look, if they have taste, if this is a good company, if this is a tier one or tier 2 company, you have to show product insight. You have to show insight. You have to show some degree of mind meld. Meaning you have to show to this person that over time that like you can complete each other's sentences. That means you have to like align at their level. Okay? You have to like try consciously to gel with their personality. All right. So you will have to make that change. Don't expect them to make that change. And then lastly, you also have to show complimentary skills because that's why again that they are hiring someone.

13:36 Okay. So this is how you drastically increase your odds. Now I know you might have questions like but what words do I say and all of that but see like you are not like this is a problem when you ask okay but okay fine shares I see all this whatever tell me what to say in an interview. You are not understanding. You should sit with this slide for a week, two weeks. You should think about this. Then you can ask like what words.

14:07 You shouldn't be asking what words a minute after you see the slide. And plus, I trust everyone here again. Like if you're wondering how do I do this, let me remind you that you all in your actual product job are solving way harder problems than what I'm talking about here. Because otherwise, how are you getting stakeholders to align, how are you doing any negotiation successfully? Please put if you've been successful in very difficult negotiations with like very contentious issues like ever in your career. Anyone?

14:37 I hope most of you have. So what did you do? Did you go ask for somebody for words? Tell me the exact words. So folks, please take ownership. You can't expect to be a vice president of product CPO or some or have some big compensation even if you don't have big title ambitions. It's like you want big compensation. You can't expect to be that person and then want the words that somebody should spoon feed you for every single situation. Like how are those two beliefs compatible? Think about it.

15:09 Okay. So this is your blueprint for success but it's not everybody's because some people won't do the work. Okay. Okay. So again, if you're not willing to do the work, okay, it's fine. It's your call, right? But if you're actually willing to do the work, it's going to differentiate you. All right. Next, here's another tip. So when preparing for like a crucial interview with you usually have that final round, the dreaded interview, right? The final one.

15:35 The recruiter also tells you, "This is it. Congratulations, Alice. Congratulations, Bob. You have reached the final stage, right? This is like a actually like a video game, right? or at least those old style video games where it's the final the boss level of the game, right? This is it, right? And it's okay, you're gonna die 20 times and at the 21st time you'll succeed, right? And those of you who played video games in the ' 80s, '90s, you know what I'm talking about. This is like that this is that level, right? So basically, I used to get very nervous. I would get nervous for every interview like but I used to get super nervous like particularly even later in my career. I'll give you one example. When I was interviewing at Stripe, I cleared the interviews obviously, but then the final interview was with Patrick Collison, right? The CEO founder of Stripe and I did not know Patrick, but like I had heard enough and read enough of what he had written. I was like pretty sure that he's one of the few people in the valley. He was like clearly a better product person than I am, right? So, I was like very nervous. Normally, by that time, I was like, "Yeah, okay. I know I'm a better product person than this than most people." So whatever question they ask me, I will be able to respond in a way that creates a very productive conversation, right? And that meets or exceeds their expectations. So I had already built that much confidence, right? But still I was super nervous about the conversation with Patrick cuz it's like I might not even understand his question, right? So that was the nervousness. Now can I like fix all of that? No. But what is in my control? One of the things that I found was in my control was like I like to imagine and simulate the conversations meaning before any important conversation I'd like to simulate what is going to happen in this conversation. I found it hard to simulate this conversation. So what I did is and this is a tip that I've used after that multiple times is like whenever you're running into that situation you're going to be subject to many different inputs and our human system is such that when we get subject to very different new inputs that we are not familiar with that increases our nervousness that increases adrenaline production which is like very natural right like just evolutionary biology right it's very natural that can happen. So the logical thing to do in these situations is to reduce the degree of new inputs you are processing so that you can focus on the rest. So that is the underlying principle. Now the application of that underlying principle in this context is I just watched like a couple of videos of him and listened to a couple of podcasts with him just so that the personality the the vibe all of that is not new input any anymore to me. And surprisingly, as you do more of this, what this also does is it helps you strike a better rapport with the individual because they don't know it, but like you have had enough exposure to them that you can there's subtle things in your communication that'll change that'll make the communication seem more natural, less awkward, and help you build a better relationship even though it's the first conversation.

18:49 Okay, so this is again an advanced tip, but I strongly recommend this in cases where you can do it. Okay, now so this is another thing I this is a thing I absolutely hate about PM interview processes. This is like basically this whole these take-home assignments are just terrible. Okay, but they're actually increasing in how many companies are using them and also how much companies are using them. Okay. And so I guess what I want to point out is actually let me ask you, right? But let me ask you these take-home assignments, right? What is the typical time duration they give you? They say this exercise should take more no more than x to y hours. What is x and y? Yeah. Like something like this exercise should take no more than 3 to 4 hours, right? Does that sound familiar? Yeah. Okay. Now, those of you who've done these take home assignments, if you really have to do justice to the problem statement and all they want you to do, how long does it would it actually take in real practice?

