Section Insights
Caring for Parents with Cancer
How did the speaker's experience with their parents' cancer diagnoses influence their perspective on healthcare?
The speaker felt empowered to take an active role in their parents' treatment decisions, realizing the importance of being informed and asking the right questions during medical consultations.
- Personal experiences with family health crises can drive a deeper understanding of healthcare.
- Feeling empowered in medical discussions can lead to better outcomes.
- The importance of asking informed questions in healthcare settings.
Patient Empowerment in Healthcare
How do clinicians feel about informed patients who come prepared with questions?
While some clinicians may find it challenging, the majority appreciate educated patients who engage in their care, as it leads to more productive discussions.
- Educated patients can enhance the healthcare dialogue.
- Clinicians generally prefer patients who are proactive in their health management.
- There are mixed feelings among clinicians about the impact of internet research on patient interactions.
The Role of AI in Health Management
What potential does AI have in supporting health and wellness?
AI can serve as a comprehensive support system for health management, offering personalized advice and reminders for fitness and nutrition, and assisting in care coordination.
- AI has the potential to act as a personal health advocate.
- Connecting health accounts can enhance the effectiveness of AI tools.
- AI can provide support beyond immediate medical care, aiding in long-term health journeys.
Challenges in Healthcare Systems
Why do healthcare systems still rely on outdated technologies?
Healthcare systems are bound by regulations that prioritize patient privacy, which can hinder the adoption of modern technologies and complicate patient care processes.
- Regulatory compliance is a significant barrier to technological advancement in healthcare.
- Patient privacy concerns can lead to inefficient practices.
- The need for empathy towards healthcare providers navigating complex regulations.
Using AI for Personal Health Management
How can individuals use AI tools to manage their health and their loved ones' health?
Individuals can utilize AI to store and manage health information, ask real-time questions during appointments, and maintain a knowledge base specific to their loved ones' health needs.
- AI can help organize and clarify health information for better understanding.
- Real-time assistance during medical appointments can enhance patient engagement.
- Maintaining privacy while using AI tools is crucial for effective health management.
Transcript
0:00 There was a period around the pandemic where both of my parents each got diagnosed with two cancers each within a week of each other. >> My mom had breast cancer three times, which is pretty crazy. >> I felt like I had an ability to potentially change the outcome based on how we steered the treatment path, and I didn't feel like I had full information. As the doctor's sharing things with me, a lot of time I'm using it to sort of real time, like, what does this mean for Dad? Like, what questions should I be asking right now? I feel way more empowered now to do that job for my family and for myself than I did without Chad.
0:31 >> All right, Ashley, I'm really excited to have you here. I think this interview is really special to me because we both care for our parents through cancer. and I really want to understand There's a lot of hype out there. I really want to understand how close we are, how close AI is to helping patients, caregivers, and also physicians and clinicians. >> Mhm. >> So, when we start this, like, can you talk about your journey caring for your parents and how it led you to OpenAI?
0:54 >> Yeah, absolutely. Thank you so much for the time to to speak about this and for your interest in the space. these are the conversations that I hope many of us will have more and more so that we can accelerate the positive benefit that AI can bring to all of us. >> Yeah. >> it's like you know me. This This is actually Some people don't don't realize this is actually the orange origin story of of how I came to be here doing this work, and it's it dates back to over decades ago when I was a sophomore in undergraduate studies. My dad was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.
1:24 >> Mhm. >> he is in remi- He's in remission actually since then both of my parents have had two different cancers each diagnosed closely with each other. Everyone's in remission and okay now. but I through that experience, I really play this role of caregiver, advocate, companion. I go with them to all of their appointments. I'm taking notes. I'm chiming in with questions on their behalf. a lot of the time especially in that in that very first time when my dad got non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, we were faced with a lot of decisions where, you know, there isn't a clear mandate, this is the treatment path. A lot of time that and and I was for me the first time seeing this in the in the system, the fact that we were kind of overwhelmed with so much information and yet still, you know, obviously in partnership with professionals, but still like they would it was like do you want to do the surgery or this radiation treatment or this, you know, there's there's there's options often and that can be feel really overwhelming when, you know, I'm not the expert. I didn't go to med school. I don't have a a background in pulmonology.
2:30 and not only that, but all the information was so fragmented, you know, for my dad, you know, the lungs and the heart they're connected, but the pulmonology and the cardiology departments, even at some of the best institutions, which, you know, we were lucky enough to send him to, they don't they don't Yeah, they don't they're not structurally set up to to have that kind of a and so I'm the one piecing together that information on behalf of him. it's just a a lot of burden and it's a real and it's a really high anxiety time.
2:56 So anyway, that just all gave me this passion to say, you know, there are a lot of like smart and wonderful individuals in this system. It's the the system is is failing us. The incentives are misaligned. There's a ton of information asymmetry. I don't feel like I'm in the driver's seat of something that's the most important to me, which is my father's life. and we just like deserve better as humanity. That's how I feel. So that was, you know, a long time ago and I took a bit of a windy road. I I studied health care management as one of my concentrations in undergraduate studies.
3:25 I worked at Bain & Company for a bit. I did a bunch of health care cases there. Ultimately, went into product because I'm an engineer at heart and I like building things and I wanted to build the skill set, but I always thought, even in that moment, I'm I'm taking a quick detour, what ended up being a little bit longer than I thought, but a detour from my personal mission to one day find a way to transpose the skill set back onto this problem that I think is probably the most important work I'll do in my life.
3:51 >> Yeah. >> And everything changed you know, I've always always looking for an opportunity to transpose that skill set back and everything changed when AI, you know, really when ChatGPT launched. I felt for the first time, you know, this this difference and shift in the kind of information and empowerment people can have in their own health. >> Mhm. >> and it really changed everything for me. Yeah, I I've I had a 1-year-old and a 3-year-old actually span So like I had the 1-year-old before ChatGPT launched and I had the 3-year-old after.
4:17 And so I had my own experience with the health system of having babies one with the power of chat, one without. And it just totally changed the game for me. So anyway, I felt for the first time my skill set can be something that really impacts this problem at scale and and the world and we as humanity like need this and deserve this and and I want to do everything I can to accelerate the timeline. >> That that's awesome. I think I'll just share my personal story, too. Like we were talking about my mom had breast cancer like three times, which is pretty crazy crazy. the first couple times like I was still younger.
4:48 And this time like now I'm actually unemployed, so I have more time to to take care of her. >> It requires that, doesn't it? I mean, it's a full-time job. >> It's a full-time job. You have to like So what I've been doing is like like you said, basically basically basically pinging the out of this thing. Pinging the out of this thing. And like you know, using ChatGPT, using a project, using a project, organizing all of the information.
5:08 Like the the problem is like a lot of the health care stuff like you know, doctors save lives and all the power to them. But the system is like you got to like get fax numbers and like make phone calls. And like it's it's hard to even get their email address. So like that that's what I've been struggling with just like calling them every every day and kind of being a pest and be like, "Hey, when can we get a diagnosis? When can we get the biopsy?" And so on and so forth.
5:27 >> Absolutely. Yeah, you have to advocate. That that word advocate is is a real is a real thing and I think I I think about all the people who don't have a you or a me there kind of fighting on their behalf. And how much, you know, they probably feel lost and scared in those moments cuz we felt that way. And you know, I come from like a middle-class family. We had insurance, you know, we're in the Bay Area where there's a lot of great access to great care. And even still, I felt scared and not empowered. And so imagine how it feels for the single mom in the middle of America who's trying to make ends meet, maybe she's working multiple jobs.
6:03 And you know, maybe doesn't even have full insurance. I don't know. That I can't even imagine how that must feel for that kind of person to go through a big health crisis. So, I think what you're doing for your mom is incredible, and I hope that we can build products that can give that kind of support. Maybe it can't fully replicate how amazing you are, but for someone whose alternative is nothing, we we deserve as humans more support than that when we're going through a health crisis.
6:27 >> This episode is brought to you by Granola. If you're in back-to-back meetings, you know how much work it is to take notes live and clean them up afterwards. That's why I love Granola, the best AI meeting notes app in the market. Here's how I use it. Granola automatically takes notes during a meeting, but I can add my own notes, too. After the meeting ends, I use a Granola recipe to extract clear takeaways and next steps in the exact format that I want. Then I can just share her notes directly in Slack with my colleagues, or even get Granola to share her notes automatically. Honestly, of all the AI apps that I use, Granola is the one that saves me the most time.
7:02 Try now at granola.ai/peter, and use the code Peter to sign up and get 3 months free. That's granola.ai/peter. Now, back to your episode. >> Yeah, and we just talked about like how amazing ChatGPT wrote real quick. So, >> Yes, tell me. Yes, I'd love to hear your setup. >> yeah, so I I basically gifted them like a ChatGPT subscription. And you know, like a lot of times the people who are sick are older, they don't actually know how to use all this stuff. But we basically created a shared project, and we had like a Google Drive or something, and I started uploading all her medical records there. once once it has that context, it's actually able to provide like really good advice for for better for us, you know? And and actually like a lot of it, like I thought I'd be using it to do research on a disease, but a lot of it is just like, "Okay, who should I call next?" Or like, "You know, who should I try to coordinate with next?" And also a lot of it, honestly, is like personal therapy. Like like cuz like, you know, like I think we're both a little bit of a control freak, so you know? But like, >> >> You're you're right for me, at least.
7:56 >> Yeah, so so like I I I feel like I almost feel like I can talk to my AI more than honestly like my mom, or you know, cuz sometimes I don't want to tell her like all all reasons and stuff. Sure. So, like kind of getting advice from the AI and like kind of like figuring out stuff out is super helpful. >> Oh, that's a a great point and I feel the same way. in large part, you know, the average doctor appointment in the United States is something like 15 minutes. And my experience has been even shorter than that in a lot of these ones. again, not their fault. It's the system set up that makes it that way. And what I found is really helpful about AI is a lot of the time I I need more time to sort of digest what's going on, to ask the follow-up questions, and I just don't get that time with the doctor. And so I What I've found is I'm able to do that in between the appointments so that I'm going in with much more focused questions that, you know, only the doctor can get to cuz they're so personalized to my dad's case.
8:48 >> Yeah. >> versus these kind of gen You know, there was a new therapy that came out recently for his interstitial lung disease and I kind of vaguely knew that the clinical trials were happening and instead of using some of those precious 15 minutes with the doctor to ask, "What's the latest? Can he try it?" whatever, in advance of the the upcoming appointment, I was able to clear all that with chat >> Okay. >> so that I could go in and say, "Okay, this is what I've learned. Do you agree with this take this sort of like take on where the clinical trials are at? Do you think we should try it with my dad?
9:14 Should we not?" And we just got to much more action planning. >> Yeah. >> because I am a control freak, too. And that just helps me feel much more prepared and then when we're making those decisions, I feel much more confident in what we're doing. And I understand what the doctor's telling me as opposed to like being overwhelmed with this deluge of information that I just can't digest all in one 15-minute slot. >> Yeah. Yeah, I've asked my parents to include me in all the doctor conversations.
9:38 >> Mhm. >> They're They're up in Canada, but like they dial me in. And but actually like now that you talk to your doctors and clinicians, I'm sure, like are doctors kind of annoyed by it, like people like us like coming with all these ideas, or can they deal with it? >> So, I I talked to a lot of clinicians cuz we we also build products in addition to building consumer products to support people in their health, like you and I are using to support our parents and ourselves. We also build products for clinicians. So, I talked to them a lot. We also have many physicians that work with us. We have hundreds of clinicians that are red teaming and evaluating every mod every major step of training has health context involved.
10:09 This is something we take very seriously in terms of making sure the models live up to the sort of responsibility and safety standards that we do. Anyway, all that to say, I I talked to a lot of clinicians. >> I definitely think there's both opinion I hear both opinions. I would say though the on balance the majority like tend to like that their patients can come in much more educated. You know, and I don't want to sugarcoat it. Like there's definitely some clinicians who will call out the the edge cases or the sort of like the sort of like it it sort of is reminiscent of the Dr.
10:40 Google, you know, days where you know, some clinicians don't don't like that. but for I would say the vast majority of them have this reaction of wow, this is actually really a helpful tool. My patients are coming in more informed. We're able to make better use of the time. because most most clinicians didn't get into the profession to have to just like fill out a bunch of charts and and paperwork and and make people feel overwhelmed and everything.
11:06 They don't like that either, you know, most of them came in because they really want to help people and they want to heal people and a huge part of the healing process is is understanding what's happening to you and understanding your options and being able to move through it together. Like so much of what a doctor does is so much more than just the actual process of prescribing, but you know, charting and whatever. so yeah, most of them I think from what I hear >> Yeah.
11:31 >> like when their patients come in more educated and and ready to have the conversation. >> I I I guess it's also like just as a caregiver you can also just like talk to the right way, right? Just like kind of like cross-functional alignment, right? You can like you shouldn't come in with like hey, you should go do this. You should be like hey, you know, you're the expert, but I did some research and like >> That's That is what I think I should >> That is such a good point and maybe a good a kind of PSA for all the all the people out there of you know, this is not a replacement for a doctor. It it is not for diagnosis and treatment, but it can really equip you with information and so you're right. So I think the the way to use this tool in a way that that really actually it actually strengthens your relationship with your doctor if you can go in saying exactly that. Like you coming to you as the expert, but I've done some homework so that I'm coming in prepared with actually some pointed questions so that I'm making better use of this limited time that we have together. I think doctors love that.
12:20 >> Yeah. Yeah, only if the doctors use like, you know, bots or whatever because like you're right, like a lot is riding on that 15-minute conversation. >> Yes. >> And if they had like these AI tools to help them process their emails or something, maybe they can actually share their emails with all the patients. >> Yes. I would I would love to help with that. I I think that's a tremendous application. I hear all the time about, you know, there's this this term that they use, "pajama time," where when the advent of the EHR came about, a lot of physicians ended up just having to do all of this paperwork after their clinic hours, and it really ended up adding to that burnout. which is really unfortunate.
12:56 I think we need to do a lot more to support the clinicians. there it's it's one of the hardest lines of work. It's one of the most important lines of work, you know, as you feel when you or a loved one is going through a health episode. >> Yeah. >> And we it I think the system makes it really hard on them, honestly. >> And then you have like printing out and like type typing all the stuff is is like very manual process, right?
13:15 >> Very manual process, and to the point that I don't know if you've experienced this, but I've seen in caring for my parents and also even for my own health, it's a lot of those they call it like in-basket, those emails, you know, in the in the chart. they're having to have like PAs and and nurse practitioners help with some of the the responses because it's just too much for any clinician. So, anyway, I I big plus one to your idea. I think there's definitely something there where this technology can help them. In the same way that it I don't know if it's helping you, but it's helping me with my own inbox, so >> Yeah, like I I don't like to fill in manual forms online anymore. I just I mean, obviously, medical stuff is more important. You got to be careful, but like, you know, I just get AI to do it for for me.
13:54 >> Yeah, I I think we're at a point where there's still that need for sort of the human-in-the-loop piece, but it's still a huge time-savings to have I I still review all of my emails. I don't have AI agentically sending things out without my review still. but it still saves me a ton of time. even if I end up making little tweaks here and there. So, I think that's a good application. >> Awesome. So, another thing that I really grind grinds my gears is like maybe I spent too much time on X, but like some rando would just tweet like, "Oh, AI is about to cure cancer." Or like this kind of stuff, right? Like AI is like very imminently about to cure cancer because of some like, you know, some research or something. And I saw Kate, the former CMO, tweet this saying like to actually get frontier cancer care is like very difficult from the standard standard care. Like have you had Can you talk a little bit more about this? Like how can people actually even get this frontier like state of the art care? Like you have to spend a ton of money. And like really go out of your way, right?
14:48 >> Yeah. I mean and and I appreciate that you and I have the shared experience of actually supporting loved ones through cancer. So, you know it intimately in the way that I do. I think in there's such a journey, right? It's It's not just the treat I know when people say cure cancer, I think a lot of time what they're talking about is the treatment, like having an actual cure in the form of some sort of you know, therapeutic or something that can actually fully reverse the disease. But to me, surviving cancer is so much more than that. That's obviously really important. I I do I do think we should point to this technology towards science and towards that that piece of the problem for sure. And we and we are.
15:27 but there's this whole journey of like from the moment that you get the first diagnosis or actually even upstream of that, at the moment that you think to even do the preventive screen or maybe you experience some symptom that gives you this trigger of like, "Hm, maybe I should get this checked out." Like that's for me that was the scariest part of like going from that sort of uncertainty of an early sign all the way to diagnosis. You're You're hanging in limbo with a lot of uncertainty. And then once you get the diagnosis, that's to me that was an equally difficult part of that that limbo period of now I have a diagnosis, but I don't know what the treatment path is. And now I'm evaluating a bunch of That was like actually the most stressful for me as a control freak because I felt like I had an ability to potentially change the outcome based on how we steered the treatment path. And I didn't feel like I had full information.
16:15 So, anyway, I say that all to say that I think we should talk about like cancer cancer care and sick care and any sort of health care as more than just cures. >> Yeah. >> so much of it is is I mean we talk about the preventative all the way upstream, right? If there were things that you could we could have all done, you know, the first question they ask when you have lymphoma patient is like did you smoke? Did you have birds in the house? You know, there's there's even so there's a really long journey here and I think the promise of what this technology and and I think we're already living it in some ways, but there's so much more to come in the future is really how it can transform that whole journey.
16:49 >> Yeah, makes sense. >> right? And and so yes, I I do think I do think when you see what's happening with the latest models what they're doing in the fields of mathematics, for example, >> Mhm. >> you have to believe if we come together as an ecosystem, which we should to to solve these important problems like what some of the diseases that have eluded >> Yeah. >> cures we can we can have some new scientific breakthroughs, but I think we would be fools to only focus on just that piece. We should focus on the like >> That that's what I mean because like actually the best cure right now is just to get scans regularly and find it stuff early so you can just cut it out, right?
17:21 That that's probably the one of my biggest >> not a doctor, but I do think that generally prevention I think can be an antidote to a lot of things, not just cancer, but all sorts of, you know, the actually some of the the largest determinants of death. There's like cardiovascular issues, metabolic issues, and a lot of those are actually things that don't even cut like it's like getting better sleep, like changing your diet, like moving. There Everyone knows kind of intuitively that those are things that you're supposed to do and yet it's still so hard for all them all of us, myself included, to adhere and that's actually one of the things I think is really cool about AI. What I I hear these stories, I heard from a a woman, for example, who was postpartum like a couple years postpartum and she had just like really struggled to shed what she called baby weight and and her and her opinion she just had whatever 15 lbs that she just really wanted to shed because she just didn't feel like her best self, like her pre-baby self.
18:14 >> Yeah. >> And she tried everything and she wrote into us saying when ChatGPT on a whim decided to just kind of confide in Chat GPT. I was like really feeling down about myself. And that was the moment that it clicked for her, and it was purely because this this tool that she had felt like a no-judgment zone, and she felt like she could be honest. >> Yeah. >> That was the difference. And And there were some day-to-day tracking, you know, she was sending progress photos, she was logging her meals, all those sorts of things. But to her, you know, there was other products that she had tried doing that and didn't work. For her, the difference was having the space where like, you know, there was a day where she would have an off day where she didn't feel like doing the workout, and she didn't feel embarrassed >> Yeah.
18:53 >> to confide in that in chat. And chat's response was, you know, get back on the horse. It's okay. Maybe Maybe it's just a 10-minute walk today if you don't feel up to the, you know, 30-minute hit workout. It's okay. Like think about the long journey. And it's almost like that support. So anyway, I just I think this is a much broader conversation than just like the moment you're in a point of care. >> Yeah, cuz like, you know, Chat GPT has perfect memory, right? Like if my wife complains to me about something, like I'll forget about like >> >> she was, you know, she was complaining something like a couple days ago, but Chat GPT won't. So I was kind of like, you know, yeah, it definitely shows you these tools. And that's a good segue to talking about like how regular people can use Chat GPT health.
19:28 I think the first step is just to like connect all your accounts, right? That's the first first step, right? >> Yes. Yes. So if you think there's there's kind of a a vision here where you could imagine the the sort of best nutritionist, fitness coach, advocate, all-in-one. That That's sort of the promise of what chat could do for you. All the way from sort of prevention to if you get into an episode of care what you and I do for our parents.
19:55 Chat could, you know, this technology could do that for you. Even to booking appointments one day. But in order for it to do a good job, in the same way that you and I need to understand the details of our parents' cases, it needs to have that that context on you. And so step one is just we're trying to make it really easy for you without having to, you know, do the old-fashioned way of like uploading tons and tons of like finding all your labs, downloading them, uploading them. What you're having to do with your mom and the Google Drive.
20:21 It works, but it's very manual. And so, what we've done is made it easy to just single tap and put your login information for your health systems, connect your health records, connect your wearables if you want to, and then have that synchronously going so that if you go to see the doctor you take some steps or whatever, that's just automatically context that chat has so it can personalize answers for you better. >> Nice. And I feel like talking to my normal friends, people not in the Bay Area, like the biggest barrier for them to really get the most out of ChatGPT is just like connecting the stuff. They're like, "Oh, you know, is it going to leak my information?" or like blah blah. And I And I would tell them like, "Hey, this is like a you know, this is like a trillion-dollar company. They're not going to leak your information." But like But like do you have any like reassurances for people watching this that, you know, you think this is seriously like >> Absolutely. Yes, it's it's something that it to me it's the one of the it's probably the most single most important feature that we put all of our energy into building first before we did anything else is is really shoring up that security and privacy approach.
21:21 because I too I mean I put my health data in here. So, I like I'm I'm I'm eating my the dog food that I make, you know, we use that term in the industry, dog fooding. >> Yeah. >> and the reason that I feel comfortable and I think other people should too is that we've we've really built that layer of privacy and thinking about the security of the data into the way we built the product. There's additional encryption layers on the health data if you sync your health records, for example, your health data. we're doing extra layers of kind of purpose-built >> Mhm.
21:51 >> and importantly, we don't train on your health the the health data that you connect. we don't target ads based on that that that So, if you connect medical records, we're not training on or targeting on that. these are kind of design decisions that, you know, are are we're doing because it's it's the right thing to do in terms of preserving that trust and building something that people feel comfortable. >> Yeah, that makes that makes sense.
22:17 so, beyond like the standard like, you know, it's the steps in the you can connect your medical records to ChatGPT. And and what what if I want to like, you know, research clinical trials of like getting into some more more like, you know, people with long long-term illnesses? Like is there is there plans for that or like, you know, Like how how how I I guess how how do you basically use ChatGPT to find that stuff?
22:36 >> Yes. Yes, there's so much potential for where this can go. I would say today where the product is at, the best thing I think would be to make sure that chat understands that that is something that is important to you, which is literally just as simple as telling chat that I have this condition. This is something where I I I want to always know the latest. I would even like set up an automation. I think we'll get to a point where chat will infer and just know these things for you, but today we still have a lot more that we can do in terms of what the models are capable in terms of proactively telling you things than it will just happen it won't all just happen right now even though it, you know, we'll get there. so for now, I think one of the best ways would be to maybe set up some sort of automation.
23:15 Like say to chat, I want you to always be looking for the I don't know, say I say you have POTS or something like that, some sort of chronic illness or Yes, you can say I have this condition. I want you to always alert me when a new study or a new breakthrough or some new finding or some new news comes out about this condition. that that it can do very well today. >> Yeah, there's these websites like clinicaltrials.gov or something like these websites where you can just search for stuff and get chat to do it.
