Section Insights
Introduction to Parenting Concerns
What are common fears parents have about their parenting decisions?
Parents often worry about making the right choices and fear damaging their relationship with their children. The conversation introduces the complexities of parenting data and the importance of feeling confident in parenting decisions.
- Parents frequently question their decisions and worry about long-term impacts.
- Data can inform parenting, but it is often complicated.
- The discussion will cover various aspects of parenting, including misconceptions and the role of AI.
Breastfeeding and Mental Health
How can breastfeeding affect a mother's mental health?
For some women, breastfeeding can trigger intense feelings of depression, which may hinder the attachment to their baby. It's important to recognize that if breastfeeding causes distress, alternative feeding methods may be more beneficial.
- Breastfeeding can be emotionally challenging for some mothers.
- Mental health during breastfeeding should be prioritized for better attachment.
- There is evidence supporting the benefits of maternity leave for both mothers and babies.
Managing Expectations in Parenting
How should parents handle their child's developmental milestones?
Parents should understand that early milestones, such as walking or talking, are not predictive of future success. Accepting that each child develops at their own pace can help parents manage their expectations and reduce anxiety.
- Early developmental milestones are not indicative of future outcomes.
- Parents should practice acceptance and patience regarding their child's growth.
- Focusing on emotional responses to milestones can prepare parents for future challenges.
The Reality of Parenting Challenges
What can parents learn from difficult parenting experiences?
Parents often face unexpected challenges, such as feeding issues, which can lead to feelings of guilt or failure. It's important to recognize that these experiences are part of the journey and do not define their parenting abilities.
- Difficult parenting moments are common and can be distressing.
- Parents should not blame themselves for challenging situations.
- Learning from experiences is crucial for personal growth in parenting.
The Role of AI in Parenting
How can AI and online resources impact parenting decisions?
Parents increasingly turn to AI and online resources for guidance, seeking definitive answers to their parenting questions. However, this reliance can create unrealistic expectations and a belief that there is a single correct approach to parenting.
- Parents often seek external validation and answers from AI and the internet.
- Relying too heavily on technology can lead to unrealistic expectations.
- It's important for parents to balance data-driven insights with personal experiences.
Transcript
0:00 We all want to know we're doing the right thing as a parent, and a lot of us carry this fear. Am I going to damage my kid? Am I going to do something that sets the course of our relationship in a bad direction right from the start? And data comes into this. But data can be complicated. In today's conversation, we're going to do four fun segments. Me and Emily Oster are going to talk about whether something is science, data, or vibes.
0:25 We're going to talk about what's really underneath that panic question we all ask to the internet at 3:00 a.m. We're going to talk about when our areas of expertise actually didn't help us at all in our own parenting journey. And we're going to talk about the questions we bring to Claude, to chat, to AI. What are good questions to ask there? What might not be such helpful questions? We're going to discuss it all. Emily is an economist, a professor at Brown University, the founder of Parent Data, and the author of books like Expecting Better, Cribsheet, The Family Firm, and The Unexpected. She's built her career helping parents understand what the data says, what it does not say, and why parenting by so often sounds more certain than it actually is.
1:04 So, let's jump into it. Let's play this game, and let's help you feel more confident about the decisions you're making every day as a parent. All right, Emily. I want to start out with a game. And so, I want to name things parents get told, or parents tell me some of these things with total confidence, and I think it's because they think they're kind of scientific facts. Okay? And as I say each statement, there's two doors, okay? And actually two paddles. Science, the data settles this, and vibes, which is kind of the data can't actually settle Okay.
1:45 This topic. And obviously >> Door one, door two. >> Door one, door two. and obviously add nuance if there's nuance, okay? But I even made you >> Oh, amazing. >> some paddles. Who doesn't want to be like at an auction house? I want you to feel like you're at an auction house. >> Okay, I'm ready. >> slash Press Your Luck. I don't know, like something like that. Okay, so science survives. Ready? >> Yeah, yes. >> Okay.
2:06 It is best to introduce peanuts early. >> Science. Science. Science. >> That is one of our best established pieces of science data about food in particular that allergy rates are lower if you introduce allergens, of which peanuts are the most serious in some ways, early. >> I feel like for my first kid, now this is over a decade ago, I feel like there was a lot of people who were like, "Don't introduce it." So, did it change or I did it wrong and didn't know that the science was established then?
