Let's build GPT: from scratch, in code, spelled out.

0:00 hi everyone so by now you have probably heard of chat GPT it has taken the world and AI Community by storm and it is a system that allows you to interact with an AI and give it text based tasks so for example we can ask chat GPT to write us a small Hau about how important it is that people understand Ai and then they can use it to improve the world and make it more prosperous so when we run this

0:23 AI knowledge brings prosperity for all to see Embrace its power okay not bad and so you could see that chpt went from left to right and generated all these words SE sort of sequentially now I asked it already the exact same prompt a little bit earlier and it generated a slightly different outcome ai's power to grow ignorance holds us back learn Prosperity weights so pretty good in both cases and slightly different so you can see that

0:50 chat GPT is a probabilistic system and for any one prompt it can give us multiple answers sort of replying to it now this is just one example of a problem people have come up with many many examples and there are entire websites that index interactions with chpt and so many of them are quite humorous explain HTML to me like I'm a dog write release notes for chess 2 write a note about Elon Musk buying a Twitter and so on so as an example

1:20 please write a breaking news article about a leaf falling from a tree and a shocking turn of events a leaf has fallen from a tree in the local park Witnesses report that the leaf which was previously attached to a branch of a tree attached itself and fell to the ground very dramatic so you can see that this is a pretty remarkable system and it is what we call a language model because it it models the sequence of words or characters or

1:46 tokens more generally and it knows how sort of words follow each other in English language and so from its perspective what it is doing is it is completing the sequence so I give it the start of a sequence and it completes the sequence with the outcome and so it's a language model in that sense now I would like to focus on the under the hood of under the hood components of what makes CH GPT work so what is the neural

2:12 network under the hood that models the sequence of these words and that comes from this paper called attention is all you need in 2017 a landmark paper a landmark paper in AI that produced and proposed the Transformer architecture so GPT is short for generally generatively pre-trained Transformer so Transformer is the neuron nut that actually does all the heavy lifting under the hood it comes from this paper in 2017 now if you read this paper this reads like a pretty random

2:44 machine translation paper and that's because I think the authors didn't fully anticipate the impact that the Transformer would have on the field and this architecture that they produced in the context of machine translation in their case actually ended up taking over the rest of AI in the next 5 years after and so this architecture with minor changes was copy pasted into a huge amount of applications in AI in more recent years and that includes at the core of chat GPT now we are not

3:13 going to what I'd like to do now is I'd like to build out something like chat GPT but we're not going to be able to of course reproduce chat GPT this is a very serious production grade system it is trained on a good chunk of internet and then there's a lot of pre-training and fine-tuning stages to it and so it's very complicated what I'd like to focus on is just to train a Transformer based language model and in

3:38 our case it's going to be a character level language model I still think that is very educational with respect to how these systems work so I don't want to train on the chunk of Internet we need a smaller data set in this case I propose that we work with my favorite toy data set it's called tiny Shakespeare and what it is is basically it's a concatenation of all of the works of sh Shakespeare in my understanding and so this is all of

4:02 Shakespeare in a single file this file is about 1 megab and it's just all of Shakespeare and what we are going to do now is we're going to basically model how these characters follow each other so for example given a chunk of these characters like this given some context of characters in the past the Transformer neural network will look at the characters that I've highlighted and is going to predict that g is likely to come next in the sequence and it's going

4:30 to do that because we're going to train that Transformer on Shakespeare and it's just going to try to produce character sequences that look like this and in that process is going to model all the patterns inside this data so once we've trained the system i' just like to give you a preview we can generate infinite Shakespeare and of course it's a fake thing that looks kind of like Shakespeare apologies for there's some Jank that I'm not able to resolve in in here but

5:02 you can see how this is going character by character and it's kind of like predicting Shakespeare like language so verily my Lord the sites have left the again the king coming with my curses with precious pale and then tranos say something else Etc and this is just coming out of the Transformer in a very similar manner as it would come out in chat GPT in our case character by character in chat GPT it's coming out on the token by token level and tokens

5:33 are these sort of like little subword pieces so they're not Word level they're kind of like word chunk level and now I've already written this entire code to train these Transformers and it is in a GitHub repository that you can find and it's called nanog GPT so nanog GPT is a repository that you can find in my GitHub and it's a repository for training Transformers on any given text and what I think is interesting about it because there's

6:03 many ways to train Transformers but this is a very simple implementation so it's just two files of 300 lines of code each one file defines the GPT model the Transformer and one file trains it on some given Text data set and here I'm showing that if you train it on a open web Text data set which is a fairly large data set of web pages then I reproduce the the performance of gpt2 so gpt2 is an early version of open

6:29 AI GPT from 2017 if I recall correctly and I've only so far reproduced the the smallest 124 million parameter model but basically this is just proving that the codebase is correctly arranged and I'm able to load the neural network weights that openi has released later so you can take a look at the finished code here in N GPT but what I would like to do in this lecture is I would like to basically write this repository from scratch so

6:57 we're going to begin with an empty file and we're we're going to define a Transformer piece by piece we're going to train it on the tiny Shakespeare data set and we'll see how we can then generate infinite Shakespeare and of course this can copy paste to any arbitrary Text data set that you like but my goal really here is to just make you understand and appreciate how under the hood chat GPT works and really all that's required is a

7:24 Proficiency in Python and some basic understanding of calculus and statistics and it would help if you also see my previous videos on the same YouTube channel in particular my make more series where I Define smaller and simpler neural network language models so multi perceptrons and so on it really introduces the language modeling framework and then here in this video we're going to focus on the Transformer neural network itself okay so I created a new Google collab jup notebook here

7:57 and this will allow me to later easily share this code that we're going to develop together with you so you can follow along so this will be in a video description later now here I've just done some preliminaries I downloaded the data set the tiny Shakespeare data set at this URL and you can see that it's about a 1 Megabyte file then here I open the input.txt file and just read in all the text of the string and we see that

8:20 we are working with 1 million characters roughly and the first 1,000 characters if we just print them out are basically what you would expect this is the first 1,000 characters of the tiny Shakespeare data set roughly up to here so so far so good next we're going to take this text and the text is a sequence of characters in Python so when I call the set Constructor on it I'm just going to get the set of all the characters that occur

8:46 in this text and then I call list on that to create a list of those characters instead of just a set so that I have an ordering an arbitrary ordering and then I sort that so basically we get just all the characters that occur in the entire data set and they're sorted now the number of them is going to be our vocabulary size these are the possible elements of our sequences and we see that when I print here the

9:11 characters there's 65 of them in total there's a space character and then all kinds of special characters and then U capitals and lowercase letters so that's our vocabulary and that's the sort of like possible characters that the model can see or emit okay so next we will would like to develop some strategy to tokenize the input text now when people say tokenize they mean convert the raw text as a string to some sequence of integers According to some

9:41 notebook According to some vocabulary of possible elements so as an example here we are going to be building a character level language model so we're simply going to be translating individual characters into integers so let me show you a chunk of code that sort of does that for us so we're building both the encoder and the decoder and let me just talk through what's happening here when we encode an arbitrary text like hi there we're going to receive a

10:08 list of integers that represents that string so for example 46 47 Etc and then we also have the reverse mapping so we can take this list and decode it to get back the exact same string so it's really just like a translation to integers and back for arbitrary string and for us it is done on a character level now the way this was achieved is we just iterate over all the characters here and create a lookup table from the character

10:35 to the integer and vice versa and then to encode some string we simply translate all the characters individually and to decode it back we use the reverse mapping and concatenate all of it now this is only one of many possible encodings or many possible sort of tokenizers and it's a very simple one but there's many other schemas that people have come up with in practice so for example Google uses a sentence piece so sentence piece will also

11:02 encode text into integers but in a different schema and using a different vocabulary and sentence piece is a subword sort of tokenizer and what that means is that you're not encoding entire words but you're not also encoding individual characters it's it's a subword unit level and that's usually what's adopted in practice for example also openai has this Library called tick token that uses a bite pair encode tokenizer and that's what GPT uses

11:33 and you can also just encode words into like hell world into a list of integers so as an example I'm using the Tik token Library here I'm getting the encoding for gpt2 or that was used for gpt2 instead of just having 65 possible characters or tokens they have 50,000 tokens and so when they encode the exact same string High there we only get a list of three integers but those integers are not between 0 and 64 they

12:01 are between Z and 5, 5,256 so basically you can trade off the code book size and the sequence lengths so you can have very long sequences of integers with very small vocabularies or we can have short sequences of integers with very large vocabularies and so typically people use in practice these subword encodings but I'd like to keep our token ier very simple so we're using character level tokenizer and that

12:33 means that we have very small code books we have very simple encode and decode functions but we do get very long sequences as a result but that's the level at which we're going to stick with this lecture because it's the simplest thing okay so now that we have an encoder and a decoder effectively a tokenizer we can tokenize the entire training set of Shakespeare so here's a chunk of code that does that and I'm going to start to use the pytorch

12:56 library and specifically the torch. tensor from the pytorch library so we're going to take all of the text in tiny Shakespeare encode it and then wrap it into a torch. tensor to get the data tensor so here's what the data tensor looks like when I look at just the first 1,000 characters or the 1,000 elements of it so we see that we have a massive sequence of integers and this sequence of integers here is basically an

13:20 identical translation of the first 10,000 characters here so I believe for example that zero is a new line character and maybe one one is a space not 100% sure but from now on the entire data set of text is re-represented as just it's just stretched out as a single very large sequence of integers let me do one more thing before we move on here I'd like to separate out our data set into a train and a

13:45 validation split so in particular we're going to take the first 90% of the data set and consider that to be the training data for the Transformer and we're going to withhold the last 10% at the end of it to be the validation data and this will help us understand to what extent our model is overfitting so we're going to basically hide and keep the validation data on the side because we don't want just a perfect memorization

14:08 of this exact Shakespeare we want a neural network that sort of creates Shakespeare like text and so it should be fairly likely for it to produce the actual like stowed away true Shakespeare text and so we're going to use this to get a sense of the overfitting okay so now we would like to start plugging these text sequences or integer sequences into the Transformer so that it can train and learn those patterns now the important thing to realize is we're never going to

14:38 actually feed entire text into a Transformer all at once that would be computationally very expensive and prohibitive so when we actually train a Transformer on a lot of these data sets we only work with chunks of the data set and when we train the Transformer we basically sample random little chunks out of the training set and train on just chunks at a time and these chunks have basically some kind of a length and some maximum length now the maximum

15:04 length typically at least in the code I usually write is called block size you can you can find it under different names like context length or something like that let's start with the block size of just eight and let me look at the first train data characters the first block size plus one characters I'll explain why plus one in a second so this is the first nine characters in the sequence in the training set now what I'd like to point

15:30 out is that when you sample a chunk of data like this so say the these nine characters out of the training set this actually has multiple examples packed into it and that's because all of these characters follow each other and so what this thing is going to say when we plug it into a Transformer is we're going to actually simultaneously train it to make prediction at every one of these positions now in the in a chunk of nine

15:56 characters there's actually eight indiv ual examples packed in there so there's the example that when 18 when in the context of 18 47 likely comes next in a context of 18 and 47 56 comes next in a context of 18 47 56 57 can come next and so on so that's the eight individual examples let me actually spell it out with code so here's a chunk of code to illustrate X are the inputs to the Transformer it will just be the first

16:28 block size characters y will be the next block size characters so it's offset by one and that's because y are the targets for each position in the input and then here I'm iterating over all the block size of eight and the context is always all the characters in x up to T and including T and the target is always the teth character but in the targets array y so let me just run this and basically it spells out what I

16:59 said in words these are the eight examples hidden in a chunk of nine characters that we sampled from the training set I want to mention one more thing we train on all the eight examples here with context between one all the way up to context of block size and we train on that not just for computational reasons because we happen to have the sequence already or something like that it's not just done for efficiency it's also done to make the Transformer

17:28 Network be used to seeing contexts all the way from as little as one all the way to block size and we'd like the transform to be used to seeing everything in between and that's going to be useful later during inference because while we're sampling we can start the sampling generation with as little as one character of context and the Transformer knows how to predict the next character with all the way up to just context of one and so then it can

17:53 predict everything up to block size and after block size we have to start truncating because the Transformer will will never receive more than block size inputs when it's predicting the next character Okay so we've looked at the time dimension of the tensors that are going to be feeding into the Transformer there's one more Dimension to care about and that is the batch Dimension and so as we're sampling these chunks of text we're going to be actually every time

18:17 we're going to feed them into a Transformer we're going to have many batches of multiple chunks of text that are all like stacked up in a single tensor and that's just done for efficiency just so that we can keep the gpus busy because they are very good at parallel processing of of data and so we just want to process multiple chunks all at the same time but those chunks are processed completely independently they don't talk to each

18:39 other and so on so let me basically just generalize this and introduce a batch Dimension here's a chunk of code let me just run it and then I'm going to explain what it does so here because we're going to start sampling random locations in the data set to pull chunks from I am setting the seed so that in the random number generator so that the numbers I see here are going to be the same numbers you see later if you try to

19:04 reproduce this now the batch size here is how many independent sequences we are processing every forward backward pass of the Transformer the block size as I explained is the maximum context length to make those predictions so let's say B size four block size eight and then here's how we get batch for any arbitrary split if the split is a training split then we're going to look at train data otherwise at valid data that gives us the data array and then

19:33 when I Generate random positions to grab a chunk out of I actually grab I actually generate batch size number of Random offsets so because this is four we are ex is going to be a four numbers that are randomly generated between zero and Len of data minus block size so it's just random offsets into the training set and then X's as I explained are the first first block size characters starting at I the Y's are the offset by

20:05 one of that so just add plus one and then we're going to get those chunks for every one of integers I INX and use a torch. stack to take all those one-dimensional tensors as we saw here and we're going to stack them up at rows and so they all become a row in a 4x8 tensor so here's where I'm printing then when I sample a batch XB and YB the inputs to

20:35 the Transformer now are the input X is the 4x8 tensor four rows of eight columns and each one of these is a chunk of the training set and then the targets here are in the associated array Y and they will come in to the Transformer all the way at the end to create the loss function so they will give us the correct answer for every single position inside X and then these are the four

21:06 independent rows so spelled out as we did before this 4x8 array contains a total of 32 examples and they're completely independent as far as the Transformer is concerned so when the input is 24 the target is 43 or rather 43 here in the Y array when the input is 2443 the target is 58 when the input is 24 43 58 the target is 5 Etc or like when it is a 52

21:38 581 the target is 58 right so you can sort of see this spelled out these are the 32 independent examples packed in to a single batch of the input X and then the desired targets are in y and so now this integer tensor of X is going to feed into the Transformer and that Transformer is going to simultaneously process all these examples and then look up the correct integers to predict in every

22:08 one of these positions in the tensor y okay so now that we have our batch of input that we'd like to feed into a Transformer let's start basically feeding this into neural networks now we're going to start off with the simplest possible neural network which in the case of language modeling in my opinion is the Byram language model and we've covered the Byram language model in my make more series in a lot of depth and so here I'm going to sort of go

22:31 faster and let's just Implement pytorch module directly that implements the byr language model so I'm importing the pytorch NN module for reproducibility and then here I'm constructing a Byram language model which is a subass of NN module and then I'm calling it and I'm passing it the inputs and the targets and I'm just printing now when the inputs on targets come here you see that I'm just taking the index the inputs X here which I rename to idx and I'm

23:03 just passing them into this token embedding table so it's going on here is that here in the Constructor we are creating a token embedding table and it is of size vocap size by vocap size and we're using an. embedding which is a very thin wrapper around basically a tensor of shape voap size by vocab size and what's happening here is that when we pass idx here every single integer in our input is going to refer to this embedding table and it's going

23:32 to pluck out a row of that embedding table corresponding to its index so 24 here will go into the embedding table and we'll pluck out the 24th row and then 43 will go here and pluck out the 43d row Etc and then pytorch is going to arrange all of this into a batch by Time by channel tensor in this case batch is four time is eight and C which is the channels is vocab size or 65 and so

24:01 we're just going to pluck out all those rows arrange them in a b by T by C and now we're going to interpret this as the logits which are basically the scores for the next character in the sequence and so what's happening here is we are predicting what comes next based on just the individual identity of a single token and you can do that because I mean currently the tokens are not talking to each other and they're not

24:25 seeing any context except for they're just seeing themselves so I'm a f I'm a token number five and then I can actually make pretty decent predictions about what comes next just by knowing that I'm token five because some characters know C follow other characters in in typical scenarios so we saw a lot of this in a lot more depth in the make more series and here if I just run this then we currently get the predictions the scores the lits for

24:53 every one of the 4x8 positions now that we've made predictions about what comes next we'd like to evaluate the loss function and so in make more series we saw that a good way to measure a loss or like a quality of the predictions is to use the negative log likelihood loss which is also implemented in pytorch under the name cross entropy so what we' like to do here is loss is the cross entropy on the predictions and the

25:17 targets and so this measures the quality of the logits with respect to the Targets in other words we have the identity of the next character so how well are we predicting the next character based on the lits and intuitively the correct the correct dimension of low jits depending on whatever the target is should have a very high number and all the other dimensions should be very low number right now the issue is that this won't actually this is what we want we want to

25:46 basically output the logits and the loss this is what we want but unfortunately this won't actually run we get an error message but intuitively we want to measure this now when we go to the pytorch cross entropy documentation here we're trying to call the cross entropy in its functional form so that means we don't have to create like a module for it but here when we go to the documentation you have

26:16 to look into the details of how pitor expects these inputs and basically the issue here is ptor expects if you have multi-dimensional input which we do because we have a b BYT by C tensor then it actually really wants the channels to be the second Dimension here so if you so basically it wants a b by C BYT instead of a b by T by C and so it's just the details of how P torch treats

26:45 these kinds of inputs and so we don't actually want to deal with that so what we're going to do instead is we need to basically reshape our logits so here's what I like to do I like to take basically give names to the dimensions so lit. shape is B BYT by C and unpack those numbers and then let's say that logits equals lit. View and we want it to be a b * c b * T by C so just a two-

27:11 dimensional array right so we're going to take all the we're going to take all of these positions here and we're going to stretch them out in a onedimensional sequence and preserve the channel Dimension as the second dimension so we're just kind of like stretching out the array so it's two- dimensional and in that case it's going to better conform to what pytorch sort of expects in its Dimensions now we have to do the same to targets because

27:38 currently targets are of shape B by T and we want it to be just B * T so onedimensional now alternatively you could always still just do minus one because pytor will guess what this should be if you want to lay it out but let me just be explicit and say p * t once we've reshaped this it will match the cross entropy case and then we should be able to evaluate our loss okay so that R now and we can do

28:10 loss and So currently we see that the loss is 4.87 now because our we have 65 possible vocabulary elements we can actually guess at what the loss should be and in particular we covered negative log likelihood in a lot of detail we are expecting log or lawn of 1 over 65 and negative of that so we're expecting the loss to be about 4.1 17 but we're getting 4.87 and so that's telling us

28:40 that the initial predictions are not super diffuse they've got a little bit of entropy and so we're guessing wrong so yes but actually we're I a we are able to evaluate the loss okay so now that we can evaluate the quality of the model on some data we'd like to also be able to generate from the model so let's do the generation now I'm going to go again a little bit faster here because I covered all this already in

29:04 previous videos so here's a generate function for the model so we take some we take the the same kind of input idx here and basically this is the current context of some characters in a batch in some batch so it's also B BYT and the job of generate is to basically take this B BYT and extend it to be B BYT + 1 plus 2 plus 3 and so it's just basically it

29:34 continues the generation in all the batch dimensions in the time Dimension So that's its job and it will do that for Max new tokens so you can see here on the bottom there's going to be some stuff here but on the bottom whatever is predicted is concatenated on top of the previous idx along the First Dimension which is the time Dimension to create a b BYT + one so that becomes a new idx so the job of generate is to take a b BYT

30:00 and make it a b BYT plus 1 plus 2 plus three as many as we want Max new tokens so this is the generation from the model now inside the generation what what are we doing we're taking the current indices we're getting the predictions so we get those are in the low jits and then the loss here is going to be ignored because we're not we're not using that and we have no targets that are sort of ground truth targets that

30:25 we're going to be comparing with then once we get the logits we are only focusing on the last step so instead of a b by T by C we're going to pluck out the negative-1 the last element in the time Dimension because those are the predictions for what comes next so that gives us the logits which we then convert to probabilities via softmax and then we use tor. multinomial to sample from those probabilities and we ask

30:51 pytorch to give us one sample and so idx next will become a b by one because in each one of the batch Dimensions we're going to have a single prediction for what comes next so this num samples equals one will make this be a one and then we're going to take those integers that come from the sampling process according to the probability distribution given here and those integers got just concatenated on top of the current sort of like running stream

31:17 of integers and this gives us a b BYT + one and then we can return that now one thing here is you see how I'm calling self of idx which will end up going to the forward function I'm not providing any Targets So currently this would give an error because targets is is sort of like not given so targets has to be optional so targets is none by default and then if targets is none then there's no loss to create so it's just

31:47 loss is none but else all of this happens and we can create a loss so this will make it so if we have the targets we provide them and get a loss if we have no targets it will'll just get the loits so this here will generate from the model and let's take that for a ride now oops so I have another code chunk here which will generate for the model from the model and okay this is kind of

32:15 crazy so maybe let me let me break this down so these are the idx right I'm creating a batch will be just one time will be just one so I'm creating a little one by one tensor and it's holding a zero and the D type the data type is integer so zero is going to be how we kick off the generation and remember that zero is is the element standing for a new line character so

32:45 it's kind of like a reasonable thing to to feed in as the very first character in a sequence to be the new line so it's going to be idx which we're going to feed in here then we're going to ask for 100 tokens and then. generate will continue that now because generate works on the level of batches we we then have to index into the zero throw to basically unplug the the single batch Dimension that exists and then that gives us a

33:18 time steps just a onedimensional array of all the indices which we will convert to simple python list from pytorch tensor so that that can feed into our decode function and convert those integers into text so let me bring this back and we're generating 100 tokens let's run and here's the generation that we achieved so obviously it's garbage and the reason it's garbage is because this is a totally random model so next up we're going to want to train this model

33:49 now one more thing I wanted to point out here is this function is written to be General but it's kind of like ridiculous right now because we're feeding in all this we're building out this context and we're concatenating it all and we're always feeding it all into the model but that's kind of ridiculous because this is just a simple Byram model so to make for example this prediction about K we only needed this W but actually what we fed into the model

34:15 is we fed the entire sequence and then we only looked at the very last piece and predicted K so the only reason I'm writing it in this way is because right now this is a byr model but I'd like to keep keep this function fixed and I'd like it to work later when our characters actually basically look further in the history and so right now the history is not used so this looks silly but eventually the history will

34:42 be used and so that's why we want to do it this way so just a quick comment on that so now we see that this is random so let's train the model so it becomes a bit less random okay let's Now train the model so first what I'm going to do is I'm going to create a pyour optimization object so here we are using the optimizer ATM W now in a make more series we've only ever use tastic

35:06 gradi in descent the simplest possible Optimizer which you can get using the SGD instead but I want to use Adam which is a much more advanced and popular Optimizer and it works extremely well for typical good setting for the learning rate is roughly 3 E4 but for very very small networks like is the case here you can get away with much much higher learning rates R3 or even higher probably but let me create the optimizer object which will basically

35:33 take the gradients and update the parameters using the gradients and then here our batch size up above was only four so let me actually use something bigger let's say 32 and then for some number of steps we are sampling a new batch of data we're evaluating the loss we're zeroing out all the gradients from the previous step getting the gradients for all the parameters and then using those gradients to up update our parameters so typical training loop as we saw in the

36:00 make more series so let me now run this for say 100 iterations and let's see what kind of losses we're going to get so we started around 4.7 and now we're getting to down to like 4.6 4.5 Etc so the optimization is definitely happening but let's sort of try to increase number of iterations and only print at the end because we probably want train for longer okay so we're down to 3.6

36:34 roughly roughly down to three this is the most janky optimization okay it's working let's just do 10,000 and then from here we want to copy this and hopefully that we're going to get something reason and of course it's not going to be Shakespeare from a byr model but at least we see that the loss is improving and hopefully we're

37:05 expecting something a bit more reasonable okay so we're down at about 2.5 is let's see what we get okay dramatic improvements certainly on what we had here so let me just increase the number of tokens okay so we see that we're starting to get something at least like reasonable is certainly not shakes spear but the model is making progress so that is the simplest possible model so now what I'd like to do

37:36 is obviously this is a very simple model because the tokens are not talking to each other so given the previous context of whatever was generated we're only looking at the very last character to make the predictions about what comes next so now these now these tokens have to start talking to each other and figuring out what is in the context so that they can make better predictions for what comes next and this is how we're going to kick off the

37:59 Transformer okay so next I took the code that we developed in this juper notebook and I converted it to be a script and I'm doing this because I just want to simplify our intermediate work into just the final product that we have at this point so in the top here I put all the hyp parameters that we to find I introduced a few and I'm going to speak to that in a little bit otherwise a lot

38:20 of this should be recognizable reproducibility read data get the encoder and the decoder create the train into splits use the kind of like data loader that gets a batch of the inputs and Targets this is new and I'll talk about it in a second now this is the Byram language model that we developed and it can forward and give us a logits and loss and it can generate and then here we are creating the optimizer and this is the training

38:51 Loop so everything here should look pretty familiar now some of the small things that I added number one I added the ability to run on a GPU if you have it so if you have a GPU then you can this will use Cuda instead of just CPU and everything will be a lot more faster now when device becomes Cuda then we need to make sure that when we load the data we move it to device when we create the model we want

39:15 to move the model parameters to device so as an example here we have the N an embedding table and it's got a weight inside it which stores the sort of lookup table so so that would be moved to the GPU so that all the calculations here happen on the GPU and they can be a lot faster and then finally here when I'm creating the context that feeds in to generate I have to make sure that I create it on the

39:39 device number two what I introduced is the fact that here in the training Loop here I was just printing the l. item inside the training Loop but this is a very noisy measurement of the current loss because every batch will be more or less lucky and so what I want to do usually is I have an estimate loss function and the estimate loss basically then goes up here and it

40:10 averages up the loss over multiple batches so in particular we're going to iterate eval iter times and we're going to basically get our loss and then we're going to get the average loss for both splits and so this will be a lot less noisy so here when we call the estimate loss we're we're going to report the pretty accurate train and validation loss now when we come back up you'll notice a few things here I'm setting the

40:35 model to evaluation phase and down here I'm resetting it back to training phase now right now for our model as is this doesn't actually do anything because the only thing inside this model is this nn. embedding and this this Network would behave both would behave the same in both evaluation mode and training mode we have no drop off layers we have no batm layers Etc but it is a good practice to Think Through what mode your neural network is in because some

41:04 layers will have different Behavior at inference time or training time and there's also this context manager torch up nograd and this is just telling pytorch that everything that happens inside this function we will not call do backward on and so pytorch can be a lot more efficient with its memory use because it doesn't have to store all the intermediate variables because we're never going to call backward and so it can it can be a lot more memory

41:30 efficient in that way so also a good practice to tpy torch when we don't intend to do back propagation so right now this script is about 120 lines of code of and that's kind of our starter code I'm calling it b.p and I'm going to release it later now running this script gives us output in the terminal and it looks something like this it basically as I ran this code it was giving me the train loss and Val loss

41:59 and we see that we convert to somewhere around 2.5 with the pyr model and then here's the sample that we produced at the end and so we have everything packaged up in the script and we're in a good position now to iterate on this okay so we are almost ready to start writing our very first self attention block for processing these tokens now before we actually get there I want to get you used to a mathematical trick that is

42:26 used in the self attention inside a Transformer and is really just like at the heart of an an efficient implementation of self attention and so I want to work with this toy example to just get you used to this operation and then it's going to make it much more clear once we actually get to to it in the script again so let's create a b BYT by C where BT and C are just 48 and two in the toy

42:50 example and these are basically channels and we have batches and we have the time component and we have information at each point in the sequence so see now what we would like to do is we would like these tokens so we have up to eight tokens here in a batch and these eight tokens are currently not talking to each other and we would like them to talk to each other we'd like to couple them and in particular we don't

43:17 we we want to couple them in a very specific way so the token for example at the fifth location it should not communicate with tokens in the sixth seventh and eighth location because those are future tokens in the sequence the token on the fifth location should only talk to the one in the fourth third second and first so it's only so information only flows from previous context to the current time step and we cannot get any information

43:42 from the future because we are about to try to predict the future so what is the easiest way for tokens to communicate okay the easiest way I would say is okay if we're up to if we're a fifth token and I'd like to communicate with my past the simplest way we can do that is to just do a weight is to just do an average of all the of all the preceding elements so for example if I'm the fif token I would

44:08 like to take the channels that make up that are information at my step but then also the channels from the fourth step third step second step and the first step I'd like to average those up and then that would become sort of like a feature Vector that summarizes me in the context of my history now of course just doing a sum or like an average is an extremely weak form of interaction like this communication is extremely

44:32 lossy we've lost a ton of information about the spatial Arrangements of all those tokens but that's okay for now we'll see how we can bring that information back later for now what we would like to do is for every single batch element independently for every teeth token in that sequence we'd like to now calculate the average of all the vectors in all the previous tokens and also at this token so let's write that out I have a small snippet here and

45:01 instead of just fumbling around let me just copy paste it and talk to it so in other words we're going to create X and B is short for bag of words because bag of words is is kind of a term that people use when you are just averaging up things so this is just a bag of words basically there's a word stored on every one of these eight locations and we're doing a bag of words we're just averaging

45:27 so in the beginning we're going to say that it's just initialized at Zero and then I'm doing a for Loop here so we're not being efficient yet that's coming but for now we're just iterating over all the batch Dimensions independently iterating over time and then the previous tokens are at this batch Dimension and then everything up to and including the teeth token okay so when we slice out X in this way X prev Becomes of shape how many T elements

45:58 there were in the past and then of course C so all the two-dimensional information from these little tokens so that's the previous sort of chunk of tokens from my current sequence and then I'm just doing the average or the mean over the zero Dimension so I'm averaging out the time here and I'm just going to get a little c one dimensional Vector which I'm going to store in X bag of words so I can run this and and

46:27 this is not going to be very informative because let's see so this is X of Zer so this is the zeroth batch element and then expo at zero now you see how the at the first location here you see that the two are equal and that's because it's we're just doing an average of this one token but here this one is now an average of these two and now this one is an average of these three and so on

46:57 so and this last one is the average of all of these elements so vertical average just averaging up all the tokens now gives this outcome here so this is all well and good but this is very inefficient now the trick is that we can be very very efficient about doing this using matrix multiplication so that's the mathematical trick and let me show you what I mean let's work with the toy example here let me run it and I'll

47:24 explain I have a simple Matrix here that is a 3X3 of all ones a matrix B of just random numbers and it's a 3x2 and a matrix C which will be 3x3 multip 3x2 which will give out a 3x2 so here we're just using matrix multiplication so a multiply B gives us C okay so how are these numbers in C achieved right so this number in the top left is the first row of a dot product

47:57 with the First Column of B and since all the the row of a right now is all just ones then the do product here with with this column of B is just going to do a sum of these of this column so 2 + 6 + 6 is 14 the element here in the output of C is also the first column here the first row of a multiplied now with the second column of B so 7 + 4 + 5 is 16 now you

48:25 see that there's repeating elements here so this 14 again is because this row is again all ones and it's multiplying the First Column of B so we get 14 and this one is and so on so this last number here is the last row do product last column now the trick here is the following this is just a boring number of it's just a boring array of all ones but torch has this function called Trail which is short for a

48:54 triangular something like that and you can wrap it in torch up once and it will just return the lower triangular portion of this okay so now it will basically zero out these guys here so we just get the lower triangular part well what happens if we do that so now we'll have a like this and B like this and now what are we getting here in C well what is this number well this is the first row times the First

49:24 Column and because this is zeros these elements here are now ignored so we just get a two and then this number here is the first row times the second column and because these are zeros they get ignored and it's just seven this seven multiplies this one but look what happened here because this is one and then zeros we what ended up happening is we're just plucking out the row of this row of B and that's what we

49:51 got now here we have one 1 Z so here 110 do product with these two columns will now give us 2 + 6 which is 8 and 7 + 4 which is 11 and because this is 111 we ended up with the addition of all of them and so basically depending on how many ones and zeros we have here we are basically doing a sum currently of a variable number of these rows and that gets deposited into

50:20 C So currently we're doing sums because these are ones but we can also do average right and you can start to see how we could do average of the rows of B sort of in an incremental fashion because we don't have to we can basically normalize these rows so that they sum to one and then we're going to get an average so if we took a and then we did aals aide torch. sum in the of a in the

50:51 oneth Dimension and then let's keep them as true so so therefore the broadcasting will work out so if I rerun this you see now that these rows now sum to one so this row is one this row is 0. 5.5 Z and here we get 1/3 and now when we do a multiply B what are we getting here we are just getting the first row first row here now we are getting the average of the first two

51:20 rows okay so 2 and six average is four and four and seven average is 5.5 and on the bottom here we are now getting the average of these three rows so the average of all of elements of B are now deposited here and so you can see that by manipulating these elements of this multiplying Matrix and then multiplying it with any given Matrix we can do these averages in this incremental fashion because we just get

51:50 and we can manipulate that based on the elements of a okay so that's very convenient so let's let's swing back up here and see how we can vectorize this and make it much more efficient using what we've learned so in particular we are going to produce an array a but here I'm going to call it we short for weights but this is our a and this is how much of every row we want to average up and it's going to be

52:17 an average because you can see that these rows sum to one so this is our a and then our B in this example of course is X so what's going to happen here now is that we are going to have an expo 2 and this Expo 2 is going to be way multiplying RX so let's think this true way is T BYT and this is Matrix multiplying in pytorch a b by T by C and it's giving us different what

52:50 shape so pytorch will come here and it will see that these shapes are not the same so it will create a batch Dimension here and this is a batched matrix multiply and so it will apply this matrix multiplication in all the batch elements in parallel and individually and then for each batch element there will be a t BYT multiplying T by C exactly as we had below so this will now create B by T by C and Expo 2 will now become identical

53:24 to Expo so we can see that torch. all close of xbo and xbo 2 should be true now so this kind of like convinces us that these are in fact the same so xbo and xbo 2 if I just print them okay we're not going to be able to okay we're not going to be able to just stare it down but well let me try Expo basically just

53:56 at the zeroth element and Expo two at the zeroth element so just the first batch and we should see that this and that should be identical which they are right so what happened here the trick is we were able to use batched Matrix multiply to do this aggregation really and it's a weighted aggregation and the weights are specified in this T BYT array and we're basically doing weighted sums and these weighted sums are are U according to the weights inside here

54:28 they take on sort of this triangular form and so that means that a token at the teth dimension will only get sort of information from the tokens perceiving it so that's exactly what we want and finally I would like to rewrite it in one more way and we're going to see why that's useful so this is the third version and it's also identical to the first and second but let me talk through it it uses softmax so Trill here is this Matrix

55:00 lower triangular ones way begins as all zero okay so if I just print way in the beginning it's all zero then I used masked fill so what this is doing is we. masked fill it's all zeros and I'm saying for all the elements where Trill is equal equal Z make them be negative Infinity so all the elements where Trill is zero will become negative Infinity now so this is what we get and

55:32 then the final line here is softmax so if I take a softmax along every single so dim is negative one so along every single row if I do softmax what is that going to do well softmax is is also like a normalization operation right and so spoiler alert you get the exact same Matrix let me bring back to softmax and recall that in softmax we're

56:02 going to exponentiate every single one of these and then we're going to divide by the sum and so if we exponentiate every single element here we're going to get a one and here we're going to get basically zero 0 z0 Z everywhere else and then when we normalize we just get one here we're going to get one one and then zeros and then softmax will again divide and this will give us 5.5 and so on and so this is also the the same

56:30 way to produce this mask now the reason that this is a bit more interesting and the reason we're going to end up using it in self attention is that these weights here begin with zero and you can think of this as like an interaction strength or like an affinity so basically it's telling us how much of each token from the past do we want to Aggregate and average up and then this line is saying tokens from

56:59 the past cannot communicate by setting them to negative Infinity we're saying that we will not aggregate anything from those tokens and so basically this then goes through softmax and through the weighted and this is the aggregation through matrix multiplication and so what this is now is you can think of these as these zeros are currently just set by us to be zero but a quick preview is that these affinities between the tokens are not going to be just constant at zero

57:29 they're going to be data dependent these tokens are going to start looking at each other and some tokens will find other tokens more or less interesting and depending on what their values are they're going to find each other interesting to different amounts and I'm going to call those affinities I think and then here we are saying the future cannot communicate with the past we're we're going to clamp them and then when we normalize and sum we're going to

57:53 aggregate sort of their values depending on how interesting they find each other and so that's the preview for self attention and basically long story short from this entire section is that you can do weighted aggregations of your past Elements by having by using matrix multiplication of a lower triangular fashion and then the elements here in the lower triangular part are telling you how much of each element fuses into this position so we're going to use

58:24 this trick now to develop the self attention block block so first let's get some quick preliminaries out of the way first the thing I'm kind of bothered by is that you see how we're passing in vocap size into the Constructor there's no need to do that because vocap size is already defined up top as a global variable so there's no need to pass this stuff around next what I want to do is I don't want to actually create I want to create

58:46 like a level of indirection here where we don't directly go to the embedding for the logits but instead we go through this intermediate phase because we're going to start making that bigger so let me introduce a new variable n embed it shorted for number of embedding Dimensions so nbed here will be say 32 that was a suggestion from GitHub co-pilot by the way it also suest 32 which is a good number so this is an embedding table and

59:16 only 32 dimensional embeddings so then here this is not going to give us logits directly instead this is going to give us token embeddings that's I'm going to call it and then to go from the token Tings to the logits we're going to need a linear layer so self. LM head let's call it short for language modeling head is n and linear from n ined up to vocap size and then when we swing over here we're

59:41 actually going to get the loits by exactly what the co-pilot says now we have to be careful here because this C and this C are not equal this is nmed C and this is vocap size so let's just say that n ined is equal to C and then this just creates one spous layer of interaction through a linear layer but this should basically

60:11 run so we see that this runs and this currently looks kind of spous but we're going to build on top of this now next up so far we've taken these indices and we've encoded them based on the identity of the tokens in inside idx the next thing that people very often do is that we're not just encoding the identity of these tokens but also their position so we're going to have a second position embedding table here so

60:38 self. position embedding table is an an embedding of block size by an embed and so each position from zero to block size minus one will also get its own embedding vector and then here first let me decode B BYT from idx do shape and then here we're also going to have a pause embedding which is the positional embedding and these are this is to arrange so this will be basically just integers from Z to T minus one and

61:06 all of those integers from 0 to T minus one get embedded through the table to create a t by C and then here this gets renamed to just say x and x will be the addition of the token embeddings with the positional embeddings and here the broadcasting note will work out so B by T by C plus T by C this gets right aligned a new dimension of one gets added and it gets broadcasted across batch so at this point x holds not just

61:34 the token identities but the positions at which these tokens occur and this is currently not that useful because of course we just have a simple byr model so it doesn't matter if you're in the fifth position the second position or wherever it's all translation invariant at this stage so this information currently wouldn't help but as we work on the self attention block we'll see that this starts to matter okay so now we get the Crux of self

62:01 attention so this is probably the most important part of this video to understand we're going to implement a small self attention for a single individual head as they're called so we start off with where we were so all of this code is familiar so right now I'm working with an example where I Chang the number of channels from 2 to 32 so we have a 4x8 arrangement of tokens and each to and the information each token

62:26 is currently 32 dimensional but we just are working with random numbers now we saw here that the code as we had it before does a simple weight simple average of all the past tokens and the current token so it's just the previous information and current information is just being mixed together in an average and that's what this code currently achieves and it Doo by creating this lower triangular structure which allows us to mask out this we

62:55 Matrix that we create so we mask it out and then we normalize it and currently when we initialize the affinities between all the different sort of tokens or nodes I'm going to use those terms interchangeably so when we initialize the affinities between all the different tokens to be zero then we see that way gives us this structure where every single row has these uniform numbers and so that's what that's what then in this Matrix multiply makes it so that

63:27 we're doing a simple average now we don't actually want this to be all uniform because different tokens will find different other tokens more or less interesting and we want that to be data dependent so for example if I'm a vowel then maybe I'm looking for consonants in my past and maybe I want to know what those consonants are and I want that information to flow to me and so I want to now gather information from the past but I want to

63:54 do it in the data dependent way and this is the problem that self attention solves now the way self attention solves this is the following every single node or every single token at each position will emit two vectors it will emit a query and it will emit a key now the query Vector roughly speaking is what am I looking for and the key Vector roughly speaking is what do I contain and then the way we get

64:24 affinities between these tokens now in a sequence is we basically just do a do product between the keys and the queries so my query dot products with all the keys of all the other tokens and that dot product now becomes wayy and so if the key and the query are sort of aligned they will interact to a very high amount and then I will get to learn more about that specific token as opposed to any other token in

64:55 the sequence so let's implement this now we're going to implement a single what's called head of self attention so this is just one head there's a hyper parameter involved with these heads which is the head size and then here I'm initializing linear modules and I'm using bias equals false so these are just going to apply a matrix multiply with some fixed weights and now let me produce a key and

65:26 q k and Q by forwarding these modules on X so the size of this will now become B by T by 16 because that is the head size and the same here B by T by 16 so this being the head size so you see here that when I forward this linear on top of my X all the tokens in all the positions in the B BYT Arrangement all of them them in parallel and

65:57 independently produce a key and a query so no communication has happened yet but the communication comes now all the queries will do product with all the keys so basically what we want is we want way now or the affinities between these to be query multiplying key but we have to be careful with we can't Matrix multiply this we actually need to transpose K but we have to be also careful because these are when you have The Bash Dimension so in particular we

66:27 want to transpose the last two dimensions dimension1 and dimension -2 so -21 and so this Matrix multiply now will basically do the following B by T by 16 Matrix multiplies B by 16 by T to give us B by T by T right so for every row of B we're now going to

66:58 have a t Square Matrix giving us the affinities and these are now the way so they're not zeros they are now coming from this dot product between the keys and the queries so this can now run I can I can run this and the weighted aggregation now is a function in a data Bandon manner between the keys and queries of these nodes so just inspecting what happened here the way takes on this form and you see that before way was just

67:29 a constant so it was applied in the same way to all the batch elements but now every single batch elements will have different sort of we because every single batch element contains different tokens at different positions and so this is not data dependent so when we look at just the zeroth Row for example in the input these are the weights that came out and so you can see now that they're not just exactly uniform and in particular as an

67:55 example here for the last row this was the eighth token and the eighth token knows what content it has and it knows at what position it's in and now the E token based on that creates a query hey I'm looking for this kind of stuff I'm a vowel I'm on the E position I'm looking for any consonant at positions up to four and then all the nodes get to emit keys and maybe one of the channels

68:20 could be I am a I am a consonant and I am in a position up to four and that that key would have a high number in that specific Channel and that's how the query and the key when they do product they can find each other and create a high affinity and when they have a high Affinity like say this token was pretty interesting to to this eighth token when they have a high Affinity then through the softmax I will end up

68:45 aggregating a lot of its information into my position and so I'll get to learn a lot about it now just this we're looking at way after this has already happened let me erase this operation as well so let me erase the masking and the softmax just to show you the under the hood internals and how that works so without the masking in the softmax Whey comes out like this right this is the outputs of the do products and these are the

69:14 raw outputs and they take on values from negative you know two to positive two Etc so that's the raw interactions and raw affinities between all the nodes but now if I'm going if I'm a fifth node I will not want to aggregate anything from the sixth node seventh node and the eighth node so actually we use the upper triangular masking so those are not allowed to communicate and now we actually want to have a nice distribution so we

69:42 don't want to aggregate negative.11 of this node that's crazy so instead we exponentiate and normalize and now we get a nice distribution that sums to one and this is telling us now in the data dependent manner how much of information to aggregate from any of these tokens in the past so that's way and it's not zeros anymore but but it's calculated in this way now there's one more part to a single self attention head and that is

70:10 that when we do the aggregation we don't actually aggregate the tokens exactly we aggregate we produce one more value here and we call that the value so in the same way that we produced p and query we're also going to create a value and then here we don't aggregate X we calculate a v which is just achieved by propagating this linear on top of X again and then we

70:40 output way multiplied by V so V is the elements that we aggregate or the the vectors that we aggregate instead of the raw X and now of course this will make it so that the output here of this single head will be 16 dimensional because that is the head size so you can think of X as kind of like private information to this token if you if you think about it that way so X is kind of private to this token so

71:06 I'm a fifth token at some and I have some identity and my information is kept in Vector X and now for the purposes of the single head here's what I'm interested in here's what I have and if you find me interesting here's what I will communicate to you and that's stored in v and so V is the thing that gets aggregated for the purposes of this single head between the different notes and that's basically the self

71:34 attention mechanism this is this is what it does there are a few notes that I would make like to make about attention number one attention is a communication mechanism you can really think about it as a communication mechanism where you have a number of nodes in a directed graph where basically you have edges pointed between noes like this and what happens is every node has some Vector of information and it gets to aggregate information via a weighted

72:01 sum from all of the nodes that point to it and this is done in a data dependent manner so depending on whatever data is actually stored that you should not at any point in time now our graph doesn't look like this our graph has a different structure we have eight nodes because the block size is eight and there's always eight to tokens and the first node is only pointed to by itself the second node is pointed to by the first node and itself

72:27 all the way up to the eighth node which is pointed to by all the previous nodes and itself and so that's the structure that our directed graph has or happens happens to have in Auto regressive sort of scenario like language modeling but in principle attention can be applied to any arbitrary directed graph and it's just a communication mechanism between the nodes the second note is that notice that there is no notion of space so attention simply acts over like a set of

72:53 vectors in this graph and so by default these nodes have no idea where they are positioned in the space and that's why we need to encode them positionally and sort of give them some information that is anchored to a specific position so that they sort of know where they are and this is different than for example from convolution because if you're run for example a convolution operation over some input there's a very specific sort of layout of the information in space

73:18 and the convolutional filters sort of act in space and so it's it's not like an attention in ATT ention is just a set of vectors out there in space they communicate and if you want them to have a notion of space you need to specifically add it which is what we've done when we calculated the relative the positional encode encodings and added that information to the vectors the next thing that I hope is very clear is that the elements across the batch

73:43 Dimension which are independent examples never talk to each other they're always processed independently and this is a batched matrix multiply that applies basically a matrix multiplication kind of in parallel across the batch dimension so maybe it would be more accurate to say that in this analogy of a directed graph we really have because the back size is four we really have four separate pools of eight nodes and those eight nodes only talk to each other but in total there's like 32 nodes

74:08 that are being processed but there's sort of four separate pools of eight you can look at it that way the next note is that here in the case of language modeling we have this specific structure of directed graph where the future tokens will not communicate to the Past tokens but this doesn't necessarily have to be the constraint in the general case and in fact in many cases you may want to have all of the noes talk to each other

74:35 fully so as an example if you're doing sentiment analysis or something like that with a Transformer you might have a number of tokens and you may want to have them all talk to each other fully because later you are predicting for example the sentiment of the sentence and so it's okay for these NOS to talk to each other and so in those cases you will use an encoder block of self attention and all it means that it's

74:58 an encoder block is that you will delete this line of code allowing all the noes to completely talk to each other what we're implementing here is sometimes called a decoder block and it's called a decoder because it is sort of like a decoding language and it's got this autor regressive format where you have to mask with the Triangular Matrix so that nodes from the future never talk to the Past because they would give away the answer

75:25 and so basically in encoder blocks you would delete this allow all the noes to talk in decoder blocks this will always be present so that you have this triangular structure but both are allowed and attention doesn't care attention supports arbitrary connectivity between nodes the next thing I wanted to comment on is you keep me you keep hearing me say attention self attention Etc there's actually also something called cross attention what is the difference so basically the reason this attention

75:52 is self attention is because because the keys queries and the values are all coming from the same Source from X so the same Source X produces Keys queries and values so these nodes are self attending but in principle attention is much more General than that so for example an encoder decoder Transformers you can have a case where the queries are produced from X but the keys and the values come from a whole separate external source and sometimes from

76:21 encoder blocks that encode some context that we'd like to condition on and so the keys and the values will actually come from a whole separate Source those are nodes on the side and here we're just producing queries and we're reading off information from the side so cross attention is used when there's a separate source of nodes we'd like to pull information from into our nodes and it's self attention if we just have nodes that would like to look at

76:46 each other and talk to each other so this attention here happens to be self attention but in principle attention is a lot more General okay and the last note at this stage is if we come to the attention is all need paper here we've already implemented attention so given query key and value we've U multiplied the query and a key we've soft maxed it and then we are aggregating the values there's one more thing that we're

77:12 missing here which is the dividing by one / square root of the head size the DK here is the head size why are they doing this finds this important so they call it the scaled attention and it's kind of like an important normalization to basically have the problem is if you have unit gsh and inputs so zero mean unit variance K and Q are unit gashin then if you just do we naively then you see that your we

77:37 actually will be the variance will be on the order of head size which in our case is 16 but if you multiply by one over head size square root so this is square root and this is one over then the variance of we will be one so it will be preserved now why is this important you'll not notice that way here will feed into softmax and so it's really important especially at initialization that we be fairly diffuse so in our case here we

78:06 sort of locked out here and we had a fairly diffuse numbers here so like this now the problem is that because of softmax if weight takes on very positive and very negative numbers inside it softmax will actually converge towards one hot vectors and so I can illustrate that here say we are applying softmax to a tensor of values that are very close to zero then we're going to get a diffuse thing out of softmax but the moment I take the exact

78:36 same thing and I start sharpening it making it bigger by multiplying these numbers by eight for example you'll see that the softmax will start to sharpen and in fact it will sharpen towards the max so it will sharpen towards whatever number here is the highest and so basically we don't want these values to be too extreme especially at initialization otherwise softmax will be way too peaky and you're basically aggregating information from like a single node every node just agregates

79:03 information from a single other node that's not what we want especially at initialization and so the scaling is used just to control the variance at initialization okay so having said all that let's now take our self attention knowledge and let's take it for a spin so here in the code I created this head module and it implements a single head of self attention so you give it a head size and then here it creates the key query and the value linear layers

79:29 typically people don't use biases in these so those are the linear projections that we're going to apply to all of our nodes now here I'm creating this Trill variable Trill is not a parameter of the module so in sort of pytorch naming conventions this is called a buffer it's not a parameter and you have to call it you have to assign it to the module using a register buffer so that creates the trill the triang lower triangular Matrix and we're given

79:55 the input X this should look very familiar now we calculate the keys the queries we C calculate the attention scores inside way we normalize it so we're using scaled attention here then we make sure that future doesn't communicate with the past so this makes it a decoder block and then softmax and then aggregate the value and output then here in the language model I'm creating a head in the Constructor and I'm calling it self attention head

80:22 and the head size I'm going to keep as the same and embed just for now and then here once we've encoded the information with the token embeddings and the position embeddings we're simply going to feed it into the self attention head and then the output of that is going to go into the decoder language modeling head and create the logits so this the sort of the simplest way to plug in a self attention component into our Network right now I had to make

80:51 one more change which is that here in the generate we have to make sure that our idx that we feed into the model because now we're using positional embeddings we can never have more than block size coming in because if idx is more than block size then our position embedding table is going to run out of scope because it only has embeddings for up to block size and so therefore I added some code here to crop the

81:17 context that we're going to feed into self so that we never pass in more than block siiz elements so those are the changes and let's Now train the network okay so I also came up to the script here and I decreased the learning rate because the self attention can't tolerate very very high learning rates and then I also increased number of iterations because the learning rate is lower and then I trained it and previously we were only

81:41 able to get to up to 2.5 and now we are down to 2.4 so we definitely see a little bit of an improvement from 2.5 to 2.4 roughly but the text is still not amazing so clearly the self attention head is doing some useful communication but we still have a long way to go okay so now we've implemented the scale. product attention now next up and the attention is all you need paper there's something called multi-head attention

82:07 and what is multi-head attention it's just applying multiple attentions in parallel and concatenating their results so they have a little bit of diagram here I don't know if this is super clear it's really just multiple attentions in parallel so let's Implement that fairly straightforward if we want a multi-head attention then we want multiple heads of self attention running in parallel so in pytorch we can do this by simply creating multiple heads so however heads how however many

82:38 heads you want and then what is the head size of each and then we run all of them in parallel into a list and simply concatenate all of the outputs and we're concatenating over the channel Dimension so the way this looks now is we don't have just a single ATT that has a hit size of 32 because remember n Ed is 32 instead of having one Communication channel we now have four communication channels in parallel and each one of

83:08 these communication channels typically will be smaller correspondingly so because we have four communication channels we want eight dimensional self attention and so from each Communication channel we're going to together eight dimensional vectors and then we have four of them and that concatenates to give us 32 which is the original and embed and so this is kind of similar to if you're familiar with convolutions this is kind of like a group convolution because basically instead of having

83:36 one large convolution we do convolution in groups and that's multi-headed self attention and so then here we just use essay heads self attention heads instead now I actually ran it and scrolling down I ran the same thing and then we now get this down to 2.28 roughly and the output is still the generation is still not amazing but clearly the validation loss is improving because we were at 2.4 just now and so it helps to have multiple communication channels

84:07 because obviously these tokens have a lot to talk about they want to find the consonants the vowels they want to find the vowels just from certain positions they want to find any kinds of different things and so it helps to create multiple independent channels of communication gather lots of different types of data and then decode the output now going back to the paper for a second of course I didn't explain this figure in full detail but we are

84:30 starting to see some components of what we've already implemented we have the positional encodings the token encodings that add we have the masked multi-headed attention implemented now here's another multi-headed attention which is a cross attention to an encoder which we haven't we're not going to implement in this case I'm going to come back to that later but I want you to notice that there's a feed forward part here and then this is grouped into a block that

84:53 gets repeat it again and again now the feedforward part here is just a simple multi-layer perceptron so the multi-headed so here position wise feed forward networks is just a simple little MLP so I want to start basically in a similar fashion also adding computation into the network and this computation is on a per node level so I've already implemented it and you can see the diff highlighted on the left here when I've added or changed things

85:22 now before we had the self multi-headed self attention that did the communication but we went way too fast to calculate the logits so the tokens looked at each other but didn't really have a lot of time to think on what they found from the other tokens and so what I've implemented here is a little feet forward single layer and this little layer is just a linear followed by a Rel nonlinearity and that's that's it so it's just a little layer and then I call

85:50 it feed forward and embed and then this feed forward is just called sequentially right after the self attention so we self attend then we feed forward and you'll notice that the feet forward here when it's applying linear this is on a per token level all the tokens do this independently so the self attention is the communication and then once they've gathered all the data now they need to think on that data individually and so that's what feed

86:16 forward is doing and that's why I've added it here now when I train this the validation LW actually continues to go down now to 2. 24 which is down from 2.28 the output still look kind of terrible but at least we've improved the situation and so as a preview we're going to now start to intersperse the communication with the computation and that's also what the Transformer does when it has blocks that communicate and then compute and it groups them and

86:46 replicates them okay so let me show you what we'd like to do we'd like to do something like this we have a block and this block is is basically this part here except for the cross attention now the block basically intersperses communication and then computation the computation the communication is done using multi-headed selfelf attention and then the computation is done using a feed forward Network on all the tokens independently now what I've added here also is you'll

87:16 notice this takes the number of embeddings in the embedding Dimension and number of heads that we would like which is kind of like group size in group convolution and and I'm saying that number of heads we'd like is four and so because this is 32 we calculate that because this is 32 the number of heads should be four the head size should be eight so that everything sort of works out Channel wise so this is how the Transformer structures sort

87:41 of the the sizes typically so the head size will become eight and then this is how we want to intersperse them and then here I'm trying to create blocks which is just a sequential application of block block block so that we're interspersing communication feed forward many many times and then finally we decode now I actually tried to run this and the problem is this doesn't actually give a very good answer and very good result and the reason for that

88:07 is we're start starting to actually get like a pretty deep neural net and deep neural Nets suffer from optimization issues and I think that's what we're kind of like slightly starting to run into so we need one more idea that we can borrow from the Transformer paper to resolve those difficulties now there are two optimizations that dramatically help with the depth of these networks and make sure that the networks remain optimizable let's talk about the first

88:31 one the first one in this diagram is you see this Arrow here and then this arrow and this Arrow those are skip connections or sometimes called residual connections they come from this paper the presidual learning for image recognition from about 2015 that introduced the concept now these are basically what it means is you transform data but then you have a skip connection with addition from the previous features now the way I like to visualize it that I prefer is the

89:03 following here the computation happens from the top to bottom and basically you have this residual pathway and you are free to Fork off from the residual pathway perform some computation and then project back to the residual pathway via addition and so you go from the the inputs to the targets only via plus and plus plus and the reason this is useful is because during back propagation remember from our microG grad video earlier addition distributes gradients equally to both of its

89:34 branches that that fed as the input and so the supervision or the gradients from the loss basically hop through every addition node all the way to the input and then also Fork off into the residual blocks but basically you have this gradient Super Highway that goes directly from the supervision all the way to the input unimpeded and then these viral blocks are usually initialized in the beginning so they contribute very very little if anything to the residual pathway they they are

90:05 initialized that way so in the beginning they are sort of almost kind of like not there but then during the optimization they come online over time and they start to contribute but at least at the initialization you can go from directly supervision to the input gradient is unimpeded and just flows and then the blocks over time kick in and so that dramatically helps with the optimization so let's implement this so coming back to our block here

90:31 basically what we want to do is we want to do xal X+ self attention and xal X+ self. feed forward so this is X and then we Fork off and do some communication and come back and we Fork off and we do some computation and come back so those are residual connections and then swinging back up here we also have to introd use this projection so nn. linear and this is going to be from after we concatenate this this is

91:03 the prze and embed so this is the output of the self tension itself but then we actually want the to apply the projection and that's the result so the projection is just a linear transformation of the outcome of this layer so that's the projection back into the virual pathway and then here in a feet forward it's going to be the same same thing I could have a a self doot projection here as well but let me just

91:28 simplify it and let me couple it inside the same sequential container and so this is the projection layer going back into the residual pathway and so that's well that's it so now we can train this so I implemented one more small change when you look into the paper again you see that the dimensionality of input and output is 512 for them and they're saying that the inner layer here in the feet forward has dimensionality of 248 so there's a

91:57 multiplier of four and so the inner layer of the feet forward Network should be multiplied by four in terms of Channel sizes so I came here and I multiplied four times embed here for the feed forward and then from four times nmed coming back down to nmed when we go back to the pro to the projection so adding a bit of computation here and growing that layer that is in the residual block on the side of the

92:21 residual pathway and then I train this and we actually get down all the way to 2.08 validation loss and we also see that network is starting to get big enough that our train loss is getting ahead of validation loss so we're starting to see like a little bit of overfitting and our our Generations here are still not amazing but at least you see that we can see like is here this now grief syn like this starts to almost look like English

92:48 so yeah we're starting to really get there okay and the second Innovation that is very helpful for optimizing very deep neural networks is right here so we have this addition now that's the residual part but this Norm is referring to something called layer Norm so layer Norm is implemented in pytorch it's a paper that came out a while back here and layer Norm is very very similar to bash Norm so remember back to our make more series part three we

93:16 implemented bash normalization and bash normalization basically just made sure that Across The Bash dimension any individual neuron had unit Gan distribution so it was zero mean and unit standard deviation one standard deviation output so what I did here is I'm copy pasting the bashor 1D that we developed in our make more series and see here we can initialize for example this module and we can have a batch of 32 100

93:47 dimensional vectors feeding through the bachor layer so what this does is it guarantees that when we look at just the zeroth column it's a zero mean one standard deviation so it's normalizing every single column of this input now the rows are not going to be normalized by default because we're just normalizing columns so let's now Implement layer Norm it's very complicated look we come here we change this from zero to one so we don't

94:18 normalize The Columns we normalize the rows and now we've implemented layer Norm so now the columns are not going to be normalized but the rows are going to be normalized for every individual example it's 100 dimensional Vector is normalized in this way and because our computation Now does not span across examples we can delete all of this buffers stuff because we can always apply this operation and don't

94:48 need to maintain any running buffers so we don't need the buffers we don't There's no distinction between training and test time and we don't need these running buffers we do keep gamma and beta we don't need the momentum we don't care if it's training or not and this is now a layer norm and it normalizes the rows instead of the columns and this here is identical to basically this here so

95:19 let's now Implement layer Norm in our Transformer before I incorporate the layer Norm I just wanted to note that as I said very few details about the Transformer have changed in the last 5 years but this is actually something that slightly departs from the original paper you see that the ADD and Norm is applied after the transformation but in now it is a bit more basically common to apply the layer Norm before the transformation so there's a reshuffling of the layer Norms

95:46 so this is called the prorm formulation and that's the one that we're going to implement as well so select deviation from the original paper basically we need two layer Norms layer Norm one is NN do layer norm and we tell it how many what is the embedding Dimension and we need the second layer norm and then here the layer Norms are applied immediately on X so self. layer Norm one applied on X and self. layer Norm two applied on X before

96:15 it goes into self attention and feed forward and the size of the layer Norm here is an ed so 32 so when the layer Norm is normalizing our features it is the normalization here happens the mean and the variance are taken over 32 numbers so the batch and the time act as batch Dimensions both of them so this is kind of like a per token transformation that just normalizes the features and makes them a unit mean

96:46 unit Gan at initialization but of course because these layer Norms inside it have these gamma and beta training parameters the layer Norm will U eventually create outputs that might not be unit gion but the optimization will determine that so for now this is the this is incorporating the layer norms and let's train them on okay so I let it run and we see that we get down to 2.06 which is better than the previous 2.08 so a slight Improvement by adding the

97:15 layer norms and I'd expect that they help even more if we had bigger and deeper Network one more thing I forgot to add is that there should be a layer Norm here also typically as at the end of the Transformer and right before the final linear layer that decodes into vocabulary so I added that as well so at this stage we actually have a pretty complete Transformer according to the original paper and it's a decoder only

97:40 Transformer I'll I'll talk about that in a second but at this stage the major pieces are in place so we can try to scale this up and see how well we can push this number now in order to scale out the model I had to perform some cosmetic changes here to make it nicer so I introduced this variable called n layer which just specifies how many layers of the blocks we're going to have I created a bunch of blocks and we have

98:02 a new variable number of heads as well I pulled out the layer Norm here and so this is identical now one thing that I did briefly change is I added a Dropout so Dropout is something that you can add right before the residual connection back right before the connection back into the residual pathway so we can drop out that as l layer here we can drop out here at the end of the multi-headed exension as well and we can also drop

98:30 out here when we calculate the basically affinities and after the softmax we can drop out some of those so we can randomly prevent some of the nodes from communicating and so Dropout comes from this paper from 2014 or so and basically it takes your neural nut and it randomly every forward backward pass shuts off some subset of neurons so randomly drops them to zero and trains without them and what

99:02 this does effectively is because the mask of what's being dropped out is changed every single forward backward pass it ends up kind of training an ensemble of sub networks and then at test time everything is fully enabled and kind of all of those sub networks are merged into a single Ensemble if you can if you want to think about it that way so I would read the paper to get the full detail for now we're just going to

99:24 stay on the level of this is a regularization technique and I added it because I'm about to scale up the model quite a bit and I was concerned about overfitting so now when we scroll up to the top we'll see that I changed a number of hyper parameters here about our neural nut so I made the batch size be much larger now it's 64 I changed the block size to be 256 so previously it was just eight eight characters of

99:47 context now it is 256 characters of context to predict the 257th I brought down the learning rate a little bit because the neural net is now much bigger so I brought down the learning rate the embedding Dimension is now 384 and there are six heads so 384 divide 6 means that every head is 64 dimensional as it as a standard and then there's going to be six layers of that and the Dropout will be at 02 so every

100:15 forward backward pass 20% of all of these intermediate calculations are disabled and dropped to zero and then I already trained this and I ran it so drum roll how well does it perform so let me just scroll up here we get a validation loss of 1.48 which is actually quite a bit of an improvement on what we had before which I think was 2.07 so it went from 2.07 all the way down to 1.48 just by scaling

100:43 up this neural nut with the code that we have and this of course ran for a lot longer this maybe trained for I want to say about 15 minutes on my a100 GPU so that's a pretty a GPU and if you don't have a GPU you're not going to be able to reproduce this on a CPU this would be I would not run this on a CPU or MacBook or something like that you'll have to Brak down the number of

101:04 layers and the embedding Dimension and so on but in about 15 minutes we can get this kind of a result and I'm printing some of the Shakespeare here but what I did also is I printed 10,000 characters so a lot more and I wrote them to a file and so here we see some of the outputs so it's a lot more recognizable as the input text file so the input text file just for reference looked like this so

101:31 there's always like someone speaking in this manner and our predictions now take on that form except of course they're they're nonsensical when you actually read them so it is every crimp tap be a house oh those prepation we give heed you know Oho sent me you mighty Lord anyway so you can read through this

102:02 it's nonsensical of course but this is just a Transformer trained on a character level for 1 million characters that come from Shakespeare so there's sort of like blabbers on in Shakespeare like manner but it doesn't of course make sense at this scale but I think I think still a pretty good demonstration of what's possible so now I think that kind of like concludes the programming section of this video we basically kind of did a pretty good

102:30 job and of implementing this Transformer but the picture doesn't exactly match up to what we've done so what's going on with all these digital Parts here so let me finish explaining this architecture and why it looks so funky basically what's happening here is what we implemented here is a decoder only Transformer so there's no component here this part is called the encoder and there's no cross attention block here our block only has a self attention and

102:58 the feet forward so it is missing this third in between piece here this piece does cross attention so we don't have it and we don't have the encoder we just have the decoder and the reason we have a decoder only is because we are just generating text and it's unconditioned on anything we're just we're just blabbering on according to a given data set what makes it a decoder is that we are using the Triangular mask in our trans former so it has this

103:24 Auto regressive property where we can just go and sample from it so the fact that it's using the Triangular triangular mask to mask out the attention makes it a decoder and it can be used for language modeling now the reason that the original paper had an incoder decoder architecture is because it is a machine translation paper so it is concerned with a different setting in particular it expects some tokens that encode say for example French and

103:52 then it is expecting to decode the translation in English so so you typically these here are special tokens so you are expected to read in this and condition on it and then you start off the generation with a special token called start so this is a special new token that you introduce and always place in the beginning and then the network is expected to Output neural networks are awesome and then a special end token to finish the

104:20 generation so this part here will be decoded exactly as we we've done it neural networks are awesome will be identical to what we did but unlike what we did they wanton to condition the generation on some additional information and in that case this additional information is the French sentence that they should be translating so what they do now is they bring in the encoder now the encoder reads this part here so we're only going to take the part of French and we're

104:50 going to create tokens from it exactly as we've seen in our video and we're going to put a Transformer on it but there's going to be no triangular mask and so all the tokens are allowed to talk to each other as much as they want and they're just encoding whatever's the content of this French sentence once they've encoded it they they basically come out in the top here and then what happens here is in our decoder which does the language

105:17 modeling there's an additional connection here to the outputs of the encoder and that is brought in through a cross attention so the queries are still generated from X but now the keys and the values are coming from the side the keys and the values are coming from the top generated by the nodes that came outside of the de the encoder and those tops the keys and the values there the top of it feed in on a side into every

105:45 single block of the decoder and so that's why there's an additional cross attention and really what it's doing is it's conditioning the decoding not just on the past of this current decoding but also on having seen the full fully encoded French prompt sort of and so it's an encoder decoder model which is why we have those two Transformers an additional block and so on so we did not do this because we have no we have nothing to encode there's no

106:13 conditioning we just have a text file and we just want to imitate it and that's why we are using a decoder only Transformer exactly as done in GPT okay okay so now I wanted to do a very brief walkthrough of nanog GPT which you can find in my GitHub and nanog GPT is basically two files of Interest there's train.py and model.py train.py is all the boilerplate code for training the network it is basically all the stuff that we had here it's the

106:40 training loop it's just that it's a lot more complicated because we're saving and loading checkpoints and pre-trained weights and we are decaying the learning rate and compiling the model and using distributed training across multiple nodes or GP use so the training Pi gets a little bit more hairy complicated there's more options Etc but the model.py should look very very similar to what we've done here in fact the model is is almost identical so first here we have the causal self

107:09 attention block and all of this should look very very recognizable to you we're producing queries Keys values we're doing Dot products we're masking applying soft Maxs optionally dropping out and here we are pulling the wi the values what is different here is that in our code I have separated out the multi-headed detention into just a single individual head and then here I have multiple heads and I explicitly concatenate them whereas here all of it is implemented in a batched manner

107:41 inside a single causal self attention and so we don't just have a b and a T and A C Dimension we also end up with a fourth dimension which is the heads and so it just gets a lot more sort of hairy because we have four dimensional array tensors now but it is equivalent mathematically so the exact same thing is happening as what we have it's just it's a bit more efficient because all the heads are now treated as a batch

108:04 Dimension as well then we have the multier perceptron it's using the Galu nonlinearity which is defined here except instead of Ru and this is done just because opening I used it and I want to be able to load their checkpoints the blocks of the Transformer are identical to communicate in the compute phase as we saw and then the GPT will be identical we have the position encodings token encodings the blocks the layer Norm at the end the

108:30 final linear layer and this should look all very recognizable and there's a bit more here because I'm loading checkpoints and stuff like that I'm separating out the parameters into those that should be weight decayed and those that shouldn't but the generate function should also be very very similar so a few details are different but you should definitely be able to look at this file and be able to understand little the pieces now so let's now bring things

108:55 back to chat GPT what would it look like if we wanted to train chat GPT ourselves and how does it relate to what we learned today well to train in chat GPT there are roughly two stages first is the pre-training stage and then the fine-tuning stage in the pre-training stage we are training on a large chunk of internet and just trying to get a first decoder only Transformer to babble text so it's very very similar to

109:20 what we've done ourselves except we've done like a tiny little baby pre-training step and so in our case this is how you print a number of parameters I printed it and it's about 10 million so this Transformer that I created here to create little Shakespeare Transformer was about 10 million parameters our data set is roughly 1 million characters so roughly 1 million tokens but you have to remember that opening I is different vocabulary they're not on the Character

109:50 level they use these subword chunks of words and so they have a vocabulary of 50,000 roughly elements and so their sequences are a bit more condensed so our data set the Shakespeare data set would be probably around 300,000 tokens in the open AI vocabulary roughly so we trained about 10 million parameter model on roughly 300,000 tokens now when you go to the gpt3 paper and you look at the Transformers that they trained they trained a number

110:22 of trans Transformers of different sizes but the biggest Transformer here has 175 billion parameters so ours is again 10 million they used this number of layers in the Transformer this is the nmed this is the number of heads and this is the head size and then this is the batch size so ours was 65 and the learning rate is similar now when they train this Transformer they trained on 300 billion tokens so again remember ours is about 300,000

110:53 so this is about a millionfold increase and this number would not be even that large by today's standards you'd be going up 1 trillion and above so they are training a significantly larger model on a good chunk of the internet and that is the pre-training stage but otherwise these hyper parameters should be fairly recognizable to you and the architecture is actually like nearly identical to what we implemented ourselves but of course it's a massive infrastructure challenge to train this

111:22 you're talking about typically thousands of gpus having to you know talk to each other to train models of this size so that's just a pre-training stage now after you complete the pre-training stage you don't get something that responds to your questions with answers and is not helpful and Etc you get a document completer right so it babbles but it doesn't Babble Shakespeare it babbles internet it will create arbitrary news articles and documents and it will try

111:50 to complete documents because that's what it's trained for it's trying to complete the sequence so when you give it a question it would just potentially just give you more questions it would follow with more questions it will do whatever it looks like the some close document would do in the training data on the internet and so who knows you're getting kind of like undefined Behavior it might basically answer with to questions with other questions it might ignore your question it might just

112:15 try to complete some news article it's totally unineed as we say so the second fine-tuning stage is to actually align it to be an assistant and this is the second stage and so this chat GPT block post from openi talks a little bit about how the stage is achieved we basically there's roughly three steps to to this stage so what they do here is they start to collect training data that looks specifically like what an assistant would do so these are

112:44 documents that have to format where the question is on top and then an answer is below and they have a large number of these but probably not on the order of the internet this is probably on the of maybe thousands of examples and so they they then fine-tune the model to basically only focus on documents that look like that and so you're starting to slowly align it so it's going to expect a question at the top and it's going to

113:08 expect to complete the answer and these very very large models are very sample efficient during their fine-tuning so this actually somehow works but that's just step one that's just fine tuning so then they actually have more steps where okay the second step is you let the model respond and then different Raiders look at the different responses and rank them for their preference as to which one is better than the other they use that to train a reward model so they can predict

113:35 basically using a different network how much of any candidate response would be desirable and then once they have a reward model they run po which is a form of polic policy gradient reinforcement learning Optimizer to fine-tune this sampling policy so that the answers that the GP chat GPT now generates are expected to score a high reward according to the reward model and so basically there's a whole aligning stage here or fine-tuning

114:07 stage it's got multiple steps in between there as well and it takes the model from being a document completer to a question answerer and that's like a whole separate stage a lot of this data is not available publicly it is internal to open AI and it's much harder to replicate this stage and so that's roughly what would give you a chat GPT and nanog GPT focuses on the pre-training stage okay and that's everything that I wanted to cover today

114:35 so we trained to summarize a decoder only Transformer following this famous paper attention is all you need from 2017 and so that's basically a GPT we trained it on Tiny Shakespeare and got sensible results all of the training code is roughly 200 lines of code I will be releasing this code base so also it comes with all the git log commits along the way as we built it

115:05 up in addition to this code I'm going to release the notebook of course the Google collab and I hope that gave you a sense for how you can train these models like say gpt3 that will be architecturally basically identical to what we have but they are somewhere between 10,000 and 1 million times bigger depending on how you count and so that's all I have for now we did not talk about any of the fine-tuning stages that would typically go on top of

115:33 this so if you're interested in something that's not just language modeling but you actually want to you know say perform tasks or you want them to be aligned in a specific way or you want to detect sentiment or anything like that basically anytime you don't want something that's just a document completer you have to complete further stages of fine tuning which did not cover and that could be simple supervised fine tuning or it can be something more fancy like we see in chat

115:58 jpt where we actually train a reward model and then do rounds of Po to align it with respect to the reward model so there's a lot more that can be done on top of it I think for now we're starting to get to about two hours Mark so I'm going to kind of finish here I hope you enjoyed the lecture and yeah go forth and transform see you later