transcribe

The ElevenLabs Situation Is Crazy

Chris Williamson · 14m · transcribed Oct 2026
More from Chris Williamson Business
𝕏 Share ▶ YouTube 📥 PDF 🤖 .md

Section Insights

# 0:00

The Concerns of Voice Cloning

What are the implications of AI voice cloning?

The speaker expresses concern over AI technology that can replicate voices, highlighting personal experiences where their voice was cloned without consent. This raises questions about identity, ownership, and the potential misuse of AI-generated voices.

  • AI voice cloning can lead to unauthorized use of an individual's voice.
  • The speaker feels a sense of helplessness regarding the situation.
  • There is a growing concern about the authenticity and trustworthiness of AI-generated content.
# 2:55

The Popularity of AI Voices

How prevalent is the cloning of voices in AI?

The speaker discovers that their voice is among the most popular on AI platforms, allowing anyone to use it for various purposes without consent. This raises ethical concerns about voice ownership and the commercialization of personal identities.

  • AI platforms can easily replicate popular voices for a small fee.
  • The speaker's voice is being used without their permission, leading to potential misrepresentation.
  • There is a lack of legal frameworks protecting individuals from unauthorized voice cloning.
# 5:50

Trust and Authenticity in AI

Why is there a difference in societal reaction to music and voice cloning?

The speaker reflects on the societal norms surrounding the use of AI in music versus voice cloning, noting that while music theft is widely condemned, voice cloning lacks similar outrage. This discrepancy highlights the need for clearer ethical guidelines.

  • Society is more aware and outraged about music cloning than voice cloning.
  • The authenticity of a person's voice is crucial for trust and identity.
  • There is a growing need for legal clarity regarding the use of AI-generated voices.
# 8:46

Legal Rights and Voice Ownership

What legal recourse is available for voice cloning?

The speaker discusses the challenges of proving ownership of their voice and the lack of legal precedents in the digital age. They explore past legal cases involving voice imitation and consider consulting a copyright lawyer for guidance.

  • Legal protections for voice ownership are unclear in the context of AI.
  • Historical cases show that voice imitation can be unlawful, but modern applications complicate this.
  • Individuals may struggle to assert their rights over their own voices in the digital landscape.
# 11:41

Documenting Evidence for Legal Action

What steps should be taken if someone believes their voice has been cloned?

The speaker is advised to document evidence of unauthorized use of their voice, including instances where people mistakenly associate them with AI-generated content. This documentation could support potential legal claims.

  • Collecting evidence is crucial for any legal action regarding voice cloning.
  • Public perception and association can play a significant role in legal cases.
  • There is a need for individuals to be proactive in protecting their voice rights.

Transcript

0:00 I think this AI company stole my voice. >> 11 laps >> 11 labs >> 11 labs >> >> The potential of conversational AI has never been greater. >> Three massive searches, more than $200 million spent. This is Archer from 11 labs. Yeah, that's Chris's voice. Give him some money. >> That's when you sue. >> It's not just about my voice. It's about the helplessness. What should I realistically do next? Have I got a case here? >> >> Cheerio, mates. Sometimes you need clean energy to focus, but sometimes you just want to get pissed. That's why I'm excited to introduce new Loco. It's like Neutonic, but the opposite. It's like piss. It's like pure Chris piss.

0:45 And for only $10,000, you can play an investor. That was obviously not me. Those are things I'd never actually say, and that is a product that doesn't exist. And yet, if it were adjusted just a bit, do you think that you'd be able to tell that that was AI? This is a problem I've been grappling with for a while. So, let's go back to the start. A few months ago, a friend of mine sent me a link to a YouTube video. I want you to listen to this clip and tell me if anything sounds familiar. It's been over 12 years since the disappearance of flight MH370.

1:18 Three massive searches, more than $200 million spent, and on March 8th, 2026, Ocean Infinity officially called off their last search. Naturally, I was a little bothered. I mean, what did happen to that aircraft? But also, that narrator sounds a lot like me. He sounds so much like me that my own friend was asking me if it was me. Clearly, this voice was generated with AI, but what makes it so creepy is that even the things it gets wrong about the way that most people speak, it gets right about me. As the internet continues to remind me on what feels like a daily basis, I say the word yours in a odd manner, and purple, and work, and June. These are all artifacts of where I grew up, which is the northeast of England. And despite me being mostly legible to people around the world, there are these odd little ghosts of where I'm from, but they're so idiosyncratic and so unique to me. There are not many people from Middlesbrough or Stockton on Tees talking on the internet.

2:27 >> I know that it's a very popular TV program. I think that fans of the show would like to find out some of the stuff that goes on during the process. >> Why pick that voice? Why have that particular style of British voice if it wasn't built on someone from that area? At first, I was able to shrug it off because, to be fair, the video was pretty good. I watched it until the end, but then it started to eat at me.

2:51 Something about it gave me the ick. If somebody had cloned my voice using AI, how long until I started hearing it advertise products I don't endorse or ideas that I fundamentally disagree with, >> >> and it didn't take long. >> You've got to try this. What if I told you I found the perfect tool for staying focused? >> Obviously, this was a big problem. That's when I discovered something that really disturbed me. >> The most popular voice, the default British voice, people say that it's really close to Chris Williamson.

3:25 >> My voice was one of the most popular British male voices on the number one AI voice platform, Eleven Labs. For just a few dollars, anyone, anywhere in the world, could make me say anything, sell anything, and support anything. Now, I want to make it clear, this isn't one of those Metallica situations where everything would be fine as long as I get my cut. I'm genuinely worried by this. Yes, there is the fact that my voice is essentially my business and as surprising as it may be, I have put a lot of time and effort into speaking the way that I do, including years of years of vocal coaching. So, yes, a part of me is a little bitter about having that democratized and freely available to the internet for the price of a cheeseburger. When someone uses AI to steal a song riff or a style from a musical artist, we know that it's wrong.

4:18 That person spent years learning their instrument. They had to practice every day and develop their creative skills. And now, anyone with access to the internet can just take the results of all their hard work and do whatever they want with it. But when it comes to just taking the accent of somebody's voice and making it say whatever you want, we haven't yet arrived at the same level of disgust or concern about doing that. Even though it's much more dangerous because that person can be made to say anything which sounds like not a performance, but an endorsement. And the bigger issue here is how violating it feels. Your voice is one of the most personal things you have. It's the vocal chords equivalent of a fingerprint. It's one of the only things that no one has ever been able to take away from you. It's how you express who you are. It's how you express what you think and what you believe in. It's how you establish trust. I got into podcasting in the first place because I had things I wanted to say and I wanted to talk with other people with big ideas. Do I agree with everyone who I have on the podcast?

5:21 Of course not. But they probably believe in what they're saying and maybe there's something I can learn by understanding their perspective. But what I say is always up to me. And I've worked hard to build trust with you guys. An AI clone of me breaks that trust, whether people know it's AI or not. It's subconscious. It just cheapens perception because AI is by nature inauthentic. And look, I love AI. It's incredibly useful. It has the potential to do many great things.

5:54 But at its basic level, AI is something that's not human masquerading as human and apparently doing a pretty good job at it. And when your brain's detector spots the inauthenticity and it will because our brains are good at doing that. It sets off alarms that say, don't trust this. And if you see or hear the same person's AI clone enough times, you'll start distrusting the actual person even when they haven't done anything wrong. Again, it it's so easy for us to wrap our heads around when we talk about music. Remember when someone released that AI Drake song? It got millions of plays almost overnight.

6:36 But the next day it was taken down because everyone understood that's not theirs to release. So, why is it different when it's someone's speaking voice? If Drake's voice had been used to make a statement, would that have caused the same type of furor? So, the question is, why is it different when it's someone's speaking voice? Because this is never really happened before and no one knows what to do. So, obviously I did what anyone would do and I reached out to Eleven Labs about the issue. And here's what they had to say. Thanks for getting in touch. I've spoken with our legal team. We take this very seriously.

7:09 Our voices team has in the past liaised with the voice actor who contributed the voice for Archer. We're investigating to ensure that there hasn't been any fraudulent behavior on that voice actor's part, but as of now, we have no reason to believe that there has been. Hold up. There's a guy, a guy who sounds exactly like me. We also ran a technical similarity test scientifically referred to as an ENCAPA-TDNN test between the Archer voice and Chris's voice. A score above 0.7 indicates with high confidence that the two voices are a match. This received a score of 0.28, indicating that the Archer voice is very distinct from Chris's voice. That same guy also reached out a few days later to let me know that a discount code for Neutonic wasn't working.

7:55 I'm glad that he's a fan. He might not have been able to help me protect my personal sovereignty, but at least I could save him some money on the world's most delicious productivity beverage. But, back to the issue here. I had to sit with this email for quite a while because I really had no idea what to make of it. Either their test was wrong, they completely lied about it, and my voice was cloned, or their test is right, and my ears are wrong, and my friends' ears are wrong, and everybody else's ears on the internet, and the thing that I was certain was me wasn't. And they'd also managed to find a voice actor from the specific postcode in the northeast of England to train their AI service on. The most uncomfortable part was I genuinely had no idea which one was true. I felt like I was being gaslighted out of recognizing my own voice. Look, I make a living with my voice. I have a platform and an audience and a legal team that I could call and a company willing to answer my emails, and I still can't prove that my own voice is mine.

9:02 So, what chance do other people have? Your voice can be taken, matched, or manufactured, and there is currently no referee on Earth who can settle it. That's a major problem for every single person who currently uses the internet, and it arrived without anyone voting on it. So, I had to really think about it. What were my options? >> That's when you sue, my friend. >> Dude, we emailed them. We emailed 11 Labs >> That's not sueing.

9:29 >> a year ago. Turns out, I'm obviously not the only one who this has happened to. There are multiple pending lawsuits against AI platforms from people claiming that their voice has been stolen. As of the time that I'm recording this, none of these cases have gone to trial yet. But, there have been some similar cases in 1988 that Midler sued Ford Motor Company and their ad agency when they hired her backup singer to do a well-known song of hers for a commercial. And the court ruled that it was, in fact, unlawful to imitate a person's voice in order to sell a product. The same thing happened when Tom Waits sued Frito-Lay from impersonating him in a commercial. And he got $2.4 million. But, that was America over 30 years ago.

10:12 >> An online network called internet. >> A lot has changed since then. The internet and social media have made privacy completely confusing even before AI came into the picture. That's why I decided to call a copyright lawyer to see what he had to say about it. Do I actually have a legal right to control the use of my own voice? Or does the law already protect me once someone uses it to impersonate me? >> You do have certain rights in your voice. There's a difference between someone whose voice is similar to yours versus appropriation. If someone hired someone or created a derivative work using your voice, you definitely have some type of protection that now there's no federal law yet, but every state pretty much has what's called a right of publicity law.

11:05 You could go into the state law and say, "Hey, this person misappropriated my voice. They used it for commercial gain." And that's what's called a right of publicity. And it it it's just how far is that right of publicity willing to go. My voice has no protection because no one recognizes my voice. >> Is there a legal way to determine how close to someone else's likeness an AI or a voice actor training an AI is allowed to be?

11:29 >> Yeah. So, courts will definitely look at a lot of factors. Ultimately, one of the biggest factors is what a reasonable person would believe. Would a reasonable person hearing this voice say, "Oh, Chris endorsed this." Or, "Oh, Chris is promoting this platform." If you're getting a lot of messages saying, "Hey, this sounds exactly like you." That's pretty strong evidence, you know, that a judge would consider and saying, "Hey, you know, this is similar enough that people believe that Chris is somehow associated with this.

12:02 >> What should I realistically do next? Have I got a case here? >> >> That's a question for a litigator. I think you could do some digging on your end, which it seems like you've already done, right? You asked for that similarity test. You've done, you know, certain taken certain steps. Going farther, I think documenting all this stuff. I think, you know, keeping a good kind of folder of of all the evidence that you could potentially have of people saying, "Hey, this is similar." Showing that they used it for commercial gain, that they're selling it, how they're marketing it. All these different things I think will work in your favor, but ultimately there's no way to compel them to provide you any information outside of official discovery.

12:46 >> Yeah. So, where does this leave us? Since this happened, the Archer voice has been taken down off 11 Labs, which is good. That's a start. Was it because I reached out and complained? Was it because Archer was actually cloned from my voice? Was it because I brought it up on a podcast episode that did a couple of million plays? They must have trained this voice >> On you. >> Like, pull up that essay. It's been over 12 years since the disappearance of flight MH370.

13:14 >> Play this. >> Three years massive searches. >> Yeah, this is you. >> It's me. >> Is this not supposed to be you? >> No, it's not me. This is Archer from 11 Labs. >> Do they own your own voice? >> I don't know what criteria they're using. >> Yes, you do. Your name, face, and likeness, and that's your likeness. own your voice. I still don't know and I have to make peace with the fact that I might never know because there's no one whose job it is to tell me. Not Eleven Labs whose test conveniently cleared them, not the courts who are still working off a Bette Midler case from before I was born, not the mysterious voice twin who I'm never going to meet.

13:48 This is the most deranging part of the entire story. It's not just about my voice. It's about the helplessness. Every other thing you own has a referee. If someone takes your car, there's a police report. If someone uses your song, there's a copyright claim. If someone forges your signature, there's a bank that eats the loss. But for your voice, there's a customer support email and a number I can't verify and a test I can't understand. That's the whole system at the moment.

14:17 And it's the same system that's supposed to protect you when it's your face on a video you never made or your mom's voice on a phone call asking for money. So, as these cases go to court, new laws roll out, I hope you pay attention because you really should care about this.

Summary

The speaker expresses deep concern over the unauthorized use of their voice by AI technology, specifically highlighting their experience with Eleven Labs, a company that allows users to create AI-generated voices. They grapple with the implications of voice cloning, including potential misuse for endorsements or advertisements without consent, and the lack of legal protections for individuals against such violations.

- The speaker discovered an AI-generated voice that closely mimicked theirs, causing distress and raising questions about identity and ownership.
- Eleven Labs allows users to create voices that can sound like real individuals, leading to potential misuse for commercial purposes.
- The speaker emphasizes the personal nature of one's voice, comparing it to a fingerprint and highlighting its role in establishing trust.
- They express frustration over the lack of legal frameworks protecting individuals from voice cloning, contrasting it with protections for other forms of intellectual property.
- The speaker consulted a copyright lawyer, who confirmed that while there are rights regarding voice appropriation, legal protections are still evolving.
- They document their experience and gather evidence to potentially support a legal case, reflecting on the helplessness felt in the current system.
- The speaker notes that the AI-generated voice in question was eventually removed from Eleven Labs, but uncertainty remains about the ownership and rights over their voice.
- The discussion raises broader concerns about privacy and identity in the age of AI, urging listeners to pay attention to these emerging issues.

Questions Answered

What are the implications of AI voice cloning?

The speaker expresses concern over AI technology that can replicate voices, highlighting personal experiences where their voice was cloned without consent. This raises questions about identity, ownership, and the potential misuse of AI-generated voices.

How prevalent is the cloning of voices in AI?

The speaker discovers that their voice is among the most popular on AI platforms, allowing anyone to use it for various purposes without consent. This raises ethical concerns about voice ownership and the commercialization of personal identities.

Why is there a difference in societal reaction to music and voice cloning?

The speaker reflects on the societal norms surrounding the use of AI in music versus voice cloning, noting that while music theft is widely condemned, voice cloning lacks similar outrage. This discrepancy highlights the need for clearer ethical guidelines.

What legal recourse is available for voice cloning?

The speaker discusses the challenges of proving ownership of their voice and the lack of legal precedents in the digital age. They explore past legal cases involving voice imitation and consider consulting a copyright lawyer for guidance.

What steps should be taken if someone believes their voice has been cloned?

The speaker is advised to document evidence of unauthorized use of their voice, including instances where people mistakenly associate them with AI-generated content. This documentation could support potential legal claims.

© transcribe · For agents Built with care and craft by Gokul Rajaram