Section Insights
The Human Element in AI Development
Why is it important to remember the human aspect in AI?
The discussion emphasizes the necessity of keeping human beings at the center of AI development, highlighting the risks of disconnecting critical systems from human oversight.
- AI should enhance humanity, not replace it.
- There is a need for a balanced approach to AI, avoiding extremes.
- The conversation around AI often overlooks its impact on human lives.
Legal Privilege and AI Interactions
Should interactions with AI be treated with the same legal privilege as those with human professionals?
Yes, interactions with AI, especially in legal and medical contexts, should be treated as privileged, similar to communications with human professionals.
- AI interactions should maintain confidentiality similar to traditional professional communications.
- Current legal frameworks need to adapt to include AI interactions.
- Public perception and understanding of AI's role in legal matters is still evolving.
AI's Role in Revitalizing Manufacturing
How can AI contribute to the manufacturing industry?
AI and robotics can play a crucial role in revitalizing the manufacturing sector, and there should be a focus on ensuring that AI development supports this industry.
- AI should be leveraged to enhance manufacturing capabilities.
- There is a need for collaboration between tech companies and communities.
- Public skepticism towards AI can be mitigated by demonstrating its benefits to local economies.
Community Involvement in AI Development
How can communities be involved in decisions about AI and data centers?
Communities should have a say in the establishment of AI and data centers, ensuring they receive benefits and have their concerns addressed.
- Local communities should have self-determination regarding AI projects.
- Environmental and economic impacts must be considered in AI development.
- Engagement with communities can lead to more sustainable AI practices.
Addressing Corruption and Building the Future
What approach should be taken towards corruption and future development?
While addressing past corruption is important, the focus should also be on building a better future, potentially aided by AI.
- The legal system needs to be more efficient to support progress.
- AI can help streamline legal processes.
- Balancing justice with future development is crucial for societal advancement.
Transcript
0:00 I personally know three people whose lives have been saved by chatbt. >> It's amazing that this is an industry where we have to remind ourselves that this is for human beings. >> Yes. >> You should never connect AI or any automated system to the nuclear stuff and you should keep the nuclear stuff disconnected from the internet. Not just because of AI, but because of all the human beings. You're like, I'm a middle of the road kind of guy.
0:23 >> Yes. I I get hit by cars going both directions. I like weaving in the middle of the road. Reed Hoffman, welcome to the Newcomer Podcast. Thrilled to have you in person. You are fresh off a Substack post laying out a sort of middle ground on artificial intelligence and obviously there's lots to talk about there. I want to just give you a second to give the highlevel view. I I feel like you resist you're not you're not like you're not claiming one of the you know monikers like I'm a EA, I'm an accelerist, I'm a D. like do you have a brand for this middle of the road take or what what is would at least give us sort of the argument behind it?
0:58 well, maybe a like a smart accelerationist, a pro- steering versus accelerating or dear accelerating. And you know, generally speaking, I think I tend to think of myself as a technohhumanist, which is how do you have technology enhance humanity, which is I think where we mostly orient towards most technology going, and we just need to keep steering in that direction. It's amazing that this is an industry where we have to remind ourselves that this is for human beings.
1:31 >> Feels like that gets lost sometimes and then there has to be sort of a corrective of oh who are we building this for? Not not the machines >> themselves. What is the main thing you're you're calling for here? Because there's sort of like the data center piece of it. There's like access to AI. >> Yep. So the primary thing is kind of two things that need to go together. one which is like why is it important that societies and let's talk about the US the America needs to win at AI because it is the next industrial revolution and industrial revolution is the thing that determines future prosperity just like the previous industrial revolution did so if you go we want to opt out of the industrial revolution that's what crushed a whole number of societies for centuries you know whether whether it's India, you know, China, a bunch of others like no, no, that you actually have to do. So, so succeeding at it really matters. But then simultaneously and at the same time, more than 60% of Americans are having a very difficult time, right?
2:37 And you know they there's questions around like okay the enormous gas price rises the cost of beef you know kind of like how many jobs you need to work and it's the responsibility of the entire American society to try to make that cuz cuz in a sense our ethos as a society is a middle class ethos to make that work better and so and I think AI can that doesn't mean there won't be and this is part of the thing that was the backdrop of addressing in the essay a lot of significant issues around work change and people are legitimately concerned about like well what can you tell me about that what's when it's going to happen how is it going to be and by the way no one actually in fact really knows neither the people who go oh my god it's going to be huge in a year or two or the people are like oh no problem nothing this year actually nobody really knows and most people in the nobody really knows get nervous about that although that's I think the kind of the nobody really knows part of it is means that it's like going down a road. It's like if you're planning a highway trip, do you know there's an accident on the road already?
3:45 Do you know that there's not? Usually, >> you know, you have the capability to navigate it. You set yourself up. This could come, this could come, I'll do that. But you don't just say, "I need to know everything ahead of me or I will not drive anywhere." >> Exactly. So, it's kind of like So, my my thing is get on the road and drive and keep driving. And by the way, sometimes you hit a curve or traffic, you slow down a little bit for that, but it's but it's a forward motion orientation.
4:10 >> Some people think we're at the curve now though. I guess to ask that directly, do you worry like should we be pacing? Should we be halting like or you think in terms of what you've seen, >> keep driving. >> So definitely keep driving. But by the way, this is the other nuance in the pacing and so forth is like for example, there's a pacing of building and there's a pacing of deploying. and I actually I actually think when I look at like Daria's call and you know Sam and I go, well, I think you probably still need to be doing the building because by the way, in order the problems they're worried about is you have a cursive self-improvement and they've built up over the years a whole bunch of different techniques for, you know, I presume most of the people on your podcast know what alignment is, but I'll explain it very quickly, which is how do you have these things align to positive human outcomes so they don't tell you how to build weapons. They, you know, generally speaking, provide you useful things in your life and not things that help you mess up other people's lives or your own. And the the challenge in recursive self-improvement is you're essentially saying, "Okay, improve yourself. How do you keep that alignment as you improve yourself?" And it's like, "Well, we don't really know how to do that."
5:27 That's like like like we have some ideas, but if you said guarantee me you can keep your alignment, they're like we can't guarantee it because we don't know what that pattern is. But the problem is you won't know we won't know what the pattern of recursive self-improvement is until we start doing it. So that's why development and deploy. So like I tend to say no no no keep developing but maybe slow down deploy you know have much higher monitoring on access to the internet and some other things and by the way be simultaneously building AIs for measuring what the states are of these complicated RSI models because we need to be understanding them in order to say oh these patterns of alignment work or by the way if we're discovering no patterns of alignment working well then at that time a real slow down can make a difference >> is recursive self-improvement sorry development or deployment like you want to keep using recursive self-improvement >> in development >> in side labs >> yes but in deployment like okay let's pace that >> I mean that gets to one of the issues that comes up in your essay which is the more we say the answer to this is labs hold back what they have you know maybe you know there are a lot fewer people to get angry about it nobody's seeing it but it's fundamentally denying sort of those capabilities to the American public. Like part of what you're talking about is like make sure they get actual applications that they can use. They can see the benefits of AI. I agree with that. But then there's also just the piece of a world where they're too tightly guarded is a world where corporations and maybe governments have this immense power that everybody else doesn't have access to. How do you balance those things? Well, so first in my Substack essay, one of the things that I think is critical for anyone who who and I think it's the right thing to have to try to help people have a positive understanding of AI. I think government should be actually helping with that. I think obviously companies desperately need to. And so it's like have a medical assistant like make a 247 medical assistant that's only available to the superw wealthy right now, but could be available to everybody. Legal assistant. Most people can't hire a lawyer to say, "I'm I'm signing this rental agreement. What are like is this okay? Is it standard? Is it?" So have a legal assistant on a whole wide variety of things like, "Oh, am I what am I what are my legal responsibilities if I'm driving the car?" A tutor, right? So tutor for your kids, tutor for yourself.
7:54 Obviously, that has some play to what could have all of that stuff should be deployed aggressively. And to really deploy it well government will have to change some liability law like on medical one of the things >> I desperately want this I think we could solve a not to there's so many intertwined problems but we live in this like surveillance state potentially that AI is going to get better at creating like you could have like a AI sort of bill of rights where it's you have legal protections you're allowed to use it you're >> yes there are cameras everywhere but this is where they're limited like there there's a lot of issues that could be bundled into a productive conversation.
8:31 >> Exactly. And by the way, the use of surveillance is frequently a sloganering word you know like the you know like a great title called surveillance capitalism and you're like wow but it's not just bad. It's like well surveillance medicine is awesome. We do it all the time. >> Exactly. And when you know when there is like a serial killer or a manhunt usually people are like how can they not find him right away? But then you know other times they hate sort of the drag net. I mean, I I I don't think we like that we're being sort of lied to about maybe the extent of the >> drag net. And also, by the way, it should be a a highly understood environment that is legally bound to be on your side.
9:12 >> Exactly. >> As a people. >> Right. Right. And this is one of the things like for example most people don't realize that London has an enormous amount of surveillance and the Londoners are actually quite happy with it because it's like oh like when someone falls down with a heart attack the ambulance arrives sooner. That's good. Or when there is a there was a crime the police respond quicker. We like that cuz it's for us not against us. And that's I think one of the really key things here. And so I think continuing to deploy carefully that I I actually and my slowdown in deployment it wasn't any of these apps.
9:45 I actually even think kind of the work productivity and all the rest I think that's part of the industrial revolution you need to be doing it. It's more the question of okay so we're making a much more intelligent AI through RSI. Let's make sure we understand what that intelligence is. Right? So like don't willy-nilly kind of just go great, we've made we made something super smart and now we're just throwing it out. You're make sure we have a good understanding that it's kind of aligned with human interest and then but but for >> there's also this risk you put it out it's so easy to distill the models. Yes.
10:19 >> Then someone's going to rip it off, make it open source which we've seen a bunch of and by the way so like one of the things on the open weight side which is another frequent discussion here. Look, I was on the board of misilla for 11 years. I'm a massively pro open source on all kinds of things. The open weights models when it gets to AI, you really do have to have good answers to like cyber security and hacking. You have to have good answers to like u you know creation of new biological materials because use terrorism. Like that's not a oh yeah it's fine or oh you can discover those documents on Google because the discovering the documents on Google is not the same thing of having a PhD co-c collaborator that will do what you ask it to do and it's like okay we should be a little bit more careful about that again open is generally good but it's an area to be careful about >> there's so many pieces of this that I don't want to drift from earlier things but I'm also interested in that piece of it I mean >> like the lawyer the medical sort of app just to put it directly like do you think people should you know if I talk to chatbt or a legal specific app I should be able to treat that is privileged like a lawyer like we should >> unequivocally right and by the way we're just fuzzy on it right now because by the way >> you know your email that's on the you know Google or Microsoft servers is privileged and it's still in that thing it's being handled by software etc >> like that's already there. There's no reason that a interaction with an agent should be treated any differently, >> right, from a privilege, you know, standpoint, whether it's legal, medical, etc. And it's really just people's >> But if I write down, I guess there's a >> there's one it's like I'm using as a tool to talk to lawyers. But there's another where it's like obviously if I wrote a word document with like my confession and they found on my computer, >> they'd use that against me. But if I'm like in Chachi BT and I'm asking it like I think I was speeding like what I don't know like do you think we should have protections there that it's like a therapist or as long as I'm not like actively saying I'm murdering that person?