2:39 >> You didn't do it wrong. There is a very sharp change here in 2015. So, in 2015, there was a trial published in which researchers randomly chose half the kids to get allergen peanut introduction early at 4 to 6 months and half of them to wait, and it's a really striking finding. Like most things in babies, the effects are not that big. This is like there's a 70% reduction in peanut allergies in the early introduction group, and then all of a sudden we just totally changed all of our advice, and that is why probably in your older child's class, like in mine, there are a lot of peanut allergies, and in your youngest child's class, there's probably not any.
3:16 >> That That's exactly right. My first versus my third. >> already seeing that in the data, which is really cool. >> Yeah, amazing. Okay. Next. Holding your baby and going to your baby when they cry is good for them. >> Okay, wait. I have to find my mhm I mean, yes, there is of course science that holding your baby and being responsive to your baby is is good. I was more hesitant there because I think that often gets translated to parents into like you must do that every single time and you cannot you cannot ever wait, and if you don't, you've ruined your child and that's all sort of overstated but certainly being responsive to some extent in those ways yes is based on science.
4:00 >> Okay, so at least the science there kind of contradicts this I don't know myth around like you're going to spoil your baby. >> people here are like you hold you're holding your baby too much or like you know, if that's what was working that's great. You're fine to hold your baby, wear your baby, do whatever with your baby. >> But I think what you're saying which I always love about your your kind of way of sharing information is that doesn't mean when there's something scientific you're holding your baby's good for you.
4:25 That doesn't mean you have to take it to the nth degree. >> Totally. >> Right, because the other thing that's good for a baby is having a parent who has a shred of sense of self, who takes showers, who drinks water, who eats meals like actually with with both hands. It's like such a luxury. >> Totally. >> That's why you need baby wearing. but yes, yeah, I think that in all of these things we can have science and then sometimes the science is sort of taken to an extreme that is not supported by the science.
4:50 >> Okay, next one. Breastfeeding is better for attaching to your baby. Vibes. >> Vibes. >> Vibes. Okay, breastfeeding >> So, we can talk more about breastfeeding. There are some documented benefits of breastfeeding. I think breastfeeding is awesome. However, it is not going to there is no evidence to suggest that breastfed babies are more attached than babies who are fed in other ways. >> Mhm. So, then maybe I'm going to label it this fear then I hear a lot from parents like it it's not coming naturally to me. I don't have enough milk. I don't enjoy it. I'm more stressed than I am connected but I have to keep going because I want to have a secure attachment with my baby and I want to be connected You've heard this too?
5:33 >> I I have heard this too. Yeah, and I think this is one of the most stressful areas for new parents because precisely because it can be very hard and because there are good reasons I think if it's what you want >> Yeah. >> to sort of work through those hard things and to think about like what is the support I can get to make this work. >> Yeah. >> But we frame it like, what is the support I I can get to make this work because I have to make it work, otherwise I'm failing.
5:58 >> Mhm. >> Which is a very different frame than, what's the support I can get to make this work because this is important to me and I want to try and, you know, do what I can. And there are these other great options. And that's kind of the frame I would like I think that people should have as opposed to if it doesn't work I am a failure, which is a terrible frame to come in, not likely to lead to success, and also just not true. So.
6:19 >> You know, I'm just thinking this new thought as we talk, where when we focus on just, let's say, breastfeeding or just bottle-feeding, what what we're not focusing on, right, is what state am I in while I am >> Yes. >> Because let's just be honest, like, when we're really talking about attachment with our kid, yes, maybe your baby is physically attached to our breast, but no one's like, well, the secure attachment is always going to be your baby to your breast. No, it's to you as a person, okay?
6:46 >> >> For three years. >> Okay? So, if I am in a state of depletion, self-hatred, spiraling anxiety, constantly when I'm breastfeeding. And maybe I also say, I don't even want to be doing this, but I am because I think I should. That version of me is the version of me my baby is attaching to. >> So, there's a there's a condition called that I always think about in the context of this called DMER. Dimorphic milk ejection reflex.
7:15 Which is a condition that actually I think more people have than we have really documented, but but when this for women with this condition, when you first begin to breastfeed, like when there's let down for, you know, every breastfeeding session, it is accompanied by a wave of like terrible depression. And sort of people describe basically like, as soon as I start to breastfeed, I feel just like it's like a terrible hormonal melt melt down, which sort of like fades but it's every single time you're doing this.
7:46 And I think about that here because if that's the if that's the experience of breastfeeding for you that every single time you start doing it, you feel like a wave of intense depression, this is probably not enhancing your attachment to your baby. >> Right. >> And it may be that for you there is a different better option. And by telling people but if you don't keep doing this >> Yeah. >> you're ruining everything. I think that's that's it's not just not supportive of the holistic approach to being a parent.
8:14 >> Staying home with your baby is better than going back to work. >> Vibes. Vibes. So much vibes. >> Okay. You have a lot I can tell you have a lot to say with this. >> have a lot to say. So first of all actually I will say Well, let me let me put a tiny amount of science and then mostly vibes. >> Okay. >> This like little teeny okay. So first I want to be clear we actually have a lot of evidence in favor of the value of maternity leave.
8:39 So it's just we're saying because we live in America and in America there is no federally mandated paid leave and that is shameful and disgusting and there is a good evidence that having say up to three or four months of leave improves health outcomes for babies, improves health outcomes for moms. So there's a a sort of like is it good that the you know average that people are going back to work like two 10 days to two weeks after having a baby absolutely not that's not good for them, that's not good for their babies, that's not good for society. We shouldn't do that.
9:12 There's a separate conversation which I think is the one you were alluding to which is you know okay my baby is you know four or six months. Would it be better to stay home with them or would it be better to go back to work? And the answer there is like the data is very clear that these are both great options. >> Mhm. >> the choice of parents staying home, parents going to work, having a nanny, using daycare that fundamentally we do not have strong data to support any of these things being better.
9:40 >> Mhm. >> They It is almost certainly the case that one of these things is better for you for your family. That you And that should involve what works for your family financially, what works for you in terms of what you want to do. I would love for people to not frame this as, you know, should I be a stay-at-home mom or should I be a working mom, which is how it gets framed. I would like us to say, "What's the optimal configuration of adult working hours in the household?" Which is longer, but acknowledges that it may be that there's part-time work that's appropriate. It may be that both parents want to step back a little bit. It may be that dad wants to stay home for longer. It may be that you want to split your leave.
10:22 Whatever it is, there's going to be some configuration of this that works. But rather than framing that discussion as, "What is going to you make us the best baby or like achieve optimal make whatever it whatever it is >> optimal babyness >> it's better to ask, you know, what's going to make our family work the best. >> Mhm. >> Yeah. >> Okay, very quickly, you're wrong. Ready? >> Yes. >> Morning sickness means you're having a girl.
10:47 Vibes. Heartburn means your baby has a lot of hair. Vibes. Keeping your baby up later will mean they will sleep later the next morning. >> >> Sorry, but no, opposite. What's the What's the science of the opposite? >> Science that it's wrong. >> Science that it's wrong. >> Early to sleep, later to wake. >> Early to sleep, later to wake. >> Sleeping gets sleep. >> Sleeping gets sleep for a small child, yes. >> Okay. talking to your baby helps with brain development.
11:12 Science. Your baby can pick up on your high anxiety. >> Mhm. I don't think we really know about that, Erin. >> Much. We're going to look into it. >> Yeah. >> All right. Next one a little different. I've been thinking a lot about what parents actually Google or put into chat at whatever 11:00 p.m., 3:30 a.m. and what I want to do is take some of these common things that people put out to the internet and kind of look at the layers underneath because I think under a panicked question is actually often two things tangled together, which is there might be a question that involves real data. It's like helpful to know. And there also might be It's like a real fear.
11:52 >> Yeah. >> And so I was thinking we could kind of unpack that together. >> Awesome. >> Okay. First one. My baby isn't hitting the milestone chart on time and I'm terrified something's wrong. >> This is very hard. It's very scary. and you know, I think the first So when when people come to me with I'll tell you how I would approach this question people come. So I think the first thing is to just ground people in well, like what do you mean by they're not hitting the milestone chart cuz sometimes what people mean is like, you know, my friend's kid is already walking and my kid's not walking. Well, that's not the same as a milestone chart. That's just like >> the comparison trap. I'm sure.
12:32 >> Okay. >> And so I think the first thing is to just ground that question in really like what do the milestones say? So the CDC or the AAP have these sort of milestone charts and their ranges are enormously wide. So for something like walking, the sort of like typical age for walking for normally typically developing kids is between 7 months and 18 months. And that's a really big range and it means if your kid is 15 months as mine was and you're in the Now they're not walking and you go to your pediatrician, your well visit at 15 months, you say my kid's not walking, they'll be like, great.
13:06 Let's see what's happening in 3 months. Right? And so these milestones are much wider than a lot of people say. So I think the first thing to ground is just like, do you really mean they're not hitting the milestones in the way the pediatrician would see it or do you just feel anxious because your kid is behind some other kid that you saw at the playground, which is like a different thing to handle? >> Yeah. >> So that's the part I want to kind of latch on to as well and you know, one of the things I found, and this was very true for me, okay? And I feel like you and I are similar in a lot of ways. I am someone who like gets a lot of comfort doing things early and first. I do.
13:39 >> Sure. >> I've done things early. I Oh, wow, you're in your PhD program. You're the youngest person there, and you know, and I think the comfort I get from that is is it gives a kind of, maybe false, but it feels like almost validation. Like you've done it. You don't have to wait to confirm you've done it, right? It's like everyone would rather their plane, you know, have a delay but then take off than still be waiting. Cuz when you're waiting for something, like, is it really going to happen? And as soon as you're like, okay, planes take off, you're like, great, right? You have confirmation.
14:06 It's certainty versus uncertainty. And and I think for a lot of us who have had some amount of certainty around achievement in our lives, to be waiting for the later end of even normal range for our kids, when our best friend in our neighborhood is on the early range, is like a a very particular kind of internal spiral. >> >> Right? And and it feels like it's about is my kid okay? But when they're really still so clearly in the range, I'm not saying you're making it up. There there's actually something else very real going on. It's just probably separate from the milestone. It's like, what is it like for me to wait? What is it like for me to have a kid who's not first at everything? What is it like for me to tolerate uncertainty, right? And I think those questions benefit us so much in some ways the earlier we look at that in parenting, because those things will play out.
14:57 >> We hear that all the time. >> Yeah, we have teens, right? And there's going to be a friend of our kids who gets into a college and they don't get in, or they make the team, or right? They have a boyfriend before, whatever it is. >> Yeah, it's interesting because I think it's there's a piece of this which is just like with these early milestones, it is kind of irrelevant. So, in terms of, you know, is it meaningful that your child didn't, you know, didn't walk until 16 months instead of walking at 9 months.
15:24 No. Does that predict something about, you know, the chance he'll go to the Olympics for a sport? They're not going to the Olympics, but also were they to be got like this wouldn't be predictive. No. So, most of these early milestones are just really not predictive. Even things like language and sort of cognitive stuff just really, you know, maybe a little time, but really not meaningfully predictive. And so, one piece there is almost that it's an opportunity to practice this kind of like waiting and acceptance. When some of the stuff that comes later, you know, is more like is going to be more predictive and then is meaningful where a kid gets into college. That's a meaningful thing different from the age that they walk out, but it's the same, I suspect for many people, kind of the same emotional Yeah. like almost like competitive feel and I think it is worse for people who spent the time before having kids, you know, achieving each of these milestones for themselves professionally and feeling like, "Okay, I'm going to, you know, just like win and win and win and win." It's like you don't need to win the walking game, but it's easy to get sucked into it.
16:23 >> Yeah. And and probably the game we want to win and and and just to be clear, I want to like I I I like talk a good game here about what I'm about to say, but I don't play a good game all the time, okay? But I think the game we want to win is how do I show up for my kid when there is something uncertain, when something didn't have the easiest route. That's also something we'll have to deal with forever. Totally. Right? And our kid, probably what's going to affect them more than whether they walked early or were the first to have two words strung together is kind of how we show up when they're in the midst of figuring things out.
16:56 Next Google or chat. Miss Rachel has become a member of my family. Am I the worst parent for showing my baby screens every day? >> No. I think we screens. Okay, I So, my sense is here the two things that are going on are again one like a sort of misunderstanding of some of the data >> Mhm. >> and then a a pervasive sense of fear that has surrounds every discussion of screens on the internet. >> Mhm.
17:25 >> And so when you look at the at the data on this, I think what happens is because people feel so bad about screens they that kind of prevents them from using them right. >> Yeah. >> Because it's sort of like I'm just I don't want to use this. I don't want to use this. I don't even use it. And then I'm using it when I'm just like totally at the end of my rope and that's actually not well planned. I would much prefer that people be deliberate about the times they're going to choose to use screens so they thought about it in advance. They've thought about the limits on it then just like waiting until you're really frustrated and then just kind of doing whatever.
18:00 >> Am I ruining my baby if we sleep train? >> Yeah, no. You're not. This is I think of late this may be the most intense part of the >> >> of the parenting internet. I think it was breastfeeding and now it's sleep training. >> you're right. >> Very broadly I think they're referring to anything that involves some crying. And that could be you're coming in checking, standing in the sitting in the room, just closing the door, like any version of of that where there's some crying, that's kind of what people mean.
18:38 >> Mhm. >> We have a lot of evidence on this kind of sleep training. One branch of this evidence is around whether it works and why it works we mean does it improve infant sleep, does it improve parent sleep? And the answer to those things is is yes. Sometimes you'll hear people say, "Well, it doesn't help babies, you know, babies don't wake up any less." That's it's a little bit of an odd way to explain it. Like everyone wakes up all the time in the night so you're you sleep in cycles and you wake between the cycles. And one of the things that sleep training does effectively is let babies connect these cycles better for themselves and so they sort of are able to fall back asleep on their own. So, in a sense they still have these like wake patterns as you will have as an adult, but the number of times that someone is going into check and the sort of consolidation of sleep is better after sleep training on average than before. That is just that's one thing.
19:34 and there are then subsequent improvements in parent's sleep and happiness and all kinds of other stuff. >> A thing that feels really infeasible is like for 2 years I'm going to get up every 2 hours a night to deal with my kid. Like that's not going to lead to the kind of mental health that people need to have. Like it just feels impossible. I almost feel like we've made it sort of impossible for parents. >> Yep.
19:55 >> We've made it impossible on many dimensions, but this one in particular. >> doing that. We keep doing that. >> you know, the the thing that you just said that really really hits me is again, when you talk about mental health of parents, my relationship with my baby is happening over the course of every hour of the day. The idea that some and I'm just I don't want this to be like social media kind of bait. So, X number of minutes, okay? That X number of minutes of my baby crying, and I'm not talking about hours, okay? This is not like right?
20:27 >> Yeah. >> Is going to determine the nature of my attachment to my baby for every year ahead as opposed to that happening and all the other hours happening. So, if someone says to me, you know, during the day, by the way, Dr. Becky, just so you know, I'm on my phone. I don't really talk to my baby. I don't really connect to my baby. And when my baby cries, I'm like, "Stop crying." And then I let my baby cry at night and my baby's just annoying me all the time and I never really get time with them.
20:53 I'd be like, "Well, what we really have an issue. Let's talk about this, okay?" But when a parent says, "Here's where I show up during the day. Like here's how here's how we connect. Here's how I talk to my baby. Here's how I soothe my baby. Here's this." I'm not here to talk about the exact math equation of what matters more, but the idea that that's not part of the conversation around attachment feels so unfair and seems to do I think the worst thing to parents, which is to tell parents that one single moment Yeah, will determine everything that's to come. All right, I I want to talk about something that is almost different from both of our like typical parenting related content and I was thinking about it when you were coming in today in terms of just in each of our personal lives a moment when our expertise didn't help at all.
21:40 >> Mhm. Okay. >> And I actually have never asked you. For all I know your expertise has always helped you on your own parenting journey. >> Yeah. No? >> Dare to dream, but it's a no. I did it. >> You are a human like I am a human. >> We are all >> Good news for everyone. And And I I I'm going to go first, okay? So one of my kids had a really really challenging feeding stuff and it's actually so perfect based on like what I kind of know about my kid now and how fiercely independent she is and kind of like, "Hey, I always need to titrate like how much I'm taking in from you because I like to feel like my own person and I you know?" And it happened right away with feeding. Like this child really struggled breastfeeding and for bottle feeding let me ask you I had to hold her head away from me. Like she couldn't make eye contact with me almost like, "I don't want to know that you are the one delivering this to me." And that was one of the feeds craziest. Okay. Okay. So it was my first night I don't remember exactly how old she was, but I was going out because one of my best friends from college, Jason, had been like playing in a band like not for his job and but they got some like gig at like a bar downtown and I was like, "Oh, I got to go show up and support Jason and all our college friends are all of that." Okay.
22:54 And so my mom was like, "I'll come over. It's all great." So I wanted to do that last feed before she went down for the night and I felt like I'm guilty like should I go out or but I'm going to do the feed and put her down. It's fine. The bottle she she takes the whole bottle. Okay, and at the time I felt like so stressed before she like went to bed for the night that she had bottle. Like it was like the thing that made me feel like we were going to have a good night. Whatever it is. Okay.
23:18 She finishes the bottle relatively easily. Okay, she was hungry. And then she like kind of turns and she catches my eye like the very end of the bottle. And she vomits entire bottle onto me. Okay. Like And I It was It was That story is terrible. It was one of the worst nights I've ever had as a parent. Like truly. And if I go to like my psychological doctor Becky expertise side separate like who I am, my identity from that moment. I'm a good parent whose baby has spit up a bottle and this moment doesn't define me and you know, and this happened this is my baby babying and you know, and I I I can still go out. All these things that would in theory make me feel like I could take a deep breath and I could say to my mom, look this happened but like I trust you and I'm going to go out and I'll be back. I I I just hysterical. It felt like she was saying to me like you're not a good mom. You don't have what it takes. I don't want what you have to give me. You think you can do this. You can't. And in some ways it felt like she was saying like I know I know you're going out tonight and like who who are you to think you can go to your friend's band, you know.
24:30 and it was just It was horrible. It was horrible and I I my mom like I I still remember my husband were like still go out. Go. Like the you have to prove to yourself the world did not end. Like you know. but the ride downtown I was it was just like really really dark. >> Yeah. But you went? >> I did go. I did. >> Good. >> I did. but no amount of kind of knowing this was normal or talking myself through it.
25:02 it didn't >> Mhm. >> Like it didn't help. It that it just was hard. I felt awful. the feeding moment felt so charged. It just felt like this communication. Like I think it can for so many parents when we're not, you know, kind of I don't know. We had a bump in the feeding journey. It feels like our baby's saying, like, "You're not good at this." You know? >> Okay. Let me tell you mine. Okay. So we talked about working parents and not working parents. And I was always very sure I would go back to work.
25:37 and but when my daughter was like 5 months old was the first time I was teaching. And the teach I was teaching business school students and like the teaching is like sort of unforgiving timing-wise. It was like I was teaching in the morning and the afternoon and in the evening on some complicated thing for these like 3-hour blocks and and that was like you cannot miss that. It was like a very short quarter system. Like you cannot miss a class.
26:02 And the first time I was teaching at night you know, I it was like I think one of the first nights I had been like away. Maybe we'd been away from her like to watch a dinner maybe, but like it was really like among the very first nights I was away and I was going to teach this class from 6:00 to 9:00 p.m. My husband was going to be with our with Penelope. It was all going to be fine.
26:24 And at like 4:45, maybe 5:15, our wonderful nanny was carrying Penelope down the stairs and she slipped. And everything was fine, but she fell down and Penelope bumped her. She bumped Penelope's head. You know, probably would have like protected her. So but like but it was like she was a little baby. She had her head bumped. She had to go to the And so Jesse, I had the car. We only had one car. I have the car.
26:52 Jesse is home with the baby. He has to get our friend I am teaching. I am in the classroom in front of these students trying to explain to them like about marginal cost. You know, it's not the same as average cost. Okay. Just FYI. And so I'm >> Like that's not a segment. >> It's like trying to teach this class and he's like our friend Dave has like driven them to the like It It was just It was a moment where like I had thought so much like I know it's right to go back to work. I know work could be like what kind of shitty parent am I? Like My kid isn't my baby is in the And like I am teaching about marginal cost. Like what Any idiot could teach people about marginal cost. You know, I just It was just I like like almost could cry thinking about it.
27:33 And she was totally fine and by you know, I got home and by the time I got home like she was in bed and asleep and she was totally fine and everything was great, but it was really a moment with no amount of telling yourself like X ante I made the right choice like I know it's good to go to work. You know, like no amount of that was going to get through like I cannot believe I missed.
27:54 >> Yeah. Fortunately I was around the all the other times she had to go to the like the time she almost knocked out her teeth. It will be another trip. Don't worry. I've gone to the many times. What? What what did or would help in that moment? I don't think anything. I mean I don't I think there are some of those moments where it's like there's there's nothing. I mean I don't know like It's not like someone could say like oh, you know, I think the only protective thing is the feeling you know, that like I I thought carefully about this choice and it was X ante the right choice and I think that's very protective in many situations, but there are times when it's just like but then this thing happened and like that's it like this this just like this is really bad and I'm feel really terrible and I don't think there's anything anyone could have said in that moment that would have made it better.
