Transcript
0:02 Hi, welcome everyone. Thank you for joining our webinar today. Um, we're super excited. This is our last trusted family webinar for the year and I think we have a really exciting topic and a really awesome family that's going to share some of their best practices about NextGen development. So, thank you very much to the Gilbane family um for joining us and being willing to um talk about this topic. Um, I'm joined today by Brianna Cole, Ryan Gilbane, and Chip Brick, uh, fifth and sixth gen family members from the Gilbane family. Um, really quick before we get started, um, I'll introduce myself and talk about Trusted Family for just a couple of minutes while we, uh, wait for everyone to join and log on today. Um, so I'm Katie Darnell. I'm the business development director for Trusted Family in the US and Canada. I've been with the company about four years and I am also a fourthgen family member and nextgen member of a family business based in Tennessee. So also personally excited to learn a lot from this webinar today. Um so for those of you who may be new, never joined a trusted family webinar before um Trusted Family is a software company. We were founded by two nextgens and family businesses um that were based in Belgium. We've been around for about 15 years now and we have over 200 clients across the world. That is family businesses and family offices. Um and our primary goal as a software company is to help family enterprises um solve communication and governance issues using technology.
1:34 Um and we hope that our goal is by using this technology uh family enterprises will just be able to operate better as a whole. um in order to um anchor that technology, we also build out a community. We have a success team that works very hard to build out the community of clients that we have and they will um put on a couple of in-person events a year and run virtual events throughout the year too where we highlight and bring on either an adviser or a client and family just like the Gilbane family to share best practices.
2:05 Uh we believe that um sharing best practices, hearing directly from the families um just helps make the whole community better. So with that um couple of housekeeping items. There is a Q&A in the webinar today. So as we go throughout the webinar, if you um come up with a question that you want answered, just please put it there and we will get to it either throughout or at the end of the webinar. Um, and so with that, I'm going to uh let my um other panelists here introduce themselves. I'm going to let Brianna start.
2:39 Hello everyone. It's a pleasure to be here with you. My name is Brianna Cole. I am a fifth gen in-law family member of the Gilbane family. I have been uh working on our family council for eight years, five of which I was the chair of our council and I now co-chair the nextgen committee with uh Ryan Gilbane who you'll hear from in a moment. Uh I this is a volunteer or I should say not a full-time job. Um I do also work in financial services in my day job helping other families and I have two young kids um that are five and three. My husband works for our operating business and we live just right outside of Boston, Massachusetts.
3:24 >> All right. Hi everyone. My name is Ryan Gilbane. Um I'm a fifth generation family member of the Gilbane family. Um as well as a member of the Gilbane family council for just about the last 5 years. Um I do not work for Gilbane uh Gilbane Construction Company. Um, I actually work for a company called Propeller, uh, which is a software platform to manage construction and earthwork sites through 3D drone mapping. Um, prior to that, I had a couple of kind of more unconventional jobs, I would say. I was a wildland firefighter in Oregon for some time and a commercial fisherman up in Alaska before uh, coming to Propeller about 5 years ago. And I did grow up interning with Gilbane Building Company um for years and years. Uh it was my first job when I was 14 years old. So kind of grew up in and around the family company. Um although after uh school I went to the University of Denver, pivoted and kind of went to more of a technology um side of the construction industry. So very excited to be here um and chat to everyone about Gilbane NextG and some of the things we've been doing with uh family education over here.
4:39 Great. Um, Katie, appreciate you and the the Trusted Family Network um for having us on today. My name is Chip Brderick. I'm a sixth generation member of the Gilbang family. I grew up in Rhode Island and I went to Brown um like many others before me uh in our family. I live and and work in Boston now. Um and I've held positions on both the debt and equity side of the real estate business. Um, today I work for GI, which is a real estate private equity firm based in Boston. Um, it's actually a third generation family business founded by the Wallace family in the 1960s. Um, and we primarily invest in multifamily and industrial real estate across the US. um with large institutional separate accounts. Um and so similar to Ryan, I spent multiple summers growing up interning at Gilbane. So very familiar with the business. I have a father who's very involved in the business. Um and my relevance here today is I'm not on the family council. Um but I was part of the original uh NextGen cohort. So I'm here to, you know, share my experience and some of the takeaways um that I had from the programming that Bri and Ryan put together. Awesome.
5:57 Awesome. Thank you guys so much. Um, so we actually have a couple of PowerPoint slides that we're going to start with. Um, Brianna's going to share kind of their family governance story to help set up how they came um to these NextGen initiatives. So, I'm going to work on sharing my screen here. Um, and I'm going to let the three of them take it away. Okay. Excellent. Thank you. So, um, for many of you, our family can act as a glimpse into the future. Here on the slide, you see a photo. This is from our 2022 Gilbane Family Summit.
6:34 This is an event that we host every 3 years where we get our family together uh, usually at a fun resort uh, to really work on our family bonding and our family glue and building relationships between all of us. Here pictured are 207 of our family members. Uh we have fourth through seventh generation represented and for the last eight years I've been involved with our family governance through our family council as I mentioned. Um and for those of you who are not familiar with us, we were founded in 1870 as a construction company in Rhode Island. We are now one of the largest general contractors globally and we also have a real estate and development company that was founded in 1970. We specialize in large-scale commercial construction and while we have many projects, I believe the number right now is 750 active projects. Some of our claims to fame um are that we've been one of the largest builders of K through2 schools in the United States.
7:31 We joint ventured on one of the largest uh projects in the history of the United States, the Exxon Mobile campus. We've built many of our nation's iconic buildings including the world World War II Memorial, the Vietnam War Memorial, and the Lake Placid Olympics. Uh we are right now working on the Buffalo Bills Stadium. So something a little high-profile. Um we are entirely family-owned and have been throughout our entire history. Um so here on this slide, what you're seeing, oh, if you go back to the previous slide, Katie, sorry. Um, we currently have 230 living family members. I actually presented this slide in March and at that time we had 211. So somehow in nine months we've added 19 family members uh to our family which just speaks to how quickly we are growing and this includes both spouses and children. Uh we have as I mentioned four living generations and you can see on this slide how many people we have in each generation and the estimated ages.
8:31 If you go to the next slide, as a business, we've been in commercial construction real estate for over 150 years. We have 3,100 employees. Uh, and our current revenues are about 7 and a half billion and we have 45 offices globally. So, a little history on the timeline of our governance specifically. Um, in 1952 we was when our foundation was founded by our third generation uh, family members, but it really didn't play an active role and didn't serve as an integral part of our family governance until much more recently. In 1998, we formed our first independent board of directors. And in 2004, the need for a family council was identified and a task force was created to work on the structure alongside Harvard University.
9:23 And the council was officially launched in 2005, so almost 20 years ago. In 2007, we established a voting trust which uh helps aggregate our our a voting shares and elect our independent board of directors. In 200 uh 21, our family foundation was overhauled and established as an independent nonprofit and now plays a much more integral role in our family continuity and family giving. So if we go to our next slide, um this is our senior corporate leadership which at the moment comprises of three family members which are highlighted in red and one non-family member who is currently the CEO of our construction company. Um Chip's father is highlighted here as well on the right hand side. Um on the next slide we have um our board of directors is actually going through a bit of a transition at the moment. So there's a lot of them listed here, but um we have a good mix of both independent and family uh corporate board of directors. We will our family members will drop to to two at the end of this year. And we have both fourth and fifth generations represented. We're honored to have a really talented group of independent board of directors who help us run our our corporation.
10:42 On the next slide, I wanted to uh this is our family foundation board. Um, and I really like this slide because it allows us to demonstrate the diversity and our governance structures. So on the bottom left, you're going to see a legend that indicates our fifth gen in yellow. Um, our sixth gen are blue and then our spouses are in red. And in fact, on our foundation, we have spouses of both our fifth and our sixth generation family members serving.
11:10 Um on the next slide is our voting trust. So over the past few years we have successfully transitioned the leadership on our voting trust from our fourth to our fifth generation. In fact you're not going to see fourth generation on any of our family governance structures anymore. So that has been a big succession um big succession work of ours over the last decade or so. On the next slide, uh you're going to see our family council which is similarly diverse by both generation and in-laws including myself in red.
11:45 And if you go to the next slide, um so our family council currently has seven committees. Until about two years ago, the council had much more of a top-down structure. Um but we revamped the structure to a hub and spoke model. We have the chair sitting in the middle uh who really helps coordinate and organize most of the work being done on the committee level. I don't want to diminish the amount of work that our chair does. Uh it is it is a big job and we're incredibly grateful for our family members who are willing to lead um this robust governance structure. But our committees are the ones that are really in charge of executing the the work that they're responsible for. Our committees will change based on the needs of the family. And a big reason for the restructuring was to accommodate our fast growing family and increase um and the increased demands on our council. So for many of you uh that have cousin consortium families like ours, you can sympathize with the challenges of continuing to develop a deep bench of family members that are both able and willing to serve on these structures. So we have found that a committee structure helps develop our our bench of talent.
12:57 So um if you look at our current committees, we have communications which is where we distribute information down to our family members. We use Instagram, we use text messages, we use email newsletters as ways as well as other ways to communicate. Legacy and technology, I just have to shout this one out. This was our committee that really helped us implement trusted family. uh this has been a couple of year effort and it's been an integral part of the way that we can effectively communicate and aggregate our family together in a digital way. So that's been a big addition to our governance structure. Um our summit is that event that we start kicked it off with at the beginning uh a big event that we host every three years. We have uh usually three other events on an annual basis at a smaller level. Uh but the summits are really big one.
13:45 >> And Bri, what what's the participation rate on the summit? Like what percentage of the family do we get there? >> Thanks for asking, Chip. Yeah, for the summit, we usually get high 90s participation. So almost every single family member uh will attend. Sometimes we're contesting with a wedding or two that might might get in the way, but generally we have everybody there, which is a a really big something that we're very proud of. We have personal philanthropy which is separate uh from our foundation. It's really just to highlight the philanthropic works of our family members. Our planning committee works on other events. NextGen which we're going to spend uh time talking about today and then education which really helps develop our education curriculum.
14:25 So the last slide that I'll cover is um really just uh about the work that all these governance structures do. There's many many things that we tried to accomplish, but some of them are the transitions um from family management to non-family management over the years. We've done the succession planning from our fourth generation to the fifth generation, election of non uh family board members, educating and communicating with the family, creating family glue and event planning, formalizing our nextgen curriculum, maintaining government's documents and frameworks, and then investing in and implementing technology for the family.
15:04 So, I'm going to go ahead and uh now that we've given you a bit of an overview of just our our broad structure, we're going to dig into the meat of the topic today, which is about our NextGen program. So, I'm going to kick it over to Ryan to cover uh to to start that conversation for us. Thank you. >> Thanks, Bri. Um so, as you have just seen, uh the Gilbane family has really been growing exponentially generation over generation. Um, I think just the stat that Bri said earlier about in between in the nine months in between giving this presentation, we added 19 family members to our family consortium.
15:44 And so as his family has been growing exponentially, we started to really see a difference between shared experiences and learning opportunities for some of the previous generations that were a much smaller base of of family um family members, company owners as compared to looking forward to future generations with this exponential growth curve. Um, as you just saw also, the Gilbane Family Council has been great at leading family education between quarterly events, doing programming around shareholder meetings as well as in these um summits that we do every 3 years. But it kind of started to raise some questions about how do we keep future generations engaged, right? How do we build a family glue that has really kept our family together and engaged and participating in the company acting as um engaged stewards of the company as we're growing exponentially as people are starting to live all all across the country as well and especially with more and more people working outside the company how do what's the best method of sharing knowledge of Gilbane sharing some of the core tenants of Gilbane that previous generations really were able to um work and collaborate on organically. And so this started some conversations uh within the family council as well as within previous generations about what does that look like? What does educating the next generation of of conscious stewards of Gilbane look like? And so this kind of started um some thoughts between Bri, myself, the rest of the family council about building a nextgen Gilbane education program with really the the need to uh or rather with the desire to keep family members engaged building that family glue.
17:42 So some of the core ideas that we were thinking about was really like I said before educ educating the future generation of shareholders. Um it's building the knowledge to be responsible stewards of Gilbane. Um as well as kind of helping to add a diversity of knowledge to this next cohort that could help throughout their careers and help build engagement um as well as participation within shareholder meetings, summits, things like that. Um the another aspect of it is with such a large family, 230 living family members, how do we kind of cultivate a healthy and active network networking opportunity between some of these younger generation family members? How do we kind of open the tap of knowledge between some of the older generation family members who work within Gilbane as well as outside of Gilbane? And so this kind of gave birth to this nextgen education program with Gilbane. So one of the um aspects of this nextgen program that we were really excited about uh about was building some more bespoke education to this next generation cohort. So for the first year of the nextgen Gilbane program, we focused on the 20 to 30 year old age group. Um, we felt that this is a group that as our family is expanding quite rapidly, might not have as many organic opportunities to go and spend afternoons together to hang out outside of these more formalized shareholder meetings or summits. And so one of the main goals was to bring this cohort of younger uh younger shareholders together to engage with each other to participate in an education program with more likeminded and similar experience level peers. Um as well as to um like I said before give give exposure to some of the other generations. We have a ton of family members who work with Gilbane Building Company as well as even more who work outside of it, right? How are we fostering collaboration between some of those non-family employees with some of this next generation to pass on some of that knowledge and information. So, like I said before, there was a real focus on kind of building this next generation of knowledge and confidence with these younger shareholders. um as well as creating that family glue that that kind of organic participation that they might not have gotten as people are living in California as well as the East Coast, right? They don't quite have as many opportunities to come together um in an in an organic way. So that being said, we did run the first uh iteration of the NextGen Gilbane program um which Chip was a member of that cohort. And so with that, I will pass it over to Chip to chat a bit more about what that looked like um as well as some of the curriculum that we that we covered in that program.
20:54 >> Sure. Yeah. No, appreciate it, Ryan. And you know, obviously appreciate all the the hard work that you and Bri put into establishing the program. Um I thought like just as a starting point um to create a more um bespoke version of next generation education was one of the things that attracted me um to join the nextgen cohort. Um I believe our total program was 10 people something like that. Um, and these people were really committed to learning more. Um, and they were committed to showing up, right? So, we had multiple in-person sessions, um, and then Zoom sessions with cameras on that you had to be a part of, right? And I think that accountability of having to show up was really important in the success of this program um, versus just shooting out um, a wide Zoom call to, you know, the next generation, right?
21:52 It's like you're accountable for one year to show up and and to really learn and be engaged. Um so I thought that that's kind of an overarching theme that Brienne Ryan did a great job of really getting um people engaged. When I look at kind of that last slide and the goals of the program and my experience within it, I break it down into really like three categories. The first being building shareholder knowledge and confidence. The second being creating that strong network amongst family members that are no longer quite as close as the previous generations and the third being leadership, self-development and other skill sets that we can learn outside of the family business. So in terms of building shareholder knowledge and confidence, um you know, we had a one-on-one with the Gilbane CFO to walk through financial statements, right? Like what are the packages that we receive every quarter?
22:48 How do we read through these? What are the entities that make up Gil Bane? Right? Um we also heard from the the building company and the development company leadership on how the businesses historically have run, where they're going, and it's a really um it's a unique opportunity because there's only 10 people in the room and you're with company leadership, right? And so instead of it being a shareholder meeting where there's a hundred people and there's a lot of big personalities in the family, like you're one of the younger generation that can ask questions and you feel more comfortable um doing sh doing so. I think Brienne Ryan also did a great job incorporating family businesses in our education that weren't just Gilbane. Um we had Devin Dantis who um works with LGA Global who advises our family and our family council and our family foundation. He came and spoke on contextualizing Gilbane within like the broader landscape of family businesses, right?
23:48 So placing Gilbane um within that landscape. Um and then we also um heard from or we read a Harvard Business School case study on Carvajal um which is a South American printing and packaging company. And then we had someone from the family actually come and speak to us on how they dealt with succession planning, how they're structured, how their nextgen programming works, right? And so it's not just education within the business but also you know bringing in outsiders to contextualize how our family business um fits into that broader landscape. On the second point in terms of creating the strong network amongst family members, I think it's important like when you look at our family tree, um when we go to these summits that we talk about and there's 90% participation, we got 230 family members. Like our family tree is so damn wide. Like we can't fit it um on one single billboard. It's like four billboards attached, right? And through this program, like I'm on one side of the billboard. Brien Ryan might be a little more central, but I met people on the complete other side of the billboard that I would have never gotten to known uh know otherwise. And so it creates those connections that you wouldn't have just um through your direct family. Um and kind of going back um in terms of connection, I think for next generation programming, it's super vital to have um in-person meetings. we kind of bookended it where we did um one after the shareholder meeting in Providence and then we had kind of a capstone in Chicago at the end of the program. Um and having those in-person meetings makes you a lot more comfortable to speak up on a Zoom call and to get to know your fellow family members. So I thought that that was really good. And then I also think in creating those connections it's one about you know learning about the business. So for example, our capstone in Chicago, like you know, we for the Gilbane Chicago office. We went on a site tour, so we got to see the tangible part of the business. Again, we heard from company leadership. Um, but also we did fun things. We went on an architectural tour of Chicago, right? We did deep dish pizza together. We went to dart bars. We did dinners. We had drinks together. And so that kind of organic stuff um also helps in creating um more of a cohesive next generation. And then lastly, just to quickly touch on the self-development and leadership skills, um you know, I think Bri and Ryan, not to toot your horn so many times, but like you did a great job leveraging um you know, both company resources, but also resources outside of the company, right? Like I'm sure everyone on this call has family members who are super capable and in you know dynamic parts of their career who can come and speak to the next generation who don't even work for the family business. Um so we had someone from our family who's a 35 year investment banker come and talk about corporate finance and transactions. Bri spoke um for two hours on family trust planning and financial planning. Right?
27:01 And so these are all skills that I didn't have beforehand. They're not even that related to Gilbane, but they're just good educational skills. Um, and then in terms of leveraging business resources, we had Gilbane HR. So, we're using like the actual infrastructure of Gil Bane. We had them come in and we did a personality test on all the different cousins. Um, and so people got to learn a little bit more about their personalities, what their strengths were, what their weaknesses were. um and really understanding and driving that that self-development. So, when I look back on the year, like it was great. Um a lot of different uh educational points. I think you know me and all the other members of our cohort were probably more engaged um and more educated than we were prior. Um and we there were skills there that I didn't have prior that I came out either about the company or not about the company. um that I developed through the program and I think you know most importantly when when we go through those councils and the family trusts and everything like you need people who are engaged to participate so I think by participating in this nextgen program you know you're going to have people in the next generation who are more likely to contribute to the business or the family council um or to the family foundation or to get involved. Um, so I think that that's kind of my key takeaways and some of the the programming that that Bri and Ryan put together.
28:34 >> Awesome. Thank you so much, Chip. Um, so we actually we've got about 25 questions that have come through. So, um, before before I jump into those though, um, I was curious, um, this probably for Bri and Ryan. Can you talk through a little bit about the pre-planning that led up to um to creating this cohort? you know, what resources did you pull from? How long did it take you to put together the cohort in order to to fully launch it?
29:01 Um, and how did you figure out who the first 10 people were going to be to go through it? >> Yeah, happy happy to. So, we I served as chair of the council for five years before really uh starting this nextG program. So, this had been something I had been incubating in my brain for for many years. We really as a family probably one of the weaknesses of our governance structure is that we haven't been great at doing bespoke education by demographic and we still this program is a great start but we still have a long way to go. We don't really have much targeted to our our really young family members high school college. Um so we certainly want to build upon what we've started here but um a couple things to get started. one we we really wanted it to be the people the participants as Chip alluded to needed to have buyin. So it was an application process. Um people needed to want to apply to the program and we set very clear uh guidelines at the beginning as to what the commitment commitment was going to be. So we already had the full 10 months of dates planned out where they were going to be, what times they were going to be so that if they applied, uh we made it very clear that the expectation is that they were going to attend all of it, you know, obviously within reason. Some things come up, but um so that that was number one. So we needed buyin on both sides. I think I've seen a lot of NextGen programs in other families where I think people get frustrated because they develop a curriculum and then they sort of push it out there and there's not a lot of uptake. And so I think that that was one aspect of this program that I thought was was really critical. Um, you know, Chip highlighted very eloquently, you know, a handful of the different uh programs that we uh started. Um, so there's a lot of resources we needed. Trusted family was a really great aspect of this. We obviously created a group within our trusted family uh platform. That's where we did the application process through.
30:55 That's where we had our messaging boards. that's where all of the content material was posted, etc. So, we being able to have a technology platform to help run this is really crucial. Um, and then having access to the networks that that Chip uh talked about, our family members generally get a lot of Gilbane education, right? If they're going to shareholder meetings, if they're going to things, they're hearing stuff about the corporation. And so, the other thing that was really, really important to Ryan and I was that this felt very exclusive. This was content that other families weren't getting access to. We have some really funny stories about this. In fact, um so Ryan's father being one of the violators and we would have some sessions and all of a sudden like fourthgens would be creeping into the back of the room and sitting trying to hear what we were talking to our nextgens about and we'd have to sort of kick them out because the whole concept is that you're going to apply to this, you're going to commit to the program, but you're going to get content that you're not going to get anywhere else.
31:54 Um, and I think that exclusivity of the program um really helped elevate the content and make it desirable for for everyone. Um, so because there was so much interest by older generations even, we've talked about as a council uh about expanding it to to other other ages. Um, and so I would just say, you know, one of the challenges though is that this kind of program takes a lot of resources. And so I think that's one of our challenges going forward is making sure that we continue to have people interested in the program, but also that we can resource it effectively. You know, it's a lot of work on people like Ryan and I to execute this. We had a lot of other help through the council and other parts of our business to execute, but it it does take a lot of resources to keep it going.
32:40 >> And Bri, just to add on to that, um a couple thoughts here. First was on um kind of this optin side of this programming. I think it was like Bri said really important to have buyin from that next generation that we were targeting. Right? if we had rolled it out and said, "Hey, we're doing this program, you know, webinars at this time, um I I think it would have been I think that we probably would have had less engagement, but by kind of having it be an application process, um sharing a flyer with some of the sessions and some of the curriculum that was put together both by Bri and myself, but also by leveraging some of the resources we had brought in to help run some of these modules. Um, I think that that really helped build out the depth of the curriculum in addition to the breadth of it. Um, also by leveraging trusted family as the application platform, it really felt like a clean way to bring in all of these applications in an easy to digest place. So, it was an opt-in, it was an application process to uh join the NextG cohort. Um from there we kind of went through some of the different applications that went that uh came in and one of the main goals was to create a space where people felt comfortable being with like-minded and of similar experience peers. So that was definitely a big um criteria in terms of selecting the people in this next uh in this nextgen program, right? to kind of build that comfortable space where as opposed to shareholder meetings where someone might not want to speak up and ask what they might think of as a dumb question, um really kind of creating that almost safe space mentality so that we could have 10 people in a room with the CFO and ask questions that older generations might know the answer to, but they might feel a little bit less comfortable speaking up and and asking that question.
34:38 And so I think that the kind of opt-in the application process definitely drove um engagement both within the platform and in terms of interest in the in the program. Um and I also think that looking forward to future iterations of this program and and future iterations of more bespoke education, I think that this program was a really great marketing tool as well. Right? We saw older generations really interested in the curriculum in some of these sessions to the point where they were kind of like Brie said, my dad was a violator of this, sneaking into the back of the room and and propping up his phone trying to kind of take pictures of the slides and and about some of the uh content of of our sessions. But I think it really drove a desire from other generations, not just this 20some year old cohort, to be more engaged and to learn about this stuff because although a lot of the curriculum was outside of the typical Gilbane shareholder meeting content, um I think it I I got a ton of feedback saying, "Hey, we want this education for for future generations, for the 50year-olds, for the 60-year-olds, right? It's stuff that um the I think the breadth and the depth of the curriculum as well as kind of that exclusivity really drove some desire to expand our education into more um bespoke bespoke groups.
36:04 >> And I I think also like and correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm sure when you guys reached out to different family members to help out, like they're happy to do it. Like the people within the business are so passionate about the business. They want it to go to the next generation. and they want people to receive that education and then the people outside of the business want to talk about what they've done with their career. They want to help the next generation of their family, right? And so once you, you know, reach out and engage with those people, they're actually pretty willing to buy in. At least that's what I saw on my end. Um and so, you know, just asking the question and, you know, getting people to buy in I feel like is easier um you know, once you once you ask.
36:46 >> Awesome. So, a couple of questions that are coming in. Um, so did you have to decline people when they applied and you only wanted to keep it to 10 and how did you guys handle that? >> Yeah, I was I was going to jump in on this. So, we're really not in the business of turning away family members who want an educational opportunity. Um, so we had announced that we were going to take between 8 and 12. Um, we didn't have to decline anyone. actually got a perfect we we did have one person apply and then in kind of pushing them on their ability to actually commit the time. Uh it was mutually agreed upon that he just wasn't going to be able to attend in a way that was effective and we didn't want to degrade the program by accepting him and then not having him actually attend. So one person sort of mutually opted out. Um but no, we didn't have to decline. I think the real purpose of the uh having an application process is twofold. One to have the buyin, right? it's it you have to actually put the effort in to apply which indicates that you actually want to be there. And two, we do want the group size to be manageable. So, you know, if we had ended up with 13 applicants instead of 12, would we have taken all 13? Probably. But if we had had 20, we probably wouldn't have. Um, now, you know, we're making this up as we go, so we could have gotten creative and maybe pre-populated the next year's program with 10, you know. So, we're not trying to turn away people, but we are trying to create that um barrier to entry and that buyin is the real purpose of the application process.
38:10 >> Here I was thinking it was exclusive this whole time, you know, and everyone was accepted. >> Yeah. Well, Chip Chip, the other the other joke is that now we have our clause in use that we can bring you into all of our governance structures. It's really a good recruiting tool, too. >> Um, another question from our audience. um what do you think has contributed over the decades to the uh well says that it seems like you have a really great positive family spirit and that you guys have really been doing a great job of driving that family glue. So what do you think has contributed over the decades to that positive spirit in your family because not all families um they still have low engagement and some more difficult relationships. And so if there's a couple of things that you could share that you think maybe help contribute to that.
39:02 >> So >> yeah, >> I I have a couple thoughts here. So I feel lucky to have grown up in what I kind of think about as kind of the central hub of Gilbane, which is Rhode Island, right? That's where Gilbane is headquartered. And so I had the opportunity to intern with Gilbane as well as interact with a lot of cousins, uncles, and other family members who are local to Rhode Island. But I think especially as we get older and people start to naturally move out um across the country, I think coming back together and having events like the Gilman family summit that we do every 3 years has been really massive in terms of continuing to build that spirit, build that family glue and keep people engaged with each other as well as the business, right? Kind of having an excuse to come together. Um we have gone to two different locations for the Gilbian Summit within the last I guess nine years now. Um one was up in New Hampshire and another was in New York kind of both out in the mountains. And so I think that by going to a location um and kind of billing it as a weekend with cousins with family members as well as education on the business um in addition to some shareholder information and education. Um, I think that really kind of was enough of a draw to attract people out to these summits, um, and kind of foster a space to engage with each other naturally. And so, yeah, I think that the summits have been great as well as kind of that um, I guess I was lucky to experience just kind of the the natural um, gathering being kind of based in Rhode Island close to the company.
40:47 >> Yeah. Do you want to talk about the family council because I feel like the family council has been so instrumental um over the last 15 years in getting people together and all that? >> Yes. So, so I'll jump in a little bit. I'm I'm an in-law, so I did not uh grow up around the Gilbane family. So, I have a bit of a different perspective. Um, so my my perspective is a little bit more I guess academic on sort of governance and just an observation of learning a lot about family businesses. So I would say first of all there have certainly been times in the 154 year history of this family that things got really difficult and we don't want to paint this picture of you know we just got here with without any issues and so I think that what in my observations and hearing stories is that it's all about really understanding what the goals of the family are right there has been a very rich culture within this family that historically that we wanted to keep this family business a family business and so in order to do that successfully that has taken a lot of sacrifice from a lot of family members particularly I would say in our third and fourth generations and so sometimes that's ac you know economic sacrifice right you there might have been opportunities to make more money but for the cohesion and keeping the business familyowned um there was emotional sacrifice there was certainly labor I mean we've had some family members dedicate their lives to making the is what it is. Um, and you know, own ownership in the company isn't equal and is not merit-based, right? I mean, you're you're born into the number of shares that you have and that's does not always equal the amount of work and effort that goes into the business. And we've seen some family members really um just dedicate their skill and blood and sweat and tears into this business um even if that wasn't always, you know, the most equal scenario. So uh we have to just just uh commend that and that is a very strong cultural uh value within the family. Gilbane has very very deep values and those are really communicated um throughout throughout the family. I think there's also something that I've observed um having spoken to lots of other families and and this is certainly part of the council piece is that I think a lot of families start to mix uh corporate governance and family governance into one pot and I think it's really crucial that you separate those two right so for example our corporate board is a corporate board it deals with running our operations and the operations of the business it is not a forum for shareholders and family owners to bring their grievances to uh key leadership. That needs to happen in a very separate format. And so that's why we have a very intentional division between what happens in our operating business and what happens amongst family owners. And I think sometimes that can get really blurred in family businesses.
43:47 And that can be the same people. It can certainly be the same people that are running your, you know, if you don't have 230 family members. If you have 10 family members, you're obviously going to have overlap between your corporate structure and your family structure. But I think you have to create a really firm boundary between what conversations are having being had in what context. Um if you think about a publiclyun company, you don't have shareholders knocking on the corporate board um being like I didn't like your dividend or I didn't you know whatever the the grievance is of the day. So I think you have to have really firm boundaries of where you can have appropriate conversations and develop those those channels. Um so and so that's I would say where the council really came in was to be that place where we could have shareholder um and family related I want to say issues on the negative side but also we spend a lot of time it's like raising toddlers.
44:37 I have two toddlers. You want to spend a lot more time rewarding good behavior than knocking down bad behavior. So we really spend a lot of time on that culture and value piece of highlighting the the successes of our other family members and you know touting the fact that we get a 98% rate at our summits and all these big wins that we have really overcome um you know some of the more challenges and I would say you know the the fourth generation sacrificed a lot for us and there's that that was really challenging for them but I will say that what we've done um as a family really well is that some of the difficulties that the fourth generation might have on a relationship side really hasn't permeated down to the fifth, right? Our fifth generation and sixth generation cousins get along really well. Um, and so that's I think just a testament to overcoming those challenges that many family businesses experience.
45:29 >> Yeah. And I and I think like the fourth generation like to give them their flowers like they also put together um the board of director like the outside board of directors, right? And so like when I look about look at the family business that I you know am a part of today at G versus Gil Bane like they're a third generation um family business they don't have an outside board of directors um it's two brothers who are still alive who are in their 90s right um but as you move um through the generations it's really important I think and it it it helps to create some you know peace um and some peace on the business operations side of things to have that um outside board of directors um you know expertise um and perspective um and then to Ryan's point like I also grew up in Rhode Island got to be around the business have a dad who's involved in the business um but I think as a family too like when we come together for the summits like there's a lot of shared values um and shared culture and a lot of people you know have a love for the outdoors and a love for the for adventure and so you know we're all very much interrelated in a lot of the passions we have which helps us um connect um and So, we do events outside of the summit, too. We do a family ski trip majority of years. Um, and then also like most recently, we all gathered for the Brown Harvard football game and then we'll do it up in Boston when Brown and Harvard play up here and in Providence. And so, you know, finding those um ways and those things that people are passionate about um and finding different ways for people to connect would be um you know, my two cents.
47:04 Um, so another question we have is after the initial cohort, what edits to the programming for the nextG would you make? If any, how would you change the program going forward? And uh maybe also like what are what are you looking to do maybe next in this process? >> Yeah. So a couple a couple of things. Um we're rearranging the order of the of the content a little bit. Um so for example, Chip highlighted that we did an insights personality test. I don't know if any of you guys have done something similar to that. We did that at the end.
47:36 Um, and in retrospect, we probably should have done that in the beginning so that everybody had an idea of how to work together from the beginning. So, there's certainly some rearranging of the components. Um, we got a lot of 20-year-olds in the first cohort. We'd like to get more 30-year-olds, but I think a lot of 30-year-olds have kids and other things. So, um, we're probably we're doing a paired down version of the program for them just from a time commitment standpoint. Um and um so those are probably the the biggest things but it is hard to continue to you know keep interest and and resource this and both from both ends. So you know just adapting as we adapt it to different age groups but overall um I think it went pretty well.
48:21 So we're not making huge tweaks to it. And to add to that, I think that uh some of the feedback that we had gotten from older generations was that a lot of the curriculum and content that we went over would resonate with them as well. And so in terms of changes to curriculum or content, I think we're looking less at that um and more about kind of opening it up and making it accessible to other age groups and other demographics and kind of coming to them a little bit more. um where the 30somes are getting married and having kids and might have a little bit less time to dedicate to a full year-long program. But I think in terms of the curriculum, keeping some of that going, um I know that we got some great feedback about involvement of um speakers and presenters who are outside the family and so kind of running some of that back as well. But yeah, I think some of the biggest changes would be I guess tweaks to the order of the curriculum as well as um as well as changing the length of the program to try to attract other groups and other demographics.
49:29 >> Um do you guys um have opportunities for your next generation to engage with other NextGen members from other family businesses? Was that part of the cohort or um how do you encourage that within within the generations if you do at all? >> We really we really haven't. I mean we've had speakers come from other um organizations. Um I've sort of discussed this with other f I you know I have a pretty broad network of other family businesses. So we've sort of threatened to make this happen which would be awesome but just like everything time and energy is always a a limited resource. So it's a it's a great idea, but we have not formalized any real structure to do that at this point in time.
50:10 >> We have enough people to meet within our own family um before we go to others. But >> um another quick question. Um so obviously you guys have a huge family. You're deep in the generations right now. Um any advice for smaller families that don't quite have just in sheer numbers of family members? Um you know the the bench strength just yet to pull from to get involved in the process. Any any advice for families on where they need to start um or kind of how they can maybe trim it down a little bit to fit um how the size of their own family.
50:46 >> Sure. I mean we obviously have a unique situation and having a lot of people that we can pull from. Just to give you an idea, um, we have, well, at least when we did the program two years ago, we had 35 20 somethings. So, we have a big family to pull from. So, I'm sympathetic to that. I I would say generally um obviously if you have three or four nextgens, quote unquote, your a program like ours probably isn't um as applicable. But I would say in general, my point of view is that the younger generations are always going to be more capable than I think the older generations tend to give them credit for. And so what we try to really do is create scenarios where they can um you know really flex that muscle. And so I think that can look a few ways. I think um transparency and communication is vital. I I I'm not really sure that um limiting communication with the nextgens, especially once they're sort of already out of college and launching their own careers and things like that is helpful. I think that we're trying to build really good stewards and really good shareholders. And in order to do that, they need to have information and they need to be given the space to make mistakes and to ask stupid questions. And um I think that you know you don't want the scenario where you have you know a 95year-old patriarch and he hasn't given up anything until the next generation is 65 or 70 you know I mean you've sort of lost the generations and the opportunity to really foster that bench of talent.
52:18 Um, and so it looks a little different in our family because our 20-year-olds are, you know, they're not all vying to become the CEO of our business in the same way, but we have a real opportunity to create a growth mindset amongst our generations. And so we really value them having big fulfilling careers where they're having their own success. Um, and so we view the our platform as a way to to leverage that. So I guess in in part I would say find scenarios to give them the opportunities to really grow to fail to ask questions give transparency and give them accountability. I think people um are very good at rising up to the challenges that you give them. And so that's the kind of the mindset that that we try to take. Um you know how you actually execute that on on your family level you know that's very bespoke to you. Happy to talk offline if if we want to brainstorm on those ideas. I think education, like to your point, Bri, like education is the most important thing, like you know, making sure people have information that gets to them. Um because I feel like in a lot of, you know, um younger family businesses, um the information isn't disseminated, uh quite as well or it's held between a couple of people. And so, you know, encouraging, you know, people to learn about the business, the growth mindset as Brie said, and, you know, to get educated on it and to encourage that rather than try to to hide things, um, would be my thing. And then, you know, secondly, it's like leverage what you do have. Um, you know, I talked about us bringing in certain family members who are outside of the business, um, who had interesting careers for us to hear about, right? And we've done similar stuff at our um summits where we have career panels of people who work at technology companies that are completely not associated with Gilbane, right? And so, you know, leverage the resources that your family does have, even if it's not the same resources as a as a company that's, you know, seven generations old, whatever, leverage what you do have and and bring in, you know, the family members who are willing to dedicate their time.
54:24 >> Yeah. I also think that um I completely agree with that point, Chip, about education and exposure and I think really kind of trying to cultivate the opportunities to exposure that that you might have access to. I remember growing up doing internships with a company and we would have um a couple say three or four family members interning at the company at one time and just taking an opportunity to sit down with the CEO and have a have a casual lunch and right just kind of do more of kind of a I don't want to say fireside chat but just more of a casual experience where there is the opportunity to ask questions that might not be raised in in a shareholder meeting or something like that right it's I think So much of it obviously depends on where you are as a family and a company as well as the goals of kind of what's next and and what um you want to build into an education program. But I think a lot of that again starts from exposure and casual conversations and just being I guess giving the footing to be able to kind of like I said ask the quote unquote quote unquote dumb questions. Um and and just more interaction the better, right? I think it's exposure. I think it's opportunity.
55:36 And I think it's education. >> Inter internship's a a huge point too, Ryan, because like I also intern for the company. We encourage everyone to intern for the company if they have interest. And like that either drives you to say like I have interest in working for the company or I don't, right? Um and so I think internship is a is another great form of education for the generation that's even, you know, younger in their late teens or early 20s.
56:02 >> Awesome. Well, we've got about four minutes left. Um, so I'll wrap it up with one more, um, kind of question here. I feel like a lot of times, um, when I talk to other families working on their NextGen programs, a lot of time, a lot of times it feels like it's a very top- down approach where it's the older generations being like the NextG needs education and they need development. Um, or like at a family office, maybe um, some of the family office administrators um, have been given the responsibility of educating. I I personally think that one of your keys to success is that it's kind of been organic within your own next generation. You guys have kind of taken ownership for to educate yourselves and develop yourselves. Would you agree that you think that's been a huge piece of it and that for other families like maybe trying to find this like champion or this person within the NextGen to kind of use it as a leadership opportunity? Honestly.
56:53 >> Yeah. Yeah. No, no question. I mean, I'm in my late 30s at this point and Ryan's in his late 20s. So, when we were running this program, I mean, Ryan was of the demographic that we were educating and and and um you know, our second cohort is is my age. And so, it also made it really easy for you know, if I'm if I'm driving content afterwards, I could go to Ryan and be like, "Is was that interesting? Did you like that? Was that engaging?" You know, and he um could really be a sounding board for that. But I think that that in our family that wasn't like our our family member leaders are young. I mean that's who's populating our uh family council and a lot of that had to do with the intentionality of removing our older generations from some of our governance structures. Uh because really your governance structures are for the future, right? they're not um for keeping things in the past. I think that it's very easy, inertia is a powerful force and so you need to be willing to really look forward and and release control. And so we've been very intentional about that. Um and so our council, I mean, we have some older fifth generation family members on our council, which they're amazing and they're incredibly helpful, but a lot of our family council is in their 20s, 30s, young 40s. So that was a really natural fit for us. that wasn't something we had to I guess really I hadn't really thought about it Katie but yeah I do think it was helpful and I think that it maybe made the program a little bit more organic and true to what we thought and I also think that Ryan and I were able to say you know we're not like talking down on people like oh we need to teach them some basic stuff we're like no this is the stuff that's really intellectually engaging for us and when I heard it you know I sat on on a call and I heard this family speak and I learned a ton so let's teach it to everybody else. I think that that pure uh pure education is is really impactful.
58:51 >> I think it helps with the recruiting too. Like I know Bri and Ryan just from like you know summers in Rhode Island like all this stuff like we know each other and so it's not like this top down approach where someone from the company's like you guys need to be educated. Um in many ways it felt very organic because you know Ryan Bree and I knew each other prior and like they're learning alongside us, right? like it's not like this was something where they weren't getting a benefit too, right?
59:17 Like it's we're all learning together um as we go through this um and they just happen to be programming it. So um I think it was definitely a helpful component um and melt and made it feel more organic. >> Yeah, definitely seconding that. And then I would also say an added benefit for us was kind of that that more um qualitative aspect of it, right? building the family glue, engaging with with family members who we might not have as much exposure to. So, kind of from a selfish perspective, that was another aspect that I really um thought was resonated with me. Um but yeah, I think that it definitely I I felt like I was in a position where I could really learn from some of these sessions, um interact with peers in a way that I probably would not have had, um access to otherwise. But I think it definitely kind of built engagement, drove interest in the program. Um, having that kind of younger generation to help to pull in these resources and and foster a a program like this.
60:23 >> Yeah. And and Katie, I know we're out of time, but I just wanted to say um thank you so much for having us and if any of the attendees want to reach out or be connected with us, we're happy to do that. So, >> yeah. Great. Um, we have several questions still on here. Um, so if your question didn't get answered, some of it's a little bit more technical about the structure of your family and everything. Um, if you want to follow up with us after the webinar, we'll get you connected and I'm sure they're they'll be happy to answer questions and help out on a more personal level. Um, but yes, so we're at the top of the hour.
60:51 Uh, thank you so much to all three of you. It's been a wonderful topic. Um, most questions I've ever had in a webinar. So, thank you so much for the, um, the awesome dialogue. Um this is our last webinar for the year, but um be on the lookout for our webinar starting in 2025. If you have any questions, just shoot us an email. Um and yeah, thank you again so much for joining and thank you to the Gilbane family.
Summary
- The Gilbane family has a rich history in construction, founded in 1870, and emphasizes strong family governance structures.
- The family council has evolved to include a diverse range of generations and in-laws, facilitating better communication and engagement.
- A NextGen education program was created to engage younger family members (ages 20-30) through tailored learning experiences and networking opportunities.
- The program included in-person sessions, guest speakers from within and outside the family, and hands-on learning experiences to foster deeper connections.
- Key objectives of the NextGen program included building shareholder knowledge, creating a strong network among family members, and enhancing leadership skills.
- The family emphasizes transparency, accountability, and the importance of education to cultivate responsible stewards of the family business.
- Future iterations of the program will focus on rearranging content, expanding to include more age groups, and maintaining engagement among family members.
- The success of the program is attributed to its organic development by younger family members, fostering a collaborative learning environment.