12:29 >> Yeah. Look, I think broadly yes. although also maybe with like one of the things I think I it kind of gets down to kind of how you do a terms of service. I like I would ideally I think have a terms of service that if if someone's like speeding etc that should be within the personal if it's like how do I make a new biological terror weapon no not so much right >> right >> so it's probably a question of where the boundary should be but like for example because if you think about this is >> we're in a far healthier society if everybody has the advice of of of some legal counsel and it's very difficult to to afford >> right >> having at least an ability to have a interaction for can you can you proxy legal counsel for me >> exactly >> is I think a very good feature to have that's that's what I was essentially gesturing at earlier >> well you know to bring a lot it's like >> I I certainly don't support people attacking flock cameras but you can imagine a world today it's like the government has all these tools to come after somebody with flock cameras and who's like destroying them and somebody goes to chat GBT and says I've done this like what you know maybe it needs to be a legal specific app because the problem is lawyers can get in trouble if they give you advice of abetting a crime versus here's the legal advice I can give you around a potential crime or something >> but yeah do you do you think like there needs to be some framework where we have talking to a model for legal advice is as if it was talking to a lawyer >> I think that's that's essentially correct and actually by the way you might do is you might say in that mode like the the model only talks legal like so so you can't go >> to switch into it you're not >> yes a and like for example it's like well you know I'd like to figure out how to break into this building and maybe the model can help you well a lawyer won't do that so if you if you're talking on lawy legal mode it was like no my legal advice to you is don't break into the building >> exactly right and and on the medical front do you think we need new policy >> in the same at the minimum from legal liability. One of the things that I've been trying to advocate for a number of years and it's part of the reason I I've been doing it in to governments and a bunch of other folks and now I'm just kind of think okay let me just start saying this >> just shout about it loudly enough and hope the culture takes it on.
14:56 >> Yes. Exactly. Because if we shift part of the reason why most people are not aware that you can actually get pretty good medical advice from Chat GBD and Claude and the reason is they don't advertise it and they lightly steer away from it to try to avoid me medical liability. >> If they shout they say we can do it then they can get sued when they fail. >> Exactly. And what you want to do is say okay government should say look if you follow the following things then you have essentially a like a kind of a safe harbor >> from medical liability so that and by the way so like the kind of things I think you would do is you'd say the app has to be free the data has to be entirely the own individuals u you have to not sell the data to anybody you have to fundamentally ask, "Do you have access to a doctor? Do you have access to, you know, kind of like medical facilities and so forth?" And and then when you're giving advice, you should say, "Look, it's still far better if you can consult a doctor, but if you can't, you know, like timing, availability, etc., here's what I would think, right?" You know, kind of thing.
16:10 And if you had that, at least three companies would go provide that. It would cost the government nothing. But and they would advertise that they would have it because it would be like look this is a really useful feature and by the way it is a really useful feature and here's how useful the feature is today. I personally know three people whose lives have been saved by chat GBT by using it as a second opinion. Right?
16:33 So like like in a hospital and they go I'm not sure and they go to another hospital and that got that hospital and it was like well if you arrived here about an hour and a half later you'd be dead >> right? You know that kind of thing and that's we want that for everyone right and that's easy enough to do. Now, of course, lawyers will argue, no, no, no, no. We need to have medical tor. It's the only way to keep it. And it's like, well, just just describe what the guidelines are for what you where you have to stay. And if you think, oh, that's a little borderline, then bring in the guideline a little bit. It's like only within like you part of the a medical assistant could be the I'm sorry, I'm not allowed to give advice on that topic, >> right? You know, please find someone to consult with. If you want, I can pull up a a list of public, you know, like potentially publicly available resources that you might be able to use.
17:23 >> It's a really interesting point on the why don't open AAI, Anthropic, etc. do a better job of taking credit for the good things they can do. It's like here's a case where maybe they're afraid that they'll get sued if they brag about it. >> Interesting, right? and it seems I mean it's clearly a good that you can you know put your medical documents into it get just get a different opinion like if it disagrees with your doctor.
17:47 >> Yes. >> Sort of. >> Second question. >> Great. And also by the way like another thing is literally for people who have high-end conciier doctors they put their blood work into chatblad and then you can talk to the agent for 2 hours about like what does this mean and how many people have this and you know does this mean that I have the following condition what would be the probability how else would I measure it should I take the blood test again doctors don't have time for that AI has all the time in the world >> and and sometimes they give simplistic answers assuming you might not do take the medicine or you might not do XYZ and if you have someone actually taking the time to explain it's like oh they're giving you that direct advice because it would take a lot of work to do the perfect solution or whatever yes >> can be helpful to have the time to get a real answer >> well this is the thing where it's like going through in depth and understanding like one of another thing that AI is useful for so say for example this is a couple years ago I was like I want to understand quantum mechanics better so I took a set of quantum mechanics challenges and I went, "Okay, explain this to me like I'm 12. Okay, I got that. Explain it to me like I'm 18.
18:56 Okay, I got that. Explain it to me like I'm a physics college student. Okay, I got that. Okay, explain to me like a professor. Okay, I don't got that. But I but I now understand what the ark looks like." >> Yeah, we need to win in AI because it's the next industrial revolution. And if you don't win that type of revolution, you're sort of irrelevant as a society. you don't get to make the big decisions of >> the big global decisions.
19:20 >> Your children are poor. >> It's it's sort of a dark world that we have to remind people of that in a certain way. It's like >> we still as Americans should think we should win. Like obviously >> we've made mistakes as a culture. We're not perfect. We need to fix it. But it is somewhat worrying that we're in a society today where it feels like we need to even make the case that it's like good to stay on top.
19:42 >> Yes. >> but do you feel like >> Yeah. Do you feel like there's a substantial part of I guess like yeah the political system that doesn't believe that and I guess a lot of people would say it's it's clear you know I'm Democratic line you're a big Democratic donor like I think we're we're shared sympathies there but the party most likely to say oh maybe we shouldn't be on top it is the Democrats and does that worry you? well, it bothers me and part of the reason why I wrote the piece was to try to show Democrats how they can have a pro- AAI vision because the answer is to say, look, part of, I think, what the Democrats most naturally identify with is the people who are disadvantaged in society. They may be poor, there may be racial biases, there may be other things. And they they say, "We're we're about trying to make sure like the rich and the powerful elites don't grind them down." And that that's a good sympathy because that's we should bring everyone along. And so they tend to think this is just you know you tech people saying how you want to get more wealthy and competing with people and it's not about all these other people.
20:46 And it's like look and by the way that has happened at points in history whether it's tech, oil, finance etc. It's like so it's a good voice to be saying that's great. You're going to win in the industry and that'll bring prosperity to the country. Make sure it's helping the country. And as an example that I use to try to wake up Democrats on this topic say well would you like to have a return to manufacturing industry in this country and the answer is yes cuz solid middle class AI and robotics is your only play right you should be leaning into that so as opposed to saying AI bad stop AI it's like well hey can you AI guys be making sure that our whole manufacturing industry is well provisioned with the stuff that's happening could you make sure you're investing in that and if you're doing that we will be more sympathetic. We still will be watching out for, hey, don't be doing, you know, harming children and other kinds of things because it's really important, but but like we'll be more sympathetic to, oh, we'll help you like figure out where you can have find a community that should buy into your data center deal because like in building the data center for doing the community because you're helping the communities with manufacturing jobs, right? that kind of thing would be good and that's the kind of thing to think of for them to think about. Now, it's absolutely right that because they tend to be the like we're on on the side of the of the of the disempowered person against the wealthy and powerful large companies, etc., etc.
22:13 They tend to do that as a dynamic, but that's a destroy our future, destroy children's future, etc. And it's like, don't do that. I hate to be the why doesn't the public appreciate tech more person, but I mean right now the deal with AI is that you know tech companies are way they're burning through investors capital very aggressively spending tons of money building in America like the capacity to do this giving these apps away mostly for free and giving access to it >> and yeah Americans pull very negatively on AI yet use it. I I I feel like something that's been coming up a lot I guess on this podcast and in my work is this conflict between sort of tech industry sort of saying revealed preferences are who you are. I was talking to like simile which is doing simulations of the future and it's like people are really what what they do in some ways and then there's sort of I don't know the media class world which is like people are what they say and they say negative things and they both to pollsters and you know wine online. I don't know what what do you make of the disconnect between obviously what people are doing which is using these tools and embracing them versus what they appear to be saying. Well, so there's a couple different sorts of using the tools. So one is sometimes people using them don't realize they're using them. They don't know that's Yes. Exactly. And then two is they're using it, but they're kind of using it for oh like where is that cafe in Midtown that I wanted to find and so forth and then they're simultaneously being told oh the people who are building this think there's an extinction risk in humanity or it's going to take out 25% of white collar jobs in a couple years. And like well why are you doing that? right? Like like are you crazy? and they think you must not be crazy. Is it just because you're going to get really wealthy? Like why are you like and so so they can simultaneously have this negative feel.
24:11 It's a little bit like I got asked by a friend of mine. He's like, "Well, why are the college students booing AI in commencement speeches?" Because they're all using it a lot. It's like look here's the thing. >> Knowing your friends, they were probably drafting their commencement speech. You're like, "H how do I avoid this problem or Yes. Exactly." And I was like, look, to your average college student, from what they're being told, they're like, okay, you gave me a homework helper and you took away my career. Take your homework helper back and give me my career back. Right? Like, and that's incorrect as a framing. But if that's what the the the the kind of the the the words that you're being told are, then naturally you have a very negative verse reaction. Even though probably the vast majority like 99% of college students use AI regularly, >> do you have a prediction on what sort of AI is going to mean for jobs over the next decade?
25:07 >> Well, anyone who has a solid prediction is probably self-d delusional. because one of the things is a little bit like getting on the road and steering is there's a lot of different ways it can play out. And I've heard smart people argue everything from, you know, the Daario 25% white collar blood bath to there's going to be zero issue whatsoever, right? Like it'll be the most empowering thing and people will use it and so and and smart people on like so the whole range of smart. So the way that I tend to think about it is what here's kind of the more crisp thing. So one is the the speed at which existing companies will change is not nearly as fast as a technologist think because how companies learn things like for example if you go to most companies now like well we're looking around to buy an AI class and you're like you know we got to train our employees we got to buy an AI class and you're like no you could just use AI for that >> ask AI how to use AI that's the whole point like you don't need to go like AI for dummies no one should buy that book just like you know don't do on the other hand so those will be much slower than most of the oh my god it's going to be here in a year or two but what will happen is new kinds of companies will be created that are much more AI native and those will be very strong competitors and then that will start forcing the competition and so that's the pattern that once we're in it I think we can make predictions about well how will the major employment white collar jobs whether they're sales or or customer service or other kinds of what do those how do those end up you know transforming >> how quickly are AI native companies out competing the old guard rather than the old guard being like goodbye everybody we figured out how to use AI >> exactly and by the way that will then cause the old guard to start adjusting and it will be some of them will fail some of them will succeed and there'll be this kind of really kind of intense period on that and in that job transformation I think that will be hard and I think one of the things that you know I've also been thinking about is like how do we create the right AI tools to help everyone in society with that how do you help them figure out like what other kinds of work might be possible or how to adjust like oh well this is what the new kind of salesperson looks like in an AI universe how to learn that job how to do that job how to find that job you know all of that stuff this is one One of the broad things that people really need to understand is you want your solution to have the same characteristics as the problem with namely in scale, cost, speed. You want to have an impedance match. And so a lot of the times people say, "Oh, we're going to have a jobs issue. We'll have community colleges do it." And you're like, "That does not have an impedance match." Like, sure, do something. No harm in doing something, but it will not it will will not survive at that, right?
28:08 So, so how do we have AI be on the on the the help side of the bar, which is totally doable. That's the thing we should be pushing for. That's the thing that I was like when I talk to any government officials, not just Democrats, >> it's help help guide you towards a job. It's help teach people how to build businesses alongside of it. You know, I'm a small business owner. We >> use it to build our ticketing platform.
28:32 We're going to do an exciting report soon that we would have never been able to sort of like >> format and build a website and password protect it the same way without AI. >> So I I can see it. But is that the path? It's like everybody's a small business owner. >> Well, I think I think you'll have a lot of entrepreneurship. I think you'll have a lot of small business entrepreneurship. I think you'll have new entrepreneurship building new companies. And I think you'll have a for example like some of it is like like how would I pitch myself as a college student saying why do you desperately need me at your companies? like I'm AI native. You need to be learning AI native. You need to hire people like me.
29:05 And by the way, most businesses are like, "Oh yeah, like we know that we need." And if they're convinced, then sure, we have entry-level hiring despite, you know, trade war and Iranian war and oil prices and all the rest, which is a lot of the reason why everyone's much more cautious in hiring in business. >> You were saying before we came on, and I don't think we've hit on this yet, just without sort of the AI sort of explosion, our economy would be in a pretty dark place. Can you paint a picture of that and like yeah and what are the political consequences of that as well?
29:38 >> And so this is a particular one in which you know call it progressive Democrats really don't understand which is our economy you know we have a serious problem problems with our economy and it's not just because a massive you know deficit and debt that a huge amount of our taxes go to just literally pay the interest on the debt. It's like we've maxed out like all of our credit cards kind of national debt. But all of this capital infusion people think oh that's just going to the tech companies like no no like a massive like like actually I should go try to measure the exact percentage but a massive percentage of it is going towards data center construction which means construction electricians carpenters real estate development you know etc etc etc you know legal work around what's going on community service engagement like just a ton ton of and and literally I've seen you know place you know people who are texting going hey this AI thing is essential for me looking after my family and so forth and so that capital is the only reason we're not in a recession right so and by the way most of that capital doesn't go to the cities and you know there's a natural reason why capital tends to aggregate in the network affects the cities most of that's more distributed across the country that's great >> on the data center freeze like how likely is that that there is one like are you worried about that? I mean, and certainly you have, you know, the Bernie Sanders of the world there. On the one hand, there's this bipartisan sort of support for it. On both ends of the spectrum, you see Republicans even sort of paying some lip service to it. On the other hand, it feels sort of implausible. It's so key America's main business right now. It's good money.
31:26 What it doesn't have to come to your community, it can come to another. How much how much are you actually worried that there will be a freeze? Well, we're capable given the broadsp, you know, kind of like like a lot of misinterpretation of of AI and data centers. We're capable of doing >> humans are getting into panic. So, ourselves into it if we want to do it. >> And so, for example, like everyone keeps saying water in data centers even though that paper was retracted as for its inaccuracies.
31:55 And so, so I I ultimately am enough of an optimist. I don't think we'll have the shoot ourselves, you know, in both legs, you know, kind of, like a national moratorum, etc. what I do think we should be doing, I think Josh Shapiro at Pennsylvania is doing a very good job of this, is saying, hey, make sure the local community's bought in. Make sure the local community is getting sustaining benefit from it. Make sure that like noise and and environment and everything else is well taken care of.
32:26 Make sure that electricity prices either stay the same or go down as a function of pro of the provisioning of this. And then allow the local community to say I want it, I don't want it, and say, you know, like it self-determination. It's one of the great things that we think about kind of American, you know, kind of the history of American culture even back to, you know, the American Revolution. So allow the local communities to do that and then have like the state and federal involved just to make sure like the environmental stuff and make sure that there's no like oh they're bribing a local official or something but it's actually it makes sense.
33:03 >> Let let different communities decide what's what's right for them. Is there any way to make them more aesthetically appealing or it's they're not the most beautiful seeming things? it's probably that but you know given that economics is always about a question of limited I I >> why spend the money on that? >> Yeah I I would like make it like definitely make it not have sound no noise issues because that can be very disruptive to a local community. Well, if you said, "Hey, we've got a spare X dollars." I'd rather spend the spare X dollars in creating local economy, right? And and saying make sure that that's invested in making the the community more prosperous, >> right? You know, one thing that I feel like Silicon Valley used to be the leader on was this talk of like UBI, universal basic income, and and there's still some echoes of it, which is, you know, there's gonna be so much AI abundance, we have to give everyone some sort of like minimum protection. On the other hand, you know, I I don't read as certainly sort of the conservatives in Silicon Valley as supportive of like expand social security or you know the any sort of like practical expansion of the safety net given sort of imminent AI abundance. I guess first question is just like what do you actually believe?
34:15 You've already brought up the deficit. Is it like oh well we need to cut the deficit so we can't expand the safety net. There is some abundance coming so we should expand it on that basis or what's your view on safety net expansion? So broadly speaking I think that as societies make progress part of your progress society is you expand your human rights you expand your safety net I think it's a good thing that you do as you progress as a society like people say well you know of course you should have you know kind of like unemployment insurance like well but that was a relatively newish thing right like it's good to be to be to be doing this to have much more human society and a functional society. Now, that being said, I was never a huge fan of either UBI or the articulation of UBI, universal basic income because one, you do the math and to get >> right and that's why I sort of pivoted.
35:12 I brought up UBI and I talked about social security. So, yes. >> Yes. But you do the math and you're like the math doesn't work like this isn't complicated math. it just doesn't work for a very like you have to be so present with massive massive abundance this year when you're paying the bills in order to do that. So it kind of like it just doesn't make sense and I think it's the it's the crazy the the people who think oh the whole world will change next year and you're like yeah it's not going to do that. So that kind of thing.
35:39 so I I think expanding safety net and I also think that the in part what I'd want to be doing is saying, hey, look, if we're going to be creating a whole bunch of massively profitable companies because AI helps make them profitable, we may need to make sure that the profitability of those companies is then reflected into the investment in society to make sure that we continue to have, you know, kind of our American way of life and so forth.
36:03 And I don't think the way to do that, one of the reasons why a lot of Americans hated the UBI thing is they don't love the idea of I'm going to put you out of work and I'm going to put you on welfare. Like no, no, no. I I work. I mean, so creating things that involve I'm doing things that are meaningful. I'm participating. I'm contributing to the world. I'm providing for my family. That's where the money should be wrapping into. And I think there's a number of different ways to do that. If we get very profitable companies, if they're American companies, we can then say, "Okay, we need to use this economics to help the rest of the folks."
36:34 >> Do you think it's fundamentally philanthropy or like when Yeah. When do we get again, I feel like the AI world can have this sort of like everybody's going to be an artist or like even sort of rightcoded people will say like do something productive and like that'll be good enough, but it's just like or I think I'm reflecting venode at the moment, but it's like where is the money coming for that? And are we about to see these sort of like violin grants or whatever? How how do people actually get paid to to be productive but not in an economically productive way?
37:04 >> So what we don't know is what does the AI productivity of companies mean? Now say for example, one universe is there's a ton more small firms. They're all operating at high function and the AI thing helps them function then it takes care of itself, right? So like that's one kind of you know positive possible outcome that you don't have to then go lean in a whole bunch of extra weight in order to make it happen. Say for example you say well there isn't a massive number of employment opportunities. There's a few and these companies are mostly only using AI and they're generating a whole bunch of economics. Well then then you say okay we have to tax them to have it I think broadly you'd want to put it I don't know about cultural grants that's fine I mean we obviously have that work with science and arts and cultures and everything else and maybe there's ways to improve that and do that but I would kind of say invest in the local communities like for example people might say hey I've got an idea about things we should be doing in terms of community centers or events that kind of stuff and I I want to be putting money into that. I want to be doing construction on that, etc. And like there's all these kinds of things, ways to do. And so I think this is a little bit of the how do we know this thing that's far down the road and on like pioneering where we've never no one's ever gone. There's a lot of different possibilities and what we need to be doing is driving down the road with the questions in our mind but not cemented answers.
38:37 >> Right. on the on the deficit like are you somebody who thinks AI is about to increase like GDP growth and change our productivity like do you think there are you betting on a world where we sort of outrun our problems or you think something needs to be done to the to the debt or or that shouldn't be a priority? Well, I generally think it's crazy the level of debt we have. and we get to that debt through all kinds of things.
39:03 Like both Democrats and Republicans just keep increasing military spending. And it isn't just because of getting into, you know, needless, very destructive wars like Iran. the the question around what should we do in order to to have economic generativity is really important. I I don't think we can austerity our way out of the debt. I think we have to grow. now that doesn't mean, oh, have as much debt as you like. You want to double the debt, you know, like it's that's that's that's it's terrible economics. Anyone who runs a business like knows that doesn't really work. So >> once you say we don't care about costs, everything goes crazy, right?
39:44 >> Yes. Exactly. And and that's one of the things that makes business such an important part of modern society everywhere in the world because like no no you're focused on costs to benefit and and you try to trim out bad costs and so and that's one of the reasons why you know governments which don't tend to have the same guidance you know kind of because they you government in every country is a monopoly tends to just take money it's like no no you need to be refactoring costs and I think that's a very good thing but the only way forward is to grow the economy. And so you gota like like part of what I, you know, tell a lot of Democrats who may not understand this as well is growing the economy is the only way you achieve the social mission that you want to achieve. Do you want the Democrats to spend a lot of time digging into correcting like the the sort of illegal activity of this administration or how you know if they're about to hopefully maybe gain power in the midterms or and then there's going to be a presidential race like I don't know you you know I think I'm more on the side of like man like Trumpcoin all this stuff like >> one way to animate society around fighting corruption is to have the specific story of how Trump abused you know, office and was able to sort of enrich himself. And if we go after those things that can also be paired with stuff to for for broader societal corrections. Do do you agree with that strategy or you think, man, we're going to have to at some point look forward and try not to overly obsess on what Trump is?
41:16 >> Well, you definitely have to look forward fundamentally, right? like like we're trying to build a future for our children and so forth. And I do think some awareness of how much grift amongst the gritocracy there has been is worth understanding so that people understand that's an important issue for the health of society. >> It's terrible for American business, right? I mean, if you create a culture where just being close to the president is self-enriching, I mean, that's it's very demotivating.
41:45 >> Yeah. Well, and also it's precisely what makes a bunch of other like it it it takes us to the bad excesses of South America. It's like it's like no no that's that's precisely why we've had prosperity is because we've had anti-corruption, we've had rule of law, we've had a pro business environment and you know I think that the you know everything from obviously Trumpcoin there's also I think Trump's has done more stock trading than the all >> he's literally selling the ability to frontr run his tweets on social.
42:14 >> Yes. Like and it's just it's it's just literally anti- business, right? I mean it's like it's terrible. And so so I think that's important to correct. I do think that the there will be a lot of emotional you know kind of instinct to say we should go get belated justice on all fronts in this. And it's like, look, there's been so much you could spend years just trying to, you know, see justice for every single part of of of of rampant corruption and abuse of power. You want to select some just to people. And then you want to build the future.
42:55 >> Man, we need to figure out a way to have the legal system move more quickly. And I I I don't know. It's just it's so slow that you know I yeah then it can jam up sort of everything else that's going on. >> Yeah. And and by the way legal system working potentially more effectively. AI can be good with that, >> right? Exactly. Well, yeah. What What is I I haven't asked you what is your PDOM?
43:21 >> Oh, funny. does your does your audience know what PDOM is? >> I think so. It's the ris pdoom. We're talking like extinction level risk here, >> right? I haven't quantified a number ever really. And the reason is because I think that people tend to like go it tends to be an agitation like my internal agitation. I give you a number of off it. But let me tell you a little bit about kind of where I think people mistake existential risk. So they tend to go like a very classic argument is does the development of AI and potential call it killer robots add an existential risk? And you say yes. And then it says, "See, you should stop. You're adding an existential risk. Doesn't matter if your PDOM is 0.001 or it's 2% or whatever. Doesn't matter because you're adding something and you should stop." And he's like, "Well, >> the right way to look at human existential risk is a portfolio. It isn't just robots. It's bio and pandemics. It's asteroids, >> right? Living in the status quo. Oh, interesting. You have existing existential.
44:24 >> So there's a whole portfolio. So then the question with AI becomes does it increase or decrease the portfolio >> the entire thing right and and sure there is an irreducible ad of mistakenly or deliberately you create some killer robots right that that that have a like extinction level impact by the way cyber attack robots aren't really that I mean there like people oh cyber the hugging face thing pdoom and you're like those have like that's not existential right yes it's a problem but by the way that hack could have been done by humans and is done by humans frequently people don't realize how many cyber hacks are happening all the time with humans >> and obviously you know in the worst case scenario like I get that cyber connects to like you know missile silos or whatever but there's like >> it feels like there's a little bit of like the internet could go offline or something it's like that is not existential I mean it is bad and certainly it would wreck my business it it would be very hard. I'm not minimizing how important the internet is, but it is not >> it's not existential. So that's the reason why I tend to avoid the pdoom conversation because it's like look what you should really be doing is thinking about like okay so how does AI reduce biorisk? How does AI reduce asteroid risk? and by the way you should never connect AI or any automated system to the nuclear stuff. And you should keep the nuclear stuff disconnected from the internet not just because of AI but because of all the human beings like yes treat existential risk as a portfolio and be turning it down but like like a a natural pandemic could be an existential risk. So it isn't that human beings are the only ones but by the way of course human beings doing things tend to be most of the existential risk.
46:17 >> I know it's amazing to talk about this new existential risk. It's like we still have nukes around and we just sort of like all right we've got used to it. We're not >> so worried about but I certainly would risk like >> pure nukes outside of AI sending them as more risky probably than AI development in my own >> exactly >> calculus. Are you we're getting towards the end, but the I mean, one of the things that AI could create is the sort of like abundance abundant lifespans like >> are you optimistic that we're going to significantly extend human life and is that a priority for you or you think there will be just we'll conclude there are sort of natural limits?
46:57 >> So, not surprising. You know me well. The answer is some degree both. >> You're like I'm a middle of the road kind of guy. >> Yes. I I get hit by cars going both directions. I like weaving in the middle of the road. The so we will be extending lifespan and not just like a lot of the progress in the last few decades have been redu massive reduction of child mortality and that is part of what drives up the average but I think we'll also be figuring out how to say hey getting to 100 on a in a in a fastible way is a is like an achievable thing as a kind of a increasing the kind of average and I think we'll do that. I think it's a good thing to do. on the other hand, like what most people don't realize is that our our like every single human being when they're born is dying of cancer, right?
47:44 >> Like because we're this homeostatic balance system which eventually gets out of balance. And so the ability to say no, no, no, we'll be able to really massively rebalance it seems unlikely given the nature where we are. It reminds me of like one of my kind of favorite Buddhism jokes is you know why did the Bu Buddhist coroner get fired and the answer is kept marking as cause of death birth right so you know and it's like look it's good to to live longer more fruitful lives it's a good effort we've been doing it on a lot of things child mortality you know the gates foundation very very good thing to be continuing to focus on but I think we will make progress we just won't make progress you in Silicon Valley you listen to. We're turning off the death gene. Oh, you mean the one that stops cancer?
48:34 >> Are there projects that you think are most likely to sort of make a difference in the near term? Is this an area you invest a lot in? >> I don't invest a lot in it. I mean, I obviously co-founded Monisai here with Sedra Muker saying to try to cure cancer because cancer is a killer. >> You spend a lot of time, right? >> So, so there is a bunch of stuff and I I helped stand up the biohub for CZI. I'm on the board of Arc Institute with the Collisons and Patrick and Solana. so I I try to do stuff for the kind of bio for humanity on this. So I I put time and energy into it. Probably I've only done two or three investments of which Manis is the most significant.
49:12 >> And so do you have a sort of cancer elimination timeline? I know we always want >> Well, AI is the best shot we've had in human history to do this. and a little bit of, you know, there's a bunch of variables you don't know of like cuz you try to tackle the major ones early. I doubt you'll ever fully get rid of cancer. And by the way, it's kind of this question of well, you get rid of that one. Oh, and then this one will happen. So, so there's probably as you get rid of the major ones and get to more of a long tail, you then start having to do things because people don't realize there's thousands of cancers, right? There's lots and lots of different kinds of cancer. Secure one, you have time now to get >> everything else.
49:54 >> But do you think we haven't I mean, we haven't had a first one yet. Do you think >> No. well, and that's, you know, we're very ambitious at Modus. We hope we we're discovering some really interesting chemistry, >> right? I mean, if you had to sort of leave us with what you think sort of a realistic message for, you know, the Democrats and and sort of I don't know, the set of the AI world that really wants to feel like they're bringing every American along and not sort of like, well, they need to sort of figure it out. It's like get, you know, take advantage of this moment or or miss out.
50:29 if you know you can extend sort of empathy to people who aren't necessarily going to easily sort of figure out how to play this huge innovation like what what is the message? So I think the message is first for everyone who is trying to help people get be ideiating and incenting and getting as much AI help for the majority of society right whether it's medical assistant legal assistant tutor you can also imagine government services working a whole lot easier say you didn't have to go down to DMV hell I mean most of the jokes in Hollywood or you know you want to visit hell on earth go to the DMV you like you know all of this kind of stuff.
51:13 You can imagine financial advice that would be very helpful like just tons of like just do all that. But by the way that doesn't mean like don't also try to help with jobs and work and so forth. And I've been, you know, thinking about like, okay, should I do another version of the startup of you for like kind of entre entrepreneurs and the AI community, you know, kind of AI age like so, but the the short answer is >> give people as much knowledge and perspective and bridges to hope as you can and don't try to be polyianish. I I don't like the oh, it'll be fine. It's like no, no, journeys can be difficult.
51:50 but the journey is not only worth it to you, it's also worth it to your children. It's worth it to your community. And you know, I one of the things I love about America is we reinvent ourselves. And I think that this like that that gives a very good position for kind of making this, you know, call it American intelligence out of artificial intelligence. >> Hoffen, thank you so much for coming on the Newcomer Podcast. That's our episode. This is the newcomer podcast.
52:16 Thanks for listening. Please like, comment, subscribe. Go find us on our Substack at newcomer.co. If you're hungry for more podcasting, I also have a talk show called the Cerebral Valley Show. we love your comments. Thanks for all your support and see you next week.
Summary
- AI is seen as the next industrial revolution, crucial for future prosperity.
- Hoffman identifies as a "techno-humanist," advocating for technology that enhances humanity.
- He stresses the importance of ensuring AI benefits all Americans, particularly the disadvantaged.
- There is a call for careful monitoring of AI deployment, especially regarding recursive self-improvement.
- Hoffman believes in the necessity of expanding the safety net as society progresses, but is skeptical of universal basic income (UBI) due to financial feasibility.
- He emphasizes the importance of local communities having a say in AI and data center developments.
- The discussion includes the potential for AI to assist in legal and medical fields, advocating for protections similar to those for human professionals.
- Hoffman expresses optimism about extending human lifespan through advancements in AI and biotechnology, while acknowledging inherent biological limits.
Questions Answered
Why is it important to remember the human aspect in AI?
The discussion emphasizes the necessity of keeping human beings at the center of AI development, highlighting the risks of disconnecting critical systems from human oversight.
Should interactions with AI be treated with the same legal privilege as those with human professionals?
Yes, interactions with AI, especially in legal and medical contexts, should be treated as privileged, similar to communications with human professionals.
How can AI contribute to the manufacturing industry?
AI and robotics can play a crucial role in revitalizing the manufacturing sector, and there should be a focus on ensuring that AI development supports this industry.
How can communities be involved in decisions about AI and data centers?
Communities should have a say in the establishment of AI and data centers, ensuring they receive benefits and have their concerns addressed.
What approach should be taken towards corruption and future development?
While addressing past corruption is important, the focus should also be on building a better future, potentially aided by AI.