28:42 >> You know, I I I'm going to try to formulate this. I'm just thinking about like making a choice that's right for us. Right, whether it's based on data or preferences. Like it's not rewarded with like comfortable feelings all the time. >> Totally. No, it's not rewarded and it's not rewarded with success. I think more. It's not rewarded like just because you thought about it and you did it get like doesn't mean it's necessarily going to be right.
29:03 >> Yes. >> And you know, it's like choosing anything for our kid, you know, we can think and think and think but sometimes you're going to make a choice and you'll be like, "Wow, that was wrong. Like that was the that was like the wrong choice to have made and now I have to go back." And that's that's part of making good choices is allowing ourselves to change our mind later, but also it's hard. >> Yeah.
29:21 No choice is going to lead to this relief of discomfort. And if that's the barometer for a good decision, right? And I think about your story or about mine. Like I wanted to have my first night out be a perfect feed. >> That one is not available. >> Not available. Not on the menu. >> Yeah. >> Right? And and then I think we tell ourselves the story that it's our fault or that we messed something up or we made the wrong decision.
29:44 >> And so what? >> We do look back with information today. Whether it's life information, experience, or data and we say, "Oh, if I knew then what I knew now." But we don't know then what we know now. >> Okay. >> Yeah. And then we make a different decision, right? But I think in both of our It's interesting both in our stories like there's just discomfort along the journey even yeah. >> I don't think I would have made a different like even thinking about it.
30:09 Like I don't think it was the wrong it wasn't the wrong decision. It was just a really really really terrible night. >> Moment, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like this is one of the things that happens when I am working sometimes. This could happen. >> This could happen. >> Mhm. so powerful. Okay. >> >> You and I both know parents are in chat and clad all the time. >> so much. >> People love clad. >> They love clad.
30:35 >> But I think we're living in this world now even more than years ago when we had our babies where there's this fantasy of this final answer, this external truth, and if I just find it, every single thing is going to be okay or, you know, be risk-free or, you know, and I'm just curious what you're seeing or how you think about parents going to AI all the time. And is that good? Is it bad? Is that Is Is that actually a place that's great? The internet can kind of, you know, an AI can bring data together and can give parents more access >> to that? When is it helpful? When is it not?
31:12 >> Yeah, I mean, I think it's I think it's really hard. Really hard. I think there are There's tremendous value in these tools, and they can give people a way to process data and information that for many questions is actually quite It can be quite useful. I think where I worry more about it is when you are trying to use it to get a like a fast and definitive answer because, as we talked about, in most of the choices you make in parenting, especially the hard ones, there actually isn't just one answer. So, if you went to Cloud and you said, you know, is it good Is it a good idea to work or not?
31:54 It's like, you know, after I have kids, it's like, I don't know what it one answer to that question. So, were you to get a like concrete answer to that question, it would not be a very helpful one for most people. Yeah. I think where these tools can be helpful is with sort of the right the with the right prompts, you can get get pretty far. So, like, can you help me think about this problem? You know, what is like, can you help me look in the literature? I still think there's more complexities there because sometimes it makes stuff up.
32:23 But, you know, that it's gotten They've gotten better on that, and I think it can be helpful for people to talk through this, but you know, it's it's not a It's the one-size-fits-all solution part worries me. But, of course, there are And then there are parenting questions where the answer is just like like this is very helpful. Like what? What is an What is an appropriate set of colors for baby poop? Like my baby's poop is green, is that okay? Yes. And so, you know, my baby's poop is poop is blue, is that okay? No.
32:49 that's not okay. I don't know what happened there. Don't be be worried. But I think there are some you know, there are there's it feels like we're still learning like how to use these tools for what they are useful for and I would frame it like that. It's tools. I mean these are tools. I think it's silly to pretend that people will not be using these tools in all kinds of of other ways. But you know, where it's hard is like they sound like they sound like people, you know, it seems like it seems like you're talking to a person and like it's not a person.
33:19 >> Yeah. >> I think you know, one thing you're saying like what range of colors is it okay for baby poop to be? That is a real fact question. It's a fact question. >> But something else is is becoming increasingly hard probably to separate inside ourselves what is a fact question and what is something I give myself permission to figure out on my own. Totally. >> Yeah. >> Because that second category involves a lot of uncertainty.
33:43 Involves a lot of waiting. Involves the lack of external validation. You made the right decision staying home, going back to work, whatever it is. Where the first involves complete external validation. Claude told me this was correct. That feels so comfortable in our body. >> Right. Totally. >> Yes, we like being told that there's that there's an answer and like yeah, we just want there we want there to be an answer. >> Yeah. >> And and it is some self-control to pull yourself out of that and say, you know, even though I would like this to be an answer, I actually maybe this is a question that needs more that needs more thought.
34:16 >> Yeah. And I think again I often think questions are really good at helping us think through things not necessarily just coming to an answer. I'm not just talking about questions to Claude, like questions inside of ourselves. So questions like what is it like for for to sit with uncertainty? What is it like for me to make a decision, you know, without someone giving me the stamp of this is the right way, right? I think a little bit of reflection on that probably tells me, am I going to be going to Claude for questions that like Claude really Claude can't really answer, you know, certain preferences and styles because only I know my values.
34:49 >> Yes, absolutely. >> Okay, as always, so much fun to talk with you. >> to talk. >> Thank you. >> >> I want to tell you kind of the loudest thing on my mind after this conversation. It's interesting to me that part of the conversation was about science and data and gaining certainty. And then another part of the conversation was about learning how to tolerate uncertainty. And and I guess the final thing I'm thinking about that I want to share with you is I think parenthood involves both.
35:23 I wish I could say it's one and not the other. It is a really powerful thing to learn more, to gain knowledge, to see what science, what data tells us. And it's also really important in our parenting journey to remind ourselves there's not one right answer most of the time. I can also check in with my own values. I can learn over time and I am inevitably going to have a moment when I say, if I only knew then what I knew now. That's actually just a sign you're a parent.
35:55 Now, I want to take that game science or vibes that Emily and I played and I want to just summarize it for you. And so I'm going to do that and link to it in our show notes because I think the way we went through each question is something you might want to see again and you might want to share with someone else in your life. So, check the show notes for that link. Now, let's end the way we always do.
36:15 Place a hand on your heart and place your feet on the ground. And let's remind ourselves >> >> even when I struggle on the outside even when there's no perfect data on the outside, we remain good inside. I'll see you soon. >>
Summary
- Parenting often involves fear of making mistakes that could harm the child or the parent-child relationship.
- The distinction between "science" and "vibes" is crucial in evaluating parenting advice; not all commonly held beliefs are scientifically supported.
- Introducing allergens like peanuts early can significantly reduce allergy rates, showcasing how parenting advice can evolve with new research.
- Responsive parenting, such as holding a crying baby, is beneficial, but it’s important not to take it to extremes that could harm the parent's well-being.
- Breastfeeding does not guarantee a stronger attachment; parents should focus on their emotional state during feeding rather than strictly adhering to societal pressures.
- There is no definitive answer regarding whether staying home with a baby is better than returning to work; both choices can be valid depending on the family's needs.
- Parents often seek quick answers from AI or online sources, but these tools may not provide the nuanced understanding required for complex parenting decisions.
- Embracing uncertainty and allowing for personal reflection can lead to healthier parenting choices rather than relying solely on external validation.
Questions Answered
What are common fears parents have about their parenting decisions?
Parents often worry about making the right choices and fear damaging their relationship with their children. The conversation introduces the complexities of parenting data and the importance of feeling confident in parenting decisions.
How can breastfeeding affect a mother's mental health?
For some women, breastfeeding can trigger intense feelings of depression, which may hinder the attachment to their baby. It's important to recognize that if breastfeeding causes distress, alternative feeding methods may be more beneficial.
How should parents handle their child's developmental milestones?
Parents should understand that early milestones, such as walking or talking, are not predictive of future success. Accepting that each child develops at their own pace can help parents manage their expectations and reduce anxiety.
What can parents learn from difficult parenting experiences?
Parents often face unexpected challenges, such as feeding issues, which can lead to feelings of guilt or failure. It's important to recognize that these experiences are part of the journey and do not define their parenting abilities.
How can AI and online resources impact parenting decisions?
Parents increasingly turn to AI and online resources for guidance, seeking definitive answers to their parenting questions. However, this reliance can create unrealistic expectations and a belief that there is a single correct approach to parenting.