23:41 >> Yes. Yeah, chat Yeah, chat can can do pretty extensive web search at this point. >> Yeah, yeah. I I I I think as caregivers, like just going back to that, I think I I I actually built this open source skill called like F cancer. I don't want to say the word, but F cancer. And all it does is like it just maintains like a one-pager on like my mom's like treatment. And like it has all the phone numbers at the top so I can call them whenever I want.
24:03 >> Wonderful. >> Yeah, and it just keeps it updated and like I guess you can say it keeps >> it updated like in a Google Doc or a site or >> right now it's a Google Doc. I I could use a site, too. But But yeah, like it kind of looks through all the emails and like, you know, like the notes from the phone calls and stuff and just keeps everything up to date. >> Yeah, cuz I I always like there's so much going around. Like it's hard to keep track of it.
24:23 >> your track. You know, some you're reminding me of a story I just heard of someone who who's battling a chronic illness actually, and what she did is she created a site where she has her her data populating there, and she's given instructions for I think she she wanted particularly her latest medications to always be at the top, and then her latest lab results next, and then I think after that was like latest appointment notes or something like that.
24:47 >> Okay. >> And she this is a site that she's given access to just sort of like her closest loved ones, kind of like her care team. >> Nice. Nice. >> And it's a helpful thing because when when you're going from doctor to doctor, this you know, a lot of the time they don't have full visibility into another system's records. Sometimes it takes a lot of faxes and doesn't always happen. >> Faxes. >> And so what she's found is actually it's really helpful when she establishes care with a new provider or even if she's just like ping-ponging between a couple different systems to just show them this because when they're prescribing medications, a lot of the time that's how they catch contraindications.
25:18 >> Got it. Got it. Yeah. Cuz doctors can't hold all that information in their heads for like 20 different patients. They need to help help, too. >> It would be incredible it would be insane to expect that they would, and even if they could, a lot of time again they don't even have visibility into the full longitudinal record cross cross-system record. Yeah, it it there there's so much that we can do, but I do hear I hear this story a lot from people who are really kind of taking the driver's seat and using chat in this way, putting all their information in one place. There's some people who actually just will always run any new treatment or any new, you know, protocol that it go comes from a doctor through chat just to just to double-check. And I've heard stories of people catching actually my former boss, Fiji Simo, has a story that she's told publicly about this where she actually caught a contraindication right before that a treatment was about to be given.
26:06 And her story was like the attending was like, "Oh my gosh, I'm so glad you said that. Absolutely we should do this other treatment." >> Oh, really? Wow. >> And it wasn't because the attending wasn't smart and wasn't paying attention. It was because like they literally didn't have visibility into that part of the record. >> Oh, so she found like a separate treatment that that >> Yes. The treatment that they she was about to be given would have had a really bad contraindication, and she narrowly avoided it because she ran it through chat and chat caught it.
26:28 Somewhere deep in her record it had that history of of >> Yeah, the indicator. And then and I I hear a story like this, I mean that that's like not a coincidence that, you know, my former boss had that sort of Like I hear stories like this all the time where like either someone yeah, narrowly avoided a contraindication or they found a diagnosis that had eluded them for years. I hear that version all the time. there's this mom, her name's Hillary Hillary Eaton. She just got written up in the Boston Globe. So she's kind of publicly telling the story of her daughter where years she spent trying to figure out what was going on. She's obviously saw these symptoms but didn't have an explanation until using the power of chat >> Wow.
27:06 >> to to to figure it out. And now they actually have a treatment path. >> Yeah, I think some of the similar like, you know, my mom like she had chemo before so you can only have a certain number of ra- radiation and chemo. So like I have records of like, you know, what I what I already just got before. >> Yes. >> So like in that 15-minute conversation I have with the doctor, hopefully we'll come to it soon. I can actually tell them that that that that stuff in case >> Yes. Well, that's great. I hope that you are able that AI is helping you keep track of that in your in your sheet.
27:29 Because those are the kinds of things that I think it's really helpful. They'll ask you in the moment like, "When was the last time you blah blah blah or how much radiation blah blah what?" You're like, "I don't know." You can now ask AI real time. It's that's been really helpful for me for more basic things than that even. You know, just like what was your latest blood pressure read like I had a recent PCP appointment and my blood pressure was kind of low. She's like, "Does your blood pressure tend to run low?" I was like, "I don't know. Let's ask chat."
27:53 Here's the last three readings. I just think it's so it's just so helpful to have >> Yeah. >> an encyclopedia on yourself. >> And and let's talk about like ChatGPT for clinicians and physicians. >> Yes. >> so maybe you can like maybe we can build some empathy here cuz like part of me is like, "Why why are these guys still using faxes and like, you know, these like 20-year-old systems inside of hospitals?" But maybe like there's some like regulation or something going on or like, you know?
28:14 >> Yeah, there there's a lot of regulation in healthcare. I have a lot of empathy for for these folks. and it really comes down you know, they're trying to uphold privacy >> That's right. >> commitments that they have to you and me. And so it comes from a place of of deep values and principles that I think any of us would be very loyal to. >> Okay. >> Unfortunately, the reality is that what ends up happening is that it makes the whole system a lot more difficult to to navigate. Like for example, when my dad was first diagnosed with lymphoma, you get you get CTs of the of the lungs. I wanted to get a second opinion. I won't name the names, but they're two institutions. It's really not specific to them. Two top institutions in the Bay Area. And in order for me to get the second opinion from the second institution, I literally had to drive to the first one to physically pick up CDs.
29:00 >> Yeah, yeah. That's exactly That's what I had to do, too. >> You have to do this, too. Yes. Which is crazy. And then physically bring them to the other institution. >> have a device I use a CD anymore. Like how how are you going to >> It's wild. And you know And you know that's not a technical limitation, right? Like that's There's There's clearly a privacy thing. So, I think >> >> I think this I hope that this can be a golden age. And what I'm seeing from every health system that we work with, and we're working with some of the top institutions in the in the nation right now, there is a hunger for They don't like this, either. You know, it's not They want to be able to uphold the privacy commitments without having to deal with antiquated technology. Like they're people, too, of the world. They, as consumers, get access to all of this >> smart, right?
29:34 >> technology. They're super smart. And and they really deserve better. So, I I do think that we're we're on the precipice of a moment where AI is And you're seeing it with some of the ambient scribe adoption, you know, we we power open We partner openly with great providers in the space like a bridge and ambient who power a bunch of the ambient scribing. You're already seeing like this rapid adoption. >> Okay. >> that previously did not happen. The The latest AMA study, I think, showed something like over 70% of clinicians are using AI regularly now, and that was up from I don't know some It was something in the 30s or 30%s or so back in 2023. So, it's it's growing quickly. It's happening. And I think faster than what what everyone tells me. I've only been in health care now for a little over a year, but for people who've been in it for decades, they're telling me that this is unlike a pace that they've seen before because there's just so much to fix, and this this technology actually able to make a difference right now.
30:25 >> And as long as like if I want I'm going to doctor I'm going to doctor this stuff, I I can just start using it. Like it's it's it's it's like trying to get enterprise adoption of AI. You have to go through a lot of different other par parties, right? >> So, there's So, there's a couple different paths, which is exciting. So, we have a a product called Chat GPT for clinicians, which is free for any clinician. They just have to verify that they're clinicians, so they use their NPI and ID, and then they get free access to our latest models. Like, they get Astra for free. That's something that we just feel from a mission perspective is very important. It's a no-brainer for us to to accomplish that for for the physicians. So, they can do that. Now, for for many of them, they might not be authorized to sign a BAA on their behalf of their organization.
31:03 That's a bunch of industry lingo, which basically means that in order to be HIPAA-compliant or to be able in order for us to be able to support their HIPAA-compliance, they have to sign this document with us. It's sort of a legal agreement. so, so those individual a lot of those individuals won't be able to, for example, sync every up all their patient EHR records. It's kind of the implication of that. And so, it's still a very powerful tool. it can they can ask questions in a very anonymized way.
31:29 You know, I have a 73-year-old patient that presents with XYZ symptoms. I'm thinking about blah blah blah as the causes. Like, give me a sense of what your differential would be. And it just helps them as a almost a thought partner. but it gets even more powerful when it is able to integrate with the the electronic medical record information and be in workflow. And so, that's why we're also working with health systems directly to then to then actually integrate, you know, in a HIPAA-compliant way with their systems.
31:59 >> And that is pretty consolidated or is it pretty fragmented? Is there like only like a couple electronic medical record platforms or >> There's a handful. and the the thing that's nice about, you know, the health system's sort of right to their own data is that we can work directly with the health systems and work with them in whatever they're provide whatever electronic record they're working with, we just work with them to say, "What's the way that you would like this to work for you?" And we figure out, you know, there's there's kind of open standards and things that we can use to sort of to to make those things a reality for them together.
32:29 >> Got it. Okay. And and and how about like like cutting-edge cancer research and stuff like that? Like like is opening I I'm I'm I'm assuming you guys are hopping in that period. >> We we have a large, emphasis and focus on science and advancing science with our models. It's some It's some of the most It's very exciting work. both through actually our PBC and our foundation. Our foundation has publicly shared that a a big portion, I'm going to botch the stats, I don't know exactly, but we can look it up after.
32:57 There a big portion of those funds, it's a lot of of money that the foundation is deploying is dedicated to advancing life sciences. >> Okay. Okay. >> so there's So, there's kind of two angles. And and it's it's a huge priority right now to say, "How do we work together with the ecosystem to accelerate discovery?" >> Okay. Yeah, I'm really excited for that. I I think, I think we talked about this before the interview, but like, you know, everyone's building personal agents and stuff to help you manage your emails and like this kind of stuff. And that's great. That saves me time. But like, to actually improve human life, like, you know, cure these freaking diseases, like that's that's that's massive improvement.
33:34 >> It's incredible. I mean, I I think all of it's incredible, to be honest. I mean, we have 300 million people coming to chat every week asking health questions. Like, chat is supporting 300 million people in their health already today, even without the acceleration of the cures for the whatever. which I think is just amazing. It's already happening in front of us. And we're we're also seeing these models that have this next level intelligence that are solving, you know, decades of math.
33:59 >> Math problems, yeah. >> Right? So, it's like, just imagine what's going to happen when we come together as an ecosystem with all the the parties involved to point that towards cures. and and importantly, there's also, you know, a a lot beyond the discovery of the cure, there's also the a bunch of steps after that to actually make sure it gets in the hands of people. You know, everything from clinical trials and deployment, right? and and what we've seen, you know, we we work in partnership with a lot of, players in the space, pharma companies, et cetera. And what we've seen is that there's a tremendous potential for AI to accelerate every step of those processes.
34:34 >> Yeah. >> which is also really exciting. So, it's Again, I just I the thing that's so cool about this technology >> Yeah. >> and and why I'm able to have the impact that I'm able to have even a year in here is because you can apply it to basically every part of the problem >> Yeah. >> and it's able to benefit in some way. So, it's pretty exciting. >> Yeah, there's like a like cuz we both work at Met- Met- right? And like part of me is like part of me feels like working healthcare that there's long shipping cycles and like cuz like a Met- Met- A/B test change some change some algorithms and you can see the result in like the the next the next day.
35:10 But do you feel that now you have to wait longer or do you feel like there's like a lot of progress making? >> Well, it's yes and no. I mean, I think we're having some of the fastest progress that we've ever seen in healthcare specifically. >> Yeah. >> now healthcare has not historically moved as quickly as the consumer tech industry. Social media, exactly. but I think for good reason because the stakes are a lot higher. >> That's right.
35:30 >> and so I think the pace is extraordinarily fast. Now, relative to consumer product, you know, social media, whatever, it it's definitely slower. But I think rightfully so. All the things we're talking about, getting security right, getting the privacy approach right, getting >> Yeah. >> getting the the the UI in such a way that, you know, my mom can figure out how to connect her medical records without having any technical experience. Like these things to me are so important it's we're we're it's a little bit of a different approach that you want to take to this type of work, I think, than maybe historical or just traditional direct-to-consumer product.
36:09 >> Yeah, you don't want to run an A/B test on like treatment stuff that you know, or like my you know, doesn't make any sense. Yeah. Awesome. Well, I I I think for people listening to this who are like caregivers or patients going through some of the stuff like like do do you have any kind of like what was the step-by-step advice that you have for them? >> Ooh, good question. Okay, so >> Yeah. >> as a caregiver >> Yeah.
36:28 >> this is this is actually an area that I think there's a tremendous amount of opportunity for for more for more for the technology to do, but at least as this product stands today, my tip would be or at least what I do, I like your setup, by the way. I think your setup is a great great example. I don't know if you do this for your shared project, but I I've made the project that I used to manage my dad's health a siloed project.
36:54 So, it's like a project only memory setting. So, when you set up the project you have to do it I think when you set up the project, but if you go into sort of the top right drop down of settings, you toggle them because most projects just generally just memory is shared across >> Okay, okay. So, you want to have it by myself. >> What I do why I do that is it it's just kind of a nice hard barrier to make sure if I'm talking about, you know, the latest diagnosis or the latest lab test or whatever, there's no chance then that chat will get confused that that might be mine.
37:22 >> Oh, I see. >> I also talk about my own health with chat a lot. So, I think that's like that's a helpful. I hear this also from a lot of parents that that are trying to get advice on on raising their kids or whatever that this is a helpful sort of power user way to make sure that that information is kind of separate. >> Okay. Yeah. >> Just a stylistic thing. I don't know. I I prefer it just to make sure there's no no chance of the the mingling of of memory.
37:48 >> Yeah, yeah. That makes sense. >> And then I think I think what you're doing is a great idea because yeah, because because of privacy and all that, that's probably the fastest way you could have a nice knowledge store that's specific to a loved one. Obviously with their consent, get their consent. I get my dad's consent and sometimes, you know, if he if he doesn't feel comfortable, I'll kind of redact personalized things if that's what he wants for my account, whatever. Put his put, you know, the latest lab report in or whatever. And I use it all the time.
38:19 The most actually and, you know, to help me understand what's going on. The most useful thing though I've found is even just real time when I'm in appointments. >> Yeah. >> Like as the doctor's sharing things with me, a lot of time I'm using it to sort of real time like, what does this mean for dad? Like what's the what question should I be asking right now? Like >> Oh, like like in person you just type type stuff?
38:37 >> Yeah, well a lot of time there's a lot of telehealth these days. So, but yes, I I would do it in person too, but a lot of time we're dialed in. >> Got >> and I'll be kind of, you know, they'll they'll mention a thing, you know, maybe a latest treatment or they'll they'll mention some >> Some acronyms. >> Some word that I don't know, some acronym, exactly. like you learn so much There's so many terms of art that >> >> you know, you wouldn't know. like what's a left wedge resection, you know, I didn't know what they were talking about lung it's a type of surgery, but you know, it was really helpful for me real time to be asking And so I didn't have to waste the time with the doctor. My dad would be asking questions and I could sort of side >> Okay.
39:15 >> be educating myself and then I could I could make better use of the time. >> Got it. >> I don't know, what tips do you have for You've been doing this a lot. >> I think I think if you actually like a lot of people when they have these problems, they don't like to share that they have cancer. But you actually share or maybe because I like maybe I share too much, a lot of people actually come out to help help you. Like like I'm I'm in touch with like a >> point.
39:36 >> I'm in touch with like a oncologist in New New in New York who's just giving like free advice and like a lot of people just come come out of the woodwork to help help me, which is very nice. >> That's amazing. >> People actually do really care. >> That's a really That's a really good point. Like lean on your community. That actually That is a great direction to take this because >> Yeah. >> I am the I am the biggest supporter of what this technology can do for us and yet still there's nothing that can replace human connection and I think it's important for us to as we have these conversations talk about in in their best case scenario what these tools actually do is they strengthen the human connections that we have because they allow us to show up in such a way that we're able to, you know, help each other, help ourselves, whatever, such that we have more of that more of that time for human connection. I I I totally agree with that. I think having a community >> Yeah.
40:22 >> when you're going through >> Like like a lot of your friends might be going through the same thing. They might be might be talking about it. Like a friend called me like, "Hey, you know, my my dad went through the same thing. Here's how how he did it." >> Mhm. >> And it's like very you know, you don't you don't talk about this in regular life, right? So like it's good to share. >> No, it's so true. And you don't know until you share. I had a similar situation with my dad It's the second cancer that my dad had. One of my best friends' father-in-law just happened to be in in in space >> Oh, really? Okay.
40:48 >> and was able to you know, they live in Pittsburgh, so they're kind of far away, but they he was able the doctor was able to refer me >> Yeah. >> to a specialist close by us that worked at Stanford, who ended up being my dad's doctor for that that other cancer. >> Got it. >> So, you're right. You know, you just never know. And you're right, people really do come out of the woodwork to help.
41:06 >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah. >> All right, let me ask you one last question, which is I've always found it like as I got older I always found it difficult to balance my career with actually spending on my parents cuz, you know, like your parents aren't around forever forever. And you know, I think working out with your eyes is pretty demanding job, right? How do you How do you think about this from your own point of view?
41:28 >> Oh, man. >> Yeah, this is a tough one. >> Yes, this is the age-old question. There's it's it's hard to do it all. >> Yeah. >> I think I really do think So, there there's all the like optimization hacks and trying to get the most out of every minute that you have and blah blah blah, but at the end of the day, we all have only 24 hours per day. >> That's right. Yeah. >> And so, there's only so much you can max out. I think it really comes down to being really clear about what are your priorities, and if something's going to drop, what realistically what what's the stack rank of things? And I think it's going to be different for everyone, but it seems like you share a value system that I have, which is that my family is is very is the most important, and so for me, it's just a non-negotiable. Like if my dad has a doctor's appointment >> Yeah.
42:10 >> even at this job, even in in my former job at Meta, I'm lucky I've worked at employers that are understanding and supportive of these things, but like I also still have to set that boundary. I'll just block the time. I just block the time. I know I know not once have I ever gotten pushback or criticism or questioning. everyone's so supportive, but it there's something that has to flip in you because until my dad got very sick, you know, when I that was just back in university, I still like ran kind of this crazy sort of always-on life even as a student.
42:41 I always felt like there's no more time in the day. There's no There's no There's no more possible thing I could do right now. And then someone gets sick, and you realize, wait, actually when I really prioritize this, like look at what I'm carving out and like look what could drop and >> Yeah. >> You know, it's always great. Obviously, you'd like to do everything, but I think I think sometimes when you prioritize, you realize like how much you really can dedicate time to certain things if you just make the hard calls. and and are you just limiting yourself? Like are you deluding yourself that you're actually that busy? Maybe some of those meetings didn't actually have to happen or you know, and speaking for myself.
43:18 >> Yeah. You know, like a lot of comedians are like that. I don't think Yeah. Yeah, but yeah. >> Yeah. Or or something doesn't need to happen right then. Maybe something can like, you know, not everything. Some things are time sensitive, but sometimes there's like self-imposed, you know, and and some things actually benefit from an extra week of breathing for people to come to it. So, I don't know. I I think I had a similar feeling when I had kids. I have a 1-year-old and 3-year-old right now, where you just start to realize that you you can you can make time for the things that are important if you if you really prioritize them. It's really that simple.
43:55 >> You you have to like kind of like not take your loved ones for granted, right? Cuz you you assume they'll always be around forever. But your kids will grow up and like your parents will go. >> to prioritize. Yeah, you have to prioritize. I know. Do you have any tips on it? >> Well, I I think like I I kind of made the conscious choice to like for for financial reasons kind of like focus on my mom's care and like >> Yes. Yes.
44:13 >> make my little YouTube videos and stuff, but you know, that's that's kind of Yeah. >> Great YouTube videos. No, I totally agree. I mean, you're actually reminding me that there was there was a period during it was around the pandemic where both of my parents each got diagnosed with two cancers each within a week of each other. >> Yeah. >> I had just had a miscarriage and it was just a tremendous >> Wow. >> bur- like a really hard month. I I actually took that I we have this program or in my former employer, we had a program called recharge, which was sort of like every 5 years you get to take a month and I used and I just took the month. I did a similar thing where I said, "Okay, this is I'm going to dedicate this time."
44:46 >> >> There's no shame in taking time off for a year. >> It's probably the best one of the best is I don't regret that a single bit. It was one of the best things I could have done in that moment to just both care for my parents but also you have to care for I guess that's the other piece of advice you have to care for yourself as a caregiver. >> Yeah. >> We don't talk about that enough. It's it's a big even with the with the with the help of AI it's still a really big cognitive load, emotional load.
45:09 >> Yeah. >> just pure time load to be a caregiver and you have to also make sure that you're budgeting time for your own >> Your own mental health. >> health. Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah, I I think AI and talking to your community helps with that. >> Yeah, I think so too and and I think it it can make it can make the you just feel just more empowered in being able to >> Yeah, like not alone.
45:33 >> take on that job. >> Yeah. >> Yes. I feel way more empowered now to do that job for my family and for myself than I did without chat. It's it's so it's amazing. I'm just so excited for where this can go because you're mentioning several times you've mentioned some of the administrative stuff that it seems like things are coming back to you. It's I agree and just with where the technology is going it's just it's really exciting to imagine a world where you know chat just knows that like I just got a PCP appointment I'm supposed to do follow up labs. I chat could the technology is totally capable now of just letting me know hey I saw your your after visit note you've got these labs they're supposed to be through LabCorp. Here's here's an appointment and a time that works for you. You're working from home this day.
46:16 Here's the time slot like do you want me to book it for you and I could literally just push a button and it could make it all happen. I mean that's that's the future we all deserve to live in. >> I'm I'm so glad I actually that you're working on this with a team and I really think this is like could be the biggest positive impact on humanity. So thank you for working on this. >> I really hope so. Thank you. Please send me your feedback and I'm I'm just really excited to keep making it better for for folks like you.
Summary
- Ashley's parents were diagnosed with cancer around the same time, prompting her to take an active role as a caregiver and advocate.
- She discusses the overwhelming nature of navigating healthcare systems and the fragmented information often encountered.
- AI, particularly tools like ChatGPT, can empower caregivers by providing real-time information and support during medical appointments.
- The conversation highlights the importance of community support and sharing experiences with others facing similar health challenges.
- Ashley emphasizes the need for caregivers to prioritize their own mental health while managing the demands of caregiving.
- There is a growing interest among clinicians in using AI to enhance patient care and streamline administrative tasks.
- The potential for AI to assist in preventative health measures and clinical trials is significant, though challenges remain in accessing cutting-edge treatments.
- The conversation underscores the need for better integration of AI in healthcare to improve patient outcomes and reduce the burden on caregivers.
Questions Answered
How did the speaker's experience with their parents' cancer diagnoses influence their perspective on healthcare?
The speaker felt empowered to take an active role in their parents' treatment decisions, realizing the importance of being informed and asking the right questions during medical consultations.
How do clinicians feel about informed patients who come prepared with questions?
While some clinicians may find it challenging, the majority appreciate educated patients who engage in their care, as it leads to more productive discussions.
What potential does AI have in supporting health and wellness?
AI can serve as a comprehensive support system for health management, offering personalized advice and reminders for fitness and nutrition, and assisting in care coordination.
Why do healthcare systems still rely on outdated technologies?
Healthcare systems are bound by regulations that prioritize patient privacy, which can hinder the adoption of modern technologies and complicate patient care processes.
How can individuals use AI tools to manage their health and their loved ones' health?
Individuals can utilize AI to store and manage health information, ask real-time questions during appointments, and maintain a knowledge base specific to their loved ones' health needs.