19:47 In actual practice, how long? How many hours? Yeah, it's easily 10 to 40 hours, right? And they and why do you think they just say 3 to four hours? These are smart people, right? Like these are people who built the amazing product that we are so excited to work for that company. They're very smart. Why do they say 3 to four hours? Yeah, it's exactly that. Just to make themselves feel less guilty because there is no way they can say this exercise should take no more than 20 to 40 hours. Right? So they just say this exercise should take no more than two 3 to four hours. Now let me ask you this and those of you who have actually instituted take-home assignments in your own company, right?

20:31 Will you ever say yes to an assignment where the person actually heeded your time guidelines? Yes or no? Will you ever say yes? No, you are never going to say yes to any person that heeded your time guideline. Why? Why won't you say yes? Even though they were the only honest person, everybody else was not only dishonest but maybe even used their cousin's help or some other colleagueu's help, right? To create this assignment.

21:05 Yeah. Because we you are not comparing any assignment on the merits of the assignment itself. You are basically comparing it to other assignments you've seen. Right? And you know what? You don't even look at the content. Do you realize this? Most of your judgment is not on the content. What is it on? Like just be honest. What is it on? Visuals, presentation. Yes, exactly. This is the nonsense that's going on, right? But the problem is if you want a job, what can you do? You have to play the game they've set. So again, you should be clear. I'm not saying, oh, revolt or opt out of all of this. No, like you need a job, okay? So play along. You'll have to. That's the only practical thing to do, right? And just again, so my only hope is once you join the company, try to change it from the inside. You opting out of their assignment is not going to change their opinion one bit. Just to be clear, you don't matter. All right? You do not matter. Again, whatever your parents told you, not true. You do not matter in the grand scheme of things.

22:10 All right? So, nobody's going to change like this person opted out of our process, so we should. And even if they reconsider their approach, how does it benefit you? Even if they reconsider their approach, how does it benefit you? And then lastly, some people see thinking is like clear thinking is very rare. Everybody thinks they think clearly. Nobody thinks clearly. Okay? So like some arguments I've found from very smart people. Some arguments I've found is oh but it's not worth working for a company that doesn't come up with a rigorous take-home assignment.

22:45 But you are wrong because the hottest companies, the best companies, more than half, maybe likely 70 to 80% of these companies are doing this nonsense in their take-home assignment. So now, how do you explain it? The hottest companies, imagine your dream company. Imagine your top three dream companies whenever, right? Odds are at least one of them, likely two of them, and probably all three of them are doing the same nonsense in their take-home assignment. So now, how do you explain it? So it's not as simple as oh I don't want to work for any company like that because clearly it's not a good company.

23:19 You have to separate the two. Sometimes the company functions really well but yeah their process is suboptimal right. So anyway my suggestion is just at least for your top five target companies just take the time you need unfortunately. Okay. So here's an example of so stripe back in the day this is like 2015 had a very good assignment unfortunately after some after a point they changed it and I couldn't control everything at Stripe at the time so I didn't fight that battle but in my opinion and I don't know what it's like right now but what I'm saying is they had an amazing take-home assignment from 2015 and I have zero credit because they created that assignment before I even joined in fact I did that assignment okay so we used it up until 2017 2018 and then somebody changed it in 2019 I think they changed it and whatever but this is an example of take-home assignment at stripe but it was a data analysis exercise and a and a and a communication exercise basically where they basically said that analyze some data and then write an email to the customer explaining the results of the experiment and providing a recommendation. So it was a very practical exercise. Again, I can take zero credit for it. Somebody else came up with it before I even joined. Next, this is something I would say like most people don't do but should do, right? Like around 75% of the way through the process, make sure to ask the hiring manager, whether it's founder, exec or somebody else, whoever the hiring manager is, just bring up somehow that by this time you should have established a strong rapport with the hiring manager. Okay, so this is a requirement. This is a requirement.

25:02 All right. But assuming you have, you should now consider asking them what are they unsure about still when it comes to your candidacy because you see most people don't bring this topic up in the hiring process. It's a very natural reason. Yeah. They don't want to. It's fear. Yes. They don't want to hear they don't want they actually don't want to hear what the concerns are. So what do you do by very objectively without being like again you have to convey the right vibe. It's not like you are like digging for some spicy news. Not with that vibe but with like very objective professional vibe.

25:45 What would happen? what is the impression you're creating in the hiring manager by just asking them or inquiring by being curious about what their concerns are as it pertains to your candidacy. So the way you want to do this is you don't want it to come across as though you want the job and that's why you're asking and particularly that you want the job at all costs. Right? That's so you don't want to convey that vibe. All right. You don't want to also overly convey the growth mindset stuff, right? That's not the you have to understand like a hiring manager wants somebody for better or worse. A hiring manager wants somebody who is already grown for that role.

26:30 They would rather hire somebody who's already qualified or overqualified for the role, not somebody who will grow into the role. If given a choice, any hiring manager, including yourself, will hire somebody, all the other things being equal, will hire somebody who's already qualified or overqualified for the role rather than somebody who will grow into the role. Okay? So that is not so again, these are like nuances people miss and you read all these inspirational LinkedIn posts that have no bearing on reality but sound very good and you get influenced by this and there all garbage is filled in your head, right? So like my point is get rid of all that garbage and just see the world for what it is right and so the reason to do the manner in which you do this right is such that you what you're conveying what you're conveying is that you are very secure what you're conveying that is you are very secure about your fit for the role at the same time you're not overconfident at the same time you are genuinely ly interested that the hiring manager hired the right person because you are conveying that you care deeply about the hiring manager success and the company's success. That is the vibe you need to convey. So again the like why do I talk about this wbe because both your body language the words you use the tone you use all of that stuff matters especially in high stakes interviews. Okay. So that's why this kind of mindset and the wibe is important because if you understand the wbe you can now replicate what words it takes or what tone it takes what body language it takes. Okay.

28:12 And again if you're thinking at this moment like no shares I don't know how to no you are doing this in your product job cuz how else are you getting engineering to agree to build three features instead of two. How else are you getting marketing to agree on dropping some nonsense requirement that's going to take two more weeks and delay your launch? Like you are already using all of this. All I'm saying is use it for the most important product in your life, which is your own career.

28:40 Okay. All right. Next, I talked about how important it is to keep your previous managers in the loop, right, in your job search, right? So, not only will you get useful advice along the way, but they'll actually be more invested in you if you have kept them in the loop from very early stages, right? So, don't annoy them, by the way. Don't like text them every day, right? But the point is like they'll be more invested and if they're more invested when it comes time for a reference check, you will end up with a stronger reference because they are more invested. Okay, so here's the summary. Essentially, this is the last tip I have. This is a summary of how you maximize your chances of getting like a strong PM leadership role. Right? So this first one demonstrates that you have the ability to make an impact, that you are going to do your best to win. Then these next three show that you have the ability and the competence that they need, right?

29:37 And the last one shows that there is founder fit and culture fit. Okay.

Summary

To excel in interviews, particularly for senior product roles, candidates must focus on cognitive empathy—understanding the needs and challenges of interviewers from various functions. Rather than just answering questions, candidates should guide the conversation to reveal their qualifications and alignment with the company's goals, demonstrating their ability to create clarity and foster collaboration.

- Success in interviews hinges on cognitive empathy, not just storytelling skills.
- Understand what different interviewers (cross-functional peers, hiring managers, VCs) are truly seeking.
- Convey your track record, execution skills, and complementary abilities to align with the hiring manager's needs.
- Build rapport and demonstrate clarity, empowerment, and growth potential to your future team.
- Anticipate and address concerns about your candidacy by asking hiring managers about their uncertainties.
- Prepare for interviews by simulating conversations and familiarizing yourself with the interviewer's style.
- Engage with take-home assignments strategically, recognizing their role in the hiring process despite their flaws.
- Keep previous managers informed during your job search to secure stronger references and support.

Questions Answered

What is the key to succeeding in interviews?

Success in interviews hinges on understanding and demonstrating empathy, particularly cognitive empathy, which involves grasping the interviewer's needs and perspectives.

What do VCs and boards prioritize in candidates?

VCs and boards prioritize a candidate's track record, execution capabilities, and complementary skills to the existing leadership.

How can candidates effectively connect with interviewers?

Candidates should convey empowerment and investment in the growth of their team while aligning with the hiring manager's vision and demonstrating complementary skills.

How can candidates prepare for interviews to improve communication?

Candidates should familiarize themselves with the interviewer's personality and style through research to enhance rapport and make communication more natural.

What should candidates know about take-home assignments in interviews?

Candidates should be aware that take-home assignments often require more time than suggested and should proactively address any uncertainties about their candidacy during the interview process.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram