transcribe

The Misogyny Of Modern Feminism

Chris Williamson · 10m · transcribed 4d ago
More from Chris Williamson Family and Health
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

The Evolution of Feminism and Its Critique of Femininity

How has feminism's focus shifted regarding women's choices?

Feminism, originally aimed at empowering women, has become critical of femininity, often promoting traditionally masculine roles as the only valid form of empowerment.

  • Feminism has evolved to sometimes devalue traditional feminine roles.
  • The movement risks becoming misogynistic by dictating acceptable choices for women.
  • Empowerment should encompass all choices, including those traditionally seen as feminine.
# 2:00

Challenging Historical Narratives of Gender Roles

What does recent research reveal about women's roles in early societies?

Recent studies challenge the notion that men were the primary hunters, showing that women also participated significantly in hunting, yet this is often downplayed.

  • Research indicates women hunted in many societies, challenging traditional gender roles.
  • There is a bias in how achievements are valued based on gender.
  • The push to rewrite history to fit a feminist narrative can undermine the value of traditionally feminine roles.
# 4:00

The Value of Traditional Roles in Feminism

Why are traditionally feminine roles undervalued in feminist discourse?

Feminist narratives often elevate masculine-coded achievements while neglecting the importance of feminine-coded contributions, leading to a devaluation of roles like motherhood and caregiving.

  • Feminism should celebrate all contributions, not just those that mimic masculine achievements.
  • The perception of value in roles is skewed towards traditionally male activities.
  • This bias creates unnecessary conflict between different choices women make.
# 6:01

The Soft Bigotry of Male Expectations

How does modern feminism reflect biases against femininity?

Modern feminism often criticizes women for choosing traditionally feminine paths, suggesting that true empowerment can only come from adopting masculine traits.

  • There is a tendency to view feminine roles as inferior compared to masculine ones.
  • Criticism of women for embracing traditional roles reflects a deeper contempt for femininity.
  • True empowerment should validate all choices women make, regardless of societal expectations.
# 8:01

Redefining Value in Women's Choices

What should be the focus of feminist empowerment?

Feminism should aim to elevate the status of feminine-coded contributions rather than solely promoting women's participation in masculine roles.

  • Empowerment should not mean emulating male roles but recognizing the value of feminine roles.
  • Judging women's choices based on masculine standards undermines their autonomy.
  • Feminism should support women in making choices that are genuinely theirs, regardless of societal biases.

Transcript

0:00 I think we might have lost the plot. >> Some feminists are so feminists that they become misogynistic. >> These tradwives are losers. >> At what point did empowering women become telling them which choices they're allowed to make? >> My generation of feminists was raised to devalue what our mothers did. >> did feminism, a movement whose purpose is to raise up women, become so critical of femininity? >> Didn't want to do what our mothers did. What was important was what our fathers did.

0:27 >> Let me tell you a story. A friend of mine had her first two kids while she was working at a huge tech company, and she wasn't just a cog in the corporate machine. She was a high-powered executive. She was literally a boss in every sense of the word, who, through sleepless nights and a roster of nannies and unbelievable discipline, managed to succeed at both her job and raising her humans. And then >> Coronavirus. Coronavirus. >> Coronavirus.

0:50 >> You must stay at home. >> Covid happened, and she had her third, a baby boy. This was the first time that she'd been forced to slow down and really think about her life, and she realized that she regretted not being as present as she could have been with her first two kids. So she made the decision to not return to work, and instead go all in on being a full-time mom. Now, a few years later, she moved to a new town for her husband's work, and there she started attending a meetup for moms with young kids in the hopes of making some new friends. All of these mothers were obviously very engaged with raising their babies, and also they all had careers. After a few weeks, one of the mothers turned to my friend and said, I wish I'd known you when you were still working. You know, when you had a lot going on.

1:35 Remember that my friend is a woman who ascended to the peak of her career. She'd climbed the corporate ladder of one of the biggest companies in the world and reached the top. But because she was now just a mom in 2026, she was seen as less than by working moms who were still living the career life that she'd already completed. They weren't looking down on her for her capabilities. They were looking down on for her choices. And I struggled to see how this worldview is anything other than deeply misogynistic.

2:06 So, what's going on here? When did feminism, a movement whose purpose is to raise up women, become so critical of femininity? We need to go back a bit. In 2023, a study called The Myth of Man the Hunter set out to challenge the traditional idea that men hunted while women gathered. It reported evidence of women hunting in 50 of 63 societies. That's 79 %. And of the societies where women did hunt, 33 % saw women hunting large game. And this was seen as a huge breakthrough. Not only were women hunting nearly as much as men, they were also hunting the dangerous stuff, like pigs and large hoofed mammals. But here's where it gets spicy. A subsequent paper by 15 hunter-gatherer researchers re-examined the work and reported sample selection bias and numerous coding errors. The critics wrote that multiple methodological failures all biased the results in the same direction.

3:00 Basically, the people who wrote the paper did some with the data in order to prove their preferred conclusion. In the abstract, the authors even said that their results aimed to shift the male hunter-female gatherer paradigm, which leaves us with an interesting question. Why would a team led by a self-described feminist researcher be so motivated to make women behave in male-coded ways? This is something that I call the soft bigotry of male expectations. It's the idea that when trying to elevate women, people assume that the only achievements worth celebrating are the ones traditionally associated with men. And this is exactly where girl boss feminism takes on a misogynistic undertone. Anything typically masculine-coded becomes high status and desirable for women to pursue, and anything typically feminine-coded becomes low status and undesirable.

3:53 It's how women can look down on my friend for just being a mom when raising children is commonly agreed to be the most difficult and important job that any human could have. Going back to the hunter gatherer data, there's something deeply patriarchal about trying to prove women's equality by rewriting history to make women more like men. Why was women did hunting too seen as more emancipatory? Why didn't the study conclude that perhaps gathering, child care, food processing and maintaining the social unit were every bit as civilization critical as spearing an animal? The scandal isn't just that the researchers overstated female hunting, it's that they apparently needed women to be hunters for women to seem impressive. It says hunting is high status, gathering is low status. Killing boars is impressive, raising the people who kill boars is not. Male coded contribution is the standard and female equality is established by proving that women could meet those standards. This makes for a strangely insulting compliment. Don't worry, women are just as valuable as men. Look, they did man stuff too. It's strange that traditionally feminine roles aren't seen with the value that they deserve by the people who are supposedly there to support women. And there are examples everywhere you look.

5:16 Let's take Rachel Zegler's comments about her betrayal of Snow White. >> She's not going to be dreaming about true love. She's dreaming about becoming the leader she knows she can be. >> No one ever said a woman being a leader wasn't a good thing, but why is it pitted against falling in love? Why does there seem to be a numerical value ascribed to each making one more worthy than the other? And this causes conflict in strange and bewildering ways. Take cooking and lifestyle influencer Nara Smith. She makes a living by cooking meals for her family and sharing them on social media.

5:47 Seems like an all round beneficial thing for everyone involved, right? Well, a lot of women disagree. In a 2024 article for Harper's Bazaar, Nara said that she frequently received hate online from women calling her a trad wife and saying things like she'd set women back by decades. So she can't even cook meals for her children without betraying the cause. At that point, whose benefit are you even working for? Look, there is a certain kind of status-obsessed girl boss feminism that seems unable to imagine female empowerment except as women becoming more like high status men.

6:23 It celebrates the female CEO, soldier, hunter, founder, and breadwinner, but has surprisingly little to say about elevating the status of motherhood, caregiving, homemaking, emotional labor, or other traditionally female pursuits. This creates an interesting question. How much supposedly pro women rhetoric is actually built on an unexamined contempt for femininity? Girl boss feminism was born out of getting women equal access to the opportunities that men had, but ended up denying women's prestige from the pursuits that they already excelled in and which arguably contribute the most to society. Male typical pursuits become something women ascend into, while female typical pursuits become something that women fall back on. Then everyone acts surprised that femininity feels low status. I'm not saying that the career path, trad wife life, or a mix is more preferable for women. That's evidently individual and constrained massively by things like preferences and economics and age. What I am saying is that prestige only seems to flow in one direction from certain corners of supposedly pro women thinkers.

7:31 The soft bigotry of male expectations is even more visible when people who hold girl boss feminist beliefs criticize men for behaving in stereotypically feminine ways. Just look at this tweet. You cannot believe this without believing that women are inferior. The only way debasing a man for being in a position that you consider feminine works is if you think of femininity as degrading. A reply to that tweet really stood out to me which said it speaks more to your perception of your own worth than it does about his. If you believe that becoming more feminine makes a man seem weaker, that accidentally reveals precisely what you think that femininity means. These people are so eager to insult man that they fail to see that they're insulting women and maybe themselves. Like am I high here or is all of this kind of impossible to unsee once you've seen it? I get it, right? For a long time women didn't have any other option than to work around the house and raise children.

8:33 Even if women would have elected to spend their years being a homemaker, it doesn't feel like a fair choice because there were no other available alternatives. That fact shouldn't mean that in a modern world where women do have alternative choices, a woman who decides to pursue the typically feminine path should be seen as less valuable. If all stay-at-home moms are rubes who have been conned into domestic servitude by the patriarchy, that doesn't feel like an equality-informed way to judge the life choices of a huge number of women and probably the life preferences of far more. It just makes me think why doesn't girl boss feminism elevate women by increasing the status of feminine-coded contributions instead of trying to prove that they can participate in masculine-coded ones. There is something truly revealing about a movement that treats women entering male roles as progress, women entering female roles as pitiful, and men entering female roles as punchlines. Timothy Leary said it beautifully, women who seek to be equal with men lack ambition. So I don't know about you, but I have loftier goals for my future daughters than for them to simply try to emulate my life.

9:44 No matter what they choose to do, I plan to let them know that they are valuable exactly as they are and that their choices are worthy as long as those choices are actually their own. That's it. That's all I've got. Now you can go and shout at me in the comments.

Summary

The discussion critiques modern feminism's tendency to devalue traditionally feminine roles while elevating masculine-coded achievements, suggesting that this perspective can be misogynistic. It highlights the conflict between women's choices in career versus motherhood and questions why femininity is often viewed as less valuable.

- Some feminists may inadvertently adopt misogynistic views by criticizing femininity.
- The narrative of empowerment often pressures women to pursue traditionally masculine roles.
- A personal story illustrates how a successful career woman faced judgment for choosing motherhood over her career.
- Studies attempting to prove women's equality by emphasizing their participation in hunting reflect a bias that devalues feminine contributions.
- The "soft bigotry of male expectations" suggests that only achievements aligned with masculine standards are celebrated.
- The status of motherhood and caregiving is often undermined in feminist discourse.
- Criticism of women who embrace traditional roles, like homemaking, reveals an internalized contempt for femininity.
- True empowerment should involve valuing all choices women make, regardless of whether they align with masculine ideals.

Questions Answered

How has feminism's focus shifted regarding women's choices?

Feminism, originally aimed at empowering women, has become critical of femininity, often promoting traditionally masculine roles as the only valid form of empowerment.

What does recent research reveal about women's roles in early societies?

Recent studies challenge the notion that men were the primary hunters, showing that women also participated significantly in hunting, yet this is often downplayed.

Why are traditionally feminine roles undervalued in feminist discourse?

Feminist narratives often elevate masculine-coded achievements while neglecting the importance of feminine-coded contributions, leading to a devaluation of roles like motherhood and caregiving.

How does modern feminism reflect biases against femininity?

Modern feminism often criticizes women for choosing traditionally feminine paths, suggesting that true empowerment can only come from adopting masculine traits.

What should be the focus of feminist empowerment?

Feminism should aim to elevate the status of feminine-coded contributions rather than solely promoting women's participation in masculine roles.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram