transcribe

How to Spot Real Passion in Interviews

Shreyas Doshi · 7m · transcribed Oct 2026
More from Shreyas Doshi Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

Assessing Passion in Interviews

What should you pay attention to when interviewing a director-level PM?

Focus on the questions they ask about the job, as these can reveal their true passion and interest in the role.

  • The first questions a candidate asks can indicate their level of interest and passion.
  • Common questions about the role may not truly reflect a candidate's passion for the product.
  • Sophisticated candidates may provide impressive answers but still lack genuine passion.
# 1:31

Evaluating Candidate Responses

How can a candidate's response indicate their passion?

An impressive answer about their interest may not prove their passion; instead, the questions they ask are more telling.

  • Candidates often showcase their persuasive skills in interviews.
  • The depth of questions asked can reveal true engagement with the product.
  • Passion is better reflected in the inquiries made rather than the answers given.
# 3:02

Understanding Candidate Questions

What do the first questions a candidate asks reveal about them?

If a candidate's initial questions focus on team size, growth plans, and evaluation expectations, it may indicate a more self-centered approach rather than a passion for the product.

  • Questions about team structure and growth can be standard but may lack depth.
  • The nature of questions can indicate whether a candidate is focused on personal advancement or the product's success.
  • Understanding the implications of candidate questions is crucial for evaluating their fit.
# 4:33

Comparing Candidate Engagement

How do different types of questions reflect candidate passion?

Candidate B's questions about product shortcomings and strategic choices demonstrate a deeper engagement with the product compared to Candidate A's more standard inquiries.

  • In-depth questions about product strategy indicate a candidate's genuine interest.
  • Candidates who ask about market competition and customer needs show a proactive mindset.
  • Evaluating the type of questions asked can help distinguish between superficial interest and true passion.
# 6:04

Interpreting Candidate Intent

Why might a candidate's answers not reflect their true passion?

Sophisticated PMs often know how to craft their responses to align with what interviewers want to hear, making it difficult to gauge their true passion from answers alone.

  • Candidates may provide polished answers that align with expectations, masking their true motivations.
  • Observing candidate behavior and questions can provide clearer insights into their genuine interests.
  • Understanding the difference between what candidates say and what they do is key to assessing their fit.

Transcript

0:00 So, let's say you're talking to somebody who say at a director level. And again, we've said passion for this problem, passion for this area is very important. So, let's say you're talking to a director level PM. You're interviewing a director level PM or even a GPM level PM. So, somebody who's who has experience, somebody who has contacts, somebody who's done a bunch of things. Fair? Okay. So, let's say you're interviewing such a person. Pay attention to the questions they first ask you about the job. So, how does this work? You have a conversation. At some point, you will say, "What questions do you have?" You might say it at the beginning or you might say it at the end. Yes? Okay. Now, if in this conversation, the first question from this candidate, who otherwise is very impressive. They have a great resume. They're very impressive. They tell you they're very passionate. In fact, when you ask them, so here's how most people test for passion. They say, "What makes you interested in this role?" That's the question they ask.

1:00 "What makes you interested in this role?" Is this a common interview question? Some version of this. "What makes you interested in this job? What makes you interested in this company? Why are you applying?" That's some version of this. Very common question. So, we think that question is actually going to test for interest. Now, usually if it's a it's if again, remember it's a sophisticated PM. How good or bad is their answer going to be to this question? How good or bad? Is it going to be a bad answer or a good answer usually to why you're interested in this role?

1:29 What makes you interested in this role? It's going to be an amazing answer. They'll say, "I have strong I really believe in the power of AI to improve media." If that's the domain. And I believe it's going to democratize access and it's going to make the world a better place, whatever. And let me tell you I did that 3 years ago at this company. And so, that really was very fulfilling. Right? Yes or no? Their answer is going to be really impressive.

1:57 So, then what do you do in a typical interview process? You say, "Great. Check. They are very passionate." But now understand, this is a sophisticated person. This is literally how they do their job, right? They make other people inspired. They make other people feel motivated. They make other people They persuade other people. So, in a way, they are showing you job-relevant skills, but they're actually not proving that they have passion. What shows their passion in the product is actually the question they ask you.

2:29 So, now let's say in this situation, the first question that this director-level person asks is, "Can you give me a sense of the size of the team and the growth plans for the team?" Is this a reasonable question that people will ask in an interview process? That people commonly ask as a candidate? Yes or no? Yes. Okay. The next question they ask you is, "Can you give me an idea of what other cross-functional leaders I will be working with?"

2:59 Is this a question that people typically ask? Yes, of course they do. Okay. Next question. "What are the growth prospects for someone in this role?" Or another version of this is, "What are the 6-month, 12-month expectations you have for someone in this role?" Is that a common question that usually a leadership candidate will ask? Okay. Great. Are these bad questions to ask in a leadership?

3:30 No, it's not. These are not bad questions. But what is important to understand, and here's where I give you a hypothetical, what if those questions that I shared with you, what if those were the first three questions this candidate asked in your very first conversation? What are you learning from this? What is the candidate telling you about themselves? Okay. All right. I know this is an advanced question. So, I will ask you few other questions so you understand. So, that was candidate A. So, candidate A basically asked questions about what's the size of the team, what are the growth plans of the team, what are the core people and leaders I'll be working with. And the third question is what are your expectations? How are you going to evaluate me in this role? How am I going to be evaluated? What does my growth trajectory look like?

4:20 Does that make sense? Those were the first several questions this candidate asked. Candidate A. Now, candidate B asked the following questions. I'm curious. I did some research on our product on this product and I'm curious while the product is doing really well and I can see that in the market, where is the product most falling short in meeting customer needs? Question one. Okay. Question two. Our product or this product, I noticed is not addressing use cases A, B, and C.

5:00 And I see another product from a startup that is actually starting to address use case use cases A, B, and C for customers. And I'm curious if this is an intentional decision, if this is a strategic choice that we have made, or if this is just something that there are plans to work on to address use cases A, B, and C. So, that's question two. Okay. Question three. Does the team and org at this point have clarity on the product strategy or have clarity on how we are prioritizing the next one or two years worth of work that is going to occur on the team?

5:44 So, those are the three questions candidate B asked. Say they were among the first few questions candidate B asked. Now, my friends, please tell me which candidate is showing a true passion for the product and the domain? A or B? Look, you all actually appreciated. You all appreciated the questions candidate A asked. Yes or no? You all said, "Oh, that shows they are thoughtful. It shows they various other things. They are excited, interested." That's sort of whatever it was. Yes or no? So, do you see how it is easy to get impressed with candidate A? However, the very questions that candidate candidate A asked indicate that candidate A does not have that strong passion for the product, the customers, the domain.

6:33 Or certainly does not have as much passion for the product, the customers, the the domain as candidate B. Is that clear? Now, why is this very evident in the questions they ask you and not so evident in the answers they provide to your questions? You know why? Because again, at certain levels, PMs are very sophisticated. They know exactly the answer you are looking for. That is actually one of the PM skills. That actually makes them effective on the job. So, it's not a nonsense skill. It's actually a useful skill. They are just manifesting that skill in the interview setting. So, when you ask them a question that is oriented around passion, of course, they're going to give you a beautiful answer. But when they have See, here's how you read a person. So, this gets to I'll complete my answer to the original question. The way you read a person is by looking at what they do and what they say when there are no constraints.

Summary

In this discussion, the speaker emphasizes the importance of evaluating candidates for product management roles not just by their impressive resumes or answers, but by the questions they ask during interviews. Candidates who demonstrate a genuine passion for the product and its domain tend to ask insightful questions about customer needs and product strategy, rather than focusing solely on team structure or personal growth.

- Candidates' questions reveal their true passion for the product and domain.
- Impressive answers to common passion-related questions may not reflect genuine interest.
- Candidate A asks typical questions about team size and growth, indicating a focus on personal career trajectory.
- Candidate B asks probing questions about product shortcomings and market competition, showing deeper engagement.
- Sophisticated candidates often know how to craft appealing responses, masking their true level of passion.
- Evaluating candidates should focus on their inquiries, which reflect their understanding and commitment to the product.
- The distinction between superficial interest and genuine passion can be discerned through the nature of their questions.

Questions Answered

What should you pay attention to when interviewing a director-level PM?

Focus on the questions they ask about the job, as these can reveal their true passion and interest in the role.

How can a candidate's response indicate their passion?

An impressive answer about their interest may not prove their passion; instead, the questions they ask are more telling.

What do the first questions a candidate asks reveal about them?

If a candidate's initial questions focus on team size, growth plans, and evaluation expectations, it may indicate a more self-centered approach rather than a passion for the product.

How do different types of questions reflect candidate passion?

Candidate B's questions about product shortcomings and strategic choices demonstrate a deeper engagement with the product compared to Candidate A's more standard inquiries.

Why might a candidate's answers not reflect their true passion?

Sophisticated PMs often know how to craft their responses to align with what interviewers want to hear, making it difficult to gauge their true passion from answers alone.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram