Section Insights
Introduction to The Audible
What is The Audible and how can I engage with it?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the off-season. Listeners are encouraged to subscribe on YouTube and follow on social media to build a community.
- The Audible is a college football podcast.
- It airs three times a week during the season.
- Listeners are encouraged to subscribe and follow on social media.
Media's Role in College Football Drama
How does media entertainment impact college football narratives?
Media shows like College GameDay are primarily entertainment rather than journalism. The focus on ratings can lead to controversial figures being prioritized over traditional journalists, affecting how stories are perceived.
- Media shows prioritize entertainment over journalism.
- Ratings influence the presence of certain personalities in sports media.
- Criticism of media figures is common and part of the job.
ESPN's Influence on Conference Realignment
What is ESPN's actual power regarding conference realignment?
While ESPN has significant influence, it does not have the final say in conference realignment decisions. If a conference leader wants a team like Utah, they will likely be accepted regardless of ESPN's stance.
- ESPN's influence on conference realignment is limited.
- Conference decisions are ultimately made by leadership, not media outlets.
- Pat McAfee's opinions won't prevent Utah's potential advancement.
Clemson's Coaching Situation
What challenges does Clemson face with its coaching staff?
Clemson is in a complicated situation with its coaching staff, particularly with head coach Dabo Swinney. The financial implications of firing him are significant, and there are concerns about the program's direction and spending on player recruitment.
- Clemson faces challenges with its coaching staff and financial commitments.
- Firing Dabo Swinney would be costly and complicated.
- The program needs to be aggressive in recruiting to remain competitive.
The Importance of the AP Poll
Why does the AP poll still matter in college football?
The AP poll serves as a historical document that captures the narrative of college football seasons. It provides context for team performances and helps market games based on rankings.
- The AP poll is a historical record of college football.
- It helps provide context for team performances and rivalries.
- Eliminating the AP poll would not stop rankings; alternative systems would emerge.
Transcript
0:00 Welcome back to The Audible. If you love college football like we do, you need to make us a part of your weekly routine three times a week during the season, twice a week during the off-season. Make sure you are subscribed right here on YouTube and follow us on Instagram and X at Audible Show. We're trying to build the Audible community and we need you to be part of that by subscribing and following. Thanks for tuning in.
0:30 >> >> Welcome back to the latest edition of The Audible presented by Trader Joe's. I am Bruce Feldman joined as always by my colleagues from The Athletic Stewart Mandel and Ralph Russo. Guys, we're going to get into the mailbag. We have some good questions. there's a lot to kind of dig into coming off of a couple of wild weeks in college football. as always, don't forget to like and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And now we are on social media. Give us a follow at Audible Show.
1:09 We're on Instagram and Twitter. all right, guys. you know, a story that kind of blew up over the weekend is is really tied to our first mailbag question. I'm just going to read what Nick sent us. Gents, I'd love to get your perspective on the drama that has ensued from the College GameDay experience at the University of Utah. As a lifetime Utes fan, I am a bit perplexed at what feels like fabricated outrage. As media members yourselves, what kind of perspective can you provide on how {quote} big media {end quote} perspectives might have on universities like my Utes, which may inhibit them on moving upwards on the next rounds of conference realignment. Love the show.
1:54 All All thanks, Nick. All right, Stu, why don't you begin to unpack kind of the surreal story that came out of Utah tied to College GameDay, not just this weekend, but it unfolded over like the next, I don't know, 48-72 hours. >> Our listener there is asking towards the end of that question about kind of broader themes, and I don't know that this particular situation fits into anything else that I've seen. It's very weird. I don't understand why Pat McAfee is so thin-skinned.
2:28 The video that he that set him off about Utah is a couple college kids saying he's corny. And I think another one says, "No, don't take your shirt off." And somehow that ended with him on his show on Monday morning invoking Charlie Kirk, invoking the Charlie Kirk assassination, and how he's fearing for his safety. And and just like shredded Utah. Like, I hope I never go back there. And, you know, I I'm somebody who I know Pat McAfee gets a lot of, you know, elicits a lot of complaints.
3:00 I am somebody who well, let's just put it this way. You know, the the the disconnect here is people have been complaining about him and frankly complaining about the show all season. And then every week I get an email from ESPN PR, "College GameDay's record-setting season continues. 2.5 million viewers from Utah. Second most viewed week eight show in history. up five the season is up 5% from last year." And it's And I think you guys would agree he's the driving reason. Like, he has come in since he's come on to that show, it's given it a boost. Obviously, Corso is not there anymore.
3:37 And so, you're if if you're ESPN, I would think you're in a bind here. Like, he's delivering exactly what you would hope. But given how important the relationships are with the schools cuz you're asking to basically come in and take over their campus for two days. I mean, Ralph, somehow this ended with the University of Utah apologizing to him rather than vice versa. >> Yeah, I was surprised at that. especially knowing some of the people who work at Utah, that that that wouldn't that seemed a bit of an odd move. I I I would think that they would have been a little bit more like, "Hey, what did we do here?"
4:13 I also find myself being wondering if if if something else went on at at Utah, something else that he didn't because if it was just that video, dude, like you got to lighten up. >> Well, he made some sort of reference to getting threats. >> Yeah, so maybe there was something else going on that he didn't reference. You know, I poked a little fun at him by saying he would never hold up being an AP voter, an AP poll voter cuz I get called pretty nasty things for not ranking teams high enough. so, but I also want to give him a little grace and say maybe something else was going on there.
4:52 I am also a a person who believes everybody's a right has a right to their feelings. You have a right to your feelings, right? I am not an "Eh, your feelings" guy because I think the people who are "Bleep your feelings" guys also get very caught up in their own feelings, right? I I would I would wonder if if people sort of directed that level of like, "Hey, you shouldn't say that, Pat, on your show," what his reaction would be.
5:22 If somebody if he was gently poking fun at someone and they came back at him and said, "Hey, don't do that. You I you know, cuz you get a lot of that. You get a lot of can can can dole it out but can't take it. And it does feel like that is a little bit of Pat McAfee. There are other examples of him getting a little sensitive here, which is I don't really get cuz like if you're going to be the edgy guy, I will give Dave Portnoy this. Like Portnoy plays this like you you know you know you got to be able to take it and we're just kidding around here and you know don't cancel me thing. But I also think Portnoy can take it to the certain to a certain degree. I think Portnoy doesn't get my sense of it is he doesn't get that riled up though he's pushed back on Ohio State a little bit. So yeah it was just weird to me Bruce that like Pat got McAfee got so so bent out of shape over something that seemed innocuous and makes me think that maybe there was something he left out of the story.
6:21 >> Yeah. Full disclosure by the way obviously I work at Fox Sports it's a competitor. I've also written about Pat McAfee and you know and know Pat feel like I have a good relationship with him and I'm somebody who watches his not all the time but I do watch his Monday through Friday show from time to time. Game day I don't see as much but it's been interesting as Stu said I mean he pumped so much new life into that show.
6:45 obviously Saban coming on and giving you know incredibly detailed X's and O's breakdowns I think has been a you know has been really good for them. That's stuff that I might be interested in. I think the other thing McAfee did was because of his kicking segment it became the centerpiece one of the centerpieces of the show as opposed to you know back in the day it was Lee Corso's headgear pick. And so it just kind of it's a different show now and I do think it it really does revolve to really revolve around Kirk but obviously Kirk has got you know he's doing NFL he's doing a lot of stuff. It's also he's been doing the show for 30 years. I think that it's a different show. What what was kind of bizarre to me was just kind of watching the this part of the story with Utah and the back and forth and you know it the first time I noticed it was Shawn O'Connell who's a guy I know in the Salt Lake City media who's a former former Utah football player but also a former professional MMA fighter and was like the PFL champ and he's like challenge I think he was like challenging McAfee to like something for charity like getting in the ring and I was just like oh my gosh this thing is like going in such a weird place now.
7:57 and it is a very strong fan base to the point where yesterday I looked at something Pat had or somebody from Pat's you know show had posted about totally unrelated and almost all the comments under it were all tied to you know the the situation with Utah and being thin-skinned and all this other stuff and so it's just it's going in like I don't know. The The kind of the horse is out of the barn on this on this story and I would say you know the ratings are up it's a lot like the dynamic with with First Take.
8:34 Stephen A. Smith is incredibly polarizing and but the ratings on those shows do really well. Pat comes from a pro wrestling background you can see it and how he delivers a lot of stuff. He's got a gift for that and you could see it in the not saying he's Dusty Rhodes but he's definitely got a knack for where you can't tell if it's is he going this direction or that direction. I'm not saying everything's a work cuz I don't think it is in this case but it it's a fascinating like soap opera that's that's entangled this iconic shows too.
9:07 >> Yeah I think people sometimes either forget or don't appreciate that at the end of the day all these shows are entertainment. The First Take is is an is entertainment it's not journalism it's entertainment Game Day is entertainment the the Barstool show is entertainment and you know you'll see sometimes people like ESPN lays off Karl Ravech or you know somebody more on the like traditional side. I can't believe they they do that but they give McAfee all this money, and it's like it's a it's a business. It's I don't want to see Carl Ravich lose his job, but Pat McAfee's probably driving the ratings a lot more than he is.
9:46 I just don't understand how he can be anybody that's on television gets criticized. That's just part of the game, right? I was on at Fox I was on shows that maybe 40,000 people watched, and I would still get emails. One guy was like really really worked up about my shirt and tie combination. Like it's just part of being a person on the air. And he had to know that that >> that that second account worked, and nobody knew who that kid was though.
10:15 >> >> it comes with the territory, and especially in his position where you're giving strong opinions. And yet, I think, you know, you made a reference to this earlier, Rob, like anytime anybody in the media says anything critical, he goes off. Chris Vannini did a does a every year he does a survey of college football on television. You know, people can vote like who's your favorite play-by-play announcer? Who's this? Who's that? And the he did it 2 years ago, probably the first year he was on GameDay, and it was like 75% don't like Pat McAfee, which by the way is not true, but that's how the survey was. And he got worked up about that. He keeps referencing a New York Times article right now that was actually on The Athletic Jerry Brewer column about his role in GameDay. He keeps bringing that up. Like how can you be on air and be so thin-skinned? I don't get it. So, again, like how are they going to go back to Utah? Now, let's say Utah is >> It's human nature though, >> contender next year. Can he go back?
11:17 >> It's it's human nature though. I mean, I'm not on TV anywhere near as much as he is, but I used to have a couple of rules when I was a sideline reporter. I would never check Twitter, cuz if I said something I did not need to have that in my head the next time I got on camera or said anything. I'm being honest. I mean, I'm I think I'm more thin more thin-skinned and don't block out a lot of stuff. It's just way certain people are wired. The fact that he's, you know, making $50 or whatever he is, I don't think that And again, I'm not trying to I'm just not even trying to defend him. I'm just saying like there's a lot of thin-skinned people out there who are very prominent. A lot of them and sometimes those are some of the most thin-skinned. I used to think, and I don't even know if this is true or not, but like I had a theory, you know, when PTI started to blow up, obviously that's the was the show with Michael Wilbon and Tony Kornheiser. I remember thinking, those guys are very comfortable on TV and part of it I think is just cuz like I would think they were people who are comfortable in how they look. And a lot of times people who might be seem like they're like better-looking people are more like uncomfortable with how they look cuz they're constantly they're just they're not over it yet. They're kind of always thinking about that.
12:35 Ralph, I think you know where I'm coming from this. So >> Wait, wait, what? >> >> But but there is something like just certain people are that way. I mean, I work with a I work with some people at Fox who are who are like you would never think they would be thin-skinned about anything, but people just are sometimes. >> A- again though, there is that level of like, "Hey man, don't get caught up in your feelings everybody else, but when you come after me I get very much caught up in my feelings." And now let me let me pivot to this, Stu.
13:09 It is College GameDay too often is it too embedded in college football? It's not covering college football, it is now is college football. It feels like they often make a lot of news. They're very cozy with everybody. Like because they are on these campuses, Saban is now a lobbyist, right? He He's great on the show, but his relationship to the bill and Kirk always and the dog and it it just >> >> Don't get me started on that.
13:40 >> Yeah, I mean it just feels like just do the show. I don't Like I don't And listen, it's the nature of the show. The show is Because the show is embedded in campuses, it's going to be a big part of college football. It is news in and of itself. The show to a certain degree is part of the college football landscape, but I often find myself just thinking of like ESPN's role in college football, Game Day's role in college football, and how dissimilar it is between like NFL shows and pro sports and NBA Inside the NBA with Charles and Kenny. Like it's its own world, but it's also not the story all the time. And it just seems like Game Day is constantly putting itself in position of being the story with its personalities.
14:28 I don't know, man. Like I don't know how you fix it and maybe it's just the a credit to the success of the show that it has become such a part of college football. But Stu, I don't know. I feel like I would love to see more of a of a firewall between the show and the sport to a certain degree. >> Yeah, well you're not seeing that cuz cuz if they're covering like they're covering the business and when ESPN confirms ESPN has done something, you know, like that's PR. That's what that is.
15:00 >> Well, to a certain degree. >> there has been an element to that all along and and I, you know, go back almost 30 years where to this day Tennessee fans are convinced that College Game Day got Charles Woodson the Heisman over Peyton Manning. I know that they they talked too much about him. 2023, Florida State fans this day are convinced that Kirk Herbstreit got Alabama into the playoff over that like there's always been an element of that but I would agree with you that this year this season >> >> has been kind of a relentless oh it looks like they stepped in it thing right especially with Ted Cruz by the way just this morning foyer ball great great if you're into like kind of in the weeds public record stuff found that Kirkherbstreet who back after Ted Cruz was like I don't really get into politics I don't I don't know who that guy is actually spoke at a fundraiser for for in Alabama for Tommy Tuberville's well for a political action committee that donates to candidates mainly Tommy Tuberville >> which is fine but Kirk be aware of that like don't you can't say what you said and then also be doing this on the side that which again it's fine for him to want to do that anyway I just want to make sure we got that >> a lot of us were also bothered last season when it came out that well first of all when all those guys were pushing for Ole Miss to let Nick to let Lane Kiffin coach in the playoff and then it came out that Saban himself had advised Kiffin to take the LSU job you know Saban in particular is obviously a walking conflict of interest he's he's got his favorites he's embedded you know and I don't know that that's that unusual in TV like they're clearly not the conflict of interest rules that there there's actually a great example of that right now in the WNBA finals Renee Montgomery is one of the analysts on USA Network and she's a co-owner of the Atlanta Dream and they're fine with that like they just the rule you know Tom Brady has a huge conflict of interest with the Raiders like they just don't have those kind of rules but yeah I would be curious they're never going to you know ESPN Burke Magnus they would never come out on the record and say like yeah this is a problem for us but behind the scenes Bruce I wonder how they feel about the show making headlines about the sport that they're supposed to be covering the headlines of.
17:20 I'm sure they're thrilled with the ratings that they're that Pat is driving and he's driving them. I think that's that's that's the that's the the main thing to them more than anything else. >> Can I just quickly address cuz the emailer's question at the end was like I I think he is seeing this as Pat McAfee is going to keep Utah out of the Big Ten, right? I think that's where he was going or something along those lines.
17:47 Like if ESPN is angry at us, they will hold it against us. guys, I I know the show has a lot of power and ESPN is a large portion of college football and has a fair amount of power. It is not quite the puppet master that you think it is and I would just point to the 24-team college football playoff which ESPN did not want and is now going to become a thing. Again, ESPN has a lot of power. They don't have that much power. If Tony Petitti wants Utah in the Big Ten, Utah will end up in the Big Ten despite whatever objections from ESPN. So I I don't know if we're that extreme on on So don't be concerned about that. Pat McAfee is not going to keep Utah out of the next round of conference realignment.
18:35 >> The awful announcing aggregation of this this episode is going to be college football insider suggests Utah could go to the Big Ten. >> >> Okay, on the other side of the break, we're going to get to your mailbag questions as well as talk some Florida State Clemson, the car wreck that nobody can look away from. And we're back. before we get to the mailbag, interesting matchup in week nine this weekend, Florida State and Clemson. Stu, lots of drama behind the scenes with both these programs. I think the big question is which team will lose their fan base first? And maybe maybe Florida State has already lost a big chunk of it. I don't know. Where do we stand with this, you think?
19:23 >> I mean, I think Florida State has has definitely lost it to the point where their president, Richard McCullough, felt the need to send a open letter this week to the to all Seminole fan athletic fans and supporters. I'm going to read some of it and try to condense it. To all Seminoles athletic fans and supporters, I hear you. I understand your frustration and I share your expectations for Florida State football and Seminole athletics. I know some of you are questioning whether university leadership understands the seriousness of this moment, whether meaningful action is taking place behind the scenes, and whether there's a clear plan for the future. Those are fair questions. He goes on to say, "Let me be clear, the leadership team and I care deeply and we are methodically working on a plan that positions Florida State for sustained sustained success." Fast forward a few paragraphs down where he says that the work is nearing completion, which means we will be able to begin the search for our new athletic director soon. So, they haven't even started the AD search after firing Michael Alford like a month ago or so, Ralph?
20:27 >> Yeah. >> Does this mean that Is this bad news for Mike Norvell or does it mean like Mike Norvell's going to be back again next year cuz they haven't got their ducks in a row for to get somebody to fire him? >> So, I haven't done as much reporting on the Florida State side of this, but I think that there's enough out there to suggest that there is a scenario where they keep Mike Norvell. That if that Mike Norvell might be able to punch his way out of the off of the hot seat, they could keep the money, move them like give them again excuse to not burn so much money on a coaching search, reinvest it in the roster.
21:06 I think they're three and four right now. >> And they gave Miami all Miami could handle at the >> Yeah, that's the thing. I think they're better than three and four and I think there's a good chance they could at least run the table before the Florida game and who knows maybe beat Florida. So, yeah, like again, like I think there was a path to Florida State keeping Norvell. but what that But I also don't think they're committed to do that. I almost think that they're begging him to do it.
21:34 Please God, like please just win a bunch of games so we don't have to pay you to go away. But But they're they're also having to risk the fans saying like, "Hey, I know he won us some games here, but this still sucks. Like this is not going anywhere long-term and we are not going to be a national championship level program with this guy." So, I think that's where the fans are. They're trying to appease the fans who I I think even if he did come out swinging and won a bunch of games down the stretch are still out on him.
22:03 Tough spot to be in. With Clemson, so much trickier because Dabo is a legend. Dabo is Clemson football and I think that there is sort of this this existential crisis going on at Clemson of how can we get Dabo to maybe make some changes, embrace maybe staff changes, coaching changes, staff changes, personnel, how he uses the portal. I know Dabo uses the portal now.
22:34 He doesn't use the portal aggressively enough, the way they pay player their players, right? Money gets distributed in ways that may not be the most efficient way to be using that $30 million. So, it's a rough situation. We We saw this coming a couple of weeks ago, Bruce, that this was going to be this like, you know, anxiety bowl. Does either team actually want Does either side actually want their team to win? Are the fans actually rooting for their team to lose so it will expedite coaching changes? Though on the Clemson side there is still like a like a like an affinity for Dabo among Clemson fans who are almost sitting there going, "Please Dabo, please make some changes.
23:16 We don't want to we don't want you to be thrown out on your ass." >> Can I ask you something, Ralph? So, like Dabo like obviously Florida State won national titles before and more recently they were they were a they had great teams much more recently than Clemson. You have to go back to you know 1980 or 81 or whatever it was. and Dabo won two national titles and he played for a third. It's different, right? but when you keep saying about make changes he's made a bunch of changes. In came Garrett Riley.
23:47 It's not like this I know. You we can say these have been >> changes, yeah. >> Yeah, Ralph did the thumbs down meaning like he's made bad changes but that's what it is sometimes. You make like look at what happened with Dan Lanning this year. You know, he didn't want to make changes. He had to make changes cuz those guys left for better jobs to be head coaches but in this case it's like you know, whatever two years ago he brought in Garrett Riley to be the offensive coordinator. That didn't work.
24:13 Tom Allen he brought in to be the defensive coordinator like Brent Venables was a was a great defensive coordinator but he left to be the head coach at Oklahoma. And then he went back to the well which had worked you know, whatever it was in 2012 which had Morris was good then. It's not working now. I mean they have less touchdown passes than anybody in the country including the service academies. What Well, my god that's such an amazing stat. What I don't know though, Ralph is yeah, he's going to make changes cuz there may be five and seven on his staff. Does that give anybody the confidence that he's going to that he's going to make home run hires though? He didn't the last couple of years.
24:51 >> That's the thing. It's not just a change is in terms of making the changes on your staff. It's can we talk about like philosophical changes, giving up some power when it comes to the personnel side of things >> becomes a Chad Chad Bowden USC dynamic where the AD goes, "Hey, we're putting a some version of a Jim Naggy or Chad Bowden as the GM. They're going to run a a lot of this. You're going to be the culture guy, but they're going to and they're going to make they're going to have a heavy influence on who's on your staff, too."
25:23 >> Bru- Bruce, the question is will Dabo accept that? That's the question. The question is will he allow that to happen? >> Dabo has way more juice because he's he's actually won at Clemson unlike Lincoln Riley, you know, who got a deal with some, you know, like similar situation though, different ADs, right? That that were, you know, there when he got there, but >> And then the question is Stu it will if he if he does like so there's a couple thing. There is will Dabo be more accepting of changes drastic changes if they lose a bunch, right? maybe that good stokes his competitive spirit and you go Yeah.
26:05 >> I've never understood why we just take it as a fact that these guys don't actually have a boss. Like Graham Neff, the AD, is his boss. If Graham Neff says "Dabo, rough couple years. Here's what we're going to do. We're going to go out and hire a GM who is parallel to you like Florida has, like Oklahoma has. And he's not going to have Clemson time." >> about that? >> can Dabo say no? Like no, don't you can't do that? Like And by the way, Bruce, you mentioned I want what I I know something I want to bring up. You said like, "Oh, he has made changes, right? He's brought in you know, >> Look at Look at some of the guys he's hired.
26:44 >> Yeah, but here's the thing. And Ralph, you've mentioned this offline. Look at their staff directory. It is a every almost everybody is a Dabo Clemson guy. Like all these guys have been there. C.J. Spiller, Ben Boulware, Taj Boyd, Nolan Turner. >> But that's not uncommon. Look at Like if you were to If you went back to Saban's staff, you would find a lot of guys >> Not that much. It's It's It's heavy heavy >> I agree, but I'm just saying it's not uncommon for programs to hire former players to their staff and and they're not coordinators.
27:22 >> receivers coaches. Will Swinney. >> But these were roles that used to be analysts guys. It's the way different now. You have 40 assistants >> other thing going on is the general man We're talking about general manager. Jordan Sorrells is a guy who has been the you know, 12th season within the Clemson football program, third as general manager. I mean >> Now they have somebody over him. I think it's Kevin Kelly. I think they have somebody over him, but Sorrells is They have so much Clemson on this staff.
27:54 >> Yeah, and he's not going to fire those guys. So somebody has to come in and do it for him. >> Yeah, it it's it's just such a tricky situation. I don't really know how it will end. You know, again, they would owe him like $57 million and I've been told by several people that if they want Dabo out of there, they're going to have to pay him every last nickel. And and again, it's that complication of like do you really want to throw out your legendary coach?
28:18 Can he be trusted to spend the money that you want to spend? Clemson wants to hit the gas and be as aggressive as possible when it comes to spending on rosters, but the worry is it's not like they spent nothing on the roster this year, but they needed a quarterback and they didn't go in the portal and get a quarterback. And by the way, I just want to make sure I was super wrong. I saw Tate Reynolds against North Carolina and actually came away thinking, "Ooh, I think they got lucky on this one. This kid looks pretty good." Now maybe he turns out to be pretty good, but he shouldn't be starting in the ACC right now cuz they have no passing game and they have good receivers. It's a really It's a really complicated and fascinating situation at Clemson. I think that they would like for Dabo I don't think they want a coaching I think if you pulled all It's hard to know this. I think if you pulled Clemson fans I think if you pulled Clemson fans and asked them, "Would you rather have a new coach or a new Dabo?" I think a lot of them would say, "I'd rather have I'd rather have Dabo change than have a coaching change." And that's not possible. I think that's not possible. I don't know. That's the That's the $64 million question is will Dabo change?
29:27 >> Can I ask you guys a This is a sort of fun kind of awkward exercise I'm about to try to get you guys to do. We're all in the same kind of range as Dabo's age. Realistically, if somebody said, "Hey, let's get a new Ralph. Let's get a new Stu. >> >> Let's get a new Bruce." That ain't happening. You are what you are. >> Dabo and I are almost the same exact age. Yeah. >> Well, Bruce, we have a mailbag question that we're going to get to right after the break that actually gets into this idea maybe not the guy reinventing himself like his personality, but reinventing their approach to staff management and football.
30:06 All right, we're back and and this is the question I was alluding to before the break from Rob Daniels in Greensboro, North Carolina. Gentlemen, the recent dismissals of Mike Locksley, Dave Doran, and Dave Aranda got me thinking, "When's the last time a coach in a power league was said to be on the hot seat extricated himself from peril and went on to meet the expectations of the job and ultimately leave on his own terms?" >> So, there's a story I have that's actually on the site now that went up this morning. It's about Noah Fifita and this amazing story that is going on in Tucson and his coach Brent Brennan is actually a really good example of this.
30:40 He had one year he followed Jed Fisch. They were finished number 11 in the country. They I think they won five of their They won their last seven games of that season including five over top 25 opponents. That off-season Fisch leaves, goes to Washington, brings a bunch of his players and most of his staff, and Brent Brennan gets the job. Brent Brennan was a former Arizona GA. It does not go well. They go 4 and 8. New AD comes in.
31:06 There is pressure on Brent Brennan. and to his credit, he makes some He makes some staff changes, brings in Seth Day to take over the offense. that ends up going great. Noah Fifita becomes just the heartbeat of the program and maybe of Tucson right now to be honest. And they're in the top 25 right now. They're you know, have a huge game this weekend. I think he's a really good example of a guy who now feels like he has a ton of juice there and a lot of momentum and people like him and you know, he's buying the whole bar shots and everybody is feeling his passion for the place. And all of a sudden it's like an A+ hire. But for that one year with a new AD, it was like and we've seen coaches get fired in under two years, it was dicey cuz remember, it wasn't just going 4 and 8. You know, then you're losing T-Mac who's the best player in the program. He ends up being rookie of the year and you're like, how are they going to be better without him, right? And they were.
32:07 and so credit to Brent Brennan and obviously, you know, to that. There's a couple other examples that I thought of that actually fit into this. One was Ryan Day. Remember that crazy year when they actually won the national title, but he lost to a pretty mediocre Michigan team at the Shoe. You had that wild surreal scene the postgame melee where he looks kind of caught in it and you're just having a hard time thinking, could this be it for him, right? There was so much pressure cuz he couldn't beat Michigan.
32:40 And then he beat everybody else, so it didn't really matter, but that was different. And then the other example is on the other side of that rivalry was Jim Harbaugh. You know, he came in there with a with big expectations and got them better at Michigan at his alma mater, but then he couldn't beat the Buckeyes at all, and he ended up taking a big pay cut. Biff Poggi, who had who he knew a long time ago, came in and basically became his consigliere, and he did a lot of different stuff. He emphasized beating the Buckeyes, and they they instilled a lot of different things. He rolled with it. He listened to his brother John and and took some of his best young coaches, Mike Mike Macdonald for one, and then Jesse Minter, and they won a national title, you know, and that went from being on definitely a hot seat. So, there are some examples of that, guys.
33:32 >> I just want to acknowledge for our Buckeye friends, yes, we know that they also were doing some things behind behind the scenes that weren't completely on the up and up because if we don't mention that, we're going to hear it. So, yes, acknowledge. >> one other quick one, Brian Kelly in 2016 has that awful 4 and 8 season at Notre Dame, and people are definitely ready to be done with him. So, at that point he goes out and remakes his entire staff practically. He goes out and he gets Mike Elko, he gets Clark Lea, he gets Chip Long as his OC, and from that point forward they win double-digit games every year, and he eventually leaves on his own as the as the question asked.
34:11 >> All right, this question from Patrick Bryant, Ralph, this basically has your name all over it. What is the purpose and value of of a ranking like the AP Top 25 in a world with a 24-team playoff? By the end of the season, the AP rankings will likely mirror the committee rankings pretty closely anyway. I'm not really questioning the idea of an AP ranking at all, but more the sense of it being 25 teams at that point.
34:36 Should the AP switch to a top 24? The number has always been somewhat arbitrary as Ralph well knows, and hopefully he'll admit. At times in its history, it's been 10 or 20 teams before switching to 25. I just wonder what it will mean to be the team ranked number 25 by the AP once we have a 24-team playoff. Anyways, I love the show. I even love Ralph. All right, Ralph, defend it. >> Did he actually say that? I don't think he said that.
35:03 So, actually, if you're going to have a 24-team playoff, you should actually rank 30 teams, by the way, because you want to know who and and that's probably something that will come with a 20-team playoff. They're going to have to rethink how they're ranking teams. You need to know who's on the bubble. >> >> as far as the AP poll, and does it need to mimic that? I don't necessarily think so. I wouldn't mind the AP poll becoming a top 30. There are more teams now.
35:29 the reason why it went from 20 to 25 was just because there were more teams playing major college football. just on a broader, what does it mean? What is the purpose of the AP poll? The purpose of the AP poll is it's the only thing in college football that hasn't changed for 100 years. And I think it serves a purpose, even the preseason polls, which I think are becoming harder and harder to kind of quote-unquote get right. I just think the AP poll is is a through line through the history of college football, and it helps sort of tell the tale. It's a historical document to a certain degree that tells the tale of a of a of a college football season. People will tell me, "Well, Oregon was overranked."
36:14 Oregon Oregon season can be played out, and the tale and the drama and the tragedy of Oregon season can be told through the through the AP poll. That that this team that brought back all these players and had these lofty expectations is starting number two. So, I I think the AP poll will always have a place in college football because it is one of the it's it's one of the few documents that, you know, it's one of the few ways that we document a college football season that lasted for 100 years.
36:44 and I wouldn't necessarily mind if it went to 30. >> One quick thing on this, Ralph. I think where it's best used is what happened 2 weeks ago, where we had five of the top seven teams get upset. And you have historical concept context. So, in that regard, spot-on. >> Yeah. >> Yeah, I mean, how many times do we cite somebody a coaches record against ranked opponents or Indiana hasn't beaten a ranked blah blah blah since whatever year, right? Like that that's probably the most handy for us, but yeah, I mean, to Bruce's point, like in some ways it helps TV more than anything. It helps them market the game. Like, why should you watch this game? Because it's number eight versus number 15 or number three versus number 12.
37:30 And the last thing, and I always say this, is whenever you hear somebody say, they should just get rid of the preseason polls. Okay, somebody else would do it. You got rid of the AP poll tomorrow, then it would just become The Athletic's. We would use Chris Vannini's rankings or, you know, like everybody does these rankings, whether they're official or not, so you might as well have the one that is the I guess what you would say the paper of record, right?
37:54 >> The standard. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. >> All right. >> Guys, the last question from Mark Weinhold, and I'm going to aim this one to you, Stu. I was wondering if the issue with Arch Manning is the issue with college football in general. There is a quote brand bias that it seems people always fall back on. He has the Manning name, so of course he's going to be great. Similar to certain brand schools, like Michigan and Penn State, which were ranked to begin the season.
38:24 Why was that? Because they were Michigan and Penn State. Certain schools get the benefit of the doubt and will be ranked because it's easier to pick them than it is to pick non-blue blood schools. Similar to Arch, easier to say he's going to be good than to go with a no-name guy. I wanted to know your thoughts. Stu, I know you have thoughts about this. >> Yeah, I do. And we're working backwards. Now, before we get to Arch, yes, there's absolutely a brand bias in the polls, I would say in the committee room, amongst the three of us. It's just like, you know, if I'm at a grocery store, why am I going to pick Coke over some product I've never heard of, right?
39:02 It's just it's familiarity. And I think more than anything like can I trust this team, right? Texas Tech, you know, I didn't entirely trust coming to the season because they don't have that long track record. Some of these other, you know, kind of brand name programs do. Alabama has gotten the benefit of the doubt year after year after year. Whenever there's Alabama is like on the bubble, whether it was way back in the BCS or now, it's like they always default to Alabama.
39:30 So, if we apply that to Arch, that's possible, but if so, is I mean, has there ever been a player before him that came in with a brand? That his last name was already an established brand. And you know, >> Not yet. It's not the same. Yes, but also not the same. Not that people people threw in the towel on Chris Sims pretty quickly, if I recall. It was no It didn't go on as long as this. And you know, I've been saying it on here like for for I don't know, going back to last season, if he had any other name, I think people wouldn't have kept holding out this hope that he's going to turn into Peyton or Eli at any moment.
40:10 The weirdest thing about it is he's not Peyton or Eli's son. It was association by uncle that that kept this benefit. So, you know, actually at the end of the day I'm going to agree with Mark's premise. >> Can I just say one of the things I tell people about brand bias in the poll? I I love the premise and I think he is he's he's definitely on to something and you alluded to this this like I know what I'm getting. It's I I go toward a brand that I feel is reliable.
40:39 If you gave me 50 years to just to and ask me over every year which will be who will be better at football this season, USC or Oregon State, and I just picked USC every year, I would mostly come out looking okay. So, that's what the brand bias tends to be. It's and that's we talk about Michigan and Penn State. Fact of the matter is if I think that these if I'm looking for a team here and I there's some signs that Michigan and Penn State should be good and maybe there are fewer signs that, I don't know, I'm going to pull one from the air. Cincinnati is going to be good. Again, I've got 100 years of history that tells me that more often than not Michigan and Penn State are going to be pretty good at football. So, we all do this in every walk of life and I think that's where the brand bias comes in in in college football, especially with the rankings.
41:32 >> I also think with that those two specific examples, they hired coaches who had been over-delivering compared to where they were. Kyle Whittingham had been remarkably successful at Utah and Matt Campbell had been the best coach Iowa State had ever seen. So, I think you give them the benefit of the doubt to think, "Okay, they're going to hit the ground running with better resources." Not necessarily they walked into very fragile situations.
42:03 and maybe we overstated that. And again, it's like it's just the situations are very, you know, like I think we said this the other day. Jason Beck did a terrific job as the offensive coordinator last year at Utah. He's not He's doing the opposite of a terrific job right now at Michigan. I mean, it's just it's you know, I think we trusted track record and sometimes the situation dictates otherwise. >> It's really hard to to break through that, too. Like you almost If you're not one of those blue bloods, you have to like prove yourself even more so. And Indiana being a perfect example, like none of us went into last season convinced they were going to be a national champion team based off that one season. And even halfway through the season, maybe more, some of us were like, "I'll believe it when I see it."
42:51 Like they're really good. My eyes tell me they're really good, but is it really possible for Indiana to win a national championship? I feel like that happened a lot with Clemson, too, in the early days, like, "Oh, great season, but they're losing Deshaun Watson, so they're probably going to come back to Earth." yeah, it's hard to We're human beings. We're susceptible to those things. >> All right, guys, some good questions. Who do you think should get the the $24 Trader Joe's gift card? I also think we should include We actually got four questions because at the top of the show we had our question about Utah that I think we can also should factor in, too.
43:27 All right, Stu, who gets your vote? >> Yeah, I'm going to go with that last one from Mark Winehold. that was an interesting topic to explore about brand bias. >> Ralph? >> yeah, and you know what? I'm going to eliminate your vote here, Bruce, and and go with Mark, as well. I would It was a tough choice this week, but I was a little skeptical about what that one, and it won me over. How about that?
43:54 >> Okay, Mark, please send us your mailing address to the audiblepod@gmail.com, and and everybody, please send whatever questions you have to the audiblepod@gmail.com. Join us on Sunday morning for our Audible live show on YouTube. >> See what hotel room I'll be in this weekend. >> Yes, hopefully hopefully Ralph will get a good game and will not be the mush for whoever he shows up this week. Where are you going, Ralph? >> Florida-Georgia this weekend. So, I'll be in Atlanta this this weekend. I have my traveling road show. Every weekend it seems like I'm in a different spot when we do the Audible live show.
44:33 >> >> This is the one weekend of the year, guys, where we get an extra hour of sleep. So, so take advantage. >> That's awesome. Thank you for telling me that, Stu. I did not realize that the clocks that that we were falling back this year. >> Excellent. >> And Saturday night is Halloween. This will be the first year I I don't get to go trick-or-treating with Battlin, but you know, it is what it is. But, if for those of you who will be out there celebrating, have a happy Halloween and we'll see you next time.
45:04 >>
Summary
- Pat McAfee's sensitivity to criticism sparked controversy after a College GameDay visit to Utah, leading to an unexpected apology from the university.
- The hosts debate the role of media in college football, questioning the influence of personalities like McAfee on conference realignment and school reputations.
- Florida State's leadership is under scrutiny as they navigate fan dissatisfaction and coaching stability amid a disappointing season.
- Clemson faces an existential crisis with Dabo Swinney, as fans call for changes to coaching strategies and staff, despite his legendary status.
- Brand bias in college football rankings is discussed, highlighting how historical performance influences perceptions of teams like Michigan and Penn State.
- The hosts reflect on examples of coaches who have turned around their careers under pressure, emphasizing the importance of adaptability in college football.
- The AP Top 25 rankings are defended as a historical document, with suggestions for expanding the rankings to better reflect the playoff landscape.
- The episode concludes with a call for listener questions and a reminder of the upcoming live show.
Questions Answered
What is The Audible and how can I engage with it?
The Audible is a college football podcast that airs three times a week during the season and twice a week in the off-season. Listeners are encouraged to subscribe on YouTube and follow on social media to build a community.
How does media entertainment impact college football narratives?
Media shows like College GameDay are primarily entertainment rather than journalism. The focus on ratings can lead to controversial figures being prioritized over traditional journalists, affecting how stories are perceived.
What is ESPN's actual power regarding conference realignment?
While ESPN has significant influence, it does not have the final say in conference realignment decisions. If a conference leader wants a team like Utah, they will likely be accepted regardless of ESPN's stance.
What challenges does Clemson face with its coaching staff?
Clemson is in a complicated situation with its coaching staff, particularly with head coach Dabo Swinney. The financial implications of firing him are significant, and there are concerns about the program's direction and spending on player recruitment.
Why does the AP poll still matter in college football?
The AP poll serves as a historical document that captures the narrative of college football seasons. It provides context for team performances and helps market games based on rankings.